Forget-Me-Not by Marjorie Bowen
The Strange Case of Lucille Clery
Writing as Joseph Shearing
First published as The Strange Case Of Lucille Clery,
William Heinemann, London, 1932
This novel is based on a fact—that of a crime so
incredible that it caused amazement equal to the horror it inspired; the
public sentiment aroused by this atrocity went far to provoke the sudden
French Revolution of 1848. The author is responsible for everything in the
novel save this central fact, and for the details of the life of the period,
which are largely taken from contemporary newspapers.
[Charles Laure Hugues Thobald, duc de Choiseul-Praslin (29
June 1804-24 August 1847) was a French nobleman and politician, who served as
a member of the Chamber of Deputies in 1838-1842. Choiseul-Praslin's suicide,
occurring while he faced trial for the murder of his wife, Fanny Sbastiani,
caused a scandal which in turn contributed to the outbreak of the 1848
Revolution and the fall of the July Monarchy. In previous years, the
Choiseul-Praslin household had been the scene of violent confrontations
between the duke and his wife. Among others, Fanny de Choiseul-Praslin
accused her husband of hiring a governess, Henriette Deluzy-Desportes (or
Henriette de Lucy, Henriette de Luzy), in order to estrange her from her
children. Deluzy-Desportes, whom she had fired six weeks before being killed
but had not left the household, was also alleged by Fanny to have been the
duke's mistress (with whom, she suspected, the duke planned to elope).The
duchess repeatedly threatened to separate from her
TABLE OF CONTENTS
• Chapter I
• Chapter II
• Chapter III
• Chapter IV
• Chapter V
• Chapter VI
• Chapter VII
• Chapter VIII
• Chapter IX
• Chapter X
• Chapter XI
• Chapter XII
• Chapter XIII
• Chapter XIV
• Chapter XV
• Chapter XVI
• Chapter XVII
• Chapter XVIII
• Chapter XIX
• Chapter XX
• Chapter XXI
• Chapter XXII
• Chapter XXIII
• Chapter XXIV
• Chapter XXV
• Chapter XXVI
• Chapter XXVII
• Chapter XXVIII
• Chapter XXIX
• Chapter XXX
• Chapter XXXI
• Chapter XXXII
• Chapter XXXIII
• Chapter XXXIV
• Chapter XXXV
• Chapter XXXVI
• Chapter XXXVII
• Chapter XXXIX
• Chapter XL
• Chapter XLI
• Chapter XLII
• Chapter XLIII
• Chapter XLIV
• Chapter XLV
• Chapter XLVI
• Chapter XLVII
• Chapter XLVIII
• Chapter XLIX
• Chapter LI
• Chapter LII
• Chapter LIII
• Chapter LIV
• Chapter LIV
• Chapter LV
• Chapter LVI
• Chapter LVII
• Chapter LVII
• Chapter LIX
She took off her glove and glanced at the wedding ring which
she had no right to wear; this irritated her companion. As he opened the door
of the musty, private parlour of the inn he reflected that many of her
actions since he had eloped with her had irritated him; a bad beginning.
He endeavoured to reassure himself by a full look at her beauty and
elegance. Mary Showler accepted with pleasure this admiration that was tinged
by doubt and reluctance. Still displaying the slim hand with the gold band
that he had given her that morning, she sat composedly at ease, ignoring her
homely surroundings, the dark room with a dusty case of prize fish, a shelf
with pewter tankards, a new engraving of the girlish Queen in her coronation
Young Morrison decided that Mary Showler was worth the trouble; a beauty,
if ever there was one... a woman of taste, too; he liked her gown of deep
indigo blue glaces silk, so neatly buttoned to the slim figure.
She was aware of his approval and smiled; her toilette had cost her all
she possessed in the world. She had never worn such clothes before, nothing
but the plainest attire was permitted the teachers at Miss Le Moine's Academy
for Young Ladies.
"Well," she said, still smiling, "so far successful, Robert! Can we get
any refreshment here? And when do you expect your sister?"
He did not like that; she should not have forced an explanation when she
ought to have understood the situation without a word. To gain time he rang
the bell and ordered coffee, she, smiling always, considering him with
furtive steadiness the awhile.
They had been travelling together since morning and the tedious intimacy
had not increased her esteem for him; she realised that she would have to be
very careful, very patient. He was pampered, wilful, bad tempered, an
indulged sensualist, and worse than any of this, she feared, with a real
sinking of the heart, that he was stupid.
But he was wealthy and the next-of-kin to a duke; Mary Showler made her
smile soft and engaging as she poured the coffee and offered the cakes.
"Are you not fatigued, Robert? The train was so wearisome! When shall we
"Well, I have to see to a few arrangements." He stared moodily into his
coffee cup. She considered all he did and said with an intense, secret
interest which she did not for a second mistake for the repulsions and
attractions of love (though he had for her, on occasion, a strong physical
appeal) she was anxious to know, to understand and to please him because he
represented to her a unique chance of escaping an intolerable life and of
achieving all she desired.
He was a well-built, rather clumsy young man with thick, closely curling
fair hair and whiskers, blunt features and pale grey eyes. He rose abruptly,
with an uneasy grin, and said:
"I shall be back in half an hour—pray command what you wish."
She granted smiling leave; she had no cause to suspect his good faith; she
was, indeed, quite sure of him, in the way a clever woman feels sure of a
stupid man whose passions she has skilfully roused and never satisfied.
As soon as she was alone she rose and looked in the dim flyblown mirror
beside the window on which was a crisp pattern of frost.
The wearisome travelling had not impaired her appearance; she had a gift
of neatness. She was twenty-three and looked seventeen; delicately she took
off the poult de sole bonnet that it had been such an extravagance for
her to buy, and studied her head and face rising against that dingy
background. This was the first time that she had been able to insist on, to
emphasise her good looks; hitherto she had been always in eclipse, effaced, a
She was satisfied with her scrutiny, with her fine small features, long
neck, silky hair falling in ringlets of a delicate auburn brown. Only her
forehead was rather high, her lashes too light and her slightly prominent
eyes, too steady, too brilliant. But she knew very well how to remedy these
defects, how to drop the curls on her brow, how to veil her eyes...
She tied the bonnet under her chin, arranged the black lace becomingly
round the brim and returned to the table where a dirty copy of 'The Times'
lay. She picked it up and read an account of the funeral of Napoleon I: the
great Emperor's remains had just been received, with incredible pomp, in
Mary Showler was passionately Bonapartist and loathed the bourgeois King
whose elevation had ruined her family. Her face became discontented, almost
violent in expression; there was so much of which she was capable and she had
been so completely frustrated. To soothe herself she opened her reticule and
drew out her lover's gift 'to amuse her on the journey,' 'Forget-me-not,' an
elegant volume of prose, verse and fine engravings. Her glance caught an
account of the miseries of governesses; she turned over the pages, she knew
enough about that subject. Her gaze rested on the frontispiece—the
young Queen again, a girl younger than herself, with the same childlike
features. Mary Showler shut up the book. As she returned it impatiently to
her reticule a silver thimble rolled out; this was wreathed with myosotis and
the words 'Forget-me-not' in bright enamel; her lover had given it to her
with the book and had seemed to congratulate himself on a pretty fancy. Her
thanks had been as ardent as was now the scorn with which she thrust both
these sentimental objects out of sight and returned to her newspaper, which
she could no longer resist though it tormented her. She had the sheet on her
knee when young Morrison returned with a cigar between his lips; she noted
instantly that he did not remove this and that he had been drinking.
"I wish I were in Paris now," she said; "a grand moment for a
Bonapartist!" As he did not answer she continued with a rising accent of
drama; "How I detest this Louis Philippe! I should like to pull him
He laughed. "You, Mary! That's rather ambitious, my dear! I think the King
of the French is too firmly fixed! Besides," he added with sudden ill humour,
"women have no need to be interested in such things."
That warned her; she sat rebuked, crumpled the paper up, cast it down;
nothing must irritate or bore him—until she had him safe.
"Has your sister arrived?" she asked sweetly.
"No." He looked at her with a slight defiance. "Perhaps she won't
"Then," said Mary Showler, "what are we going to do? We can't stay here
together." She urged his silence. "Perhaps I could get a room somewhere in
the village? But surely your sister will come? You said, Robert, that you
could rely on her."
"And you thought, of course, that you could rely on me?"
"Of course." Her voice was tender; she tried to soothe his obvious
discontent; no doubt he was vexed by his sister's defection, and so was she,
but she concealed this: "Never mind—we can manage."
Young Morrison caressed his tight, curly, blond whiskers.
"I suppose so," he said sulkily.
She waited, in an attitude of graceful abnegation, for his childish temper
to pass; she was not really uneasy for she had never quite believed in the
staunch loyalty of Lady Hayes that her brother had so often sworn to. Was it
likely that an aristocrat would welcome a Mary Showler as a sister-in-law?
No, the poor orphan had relied on herself; though she had had no help at all
in the affair she believed she had managed very well from the first moment
she had had the luck to attract the attention of Robert Morrison—she,
demure in the Bath streets with her posse of pupils, he, idling in his
Tilbury with a roving eye for a pretty female shape... secret meetings, a
secret correspondence, a dramatic passion, a complete decorum, the man
enmeshed until he proposed elopement, marriage...
She had relied on all that he had promised her, not because she had much
respect for his honesty, but because she knew he was infatuated. Therefore
she had left everything for him. They were to be married to-morrow at St.
Mary's, Paddington, where, he said, he had had the banns called—oh,
quite safely, no one knew him, no one would think of looking for him in such
an out of the way place... There would be a night to put in; they could not
get from Bath to London in time for a marriage, but his favourite, his
indulgent sister, Amy Hayes, would meet her and chaperone her till the
wedding morning; afterwards, he had a really charming cottage ready for her
No need, Mary Showler thought, to upset these convenient agreeable plans
because Lady Hayes had proved cowardly or false.
"Where were we to have stayed?" she asked pleasantly. "You said you had
found rooms for us with an old servant. Cannot I go there? It is getting late
and really I cannot remain much longer, dear, in this common inn."
She longed to comment on his cigar; odious to smoke in front of her! but
she dared not object to anything—yet.
"We'll have a little talk first, Mary." He spoke with clumsy abruptness,
then lost patience. "Damn it, you make it deuced awkward!"
"Do I?" She was meek, was sweet, but he suspected her, feared that she was
intelligent. He knew that she was well educated, that might be ignored; but
that shrewd flash in her gold eyes, that edge to her words, that curl to her
lip! He did not want a vixen, a damned blue stocking; she was going to be
clever and difficult. He was profoundly irritated; she ought to have shown
alarm, confusion, there should have been tears, supplications by now. That
mood he could have dealt with, but this poise, that erect head, that steady
glance... equal to equal. All the brandy he had taken could not arm him
against her. He cursed the extraordinary infatuation that had involved him
with Mary Showler.
"Look here," he blurted out, "you don't really think that I am going to
She did not lower her gaze. In a second she had taken in and tasted to the
full the bitterness of her own lunatic mistake, and recovered her
"Aren't you?" she whispered.
"Well—it stands to reason—confound it, you know who I
"And you know who I am, penniless, defenceless—that makes it easy
for you, Robert."
He took, with clumsy eagerness, this opening.
"If I do, it isn't because you told me. Your tale was all lies—"
"I told you there was a mystery, that I was quite alone—"
"Mystery!" He was glad to fasten this quarrel on her. "You said you were
Mary Showler, your father an English doctor, and that your mother was a
daughter of one of Bonaparte's marshals—ruined, of course—in
exile, all the rest of it—"
"Stop!" She rose, checking his stupid triumph. "What has this to do with
our marriage?" He frowned at her coolness. "You don't intend to marry
"Why all these falsehoods, then?"
"I suppose you expected some consideration for your damned
"Why are you treating me like this? What do you want from me? What have
you found out about me?"
These questions and the manner in which she delivered them revealed her as
the powerful personality he had always suspected her to be. Intensely
annoyed, he replied:
"Your mother was never married, no need for you to be."
"Ah, so you found out that? Made enquiries?"
"I'm not a fool, my dear."
"No, I have been the fool." She sat down and shaded her face with her
hand; she was in a terrible situation and did not see how she could extricate
herself. Her limbs trembled from shock and the effort she made to maintain
her control and for a moment rage at her own folly consumed her. She had not
had much experience, but she had read, observed, deeply and she ought not to
have been deceived like a girl from a convent. Vanity had misled her; it is
so easy for a woman to over-estimate the force of the passion she
As she sat there, her face hidden by her frivolous bonnet and her slim
hand, she was calculating rapidly, desperately—but her attitude seemed
one of complete, miserable defeat, and though she was not a person easily to
inspire pity nor he one to feel it, he was touched by a certain compassion
for the woman whom he had so cleverly caught.
He put his cigar into his coffee cup and crossed over to her.
"Look here, Mary, I'm sorry if I spoke unkindly—you know I'm fond of
you—I meant all I said—except the marriage—and you ought to
"Ought I?" She dropped her hand, but did not raise her face. "Why, then,
did you trouble to mention marriage to me?" This was the sort of answer he
did not like; it was detestable for a woman to be logical.
"You may take it as a compliment, I suppose, my dear—I thought you
wanted to at least keep up appearances—and you can't blame me for
playing your own game, for you told me a lot of nonsense about yourself."
She did not reply, and he continued, half ill-tempered, half conciliatory,
to justify himself; she paid no heed to his arguments, but what did impress
her was his tone. At Bath he had always treated her as a gentlewoman, now he
definitely spoke to an inferior, a creature already declassé, of the
demimonde. Anger at her own folly merged into unspeakable anger at his
insolence, yet she knew that, in his own estimation, he was being
"Don't be sulky, Mary, and spoil everything. There isn't another woman
I've ever met for whom, I'd take the trouble I've taken for you."
"The trouble?" She raised her head and looked at him. "Was it so difficult
to tell a few lies?"
"Oh, come now, I've been after you for weeks." Resentment at her coolness
goaded him into adding: "You were supposed to be fond of me, weren't you?
Seems to me that all you were thinking of was the advantages you were hoping
She easily extricated herself from this.
"I was prepared to be your wife, Robert—I don't know I'm prepared to
be any man's mistress." She rose, unable any longer to control her violent
wrath. "You offer me this vulgar—this bitter insult—then expect
me to still be—fond of you?"
Young Morrison was impressed; she had, in that moment of stung pride, the
lure of the unattainable. She was really lovely, flushed with a fever of
passion, and he wanted her; wanted to tame her, break her, leave her... but
that last, not for a long while yet; she would make a fine show before his
friends. He took her wrists and began to woo her, thickly, insistently; he
was in earnest, as he had been in earnest at Bath.
Mary Showler stood rigid, not listening, her head turned aside. She earned
forty pounds a year, in eighteen months she had saved twenty pounds; it had
all been spent on the clothes she wore. There were five shillings in her
purse, she had nothing else in the world. Her sole relative was her
grandfather, a fierce, bitter, penurious old man who had already told her
that she could starve for all he cared. In leaving Miss Le Moine's
establishment in such a manner she had lost her character; in what way
besides teaching could she earn even a pittance?
She was roused from these bitter reflections by the young man dropping her
hands and exclaiming violently:
"Why don't you answer? What have you got to say?"
She looked vaguely at him.
"What am I supposed to answer? I did not hear what you said."
She knew that she ought to soothe, to flatter Robert Morrison even now,
but she had not sufficient self-control to do this, and he for a moment
almost lost his complacency before her cold hostility.
He recovered himself with a flare of temper.
"Very well, I'll leave you here. No doubt you'll find your way back to the
paths of virtue without my help—"
At that she forced herself to say:
"I am very cold. And tired. I have had a great shock. You must forgive me
if I am rather—stupid."
This confession of weakness and the sight of that charming head as she
flung off her bonnet, restored his good humour. She was a prize and worth an
effort, and, after all, she had taken it pretty well, no hysterics, nor
reproaches, not a single tear; he had got off lightly. As he rang the bell he
was congratulating himself that he knew how to manage a woman.
His haughty orders to the waiter got lamp and fire hastily lit, wine and
food on the table and the announcement that the best bedroom had been warmed
and aired for "your honour if your honour is staying the night."
"Yes, we'll stay," said Robert Morrison. "We have missed the train and my
wife is tired."
He ordered more brandy, and, as soon as it came, drank eagerly; warmth
began to spread from the fire. Mary Showler drank a glass of sherry, took off
her shawl and held her hands to the flames. She knew that she ought to refuse
this man's company with horror, to fly from him at once, anywhere, but she
remained in the easy chair by the fire, sipping another glass of sherry,
eating bread, ham and macaroons, and thinking deeply; her childlike features
did not betray the agonised bitterness of her thoughts.
Protected by the company of the waiter, Robert Morrison made a good meal
and emptied his glass every time it was replenished. Mary Showler stole a
look now and then at his thick red neck with the dusting of blond hair, at
his blunt, handsome features, at his heavy, robust body in the fashionable
clothes; a brute, who had behaved to her like a scoundrel, but she did not
regard him wholly with repugnance. He was better company than Miss Le Moine
or her pupils. Even silent, absorbed in his meal he pleased her more than did
the affections of feminine gentility.
When he had finished and the table was cleared, he approached her in
smiling good humour and asked her if she had made up her mind?
"About what, Robert?"
"Don't put me off, there's a good creature—look here, who are
"All I told you was true, except that my parents weren't married—my
grandfather was one of Napoleon's officers—"
"But not a marshal, eh? Never mind, what's your name?"
"Did you not remind me that I was nameless? I was christened Lucille, my
mother was a Mademoiselle Clery. My father, till he died, gave me a good
education. I took an English name for teaching, that of an ancestress.
Despite me, as you will," she added. "I have never been treated before as you
have treated me."
He ignored that.
"Well, Mary Showler, or Lucille Clery, I think you are much too smart and
pretty to be a miserable governess and I mean to treat you very
well—I'll give you an apartment in Paris and a handsome allowance. You
can have a cabriolet and keep a maid—I shan't marry till I can help
it—come, I really want you and you could do no better—"
He took hold of her, muttering some endearments, pulling her close. His
breath, tainted by tobacco and spirits, was on her face, and she felt the
full contact of his body, powerful, warm, full of strength and passion. This
was not displeasing to her after a narrow, cloistered life, excluded from all
touch of masculinity. She was conscious of a certain relief to her agony in
this embrace of the man who had caused it. At last her fatigue, her rage, her
shame melted into tears; she was shaken by sobs in his arms and he was
gratified. This was true feminine surrender; his caresses became quick,
violent, he muttered promises that were quite sincere; he meant to spend a
lot of money on her. For a while she endured this, took comfort in this. But
she was icy proud, strictly bred, not sensual, not in love with him; she
stifled her tears as rage and humiliation surged uppermost in her heart, and
wrenched away the thick fingers fondling her throat, her ears, her curls, her
"I can't—I can't," she muttered, shuddering violently and turning
away. "I won't be treated like this—" She added something in French
that he sensed was an expression of hatred. Startled and disgusted, the young
man drew back; was she such a prize? Her features were distorted, and her
vivid repugnance chilled and offended him. He, too, mustered some
"As you please. I've never forced a woman. Good-bye, if you like. If you
change your mind I shall be upstairs."
He left her, making an effort over the lurch in his gait. Mary Showler sat
down before the opal globe of the lamp that cast a circle of light over the
dirty cups, the stubbed out cigar. Through her humiliation she tried to see
the advantages... What had he offered her? Paris, a carriage, a maid, a
'handsome allowance'; no one else had ever offered her anything at all. She
liked Paris, Tortoni, the Maison d'Or, the opera, the theatre, in the
demimonde she might, surely, have some success, throw over, perhaps,
Morrison and find some other man more clever, more influential... yet it was
detestable to accept less than marriage, to become an outcast at this fool's
But the alternative? To return to the slavery that was called teaching,
classed with the housekeeper, the lady's maid, keyed down to vapid, sub-acid
feminine gentilities and futilities! Mary Showler wished to attach herself to
men's destinies, to their passions, their splendours, their vices.
She glanced up at the portrait of the young Queen—a silly vacant
face with pale full eyes and a baby mouth, too like her own, she thought ...
what luck some women had, what luck!
She thrust her fingers into her fine ringlets; the heat of the lamp was on
her flushed face, the smell of the paraffin in her nostrils. Fatigue and
grief began to overcome her anger, her shame.
The man upstairs would be kind to her if she was submissive; he desired
her if he did not love her. It was better to be degraded by a carnal passion
than to be ignored; of what use was this chastity, this honour she had been
told to rate so high?
Aloud she asked herself: "What use?"
A woman must never give her body except as the final gift of a life-long,
a perfect love. Who was going to love Mary Showler like that? A bastard
orphan, penniless, friendless... young Morrison's behaviour had taught her
what she might expect from gentlemen; she could not bear to think of any
union with one who was not a gentleman. "It was cruel to educate me better
than my birth." The sense of her great loneliness overwhelmed her; no one to
help, no one to care, many to scold, to mock, to condemn; she began to think
with relief of the man waiting upstairs, to wish for his brutal caresses that
would at least stun thought.
She rose, picked up her bonnet, her tartan scarf, her shawl, her reticule,
went out into the brown varnished passage. A waiter, yawning, was coming out
of the coffee-room opposite; he seemed surprised to see her. Through the open
door behind him she saw the bleak face of a clock; it was far later than she
had thought, her trance-like musing must have been very long. Robert
Morrison, she reflected instantly, had not come back to urge her
"Has my husband gone out?"
"No, Madam, he is upstairs—your room is that with the brass knocker
at the head of the stairs—"
"I can find it. Is there a little closet or chamber that I could have to
"Oh yes, Madam, that at the side."
"Thank you." Her air of authority quelled his curiosity, but his dull eyes
stared after her as if he guessed something of her sordid story.
Mary Showler went upstairs, passed the door with the brass knocker and
entered the one beside it, a cold room with white everywhere, walls, bed
cover, curtains. She took off her shawl, shuddering, combed her hair, bathed
her face and stood still a moment to gather her courage, staring at herself
in a mirror that hung beneath a pink china plaque showing John Wesley
preaching, then went softly and raised the brass knocker. As there was no
reply, she entered.
It was a large room; a fire was burning low on the hearth, a lamp, turned
down, was on a table by the window; an unstrapped valise lay on the floor.
She put her hand before her eyes.
"Robert, I've come."
No reply; she advanced to the large bed from which the curtains were
looped back; he was lying there, fully dressed, asleep.
Mary Showler crossed to the lamp and turned up the flame, returned to the
bed and tried to wake the young man.
His face was congested, he was snoring heavily; bottles and glasses were
on the night table. She saw that he was not asleep, but drunk.
He had not cared enough to keep sober to wait for her; disappointed at her
delay, he had drunk himself into insensibility; first his love and then his
lust had left her cheated, bereft. He was not able to receive the sacrifice
she had, at such cost to her pride, come to make: she could not even forget
her torments in his coarse embraces. The affair had become worse than
Her desire for the sensational, the dramatic was frustrated; she had meant
to fling herself into his arms with at least simulated passion...
She bent over him with an expression of loathing that sharpened her
features painfully; how ugly he was in his stupor! She marked every defect in
his face. The thick hair and whiskers were straw colour on the purplish skin,
his mouth had fallen open and was twitching; to her he was vile, obscene.
"You miserable blackguard," she whispered, "sale bête—"
She withdrew, hastened to the other room, panting, trembling, tied on her
bonnet, flung on scarf and shawl, snatched up her reticule, remembered ...
only five shillings...
She was back in his room again, swift and concentrated in her actions. His
merino coat hung over a chair; she went through the pockets—some
guineas in a beaded purse. She took these and fled, hovered for a moment on
the wide landing till the passage below was empty, then descended, escaped
unobserved and was out in the raw damp of the December night. "I think," said
Lady Anfield, "that she would be most suitable."
"Madame Faustin seemed very impressed by her. It is so
difficult to find the right person!"
The two ladies smiled with vague amiability at each other; they were not
very interested in the subject they discussed but it was one of those rather
tiresome services to a mutual friend that cannot be refused. Madame Clapisson
Faustin, the wife of the French ambassador, had asked Mrs. Coombe Wade to
find a governess for a family of her acquaintance and the Englishwoman
believed there was an excellent person about to leave the employ of Lady
Anfield; Madame Faustin had herself seen this young woman with her charges
and had highly approved her appearance and behaviour.
But Mrs. Coombe Wade felt a certain responsibility that urged her to make
"An exceptional person is required—there are five children and the
mother can do nothing, social obligations, you know, and ill health, then the
establishment is really magnificent! One requires someone with
"Mademoiselle Debelleyme has that—she is very good with servants, a
wonderful gift for keeping order and discipline—with children,
too—she really takes all the trouble off one's shoulders!"
"Yet she is leaving you?"
"Well, the girls are almost too old—besides—"
As Lady Anfield left her sentence vague Mrs. Coombe Wade hinted:
"She did not stay long in her last place, either?"
"Oh, with the Brentwells? You see, those were boys and soon had to have a
Determined to do her duty the other lady persisted.
"Isn't she rather good-looking?"
Lady Anfield appeared surprised, a trifle uneasy.
"No one has noticed it, I assure you she is very discreet and
"But this air of authority? Isn't that rather out of place in this sort of
Lady Anfield hastened to explain.
"Oh, she never presumes, she is most respectful and agreeable, I'm
sure—it isn't an air of authority either, quite—difficult to
explain! She gets things done, without any fuss."
"Who is she?" asked Mrs. Coombe Wade directly.
"Well, really, one hardly troubles, does one? I mean I had excellent
credentials from the Brentwells and they had a strong recommendation from
Lady Tryon, and I believe before that she was in an Academy at
She smiled good-naturedly at her friend, hoping she would turn the tedious
conversation, but Mrs. Coombe Wade, who did not wish to disoblige the French
Ambassadress, was firm.
"I must know something, Peggy dear, they rely on me—I am to engage
the young woman, you see."
"Well, she is a Parisienne—but there is a romantic mystery, yet
nothing to her discredit, you see"—Lady Anfield lowered her pleasant
voice—"her grandfather was one of Napoleon's maréchals—a
Baron of the Empire, I think, and, of course, he lost everything at the
Restoration—her mother was Italian, or was it Corsican?—anyhow,
of a noble family, but ruined; she has been brilliantly educated, and is much
more refined and well bred than these people usually are—"
This was vague, but Mrs. Coombe Wade was satisfied.
"She sounds a jewel, Peggy—I suppose you have never found any fault
"Never. Her position is peculiar, she has no relatives—they are in
exile in Italy, I believe, and that is rather an advantage—I think her
name is assumed, that of an ancestor, but as no exception could be taken to
her in any way, I did not object." And, anxious to end the matter, Lady
Anfield added, "Would you like to see her yourself? She is leaving me at the
end of the week."
"Oh yes, if you please—then she might wait on Madame Faustin and
With relief Lady Anfield rang the bell and requested the footman to "send
Mademoiselle Debelleyme at once."
It was a handsome, ornate room in which the two ladies discussed the
governess, looking on to Belgrave Square. Lady Anfield and her friend were
young matrons, dressed expensively and without taste. Lives of busybody
idleness had given an expression at once vacant and inquisitive to their
amiable faces; their experience was even more limited than their
understanding, but they were adepts in all the conventions of their
While they chattered vaguely the governess appeared.
"Ah, Mademoiselle, won't you sit down? Mrs. Coombe Wade would like to
speak to you—this is Mademoiselle Debelleyme, dear—"
The governess seated herself and waited, with downcast eyes; her demeanour
was perfect, respectful without being servile; her personality was completely
effaced in her post; she was the governess in a rich gentleman's
establishment and could never make the mistake of asserting that she was a
human being. Mrs. Coombe Wade looked at her and approved; she was pleased to
note also that she had been mistaken in thinking the young woman
good-looking—her features were insignificant, her hair was pulled back
unbecomingly from a forehead that was too high, and pinned in an
old-fashioned manner at the back of her head, her clumsy but neat dress of
dark merino was buttoned in a pelerine up to her chin, and its heavy folds
quite disguised any graces her figure might have possessed; yet she had that
distinction, that dignity that an aristocrat would like to see in a
dependant—surely, thought Mrs. Coombe Wade, anxiously, she was the very
person for whom Madame Faustin was so eagerly searching? Such excellent
testimonials, too, an exquisite flower painter, a good musician.
There was a short pause while one lady scrutinised the governess and the
other furtively yawned.
Mademoiselle Debelleyme bore the silence with equanimity, and listened,
without a change of attitude, while Mrs. Coombe Wade stated her case.
"I am looking for a governess for a friend of Madame Faustin. As you are
leaving Lady Anfield and she very kindly recommends you and I hear that you
have other good testimonials I wondered if you might be suitable."
"What is the situation, please?" The governess, still keeping her lids
modestly down, spoke in a very low, but distinct voice.
"With the Duchesse Montlosier du Boccage—you know of her, of
"It is an historic name."
"Yes, indeed. The Duchess is a daughter of Maréchal Frediani, you know,
the victor of Warsaw, and immensely rich. She keeps a very splendid
establishment in the Rue St. Honoré—the Duke is Chevalier
d'honneur to the Duchesse D'Orleans and an intimate at Court—you
understand that you would have a very envied post!"
"What would it be, precisely?"
"There are five children—two boys; there is an under-governess, two
nurses, the children have their own maids—you: see, Mademoiselle, that
an exceptional person is required!"
Gently the governess raised her head, and asked:
Mrs. Coombe Wade was not a sensitive woman, but she was conscious of
something in mademoiselle's glance, revealed suddenly, that made her feel
uneasy. Those eyes were such a peculiar colour, a clear gold, large, cold,
yet compelling, as if a strong and frantic spirit stared from behind bars;
but Mademoiselle Debelleyme looked down again and the vague impression
But the lady was slightly ruffled as she replied:
"Well, it is a considerable responsibility—five little children of
"There are, as always, the parents," remarked the governess, quietly.
"Oh yes! But the Duchess does nothing; she is often ill, she has lost a
number of children—besides, she must be continually at the
"Then I should have sole charge?"
Mrs. Coombe Wade was a little taken aback by this direct question.
"I believe that the Duke directs the education of the children, I really
don't know. Madame Faustin could tell you."
Bored by this conversation but still good-natured. Lady Anfield
"Why not wait on Madame Faustin, Mademoiselle, and find out what you wish
"But, Lady Anfield," smiled the governess. "I don't think that I can
accept this kind suggestion—I have almost engaged myself to teach
music, French and painting at Miss Graham's Academy."
Mrs. Coombe Wade was disappointed; she did not want to have to search
further for a governess for her friend, and she was really impressed by the
correct, icy and respectful demeanour of Mademoiselle Debelleyme.
"Madame du Boccage offers a hundred pounds a year and your own apartment
and full service. I believe this is better than you have had before."
"Lady Anfield was good enough to pay me sixty pounds; I have been quite
"Surely you would like to return to Paris?"
The governess smiled.
"My family lost all with the Restoration," she remarked with an air of
reserve. "I remain passionately attached to the memory of the
Emperor—Paris under Bourbon rule has no attractions for me. I prefer
Both the ladies cherished a sentimental regard for Napoleon I, and thought
this a very proper speech on the part of Mademoiselle Debelleyme, one, too,
which gave her the dignity of a certain mystery. Mrs. Coombe Wade became more
eager than ever to engage her services and began to press the advantages of
this post in one of the most sumptuous establishments of France...
"Surely," objected the governess, "Madame du Boccage could find someone in
Paris whom she could interview personally? Is it not rather peculiar for her
to entrust so delicate a mission even to the most intimate of friends?"
Again Mrs. Coombe Wade was at a loss; reluctantly, vaguely, she
"It is not very easy, I understand from Madame Faustin, to satisfy Madame
du Boccage—she thought perhaps that a person used to English
life—" Becoming further baffled by the upward flash of the governess'
clear eyes, she added weakly:
"There have been six governesses in the last two years—so you
"That Madame la Duchesse is difficult?" finished Mademoiselle gently.
"No." Mrs. Coombe Wade made a gallant recovery, "She is the most charming,
the most generous of women! But an exceptional person is required—"
"Do you think I should suit Madame du Boccage?"
Lady Anfield rose, resolved to end the interview. "Oh, I'm sure!" she
smiled. "I should think it over, Mademoiselle—and then you could see
Madame Faustin, couldn't you? A hundred a year is quite exceptional, isn't
it? It was so kind of Mrs. Coombe Wade to think of you, wasn't it?"
The governess was well trained to know when she was dismissed; she rose
"I am deeply obliged, Lady Anfleld. If I might have till tomorrow? Just to
think over my plans? Thank you. I am so grateful, Mrs. Coombe Wade. I hope
never to disappoint your kindness."
Something in her carriage as she crossed the long room to the heavy door
roused again that vague feeling of uneasiness in the mind of Mrs. Coombe
Wade—but she could not name even to herself what quality in
mademoiselle provoked this, and Lady Anfield said decisively:
"She really is a prize, dear, you must persuade her to accept."
Mademoiselle Debelleyme had immediately decided to take the position
offered in the establishment of Madame du Boccage; her hesitation had been
only assumed in order to increase her value. She longed to return to Paris
where she had not been for eight years, and the post seemed one that was in
every way more desirable than anything that had come her way before. Not that
she hoped to remain long in the Faubourg St. Honoré; she never remained long
anywhere; despite her excellent credentials, her perfect behaviour, her
talents, her unimpeachable character, no one wanted to keep her. A year with
Lady Tryon's delicate little girl, then the child had been sent to Italy and
mademoiselle had not been asked to accompany her. Teaching at various
Academies for Young Ladies, Clapham, Highgate, Bedford, a few months at each,
then, under some perfectly reasonable excuse, her place had been filled by
another. After that the Brentwells, two years with three little boys and
dismissed to give way for a tutor; now Lady Anfield, who had suddenly and
vaguely found her girls "too old for a governess." Nowhere did mademoiselle
attach herself and she knew now exactly what her utmost endeavours and
exertions could obtain for her, which was the position of an upper servant in
a large house, a position which could only be maintained by complete
abnegation, rigid self-discipline, tedious toil and an attitude of exact
decorum and humility.
She knew why she had lost her various posts when some women remained with
one family for a lifetime; she had a strange influence over children, roused
their passionate attachment and loyalty, and the mothers, lazy and careless
as they were, became jealous. She was able to make herself obeyed by servants
and, after a while, her influence, very subtle but powerful, permeated any
household in which she stayed. She had been very careful, trained herself to
complete effacement, been tactful, discreet, useful, patient; but the candour
of the children's affection had always betrayed her, she became too
important, she must go.
Oh, nothing to complain of—she might have excellent credentials! Her
employers, with the most kindly intentions, praised her warmly—but she
left one place after another with the laments of her little charges in her
ears as her sole reward.
Yet in much she had been lucky; the various oblique lies she had
insinuated about her origin had gone down very well; Lucille Clery, Mary
Showler, had easily become Lucille Debelleyme, she had even lived down the
folly of that elopement from Bath; Miss Le Moine's testimonial lay with
others in her reticule. A telegram had summoned her to her grandfather's
death-bed, she had fled in such haste and distress that she had forgotten to
even leave a message. Did Miss Le Moine believe this? She had regretted she
could not receive Miss Showler again in her Academy, but she had not refused
a handsome certificate of character.
Robert Morrison was dead, killed in the hunting field; the reading of that
news in the papers had given Mademoiselle Debelleyme the only real pleasure
she had known in five years.
She went up to her room in the gloomy Belgravia mansion. A dull, sunless
apartment, shabbily furnished with cast-out articles from the other rooms, a
hard bed, a tarnished mirror and faded curtains of an ugly plum-coloured rep.
The view was over backyards, basements and barred kitchen windows. The
governess sat at the window and looked with loathing at this dismal
She wondered how she existed from day to day, body and soul in invisible
chains, her pride in fierce subjection, all her desires denied, no prospect
whatever for the future; completely isolated, disdaining to make friends with
servants, disdained by those above servants, forced to hide all her
character, half her gifts, all her attractions; twenty-eight years old,
immersed in resignation.
"What is the use of existence on these terms? How do I find the strength
to endure it?"
Yet she knew; it was because of some lunatic hope that one day, by some
miracle, something would occur to change her life into the extravagant, the
fantastic, the passionate adventure she wished it to be. She deluded herself
from day to day, knowing that she was doing so, yet not daring to face
reality. To one situated like herself escape could only come through men and
no man had shown himself ready to be her deliverer.
Robert Morrison was dead; her brief affair with him was dead; but not
buried. It lay corrupting in her soul, poisoning even her dreams. For five
years she had, by hard work and a watchful discretion, maintained a position
in aristocratic families, secured a bare if genteel living, but always
ignored, a virtuous gentlewoman forbidden to the libertine, a pauper
forbidden to the marrying man.
She had never again met as bold a rake as Robert Morrison. Once or twice
she had observed a licentious glance pass over her when, summoned to the
drawing-room during a reception, she had played some young lady's
accompaniment on the pianoforte, once or twice she had been insolently
addressed in the street. On each occasion she had in her mind shudderingly
rejected the advance. She did not demand an honourable love but Robert
Morrison had taught her that she must have some gloss of elegancy over lust.
She was eager to sell herself, but the purchaser must be delicately behaved,
respect her pride, her fastidiousness; she could not again live through an
experience like that of that night in the inn outside Paddington.
Often after some bitter humiliation when her vanity, her ambition had
refused to lie quiescent, she had reflected in despair: "I should be better
off in a brothel."
But her difficulty lay in the fact that she did not really know what a
brothel was, where to find one, nor how to gain admittance if she did. Did
one discover the address of a house of ill fame, knock and say: "Madame,
permit me to help entertain your clients?" Did one creep out after dark, pull
some man by the coat and whisper: "Take me somewhere where we shall be
There might be a stepping stone there to liberty, independence on the
stage or as the kept woman of a rich man, "but I have no knowledge, no
courage to face another Morrison—and worse."
Constantly in the company of children or smugly respectable women the
governess could know little of the world save from an avid but limited
reading and the sordid gossip of servants.
So she remained chaste, dainty, in person, habits, behaviour, but her
thoughts ranged wide and the least of them would have profoundly shocked her
Her experience with Robert Morrison had given her a disgust of sex and she
was too absorbed in herself to dream of an ideal lover; so, naturally cold,
she did not suffer from her enforced chastity, but she raged that she could
not turn it to advantage before she was old... surely some man, somewhere,
would for the sake of her lovely body, hidden under her ugly clothes, relieve
her of her intolerable servitude? But where to find him?
A cloud obscured the mournful pale blue above the ugly backs of the
houses, a few drops of rain fell on the sooty sill of her window. She roused
herself. She had the afternoon for her packing, her pupils were out with an
aunt. She turned to her trunk, carefully folded her plain linen, her sombre
dresses, her thick stockings and one or two rich and elaborate scraps of
embroidery that she had worked herself.
She would go to Paris—a hundred pounds a year, a sumptuous mansion;
worth trying, but how long could she placate Madame du Boccage who had had
six governesses in two years? Here obviously was a difficult, tyrannical,
tiresome, spoilt woman, probably a peevish invalid—"but I might stay
till I had found something else in Paris—Paris in the spring! Mon Dieu!
There is life to be seen there—even from afar!"
And surely in a ducal establishment she might hope to escape from some of
the most degrading humiliations inflicted on her by her English
employers—"Yes, darling, the peaches are rather bruised, you may offer
one to mademoiselle—" "Oh, the concert will be very dull, mademoiselle
must take you—" "These gloves are badly cut and Bennetts won't take
them back, would you like them. Mademoiselle?" "No, dear, mademoiselle never
has a headache, though it is my sweet child to think of it—she can very
well go on reading to you"—or, most humiliating of all, "Mademoiselle,
I think you should not wear that lace collar and brooch, I always insist on
my governesses being most plainly attired."
She dropped the lid of her trunk and stood reflecting on the faint
possibilities offered by this new position—this new chance?—in
And an ironic smile lifted her lip into an unpleasant expression. The
governess' interview with Madame Faustin passed off very well. The great lady
found the young woman modest, dignified, as agreeable as intelligent, and
well bred. Mademoiselle Debelleyme left the French Embassy engaged as head
governess in the establishment of Madame du Boccage, with three months'
salary and her fare to Paris in her pocket.
There had been one little difficulty; the question of
religion. The governess, bred a Roman Catholic, had become a Protestant to
please her English employers, and Madame du Boccage was devote; but Madame
Faustin was not and thought that the governess could quietly return to her
early faith without any reference to her heretical lapse, and easily conform
with Church observances sufficiently to satisfy her mistress; and the
governess, who cared nothing for any creed, thought so too.
She returned for the last time to the mansion in Belgravia; performed her
final duties to her pupils, who were sullen and red-eyed because of her
departure, and took leave of Lady Anfield, who vaguely congratulated her on
her "splendid good luck".
In the wide bedchamber of the little girls the governess knelt at prayers;
the night lamp cast a soft light over the heavy furniture, the prints of
religious subjects on the walls, the toys neatly stacked on the shelves, the
straight beds with the dimity covers sprigged with roses. The children's
heads were bowed in their hands, their well-brushed, pale yellow hair hung
down over their white nightgowns which fell over their woollen shoes slipping
off their pink heels.
The governess knelt between them but her head was raised; she stared into
the warm flickering shadows of the familiar room and she did not repeat the
formula of the prayers even with her lips.
The children loved her; that was her offence here. Probably it would
always be her offence wherever she went. With children she was herself,
vivid, amusing, possessed of a delicate understanding of childish minds, of
the art of making the commonplace exciting, of banishing boredom, of soothing
by firmness, by an exact order. She knew that she could make any child love
her and she could love any child for the same reason that a blind beggar
loves his dog; the animal does not know that his master is less than other
men, and children did not know that Lucille Debelleyme was below other women,
"only the governess." She set herself deliberately, carefully, to charm them,
to win their respect, their devotion, and they responded instantly.
Sometimes, as they grew older they became tainted by the world's opinion and
realised that their fascinating companion was only a penniless dependent in
their father's house; but with the little children she was always sure of her
The prayers over, the two girls embraced her with sobs, stammering over
their good-byes. She soothed them gravely, tucked them in bed, stayed till
they slept, then left them in charge of the nurse, who did not like her, and
watched her departure with gratified malice.
In her upper room the governess lit the candle and finished her packing.
On top of all her other clothes she carefully placed a blue silk dress, a
tartan scarf, a gros de Naples mantle, a bonnet with a black lace
fall; in the bottom of the trunk was a copy of 'Forget-me-not' of 1840, and a
silver thimble wreathed with pure blue flowers.
She began to undress. The evening was warm; she had half raised the
Holland blind and she could see the tiny lights in the windows of the backs
of the houses across the yards. Above the ugly chimney-stacks a few stars
showed a melancholy, remote sparkle.
The governess took off her clothes and drew the curtains. She had locked
the door and felt that she had escaped from the pompous house, from the
people in it, from the routine of the day; she was no longer the governess
but a woman. She dominated her shabby surroundings as she stood naked on the
square of drugget by the bed; she had taken the pins out of her hair and it
fell in natural ringlets to her waist, a lovely shining colour and
She arranged the mirror so that/she could see as much of her body as
"This is I, myself. All that I have. And I must hide it away, be ashamed
of it. No one knows what I am like."
Long, pale limbs, of firm line, a body in perfect harmony with the small
classic-featured face, with hair fine as silk.
She admired her hands, her feet that she tended so carefully, the
smoothness of her skin, her full bosom, the slope of her waist and thighs. In
the curve of her back were two brown moles.
Moving the mirror from place to place she gravely surveyed herself; she
was not thinking of any possible lover, there was nothing voluptuous in her
pose or her gestures; she contemplated her own beauty because it gratified
her pride, her self-respect, increased her value in her own eyes. Only by the
convention of society was she less than other women.
The candle was guttering; she extinguished it and the dark completed her
sense of deliverance. Her cold eyes gazed gratefully into the blackness as
she sat on the edge of the bed, her body freed from ugly garments, her mind
from the necessities of servitude.
The steamboat left Harwich on a bright, windy morning. Mademoiselle
Debelleyme sat on deck; she had managed her affairs without haste or
confusion, her purse was in her hand, her carpet bag by her side, she had
seen her trunk on board, knotted her veil round her bonnet, drawn her shawl
round her shoulders and sat at ease and leisure.
She was the only female travelling alone. She watched contemptuously the
helpless disorder of such other women as there were, how they clamoured for
the protection of father, husband, brother, making a parade of foolishness
and helplessness, how they lamented the distress of the voyage, and retired
to the cabins immediately with smelling salts, eau-de-Cologne and toilet
vinegar. Possessed of perfect health she was not disturbed by the motion of
the ship and her spirits rose when England dropped out of sight on the
She disembarked easily, found her place in the Paris train and felt all
her excitement sink suddenly; even the unusual speed, the spinning past of
the Norman orchards, the puffs of whirling smoke crossing the coach window
could not distract her fatigue. Her companions were dull and soon slept, the
seat was uncomfortable, she felt imprisoned in this box. She ate some cake
and an apple; her head began to ache, she took off her bonnet and closed her
eyes; half drowsy, she tried to plan for the future to the exasperating beat
of the engine.
How long shall I stay in Paris? Surely something will arise. Anything
would be preferable to returning to England. My grandfather, too, is living
at St. Cloud, the miser! I believe he has money hidden away, surely he might
do something for me! Would it be any use appealing to my father's people? No!
No! They would never acknowledge me. I must remember I am a good Catholic
now. Shall I possibly have a chance to go to the Opera, the theatre, a fine
reception, a concert, the Tuileries? Of course not, stop dreaming, stop
dreaming, Lucille Clery, you fool! Will some man want me as a wife or a
mistress? How contrive, with complete decorum, to attract any one? And I
won't be despised, I'm glad that Robert Morrison is dead, dead, dead. Was he
drunk when he fell from his horse? No one will notice me, I don't look pretty
in the hideous clothes I have to wear, I'm always effaced. Why was I given
that genteel education? Shall I ever fall in love? All men have a look of
I must recall all Madame Faustin told me of Madame du
Boccage—devote. Mon Dieu! She was eighteen when she married; she has
had nine children in fifteen years, four are dead—she is, then,
thirty-three, not so much older than I. What a different life! What is it
really like to have children? I should think it would be a sort of ecstasy to
have your body used.
Nine children. M. du Boccage is even younger than she—he was only
seventeen when she saw him at a ball and vowed that no other should be her
husband—she had a dowry of two million, a great name, she could pick
and choose. Sweetly romantic, Madame Faustin said, and their devotion a
byword in France. I've seen enough of these affectionate families, it's like
being cold and looking at a fire through a window.
How easy, with all that money and power, to be happy!
But Madame du Boccage is difficult—no one has stayed with her, what
is the trouble? Shall I be able to overcome it?
To live in the Faubourg St. Honoré! With one of the greatest families of
France! I must please her, if only for a while—
The governess could not escape from the trammels of decorum; she had
scarcely begun to breathe the clear exciting air of Paris before she was
accosted by an elderly couple who introduced themselves as Monsieur and
Madame Santerre. They had been sent by Madame du Boccage to look after the
governess for the night, until she was sufficiently rested and composed after
her travel to present herself in the Faubourg St. Honoré.
The tired, disarrayed young woman accepted this considerate attention with
due gratitude; but she would have liked this one evening in Paris to herself,
at an inn, or even with her grandfather, where she could be outspoken, at
But she was shepherded to the respectable home of the Santerres; they had
both been in the service of Madame du Boccage and were full of tales of her
bounty, sweetness, domestic virtues, modesty and piety, as well as of her
riches and splendour.
Mademoiselle Debelleyme listened with an appreciative smile and downcast
"But it has not been easy to suit Madame with a governess?" she suggested,
"Ah, Mademoiselle understands that Madame is most careful, devoted as she
is to her children she requires an exceptional person!"
The governess had heard that expression several times before; was she the
exceptional person Madame du Boccage required?
"There is a Mademoiselle Broc who has been in entire charge—but she
had not the authority; she will remain, but under you—"
"Mon Dieu," thought the governess, "I shall have to placate this creature,
too! How spiteful she will be at being displaced!"
During the modest supper the Santerres continued to praise the
establishment in the Faubourg St. Honoré; through the welter of simple-minded
adulation the governess contrived to extract one or two useful facts.
Madame du Boccage was a Corsican; on the death of her father she would
inherit even greater wealth than she at present enjoyed. M. du Boccage had
just come into the title and been elected a member of the Chamber of Peers.
He was an intimate friend of the Royal Princes, M. de Nemours, M. de
Montpensier, M. de Joinville... but he was not so often at Court now as he
was occupied in restoring the famous Chateau of Javiaux du Boccage near Melun
which he had recently inherited—but usually the family went for the
summer to Locroi in Normandy where Madame had an estate, or to Dieppe for the
The governess thought: "No doubt I shall have left them by the holidays,"
nor was she interested in M. du Boccage. The fathers of her charges had never
concerned her in the least; they had always remained strangers whom she had
hardly seen. "I shall have to deal with the mistress, this other governess,
the children, the servants—eh, well, one does one's best!"
She was given a neat room high above the darkness and rumble of Paris. A
crucifix was over the bed, a book of religious meditations on the table; the
governess leaned eagerly from the window into the spring night.
She loved this city in which she had been born and educated, the old
quays, the dark scented churches, the narrow streets of the Isle, the
luxurious gardens in front of high palaces, the quarters where the
fashionable shops and restaurants flourished. She knew Paris very well from
the outside, she was at home in this country, her own country, among the
people and the places which had formed her obscure origin.
Kneeling before the open trunk, Mademoiselle Debelleyme took out her one
silk gown which had been worn once and then hidden for five years. Out of
date, but not so markedly; she could adjust it. Paris had already excited
her; she would not appear in the Faubourg St. Honoré in the dowdy merino that
pleased the English gentlewomen. Madame du Boccage was Parisienne, she would
not expect a fright, she must be above the petty jealousy of frumps like Lady
Fingering the stiff silk made furtively by the Bath dressmaker, the
governess' mind went back to her sordid elopement, and, curiously, to the
impetuous exclamation she had made to Robert Morrison. Reading of the funeral
of the Emperor she had allowed her scorn of Louis Philippe to find
expression, and had cried: "I wish I could pull him down!"
She smiled bitterly at this recollection; what a fool to think she could
have any hand in public affairs! Here she was, in Paris, not as the Hon. Mrs.
Morrison, who might have meddled in politics, not as a successful courtesan
who might have pulled strings, but as a dependant in the household of one of
the Orleans King's courtiers.
The governess knew contemporary politics as she knew Paris, thoroughly,
from the outside; she had learnt from her grandfather a sentimental and
selfish devotion to Napoleon I; it was true that her family had been ruined
and scattered at the Restoration of the Bourbons. And if she hated the
Legitimists she scorned more deeply the cadet branch of the Royal House which
had cringed to the people, paraded liberal ideas and risen to a restricted
power through the ruin of the rightful Kings.
Louis Philippe D'Orleans had fought the Royalists at Valmy, erased the
Lilies from his escutcheon, and. Prince of the Blood, son of the man who had
voted for the death of his cousin, Louis XVI, effected the "bon bourgeois,"
the citizen monarch, and meanly named himself Louis Philippe as if he was a
petty Prince of Italy or Germany. The governess would very willingly have
seen him chased from Paris amid the uproar of yet another revolution; she had
been pleased to observe in a print-seller's window as she drove from the
station a caricature of the stout monarch, with his close whiskers and neat
curly toupet as a huge pear!
She must think of her own affairs; she needed gloves, shoes, a veil. She
must be up early to purchase these before she waited on Madame du
Weariness overcame her, she slid cautiously into the bed and slept beneath
the dark outline of the cheap crucifix.
The Hotel du Boccage was situated near the embassies of
England and Mecklenbourg and some of the finest mansions of the French
aristocracy. A high gateway flanked by Doric pillars and two porters' lodges
faced the street and opened into an enchanting little garden enclosed by high
walls above which, to the right, rose the handsome edifice of the Elysee
Beyond the light foliage of the slight poplar trees, the Persian lilac and
early roses. Mademoiselle Debelleyme saw the charming facade of an eighteenth
century mansion of elegant white stone. The French windows of the rez de
chaussée opened on to handsome balconies of ornamental ironwork, the
floor above and the mansard windows that cut the high roof of grey slates
were alike surrounded with graceful swags of flowers and fruit. The new
governess crossed the little sanded court beyond the garden and mounted the
few shallow marble steps that led to the door that broke the windows of the
She was instantly admitted and conducted across an antechamber to the
salon de reception. This was a magnificent apartment which looked on to the
Champs Élysées and the Avenue Gabriel; there was no sound nor sight
suggestive of a great city; the house might have been set in a great
The new governess was asked to wait; as soon as she was alone she looked
about her eagerly. She was used to the heavy, expensive comfort of wealthy
English homes, but this was different, this was magnificence, taste,
elegance, this was, above everything, French. She liked to think that her
ancestors had enjoyed such luxury and that she had been debarred only by the
accident of birth from just such surroundings. So pleased and excited was she
that her whole attitude and expression subtly and unconsciously changed. She
drew herself more erect as her glance went from pale velvet carpets to
delicate brocade curtains, from tall mirrors wreathed in gilt lilies to
porcelains smooth and lustrous as silk, from chairs in exquisite tapestry to
the drawn straw-coloured moire of the wall panels, which alternated with
scenes of pastoral loves by François Boucher.
Crystal candelabra hung from the painted ceiling, flowers adorned
jardinières of Saxe and Sèvres, the April sunshine dancing through the
moving trees outside filled the room with light. The atmosphere was that of a
palace; the taste, the decor of the Regency, that period so smoothly lovely
on the surface, so completely rotten within, a period that would have suited
Lucille Debelleyme exactly.
She looked at herself in the mirror above the ornate alabaster mantelpiece
as she had looked at herself in the Paddington inn, and her room in the
Belgravia mansion, with a keen scrutiny, with a jealous pride. She did not
belong to the room, nor to the eighteenth century, yet she was not out of
place, her five-year-old refurbished finery was still in perfect taste, her
long curls framed a face that only required the right setting to be
beautiful. She flung out her full skirts and thought: "Ah, no one will be
able to prevent me from thinking I am the mistress here, no one can read my
Something startled her, fear like a cold breath dampened her rebellious
pride; she saw a white, menacing face staring over her shoulder.
She spun round, then smiled at herself; the mirror was placed in the
corner and against the opposite wall was a marble statue that represented a
Cupidon arming himself with bow and arrow and staring before him to mark the
target for the shafts of Love. This figure displayed all the graces of the
irresistible Clodion, but, even on close scrutiny, the governess thought
there was something sinister lurking in the contour of the fair marble face,
a peculiar, disagreeable expression. But she never indulged fancies; she
continued her eager observation of the gay and beautiful room that so
delighted her. Her appraisal was professional; for nearly ten years she had
been making herself expert in the domestic side of life, turning her
energies, denied all other outlet, into this narrow channel.
She observed therefore much besides the impressive luxury of the place.
There was dust on everything, the hot-house flowers were withered, the
alabaster needed cleaning, here and there a braid hung in a loop; a chair had
been stained, and above the massive pelmets that sparkled with gold thread a
few cobwebs could be discerned in the shadows. The new governess had noticed
that the footman who had admitted her was not as smart as he should have
been; and the porter in the lodge, a little too untidy, a little too
good-natured—not that well-trained impersonal behaviour that should
have been demanded in such an establishment.
"All that money—and careless," reflected the governess. "I suppose
they let everyone rob them. I wonder if I shall be able to get anything out
A heavy sigh disturbed her; she turned as a low voice said:
"You are Mademoiselle Debelleyme, the new governess?"
Madame du Boccage had entered softly through the pale-rose velvet curtains
at the end of the room; the governess dropped a curtsy and waited.
"Pray sit down, Mademoiselle. I trust you had a tolerable voyage? And that
the Santerres made you comfortable? They are good people."
"Yes, Madame, I am very grateful for your thoughtfulness."
And Mademoiselle Debelleyme waited for the usual scrutiny to which she was
subjected by new employers; with an air of fatigue and another sigh the
Duchess had sunk on to a canape,
"You are much younger than I thought," she remarked rather wistfully.
"I am twenty-eight, Madame."
"I know—but Madame Faustin told me that you were a very serious,
grave person—much older than your years—I do not perceive
Madame du Boccage spoke gently, even benevolently, but the governess knew
that she was disappointed, and knew why.
The young woman in the dark merino, with the pulled-back hair, who had
been interviewed by the wife of the French Ambassador had given a different
impression from that made by the silk-clad lady with the long ringlets, now
being examined. "I have made a mistake," thought the governess, and adroitly
endeavoured to efface her error.
"It is the attire. Madame will understand that what passes in London will
not do for Paris. Nor is the establishment of Lady Anfield on a level with
that of Madame. I believed I should please by an appearance comme il
faut, but," added the governess, suddenly raising her clear eyes, "it is
true that I have never been in a household like that of M. du Boccage and if
I have done wrong I hope that Madame will overlook it. I will wear anything
that Madame pleases."
The women's glances met and held each other for a second; it was that of
the Duchess which wavered first.
"Oh no," she said with a touch of confusion. "I should never interfere in
that way. Pray don't think so. It is only—one thought of
a—different personality—but it is nothing, nothing at all! Your
testimonials were excellent, excellent, Madame Faustin spoke of you so
She was silent and the governess dutifully waited again with lowered eyes;
this had become a habit with her, not from modesty, but from fear that her
rebellion, her scorn, her pride might, despite her control, show in her
powerful gaze. But in that brief glance she had received an exact impression
of her new mistress.
Madame du Boccage was very dark, black hair, soft black eyes, amber
complexion, too plump but handsome. There was something imposing about her,
but something also gentle; she seemed anxious to please but slightly troubled
as to how to do so, and the governess had instantly noted the same slight
disorder in the lady's dress as she had observed in the mansion. The robe of
the Duchess was both fashionable and costly, but carelessly worn, her
jewellery did not match, and the exquisite lace cap that rested on her glossy
curls seemed to have been pinned in place by an indifferent hand.
She began to speak again. Her voice, the warm, slightly husky voice of the
South, was very pleasant, but she spoke vaguely, the usual commonplace talk
of a woman relegating her maternal duties to another and salving her
conscience by elaborate instructions she will never trouble to see carried
out. Several times she sighed, lost the thread of her discourse, was a little
incoherent. The answers of the governess were prompt and precise, mere
mechanical acceptances of orders, or assurances of obedience; but suddenly
she made an objection.
"Mademoiselle Broc will tell you all that you wish to know. You will go to
her for everything."
"And not to you, Madame?"
The governess raised her eyes again; she was gaining confidence from the
obvious weakness and indecision of the other woman, a confidence increased by
the sudden flush that coloured the handsome face of Madame de Boccage, by her
"I do not interfere at all—you understand—my attendance at
Court—I entertain a great deal—you will have sole
"And sole responsibility? It is a heavy task—I had hardly
understood—" murmured the governess carefully feeling her way before
this unexpected situation.
"I know. Several have failed at it! It is difficult indeed! I will not
disguise that we have had a good deal of trouble to find the right
person—I hope that you may be she—let us try, Mademoiselle. We
can but try."
The governess thought: "Something is wrong here—what? And can I turn
it to my advantage? The woman seems a fool. A tiresome, melancholy fool. She
looks ten years older than she is—why does she sigh and flush? Mon
Dieu, if I had what she has, I'd have Paris at my feet."
And the governess averted her gaze test this should too plainly show in
her eyes. "How I hate you for having everything while I have nothing, nothing
This interview that the indecisiveness and hesitations of the Duchess were
prolonging indefinitely, was cut abruptly short.
The door was opened brusquely, a man entered.
The Duchess instantly rose.
"This is Mademoiselle Debelleyme—Mademoiselle, M. du Boccage."
And she was gone, with startling swiftness, through the rose velvet
The governess was, for once, at a loss; this sudden departure of her
mistress, this sudden appearance of her master whom she had not troubled to
reckon on at all, disturbed her well-trained control, her cold
self-assurance. She curtsied to the man who had paused before her, nervously
put aside her veil, flicked her handkerchief across her lips, then, as she
grasped the personality of the stranger who was looking at her keenly, her
courage really broke, she dropped, trembling and speechless, into a
For it seemed to her that she was staring at Robert Morrison.
"You are ill. Mademoiselle? You have not, perhaps, recovered from the
The voice was courteous and kind, the tone one of a solicitous respect
with which she was not familiar; she quickly thought of an excuse for female
faintness that she had read of in one of Lady Blessington's languishing
"The flowers. Monsieur—I am not used—the perfume of exotics is
overpowering, is it not? And the air so warm—"
The Duke snatched up one of the vases that stood near his hand, and
exclaimed in deep vexation:
"They are not fresh and the water is stale—always the same! These
little things—excuse me, Mademoiselle."
He went to a window, flung it open and tossed out withering tuberoses,
gardenias, camellias and stagnant water.
There was a sharpness in this unusual action that had the dramatic quality
of emotional expression; the young man was plainly angry. The governess
stared at him, thinking in a panic:
"I can't stay in the same house with anyone who looks like Robert
Morrison—Mon Dieu, what cursed luck!"
She could not immediately recover from the shock of this likeness between
the living and the dead; it was inescapable, exasperating to find in M. du
Boccage, of whom she had formed only a vague, disinterested image, a replica
of the man who had caused her to regard all his sex with abhorrence.
The Frenchman had the same type of athletic figure as the Englishman,
compact, powerful, graceful under his costly attire of a dandy, the same
excessive blondness that had alternately attracted and repelled her in Robert
Morrison. His thick straw-coloured hair curled into the toupet fashionable
among all the courtiers of Louis Philippe, his grey eyes were shaded by
lashes that appeared to have been powdered. The features were blunt, good,
youthful, he appeared less than his years, much younger than his wife; his
clothes and accessories were exquisite, from the light-grey and blue striped
trousers strapped under his feet to the pearl-hued waistcoat and fine cambric
Having relieved his temper by casting the contents of the vase into the
Champs Élysées, the Duke turned with an engaging smile that seemed to excuse
his ill humour; his natural manner appeared to be soft, gentle, even gay, his
voice was low and seductive. He approached the governess, who was shrinking
into herself with loathing, and began to speak with that enchanting air of
grand seigneur which was more welcome to her than fine wine to the
palate, than rich perfume to the nostrils, than soft cushions to the
But she resisted, still in a panic; she rose, breaking through his
apologies, his excuses—he, not his wife, should have received her, it
seemed, there had been a mistake—but what did that matter now? She must
leave his presence, his house—
"I regret, Monsieur—the position seems too difficult, I did not
understand—I fear I could not undertake—"
"Mademoiselle, you would not leave me in this embarrassment—this
"The loss of a governess embarrasses Monsieur?"
"I must confess it—I have been overwhelmed lately. You seem,
Mademoiselle, the person for whom I am searching—"
"Do I?" She could afford to be bold as she intended to leave the Faubourg
St. Honoré for ever, so she looked at him steadily with dislike and irony.
"But Monsieur knows nothing of me."
"I have excellent testimonials. I rely on the judgment of Madame Faustin
and my own observation."
The observation of a few seconds?"
"It is sufficient. Mademoiselle, you have a presence and manner that give
confidence. I feel that my children will be safe in your hands."
"Monsieur obliges me by this condescension—but I still
"If, Mademoiselle, Madame du Boccage has said anything to discourage you,
may I beg that you will listen to me before refusing to remain?"
She seated herself, but averted her face with unquenchable repugnance;
only curiosity kept her there at all. What was the secret of this
As the Duke spoke she listened, however, more to his voice than to his
words, for this had an irresistible charm for her; and presently she ventured
to look at him again and her shocked loathing lessened.
He was like Robert Morrison, not in everything, he had not the
Englishman's coarseness, arrogance or careless dress; he was essentially a
French aristocrat, a courtier, and in all he did and said was the
distinction, the allure of breed. Like the room of the house in which he sat
he had an air of the ancien régime.
What was he saying? She drew herself together to listen—Ah,
banalities, trivialities, his children, his governesses, his servants, the
disorders of his household, his wife's ill health. She was bewildered.
He was not clever with words, he spoke in cliches and repeated himself.
One sentence leapt from the others and fixed her distracted attention.
"I want you to take entire charge. Mademoiselle—expenses, nurses,
maids, amusements—you will have the first floor entirely to
"Entire charge? And the mother?"
"She will see the children for half an hour in the morning—otherwise
you will manage absolutely alone."
Unlimited power! In such an establishment! I must not be a fool again. I
must forget he is like that miserable Englishman—at least I will find
"I regret, Monsieur, I could not accept a position that would be the means
of separating mother and children. I could not live apart—with the
"I shall always be available. You can consult me whenever you wish. I take
the warmest interest in the education of my children."
Again the governess murmured:
"And the mother?"
"Neither her health nor her temperament permit her to interfere. She will
be only too happy to leave everything to you."
Mademoiselle Debelleyme raised her eyebrows; it was now perfectly clear to
her why there had been six governesses in three years at the Faubourg St.
Honoré. It was not in the least likely, she reflected rapidly, that she would
be more fortunate than her predecessors. A definite refusal was on her lips,
but she hesitated because of the charm of M. du Boccage's voice.
She raised her eyes from the flowery wreaths on the Aubusson carpet to
where the Duke's hands grasped the gilt foliage of the chair back. Startled,
she noted the extreme nervous tension in that grip on the frail woodwork, the
power in the wrists and fingers. These were the hands, not of an idle
gentleman, but a man of enormous strength.
She looked up into his face. His eyes, under the thick blond lashes,
regarded her steadily, and she saw in their depths something of the
expression she had so often tried to disguise in her own. For a second two
fellow spirits welcomed each other, then the glances fell apart; he was the
Duke again and she the new governess in his household.
But she had made up her alert, adroit mind; this man with whom she would
have to deal, to consult with every day, might be hatefully like Robert
Morrison, but he was also possessed of exquisite manners, great physical
strength and capable (she was instinctively sure) of profound duplicity. This
combination attracted her; she asked no more from any human being than
decorative qualities and a convenient unscrupulousness. She felt excited but
preserved a melancholy resolute exterior.
"Well, Monsieur really wishes me to undertake this charge?"
"I have been asking you for the last half-hour. Mademoiselle, to do
"Monsieur realises there are objections—from my point of view?" She
rose and her glance was at once an appeal and a challenge. "And Monsieur will
remember that he persuaded me—and support me in case
"You may count on me, Mademoiselle."
She still appeared to reflect; as she slowly buttoned her tiny glove (how
easily both her hands could have lain in one of the large palms of M. du
Boccage!) she observed, casually, the white mask of the Cupidon that had
startled her before. Certainly there was something sinister in that marble
face, as if the malicious god tipped his barbs with poison.
"Very well. Monsieur, I will stay. I will attempt to please
Mademoiselle Broc, lean, vigorous, elderly, poured out bitter gossip as
she showed the new governess over the floor reserved for the children and
their staff; her eager spite flowed out like the steady rush of water falling
from an upturned vase.
The household was impossible, an inferno, Mademoiselle Debelleyme would
find that out for herself—of course she would not be able to manage,
not be able to stay, who could!
The Duchess was sick, hysterical, wildly jealous, unbalanced: Matilde, her
maid from Normandy was a toady and a spy, the children were spoiled, the
household out of hand, the nurses were idle, insolent gossips, the servants
did what they pleased, the robbery, the waste, was sinful!
Mademoiselle Broc named everyone in the sumptuous household and gave each
one a bad character.
"And the Duke?" asked the new governess, quietly.
Mademoiselle Broc had nothing but praise for the Duke; he had been
charming to her, kind, considerate, the children adored him—but what
could he do? Whenever he tried to interfere Madame made a scene; sometimes it
was clear that he was driven half distracted—that was why he was trying
to take the children away from their mother because he was sure the little
ones were being ruined by this perpetual disorder—whenever Madame came
near them there was trouble.
"Madame and Monsieur du Boccage do not agree, then? It is an unhappy
It was clear from the confused venom of Mademoiselle Broc's reply that she
did not know; there was no definite scandal, merely a clash of temperaments,
a disagreement over the education of the children—but what did it
matter? The household, the displaced governess insisted, was an inferno!
"Which you have helped to make, you old fool," thought Lucille Debelleyme.
"I must, of course, find out the truth for myself but, unfortunately, the
truth is generally what one does not find out."
She was only half listening to the tirade of Mademoiselle Broc, her
attention was distracted by the comforts, the splendours of the apartments
which were to be under her sole charge. With greedy pleasure she noted every
luxury; two rooms for herself, furnished like the bedchamber and boudoir of a
gentlewoman, a pianette, a harp, a desk, flowers, pictures, a lovely view on
to the tree tops of the Champs Élysées... a sharp difference from the little
room with the drugget square, the hard bed, the cracked mirror, of Belgrave
"I'll stay here," thought Lucille Debelleyme, "as long as human ingenuity
can contrive it."
Mademoiselle Broc continued to assail her ears with a tumult of involved,
petty and sordid complaints.
"Don't you think," rebuked the new governess with gentle authority, "that
we should not gossip about our employers? And that we should always speak
respectfully about Madame la Duchesse?"
"My dear Camille," said Madame du Boccage carefully, "I am sure that
Mademoiselle Debelleyme will not suit us."
"On the contrary," he replied with his ready, amiable smile, "I believe
that she will do very well."
"Oh no! She is not in the least the sort of person I expected. Really,
Madame Faustin quite deceived me. She is too young for such a
responsibility—and that cold, English type!"
"She is a Parisienne."
"Who is she, really?"
"Of a good family who was ruined at the Restoration, her testimonials were
sufficient. We will give her a trial at least."
He waited patiently for his wife's answer to this, but he had an air of
being detained; she had indeed intercepted him in the antechamber as he was
about to leave to accompany the Royal Princes, M.M. D'Aumale and De Nemours,
to the races on the Champ de Mars where the colours of Rothschild would
compete with those of de Morny and de Pontalba. He looked very elegant in his
correct English clothes; the Anglophilia now the height of the fashion suited
him exactly, for he was of the type that his countrymen called
His wife looked at him frowning.
"Believe me, Camille. she will not do—Mademoiselle Broc came to me
immediately complaining of her—"
"Mademoiselle Broc has been displaced—it is conceivable that she is
prejudiced. All the trouble lies in these perpetual recriminations. Has
Mademoiselle Debelleyme complained of anything?"
"Give her, then, at least a trial, my dear Fanny. Are you coming to the
ball at the Tuileries to-night? M. Guizot would like a brilliant display to
impress those ridiculous Arab chiefs."
"I am sorry, I am not well enough."
"A pity." M. du Boccage approached his wife and kissed her lightly on the
brow with cold, firm lips; she watched him cross the sanded courtyard and
disappear under the delicate, waving shadow of the lilacs. The sunshine made
his hair shine like pale metal under his jauntily adjusted top-hat.
Madame du Boccage sighed in a bewildered fashion; she was a woman who
would be found at a loss in every situation that life can offer.
Lucille Debelleyme, having resolved to remain in the Faubourg St. Honoré,
now seriously considered how to do so; she used all the mingled prudence and
audacity of a general planning a campaign and enjoyed the exercise of certain
qualities she possessed that, hitherto, had had no scope.
In a few days she had summed up the position of affairs as accurately as
her sources of information would permit.
What Mademoiselle Broc had said of the disorder in the household was true.
Everything was badly, wastefully run; the servants gossiped, idled and
divided themselves into cliques, there was an atmosphere of unrest; the
frequent lavish entertainments at which Royalty were received were
extravagant but neither well-run nor successful; the children, pretty and
charming in themselves, were over-indulged in one direction, neglected in
another and drawn into the intrigues of nurses and governesses.
Madame's chaplain, the Abbé Galle, was very frequently on the scene and
interfered too much in the household. Madame's reckless charities brought
hordes of beggars about the place, many of whom imposed shamelessly on her
Against all this put these facts; the Duke liked order for its own sake
and he was anxious not to waste a sou, because he was absorbed in the
restoration of Javiaux du Boccage which he had begun on a lavish scale. He
had come into a vast property and a magnificent title, but he had a mother, a
brother and three sisters to provide for, and to maintain his position and
revive the splendours of Javiaux du Boccage, built by the Maréchal de Villars
out of the spoils of war, his wife's huge fortune was necessary to him. He
was, unusually so for his rank, fond of his children, anxious for their good
and passionately desirous of a household orderly, peaceful, cheerful in which
they could nourish in perfect harmony; also he was Voltairean and liked
neither the Abbé Galle nor the paupers whom he brought in his train.
Madame du Boccage was generous, impulsive, romantic, sentimental,
tactless, uncontrolled; by the very strength of her affection for them she
upset her children. She could not be with them for five minutes without
introducing a distressing emotional tension or provoking a scene. She was
really in ill health and took a good deal of opium.
It was no wonder that she and her husband had their disagreements.
How far did these disagreements go?
The governess wished that she could put her finger on that.
But she was shut away from those apartments on the rez de chaussée
where Monsieur and Madame du Boccage adjusted their differences. It had been
a romantic love match, they had had nine children; not even scandal gave M.
du Boccage a mistress. No doubt, despite the unhappy friction from petty
matters that disordered their household this couple, young and charming, were
still secret, if intermittent, lovers.
"I shall have to be very careful," thought the new governess. "I expect
she has the last word in all disputes—the wife, the mother—and
the bulk of the money hers! Shall I attach myself to her? Champion her?
Become her confidante, help her torment him—the man so like Robert
Morrison? That would be the strongest position for me. She is a weak fool and
I could soon get a hold on her—oust the Abbé, the maid, the
paupers—make myself indispensable. Of course he is infinitely more
attractive, but to vex her in order to please him would be too dangerous. If
she resolved that I was to go he would not be able to resist."
It was the King's birthday, and Paris rejoiced in the warm
May weather. There was much to rejoice at indeed, fifteen years of a peaceful
monarchy under this citizen King, with his liberal ideas, who despised
military force, who ruled by affection alone—not King of France, but
King of the French.
In the morning, concerts were held under the high windows of the
Tuileries, aubades for the King; from the Invalides cannons echoed
round the new tomb of Napoleon I, saluting the heir of the House of Orleans
who had espoused the cause of the Sovereign people in 1789. Among the crowd
that pressed in the streets to enjoy the excitements of the fête du
roi were many who could recall the execution of Louis XVI, the First
Republic, the Directory, the Consulate, the Empire, the Restoration of the
Bourbons, the death of Louis XVIII, the flight of Charles X. All these
changes and tumults were now in the past; France rejoiced under the mild,
wise rule of Louis Philippe, all was prosperous, tolerant, secure.
The courtyard of the Tuileries was blocked by the carriages of the
aristocracy, the ministry hastening to offer their congratulations to His
Outside the gates a respectful crowd listened to the concert given by the
Garde Nationale; among the equipages was that of M. du Boccage, occupied by
his elder children and the new governess,
Mademoiselle Debelleyme enjoyed the spectacle and her own part in it,
sitting at ease in the handsome carriage with the magnificent escutcheon on
the gleaming panels and liveried servants on the box, in the company of these
pretty, eager children (already, by the exertion of all her charm, all her
art, she had won them), in the midst of the bustle of the animated crowd, in
front of the palace.
People noticed her; never before had she been so elegantly attired in such
elegant surroundings. The acquaintances of M. du Boccage who stopped to
salute the children glanced at her more than once, paying the tribute of
curiosity to her distinction, her composure, her charming appearance.
Under her aloft decorum Lucille Debelleyme was pulsing to a nameless
enthusiasm; Paris, the spring, the edge of great events! To be part of it,
even as a spectator, to be in touch with all this life and movement... she
thought of one man among the many crowding in the antechambers of the
King—the man who had, a few days ago, spoken to her so anxiously, so
intimately, who every morning gave her her instructions with a kindness, a
consideration, a courtesy which she had never received before, this grand
seigneur, this friend of royalty, this blond athlete with the allure of a
cavalier of Lancret—this enigma that she believed she would in a short
time be able to solve.
Amid loyal acclamations the Royal Family appeared on the balcony of the
palace. The King, that man of many adventures, the dashing young victor of
Valmy, the grave young school-teacher of Reicheneau, the aging exile, now
heavy with the painful bulk of disease, but still an imposing figure in the
white trousers, tight coat, high braided collar, stiff épaulettes and azure
riband—the Queen, spirited yet melancholy, still overwhelmed by the
tragedy of the sudden death of her eldest son, and that group of young
Princes and their wives who seemed to promise a flourishing succession to the
House of Orleans.
As the King bowed, his cocked, feathered hat in his hand, a raven rose and
fluttered above the busbies of the Garde Nationale, hesitated, then circled
round the Orleans flag in the midst of the soldiers.
Mademoiselle Debelleyme was conscious of a sudden tension in the crowd;
she knew that the bird was believed to foretell misfortune. The people
stopped talking, stopped moving, and watched the raven, which, an ugly shadow
in the brightness of the scene, rose and flew three times above the balcony
where the members of the House of Orleans were grouped.
The governess was not superstitious, but superstitions amused her; she
narrowly watched the people who seemed to draw a breath, then let it out in a
sigh—or a hiss? A sound of regret or of menace?
The band finished playing a melody from "La Barcarolle" the last success
of M. Auber from the Opera Comique, and someone, somewhere, raised a cry for
the hymn of the people, "La Marseillaise," the fearful song of 1793—a
slight hesitation and it was played. The governess of M. du Boccage watched
the people intently; were they as satisfied, as peaceful as they appeared?
Did they not secretly long to try again the fortune of a bloody
revolution—to see the heads of those who called themselves their
masters drop into the basket of the guillotine?
The delicate nostrils of the governess expanded; she recalled her
inherited hatred of the Bourbons which mingled with her rebellion as an
outcast against any settled state of society; gladly would she have seen that
family bowing from the balcony of the Tuileries sent the way of the relations
they had displaced.
The playing of the song of the people was short; there was a clamour for
repetition, but the soldiers ignored this and broke into the sweet strains of
an aria from Richard en Palestine—the King left the balcony but the
raven continued to hover over the flag of Orleans.
"Is it not all charming and agreeable, my darlings?" smiled the governess
to the two excited little girls by her side. "Now you may each have some
sugared almonds and we will drive along the river before going home."
Lucille Debelleyme had been a fortnight in the Faubourg St.
Honoré and had sized up all the conflicting characters with whom she had to
deal. She decided that it would be only possible for her to remain in this
very desirable post if she could gain the confidence of the Duchess, who
regarded her, she knew, with an increasing hostility.
This resolution cost her a sigh, a pang of regret. M. du Boccage was so
much more interesting than his wife, disliked and despised by the
governess—but it was obvious that the final decision would lie with the
mistress, not with the master of the establishment; better toady to the
Duchess than leave; better cringe to a woman who could defend, protect her,
than rely on a man who at the first murmur would be forced to abandon
Madame du Boccage returned late from a soiree given by the Duchesse
D'Orleans; she was sitting wearily in her chamber, idly regarding herself in
the mirror on her dressing-table while Matilde took off the superb parure of
diamonds that had been her father's wedding gift to Isabella Rosa
Frediani—(Fanny to her husband), when a discreet tap announced the
The Duchess was startled.
"Mademoiselle! Is anything the matter with the children?"
"Madame, they are all in perfect health and asleep in the charge of the
"Well, then, Mademoiselle?"
"I have had no opportunity of talking to you, Madame. I very much wish to
know if you are satisfied with my services?"
The governess crossed the rich carpet and stood respectfully before her
The noble brunette beauty of Madame du Boccage was finely set off by her
crimson robe de parade, her glittering jewels, the display of her smooth
shoulders and arms, the garland of purple roses that took the place of the
matron's cap on her shining black hair. All the light in the room was on her
dressing-table and all this was centred on the splendid Corsican; the slender
figure of the governess in her prune-coloured silk remained effaced in the
warm shadows beyond this circle of illumination.
The Duchess said, quietly:
"I should have told you if I had had cause for complaint,
"That—no! But satisfaction is another thing, is it not? I am very
desirous of pleasing you, Madame."
"You appear to be an excellent instructress."
"I would wish to be something more."
"The care of five children includes so much besides instructing them. Only
the mother can realise how much! If I might consult you often, Madame? Put
before you my little plans and suggestions? Interest you in the affairs, the
pleasures of the children?"
A slight spasm passed over the watchful face of the Duchess; her eyes were
dimmed by tears. Touché! thought the governess, but Madame du Boccage
"You see M. du Boccage every day, do you not? And take your instructions
from him, as was arranged? You understood from the first that my health was
feeble, my social duties pressing."
"Madame is too generous, so sympathetic; the Abbé Galle, the poor are so
full of her praises! Just a little of the time given to piety taken for the
children would make all the difference to my task—"
Matilde, arranging the big brilliant drops for throat and ears in the
velvet case, knocked over a satin box and glanced malevolently over it as she
picked it up at the governess, who thought instantly: "The maid knows
everything—but I shall never find it out from her—she hates me
and is loyal—but surely I can oust a peasant?"
"No doubt," sighed the Duchess putting a hand to her forehead as if it
ached, "your task is hard. I feared that you would find it too
"It is not. I have never been so happy anywhere. But I should like the
approval of Madame."
As the other woman did not reply the governess continued more boldly, yet
always with insinuating sweetness.
"I am in all at the service of Madame."
The Duchess raised soft, candid, troubled eyes to study the other woman;
the clear, cold glance of the governess said: "I know your household is
divided. I am willing to be your ally against your husband. Between us we can
circumvent him at every turn."
And the gaze of the Duchess replied: "I believe you to be sly and false. I
will not give you my confidence. And I do not intrigue with my
Slipping her broad sapphire bracelets from her fine wrists, Madame du
"I have had no reason to reprove you. Mademoiselle—you say you are
happy. Well, let us try how affairs work—a little longer? And now
forgive me, I am so sleepy."
The governess understood instantly that not only was her alliance refused
but that the Duchess did not intend to retain her services indefinitely. The
maid's face darkened with triumph which helped to inflame the burst of rage
and hate in the heart of Lucille Debelleyme as she withdrew respectfully,
apologising for her intrusion.
At the door her glance went round the extravagant room opulent with every
luxury, and rested on the magnificent bed raised on gilt steps, flounced with
embroidered satin, hung with curtains of Brussels lace that the flying
figures of gilt puttini attached to a massive baldaquin; she glanced at the
two sumptuous pillows side by side; what was the secret of this marriage?
"Good night, Mademoiselle," came the husky voice of the Duchess, hastening
her dismissal, reproving her hesitation.
This so goaded the exasperated mood of the governess that she had, like a
quick dart in her mind, a wild wicked thought... if that heavy baldaquin
could fall in the night, crushing the woman who slept beneath...
The governess moved slowly down the corridor, repulsed,
defeated, her alliance refused, before her the prospect of another departure,
another period of servitude in a place that was sure to be far less pleasant
Already she was at home in her elegant apartments, already she had
introduced order, serenity, discipline into her little world and secured the
grateful allegiance of the children; already amid the confusion of the
mismanaged household her department ran smoothly, without friction or
And must all this be given up because that other woman did not like her,
would not trust her?
Faint with rage Lucille Debelleyme leant against the wall of the
"She has everything, youth, beauty, wealth, rank, a charming husband,
delicious children—a powerful father, hosts of friends—I have
just myself, possess nothing, have no one to help me. Possess nothing? I have
also beauty, youth—perhaps more wit. Dare I match myself against
The next day the domestic storms that always muttered below
the horizon in the Hotel du Boccage broke into the open. There had been an
entertainment at which the Duc de Nemours had been present and everything had
gone awry; the service, the food, the music, the lights. The Duke had spoken
sharply to the Major Domo, he to the housekeeper, she to the cook, the house
had rung with recriminations. The Duchess, with reddened eyes, had shut
herself into her apartments; everyone shifted responsibility on to someone
else and blamed some invisible daemon for creating this devilish
Mademoiselle Lucille Debelleyme was a good gambler, she knew when to play
for high stakes. Twenty-four hours after this fracas, some time before her
usual daily consultation with the Duke was due, she knocked at the door of
his apartments, which, to the right of the entrance chamber, were separated
from those of the Duchess by a narrow corridor.
M. du Boccage himself opened to her, and seemed, she thought, relieved to
see her, as if he had expected some more unwelcome intruder.
He had risen from a light green bureau, charmingly painted with flowers.
The room was done up in the gayest manner of the Regency, and seemed, even
more than the other apartments of the hotel, an expression of his
personality, virile, passionate, but carefully masked by an affectation of
careless elegance that touched the appearance, but the appearance only, of
The governess, in spotless, severe muslin, stood in a bar of sunshine that
fell through the pale silk curtains and made an indiscreet gleam in her long
curls. What she was about to do was the result of desperation on her part and
she was mentally fumbling her way in a situation that she only half
understood, but her air was serene, melancholy and resolute.
"You are in some difficulty. Mademoiselle?" asked the Duke pleasantly but
with the apprehensive air of a man who has too many people coming to him with
difficulties. He stood by his desk; under his hand was a portfolio of white,
gilded parchment on which lay a letter evidently just taken from the
"I am in no difficulty whatever. Monsieur," said the governess. "I hope I
give satisfaction in my duties?"
"Your department is the only one in the house that is well run—"
She had hoped that he would say something like that; instantly she took
"That is the point I wished to raise. Madame du Boccage is overburdened
with duties—the poor, the church, her poor health, it is marvellous she
does what she does—I feel already for her a devotion, a
respect!—I would wish to help her—never have I had a mistress so
The Duke regarded her steadily from under his thick fair lashes, the smile
on his sensual mouth was expressionless, but the governess was
"Pray be seated. Mademoiselle, and tell me what you mean."
She gracefully sank into the light chair behind her, she had the delicious
sensation of being perfectly understood without the help of words.
"Would it be any assistance to Madame du Boccage if I was, without
troubling her at all, to undertake the management of the household?"
"You could do it. Mademoiselle?"
He regarded her thoughtfully; she still was not quite sure of him, not
quite free from a fear that he might deeply resent her effrontery, yet she
felt, somehow, secure.
She saw him look down at and flick over the letter on the desk. She sensed
that this letter was important to him and was very anxious to know what it
was; she rose as if in agitation, and approached the desk.
"If Monsieur thinks I have presumed—" she contrived to read the
first line of the letter and notice the feminine handwriting—"My dear
Camille, I implore you—"; he had then a mistress?
"No, Mademoiselle, you do not presume. I am, on the contrary, grateful for
He closed the portfolio and carelessly flung it into a drawer of his
bureau; the governess marked which drawer. Henri, the valet de
chambre, entered from an inner door to ask if his master was going to the
hunt that day? Mademoiselle noted, behind his shoulder, an elegant
bedchamber; M. du Boccage was not, then, so uxorious that he must always
sleep beneath the baldaquin supported by amorini, draped with lace curtains
where his wife took her repose.
While he spoke to his servant, the governess, whose eyes were never idle,
noticed an engraving of a portrait hanging near the window of a soldier in
armour, wearing a huge dust-blond peruke knotted with a black ribbon, who
bore an unmistakable likeness to M. du Boccage; the same firm, blunt
features, the same full, smiling, sensual mouth, beautifully formed, the same
sweet expression, in the eyes that look which Mademoiselle Lucille
interpreted as a profound duplicity, and, grasping a baton strewn with fleur
de lis, the same powerful hand, indicating a brutal, almost vulgar
The Duke noted the young woman's glance, and, as the servant left, he
"An ancestor of mine, Charles O'Brien, Vicomte de Clare—an Irish
"It is a fascinating personality, Monsieur."
"You think so? He had a bad reputation—for cruelty, I believe, but
in those days, bah!"
He broke off; she knew that he expressed himself ill on serious matters,
had few words and found it an effort to use more than the light, idle
sentences at which he was an adept, therefore she waited, patiently,
"Eh, well. Mademoiselle," he brought out at length, "you have perceived
the disorders in my household. I confess that they torment me, for I like a
peaceful life. You appear to have energy, discretion—a gift of
management—let us try what you can do—"
The governess cast down her eyes to hide her triumph. "Monsieur will
"Naturally—if I have given you authority, I shall support you."
In a fortnight it was done; by tact, by firmness, by the use
of her gift of authority that was often resented, never resisted, by sheer
talent for organisation and the experience that had come from long, ironic
observation of where other women went wrong, the governess had transformed
the establishment of M. du Boccage. Some servants had been dismissed, some
reformed, the place of Mademoiselle Broc had been taken by a stolid, effaced,
hard-working Swiss, Mademoiselle Heller; the Major Domo, who had taken ill to
the domination of the governess, had gone and in his place was an Italian,
excellently trained, keenly anxious to please the woman to whom he owed his
There was no more dust on the pelmets, no more faded flowers in the vases,
no longer did the sound of quarrels come from the kitchens; the accounts went
down, the entertainments were smoothly successful, the equipages, the lackeys
smarter than before; the whole establishment had that air of easy finish that
hitherto it had lacked.
M. du Boccage could lead, at ease, that life of voluptuous idleness, of
charming social amusement, of domestic felicity with his lovely children that
he so enjoyed.
And Madame du Boccage had ample leisure in which to administer her
charities, attend her Masses, confer with the Abbé Galle, nurse her
But the trouble in her dark eyes, the cloud on her broad brow did not
lessen; she was often shut for hours in her splendid apartments alone with
Matilde, her maid.
And when she showed herself among her now perfectly run household her
suffering appearance evoked the pity of her servants to whom she was no
longer of much importance, but merely an invalid who had relegated all her
duties to a dependant.
Mademoiselle Lucille was not wholly occupied in her labours;
now that she had surrounded herself with reliable underlings she had a great
deal of leisure. This was devoted to the children.
There were visits to the grandfather, the magnificent Maréchal Comte
Frediani del Marco, to the grandmother, the blind Dowager Madame du Boccage
who lived with her son, Comte Edouard, recently betrothed to the exquisite
Mademoiselle Schickler; to the pretty, blonde married aunts, all of whom had
made brilliant marriages when the Revolution of July brought the House of
Montlosier du Boccage a position of wealth and splendour.
And it was not difficult for a clever young woman to find constant
amusements for five lively children, the eldest of whom was only twelve, when
she had so many resources and unlimited money at her disposal. The little
Marquis, Philippe Joseph, was as delighted as his eldest sisters, Isabelle,
Cesarine, to visit General Tom Thumb again and again at the Theatre du
Vaudeville, or to drive in the Bois in the hopes of seeing him in his azure
carriage drawn by the six white ponies. Even the two younger children,
Gaston, Laure, enjoyed the fairy pantomime, La Biche au bois, at the
Porte St. Martin and they all looked forward to the opening of the
Hippodrome, which they were driven to see being built at the barrière de
L'Étoile, and delighted in the concerts, marionette shows and diversions
Mademoiselle Lucille never failed to find. There were brief visits to
Tortoni's, to the restaurant Royale, for an ice, a shop, in the company of
the dandies, and the society men and women; and Mademoiselle was always so
gay, kind, loving and charming that the happy children did not notice that
they were seeing scarcely anything of their mother.
M. Gavaudan Clery welcomed his granddaughter with grim
sarcasm to his small house at St. Cloud. He told her frankly that he was
surprised that such a fine lady as she had become should trouble to visit a
poor wretch like himself.
"When one has only a single relative in the world, one likes to keep an
eye on him," replied Lucille, coolly. "How do I know, mon vieux
bonhomme, that you have not a neat little fortune hidden away?"
She seated herself at the table and helped herself to a portion of his
meagre meal; this poverty struck her after the luxury of the Hotel du
"Besides," she added, "I must not make myself too much a slave—I
must insist on a holiday now and then—a whole day, I said, to visit
"You try to make yourself indispensable?"
"Naturally. Never have I been so well paid, so well treated—had so
"Take care you are not too clever," warned the old man sourly. "These
people are of the great world. It is very strange that they should have let a
nobody like you assume such a position."
"I am very careful. I work underground. I quarrel with no one. M. du
Boccage is pleased with the order that I have brought about."
"And Madame du Boccage?"
"She is devoted to the poor and the priests. And always ill. I see very
little of her."
"Is she happy with her husband?"
"I wish I knew," said Lucille sincerely. For all her art, she had not been
able to penetrate the secrets of the rez de chaussée where husband and
wife resided, or break down the loyalty of Matilde, the Norman maid, who was
the confidante of her mistress. "He always speaks of her with warm
respect—they have the appearance of the utmost felicity—but she
is a tiresome woman—"
"Is there another—a mistress?"
"I don't think so," replied Lucille, thoughtfully, remembering the letter
beginning—"My dear Camille"; she had not yet had an opportunity to see
if the Duke kept the drawer, into which he had thrown that letter, locked.
"At any rate, he is very discreet. So what does it matter?"
"I thought," sneered M. de Clery, "that you might be enamoured of him
"Bah, I am not that sort of fool! I play for respect, decorum. I make
myself useful. He could easily find a pretty woman for a mistress, he could
not so easily find a woman to do what I do for him. In this case virtue
"You play the game of an adventuress."
Lucille's clear eyes gave a formidable flash.
"And if I do? Good God! have I not been trained to be an adventuress? If
there is no place for me in society, must I not make one?"
"You fly too high," objected the old man. "Take care you do not lose your
"That I shall never do." She smiled coolly. "Tell me, Grandfather, what do
you know of these Montlosier Boccage?"
"Nothing that will help you much. I saw them married in '30. By the Bishop
of Beauvais it was, in the chapel of the Luxembourg—a fine sum of money
it must have cost! You never saw such a display! She was a beautiful
woman—- eyes, hair like jet, the figure of a goddess!"
"That has gone—she has had nine children."
"So much the worse for her. He looked like a girl—a stripling, pale
as a glass of milk, hesitating—bah!"
"He has changed." smiled Lucille.
"One understands. Poor devil, married at seventeen, by his old miser of a
father who nearly went mad with joy when the great heiress took a fancy to
him. Nine children, fifteen years of cooing in a dove's nest at thirty-two!
The fool, who can't have the spirit of a louse, must feel himself a little
"I believe he does—but we don't know how he employs his
"No doubt she does! A Corsican!"
"Jealous, you think?"
"What do you suppose? That is why I said—you had better be
"I have been. She is really very wealthy, is she not?"
"Two million now and eventually the Frediani fortune and the estate in
Corsica! Her old fox of a father! I remember him at Austerlitz. But he soon
changed over to the Bourbons. Now if I had done that, things might have been
different with me—but no, I must be loyal to the Emperor!"
"M. Frediani is a very imposing, handsome man, devoted to his
"Eh, maybe! I remember when he was ordered to quell the revolt in Poland
and sent the message—'All is quiet in Warsaw,' and so it was, for he
had massacred the lot of 'em!"
Lucille joined in her grandfather's laughter; for a moment the two
small-featured fine faces, one so wrinkled, one so smooth, had the same
expression of heartless amusement; but M. Clery soon returned to his ill
"And doesn't M. du Boccage want to know who you are?"
"He has not asked. I have an answer ready if he should."
Take care what lies you tell him, he'd find you out at once."
"I know. Well, you can't be any help to me, and I believe I can contrive
very well by myself."
The old soldier turned his dim, malicious glance on the neat shape, the
lovely face, the elegant curls of his granddaughter. She was spending every
sou of her salary on clothes and was finely, if simply, dressed; never before
had she had such an air of self-assurance, of modest, but serene
"A pity," he sneered, "that you were born the wrong side of the sheets!
You might have yourself been the mistress of a house in the Faubourg St.
He chuckled to see her irritation. She decided that she would not come to
see the wicked old rogue again as she restored her equanimity by gazing out
of the window at the noble beauty of the trees in the Park of St. Cloud.
But she felt tolerably satisfied when she returned to the Hotel du
Boccage; she felt that she had analysed and controlled to her own advantage
the world in which she had found herself; what more could cleverness do?
When Mademoiselle Debelleyme reached her charming little
apartment, she found the Duchess waiting for her in the spring twilight and
her sense of security was rudely shaken.
Madame du Boccage, who seemed very nervous, began to speak at once.
"Mademoiselle, I must regret—a sudden change of plan—M. du
Boccage and I have decided—the elder boy will have a tutor—go
perhaps to school—the girls—I will see to myself. We go to
Javiaux du Boccage soon—or perhaps to Locroi. I will pay your salary
for the year—I will give you—yet another excellent
"I am to leave, Madame?"
"If you please."
"If you please."
"May I ask why?"
"I have given you my reasons."
"They are scarcely sufficient, Madame," replied the governess, quietly,
"for a sudden dismissal. An insulting dismissal. My character is my sole
"I have said that I will give you an excellent testimonial."
"Even that will hardly cover my sudden departure from your house."
"It must." The Duchess rose; both her dignity and the emotion it cloaked
were formidable. "If you have no other place ready, no relatives in Paris,
you may lodge with the Santerres."
"May I know the cause of my offence? I have tried hard to please."
"Too hard. Mademoiselle!" murmured Madame du Boccage. "You are a good
instructress, a fine manager, but your personality, no doubt in itself
admirable, is not one I care to have placed in power—such full
power—over my children."
"Ah! But I have acted under the instructions of M. du Boccage."
"I know. You are blameless. He admits his mistake. He hopes you will
There was an unescapable finality about these words that made the
governess recoil against the wall and pull at her fingers in a display of
passion such as she seldom allowed herself.
"I have the right to know; Madame, the reason for this sudden
"Oh, Mademoiselle!" cried the Duchess in generous scorn, "you are no fool.
You know perfectly well that you have created an intolerable situation which
And she was gone.
Mademoiselle Debelleyme packed the neat fine clothes, the
pretty trifles into which she had put her last sou, filled with a rage that
made her feel physically sick.
Rage chiefly against the man; she had exerted herself to serve, to please
him, she had really toiled to carry out his wishes, he had professed himself
grateful and then he had abandoned her, with contemptible weakness, to the
stupid, senseless spite of his intolerable wife. His image fused with that of
Robert Morrison, that other man who had betrayed her, and such loathing shook
her that she had to lean on the edge of the trunk, her cold hands pressed to
her smarting eyes.
The servants, even those who owed their places to her, now avoided her;
all her power, so painfully acquired by hard work, tact and charm, had gone
in a few hours; she was merely a governess who had been dismissed.
Only the children remained loyal. Their wild distress was her one triumph,
but Madame du Boccage had taken them and Mademoiselle Heller to her own
apartments; the governess was left alone to make the preparations for her
The Duke, of course, was out of the track of the storm; he had gone to the
"The coward, the miserable, false coward," she sobbed, kneeling by the
trunk. Only pride, only a fear of collapsing before the spiteful grins of the
people who had flattered her yesterday, got her to her feet.
She then noticed, on the table where the Duchess had left it the evening
before, the envelope containing the testimonial Madame du Boccage had
The force of the governess' anguish was suddenly stayed; she recognised
the writing. It was that of the letter beginning—'My dear Camille' that
she had seen the Duke toss into his desk.
So! his wife wrote to him?
What terms were they on, then? The one line she had read had been the
beginning of a protest, a complaint—or a supplication—
"Ah, no wonder she is jealous of every woman who comes near him! They
quarrel; they are, perhaps, separated—but how come that he, the
miserable coward, allows her to dominate?" She wished, with an almost frantic
passion, that she could read the letters shut in the pretty green
desk—letters from wife to husband, living in the same house—
She caught herself up. The secrets of the Hotel du Boccage were no longer
of any consequence to her; she was leaving—with, as the Duchess had so
ironically remarked—"another excellent testimonial." All her talents,
her efforts, her charms, her intelligence had been, as usual, of no
"Who," she asked herself, furiously, "am I? Lucille Clery? Mary Showler?
Lucille Debelleyme? Nameless—Oh, God! Can I do nothing against this
It seemed that perhaps she might. A well-known step interrupted her, and
the Duke entered. Never had she seen him so animated.
"You are leaving, Mademoiselle? What is this?"
"You did not know. Monsieur? Madame dismissed me last night."
"I did not know."
She saw that he was as shaken by wrath as she was herself and a deep joy
displaced her rage; but she continued her packing.
"Monsieur, pardon me, I have so little time—-"
"You are not actually going?"
"What else? I have been dismissed."
"It is a mistake. Surely you did not think that I had sanctioned
She read in these words a nervous challenge, and instantly she lied:
"I believed you knew nothing about it. And I thought it best to leave
before you knew."
"Since I do not please Madame, I cannot stay."
"She is a sick woman. She does not know what she says—a Corsican,
impulsive! I ask you to stay." He looked pale as he added: "I am master
here—this is my establishment."
He paced about the pretty boudoir with the formidable grace of a panther
preparing for the spring. The governess had a glimpse of the man whom she had
always suspected him to be and she thrilled with pleasure because she was
instantly lifted up in her own esteem, she was no longer a helpless creature
contemptuously cast out of a dependant's place, but a woman who had caused
trouble, who had found a champion, who was, above all, being treated as an
equal by this great gentleman. She pressed her advantage.
"I could not stay. Even a poor servant (I have never been able to count
myself as more) has some self-respect—"
"Do not speak of yourself like that," he said, harshly. "A woman of your
education, gifts, presence—"
"I have never, Monsieur, found that these advantages have helped
me—" Sincerity gave a sharp edge to her words; a sleepless night,
strong emotion had exhausted her, she had lost much of her smooth, assured
calm. There was something in her then of the woman who had recoiled from the
drunken sleep of Robert Morrison, the desperate, hunted creature at bay and
ready to bite; but a wild hope filled her that in this powerful man she had
really found a protector.
He stood close to her and said:
"I beg you to remain, Mademoiselle. Think of this as a mistake—"
"There could be no mistake in what Madame said—"
"Leave that to me."
The large clear eyes of the governess, brilliant with a cold sparkle,
turned on him a steady look; how far would he stand by her, how far dare she
"I can only stay if madame asks me to do so—-"
"Very well—she will ask you. Already she repents her error."
"Forgive me if I can scarcely believe that, Monsieur. The hostility of
Madame has been too manifest—she has it in her power to make my
position odious—I am merely a dependant, Madame has
everything—forgive me, but the struggle is too unequal, I must retire
from it—" And she continued to put her water-colour sketches, her
sheets of music, her few books, into the trunk. She feared that she was
pushing him too far, but it was difficult for her to resist the exquisite
pleasure of hearing someone beg her for a favour, she who had always had to
do everything in response to commands; not since Robert Morrison's confident
courtship had she heard anyone ask her for anything.
"Where are you going, Mademoiselle?"
"I do not know. I have a relative with whom I can stay. No doubt I shall
find another place."
"Do you want to go?"
Using the truth with fine effect, she replied:
"No—I am very fond of the children, I like elegance,
luxury—but there is something more than these I value—your
consideration, your courtesy. You have treated me as an equal. Perhaps you
can scarcely realise what that means to me."
He appeared profoundly moved.
"I have only behaved as you deserve, Mademoiselle."
She looked at him directly, her hand on her bosom; her natural aptitude
for extravagant passion, sweeping drama, that she usually kept so carefully
controlled, pointed her words, her gesture.
"You have behaved as no one has behaved to me before, Monsieur. I am not
so spiritless, so crushed that I cannot appreciate that. I will not deny that
I had hoped to stay in your household—to show my gratitude—"
"Stay, Mademoiselle, stay—I really entreat you."
"I cannot. I have too much to gain. It would seem self-interest on my
part. And I fear that I have said too much, have appealed to your pity. It is
true that I am penniless, friendless, in a most unfortunate position, but I
never meant to let you know that. I was wrong to indulge in the happiness I
She spoke without conscious falsity; there was something in him that drew
the truth out of her, and in this case truth served her very well: she was
then certain that he wished her to stay. What she was not clear about was
whether he wished her to remain for her own sake, or merely to exert his
authority against his wife.
His hesitation ended in an impulsive action that swept away all doubt. He
took her cold, trembling hand in his massive grasp, and said:
"If you stay I will see that you are happy; can you trust my promise?"
"If you think it worth while to make me a promise—"
They were close together and he was still holding her hand. His air was
not that of a lover, but of a friend, which she valued more. She sensed that
here was not a brief, careless intrigue, but something strong, lasting: the
man admired her, relied on her, she had too, appealed to his chivalry, his
protective instinct, most subtly flattered a nature afraid of the charge of
effeminacy, bitterly fearful of domination.
"I cannot refuse," she said; she gently withdrew her hand, partly because
she wished to preserve among her weapons an irreproachable decorum, partly
because his contact disturbed her. He was the first man since Robert Morrison
who had physically attracted her—not that she meant to let that trouble
her—she had, she thought, all her emotions well in hand.
He sighed with relief.
"That is settled, then, and you will come with us to Javiaux du
"Wherever you wish, Monsieur, whatever you wish."
This was said with passionate sincerity; she felt the almost ferocious
gratitude of the pariah whose one good quality lies in a fanatic loyalty to a
"Continue as you are doing, all goes very well, the children are
happy—for the first time! Come to me with everything, you understand?
One must be patient, a little sly, when one seems to concede most one must be
most tenacious. You understand?"
She did—not so much his words as the look from behind the thick
light lashes; they were to be allies, to confer, to plot, to contrive
together. She had not been mistaken—they were akin in spirit and each,
from the first, had known it; he offered his hand, she took it—a
M. du Boccage left the governess to empty her trunk, to replace on easels,
in portfolios and on shelves her books, her dainty drawings of flowers, her
exquisitely copied music scores. She relaxed into great ease of spirit.
"He will now tell his wife she must ask me to stay! What a triumph! Never
have I been so important before! It is a most extraordinary thing that a man
in his position should support a governess of six weeks' acquaintance against
his wife—I must find out all his circumstances—I must—more
than ever—be very careful."
Madame du Boccage herself brought her children up to their
usual lessons; she appeared no more suffering, no more languid than usual.
Whatever had passed between her and her husband, she maintained a dignified,
almost a casual air, as she said:
"We have, after all, decided that you had better remain for the present,
Mademoiselle. Philippe is young for a tutor—if you would
"I am happy to be of some service to Madame." And the governess, secretly
so secure, permitted herself so clear a glance of cold triumph that the other
woman turned aside and hid her face as she caressed little Laure.
After this brief episode the household of the Faubourg St. Honoré swung
again into the smooth rhythm it had taken on since the ascendancy of
Mademoiselle Debelleyme; only perhaps the Duchess remained for even longer
periods in her apartments, went even more seldom into society and the Duke
stayed a little longer every evening with his children in the charming
boudoir of the governess, sometimes lingering even after the children had
gone to bed. They discovered so many tastes in common: music, painting,
letters, topical events interested them both; he was a fine dilettante in
many arts, he had a great sense of grandeur and was passionately interested
in the costly restoration of Javiaux du Boccage. Mademoiselle Debelleyme was
able to understand, to appreciate, to offer enthusiastic sympathy, an
intelligent admiration heightened by gratitude, by a hint of awe. Warmed by
the first genuine companionship of her life she genuinely sparkled; all the
woman she might have been under happier circumstances showed in these
interviews, but she never forgot her tact, her arts, her subordinate
position, the need of delicate, spirited flattery.
It was no wonder that M. du Boccage prolonged his visits to the nursery
floor of his great house.
She resolved that, at all costs, she must read the letters
in the green desk. As long as she did not know the exact relations between
husband and wife she was working in a half light. As long as Madame du
Boccage had any hold on the Duke she might, in any chance moment of nuptial
reconciliation, triumph, and the governess fall—if this fertile woman
produced, for instance, another child, what might she not exact?
"Best to know just where I stand, how far I may go, how long I may hope to
remain in this extraordinary, this enchanting, but, I fear, this precarious
Her eagerly awaited, anxiously sought opportunity arrived; M. and Madame
du Boccage were both out, the children driving with Mademoiselle Heller, she
herself had affected a slight indisposition and would read in her room. It
was the valet de chambre's day off; the other servants would not be
likely to spy on her and the hateful Matilde would be enclosed in the
apartments of her mistress. But as a last precaution the governess took a
book that the Duke had lent her; if caught, she would say that she had come
to change this first handsome volume describing the chateaux of France, for
the second that would doubtless be of an even more absorbing interest.
With the lightest possible of steps, and a watchful eye, the governess
crossed the entrance hall, the antechamber, the narrow corridor of the rez
de chaussée that separated the apartments of the Duke and the Duchess,
and entered, after an unanswered knock, the delightful little room in which
stood the green desk. Cautiously she opened the inner door, the bed-chamber
was empty; well, then, time to do it—if the drawer was not
It was not, nor was the gilt and white vellum portfolio that was bulging
with letters; Mademoiselle Debelleyme stood with another woman's secrets
completely at her mercy.
Adroit, quick, listening for a possible interruption, with her delicate
fingers flicking over page after page, the governess pried, with cold,
hostile curiosity, into the soul of Fanny du Boccage.
There were dozens of letters, they went over years, they covered pages,
they breathed passion, rage, jealousy, despair, all the torments of an
absorbing love, they were full of every manner of lament, reproach, promise,
supplication, and yet all showed a touching dignity, an inexhaustible
tenderness. They were the letters of a romantic, pure, noble woman profoundly
in love, profoundly tactless, blundering through innocence and excess of
feeling, frantically alternating, pleading for, and insisting on, a return of
an affection she had hopelessly lost.
The governess read with joy these terrible cries of a soul in torment; not
a throb of compassion softened her triumph as she rapidly put together the
sequence of events in the tragedy of Madame du Boccage.
Her husband, married as a boy, had tired, after twelve years and nine
children, of the pious sweetness, the clinging passion; the exacting jealousy
of his wife. She had tried to utterly hold, dominate, absorb him, to preserve
forever the first fervours of the honeymoon; incapable of coquetry, of
subterfuge, of any art, enervated by her continual child-bearing, of an
impulsive emotional nature, she had resorted to the fatal expedient of
reproaches, tears, scenes and the piteous stupidity of espionage And the
result had been a separation. For three years the unhappy woman had been the
widow of a living man, for three years he had passed the nights in his own
rooms, while she anguished, tormented, sleepless, had passed hers in writing
these frantic, melodramatic, despairing letters, some of which were half
incoherent in a delirium, of misery, desire and insomnia.
The governess winced for a second at some of the lines—drew back as
if she had been scorched.
"Mon Dieu, how fearful to love a man like that—and lose him."
Eagerly searching the more recent letters she found bitter references to
herself—"this light young person who is without religion"—"this
impertinent nobody to whom you have dared to give the charge of my
children"—"the scandal of the domination of this governess in my
establishment"—"ah, she may be capable, clever, an excellent teacher,
but she has neither principles, heart nor tenderness, she is too light to be
guided only by a young man in your position—it is a scandal and soon,
for all my care, will have the appearance of one"—
The governess dared linger no longer; she hurried the letters back, under
the false smiling gaze of M. de Clare, imposing in his panoply of war, and
fled quietly to her own room.
She was much agitated and it took her a little while to realise the
importance of her discovery.
The whole hopeless tone of the letters had shown her that the Duke not
only neglected his wife, but treated her with heartless indifference, refused
to accede to any of her supplications, endeavoured to separate her entirely
from her children, ignored her advances, her promises, her entreaties, and
only kept up an outward semblance of harmony because he could neither afford
a public scandal nor to forego the Frediani millions. The wretched woman,
beaten to her knees by his neglect, imploring in vain for a little kindness,
had, however, behind her, the Church, her powerful father, public opinion,
all his relatives and the Royal family, all of whom found her an ideal spouse
She was, as she had the incredible tactlessness to remind him again and
again, his wife before God and man, and had lost her health, her beauty, her
ease in giving him heirs to keep his honours flourishing.
"He must hate her," thought the governess. "What a fool she is—she
must have maddened him with scenes till he never goes near her except in
public, and then she bombards him with these letters! Does he read them? What
a life! It is indeed an inferno. And my part? He protects me, wishes me to
stay, he never makes love to me, but in some way I must be necessary to him.
Well, now I need no longer be afraid of her, she is powerless, poor
The governess had no pity whatever for the foolish woman who, through
sheer clumsiness, had made her life so intolerable a burden; she merely
despised such lunatic methods, scenes, tears, reproaches, espionage. Yes, she
or Matilde spied on all his movements, she was certain of that. Some of the
passionate phrases in the letters, some of the wild expressions of love with
which they all ended, hung in the mind of the governess—"All the
happiness that I have ever known has been through you"—"Ah, my beloved,
so many memories, so sweet, so dear, so many hopes, is it possible that all
is ended?"—"Always I shall love you, never can I forget the
past—how good you were to me. God bless you always. God help your poor
The man knows how to make love, evidently, thought the governess; his
value was immensely increased in her estimation by the other woman's hopeless
passion and his cold, clever resistance. She was filled with excitement.
The household in the Faubourg St. Honoré appeared to run as usual but to
the governess nothing would ever be the same; for at last she understood the
situation in which she found herself. With that cold, intellectual
understanding that is entirely devoid of sympathy, she could divine all the
feelings, foresee all the probable actions of Madame du Boccage, of her
relatives, her world, and at the same time absolutely comprehend the point of
view of M. du Boccage, whose behaviour, through his wife's loyalty still
completely secret, would, were it known, find, the governess was sure, no
possible supporter. Mademoiselle Debelleyme was well aware that if all the
circumstances of these continuous quarrels, the long separation there had
been between husband and wife, were made public, the woman would appear as a
saint and a martyr, the man as a heartless brute. But the governess was
passionately sincere in her loyal adherence to the Duke; not only was she
strongly moved in his favour by his persistent and uncommon kindness towards
herself, but she was deeply grateful to him for becoming her protector and
keeping her in a post which she would have lost without his help. From the
first she had hated the Duchess who had not disguised her candid dislike for
the new governess. All her temperament, all her ideas, her training were
against this romantic, sentimental, clumsy woman who was weak enough to be
jealous, stupid enough to spy, insane enough to make scenes and reproaches,
to pour out her most secret torments in page after page of melodramatic
lamentation: the woman who, in brief, had had everything and lost it all, as
the governess judged, entirely through her own fault. It was not likely that
Lucille Debelleyme with her hard, bitter experience, should feel any sympathy
for the wealthy aristocrat who had been pampered all her life, and had
created out of her own thoughts and weaknesses, so the governess believed,
the miseries in which she now writhed. Did not that poor fool, his wife, see
that he had had enough of enclosed, domestic bliss, that he required some
liberty, some independence, that the youth of seventeen, gentle, sweet and
easy going, whom she had married, was not the same as the vigorous developed
man of over thirty? He was now in the full flower of his prime, while she, as
with incredible tactlessness she noted again and again in her letters to him,
had already lost that dazzling southern beauty which had at first attracted
The governess looked at her own face in the pretty little mirror that hung
above the pianette in her boudoir. A few weeks of luxurious living and ease
of mind had improved to an astonishing degree the beauty that Lady Anfield
had not noticed and that had even escaped the searching glance of the French
Lucille Debelleyme was now a charming, a lovely woman; she took a great
deal of care with her appearance and no longer obscured any of her good
points with clumsy dressing. Her hair fell in fashionable curls, her dresses
were well cut to show off her slender, yet voluptuous figure. Though she was
careful not to depart in a single particular from the decorum enjoined by her
position, she had not the air, either in her dress or her appearance, of a
dependant; indeed, after she had read the unhappy letters of Madame du
Boccage she had rather the air of the mistress, both of the situation and the
She pursued her agreeable duties with an added zest, she put even more
enthusiasm into tending the children, in whose company she really delighted,
she was even more resolutely firm and yet gracious with her servants, she
received M. du Boccage with a yet franker delight in his company, and on the
rare occasions when she saw the languishing Duchess she greeted her with a
curtsy which had more than a hint of mockery, and it became one of her chief
pleasures to reconstruct in her mind the scenes which, no doubt, took place
almost daily in the rez de chaussée, of which she would be the main
cause, the Duchess clamouring for her dismissal, the Duke coldly refusing
But Lucille Debelleyme, bitterly schooled, by long misfortune, did not
lose her head; though she sometimes permitted herself the most enticing
dreams, her sternest enemy could have found no fault with her outward
The governess, however, for all her discretion and tact,
believed that now the foundations were so solid beneath her, she might risk
stretching out a hand for further advantages, and she ventured to introduce,
subtly and delicately, a personal note, an intimate air into the hitherto
impersonal conversations that she had with the Duke almost every evening when
he came to consult with her about the education of his children.
She directly asked him when the family were going to Javiaux du Boccage or
to Locroi in Normandy?
He seemed slightly confused at the question, but said "that he did not
The governess then put forward a definite point of view.
"It is a matter to which I should go to Madame but I dislike to trouble
her as she is so ill! I fear she has been suffering more greatly these last
few days. The heat is increasing in Paris. Ah well... what I have to say ...
Perhaps I have not sufficient of your confidence?"
He encouraged these pretty broken words with a deepening of his amiable
The governess continued smoothly:
"My salary is more than I have ever received before. It is certainly
sufficient for my services but, for the sake of the children, you are aware,
Monsieur, that I take them out a great deal, to concerts, to entertainments,
for drives? I have never" (her large clear eyes gave him a bold, flattering
look which was in contradiction to the quiet respect of her words) "been in
such an establishment as yours before. I am not in every way equipped. If I
am to remain much longer in Paris I shall require new dresses; for the
country also I shall require different clothes... "
"You may have," he interrupted pleasantly, negligently, "all you
"I shall not trespass on your easiness," she replied, "I was only about to
ask that I might have a few items from Mademoiselle Rose, Madame's
"Why should you wish to go there?" he remarked with a flight irritation.
"Choose your own establishment, Mademoiselle, and send the account to
"Impossible," she objected. "Monsieur must understand the delicacy of my
position. What I require is for Madame's service and must go on to her
"As you please," he agreed indifferently, and she wondered if he was
clever enough to understand the meaning behind her words, which was 'though
she could not accept the least present from him personally, he might give her
what he would under cover of his wife's name.'
She said no more on the subject, she showed him a charming little pastel
drawn by his eldest daughter but her brilliant smile was not all for pleasure
in the child's work; she was thinking of the lively scene Madame du Boccage
would make when she saw gowns, bonnets, gloves, parasols for the governess
added on to her account with Mademoiselle Rose, the most fashionable, the
most expensive dressmaker in Paris.
* * * * *
Mademoiselle Debelleyme found, as she expected to find, that
she had not a single ally among the magnificent train of relatives, friends
and acquaintances of the house of du Boccage, who came and went in the
splendid salons of the Faubourg St. Honoré; indeed, as her ascendancy
obviously increased, so did their hostility. Her sense of character assured
her that the Duchess, proud and sensitive, had not complained, but she was
perfectly well aware that her own position was extraordinary and must be
adversely commented upon, yet by the great sweetness of her manner, her
tactful avoidance of all possible cause of complaint she had warded off, she
thought, any open protest, though of course she could not be aware of what
was said privately to M. du Boccage?
But nothing appeared to ruffle his serenity, he was gay and amiable;
daily, under one excuse or another, he detached himself more and more from
his wife and led with zest and pleasure an indolent, amusing, fashionable
life, that of a courtier, a man of wealth and taste, but rather in
contradiction with these qualities, he showed an increasing interest in his
children; he was the most indulgent, the most charming of fathers.
Even Lucille Debelleyme sometimes wondered why the growing affection for
his children did not inspire him with some tenderness for their mother.
"But," thought the governess, "she's driven him hard, bit and spur together,
There was one only of the great personages who surrounded the maison du
Boccage that the governess had been able to ingratiate herself with and that
was the old blind Dowager Duchess, widow of the late Duke Felix.
Her eldest son was not her first child and the Duchess, nearly seventy and
long since completely blind with cataract, lived, in that modest fashion
imposed on her by a lifetime spent with a miser husband, in an apartment in
the Faubourg St. Germain. Mademoiselle Debelleyme often took the children to
visit their grandmother and had contrived to give the impression of a weak,
timid, depressed creature who was, for the first time, enjoying a little
liberty, a few pleasures.
Old Madame du Boccage adored her son and Mademoiselle Debelleyme mingled a
few discreet praises of the Duke with her continuous stream of gratitude for
the benefits conferred on her by her residence in the sumptuous establishment
of the Faubourg St. Honoré.
The old lady was moved, was won, for the governess was careful not to say
a single word against the Duchess but praised her continually for her piety,
her charity, and lamented her increasing ill health.
It rather amused Mademoiselle Debelleyme to dress herself in some fine
creation from the clever hands of Mademoiselle Rose, to make herself look as
beautiful, as dignified as possible, then to conduct the children to their
grandmother and, seating herself on a stool before the old lady's hooded
chair, pose as a poor plain creature, who could expect nothing in this life
but must look for her reward in heaven.
She could keep it up for half an hour very well and the old lady was
touched by the tales of this young person who had been helped through many
trials by the aid of religion. Knowing that she was in complete confidence
with her son and likely to repeat anything of interest to him, Lucille
Debelleyme thought it well to tell Madame du Boccage the story of Robert
Morrison, carefully coloured, of course, to suit her audience. The chance was
given her by the Dowager asking her once:
"How it was that she had not married a good fellow in her own rank of
life, who would have relieved her from the state of dependency?"
In a low voice the governess replied: "That she had had several offers but
none of them from men whose person she could admire, whose character she
"Have you never, then, my poor child, been in love?"
"Once," sighed the governess, "and it was nearly my undoing. Oh, Madame, I
was so young at the time, I had no mother to advise me. I was an instructress
in Bath, I worked too hard, my superiors were harsh, I have always been
"They tell me you are very pretty," interrupted Madame du Boccage. "my son
always speaks of you as most charming."
Forgetting for a moment that she was with a blind person, Mademoiselle
Debelleyme lowered her eyes to hide her fierce pleasure, but her voice was
unchanged as she continued:
"Ah, that, Madame, is mere polite condescension on the part of Monsieur du
Boccage! I have few charms but I had indeed then the bloom of youth and
attracted the attention of a young man who protested that he felt for me an
honourable affection. He was in a good position and I must confess, not only
did he win my heart, but I was attracted by the thought of leaving an odious
She stopped as if overcome with the bitterness of her recollection,
perhaps, indeed, she was so. She could not think of Robert Morrison with
equanimity even now, and the kind old lady patted her hand, where it rested
on the arm of the hooded chair. She asked with sympathy:
"And what went wrong, my dear? Why did not he marry you, I am sure you
would be a good wife for any man."
"He did not think so, Madame. I discovered, thank God in time, that his
intentions were not honourable. He wanted me but did not wish to marry me. He
promised me, Madame, independence, riches, an apartment in Paris, a carriage,
my own maid, all the lures usually offered to unfortunate creatures like
"And of course you refused?" commented the old Duchess tenderly. "You had
the courage, my dear? It must have been difficult, especially if you liked
Lucille Debelleyme sighed:
"I more than liked him, but I hope you know me well enough, Madame, to
believe that I did refuse him! It was a shock from which I have even now
The Dowager Madame du Boccage deeply sympathised with this pathetic
"I know," she declared, "something of the perils, the vicissitudes to
which young ladies in the forlorn position of yourself are exposed! But you
will have no trials like that in this establishment," she said, "my
daughter-in-law does not encourage rakes or libertines. Hers is the warmest,
the kindest of hearts and if you are in any trouble go to her at once. I hope
after all, my dear, that you will find a good husband. You are so fond of
children and so wonderful with them that it would be a pity if you were not
to have any of your own."
Mademoiselle Debelleyme now took up a subject which she had already
insinuated several times with the Dowager Madame du Boccage. "She wished
above all to go to the Opera before the season was over and the children were
too young and Madame du Boccage never went... it was of course not to be
thought of for her to join a party without her mistress though she had had
several offers. She was a passionate lover of music, she wanted to hear I
Puritani which was to be given next Thursday... Mademoiselle Schickler, the
betrothed of Comte Edouard, had been so kind as to make it possible for her
to go with these two charming young people, to sit behind the heiress in the
box as attendant shadow, completely effaced if only she might hear the
The Dowager Madame du Boccage was accompanying her son herself, she could
not see any reason in the world why the obliging, the simple young governess
should not be one of the party; she did not know that the refused offers to
which Lucille Debelleyme referred had come from the Duke himself... the
governess had rejected such reckless generosity with smiling, cold dignity.
She did not wish to compromise herself by such a public flaunting of her
supremacy in the household of the Faubourg St. Honoré, but she did want to go
to the Opera, she did want to show herself beautifully turned out to all her
enemies. She thought: "How lucky it is that the old Dowager is blind, if she
had her sight she would never give her consent."
The Comte Edouard was a little surprised and Mademoiselle Schickler a
little doubtful when the suggestion was made to take the new governess to the
Opera, but old Madame du Boccage insisted that it would be the harshest
unkindness to refuse a timid request put forward by a poor young person who
had had so few pleasures in her life, who would sit quietly at the back of
the box, and be no trouble to anyone. "If Fanny was not in such continual ill
health she would take her herself," declared the kind old woman, "and I am
very pleased to be able to offer such an estimable young woman this little
Count Edouard and his betrothed exchanged glances. There had not yet
exactly been any gossip or scandal attached to Mademoiselle Debelleyme but
everyone thought there very soon might be. If Madame du Boccage had not
appeared so perfectly satisfied there would surely have been already. The
position was certainly a curious one but as everything appeared so smiling
and peaceful in the establishment in the Faubourg St. Honoré there was no
cause for any comment, and why trouble the old lady's simple conception of a
homely young creature pleading for a little diversion?
Step by step the governess had won; she felt like a general
who takes the enemy's outposts in a slow, steady progress. She was going to
the Opera, going to sit in the Du Boccage box in company with the Dowager, in
full decorum, but also in full splendour, everyone would have to look at her,
and no one would be able to say anything against her.
Fanny du Boccage would rage, no doubt, be wounded to the quick, but she
would be powerless, and the Duke, the man who had befriended her, the man who
seemed to admire and need her, though he never said so, would see her as she
She had the advantage of the Duchess' account with Mademoiselle Rose. She
was secure of her gown, there remained only her jewels. She had nothing
whatever suitable, only a few garnets, a cameo, a tortoiseshell chain, and
while she appeared to absorb herself in her lessons and her games with the
children she was thinking deeply, wondering by what subtle or daring move she
could secure a parure to wear on Thursday. She decided to try her one friend;
the Duke knew she was going to accompany his mother to the Opera, he said
that he himself might go, he wished to hear I Puritani again. It was a pity
that Madame, his wife, was too unwell to attend this gala performance. The
doctors had said she must forego all social duties for the present until she
had cured her insomnia.
M. du Boccage asked the governess, with a Frenchman's delicate
consideration in such matters, if she had a suitable gown for this uncommon
"Through Monsieur's kindness I have a robe de style from Mademoiselle Rose
but I have no jewels. I hope I shall not look ridiculous," smiled the
governess. "It was perhaps a little presumptuous of me to wish to go. My love
for music has led me into a false position."
He gave her a look which shook her superb self-assurance a little.
"You shall have the jewels, there will be no difficulty about that."
"I could not accept," she began with a proud reserve.
"I offer you nothing," he interrupted, "you may take a parure for the one
evening," and with that smiling negligence she so admired in him, he added:
"It will be no obligation to you and a pleasure to me. I hope you will enjoy
the music, Mademoiselle."
On the Wednesday afternoon Henri, the Duke's valet de chambre,
delivered a large case at the apartments of the governess. She opened it
>and discovered, set out on white velvet, a superb set of emeralds. Her
heart beat with an excitement which made it difficult for her to maintain a
very necessary calm. Ambition, that she had hitherto discarded as foolish and
dangerous, again rose in her heart. She began to believe that she had
underestimated her own attraction, her own power, had been too cautious, too
slow; she resolved in that moment to move more boldly, to strike more
deliberately for her own advantage.
The splendid heavy antique coach of the Dowager Duchess du
Boccage arrived at the Faubourg St. Honoré for the governess, who waited
alone in the antechamber. The Duke, if he came at all, would follow later;
the Duchess had not been visible all day. Lucille Debelleyme knew that the
whole atmosphere of the house was filled with apprehension, tension,
excitement, but she was herself suave, smooth and smiling.
The mantle that enveloped her was dark, decorous, a dull violet velvet, a
loose hood of fine black lace covered her long fair curls; without any
artificial aid her complexion was dazzling, her features were exquisite in
their exact, firm outline.
She saw the Comte Edouard look at her uneasily, and Mademoiselle
Schickler, the spoilt heiress, with a little grimace of disdain. The
governess was not abashed, tonight she was neither to be patronised nor
A well-known step caused her to turn her head; M. du Boccage came from the
salon de reception. Lucille Debelleyme, a little frightened, cast off her
dull-coloured cloak. It was impossible to consider the woman revealed as a
governess, as a dependant, as anything but a beautiful woman. Lucille
Debelleyme exactly suited the mode and she had further the exquisite art of
making the mode exactly suit her, and set off her fragile charm; woman and
dress appeared one, the smooth pale shoulders were barely distinguishable
from the smooth pale satin of the bodice; her long hair might have been woven
of the same material as the filmy lace shawl that drooped over her arms. All
this delicate beauty was emphasised by the emeralds, which like drops of
green fire glittered round her throat and small wrists.
The young Comte gave his brother a startled, reproachful glance;
Mademoiselle Schickler flushed with irritation. This sudden beauty on the
part of a servant seemed to her a piece of effrontery that she did not know
how to deal with; she fidgeted with her gloves. The old blind woman stood
benevolent, smiling, leaning on the arm of her younger son, while the elder
M. du Boccage remained inside the folding doors, his hat in his hand, looking
at the governess with his expressionless smile on his sensual lips and his
dark eyes almost completely veiled by the thick, fair lashes.
It was Lucille Debelleyme's moment, and she knew how best to turn it into
one of complete triumph. With a graceful movement she swept over the black
and white tiles to Madame du Boccage, dropped a low curtsy and, kissing the
old lady's hand, murmured in a voice that seemed to tremble with emotion:
"How can I thank you, dear Madame, for such an evening of undeserved
pleasure!" There was no obvious mock modesty about this action, which
appeared simple, dignified, touching.
The coldness of the Comte Edouard and his betrothed increased but the old
lady placed her hand on the smooth ringlets of the governess and murmured in
a gratified tone:
"I am very glad, my poor child, to be able to give you this little
As Mademoiselle Debelleyme again fastened her cloak over her illicit
beauty to which she knew everyone who saw her tonight would feel she had no
right, she gave a sly glance at her one friend; his subtle smile increased,
she thought his lips formed the word "brava."
"I congratulate you. Mademoiselle," remarked the Comte Edouard, drily, "on
your magnificent parure of emeralds."
"Thank you, Monsieur," replied the governess with humility, "they are
indeed beautiful and it gives me great enjoyment to wear them."
Coming forward, swinging his gloves, the Duke said to his brother with the
"I lent them to Mademoiselle for to-night. I bought them two years ago in
London. Fanny did not like them—I thought to have them reset for
her—I put them aside and forgot them. Tonight they have served some
Mademoiselle Schickler, who was a great heiress and thought in terms of
money, permitted herself the vulgarity of saying:
"They must be worth a great deal."
The elder M. du Boccage replied with the lightest, coldest courtesy:
"They are certainly worth something now—when Mademoiselle Debelleyme
wears them, one discerns in them an unexpected beauty."
The Opera was all that Mademoiselle Debelleyme had dreamed it might be.
Amid that brilliant crowd she felt the triumph of a beautiful woman who feels
she is in her proper surrounding. Her will was strong enough to enable her to
forget she was there on sufferance, an intruder, an outsider, that never
again might she taste such a moment. She enjoyed herself, therefore, without
any thought of the morrow.
She, naturally (but without servility) took her place at the back of the
loge, with the two men of the party, but it was also natural that the old
Duchess, who had procured for her this rare entertainment, should offer her a
seat in front. This was not refused and Lucille Debelleyme sat beside the
rich, sulky heiress, Marie Schickler, in one of the finest boxes of the
Opera, and had the intense gratification of knowing that she had entirely
eclipsed the mediocre dark charms of her companion, who formed indeed a
perfect foil to her radiant fairness. She was stared at immoderately,
lorgnettes and glasses were perpetually turned in her direction. It seemed to
her that she could feel against her ears the murmur of curiosity, of
hostility, which was passing from lip to lip as she was noted, named and
commented upon. She enjoyed this, it was amusing to provoke a scandal and to
know that she was impregnable both in her real virtue and in her appearance
of virtue. Who could say anything while the venerated blind Dowager sat
beside her and spoke to her so kindly, while that spotless virgin,
Mademoiselle Schickler, with however ill a will, was forced to endure her
The governess took pleasure in the knowledge that all the malicious
gossips were really wrong—she was as virtuous, as pure as she appeared
to be. Not a single word to which the most rigid prude could object had ever
passed between her and M. du Boccage.
She smiled to herself as she reflected how bewildered many of those who
stared at her with such inquisitiveness must be, Their first impulse would of
course be to proclaim her as the mistress of her employer but at the same
time they must be rather confused that he allowed her to sit beside his
mother, still kept her for the instructing of his young children. She felt
her position inviolate, far stronger than if she was really involved in a
vulgar and therefore brief intrigue.
If all these people only knew how intensely cold she was, how she had
learnt her lesson; if they could be but aware of that episode with Robert
Morrison which had told her to be so ironically careful in all her dealings
with men. Yet there was a certain sting in her transitory triumph also; she
had once dreamed it differently. She was not sitting there as the Honourable
Mrs. Morrison, wife of a wealthy English aristocrat, possibly (as she had
once imagined) an English duchess, moving elegantly in the highest circles of
Paris, mingling in politics, intriguing with men of affairs; nor was she
there as a successful courtesan with her following of lovers, her maids and
her apartment and her carriage, with all the extreme luxuries of her
profession, which she had once, for a few hours only, thought the infatuated
Englishman might give her... No, she was there, after all, as a dependant in
a false position. Neither wife nor mistress, but a servant dressed up for a
Her behaviour was perfect, she addressed herself exclusively to the
Dowager Madame du Boccage, ignoring the genteel rudeness of Mademoiselle
Schickler and the brusque courtesy of the Comte Edouard. M. Le Due du Boccage
also behaved admirably, covering all possible embarrassment with his correct
elegance that the fashion of the moment called "English coldness" and was
considered so admirable.
He stood next to the governess and kept his attention on the stage; in the
persistent dazzle of the gas globes she could, whenever she chose to look up,
see his face clearly. He smiled in unmoved idle good-humour, amiable,
expressionless; his hand lay on the red velvet edge of the box close to her
still fingers holding the programme.
She dared not look up at him for long; but a downcast, demure pose suited
well with a scrutiny of his hand, the useless strength of which was so in
contrast to his delicate linen, the velvet cuff, the dark-blue sparkle of the
Although they did not touch each other, even by the tips of their fingers,
nor look at each other at all, the governess was conscious of a current of
violent, exciting, powerful feeling passing between them.
So strong was this, that, despite her exquisite self-control, she was
shaken by a bitter surge of rebellion at the thought of the| insurmountable
barriers between herself and this man.
The emotions of this curious evening were not over at the
fall of the curtain, nor with the return of Lucille Debelleyme to the
Faubourg St. Honoré, nor with her grateful and charming farewells of the
Dowager Madame du Boccage, with her timid thanks to M. Du Boccage and her
modest retiring to her apartment, to take off the borrowed emeralds and put
them in their case.
It was late and all the household (she had believed) was asleep; but the
Duchess, always restless, tortured by jealousy and insomnia, had waited for
her return. The unhappy woman, in a storm of feeling, brusquely entered the
pretty apartment of the governess; her quilted chamber-gown was untidily
gathered round her full uncorseted figure, her eyelids were wrinkled and
stained either from tears or lack of sleep, and her hair fell in a tangle on
her shoulders as if she had continually pushed impatient fingers through it
in a desperate gesture to relieve an aching head.
Lucille Debelleyme immediately understood and mastered the situation; she
stood by her bed, illuminated by the soft light of a lamp with an opal globe,
and in her pale satin gown, herself colourless from excitement and emotion,
appeared unearthly as a shadow.
"Ah, Madame, you are ill! if I can do something for you! I am sorry I am
so late, I had no idea how the time went—"
The Duchess, with trembling dignity, cut short these false protestations,
the value of which she knew perfectly well.
"Where have you been. Mademoiselle, in that attire? And what are those
jewels you have in your hand? I am informed that you have been to the Opera,
wearing emeralds that my husband gave you."
"I thought they came from you," smiled the governess, opening wide her
brilliant eyes. "Were they not some cast-off jewels of your own, Madame, that
you did not care to wear until they were reset? It was great kindness in the
Dowager Madame du Boccage to offer me one of the seats in her box to-night,
when I was to hear for the first time, and I daresay for the last time, a
performance at the Opera. I believed that you allowed this kindness. Am I
The Duchess sat down heavily, with the weary sigh of a woman overwhelmed
"Do not seek to deceive and bewilder me, you know that what you have done
is outrageous, and you must also know that I was not aware of it."
Erect, slim, resolute, holding before her like a shield the case of
jewels, the governess replied with coldness:
"You must speak to M. du Boccage, Madame, it was he who gave me to
understand that I had your permission."
Folding her hands over her disordered garments the other woman
"You have no self-respect, you have no idea of decorum or dignity. How is
it possible for me to entrust my children to you?"
"In everything, Madame, I obey the orders of M. du Boccage."
"Do not keep repeating that name, please. You must be well aware—"
but the forsaken wife, distraught as she was, caught herself up; the
interview was approaching a dangerous point where she would not be able to
handle it at all. Rising, with her air of frank dignity, she added: "It is
not a matter for discussion, Mademoiselle. It is a matter for a reprimand. I
cannot believe you were under a misconception to-night. Shrewd as you are it
must have been clear to you that your action was—impossible."
Afraid of saying too much she left the room with an agitated movement,
allowing the door to fall heavily to behind her; the governess sprang after
her, caught the handle even as the latch slipped into place, and went out
into the corridor so swiftly that they were suddenly face to face.
"Forgive me, Madame, I cannot be left like this, the position is
"To me, also," replied the Duchess recoiling, and making a forbidding
gesture with her shaking hand as if she waved some venomous creature aside.
"Believe me. Mademoiselle, to me, also."
She passed down the passage to the rez de chaussée and began
heavily to descend the ornate stairs with the scrolled, gilt bannister.
"I have been spied on," thought Lucille Debelleyme. "Matilde, no doubt.
Everything in this house is watched and noted. I had better do a little of
The dim night-lamps set on the painted walls illuminated the expanse of
the shadowed stairway, and there the governess lingered in the obscurity
watching the slow descent of Madame du Boccage. It was not perhaps prudent to
spy on her mistress, but she had heard a familiar step in the hall below and
longed to hear at least a few words between husband and wife; her painful
curiosity was eased. As soon as the Duke saw the heavy figure descending so
laboriously to the rez de chaussée he demanded imperiously:
"Well, Madame, where have you been at this time of night? Why are you not
in your own apartment?"
The answer came in a voice made harsh by anguish:
"How is it possible you found the courage to do what you did
to-night?—this young person... "
He broke in, his tone usually so soft and gentle, was rough.
"These incriminations are useless, dare to say she is my mistress!"
"I do not say so, Camille, and I do not think so in the full force of the
word. You would not so affront your children; besides, I know you have other
diversions, it is not she who fills your life, but she has the air of doing
so, it is of that I complain! She takes my place, she tries to dominate in
With intense bitterness he interrupted:
"You to talk of domination!" and he flung from her; his wife, half
moaning, followed him, the doors of the antechamber that led to their
apartments closed on them, the governess heard no more. She hovered a moment
in the silence, then went lightly to her pleasant room, her comfortable
She was excited, exhausted; the drama in which she had so profitably
involved herself became every day more interesting.
As she lay, warm and drowsy in her bed, it did occur to
Lucille Debelleyme: "What would a good woman do under my circumstances? Is
there such a thing as a good woman?" came the quick reflection. She would not
leave the Faubourg St. Honoré. She would not say to herself: "I cannot be the
cause of this terrible dissension between husband and wife, I cannot be a
further instrument of torment to a woman already half mad with unhappiness, I
cannot steal these children from their mother, this husband from his wife, I
cannot remain here making my pleasure and my profit out of the miseries of
She wondered, as she lay there, whether there existed any woman who would
She supposed so, there must be these ideal beings somewhere, women who
were not absorbed in their own profit, who believed in God; women who,
thought Lucille Debelleyme with a sneer, were afraid of God, who would argue:
"This is wrong, I am wicked; I am, perhaps, condoning a crime, nothing but
evil can come out of this situation and for my share in it the Father will
surely punish me."
Lucille Debelleyme had no such fear, she did not believe in God, she
thought she had her own human destiny well in hand. She felt no pity for the
woman whose place she was gradually, and with such cleverness usurping.
"I have had nothing out of life, nothing at all, my duty to myself is to
get all I can. I will not yield, as long as this man supports me I will get
the last drop of pleasure, of power, of profit out of this extraordinary good
She fell smilingly asleep, the music of the Opera in her ears, the little
lights of the Opera before her eyes, and mingled with them hundreds of
curious, hostile but powerless glances, whose impudent malice she had so much
enjoyed; while through all her dreams darted the cold rays of the only jewels
she had ever worn, the icy sparkle of the emeralds given her by M. du
But it appeared that the governess had been a little too
self-confident in her triumph at the Opera; the next day when the Duke
inspected his children's lessons he informed her casually but definitely that
he had changed his plans, he would go to Javiaux du Boccage to supervise the
restorations there and she would go with the Duchess and the children to
Locroi in Normandy.
As he unfolded his scheme to the governess she understood that they had
gone too far, that it was necessary to give way, to concede all along the
line. Probably the outraged wife had spoken of a separation, of appealing to
her father, even to the Court, and her husband had found it necessary to
dissimulate, to placate her, even perhaps to pretend a reconciliation.
"Madame wishes to undertake the education of the children herself, it is
perhaps her right, I will not disguise that she has taken very hardly the
experiment I made in handing over so much authority to you, though it was to
spare her ill health, her excitable temperament. Well, now let us try another
way, you will go to Locroi, she will have full charge, you will stand aside,
work under her, do as she bids you, and when I return from Javiaux du Boccage
I will judge the result."
As usual he had the air of saying what he did not mean, as usual the
governess looked to his smiling glance for his true intentions.
"It is an excellent idea," she agreed amiably. "Madame is obviously
suffering; it would be well to avoid all that could give her nervous
excitement. In the peace of the country no doubt she will recover her
equanimity. I will resign everything to her hands."
"You help me immensely, Mademoiselle. Perhaps you will wait on Madame and
unfold to her this plan yourself?"
She agreed at once and in the same breath thanked him for her
entertainment of the night before and handed him back the case of emeralds.
She knew that the Duchess was quite incapable of conducting the children's
education, that the experiment was bound to end in disaster, that the Duke
intended that it should do so. What did she care as long as she was allowed
to remain in her place? She was perfectly ready to take even an apologetic
attitude towards her mistress; what did it matter? The wretched woman was, in
advance, defeated on all points.
She sought out Madame du Boccage, endured with a smile the icy insolence
of Matilde, her worst enemy in a household where all were hostile to her, who
spied on her and hated her bitterly. What did the governess care? M. du
Boccage was playing a subtle game which she understood and would assist
without the need of instructions.
She was admitted into the presence of the Duchess, whose haggard
appearance showed the miserable night she had passed; the governess did not
hesitate to apologise for her behaviour of the night before.
"Madame would have the generosity to believe that it was entirely a
mistake. Old Madame du Boccage was kind, I should not have accepted but I was
tempted—Ah, Madame, if you knew how little I have ever enjoyed you
would realise how difficult I found it to refuse, how I perhaps lost my head;
now I see that I was wrong, I have come to ask your pardon."
The Duchess flushed; this made her own behaviour of the night before,
already in her own generous judgment contemptible, appear detestable.
"Say no more, Mademoiselle. All is over, think no more about it. I hope,
if I can a little regain my health, to go to the Opera myself one night and I
can then offer you a seat in my box."
The governess curtsied in silent gratitude.
"But that, after all," sighed Madame du Boccage, "is a mere detail, a
matter of nervous irritation. I have more than that to complain of.
Mademoiselle," and in a voice harsh with suppressed sobs she stammered: "I
have to complain of the fact that you take my children away from me and I am
never allowed to see them, that you are in their company day and night." She
could no longer command her words; the governess coolly took up the broken
"Why do you suppose that I have performed any such project! I was afraid
that for the moment your health does not permit you to undertake the heavy
task of educating all these little ones—Monsieur le Duc has always said
so, so he says to the children, that and nothing else. For a little while I
tried to take your place, I fear with poor success. Now if you feel equal to
having your family around you there is nothing for me but to efface myself.
Monsieur told me to do so even now."
"Did he?" asked the unhappy mother with a gleam of ingenuous hope in her
"He did, indeed, Madame; he said we were all to go to Locroi while he goes
to Javiaux du Boccage, and that I was to leave you in full control. Did I
not," added the governess with a smile, "from the first, Madame, ask you to
interfere more, to show a deeper interest in our little world above the
rez de chaussée?"
The Duchess hesitated; she was plainly baffled as to what sincerity there
might be in these declarations, as she had been baffled as to the degree of
sincerity in the protestations made to her by her husband, brought about, she
feared, solely by the growing scandal in Paris, by some remarks dropped by
her father, by some comments made by members of the royal family, by fear of
a legal separation, of losing the children, of losing her money, by his dread
of a scandal... which would mean that he would have to give up all that made
life agreeable to him.
Fanny du Boccage sighed; only one thing would have pleased her, would
really have eased her implacable anguish, and that would have been the
dismissal of Lucille Debelleyme. But this was impossible for her to obtain as
she was bitterly aware, so she accepted what she could get in the way of
concession, and in her heart trembled the hope that all her prayers to God,
all her supplications to the man who had once been her lover and was still
her husband, might at last have been answered, and that there might be some
sincerity in this sudden offer of reconciliation. She accepted therefore with
dignity, with ingenuous candour, the project of these peaceful holidays to be
spent in Locroi.
It was a wonderful summer. Day after day of unclouded
sunshine sent a haze of gold over the lovely Norman meadows, and Madame du
Boccage with her little family and their governess installed themselves in
the chateau of Locroi. They did not, however, inhabit the recently restored
Gothic building in the midst of a large wooded park, but used a small
pleasure house in Italian style, built in the elegant taste of the
mid-eighteenth century, near a vast, magnificent orangery.
This charming house of pale rose-coloured bricks and amber-hued marble,
with Corinthian columns and balustrades wreathed by clematis vines and
convolvulus, stood on the banks of a stream which hurried beneath the
graceful tresses of golden willows. This was Fanny du Boccage's own property,
one of her marriage gifts to her husband; she returned to it with the same
pleasure that a child might return home.
As soon as she was among her own people, the peasantry who adored her, the
poor who came in crowds to implore her charity, the priest who came to offer
his blessing, her burden seemed to fall from the spirit of the tormented
woman. No longer enclosed by the evil atmosphere of the Faubourg St. Honoré,
full of lying, quarrelling, incriminations and scandals, she was able to
forget a great part of her misery, to indulge in the dreams that her present
reconciliation with her husband might be permanent, and when he returned from
Javiaux du Boccage they might renew amid these Norman fields the joys of
their honeymoon, which had been spent at Locroi.
Mademoiselle Debelleyme obeyed the instructions of her master and effaced
herself; Mademoiselle Heller, who was completely under her domination, did so
also; in the enchanting little house by the orangery Madame du Boccage had
once more full charge of her children. It was, at first, difficult to detach
them from their governess who was so well able to amuse them; they were all
estranged from their mother who had always been ill, suffering, emotional,
who had always embarrassed the candid, amiable selfishness of childhood by
her exaction of passionate affection, by her demonstration of jealous love,
by her impulsive hysterical temper.
The Duke sent his written commands to Mademoiselle Debelleyme, emphasising
his wish that all authority should be with the Duchess; as she had promised
she effaced herself, and the children reluctantly resigned themselves to the
constant companionship and tuition of their mother; but Mademoiselle
Debelleyme was always in the background.
The governess, who thus found so much leisure on her hands, enjoyed her
stay in this lovely place.
She had a fine young horse and would ride through the leafy park imagining
herself mistress of the place, that she was returning to the Gothic chateau
with a train of servants waiting to welcome her, that she was about to leave
for Paris where she lived in a fashionable circle where she would soon be
entertaining some of the royal princes, the King himself, that she was a high
and important figure in politics who knew and led most of the notable men of
the time. Great statesmen came to consult her judgment, great artists
clamoured to paint her face, famous sculptors wished to model her delicate
hand, her lovely foot, the fashionable dressmakers named materials and
fashion; after her, the newspapers eagerly chronicled her doings. In brief
she was, in every possible sphere of life, not only celebrated but dominant
... The sunlight, the magnificent blue shadow of the cedars against the pale
azure of the sky, the perfume of the orange flowers covering the hundreds of
dark green trees in the orangery, the murmur of the stream beneath the yellow
droop of willows; all these were delightful accompaniment to her daydreams:
but Lucille Debelleyme had them well in hand.
At the end of the summer M. du Boccage appeared at Locroi; no
communication for several months had passed between him and the governess but
she was completely at ease, she believed she had exactly followed out his
instructions, the plans that had been arranged with silent understanding
between them and that had worked out exactly as they had both wished.
The Duchess, nervous, exhausted and, despite her good intentions, her kind
heart, tactless in all her relations with others, had made a complete failure
of her attempt to take charge of and educate her children; an emotional
confusion reigned in the charming little Italian house.
Within a few hours of the arrival of M. du Boccage the timid, half
apprehensive joy with which his wife had greeted him was dispersed by his
"I have given you what you wished for, complete authority over the
household, over the children, but you have proved yourself incapable. Well.
my dear Fanny, resign yourself to relinquishing these burdens that are
obviously too heavy for you."
Stung by what seemed to her a cruel injustice and half suspecting, candid
as she was, that she had been the victim of a plot, the impulsive Corsican
"I have not been free, I have not had sole charge."
"Ah!" interrupted her husband quickly, "did not then Mademoiselle
Debelleyme do as I bid her and efface herself utterly?"
"She has always been there," she replied hotly, "watching me, spying on
me; as long as this woman remains near me... "
"You blame the governesses, do you?" interrupted the Duke, with the air of
a man who pays little attention to what is said to him because his decision
is already taken. "I admit that they may be in the wrong. Mademoiselle Heller
shall go. In the autumn we will have a tutor for Philippe Joseph... "
"And Mademoiselle Debelleyme?"
"I have no complaint against Mademoiselle Debelleyme," he answered
steadily, "she will stay."
Foreseeing one of those terrible scenes he so dreaded, to which he never
became used, and from which he had so thankfully escaped during the last few
months, the Duke added hastily, with a raised voice, forcing his
"Madame, I will have no dispute, no argument; I am only here to sell a few
horses, to arrange for the transportation of the orange trees to Javiaux du
Boccage. I intend that we shall all go there these last few days of summer
and for some of the autumn before we start for Paris."
"I refuse," stammered the Duchess in a faint voice. "If you will not part
from this woman you must part from me."
And the Duke replied quietly, "Very well, Madame, make your own decision.
No doubt it will do you good, as I can see that your health is still poor, to
remain here. I, the children and the governess will proceed to Javiaux du
Such was the meeting with her husband to which Madame du Boccage had
looked forward with such hope through all the summer months, such was the end
of her piteous attempt to regain her utterly lost domination over her family.
She was more than ever isolated, more than ever miserable. The little red
morocco diary to which she confided her desperate thoughts had more pages
covered with a corroding, an unresigned passion, the cries of an atrocious
suffering that even a deep religious sense could scarcely subdue.
The Duke had coldly triumphed, conceived his plans carefully, put them
into play and succeeded admirably in his intentions.
One glance of satisfaction, one only passed between him and the blonde
governess. The Duchess, whose terrible disappointment brought on an attack of
fever, kept to her word and refused to leave Locroi.
For the sake of appearances the youngest child and his nurse were left
with her, the others went to Javiaux du Boccage on a beautiful mellow day at
the end of September.
The children, delighted to be again with their beloved father, to be once
more under the guidance of their adored governess, filled the hour of
departure with cries of joy, and shouts of laughter.
Lucille Debelleyme on that bright morning looked back, from the wagonette,
at the little house on the edge of the stream, at the last saffron-coloured
roses, the trails of scarlet and amber-coloured creeper climbing round the
slender pillars of the open balcony, with the silk curtains behind the
shutters fluttering in the warm breeze, looked towards the green forest, the
limpid water running at the bottom of the lawn beneath the willows. It was a
charming scene and she found it ironic that the small house should enclose so
much misery as Mademoiselle Debelleyme knew overwhelmed the woman who hid
But it was when she arrived at Javiaux du Boccage, which was
far more splendid than anything she had seen before, that for the first time
Lucille Debelleyme allowed her ambition a little rein. Nothing could be too
large, too extravagant, too luxurious for her taste, and this huge palace set
in a colossal park, greatly increased in her estimation the master of such
magnificence, increased also her joy and pride in his friendship, and his
championship—dangerously increased her hopes.
This sumptuous chateau, which Lucille Debelleyme surveyed with
enthusiastic approval, had been built, in a mood of reckless splendour too
grandiose to last, from the combined spoils of a successful soldier and a
The mighty building with an immense facade of white stone rose from the
sloping banks of a small river; the governess learnt with delight that half a
dozen villages had been razed to the ground to form the park, that it had
cost five or six millions to build Javiaux du Boccage, and had occupied, for
several decades, thousands of workmen. Nothing lacked of that impression of
reckless luxury that was the stamp of that glorious world which had endured
so briefly and vanished so completely—the age of Louis XIV.
The forecourt and the court of honour separated the Castle from the park,
colossal sculptures adorned the wide terraces and supported the huge pillars
crowned by trophies that guarded the gates, iron wrought to the delicacy of
There were at least five hundred rooms, some painted by Le Brun, by
Mignard, adorned by tapestry from designs by Boucer, the youth of Bacchus,
the Chariots of the Sun, battles of Titans—Javiaux du Boccage had been
built on a scale that could only have been continued by a succession of
The first splendour was dimmed, in part effaced; it had been through the
Revolution of 1789, it had been neglected by the old miser who was the father
of the present Duke, The chapel, the guard house, the terraces, the gardens,
the fountains, the grottos, the canals, the state apartments were all in
urgent need of restoration.
When Mademoiselle Debelleyme saw the hundreds of workmen employed in this
labour, when she saw the architects, the painters and the sculptors who M. du
Boccage had lavishly engaged in the task of reviving the glories of this
incredible chateau, she understood the vital need he had of all his wife's
It was the miserable woman abandoned in Normandy to the torments of her
devouring jealousy who owned all the money her husband was lavishly spending
on his beloved heritage. Mademoiselle Debelleyme sympathised profoundly with
his situation, deeply admired the skill with which he was extricating himself
from an intolerable position, gradually separating himself, his children,
completely from his wife, yet avoiding all scandal, all open complaint, all
the inconveniences of a legal separation, while still maintaining full
control of her huge and necessary fortune.
In this superb place, walking through the great rooms, along the enormous
terraces, the governess, though so cautious, though so sure of herself,
though, till now, with her emotions her aspirations well in hand, allowed
herself to look steadily into the future, to consider her situation coolly,
or, as she believed, coolly. But in truth the fact that she was alone with M
du Boccage in this intoxicating environment had gone a little to her head;
what might she not make of a destiny which seemed so suddenly, so
unexpectedly brilliant? This man, who never uttered a word of a love to her,
who treated her alway with respect, who saw her for the most part in company
with his children, yet who continued to seek her out every day, more and more
frequently—what might now be made of him?
Freed from the restraint imposed by the presence of his wife, he consulted
the governess on every point. Her judgment, her taste, her enthusiasm were
frequently called upon to decide this and that in the restoration of Javiaux
du Boccage... however prudent she might be, however cold-blooded, she could
not but begin to feel that she was necessary to this man, that she was
acquiring over him a subtle but powerful domination.
If he did not love her now, he might come to do so. She recalled Madame de
Maintenon, Madame de Genlis, women who had maintained a perfect decorum in
positions like her own, yet contrived to oust the mistress or the wife in
possession, to completely obsess with their intelligence, their
personalities, the men who had at first employed them as humble
Mostly the governess dwelt on the case of Madame de Genlis; a model
governess, a paragon of virtue, intelligent, with liberal ideas, who had
entered unobtrusively into the establishment of Monsieur D'Orleans, the
father of the present king, and before very long had, still under the cloak
of complete respectability, utterly eclipsed his wife until she was a
melancholy stranger in her own house, and had absorbed father and children
alike. Had she been his mistress, or merely his platonic friend, his Egeria?
No one knew to this day, she had been so clever. Scandal had raged, of
course, but had not dared to rear its head against the implacable armour of
her propriety, and she had reigned supreme. It was Madame D'Orleans who had
crept away, abandoned, robbed of children as well as husband, to die of a
broken heart in solitude, and now Lucille Debelleyme ventured to speculate:
"Perhaps I can do that, perhaps I could play that part. I am dealing with a
woman who plays into my hands, by her inexperience, by her folly, by her ill
health, by her very virtues. My God! how he winced to see the paupers ruining
his lovely grounds at Locroi, how he turned aside when he saw the priest in
the anteroom! She is so stupid she does not even know how to hide the virtues
that irritate him, she has lost him... lost him, and why should I not catch
his heart on the rebound? I believe we understand each other very well, that
he as well as I would see that all was done with perfect decorum; there would
be no scandal, he would not have to affront her father, to give up her
fortune, leave his place at Court, to face a Separation from the children he
adored. Can I do it?"
She believed she could; though of course some risk must attend any
enterprise so ambitious.
But nine months of power had given Mademoiselle Debelleyme a good deal of
self-assurance, her native audacity came to the surface. She resolved to
strain every nerve in a tenacious battle with the Duchess, in an attempt to
make permanent a strange ascendancy she did not quite understand herself (she
could not tell for all her skill if the man really loved her in any sense of
the word) over M. du Boccage.
From the peace of her retreat in Normandy, Madame du Boccage
wrote to her husband, absorbed in the grandeur of Javiaux du Boccage, and the
governess found opportunities to read some of these pathetic letters.
Left to herself, some resignation had fallen on the tormented spirit of
the neglected wife and she wrote tenderly, entreating her husband for a small
return of his love and confidence, promising with almost servile humility
complete obedience if he would only smile on her again...
She reminded him that she had never cared for the way of life that
belonged naturally to her position in society and her vast wealth. All she
had wanted was happiness in her own home, among her beloved children.
In one letter that the governess' cruel eyes had spied upon the wife had
written: "Into this marriage I have put everything, all my hopes of any
"Lay all your eggs in one basket and you will break them," was the mental
comment of the governess.
A few days before the proposed departure for Paris (the winter was drawing
in) Madame du Boccage arrived suddenly at the Chateau Javiaux du Boccage,
although her husband had tried to dissuade her when she had first hinted at
her intention, saying that it was foolish in her state of health to take such
a long and tiresome journey.
But full of good resolutions and not despairing even now of complete
reconciliation with her husband, the impetuous Corsican arrived close behind
the message announcing her arrival.
The carriage drew up before the vast steps on which stood her husband and
behind him the governess, holding by the hand little Isabelle. It looked like
a family group by Winterhalter; man, woman and child, elegant, precise, stood
against the great expanse of marble in the clear, cold, early winter
sunshine; there even seemed to be a resemblance between them, for the pretty
girl was blonde like her father. It was the dark, heavy woman descending from
the carriage who appeared to be the alien; she recognised this with a sense
of fearful desolation, it was she who was the intruder, it was she who was
not wanted. Her husband's face was overcast, the greeting of the governess
icy and that of the child distracted. She, this tiresome hysterical invalid,
had come to spoil their fun.
She realised this so keenly that she was unable to put into practice her
good resolutions, she became at once peevish, reproachful, and for the first
time since she had handed her fortune over to her husband's care, she, so
indifferent about money, found occasion to reproach him for the lavish sum he
was spending on a useless monument of wanton splendour such as Javiaux du
There followed one of those violent quarrels which had taken place
frequently enough in the rez de chaussée in the Faubourg St. Honoré
but always behind closed doors, with lowered voices; but here the Duke,
exasperated by this intolerable interference in his labours, broke openly
into one of his rare but frightful rages.
He snatched his wife's blue silk parasol from the chair where she had
thrown it and snapped the ivory handle in his powerful hands to prevent
himself from touching her, and when she, with bitter dignity, reproached him
for his appalling ill manners he was goaded into further violence and smashed
a gleaming Sevres vase which stood on a stand of onyx.
Madame du Boccage became really alarmed herself; she knew she could have
avoided provoking her husband's rages if she had sufficient self-command, and
this fury came with devastating effect from a man usually amiable, sweet,
even indolent in his manner.
She ran from the room uncaring as to who might see her and in the barren,
hateful splendour of the large salon, darkened by heavy statues, gods and
goddesses sprawling from the blue foliage of tapestries, she gave vent to an
excess of despair, all the more bitter as it followed on her hopes of a few
A plasterers, knife had been left on the window sill by one of the men who
was restoring the elaborate stucco round the deep frames. The frantic woman
snatched this up with a melodramatic gesture so detestable to her husband,
who had followed her and saw with profound disgust her intention. The scene
was made worse for him by her ludicrous likeness, in her heavy clothes, in
her frantic, yet majestic despair, to some blousy, tragedy queen of the
Theatre Français in the bloody climax of the last act. As he pulled the knife
from her, defeating her easily with the least exertion of his enormous
strength, he hated her for the worst of her sins, that of making them both
She fell back, crying hysterically, and Matilde, the busy spy, came
running in. This heightened his fury, his humiliation, he was scarcely able
to restrain himself. He saw that in the struggle to gain possession of the
knife he had cut himself; he stared at the blood dripping down his pale
waistcoat and tight light trousers.
Breathing hard, M. du Boccage went to the large room on the ground floor
which he had given as a salon to Mademoiselle Debelleyme. Stammering, he told
her the story of that gash in his palm and, while, without comment, she
fetched her liniment and her bandages, he stared with horror at the red
wound. As she tended him, she thought that never had she got so far into his
confidence, never had he revealed to her so plainly his miserable relations
with his wife. She knew that the cut was nothing; it was not for comfort for
a scratch on his hand that he had come to her but for consolation in those
wounds to his pride, his dignity, his self-esteem.
He sat down shuddering and placed his hand on the table; she bent over it
and gently wound round and across it long strips of soft lint. She recalled
when she had seen that hand, in its velvet cuff, and sapphire stud, resting
on the edge of the box at the Opera. For a while he did not speak; a man ill
able to express himself, he was usually silent in moments of strong emotion
but at length he brought out:
"Mademoiselle, you have understood how I am situated?"
She raised her head from her bandaging, paused in the quick movement of
her fine fingers and looked directly into his eyes. She had never seen them
so wide open nor understood so well their expression.
"What is your impression of my life?" he asked as if he would rather that
she and not he might put what was between them into words.
"You live in an inferno."
"It is quite true! There is no one to help me, no one to understand. She
is considered a saint, a martyr and I have to put up with it. Is it my fault
that I married when I was a child and knew nothing? Is it my fault that I
have changed from loving her, admiring her? That I have come to regard her
Lucille Debelleyme drank in eagerly these harsh words which were vibrant
with a passion so long repressed; she knew that she was his first confidante.
To whom indeed could he speak in these terms of his innocent, his admired
wife? The governess understood his point of view, it was not only
self-interest that made her his champion.
"She will not let me go," whispered the Duke as if he spoke to himself;
his free hand beat lightly on the table, "she will not let go! She clings and
clings and I wake in the night and feel her clinging when I am alone. She is
like a vampire that bites into one's very entrails. I have read of such
beasts. Mon Dieu, I do not know what I may be driven to if she will not let
me go! Her cries, her reproaches, her scenes, her priest, her maids! She even
sets her porters to follow me and pays beggars to report my movements to her.
Yet to all the world she is a model wife and mother, a pure, virtuous woman.
To hell with all such virtue, I say! I would sooner have married a harlot
than this exacting piety, this jealous lunatic goodness that will not let me
He had spoken the truth, words he could never retract nor she ever
Lucille Debelleyme listened with joy mingled with fear, to this terrible
confession wrenched from the man before her. Gone was his usual gaiety, his
suave amiability and correct manners; she noted the drops of sweat on his
forehead, the way he beat his hand again and again on the table. He went on
"You have heard much of her sufferings, I suppose—have you ever
thought of mine, what this life means to me? I will not give way—I have
been considered weak, but I will not give way. I will neither become her
lover nor her slave. I will not lose my children, the money, my position,
make myself a laughing stock. She would have all the sympathy—I will
not listen to the reproaches of her father... " He checked himself with a
terrible effort, pulled his handkerchief from his waistcoat and wiped his
"Go on, Monsieur," said Lucille lightly holding his bandaged hand in hers.
"You do not say a word of what I have not already suspected."
"So I guessed, a woman of your intelligence would have understood from the
first. But I never said anything, did I? I should not be telling you all this
"We are past such conventions."
His bandaged hand turned over on the table and clasped her fingers.
"You will stand by me, you will help me? Without you I cannot do it."
"Help you? How?"
"It must be done by subterfuge, one must keep one's patience, one's
temper, one must wear down this intolerable opposition, one must force her to
He was silent, overpowered by an excess of emotion.
"That is the only way," breathed Lucille, bending close to him, "to be
wary, to be careful, to feel one's way. Monsieur, if you could only bring
yourself to be a little kind to her, even perhaps to give her all she
"I cannot." The truth seemed drawn from him against his own volition and
hung on the air between them. "It is a physical repugnance, the last time I
slept with her, the scent of her hair on the pillows... " He turned away.
Lucille Debelleyme remembered the handsome bed with the Brussels lace
curtains amidst the amorini upholding the huge baldaquin. She was filled,
vicariously, with distaste for Madame du Boccage, ill, half-dazed with opium,
thickened by continuous child-bearing; how well she could understand his
repugnance, born of personal, physical aversion. No doubt he had recoiled
from the bed and the woman who clamoured so piteously for his love, with the
same violence as she had flung away from Robert Morrison. That to her was
unforgivable, this attempt to force the relationship of the body as the soul
sprang back in disgust.
"I know you cannot do it; whatever you decide I am your ally and will help
He had so little command of himself that as he wiped the sweat from his
forehead he confessed:
"I should not have spoken to you. I should not have involved you in this.
I was overcome, I came to speak to you because I was afraid I might strike
"If you had I could have condoned it. To me. Monsieur, there are worse
things than a blow."
To me also. Sometimes I think I do not belong to this period, to this
century. Sometimes, Mademoiselle Debelleyme, when I escape to these houses,
parks that belonged to my ancestors, I think of the days when no man allowed
himself to be so hellishly dominated by a woman, when one got free even at
the cost of what they would call now crime. Many a man has killed his wife
for adultery and been thought none the worse for it because he was saving his
honour... his honour! There are worse things than adultery."
"I also think so."
His breast was heaving as he stared at her straightly and demanded:
"You do not think the worse of me for this—because I cannot love my
wife? You perhaps understand? That you, of all people, capable of
understanding, should have come my way when in the eyes of almost everyone I
appear a heartless, a mean brute!"
"Not to me, Monsieur. I understand, I—sympathise."
She walked round and round the table, approached where he sat and
retreated from him again. Through the tall uncurtained window of the half
unfurnished room a shaft of gold from the western sun fell into this
apartment, at once bleak and sumptuous.
"I understand Madame du Boccage also," she added; she too allowed her
emotions a little range, forgot her old conventional manners, her traditional
humility. "I can understand what it might be to love, and hopelessly, some
man, a man like yourself, Monsieur Le Duc. Oh! I am fastidious and squeamish,
I could be devoted and loyal and passionate, but I should not make these
scenes; I have the strength to control myself."
He rose and held on the back of the chair with his sound hand in an
attitude like the one in which she had first seen him in the Faubourg St.
Honoré, and stared at her, and these two, neither of whom believed in God,
neither of whom felt the lack of that belief, both hedonist, epicurean and
passionate, looked at each other with increasing excitement.
"You know what is said of us?" he asked abruptly. "You are aware how we
"As well aware. Monsieur, as I am aware that there is no foundation for
that slander." She spoke with the force of her real pride, rejoicing almost
savagely in the consciousness of her immaculate, technical innocence.
"You are prepared to endure this, Mademoiselle, for my sake? I will in
every possible way protect you, but there is much I cannot do, there is a
great deal I cannot save you from."
"I do not care, I have nothing to lose. Your friendship has been the only
thing I have had that has been worth anything, that and the affection of your
children, the protection of your household."
"My mother told me you had once been deceived in a man. I from the first
knew the kind of a woman you are. I have not... I would not... " he
hesitated, struggling with his words, phrases did not come readily to his
lips even at a moment of emotion, "I would not insult you. Mademoiselle, by
taking a vulgar advantage of your position, but nevertheless you mean a great
deal to me... "
"I will do whatever you wish. No matter what occurs I will not leave you
till you tell me to."
Then, with a sudden excess of feeling which she could not control, she
flung herself on her knees on the marble floor beside him, took the hand that
hung by his side and pressed her lips to it.
"All I have is yours," she whispered, "my gratitude, my devotion, my
She rose and was gone, and he, who had been so outraged by the
melodramatic passion of his wife, found this display gracious, touching and
infinitely soothing to his stung pride.
Custom reasserted itself, and every day life dropped into it
usual routine, but now between Madame du Boccage and the governess it was
open warfare, waged with that tenacity which only those whose passion is
fully roused have the strength to maintain. Not one spark of pity did Lucille
Debelleyme feel for the woman whom she now regarded as a rival. Did she not
employ her servant to spy upon her husband?—did she not listen eagerly
to tales that anyone brought to her of him? And what if not rejected love was
the root of all her miseries and anguish?
Lucille Debelleyme did not put a very high value on that passion; she knew
the world would call it a pure wifely affection, a mere insistence on sacred
vows taken before God; but, looked at clearly, what was it? A physical desire
for a man whose character she could not admire if she was the virtuous woman
she pretended to be, a man whose actions she must, as a good mother, despise,
a man she should, if she were sincere in her pious protestations, condemn as
an atheist, a libertine, a heartless rake.
Lucille Debelleyme thought she could read Fanny du Boccage well enough,
her physical desires tormented her, it was impossible for her to live in
peace near her husband and not have him as her lover. If he would once more
share the bed beneath the mighty baldaquin he might indulge in any
improprieties, any frivolities, and continue his reckless expense on Javiaux
du Boccage with no word of reproach from his satisfied wife.
"She is no better than I," thought the governess with contempt, "she has
not been able to make anyone, except toadies and spies and beggars and
priests love her, and even the children have turned to me; she is in my way
and she must go, even if it means destroying her utterly."
The Du Boccage household returned to the Faubourg St. Honoré and life in
the elegant mansion pursued, on the surface, its usual course throughout the
gaieties of a Parisian winter.
M. du Boccage did not renew his confidences with the governess; when they
met again after that interview at Javiaux du Boccage he had resumed his usual
manner and she was mistress of hers, all was understood and there was no need
for further words.
The Duchess appeared vanquished, her long illness kept her in her
apartments, the installation of nurses, the visits of doctors helped to pass
over the winter with some outward decorum; and also allowed ample leisure for
the governess and M. du Boccage to pursue their companionship, their
friendship, the indulgence of their common tastes.
That was a memorable season for Lucille Debelleyme, she felt
herself in the forefront of those great events she had often regarded
longingly from afar. She took a lively interest in all that was happening
around her, herself a product of a new century she felt at one with all the
manifestations of progress, She enjoyed it all, from the grand review at the
Champs de Mars in honour of the Envoy of the Emperor of Morocco, to the
ceremonious openings of two new railway stations, that from Paris to Tours
and that ambitious line to the North. She was present at the marvellous
experiment of the invention of M. Le Docteur Payerne when a submarine was
sent under the Seine where it remained with its crew for two hours, she
watched the Viceroy of Egypt's arrival at the Palais Élysée, heard from M. du
Boccage an account of the brilliant reception given by Madame de Recamier in
honour of Chateaubriand, she attended with the children the fete in the
Champs Élysées given for the benefit of the Spanish refugees, she took the
eldest boy, the Marquis Philippe Joseph, to see the great steeplechase at
Croix de Berny, she was present at the fashionable parade at the Madeleine
when the monstrous new organ by Cavaille was inaugurated, she listened with
malice to the accounts of two attempts against the life of the King, one at
Fontainebleau, one at the Tuileries, she watched the Due de Nemours,
reviewing his troops and she read in the journals of the elaborate
preparations for the marriage of the Due de Montpensier with a princess of
She was present in the Opera-Comique when Berlioz gave the first
performance of La Damnation de Faust; she listened keenly to all the talk,
the whispers of the salon, the hints in the press (that new power becoming
every month more formidable), sometimes she even caught a word or a phrase in
the streets which proved to her that the present dynasty was not so firm as
it might seem, nor the King and his numerous family as beloved as they might
appear, and the governess, like a butterfly flitting ahead of flames that
could not overtake her, nor even scorch her wings, trembled with anticipation
at the thought of yet another Revolution.
She knew herself on the edge of an abyss but she knew herself also at the
bottom of a cliff, an uneasy position, she might either climb or
fall—but she was happy.
She believed that she was making M. du Boccage happy also.
By patient dissimulation, by laborious subterfuge he had almost entirely
disentangled himself from his wife. His leisure, his companionship, his
interests were more and more for the children and the governess, he went less
frequently to Court, joined more seldom those amusements which formerly he
had found so delightful, as if there was no keener pleasure for him than to
be entertained by Lucille Debelleyme on the first floor of his mansion in the
Faubourg St. Honoré.
They based their mutual security on the pride and reserve of Madame du
Boccage. Scandal might murmur, bitter remarks might be dropped, hostile
glances given, but as long as the wife did not complain no one else could do
Yet Lucille Debelleyme knew that this provoking and piquant situation
could not last, there must be a climax and she hardly dared to speculate as
to what that might be.
She felt secure as far as M. du Boccage's wife was concerned, but she did
not feel so secure in regard to his possible passion for herself. It was true
that they appeared to understand each other perfectly; after his outburst at
Javiaux du Boccage when she had dressed his wounded hand (an incident to
which he never referred) she was certain she possessed his entire confidence,
but what would he risk for her sake if the Duchess was driven to make open
complaint, if she should call in her father, her family?
Would M. du Boccage sacrifice everything or anything for the sake of
He came upon her one day when she was sewing; her thimble dropped off and
he picked it up, remarking on the bright design of forget-me-nots, so
gracefully entwined on the silver.
"It was given to me by someone whom I shall certainly never forget."
"A lover, Mademoiselle?"
"I have never had a lover, but—a man who might have been one had I
Turning the tiny thimble round thoughtfully on his palm the Duke
"Have you never thought of marrying. Mademoiselle?"
Dropping her hands in her lap she studied the pale wreath on the Aubusson
"While I can be of any service in your establishment I should never think
of marrying, but if something should occur so that I have to leave... "
"Why should anything occur to cause such an unhappy event?"
"One never knows. Monsieur, but I was saying I think I should not have the
heart to seek another place. I believe if I had to leave you, I should
"You have, then, someone in mind?" and the sharp jealousy in his tone
caused her instantly to invent a suitor.
"There is a man who has long wanted to marry me, a retired officer in a
good position. I have refused him many times but he continues to pursue me,
and one day, friendless, unprotected as I am—" she ventured to look at
him, there was no mistaking the expression on his face.
"You do not care for this tiresome fellow?"
"I might be forced to marry someone for whom I did not care."
The Duke picked up one of his daughter's pencil sketches of rabbits and
carrots and tore it across, murmuring that it was poor and childish, then
returning to the subject that really interested him he exclaimed:
"Do you often see this man?"
"Never, Monsieur," replied the governess turning on him bright candid
eyes. "He is not in Paris. Sometimes he writes to me."
"You must never marry," whispered the Duke, looking away, "at least not a
man you do not respect."
She noticed he was careful to avoid the use of the word love, but she
rejected the word he did use.
"Respect," she exclaimed contemptuously, "surely that is the last thing
necessary in marriage!"
"What, then, would you have?" he asked quickly.
"You know," she smiled, "passion and understanding."
She took the thimble wreathed with forget-me-nots and replaced it again on
her small finger.
"For the moment I need not think of this marriage, I did not mean to tell
you, it is only my last refuge."
"While I live there is surely no need for you to think of it."
Very indifferently the governess remarked:
"You perhaps forget that I am only a dependant in this establishment, that
I am not honoured with the confidence of Madame... "
He bit his lip, turned away, then left her impulsively; she thoughtfully
continued her sewing and wondered whether she had done right or wrong to
invent this pressing suitor. It was amusing, it was delicious to provoke the
jealousy of M. du Boccage, was it not also perhaps risky?
But the governess was used to taking risks.
Now and then during that winter and spring the governess
ventured to creep to the little private apartment of the Duke, pull open the
drawer in the pale-green painted desk and read the letters which were now too
numerous to be contained in the vellum portfolio and were flung carelessly
She never dared to stay longer than gave her time to read a few lines, but
these were sufficient to prove to her that the relations between husband and
wife were even worse than they had been, and that the Duchess, with the
recklessness of a woman who has lost all hope, was still battling vainly to
be rid of herself—the governess.
Some sentences stirred the curiosity of Lucille Debelleyme. Madame du
Boccage vehemently reproached her husband, in several of these distracted
letters, with the little apartments in houses she was told he had hired in
various parts of the city, "and do not try to persuade me that they are for
She reproved him for going out late at night and hiring public vehicles
when he had so many carriages of his own at his disposal. "Do not tell me
that it is for the club, for the Court, or to see your mother or sisters that
you leave me," she wrote, "for it has occurred when the Court is at the
Chateau D'Eu, when your family are not in Paris."
"How minutely she must spy on him," thought the governess, "to find out
all his movements like that! What an incredible fool she is to flaunt her
knowledge in his face!"
Then Lucille Debelleyme herself began to wonder as to where M. du Boccage
spent the time he did not devote to her and the children.
He came to see her almost every evening, it was true, but always left at a
respectable hour, usually soon after the children were in bed; that he did
not go to his wife was abundantly clear and, rather to her own dismay, the
governess, who thought she had herself so well in hand, began to know
something of the prickings of jealousy with which she had so coldly tormented
the other woman; whom did M. du Boccage meet at the secret rooms which his
wife had discovered he hired?
Other women, of course; he had not lived like a monk, a man of that
physique, for six years. She knew about these things but she did not greatly
care to have them brought home to her and she was rather alarmed by the
distaste with which she considered even the casual mistresses of M. du
Was she about to fall in love with him herself or rather was she going to
allow him to assert a sway over her senses? That would be intolerable, that
would spoil everything. If she could not keep her head in that direction she
was surely lost, unless she thought again of Madame de Genlis and Madame de
How much had they loved the men on whose backs they had climbed to power?
The governess boldly asked herself: "Could I become his mistress, keep my
position here, look after his children, defy his wife? I believe it would be
very difficult, I believe if we became lost in passion it would be
She could not put those other unknown women out of her mind, she was
tortured with the thought that one of them might suddenly retain a hold on
him, satisfy more than a transient need.
She was tempted to make some advances to him, yet hesitated. She knew he
regarded her as immaculate, was not that her chief hold on him? He respected
her, admired her honour, her dignity and her purity, he had heard the story
she had told his mother solely in order that it might reach his ears. But
every time he came to see her she found his visit more pleasant, his presence
more alluring, his contact more dangerous, the glances veiled by the thick
fair lashes more seductive, and the slightly hesitating voice in which he
conversed with her more enchanting.
Everything about him, his costly clothes, his fine perfume, even that
thick blond hair that at first she found so repulsive because it reminded her
of Robert Morrison, the powerful hands which were almost vulgarly strong,
everything attracted her, and excited her keen senses.
When with locked door, with drawn curtains, in the rosy light of the
opal-shaded lamp, she stood in a thin robe of lace or silk, which would go on
the account of Madame du Boccage, and looked at herself in the mirror, pride
in her pale luminous beauty was not so impersonal as it had been. She began
to wish that M. du Boccage could see her like this, she began to regret that
she had taken such care to impress him with her purity.
The governess, watching on the stairs or visiting with the
children in the neighbourhood, saw many of the society figures who were
received in the Faubourg St. Honoré: Victor Hugo, the renowned novelist,
recently elected a member of the Chamber of Peers, General Cubières and
President Teste who were presently to be involved in those appalling charges
of corruption which would shake France, and she noted on several occasions a
grim and sinister figure which impressed her unpleasantly, that of the old
Due Pasquier, Chancellor of he Chamber of Peers, cold and cruel, bowed with
age, nearly blind with cataract, but possessed of a formidable presence
before which even Lucille Debelleyme quailed. He was believed to have no
interest in life beyond the prestige of the peerage of France, his face was
rigid with all the hauteur of those ancient nobles who had mounted the
bloody steps of the guillotine.
Mademoiselle Debelleyme hated the Due Pasquier and wondered why this
aversion was like a presentiment of ill fortune. An aura of evil, she
thought, surrounded the old man, with his eyes ringed by white circles, his
thick grey whiskers, his shaking hands, his implacable strength.
The propriety of the Faubourg St. Honoré could not satisfy her avid
curiosity; there was so much she did not know, there was a great deal she had
never experienced and she was haunted by the lines of the Duchess' letter
about the secret rendezvous to which her husband went so frequently.
Where did he go? What did he do? What kind of women did he meet? How did
he entertain them? What gifts did he give them? In brief, what life was this
that flowed beneath he even existence? What glitter, what darkness which she
might never hope to know?
On some of the light spring evenings of the first mild days the governess,
when the children were in bed (when he left he early) crept out of the house
wearing her simplest clothes, the thick, ugly dresses that had been so
approved of in Belgrave Square, and, pulling a veil over her dark bonnet,
hired a cab and drove to any chance address, any street that came into her
mind, an old church on the island of the city, an ancient house she had heard
of in Quartier St. Antoine. She would often drive over the Pont Neuf where
stood the last remaining shop like a temple with a black gateway, but mostly
she went to the poorer quarters where she could not possibly go in the
daytime with her charges, and gazed from the window of her carriage at this
other Paris of which she knew so little.
She noticed the public writer, with his soft hat and long torn coat,
shivering before his table in the open air of the Rue St Jacques; she watched
the charlatan in tartan trousers selling bankrupt stock in the Rue St. Denis,
and she drove once, on an evening when her spirit seemed restless, to the
prison of the Quartier Popincourt and looked, with she know not what kind of
interest, at those sombre walls, pierced by tiny windows.
Several times she dismissed her cab at the corner of a street where a
flickering gas-lamp gleamed down some dark alley, and started out, light
footed, apprehensive yet audacious, her clear cold eyes beneath the cotton
veil scanning the shabby house on which were stuck placards "lodgings for the
night," glancing down the open doors in the cellars where drunken men
quarrrelled, listening, as she hastened past, to the muttered conversations
of men, huddled together with their hands in their pockets, their caps over
their eyes, in broken doorways. She watched the rag-sellers, the sick
children sucking dirty crusts, the sore-eyed cats in the gutter, smelt the
reek of foul cooking that came from these obscure windows and blackened
doors. She watched the hawkers trying to sell their nostrums, their elixirs
for happiness; she listened to the wail of violins and mandolins outside
drinking houses, she saw the homeless prostitutes, many of them no more than
children. Without bonnets, without shawls, with clothes torn over breasts not
yet fully grown, stumbling down the gutters, the refuse round their skirts,
their faces flushed and haggard, their eyes confused, their breath heavy with
Satisfying she scarcely knew what avid need, the governess, from behind
her veil, drank in all these scenes, stamping them on her memory. This also
was life, as real a life as sparkled at the Cafe de Paris in the elegant
apartment Demidoff where the next morning she would pause in her ride with
the children and sit for a moment or so at the tables under the elegant trees
in the Boulevard des Italiens; yes, this was life and she might easily have
been a part of it. It was mere chance that she was not one of those
bedraggled women dying of vice and consumption.
It excited her, the ugliness, the filth, the suffering, the confused
medley that poverty, disease and crime made of life. Her cool fastidiousness
regarded without wincing the drunkard vomiting outside the cabaret, the
half-naked child, covered with ulcers, searching for rotting fruit among the
garbage pails, the hag stumbling into the disreputable pharmacy which
administered to the victims of vice, to buy rouge with which to daub the
cheeks of the consumptive street-walker.
She listened to the shrieks of women in child-birth coming from behind the
rags that blocked the windows of tenements, she heard the oaths of the police
as they struggled with thief or suspect, she heard the tired voice of some
priest praying above a death-bed, she heard a man in a grocer's shop beg a
biscuit box for his child's coffin, and the thin song of a demented woman
pacing before the great gates of a vast burial ground.
She saw the exhausted beasts being driven by the blows of sticks into the
slaughter house and the trails of blood that flowed sluggishly over the
cobbles, she saw a pigeon fluttering alive on a butcher's stall and a sewer
rat devouring the entrails of a decaying dog.
Once her light, hovering step brought her to the Seine, the dark bulk of
the Hotel-Dieu, the squat edifice of the Morgue. The few gas-lamps on the
quays were dully reflected in the sluggish river where long, dark barges
rocked at their chains.
The governess did not dare enter the building where the unknown dead drawn
from the filthy water lay corrupting on their marble pillows, but, as she
hesitated, staring, fascinated by this ultimate horror, a dark procession
formed out of the river mists about her. Some men in uniform, were carrying a
dripping body, half covered by a sack on which was stamped the name of a
sweetmeat manufacturer; the lolling head was exposed, the face was that of a
young boy, the outline gentle and refined, the expression one of insane
As the governess stared at this group which turned towards the Morgue, an
old woman lurched up out of the fog and thrust a bunch of dead roses under
her nostrils; so, thought Lucille Debelleyme, that drowned child might stink
in the nostrils of his Creator. She paid a few sous to the shivering woman
and when she had gone, dropped the dusty roses, that seemed rotten with
tears, into the river.
As soon as these nocturnal expeditions began to be observed and her
excuses of paying a visit to the poor, to a relative, would no longer serve,
she gave up what had become a dangerous diversion, but she had seen enough,
she had satisfied a restless, brutal curiosity.
The King walked up and down one of the galleries of the
Tuileries, a bundle of newspapers under his arm; disease had thickened his
once graceful figure to a stoutness that was daily turned to ridicule by the
venom of the caricaturists. In the not undignified person of Louis Philippe,
the careful benevolence of the professional democrat was tempered by
hereditary pride, indolence and obstinacy; as, affecting to found his
monarchy on the love of his people, he had never dared to use force, he had
been obliged to support his power by strategy and all the ramifications of
political corruption. Never had a Bourbon lived through so many vicissitudes
nor a King of France been through so many sordid experiences.
His civilian dress, ostentatiously devoid of any touch of grandeur, his
air of easy, unceremonious good humour, showed the citizen King appealing for
the sufferance of his dear countrymen, but he remained a royal Prince,
surrounded by an aristocracy modelled, as far as he dare, on that of the
ancien régime, and he knew, despite his elaborate devices to gain
popularity, that he was as despised and resented as any of these tyrants
whose lilies he had erased with such servility from his escutcheon.
The long gallery of the palace was dull with a neglected splendour; the
modest habits of the liberal monarch went ill with this background designed
for the flourish of, at least, outward glories. The King, with his bundle of
newspapers, approached a group of gentlemen who were talking casually of the
Chinese Industrial Exhibition in the Rue Neuve-Saint-Laurent; Louis Philippe
detached one of these from the others, and, with his air of gentle candour,
"Everyone is talking of your extraordinary governess, M. du Boccage."
"I was aware of that, but I was not aware it had reached the ears of Your
"Ah, I hear everything; the newspapers take care of that," replied Louis
Philippe with a grimace. "We have a new power here"—he touched the
packet under his arm—"these rogues are dangerous."
The Duke, smiling, amiable as usual, did not appear in the least
discomposed. The King regarded him shrewdly.
"You are going too far, I do not know whether you are very simple or very
cunning, that is scarcely my business, but, my dear fellow, you must
understand this is a game you cannot play."
"The situation has entirely been misunderstood; it is my wife's wish that
this lady retains her place in my establishment."
"With so much domination, so much power, going everywhere with your
children, received by all your friends?" asked the King sharply, "wearing the
clothes, even the jewels, she does? Oh, I admit she is a remarkable young
person, but she is also a nobody."
"My wife has not complained."
"She is very loyal and greatly beloved."
"There is no need for her to complain: the situation. Sire, is neither
mysterious nor painful—as for these gutter rags... "
"You have a treasure of a wife."
"No one knows that better than I do, Sire. Unfortunately Fanny's health
does not permit her to undertake any of her duties. As for the power that
Mademoiselle Debelleyme seems to allocate to herself, it is my wife's wish
she should assume it, and her clothes go to my wife's account."
"Very clever... very clever," exclaimed the King impatiently, "but, I pray
you, stop in time."
With emphasis he added:
"I have seen it done in my own home. It is quite true that I and all my
brothers and sisters, adored Madame Genlis, made of her almost a goddess, she
was everything to us, my mother the merest shadow. Let me, however, tell you
this—I have been through much, as you know, prison, exile,
poverty—but I have no sadder, more poignant recollection than that of
my poor mother, estranged from us, from her husband, by this woman, dying,
alien from all who should have loved her—of a broken heart. I am an old
man now, M. du Boccage, I have a little experience, if not much authority.
Look to your affairs."
M. du Boccage did not take this pathetic appeal in good part, especially
as it followed on one or two galling remarks dropped by M. de Nemours.
"Your Majesty is mistaken in supposing that anyone—that any woman
can dominate me."
"Yet this has the air of an infatuation. Of course everyone thinks that
she is your mistress. My dear Du Boccage, you do not suppose I would
interfere in your intimate affairs? But scandal—with a man of your
rank, I cannot afford—"
"Mademoiselle Debelleyme is not my mistress, she is a woman of the highest
To this the troubled King replied, almost in the words that had been used
by Madame du Boccage:
"She has the appearance of being so and that is the main thing. Listen to
me," he added with impressive earnestness, "I cannot, I will not have a
scandal among my friends, among the nobility. You have some idea how affairs
are in France, the feeling of the people against us, the difficulty of
maintaining this role of liberalism, the hatred there is for the aristocracy,
for the Chamber of Peers, the avidity with which every scrap of scandal is
leaped on, and, mon Dieu! Teste—Cubières—that's deadly, that is
sufficient! You," he added with that emphatic and persuasive dignity he knew
so well how to employ, "are widely known, an intimate of my son, one of the
firmest supporters of my House, I have richly rewarded all that you and your
father have done for me, you are Chevalier d'honneur to the Duchesse
D'Orleans: if I may not command, I entreat—do not allow slander the
least ground, put an end to these insinuations in the press, make up your
differences with your wife and dismiss this governess."
"Sire, I have no differences with my wife and she does not desire me to
dismiss this governess."
"It is sufficient that everybody is gossiping, whispering,
hinting—and there is some ground for suspicion. When, the other day,
Madame de Brancas said to your wife: 'Is it not true that your husband adores
you?' the poor woman could not command herself—she lost countenance and
nearly broke into tears."
The Duke's smile twitched into a grin. "Fanny is hysterical. And these
recriminations of women! Who, Sire, put Madame de Brancas on to probe my
wife's feelings? Forgive me if I find it strange that my most trivial
domestic affairs interest Your Majesty."
He had flushed violently; the King regarded him shrewdly, wondering what
was the truth about this man whom he had, until lately, regarded as an
indolent, good-natured, elegant creature sunk in connubial bliss, leading the
most blameless life of any member of the aristocracy.
"It does interest me, M. du Boccage. It amazes me, too. Frankly, what do
you hope? It is her money, the Frediani money that you spend on Javiaux du
Boccage. Foolishly, as I think, for no one of your rank will ever be able to
live on that scale again."
The Duke did not answer; he had not sufficient skill with words to be able
to disguise his deep anger; he was a man who most bitterly resented the least
interference, yet seemed destined to have perpetually to endure it. He gave
the King an uneasy impression of something savage at bay.
"No more words. Monsieur," sighed Louis Philippe. "You must understand me.
Let the young woman go while you can do so without an open fracas, give her a
pension, what you will, send her to England, to Italy, anywhere. I give you
"Sire—I have been spied on—by servants."
"Who is not spied on—by servants? You should have been equal to
circumventing the baseness of—what? Despair, perhaps, M. du
The King turned on his heel and walked away down the gallery; the Duke
drew further into the window recess, dragged out his frail cambric
handkerchief and, under pretence of wiping his lips, tore it with his strong,
The King's warning, the murmurs of his brother the Comte
Edouard, his sisters, his friends, caused the Duke to offer large concessions
with the readiness of a man who does not intend to give an inch. He forced
himself to go through a form of reconciliation with his wife, and took her to
Dieppe for her health, as he said, but really to escape the espionage of
Paris, leaving the governess in the Faubourg St. Honoré with the children.
But at the end of the week Mademoiselle Debelleyme joined them... it was
really a pity to separate mother and little ones, and the sea air had not
proved as beneficial for the Duchess as had been hoped; she pined in the
hired villa in Dieppe and had to continue the frictions of opium on head and
chest that had so long been her only means of securing sleep.
The truth was that she alone knew the extent of that concession on the
part of her husband at which his monitors rejoiced. Their apartments in the
Villa Violette were as separate as those in the Faubourg St. Honoré, he never
spoke to her except in public; his nervous, desperate desire to avoid a scene
had made him recently cease that evening visit of courtesy to say good night
that had been his last link with one time tenderness.
She had now no chance to break through his frozen amiability, his
deliberate civility, and the frantic letters she wrote in her lonely bedroom
redoubled in clumsy invocations of the past and anguished fears as to the
The villa was gloomy, the weather bad. The pale light of the sea invaded
the tall rooms with the uncomfortable Empire furniture, the stiff draperies
of a chill ocean-blue colour, the austere tea-table set with cumbrous silver
and china where the governess, in her neat striped silk gown, presided. The
Duke played backgammon with Isabelle by the hearth, the boy whispered over a
book with plates of coloured shells by the high window that looked on to the
calm sea, and Cesarine and Laure played with a grey kitten on the floor by
Into this scene the Duchess entered and sank, breathing heavily, on to the
sofa facing the window. Her bonnet was unfastened, she was unbecomingly
flushed, her hair was untidy; she appeared coarse and unattractive beside the
governess. She held several small parcels on her lap, and in an unsteady
voice implored the children to come and look at what she had bought for them;
none of them responded, and the Duke, who had risen at his wife's entry but
taken no further notice of her, continued his game, standing.
"Oh, fie," cried the governess to the little ones at her feet. "Go at
once. Mademoiselles, and see what Madame your mother has been good enough to
"We want to play with Mimi—"
The mother rose and came forward, holding out a little doll dressed as a
fishwife; Cesarine had sprung up, but the heavy emotion of Madame du Boccage
gave her an air of menace. The child was frightened at the greedy advance of
the dark heavy woman, she threw herself into the arms of Mademoiselle
Debelleyme and hid her face.
"Ah, that now!" exclaimed Madame du Boccage; above the golden head of
Cesarine she saw the brilliant steady eyes of her enemy looking at her with
scorn, with triumph, though the governess was murmuring: "Go to your mother,
darling, she has brought you a pretty present—"
The Duchess stumbled to the door with a cry that roused the boys from
their absorption in their book; Philippe Joseph cried out:
"Mother! Mother! What is it?"
"I will trouble none of you! I am a stranger here—my position is
intolerable! I am going to make an end of it!"
She rushed out, slamming the door. The Duke did not move, but Isabelle,
overturning the gueridon on which the game rested, clung to her father,
screaming out for him to "Stop mother!" Cesarine clasped the governess
tighter and began to sob loudly.
For a moment the Duke was immobile; he and the governess looked at each
other over the children's heads, a long, intense glance of complete
understanding. The little girls continued to sob, the boys to urge.
Mademoiselle Debelleyme held Cesarine tight by her slender body as the Duke
moved slowly across the window, behind him the pale glimmer of the sea. Then
with a shrug he turned and reluctantly left the high, pale room.
When the Duchess found herself on the beach she was ashamed of her
outburst. Her husband found her in a bazaar buying Chinese curiosities and
informed her brusquely that they were returning the next day to Paris... this
visit to Dieppe could not be called a success.
With a look, a gesture of despair, the unhappy woman locked herself in her
room with Matilde.
The Duke returned to Mademoiselle Debelleyme, who was amusing the
distracted children in the high, sombre parlour, lit by the cold light
reflected from a colourless sky and grey sea.
Sending the children out with the nurse, he turned to the young woman and
"How long do you think this can go on? She will come to some harm, she
should be where she can be looked after, day and night."
To these commonplace phrases Lucille Debelleyme replied with one of those
looks which was their mutual language:
"I have often feared it, I had a strange uneasiness when I saw her bedroom
... You know, if in one of her passions she threw herself, heavy as she is,
on that bed—the baldaquin seems so ill balanced... "
He bit his forefinger:
"Why, so it is, yet I had never thought of it—I will look to the
"And then," continued the governess lightly approaching him "if she was to
one day find a cord, a bottle of laudanum or arsenic—you had some at
Javiaux du Boccage for the rats in the vaults—or—her
opium—the doctor measures it out, I know—but if one day he should
leave it behind by chance... Oh, Monsieur, we really should be careful."
There was an awful blankness in his stare as he replied dully:
"Yes, we must be careful." Then in a low tone of repressed fury: "But
would it not be better if she did make an end it?—This is intolerable,
The governess did not answer; she was invaded by a sense of horror. She
detested this lofty, pale room, the depressing pallor of the misty sea beyond
the high windows, an atmosphere that was filled at once with boredom, nervous
tension and the dread of violence.
She knelt down before the empty hearth and began to pick up the tric-trac
pieces. This was the second time she had been at his feet; he made no effort
to raise her. When she stood up, the game in her hand, he was still staring
at the sea; she touched his arm, for he had the look of someone in a trance.
He started and exclaimed:
"Yes, yes, we must certainly return to Paris—and I will see about
* * * * *
It was the Duchess who relieved the tension of this
situation. As soon as she had recovered sufficiently she retired to Locroi,
taking with her the youngest children and the nurses, while the Duke, making
his gesture towards a peaceful settlement of his domestic affairs, sent the
elder boy to the care of a tutor in the College Bourbon.
At the beginning of spring Maréchal Frediani sent an invitation from
Corsica for his daughter and his grandchildren to visit him. The Duchess
refused to return from Normandy, but M. du Boccage declared he was weary of
Paris and longed for a holiday, he had the pleasantest recollections of the
Mediterranean, he would himself take little Isabelle, now of an age to
appreciate the beauties of the South, and, as a matter of course, the
governess would accompany them.
The Duchess, advised by a cold letter from her husband of this project,
offered no objection. Whether her consent was forced from her by resignation
or despair her husband neither knew nor cared.
"You see," he remarked to the governess, "patience gains the day. I have
conceded nothing, but now she has conceded all. She has the good sense to
learn that I am not to be moved by scenes and lamentations."
He sighed with satisfaction at the thought of the success of his long and
patient manoeuvres which had ended in his wife's unexpected permission for
this voyage to Italy. He appeared to believe that this tempestuous,
tenacious, exasperating woman had at length realised that she had lost for
ever all domination over him and that she would allow him in the future the
liberty he had for several years demanded.
He appeared almost gay at the thought that this intolerable tyranny had at
length come to an end, more than ever he was the cavalier preparing for the
Embarkation for Cytherea.
The governess regarded him curiously; she wondered, with secret
apprehension, if he was, after all, despite all his subtle ties and patient
intrigues, really a stupid man?
He remarked her hesitation with some irritation.
"Do you not care. Mademoiselle, for the thought of this escape to the
South? Are you not also a little weary of Paris?—of the Faubourg St.
"I am thinking, Monsieur," replied the governess with her cold brilliant
smile, "that it will be like standing naked in the Palais Royal and expecting
people not to stare at us."
"Do you think that it will cause a further scandal? Ah, very well, but one
should pay no heed to the gossips, all that can be said has been said. And
the purity of our intentions—"
She decided that such banality must be really irony. She hesitated a
moment but a moment only; what, after all, had she to lose? Her all was
centred in this man, his protection, his friendship. It did indeed matter to
her very little what the world might say as long as she preserved his
To travel with him on the borders of the Mediterranean, in Italy, free
from spies and the overwhelming presence of the sick, jealous woman—a
dangerous pleasure, perhaps, but she had never allowed cowardice to interfere
with her design Without changing her manner of passionate loyalty veiled by
implacable decorum, she said:
"I shall be pleased, Monsieur, to accompany you and Isabelle to
This Italian interlude was the entering of another sphere for Lucille
Debelleyme. If she had hoped to escape all hostility, all espionage she was
soon proved to have been mistaken; the glances, the comments she had to
endure even on the voyage showed that, and when she reached the great palace
in Corsica owned by the father of Madame du Boccage, the icy courtesies and
ironic glances of the old Maréchal informed her that she was still under the
supervision of an enemy, warned her that she danced and flaunted on the edge
of an abyss; but the borders of an abyss hung with the most entrancing
flowers. After all she could not find much that disturbed her, beside the
fact that she was in the company of Camille du Boccage.
She was not often alone with him but constantly in his presence. No word
of love was exchanged between them, but the strongest, deepest, most
intoxicating intimacy bound them.
He would look at her across a crowd; the pressure of his hand when he said
good night; his smile when he saw her in the morning; this was enough.
Careful not to allow a handle to any slanderer, not to trespass on the rigid
rules of propriety, Lucille Debelleyme enjoyed this intricate and difficult
game that she and M. du Boccage played. This secret alliance, this complete,
silent understanding produced a serene tranquillity that enveloped them
whenever they were together—alone or among others.
Her cold sensitive, fastidious nature, profoundly shocked by the sordid
issue of her one love adventure, did not fret at this long prelude to a drama
on which the curtain might never rise. It was enough to see him, to listen to
him, to know he was always there, near, to know that he watched her when she
played with his charming little girl, to note the change in his voice as he
spoke to her, to experience the subtle joy of seeing him turn his head, pause
in his conversation and look at her as she entered any room in which he might
His wife wrote to him; Lucille Debelleyme had come upon him tearing up the
unopened letters in the familiar writing and throwing them under his
writing-table, she had also come upon him tearing up a packet of Parisian
newspapers, "No doubt he and I are being pilloried there."
She could not of course avoid asking herself how is this going to end? Had
the Duchess really given way, resigned herself, without a struggle, to the
authority of the governess? Would the lawful wife's father, her relatives,
the Royal Family, public opinion, allow her to sink effaced into the
background? Would she, Lucille Debelleyme, become now what all the world
believed her to be, mistress of M. du Boccage?
He had not asked her for the slightest favour; if he did Mademoiselle
Debelleyme did not know what her answer would be. For the first time in her
life she found that her usual cool, keen consideration of her own interests
were confused by a rising passion.
Continual parties in honour of the charming little
granddaughter of M. de Frediani were given on his vast estates while the
Southern spring burst open around them. The sky and stars and flowers, sun
and moon and sea offered the most entrancing decoration for any tale of
One night Lucille Debelleyme, who always had to leave balls and receptions
early with her little charge, put a lace shawl over her delicate silk dress
and quietly left the Palace; she had wanted to for many nights. The moon was
full and, urged by a restless excitement, she had been unable to remain in
her room. She walked without conscious direction through a grove of oleanders
and came out on the shore, pale gold sands silvered by the moonlight, a line
of slowly curling surf white as ivory, and a sea of violet blue. Above her
the Southern moon seemed huge and very near and she felt as if she could
catch it in her hand.
She walked along slowly, losing herself in the enchantment and beauty, and
where some low rocks dark with the fragrance of some rich aromatic plants
stood, almost at the water's edge, she met Camille du Boccage.
She wondered if he had followed her, but she did not greatly care; he was
hatless and pale, the moonlight touched his thick blond hair, his colourless
face, the linen of his cravat and shirt almost into the likeness of an
alabaster statue, only faintly tinged with colour, and Mademoiselle
Debelleyme thought, idly curiously, of the statue of Cupidon that she had
noticed, looking over her shoulder into the mirror the first day that she
came to the Faubourg St. Honoré.
She did not pause in her slow walk along the edge of the surf and he fell
into step beside her. She could see nothing remarkable in this. Without a
word they experienced the intense delight of complete intimacy, their
everyday relationship and circumstances completely forgotten. Their hands
hung idly a their sides and as if by accident their fingers touched. The
silver mist that seemed to rise from land and sea, drawn up towards the moon,
enveloped them both, shutting them off from reality. She raised her face,
smiling steadily, and he said, under his breath:
"Is this love or something more?"
The question seemed to have no meaning, for what could be more than love?
Yet she knew; here was something so rare that she had never known of it
before and never would look for it again, something so real that all the rest
of her life seemed a sham beside it; he and she, in what relationship? It did
not matter. He and she, drifting towards what catastrophe? It did not matter.
They had met, and recognised each other, by what magic? She did not care. It
was enough that they had.
They walked on again in silence, she shivered as the cold creeping edge of
the sea wetted her thin doeskin shoes. He took her hand and turned it over
curiously in his own, looking down at her.
"Of course," he whispered in a voice that sounded far away, "this would be
too powerful for anyone to resist. Nothing would matter beside this."
A sudden inlet of the sea running in a wide arm between the rocks cut off
their progress. They turned back and saw before them the Palace with its
lighted windows showing deep yellow in the incandescent blueness of the
"What will happen?" asked Lucille.
"I do not know."
He seemed like a man under the influence of a heavy drug. She knew, and
this was one of the traits she admired in him, that he was very sober, he
neither drank nor smoked; his vices and indulgences were not those that left
traces upon his person. Yet to-night he seemed intoxicated.
They walked on towards the purple rock on which the great Palace Frediani
This was a very different ocean from that which had lapped the dreary
beach before the austere respectability of the Villa Violette. She drew her
fine, silk hem away from the crawling reach of the ivory-coloured foam and
found pleasure in the grace of her own gesture. She looked up again at his
face outlined between her and the sea, illuminated by the moonshine. It was
slightly distorted, that face, there was something of the demi-god, she
thought, in the outline... debased demi-god or noble beast? Something, at
least, not human, something she had always wanted, that satisfied her
She neither tempted nor repelled as she walked beside him in silence; she
was not one to force a moment, to provoke a climax. Above all she was not one
to indulge her own passion. They mounted in silence the dark rock, scented
from the growing plants; from the open windows of the Palace came the sound
of a polka.
All that winter Lucille Debelleyme had listened to the polkas so
fashionable in Paris, she had heard them played, she had played them hundreds
of times... Never yet had she danced the polka or any other dance: the music
came out persistently into the night.
"I must go back."
"Yes, I was wrong to believe that here we should be free from
"Well, it's her father's house!"
"Everyone is against us."
"It matters so little."
"Lucille, Lucille, you played that polka in Paris?"
"For your daughters."
"Is it honest to marry a boy of seventeen?—my father—"
"I must go."
"Yes, you are right to think of your reputation—"
Tenderly she replied:
"I do not. I have nothing to lose equal to what I have gained. But you!
You risk too much."
She moved swiftly from him, leaving him a shadow among the rustling
oleanders. The Palace rose sheer above her with the menacing bulk of a
monster chained to the rocks; the lighted windows were like eyes to spy and
mock, but above was the moon, the fresh night wind, below the sweep of the
surf on the sand. These were her allies; in their presence she was
When she reached her own room she was shaken by a force of emotion she
could not control, and she fell on her knees by the bed of chestnut wood. The
window was open wide and all the beauty of the night outside seemed filled
with his presence. The governess put out all the candles except one. She
undressed quickly, unhooking, unbuttoning in haste, taking off the little
shoes cold with sea water, the corsets of white satin warm from her body. She
peered into the mirror, not with self-assurance as usual, but timidly, asking
herself: "Am I lovely enough? Will he expect more than this?"
She put out the one candle; the moonlight was enough.
He knew where her room was; she kept a night lamp burning and set her door
wide, but he did not come. She writhed under the scorn of her own caution,
she wished she had not been at such desperate pains to impress on him the
legend of her purity.
She flung herself face downwards on the bed and bit her thumb to steady
her nerves; persistently there beat on her ears the rhythm of the polka.
The Maréchal Frediani decided to accompany his son-in-law
and his grandchild back to Paris and Lucille Debelleyme knew the reason of
this decision. The scandal that the pride and dignity of Madame du Boccage
had for so long kept at bay had now broken into the open. Every newspaper
published in Paris had something about this aristocrat of the ancien
régime living in open adultery with the shameless governess, who was,
according to some, Italian, according to others, English, according to all,
on the make. The Church was roused against this atheist who defied all moral
laws, the legitimists were roused against this member of the old nobility who
had followed the cadet branch of the House of Bourbon, and the people, hating
anything to do with the Chamber of Peers, murmured in increasing fury against
this flaunting of open immorality which in a less important man would have
been punished severely.
Lucille Debelleyme knew from the moment she arrived in Paris that the
affair had come to a climax.
Very shortly after her return to the Faubourg St. Honoré, where Madame du
Boccage had received her with resigned sweetness, the governess waited on the
Marshal Frediani who had come, she knew, to Paris with the sole purpose of
removing her from his daughter's household.
She carried in her small, exquisitely gloved hand some newspapers and put
them down on the ornate Empire bureau before the old soldier, pointing out to
him the paragraphs where there were scarcely veiled insinuations against
"An abominable situation has been created for me, I cannot remain with
your daughter, Monsieur Le Maréchal, another day. There is nothing for me to
do but to immediately withdraw from her establishment, from Paris."
"Why, Mademoiselle, do you come to me?"
"Because I am helpless, friendless, a young woman who has been foully
attacked, and because you. Monsieur, know that I am innocent. You had my
behaviour every minute of the day, under your eyes, in Corsica."
M. Frediani did not immediately answer, he was perfectly aware of his
daughter's frightful situation, of the miserable disarray in her household,
of the long separation between her and her husband. He disliked the governess
for the part she had played in the tragedy of Madame du Boccage but he could
not precisely put his finger on what the part was; he was baffled. It was
quite true that during the stay in Corsica he had observed nothing; and this
move now, this appeal to him, was it cunning or innocence?—he did not
know. Experienced diplomat as he was he could read nothing in the cold eyes,
so brilliant, so searching, that the governess turned on him in righteous
She must certainly go, he had resolved that. She must, as soon as
possible, leave the Faubourg St. Honoré, but the wily old man saw that for
her to go with a burst of scandal would be to play into her hands, to make
her a heroine, a victim, to sacrifice his daughter's dignity and peace of
mind, and would create an uproar that would split the whole house of
Montlosier du Boccage and probably cast a slur on the whole of the ancient
peerage, already with so much difficulty upholding if prestige in the eyes of
He rose, took a turn about his beautiful apartment, then with an air of
friendly but formidable authority, he paused before the slender expectant
figure of the governess.
"No, Mademoiselle, it is not the moment for you to leave my daughter's
establishment. To do so would be to confirm all the lying gossips which have
so justly offended you; ignore their slanders and they fall silent of
"Of all things avoid a scandal?" asked Mademoiselle Debelleyme, rising to
her feet. "Yes, for the sake of your daughter, of your grandchildren, of your
son-in-law himself, perhaps, for the sake of all your house and
"Certainly, Mademoiselle, that is my wish."
"But for me," she lightly struck her breast, "you do not think of my
reputation or peace of mind, or happiness? I am worthless, a nobody!"
"I do not see, Mademoiselle, how you would serve your interests by leaving
my daughter's house now. Remain where you are, pursue your usual course of
life and we can talk of this later, when all this hurly burly has died
"Then, Monsieur Le Maréchal, will you please see your daughter and get her
to ask me herself to stay in her establishment? This request cannot come from
M. du Boccage, as you must be aware, nor scarcely from yourself; she alone,
for her own sake, must ask me to remain."
The old man was silent; he began to perceive that he dealt with a very
clever person. No doubt the governess had not the least intention of leaving
the Faubourg St. Honoré, no doubt she meant not only to remain there but to
remain on the most honourable terms; that was why she had forced his hand,
compelling him to ask his daughter to allow this formidable enemy to remain
under her roof.
He bit his lip and his dark Southern eyes were angry but she had him
cornered, there was nothing he could do but to accede.
"I will speak to Madame du Boccage; it is desirable that you should for
the present"—he stressed the three words and Mademoiselle Debelleyme
perfectly understood why—"remain in the Faubourg St. Honoré."
The governess took her dignified leave, she had triumphed completely.
The Maréchal Frediani kept his word, he spoke earnestly to his
"I returned to Paris with the full intention of helping you to get rid of
this young woman, but I was not quite prepared for this outburst of
scandal—that must be weathered. She has come to me, she had the
effrontery to complain, she has won, I fear, the first move. She must remain
until all this noise has died down. Take my advice, my dear Fanny; I know
something of the world, show yourself as friendly as possible to this
creature, have an air of disdaining all that is insinuated, and presently, we
will get rid of her."
Madame du Boccage agreed with her father with a readiness that surprised
him; her pride in her family, her dignity as wife and mother were strong, she
was ready for almost any sacrifice that would avoid a scandal which would
reflect so miserably on herself, her father, her children, on the whole caste
to which she belonged.
"I had already resolved to do so, I will do all I can to ignore these
"It is you alone who can do anything. Fanny; I will not deny that the
situation is ugly. What," he added with impulsive irritation, "is the matter
with Camille? Is he in love?"
"In love, yes, but in what fashion? I confess that I have lost all hope!
But I did not wish to tell anyone, not even you. You know nothing of my
sufferings, of what it has been like; I have been wrong, too, I lose my
temper, I speak violently and I make scenes and he can endure none of these
things, and yet when he is with me I cannot control myself."
With an effort she maintained her calm. "Tell me, father, you are
experienced, you know the world, men and women. They were together under your
eyes in Corsica. Is she, I do not know—I am baffled—is she his
"His mistress, no, though it may seem strange, I do not think so."
"What then is it? It is like an enchantment, a witchcraft, as if she has
taken possession of his very soul. He has given her all my authority, all my
power, he has put in her charge all my children."
Seeing a rising storm of hysteria threaten his daughter's uneasy calm, the
old man put his hand on her shoulder and said tenderly:
"Think no more of it. Fanny, we must wait, we must be patient. Dignity,
generosity, charity, these are your only weapons."
"I know, but, Camille, my children, they are lost... "
"Nay, not lost, this passion, this infatuation, whatever it is, is too
violent to last."
Looking at her father timidly, the Duchess asked in a pitiful voice:
"Do you intend that she shall go?"
"I do, I shall use all my power, all my authority; I have the Royal Family
behind me, public opinion; he cannot resist. Do not look so uneasy," he added
impatiently; his daughter was taring at him with an expression of awful
terror. "What is the matter, do you not wish this creature flung out of your
establishment? Nay, all must be done with decorum, she must have a pension,
she must be sent to England. It shall be arranged."
"But, Camille," murmured the Duchess, "he will never forgive me. I have a
presentiment—I know not—but I believe if I force him to give her
up, whatever she may be to him, I shall at the same time destroy myself."
On the occasion of Madame du Boccage's birthday, the
governess sent the Duchess an exquisite piece of needlework designed and made
by herself. Complimentary, charming and delicate letters were exchanged, the
Duchess returned the present, that she received with graciousness, by a gift
of a bracelet of blue turquoises arranged so that they looked like a cluster
of forget-me-nots. Mademoiselle Debelleyme tried them on, an ironic smile on
her lips, and then flung them into her trunk.
Madame du Boccage, who had begun to go about much in society in order to
dispel the scandals so vibrant in Paris, frequently appeared with her husband
at formal entertainments. On several occasions she offered the governess a
seat in her box at the Opera; paragraphs in the newspapers became less
frequent and gossiping tongues wagged more slowly, and finally, with disgust,
fell silent; M. du Boccage had been saved by the tact of his father-in-law,
by the generosity of his wife. It was impossible to say either openly or
secretly that the pale young woman who, bearing herself with dignified
respect, sat behind the Duchess in her box at the Opera, at the Hippodrome,
who shared her carriage with her in the Bois, who continued to take charge of
her children, who frequently led them to the old Maréchal Frediani's
establishment, was the mistress of her husband.
In a few weeks talk had died away and things were as they had been in the
Faubourg St. Honoré. It was then that the Maréchal Frediani, with his
daughter's assistance, prepared an ultimatum for the Duke, who, during all
this cautiously arranged intrigue, had given no indication of what he thought
Mademoiselle Debelleyme was not deceived by the false calm
which had descended on the household in the Faubourg St. Honoré, nor by the
compliments that passed between herself and Madame du Boccage, nor even by
the seats in the carriage and at the Opera.
She understood perfectly the intentions of M. Frediani to get rid of her
quietly when the gossip died away. She waited, tenacious, resolute and
patient, but she saw, with a certain ironic tenderness, that M. du Boccage,
at least, thought that he had triumphed over his wife and father-in-law, for
he began to plan other journeys to England, to Italy, with his eldest
children and the governess for company.
From these pleasant prospects a sharp interview with M. Frediani brusquely
awakened him; the Maréchal demanded in plain terms when this folly was to
come to an end and the blonde governess to be sent about her business?
The Duke received these sudden reproofs in a silence that the older man
perceived was both amazed and bitter. The Maréchal stressed his point.
"This has been going on for two years; the press of Paris has taken care
to inform the whole world that you are the subject of all manner of
The Duke, in a low voice, threw in one of his banal phrases:
"Vulgar scandal matters nothing to me."
"Your daughters, your children, are they to be sacrificed?"
"They know nothing, they are children."
M. du Boccage had met his father-in-law in the salon de reception where he
had first seen Lucille Debelleyme, and as he spoke he stood in the corner
between the mirror and the alabaster statue of Cupid stringing his bow. He
was nearly as pale as the white figure, and his face, still mechanically
smiling, had something of the same sinister expression.
Exasperated, for he believed that he had behaved in this irritating affair
with the greatest tolerance and generosity, the Maréchal exclaimed:
"What, plainly, do you hope to do?"
"To keep Mademoiselle Debelleyme in my employment until my children no
longer require a governess."
"And do you also intend to persuade everybody that there is nothing
unusual in this resolution? Do you hope to travel over England, Italy and
France with your daughters and their governess without their mother and
expect that you will not start the most provoking slanders?"
"Have you," asked the Duke in a low, harsh voice, "been one of those who
have helped spread these same slanders and endeavoured to destroy the
character of Mademoiselle Debelleyme?"
"No," replied the haughty old man flushing with deep anger, "I have been
too complacent, I have played the odious part of pretending not to know what
was going on under my nose. I have never spoken to anyone. I even received
her in my house in Corsica, for I believed that must be the end of it, that
when you returned to Paris she would leave."
"Why should she leave?" asked the Duke; his smile stretched to a grimace
as he fixed his dark eyes, glittering under the thick, fair lashes, steadily
on his father-in-law.
"You are blinded by a fatal passion to ask such a question."
"Ah, you, like all the others, believe she is my mistress."
"It is difficult to believe anything else."
"If it is any satisfaction to you I can assure you that she is not. I put
it to you in confidence. Monsieur Le Maréchal, whether in Corsica you saw
anything wrong? You know you did not and that Mademoiselle Debelleyme is a
young woman of unblemished reputation."
The old man was profoundly irritated by these words, which were spoken
with a tone of barely controlled fury, the more so as he was indeed baffled
as to what was the precise relationship between his son-in-law and the
"If I had observed anything," he replied, coldly, "I should have had to
interfere. But what does that matter?" he added with exasperated impatience.
"You know well enough how the thing looks to the world."
"And care nothing," said the Duke, advancing a step towards his
father-in-law. "This young woman suits me. I admire her management of my
household, since she has been with me I have had more peace than ever in my
life before. I intend that she will remain."
The Maréchal endeavoured to control his rage and despair; he felt he was
dealing with a character that he could neither understand nor manage, with a
stranger too, yet he had loved his son-in-law whom he had hitherto always
found agreeable, amiable and docile.
"It is like a bewitchment," he muttered. Then aloud, collecting all his
forces: "Listen, Camille, I do not wish to think evil, I do not wish to cause
trouble, but this woman must go. With all dignity, with all respect. She had
better be sent to England, I will undertake to pay her a pension for life, if
you will, give her what she wants—whatever she demands."
The Duke's curious smile deepened.
"It is not a question of money, she suits me, that is all."
"You are the only one in the household whom she does suit. Everyone is
against her, the servants loathe her—"
"Ah, the servants," the Duke's sneer was deadly, "the servants whom Fanny
has trained to spy on me!"
"If Fanny has spied on you no doubt you have given her good cause for
suspicion, but, my dear Camille, your domestic affairs are not my concern. I
know I cannot assure my daughter's happiness by any interference of that
nature. Have a dozen mistresses, if you will, but do not put them in charge
of your house and your children."
Drawing himself up, the formidable old man, moved by profound emotion,
added: "If you do not give way, I must take strong measures. I shall refuse
to receive you in my house and refuse to see that woman if she brings the
children to see me. You will not then be able to avoid a tremendous scandal.
Remember that I have behind me the whole of public opinion. If you wish, I
will see drawn up to-morrow a separation between you and Fanny. You may
choose then, Camille, between your wife and this woman."
The Duke turned away quickly to hide his face, but his father-in-law saw
it reflected in the glass; it was contorted and sweat drops had gathered
underneath the pale, stiff hair. He was opening and closing his powerful
hands and his wide shoulders shook.
"You are beside yourself. I have regarded you with great affection and I
am still fond of you, Camille," said the Maréchal, picking up his gloves and
cane. "This passion, this infatuation, whatever it may be, I confess I do not
understand; but I understand very well what I must do, and I will not retract
a word of what I have said."
Pulling out his handkerchief and wiping his face, still without turning,
the Duke muttered:
"We are going almost immediately to Javiaux du Boccage. Cannot this
question remain until we return? Perhaps when I am out of Paris these rumours
will peter out."
"If you take Mademoiselle Debelleyme with you to the country that is not
likely, nor can I permit this delay; my daughter will refuse to accompany you
unless the dismissal of the governess is settled before you go."
This was a declaration of war. The Duke was no longer dealing with an
overwrought, hysterical woman. Here was something more formidable to face
than the frantic letters, jealous cries and entreating tears of poor
He said nothing but stood with his back to the Maréchal and continued to
wipe his face, holding the handkerchief so that even in the mirror his
expression could not be seen.
"You have heard, Camille, you have understood?"
Receiving no reply, the old soldier, profoundly depressed, left the
Faubourg St. Honoré.
Madame du Boccage, under the guidance of her father, wrote
her husband a letter that was quite different from those romantic,
sentimental, heartbroken outpourings which lay in the drawer of the green
In it she told him with calm dignity that she insisted on the departure of
the governess, that she wished to undertake the education of her own
daughters until they were old enough to be married, that the boys should
remain at the College Bourbon with a tutor, and that she would refuse to
depart for Javiaux du Boccage until the governess had left the Faubourg St.
'My father has offered to Mademoiselle Debelleyme a yearly pension. In
returning with these means to England, her talents and her introductions will
procure her a good position. There need be no scene. Her withdrawal will be
assured in an honourable manner by a pension from my father guaranteed by
myself and her departure to England which will explain in a favourable manner
her sudden leaving of our family. If Mademoiselle Debelleyme makes the excuse
that she must go to Javiaux du Boccage to fetch some of her property that she
has there, then I will wait in Paris until she returns. I believe I have
shown already sufficient complaissance to save your reputation before the
eyes of Paris.'
The Duchess sent this letter to her husband in the morning; during the day
she did not see him, she believed he was closeted with the governess. This
did not give her the torment it would have formerly done for now she was
convinced that he must give way and Mademoiselle Debelleyme leave. Yet she
shrank from the thought of her triumph as she had formerly shrunk from the
thought of her defeat.
Towards the evening her husband softly entered her apartment; it was so
long since he had come to see her that the very sight of him in her own room
seemed unnatural. Not finding her in her boudoir he had come into her bedroom
where she was sitting languidly by the window, having pulled aside the heavy
damask curtains. It was becoming oppressively hot in Paris; the trees on
which Fanny du Boccage gazed were dry and scorched.
She turned and looked at the man she had once so passionately loved with
the only emotion which she now ever regarded him, that of fear.
He appeared sullen, unnaturally quiet; she waited for him to speak.
"We go to Javiaux du Boccage to-morrow," he announced.
Clasping her hands, whispering a prayer, Fanny du Boccage forced the
courage to say:
"Have you not read my letter? I cannot leave for Javiaux du Boccage."
As he came towards her she turned away, his look made her shrink against
the heavy folds of the damask.
"Do you persist, then," he said in a low voice, "in your attacks against
me? Ah, by this act you have spoilt all your life, take care!"
She rose, holding on to the curtains. Ruined by ill-health and devastating
emotion as she was, heavy in her figure and slow in her movements, yet she
was not without dignity or some remains of her once warm, seductive beauty,
which had often enough brought him to his knees with passion.
"You make a party against me," he whispered, "you set the priests, the
Royal Family, the public, I know not who, the servants against me, even the
children—you try to corrupt their souls, you inspire them with hatred
of their father."
"These are ignoble words!" cried Fanny du Boccage wildly. "Camille, what
has happened to you? You used to be so good, so tender, so kind! This woman
... ah... "
"Seek further back than that," he interrupted, "she has had nothing to do
with it; hold her blameless, please!"
"Ah, you are so ready to defend her!" With a cry that was one of as much
bewilderment as of despair, Madame du Boccage exclaimed: "Who is this woman,
what is she?"
He did not reply but continued to walk up and down the chamber, trying,
she thought, to ease his profound irritation with those quick, almost
stealthy movements. He paused by the bed where she saw him glance up at the
heavy baldaquin from which hung the curtains of Brussels net supported by
She believed that in the tumult of his thoughts he did not know what he
was doing, what he was gazing at; his face had a blank expression, yet there
was something so menacing in the whole tense attitude of the man that she
sickened with fright and began to mumble a promise that she would go to
Javiaux du Boccage, would try to live in the same house with the
After all, there was no more that she could suffer; she had endured the
last pangs of neglect and jealousy; why not go on and face the martyrdom to
But as she had no hope of ever recovering his affection, much less his
love, her pride, her father, her confessor's advice, the real interests of
her children, inspired her with strength; she caught back her stammering
avowal of weakness and was silent.
When at length he left what seemed his blind contemplation of the bed and
turned towards her, demanding in a harsh voice: "Will you come to Javiaux du
Boccage with Mademoiselle Debelleyme?" she, though clinging to the silk cords
of the curtains to give her support, answered: "No."
She thought that he was advancing on her to strike her; he gave her again
that peculiar smile which for so many years she had found so lovable but
which of late had seemed to her terrible, as if it was caused by a string
being pulled at the back of a mask.
"Well, we shall see." His voice was a low whisper as if he could command
For the first time Fanny du Boccage saw with pleasure her husband leave
her; she had cowered before him.
That lonely, hot night she wrote in the diary that had become her sole
relief: "It is true, as my father, as all say, that I have rendered him a
real service but—he will never pardon me. He will revenge on me day by
day, hour by hour, minute by minute this service I have done him. He will be
revenged on me for being right when he was wrong. The abyss opens every day
more profoundly between us. The more he reflects the more he will feel
himself guilty and the heavier will be his vengeance on me. The future
frightens me, I tremble in thinking of it, I feel myself so alone. My God,
come to my aid, give me the strength for these new trials, if it is Your
wish, grant the greatest mercies possible for my children, for him, the
unhappy man, who suffers, I can see that! He feels his position! My God, have
pity on my poor children, left alone without advice in the middle of these
agitations, these furies! And their father, my God, do not abandon him, make
the light enter into his spirit, open Thy arms for his repentance, fortify
him, sustain him, see that he does not fall! Alas, my God, he is blind and
knows not what he does."
Lucille Debelleyme continued her calm way, performed her
duties with her usual radiant gaiety towards the children, her respectful
behaviour towards Madame du Boccage, her tactful courtesy towards the
servants. She knew that she was the centre of what the Duchess had called
"these agitations and these furies." She knew that the servants hated her and
spied on her. She knew the Maréchal worked to remove her. She maintained her
calm trust in M. du Boccage—she saw very little of him, his visits were
now brief, even his conversations, his diversions with his children were
distracted. Using a natural patience and a powerful tenacity she did not try
to force his confidence, she never asked him what he was about to do nor what
her fate was to be, she waited for a signal for them all to go to Javiaux du
Boccage. She believed she was sure of him, a look, a word, a pressure of the
hand were enough—she believed in his loyalty, his pride; despite the
great forces against him she was confident he would not give way.
An unexpected visit from an unsuspected enemy, the Abbé Galle, the
confessor of Madame du Boccage, and in this case the emissary of the Maréchal
Frediani, disagreeably roused the governess from her sense of security.
Courteous, cool, but obviously hostile and formidable, the priest remained
standing in Lucille Debelleyme's gay little boudoir which he had never
entered before. She stood leaning carelessly with an air of respectful
insolence against the muslin lace curtains, her delicate figure, her
melancholy face, resplendent in the powerful sun of July; the Abbé, with an
air of authority which she found peculiarly galling, came at once to his
"Mademoiselle, I beg you to reflect seriously on the troubles your
presence is causing in this house. No one dares to speak to you face to face;
I have thought therefore that it is my duty to show you the disaster towards
which you push an illustrious family. If you insist on staying here, it will
be impossible to avoid a great scandal. This scandal will follow you all your
life—do not persist in your resistance. Madame la Duchesse demands your
departure, you cannot refuse it."
With an air of candid astonishment the smiling governess replied:
"Madame the Duchess demands my departure? My relations with her are
excellent, it is not long since that we exchanged presents and complimentary
letters—what has she to complain of in my behaviour? And if she has
these complaints why does she not bring them to me herself. Monsieur
The priest looked at her with a grave glance that stripped aside all her
"Madame la Duchesse has not any particular grievance against you,
Mademoiselle. She intends, on the advice of her father, the Maréchal, to
rearrange her establishment, she will herself take care of her daughters, the
education of her son is provided for elsewhere. There is no longer any reason
for your presence in this house."
"I am astonished," replied Mademoiselle Debelleyme coldly. "What has
occurred, Monsieur l'Abbé, to bring about this sudden resolution on the part
of the Maréchal and Madame du Boccage? Forgive me if I know nothing, I live
enclosed here with the children, performing my duties."
The Abbé smiled and there was something in that smile, at once
compassionate, understanding and sadly disdainful that brought a faint colour
to the pale cheeks of the governess. "You are very clever. Mademoiselle
Debelleyme; a young lady of your talent will never lack a post. I believe you
are also clever enough to have understood me perfectly and to act on my
Lucille Debelleyme was silent; her attitude remained completely
self-assured, but in her heart was a little growing chill of fear.
"And Monsieur le Duc?" she asked after a pause.
"He has nothing to do with the affair, the decision remains with Madame
and her father."
He turned to leave; at the door he turned and looking again sadly at the
slender figure of the graceful young woman, he added:
"Remember, Mademoiselle, it is not words nor even actions that count
before God, but the intentions of the heart."
"It is such banalities, Monsieur l'Abbé, that disgust the intelligent with
When M. du Boccage came to see his children that evening,
Lucille Debelleyme, without comment, repeated to him her interview with the
The Duke sat down by the pianette and began savagely turning over pages of
the music which she had been copying for his daughters.
"This scandal the Abbé spoke of," he said, "can be nothing but a legal
separation; you see, they force things to the extreme."
And then the governess, breaking her long silence, asked quietly:
"What do you intend to do?"
For reply he muttered another question:
"Do you expect anything of me?"
"No," she said, coolly, "nothing whatever. You owe me nothing. I have
always been your paid dependant, generously treated."
And approaching the other side of the little musical instrument, turning
on his downcast face her full brilliant glance, she added, with a flash of
feeling in her voice:
"It is curious to think, is it not, Monsieur le Duc, that you and I are
the only two people who know the truth of all this? The entire world thinks
we are lovers."
"Yes," he whispered. He looked up at her; a sense of perfect intimacy, of
complete understanding passed between them, "she has cornered me as if I was
a tracked beast with the entire hunt out after me. All of them, in hue and
cry at my heels! Her servants, her priests, her father!" He clenched the
frail music sheets in his hands and flung them down. "I am to lose
everything, my position, the children, the money... She will have no mercy,
and why? Because I could not continue to be her lover, because I relegated
the duties she was incapable of to one who could undertake them. For that I
am to be ruined."
"No, I will leave."
"You will leave? Do you think that the better way?"
"I think it is the only way, but I will accept no pension from M.
Frediani, and I will not go to England."
"What will you do, then? Where will you go?"
She hesitated, it was in her mind to bring forward her imaginary suitor,
to talk of saving herself by a miserable marriage, but she decided, on
reflection, that this would be unwise. He had had as much as he could endure
and though she by no means intended to lose any hold on him, she thought that
her interests were now best served by conceding all.
"We have done no wrong," she said quietly, "even the Maréchal and the Abbé
had to admit that. They spoke to me with respect. I shall leave with complete
dignity. If you. Monsieur, if the children wish to continue any friendship
with me you know where I am."
"I will find a way yet. I will prove to you what this has meant to me. Yes
... yes... " he added, distracted, "it is better that you should give way
than subject yourself to these daily affronts—these scenes with Madame
du Boccage—I cannot endure them—the house is hell."
"It has always been," said Mademoiselle Debelleyme with bitter
tranquillity. "I stayed for your sake. Monsieur, and for that of the
children. Believe me, it has not been very pleasant for me—the
servants, inspired by Madame du Boccage, hate me; I am, as you say, daily
affronted. I have even been—with the Abbé to-day—threatened with
a scandal that will remain with me all my life. Why should I endure
As if he had not heard what she said he whispered:
"I cannot think what it will be like without you. You were my only
friend." He rose and made half-blindly for the door, murmuring, "they'd
better take care—they'd letter take care," then paused and looked back
at Lucille Debelleyme.
She returned his gaze steadily, passionately; she was furiously
disappointed that he had abandoned her to her enemies, but she understood
with perfect sympathy his position. She did not blame him at all, she valued,
in that moment, the man himself as she had never valued him before.
Nor did she intend that this should be the end of their strange,
exasperating relationship; when she conceded the most she meant to cling the
most tenaciously, and now that she was forced to leave she intended to give
her departure some drama.
"It is right that I should make this sacrifice. Be assured, Monsieur, that
I shall not add to your troubles."
"Are we, then, to admit defeat? To accept commands forced on us?"
"We are, at least, to appear to do so." At that he made a step towards
her, but her quick gesture, her quick words held him off. "No! Every moment
that you spend with me is counted. Spare me what ignominy you can."
He left her and she sat down at once and wrote to Madame du Boccage,
excusing herself from a personal interview by saying that she was too
'Madame la Duchesse, I wished to express to you myself the sentiments that
animate me but I feel that in the present circumstances it would be a task
beyond my power. Permit me to defer to a more calm and happy time the thanks
which I wish to address to you for the generosity with which you have
rewarded my feeble services. In this moment of leaving the children, towards
whom I have always felt the liveliest tenderness, I find, in witnessing your
satisfaction, a powerful consolation. I accept with gratitude the offers of
recommendation that you say you will give me and I shall hasten to avail
myself of them sometime when they may be useful to me. At present the health
of my grandfather, very doubtful for several months, makes it a duty for me
to go to him at once. I beg your permission to delay till a later date the
account of all the various expenses, etc., which I must make to you, and I
beg you, Madame, to believe in the assurance, of my most profound
When she had written this letter and sent it by the nurse to the
apartments of the Duchess, Lucille Debelleyme paused and, locking herself
into her room, faced her defeat as if it was a tangible object blocking her
The other woman had won the battle, always an unequal, dangerous one for
Lucille Debelleyme, penniless, without friends or resources, a servant. She
must go, she would be no better off than she had been two years before when
she had entered the Faubourg St. Honoré. All the delights, the luxuries, the
pleasures of the Du Boccage establishment would now be lost. She would have
to face frightful humiliation in this sudden departure, the gratified sneers
of the servants—and then the children—she was really fond of the
children, his children. She allowed herself no emotional breakdown, but set
her teeth and began to plan for the future, trampling down her defeat,
motioning it aside.
Madame du Boccage replied, with that air of candid dignity that came
naturally to her, to the letter in which the governess, in a tone so coldly
formal, confessed that she had lost the battle and that her resignation had
been wrung from her. Without touching on the painful circumstances of the
case the Duchess thanked Mademoiselle Debelleyme for her care of the children
and promised to take every occasion to be useful to one who was so diligent,
so good and so faithful an instructress. She offered several letters of
introduction to English ladies. Lady Hislop, Lady Tankerville, Miss Elkinson,
and even promised to send to the French Ambassadress in London a letter
declaring that Mademoiselle Debelleyme's conduct had given every satisfaction
during the period of her stay in the Faubourg St. Honoré, and thanking her
for recommending to her this excellent young lady.
Madame du Boccage further added to her generosity by sending with the note
a book which Mademoiselle Debelleyme had once admired at Locroi. It was an
English work entitled Amateur Gardening for Gentlewomen and was
decorated with many beautiful hand-coloured plates.
Lucille Debelleyme read the letter but did not open the
book; the recommendations were useless to her, she did not intend to go to
England, and she had, for at least the present, lost her interest in amateur
If Madame du Boccage had accepted her victory with gracious dignity, she
did not however intend to forego any of the fruits of it; when she perceived
that her husband, in order to put off the day of the governess' departure,
now delayed the journey to Javiaux du Boccage she declared that she would
remain in her own apartments till the governess had left the house.
The Duke begged her to at least share her meals with the governess as
before; she replied she would feel too embarrassed sitting at table with one
who was under dismissal, but when by chance she passed the governess on the
stairs Madame Du Boccage greeted with the most serene kindness the woman who
had wrought such bitter havoc in her life.
It was not as easy for Lucille Debelleyme to leave the Faubourg St. Honoré
as she had thought it might be; her strength was not as great as she had
believed. These last days were full of an extreme nervous tension, with the
servants all looking at her with scarcely concealed triumph, avoiding her
when they could, the children depressed and tearful, Maréchal de Frediani,
all the members of the House of Montlosier du Boccage keeping away from the
Faubourg St. Honoré till she left it. Her one friend, the Duke, defeated like
herself, unable to offer her any hope, any suggestion, any succour for the
future, Lucille Debelleyme felt her spirits sink, but she kept her control;
repeatedly she said to herself, "go quietly, no scenes, he has had enough of
But when the last moment came and she had packed all her belongings (they
amounted now to a good deal more than the one poor trunk she had entered the
family with) when she had shut up the pianette, drawn the cover over the
harp, watered her flowers for the last time, she felt such a sense of loss,
that it was difficult for her not to do what the woman whom she so despised
did—break down, cry and scream.
With her bonnet and cloak already on, her hands neatly gloved, folded in
her lap, she was sitting in her favourite chair of pale brocade when the Duke
brusquely entered her apartment. She knew that during these last few days his
life had been as painful as her own—he had put up with daily scenes
with his wife, strong criticism from her father, her relatives, the Church.
An expression of sharp suffering had erased all youth from his face. He began
to talk confusedly with his usual banal and clumsy phrases.
Lucille Debelleyme pitied him profoundly, it was like seeing a dumb
creature in agony that could not express its pain. He muttered expressions of
rage about the rumours spread against him, against the Maréchal, the Abbé,
his wife, regrets he could not take Lucille Debelleyme with him to Javiaux du
Boccage, and mingled with all this he promised to pay her fifteen hundred
francs yearly in recognition of her services whether or not she found another
Lucille watched him being torn by a terrible inarticulate passion. She
remembered that whisper in Corsica; "Is this love or something more?"
She had a sudden, bleak realisation that in this long, patient game she
had played she had staked and lost more than she knew; M. du Boccage, she
knew now, was more to her than the wealthy aristocrat who could give her all
her heart's desire in the way of luxury and pleasure, power and pride, more
than the friend who understood her, who supported her, more than the only
champion she had ever known; he was the man she loved. She began to sob
quietly, like a child, into her little gloved hand, not troubling even to
find a handkerchief.
He made a little moaning sound and was with her and had her in his arms.
That was a moment of pure delight for Lucille Debelleyme; what ease in his
warmth, his contact, what relief to feel his body through his fine clothes;
the very sensation of the cloth of his coat against her cheek, the perfume
that he used was delicious. This was what she had been afraid
of—realising how much he meant to her, and not being able to go on; she
desperately pushed him away with a gesture that seemed of anger, but it was
too late, Matilde, the maid had cautiously opened the door and seen them in
each other's arms.
"Madame du Boccage would like to speak to Monsieur le Duc."
Her face was sullen with malice; Lucille Debelleyme stared at her directly
and uttered the first and last word of defiance she used during her stay in
the Faubourg St. Honoré:
"Monsieur le Duc is here, go and tell your mistress where and how you find
He had recoiled, at the entrance of the servant, but only a step; he
continued to gaze at Lucille Debelleyme from under his thick, pale lashes,
and she thought with a wild triumph:
"Surely if that moment meant half as much to him as it did to me he will
find me, he will see me again."
In half an hour she was in her hired carriage and had left the Faubourg
St. Honoré and through the sunny, dusty streets of Paris, Lucille Debelleyme
drove to St. Cloud.
No longer would a neglected wife have to sit lonely in her
splendid apartments knowing that Lucille Debelleyme was entertaining her
husband in the rooms above. No longer would she, tortured by insomnia, by
jealousy, by mental and physical agony be forced to herself descend to
espionage and wander miserably up and down the stairs, in and out the
corridors, seeking to discover the whereabouts of her husband, of her
governess, no longer need she risk an outburst of rage by knocking timidly at
his door. She would not do that again; the last time he had frightened
her—he had taken her by the shoulders and pushed her across the
corridor from his own rooms to hers, in her presence smashed an enamel vase
and ripped a lace shawl that she had flung over a chair; the fury of a spoilt
child, or the savagery of a man desperately roused? Madame du Boccage did not
know; but she was frightened, he was so changed. She had always, until these
last few years, thought of him as indolent, sweet-tempered, easily led
Well, she had triumphed, there would be peace now in the Faubourg St.
Honoré; but as she sat lonely as ever that evening, she could not feel that
the departure of the governess had lifted any load from her heart. The words
her husband had spoken to her still rung in her ears: "You will not go with
her to Javiaux du Boccage?—you have spoilt all your life, so, you will
not go—we shall see!"
With her eyes and head aching Fanny du Boccage wrote the last lines in her
diary, she would write no more. What more would there be to say? She believed
that everything was finished between herself and her husband, between herself
and Lucille Debelleyme.
She had no hope for the future as she wrote: "He is always unpleasant to
me now, he feels too keenly the extent of his wrongdoing, his malice, and
will not understand that I can pardon and forget. My merit in that is not so
great as he believed, I could not help being jealous where I love and I can
forgive easily. How will all this finish?—I cannot believe in
For a moment Fanny du Boccage could write no more, her great sorrow
weighed her down. She could scarcely yet realise that it was all over, that
the man she loved and for whose love she had fought was lost and perhaps her
children lost too; all day they had been crying for the governess... she had
forced him to choose between herself and Lucille Debelleyme—he had let
the other woman go but he had not returned to her...
Madame du Boccage, sincerely pious, turned to her usual refuge and
concluded her diary by a prayer: "my God, my God, sustain me, direct me. I am
afraid of the future, of his threats, of the difficulties which arise every
day. If You will be there, in You I have confidence. You will sustain the
poor mother to whom You have given the desire to protect her
She put her diary in a packet with some other papers and sealed this with
a black seal and wrote on the cover. "To be given to my husband after my
As she did this she felt a shudder of fear, as if she was condemned to
die; so strong was this presentiment that she began to think about her
health, she had been very ill of late, it was quite possible she had not long
to live. She went through her other papers and sealed them also with the
Monsieur Desire Gavaudan de Clery received his granddaughter with bitter
contempt. She had no sooner entered his meagre apartment than he began to
assail her with mocking reproaches.
"So in your splendour and grandeur you remembered your poor old
grandfather! Have you come to take me promenading in the Bois in Monsieur du
Boccage's carriage? I suppose you have at least a magnificent equipage at the
door? Ah, your gown is very fine though I expected to see something even more
splendid, does he not then give you presents, do you not run up accounts in
Lucille Debelleyme had been prepared for these insults and took no
"I have left the Faubourg St. Honoré," she said, leaning against the table
for support, "and I must beg you to take me in, for the sake of appearances,
for the sake of my dignity."
"Appearances and dignity!" he sneered, "you have had little regard for
either these last couple of years! Why have you come to me whom you have
ignored when you had a few sous to spend? Why doesn't Monsieur du Boccage do
something for you?"
"I have had," said Lucille, steadily keeping to the point, "to give your
name, to say I was coming to stay with you, that was my excuse for leaving,
you must take me in."
"Must, indeed! I will not. Did I not warn you?"
"I regret nothing." Lucille defied him with a pale smile. "I am asking you
for a little help, you are my grandfather, my only relative—are you
going to refuse me?"
He looked her up and down with cold and malicious contempt.
"You must be a fool as well as a hussy."
Without losing patience and with a coldness equal to his own, his
"It is you are the fool, Grandfather; I suppose you have listened to the
stories current in Paris? Well, they are all lies—believe me or not as
you like. Monsieur du Boccage is not my lover."
"Then, my girl, you have played your cards very badly. You've created a
scandal, lost your place and gained nothing out of it! Be gone, I will not be
involved in your affairs."
"You must have money," she insisted, standing her ground with quiet
desperation. "Give me some, enough to start a little school for girls on my
own. I cannot go back to being a servant. Enough perhaps to marry—with
a small dowry I could find a husband."
This mention of money turned the old man's malice to fury.
"Life is impossible in Paris for you. Why do you want to stay, you
imbecile? Go away anywhere—Russia—England—Italy—I
care not. I have nothing to give you, you must rely on what you can make
yourself. After all," he added with a sneer, "you have done pretty well so
far. You may find someone else who will give you a fine carriage to ride
His granddaughter gave him a long look and gazed round the mean, squalid
"What am I going to do? I have had to leave suddenly, I have had no chance
to make preparations."
At that the old man, muttering sullenly to himself, took a piece of paper
from his pocket and wrote on it a name and address: 'Madame Flamme, 9, Rue du
Harlay.' "You may go there. She knows me, she will take you in for a night or
two. That is more than many people in Paris would just now, I think, and if
you have any sense left at all you will leave the country as quickly as
With that he turned his back on her. She, without a word, left him, went
out to the waiting cab which was still piled with her luggage, and asked the
driver to go to Number 9, Rue du Harlay.
The Hotel du Boccage was closed, the family and the servants
had gone to Javiaux du Boccage, only the concierge remained in charge.
Lucille Debelleyme walked in front of the high gates, above which waved
the pleasant summer trees, gates which were now locked and closed to her, as
it seemed, for ever. But she still resisted the demand of her enemies, she
would not, however bribed by pensions or recommendations, go to England. By
diligence, by tenacity, by accepting a miserable weekly sum she had secured a
position in a small school for girls, which was situated in the same Rue du
Harlay where she had found refuge with Madame Flamme. This pretentious but
meagre enterprise, run for the benefit of the better class tradespeople who
wished to ape gentility, was run by a Madame Trou, a Swiss woman who, it
seemed, had passed by the scandals of Paris which had so brushed the bloom
off the fair fame of Lucille Debelleyme. At least she appeared satisfied by
the governess' excellent English testimonials and by the last letter written
by Madame du Boccage. She accepted her brilliant services in return for a
small remuneration and a miserable room looking out at the back of the house
on to a small enclosed courtyard.
The governess faced all these disadvantages with a smile. She was, at
least, entrenched in Paris. The humiliations of her position, the poverty of
her surroundings, were detestable, especially after two years of luxury, but
they were also effective. She stood out as a poor young creature earning her
living under difficulties, earning an honest and an honourable living. She
had preserved, even in this vicissitude, even in spite of her grandfather's
repudiation, her implacable decorum. The establishment of Madame Trou was of
the utmost respectability.
Her refusal of the benefits offered her by the Maréchal de Frediani and by
Madame du Boccage was not, she knew, without an impressive dignity. She had
lost all—she had been ruthlessly sacrificed to the unfounded jealousy
of a sick, stupid woman; she must surely, in the eyes of many, cut the figure
of a martyr...
Madame Trou's establishment was partially closed for the holidays, there
only remained a few girls whose parents were abroad and who had no friends to
offer them holidays. It was Mademoiselle Debelleyme's duty during her first
weeks in the Rue du Harlay to give a few lessons in music, needlework and
painting to these poor neglected creatures, and occasionally to take them out
in the public parks and places of instruction—the Botanical Gardens,
the Museums of the Louvre.
She performed these duties conscientiously, but without her usual gaiety.
Indeed, as the days went on she found it very difficult to sustain the part
she had undertaken, to walk on foot or ride in an omnibus when she had ridden
in a carriage, to sleep in a small, dingy room, to eat coarse, greasy,
unappetising food, to have the company of these stupid, plain, provincial
girls, the dull, pedantic Madame Trou, after that intoxicating intimacy with
a man like Camille du Boccage, after the affection she had enjoyed from his
Her mind wandered to the glories of Javiaux du Boccage that her rival was
enjoying, and the thought of that magnificent place which she had so admired
was almost intolerable to the governess, languishing in the stale squalor of
the narrow city streets. She began to be assailed, soul and body, by a
longing for the master of all that magnificence. She repeated to herself the
words murmured on that moonlit shore in Corsica: 'Is this love or something
Clever as she was, firm as was the grip she had on herself, she had
scarcely realised how she would miss him, how precious to her had been that
one friend—that one protector, that potential lover. There was not a
sign from him, but the two eldest children wrote charming little letters full
of affection, and she replied eagerly, passionately, making no secret of her
Writing to the eldest girl, Isabelle, who was of an age, the governess
affected to believe, to understand, she dwelt on her misery, on her despair,
the wretched post she was forced to take, the unpleasantness of Paris in the
great heat of the summer, the effect on her own health, her homesickness, her
yearning for Javiaux du Boccage, and at the end of the letter added that she
intended to change her life by a marriage that would be in a way a sort of
suicide but which, she declared, she offered as a final sacrifice to the
conventions, to clear her name for the sake of her dear charges whose peace
she had outraged so unwittingly, by impulsive indiscretion.
She knew that the little Isabelle would not be able to understand these
lines, she knew also that she would take them not to her mother but to her
It was the Duke who replied to this letter; in a few curt phrases he asked
after her health, said he lacked her company at Javiaux du Boccage but that
the work of restoration was proceeding very well. He demanded to know what
was this marriage project, was it that she had mentioned to him before? He
begged her to wait till his return to Paris when he hoped to be able to
arrange something more satisfactory for the future.
This was not much in the way of a love letter, nor even of a letter from a
friend, but Lucille Debelleyme knew the man with whom she dealt, she was
satisfied. She wrote to him in reply, she dwelt on her sufferings, on her
miseries, she emphasised the marriage, this sacrifice, this kind of suicide
she was making to stop all slander, to regain the honourable place in the
world which she feared she had lost. She reiterated that only he and she knew
their mutual innocence, she poured scorn on their slanderers, she dwelt with
regret on the beauties of Javiaux du Boccage and contrasted it with the
squalid surroundings she was forced to endure.
He responded by platitudes but she believed that she could read under the
dry words the throb of passion and she replied again in language that never
infringed decorum (for she always had it in mind that his wife or some spy
might see the letters) but yet in a language that must speak to even the most
stupid of men in an unmistakable tone of adoration.
She would marry or not marry as he directed, he was he one friend, her
generous protector, her future lay in his hands....
This correspondence was Lucille Debelleyme's last weapon, she did not mean
to lose it or misuse it; remembering the hysterical letters of Madame du
Boccage, which she was sure had never been read by her husband, she wrote
briefly and to the point, yet never coldly, nor did she need to employ any
art, duplicity or hypocrisy in this correspondence which had become the sole
interest of her impoverished life. Seated in her cramped, dingy room, looking
out on the dirty courtyard, again dressed as she had been in Belgrave Square
(she did not dare show in the Rue du Harlay the gowns she had flaunted so
prettily in the Faubourg St. Honoré) Lucille Debelleyme realised that she had
no object in her life beyond that of renewing this enchanting friendship, of
making it, at any cost, more than a friendship.
M. du Boccage was absorbed in the restoration of Javiaux du
Boccage; his wife was completely estranged from him. She had got rid of the
presence but not the influence of Lucille Debelleyme. It was the same with
her children, they avoided her, were sullen and petulant in her presence, all
her arts could not win them. They openly lamented the absence of the beloved
governess. "If only Mademoiselle were here." "We used to do so and so with
Mademoiselle." "mademoiselle did it like that." "mademoiselle used to make it
so amusing." And she had surprised out of them the confession that the
governess wrote to them and they wrote to her.
"And to him also, I suppose," she thought. "How can life go on like this?
I shall never separate them—never."
The Maréchal de Frediani, believing he had very comfortably settled a
painful affair, had returned to Corsica and the Duchess had, in the isolation
of the country, no friend beyond Matilde. She resorted to reproaches, she
accused her children to their faces of disloyalty in preferring the governess
to herself; she frightened and repelled them by tears and scenes. They fled
from her to the company of their nurses, when they heard her step on the
stairs they would shut themselves in their room and refuse to answer when she
knocked on the door.
The Duke, without comment on this chaos, sent the boys to Locroi with a
tutor and ordered the nurses to keep the other children away from their
mother as much as possible.
Dryly, and before several servants, as if he sought their protection, the
Duke informed his wife that he had decided to return to the Faubourg St.
Honoré—the work on the chateau did not require his supervision for the
moment. The Duchess vehemently objected.
"Do you then," he asked, "find it so agreeable here? I wish urgently to
return to Paris."
"To visit, I suppose," she thought, "the Rue du Harlay."
She resolved that the governess must leave Paris, the battle was not then
yet won, there was still another struggle ahead; with an effort the Duchess
braced herself for this. Her father was abroad but she had still her priests,
her lawyers—she would get their advice as to how to dislodge the blonde
governess from the Rue du Harlay.
She was actuated by nobler motives than mere jealousy; she had resigned
herself to the loss of her husband, but she could not resign herself to the
loss of her children who might, she firmly believed, be morally ruined by the
Influence of a woman who was, to Fanny du Boccage, abominable. She had been
told by all her anxious advisers that the only hope of saving her family from
disgrace, ridicule—the worst dishonour—was to break the
connection (whatever it might be) between her husband and Lucille
But, always tactless, and now in her emotional turmoil more than ever
incapable of dealing with so complicated a situation, the Duchess employed no
arts to gain her purpose.
"What! You want to return to Paris, in this heat! What is Paris like in
August? Everyone is away—"
"I might return here presently. The journey is very short. If you wish you
can remain here—with Cesarine and Laure. I will take Isabelle."
"Why?" unable to check her anguish Fanny du Boccage added in a
whisper—"Yes, one of the children, to save your face when you visit the
Rue du Harlay—your own daughter as a screen!"
Affecting not to hear this the Duke replied:
"I want to take Isabelle to the dentist, she has been complaining of
"I could take her—one night in Paris would suffice for that."
"If you wish. But I have affairs to attend to in Paris—there is no
need for you to accompany me—"
"I, too, have affairs," replied Fanny du Boccage with that total lack of
subterfuge that he found so galling. "If you work to keep Lucille Debelleyme
in Paris I must work to see that she leaves."
"You are foolish to torment yourself with these suspicions."
"Camille, pray do not try to deceive me by this miserable strategy! I can
believe nothing that you say. Once you were candour itself, now I detect you
in lie after lie, evasion after evasion—"
"And whose fault is that?" he muttered, turning away, then, harshly, "I am
returning to Paris and I shall take Isabelle."
"I, then, shall accompany you. I do not like this place—this
senseless extravagance, this stupid luxury—no. I cannot be left
here—but neither can I remain in Paris. We will go on to Dieppe."
"Is it possible you wish to return there?"
"Why not?" but she shivered as she recalled the dull pallor of the Villa
Violette, the monotony of that veiled sea. "We will find another house. I
shall not stay in Paris while Lucille Debelleyme is in Paris. Remember,
Camille, I have my friends, my protectors now."
Feeling the lack of air, for the evening was stifling, she hastened out of
the half-furnished apartment and walked slowly up and down the wide white
stone terrace. The massive shape of the ornate building, covered in part by
scaffolding, showed heavy against the luminous sky; the trees were
motionless, no wind stirred the grass. Madame du Boccage, walking heavily,
paced up and down the cracked paving-stones. She rejoiced in the increasing
symptoms of her illness, her shortness of breath, the pain in her side,
giddiness, a dimming of the sight; she hoped she would die soon, surely it
would not take the outraged heart much longer to wear out the failing
Her husband appeared at the long, open, uncurtained window behind her, and
stood for a moment, his hands on the window frame, looking about him at the
red evening sky; the reflection of this glow was on his face and hair
touching his intense pallor. His wife, pausing near him, scrutinised him
He was a stranger and not in the least like the man she had married, yet
always the man she loved. He wore a riding suit, costly, negligent; he had
been directing the workmen who, under the supervision of an architect, were
decorating the chapel, his high boots were covered with white dust and
stained by liquid plaster, there was clay on his hands. He seemed to be at
one with the enormous empty chateau, the sombre uninhabited landscape and on
his handsome face was that blank look which the Duchess had noticed, with an
inexplicable sense of terror, when he had stared at the heavy baldaquin of
her bed in the Faubourg St. Honoré. It was as if, she thought, his spirit was
utterly estranged from all about him; terrified of that immobile stare, she
crossed to the window and asked him in a low voice to give her his arm as she
He did so without a word, she leant on him heavily as he fell in step with
her along the terrace. She was acutely conscious of the difference in their
appearance, he in the full comeliness of his manhood and she, exhausted, worn
in soul and body without either strength or charm.
Suddenly, she said with an utter, a hopeless sincerity, "Camille, is it
too late even now? This misery—it seems as if it cannot be
"Are you not satisfied even yet? What have you to complain of? You have
had your own way. The governess has gone."
"Only her bodily presence, I think, Camille. How harshly you speak! Surely
you know what I mean—it is this estrangement that is killing
"I gave way. I can do no more."
"Camille," she hung heavily on his arm, she gazed up at him earnestly, "it
was for your sake and for that of the children that she had to go—not
for mine. I am so used to unhappiness—but everyone said you were
wrong—that it could not be—"
"Oh, everyone, eh?" she felt his arm tremble under her clasp. "Well, she
has gone and everyone should be satisfied."
He spoke with such cold hostility that she had not the heart to reply; as
they reached the end of the terrace where low steps led to the lawns, he
"Would you not care to see the funeral vaults under the chapel? They have
been working on them to-day."
"No, I should not care to, Camille."
"Why? It is really a superb Gothic design, excellently carried out."
She shook her head; she was aware that she was wrong in showing no
interest in the work which so absorbed him, but she could not bring herself
to play a part, to assume any aspect of happiness.
"You will not come?" he insisted.
He paused; she loosened her arm from his and stood apart from him; she
wore a light muslin dress, the sunset dyed it a pale scarlet.
"Why should I?" she sighed, "in a short while I shall be there for
She spoke with complete sincerity, but these were exactly those words of
melodrama that he most detested.
"As you please," he replied with that ironic coldness she found more hard
to bear than his worst rages, and leaving her standing alone on the great
expanse of the terrace he turned towards the chapel, walking slowly and
looking at his hands from which he pulled fragments of dried plaster.
M. du Boccage called on Mademoiselle Debelleyme at the Rue
du Harlay. The servant, her eyes lively with curiosity, gave his message to
Lucille Debelleyme; descending the narrow stairs she had to pass Madame Trou
whose broad face expressed an hostile curiosity, but the governess slipped
past, keeping her eyes lowered. She was watched and suspected even here.
"What does it matter? He has come! There was, then, behind the banal words
of his letters—something. Friendship? Passion? Interest at least. He
M. du Boccage waited in the parlour reserved for interviewing parents; it
was full of the greasy smell of cooking; he walked up and down impatiently,
his handkerchief to his nostrils, and his two little girls, Isabelle and
Cesarine, danced about with excitement on the worn Empire horse-hair
The embarrassment of this meeting was dispelled by the children's joyous
welcome of their governess; while they clung to her with exclamations of
pleasure and love, she looked over their blonde heads at their father.
He had not said a word beyond some murmur when she had entered but, as
usual, their eyes told each other everything.
Greedily they stared; how necessary they were, one to the other; this
separation (so foolish for their enemies to insist on that) had only shown
them the vital need they had one for the other, and how empty, how impossible
were days spent apart.
After the gloomy, lonely miseries of the Rue du Harlay, the presence of M.
du Boccage seemed, to the governess, to transform the world.
They exchanged a few commonplaces, always looking at each other, while she
spoke to the children the words that she meant him to hear; of her suffering,
of her ill-health (did she not appear pale and thin?), how she missed Javiaux
du Boccage and their company, the dullness, the stupidity, of the people with
whom she was surrounded, of her half thoughts of marriage with an old man she
detested. "I must somehow put an end... "
She broke off, having never taken her vivid glance from his face, she felt
that the man was trembling, overwhelmed, she knew his violent jealousy was
aroused, darkness flickered in his eyes as he stammered out his
Madame Trou knocked at the door, then immediately opened it. Her plain
face was hard and ugly with suspicion; "Would Mademoiselle's visitor detain
her much-longer? One of the pupils wished for her music lesson, the hour was
Lucille Debelleyme was not sorry that the Duke should see this instance of
the tyranny under which she lived; as the door closed on the figure of the
Swiss woman she murmured: "It is killing me to live here." Then with rising
agony not feigned: "I shall die in this disgusting place."
She glanced at the children, making an effort to control herself; how was
she to speak to him alone? What was he going to arrange or to do? She began,
contrary to her nature, to be impatient.
He owed her something, too, for what length of time must she endure this?
Had he no device whereby they could at least have half an hour alone?
The Duke, aroused by the appeal in her brilliant eyes told the children to
go to the carriage and fetch the basket of fruit and flowers that they had
brought up from Javiaux du Boccage for Mademoiselle.
As the little girls ran out and the door closed after them, she turned to
him instantly; she did not trust him, was not sure if he knew how to make the
best of this snatched moment.
"Well?" she demanded, "what are you going to do? I'm trapped and
She approached him, risking the torment of another embrace; there was so
much she must risk.
"What did you mean when you said to me—On the seashore at Corsica,
'is this love or something more?'"
"Yes. But is it in good hands—our mutual fortunes?"
"Oh, Mon Dieu!"
"We are both of us in torment, is there no way out?"
He was silent and she with her whole urgent presence goaded him, harassed
as he was, to think of some device, some expedient; yet, contemptuous as she
usually was towards all hesitations and falterings, she did not blame this
man, for she loved him.
"Can we not meet somewhere?" she whispered, "without the children? You and
I, not as governess and employer—"
"As what then?"
"You must tell me that—as anything you please. This has gone far
enough, has it not?"
"I have always respected you—I would not offer you the least
affront," but his eyes contradicted the words, he had always an air, as she
well knew, of saying what he did not mean, of entrenching himself behind
She replied in a lowered voice for she feared a spy at the door.
"Can you bear it? I cannot—tell me where I shall come."
He said, "Do you know the chemist and perfumer's at the corner of the Rue
Keller? To-morrow at six."
He took a key from his pocket and placed it on the table, not daring to
touch her hand, indeed she shrank back for fear he should do so. "There is a
side door and you go up one flight of stairs; it was taken in the name of Luc
Lucille Debelleyme remembered instantly, vividly, the phrases in the
Duchess' letter: "those little rooms you are known to hire—I do not
believe they are for your sole use." This, then, was one of them; he was
putting her on a level with those other, obscure rivals; as indeed she had
asked him to do.
She put the key in her beaded reticule: "This is because there is no other
"Can you suggest anything else?"
They already heard the eager feet of the children outside. "No, nothing.
Only this—you did well to respect me. I have as much virtue as I ever
professed to have...."
"I know. You'll come?"
"You've thought of me, you've missed me?"
"God knows," he whispered with violence, "how much!" The laughing children
entered the room bearing between them a huge basket laden with exotic fruits
and flowers, rare, costly; as they placed this rich trophy of the summer
before Mademoiselle Debelleyme she whispered between her exclamations of joy
at dusky grapes, soft peaches, red-stained nectarines, the last roses and
striped dahlias, cast in this sudden profusion into her miserable privation:
"I shall be there."
It was not difficult for Madame du Boccage to learn what she
regarded as this new outrage on the part of her husband. The innocent chatter
of the children themselves before their nurses, the nurses' repetition to
Matilde and Matilde's instant bearing of the news to her mistress was the
matter of an hour or so. "A visit to the dentist indeed! But first they had
gone to the Rue du Harlay... "
The Duchess consulted with the Abbé Galle, with her lawyer, Maitre Cottin;
although death was in her soul she was still resolved, for her children's
sake, not to give in. What would their fate be if they fell powerless into
the hands of this other woman?
She was advised to insist on an instant departure for Dieppe, and the Abbé
Galle undertook to immediately dislodge the governess from the Rue du Harlay.
He would bring pressure to bear on Madame Trou and force her to demand from
her new teacher a certificate of good behaviour recently written and signed
from Madame du Boccage. Madame Trou could say with truth that scandalous
rumours had begun to reach her ears, indeed had been confirmed by the visit
to M. du. Boccage to his one-time governess the very day he had arrived in
Paris, glossed over by the presence of the children, no doubt, but a glaring
piece of indiscretion none the less.
She could, therefore, with propriety demand this new certificate of good
character. Madame du Boccage would, of course, refuse it, the governess would
be expelled from the Rue du Harlay and ruined, penniless, without a good
name, would have nowhere to go; she would then be reduced, so the astute Abbé
argued, to accept the generous charity of her enemies, take a handsome
pension and some more excellent testimonials and return to England.
Madame du Boccage hesitated a little before employing these methods, which
savoured of brutality, but she had resigned herself to the guidance of her
advisers, and a few hours after the Duke's visit to the Rue du Harlay the
Abbé waited on Madame Trou; he found that woman, who disliked Lucille
Debelleyme, ready to espouse the cause of justice and to preserve the
respectability of her dreary establishment as well as eager to please a great
lady of such influence as the Duchesse du Boccage.
That same evening she told Lucille Debelleyme what had occurred: "I must
have this certificate of character, Mademoiselle. If you are on the good
terms you say you are with Madame du Boccage then there will be no difficulty
in obtaining it—if there is any difficulty in obtaining it I cannot
keep you here—I have my reputation to think of. I live a very retired
life and I had not heard of all these scandalous rumours when I engaged you.
I cannot have the parents of my charges objecting to the character of the
young person whom I employ to instruct them."
Lucille Debelleyme's heart swelled with hatred against this woman, against
all the horde of women, respectable, spiteful, virtuous, whom she
"You shall have your certificate of good character, Madame. I will secure
it for you to-morrow."
The woman was silent at this bold front and left her with a cold glance of
enmity; Lucille Debelleyme's rage exploded in a burst of rare laughter that
startled the other, who paused on the stairs to listen.
"A certificate of virtue from Fanny du Boccage!"
The governess laughed to think that she was really as 'virtuous' as she
said she was—who would believe that?—perhaps, after to-morrow
night, it might not be true.
Lucille Debelleyme passed rapidly through the streets on her
way to the Rue Keller, the heat was suffocating and it seemed to her excited
imagination that there was unrest everywhere. Outside the shops, the clubs,
the cafes, groups of people disputed and surged; placards seemed to be
everywhere; the air was full of murmurs of discontent and disdain for M.
Guizot, for his master.
The evening papers that were being eagerly bought and read were full of
scandals about the ruling classes. A general had been found guilty of
corruption, a minister of intrigues, a lunatic prince had murdered his
mistress... the first two had been punished, no doubt, the third sent to an
asylum, but people would not forget; these scandals fermented in the masses,
and the whole structure of the Orleans monarchy which had risen out of the
tumult of the famous Three Days was steadily shaken by the increasing menace
of popular scorn.
The governess had difficulty in finding the Rue Keller as it was in a
quarter unknown to her. She took an omnibus for she felt strangely fatigued;
the man who was sitting next to her had one of the evening sheets on his
knee; she could not avoid seeing the headlines of an inflammatory political
article, and on another column the word—again and
She had never dwelt on murder nor indeed any crime before, she had always
relegated it into that part of life which she knew existed but with which she
was never faced. Now in her disturbed, distracted state, an odd sickening
curiosity crept into her mind... People of her own class, people of a class
higher than her own, did commit murder. Why? Deeds of violence were, to her,
incredibly stupid, an underground method was the only way, she was sure, of
attaining one's end. She did not reflect that while it is the savage, the
stupid, who commit murders, it is often the subtle and the fastidious who
Her companion, who smelt of garlic, put a spotted red foulard over his
face to keep off the flies and the newspaper slipped off his knee to the
floor of the bus, so that the word 'Murder' was under the feet of Lucille
It was so hot in the omnibus. A fat woman entered with two plucked fowls
in a handkerchief; dangling over her legs and her cotton skirt were their
heads; on which hung the withered flesh of the combs and wattles, and long
red feathers; drops of blood and water dripped from the ends of their yellow
beaks. Passers-by hailed the omnibus, which stopped reluctantly; steam rose
from the lean backs of the horses; the conductor took off his shapeless cap,
mopped his bald head and pulled from his pocket a sensational paper-backed
romance which he read as the vehicle jerked over the cobbles. Torn placards,
on houses, hoardings and kiosks announced old plays: La Kerne Margot by
Alexandre Dumas, Haydee by Scribe and Auber—summer fêtes, the 'Chateau
des Fleurs' at the Arc-de-Triomphe with comic songs, games, Bengal
lights—one franc entrance. The print shops showed metal caricatures of
Teste and Cubieres, who had brought such infamy on the government, and
reproductions of a popular painting that, in crude satire, showed the Paris
of 1847 under the likeness of the Rome of Tiberius; everywhere could be
sensed a public unrest, a malaise, a nervous disquiet.
"Or am I wrong? Is it only in myself, this uneasiness?"
She got out of the jolting omnibus at the corner of a small cobbled street
and, following the conductor's direction, found the Rue Keller. There was the
chemist's shop with the strong August sunshine gleaming across the huge
purple, crimson and green bottles, with jars of medicines showing through the
open door. There, at the side, was the little door of which she had the
She passed it, and walked away rapidly up the street. She had been
reminded of the inn at Paddington, the back parlour and the large, bleak,
cold bedroom where Robert Morrison lay drunk. She was not a woman who could
easily become used to the peculiar, furtive atmosphere of illicit intrigue.
It was not the duplicity that shocked her, but the slur on her pride. She had
gone up to Robert Morrison's hired bedchamber because he represented (she had
thought) her only chance of escape from an insupportable situation; she
turned back now because of the urge of a similar desperation, and took the
key out of her purse. Events had so narrowed down her sphere of action that
there was only this left to do; a complete resignation, a complete
abnegation, she could not contemplate.
The stairs were dark, already lit by a small jet of gas which showed
another door at the top, that of the apartment which was marked with the
assumed name the Duke had given her. She turned the key and entered, closing
the door carefully behind her, holding her breath, stepping even more lightly
He was not there; she sat down at a table covered with a long chenille
cloth in the centre of the room, and peered round, pale with an increasing
rage against her destiny. Her hand had been forced, she was doing the thing
that she had above all things not wished to do, throwing away the fruits of
years of self-respect, decorum, of correct behaviour. If she was discovered,
and she believed that, spied upon as she was, she would certainly be
discovered, she would be openly revealed as the wanton that her enemies had
for the last two years de-dared her to be. She would have lost that nominal
innocence which was her chief asset. The need she had of the man whom she had
come to meet waged with her disgust that he could have found nothing better
for her than this.
The room was hidden away at the back of the small house and looked on a
blank wall, the sun, though still powerful, was completely shut away and
twilight fell over the small apartment where she waited. She endeavoured to
divert herself (nor was this so difficult as her curiosity was avid) by
noticing every detail of her surroundings. All was in his taste, she could
see that at once; nothing much modern—all frivolous with decor of the
Regency, no touch of the present century. Her gaze concentrated on the long
couch with gold-scrolled back, set in the wall behind looped draperies,
covered with silk pillows and cashmere shawls.
Who was that woman for whom he had furnished the room, and how often had
he entertained her or others? The governess locked her hands under her chin;
supposing he did not come? She had always found it so agreeable to realise
that he was like herself, so capable of getting his end by plot and plan, by
underground intrigues. But this worked against herself now, she could not be
quite sure of him, even though she believed that his feeling for her was
genuine. After all, he had never committed himself to her save by half-looks,
half-words. Their behaviour had always been of complete outward
"He does not give a woman much to build on and what, after all, can I be
to him compared to all he risks in any further dealings with me?"
There were some Journal de Modes on the table, Le Follet,
Le Courier des Dames; she turned over the glossy leaves and became
discontented with her own gown, not the finest that she had, but the smartest
in which she had dared leave the Rue du Harlay. For whose diversion had he
bought these frivolous pictures of ruffled silks, wide laces and frail
"Some women know how to get these things without fuss or scandal—mon
Dieu! It must have been my virtuous training that set me on the wrong path! A
man of his wealth—and what have I had of him? A man of his position and
he meets me here!"
Her cupidity, her disappointment clouded her delight in him:
"Peers of France were not formerly so cautious nor so niggardly, I fear
that I am born into the wrong century."
He broke in on her meditation, holding in his hand the fashionable light
top-hat, that, high and wide, made so many men appear ridiculous, but which
oddly suited his height and build.
The governess remained seated and such was her control that not a tinge of
colour passed over her pale, pensive face; she thought instantly: "this time
we must really come to a definite understanding, this time we cannot leave it
M. du Boccage put down his hat, gloves and cane, then locked the door;
they did not speak to each other. He approached the table where she sat
waiting; she nerved herself to hear what he was going to say and not to be
jarred at the wrong words he was sure to employ. She was used to interpreting
his banalities, but sometimes she resented them. Whatever her feelings for
him, at the present moment they were not strong enough to lift her above
those minute exasperations; this place where she was forced to meet him, this
silence, overshadowed the triumph of the fact that he had come...
At length he said: "Madame du Boccage insists that we all go to Dieppe
to-morrow. I cannot resist without a further scandal. She harries me day and
night, I have not a moment's respite."
How flat an opening for a clandestine love meeting! The picture he evoked
was touched by absurdity for the governess; a family trip to the
seaside—the carriage full of children, the servants busy with luggage,
the nurses scolding, everything—now her own touch was lacking—in
chaos, and in the midst of these agitated domesticities this elegant young
man—this roué manqué. Ah, Camille Pierre Marie du Boccage
Montlosier had indeed made himself ridiculous by his early marriage; but if
the thought of Dieppe gave the governess a little amusement, it was obvious
that it afforded none to the Duke; his sense of humour had for some while
been in eclipse.
"I have been driven," he repeated sullenly; "she harries me—"
"Yes," smiled the governess, "she has harried you here. Monsieur du
Boccage, harried you and me to this shameful place."
He glanced at her sharply, askance, and his mouth twitched:
"I hardly believed you would come."
She read the words and the look; he was one of those men who held women
sharply divided into two classes, the chaste and the wanton; having put
Lucille Debelleyme in the first category, it was profoundly difficult for a
mind like his to remove her to the second.
"Yes, I have made this sacrifice," she still continued to smile. She took
off her bonnet and swung it by the lilac ribbons. "The last sacrifice."
"It need never be known."
"But I dare say it will be!" She rose. "Do you not see this is delivering
us into the hands of our enemies? You say they have driven us here, where
will they drive us next?"
He continued to look at her intensely, with an expression, she thought, as
if he waited for a signal, but she could not think what signal; her
"So you are to leave Paris to-morrow and I—what is to become of me?
Am I to stifle in the Rue du Harlay, if indeed that woman will keep me
there—you have not obtained, indeed, you cannot obtain that letter
which is demanded from your wife?"
He said under his breath: "she will not give it to me," then, "if you were
to come yourself to-morrow and ask for it... "
Lucille Debelleyme interrupted: "It would be a useless humiliation. Do you
not see it is a trap to get rid of me? But I will not go, I will not leave
Paris. After all, there are always things one can do."
"That marriage?" he asked sharply.
"Perhaps worse than that."
She began walking up and down the room swinging her bonnet by the lilac
strings. He sat down at the table in the chair she had just left and dropped
his head in his hands, his elbows on the piles of magazines.
His indolent gaiety, his haughty self-assurance so skilfully cloaked by a
smiling amiability were all gone, she pitied him as he sat in that abject
attitude. He, wealthy and powerful, with every worldly advantage was as
cornered, as defeated, as helpless as herself. She bent over him, put her
hand on his shoulder. He instantly shuddered at her touch.
"There must be something, you are not going to give in, let them do what
they will? Have you no authority, are you not master in your own home? Come,
we are no longer in the relations of master and servant. We can speak clearly
I hope, plainly, Camille." For the first time she used his name. He glanced
up quickly with eager expectancy.
"I have not come here to use evasion, your troubles, your humiliations do
not come from me. When you begged me to stay, I stayed, though the position
was almost insupportable. When you asked me to go I went and I made no
"It is true, it is true; you have been my one friend."
"I have thought of you like that, too—my one friend, the only
creature who has treated me as if I was a human being. You know you have my
loyalty. I have done what I could."
She turned aside, her nerves giving way before his immobility, his
"Mon Dieu! I would not be so forced down by circumstances! Are you not
young, with money and position? With everything most people cut each other's
throats to get? And do you allow this odious woman—come, she is odious
to me and to you also, is she not?"
As if stimulated by the intense passion in her words he rose to his feet.
"she is odious to me. I hate her, I have for her a repugnance—"
"That is enough!" cried the governess. "Free yourself of her, be done with
He did not reply but cast his eyes down while a shudder passed over his
face as if an unspeakable thought was struggling in his mind; she added
swiftly: "Why did you ask me to come here to-day?"
"I had," he answered with difficulty, "to speak with you in private. There
has always been somebody, the children, servants, spies—"
"Yes," she retorted, "It is very difficult for us to get away from all
that even here. You seem tongue-tied, stifled—but what? The weight of
custom, the legend of my respectability?"
He said slowly: "I cannot believe in what we are being driven
"What we are being driven to, Camille, what do you mean?—that you
are forced to ask me to be your mistress?—well, this is a proper place,
is it not? I am no longer in charge of your little children nor in the
services of your virtuous wife, I no longer have to satisfy your friends and
relations as to my purity and my good behaviour—I have come at last to
the position where certificates of virtue and decorum are not required."
"I do not want you to lose everything through me. I do not like what I do,
what I am forced to do. I have never asked a woman like you to a place like
Lucille Debelleyme smiled, his code that it hurt him so to surrender,
mattered very little to her; she had already sacrificed her own.
With the greatest possible effort, as if all his faculties were fast
slipping his control, he added: "I find that life without you is awful,
impossible. You are ill, dying in that hideous Rue du Harlay. I must do
something, I must alter it."
"Get me," she said with rising contempt for his slowness, for his
inaction, "that letter from Madame du Boccage—send me with a pension to
England—then all will be peaceful again. Get rid of me and go your
"You know that I cannot."
"Then what do you intend to do with me?"
She believed that he was going to ask her to be his secret mistress and
she believed that she was going to accept his proposal, yet her pride was not
stung as it had been when Robert Morrison had turned on her and said he had
no intention of marrying her. She was better schooled now, besides, her
senses, her emotions were touched; she believed that it would be impossible
to live without this man...
She sank down on the couch set in the wall and flung her bonnet on the
cushion beside her; he turned to stare at her, she was annoyed by the stray
thought that made her think of the marble mask of the cupidon in the salon of
the Faubourg St. Honoré, for he had that same strange expression, a smile
that might pass as gaiety but on a closer inspection seemed a grimace of
"Life is blank without you. I never thought this would happen to me, to be
so entangled and trapped."
"Cut free," breathed the governess, leaning towards him.
"I must think of my name, of my family, my children."
"And must you not," she asked, leaning further forward, "a little think of
She rose impulsively, throwing aside her long, patient restraint, as if
she unbuttoned a cloak and cast it down.
"I have always restrained myself, Camille. I thought you had enough to
endure from that other woman, and I have been forced to earn my livelihood
for many years so am not able to indulge in emotionalism, but I too could
weep and pray, I too could point to my wrongs and sufferings, I too could ask
you to take pity on me, to contemplate what my life has been! I am a woman
after all, not a machine. I am, too, what you think of as a good woman."
"Do you love me?" he asked, his voice was hoarse and his tone flat, she
saw that he was at the end of all subterfuge as she was herself; they dropped
all the tricks of the elaborate game that they had played so long.
"I love you. You are, in every way, my only hope and love. Is it that? I
don't know—perhaps, as you said, something more."
He approached her and unsteadily sank on his knees beside the couch and
put his head and his arms on the pillows beside her, in the relaxed attitude
of a tired child. She saw his shoulders heave under the fine cloth and though
she could hear nothing she thought that he sobbed, and she sat silent, not
intruding on his grief by a gesture. The light was failing in the small,
overcrowded room—she had been there longer than she knew; with the
setting of the sun the heat seemed to increase; all the fumes of a summer day
in the city began to assail them. She began to count the hours they had
before them, how long might they in safety stay there... the habit of
calculation was so strong with her that she could not forget it, even in this
moment of genuine emotion. She touched his shoulder. "Camille, we are both
very wretched. Do not lose heart—there must be a way out."
He lifted his head to look at her, his hair had fallen over his eyes,
which strangely altered his appearance.
"Yes, I'll find a way. Will you stay with me here to-hight? All the
Her answer came in a whisper: "I dare not, we are spied on, you know, do
not forget that. If I am not at the Rue du Harlay at least to sleep, the
worst will be suspected."
"Stay with me to-night."
Twice she had knelt at is feet; it was curious to see him kneeling.
Detached from his usual surroundings, his usual manners, his personality
changed; this fascinated her, for she had thought, with the self-confidence
of a clever woman, that she had known him through and through; she recalled
her mistake with Robert Morrison. The Duke had not been weeping; his eyes
were clear, his complexion pale, why then had he hidden his face? To conceal
She got to her feet and moved away: "I saw you had something here to make
coffee. I feel so thirsty, my throat quite parched. The gas, too, shall I not
light it? It is getting so dark,"
"And hot too," he complained, rising quickly, "suffocating."
With what seemed a frantic gesture he threw off his blue coat. It fell on
the ground at her feet, she stooped to pick it up, he prevented her, their
"What is this in the pocket? You have had a bottle in the pocket, I think
it is broken." Her fingers closed on a small phial which had struck the
floor. He instantly took it from her and returned it to the coat pocket.
"It is laudanum—I found it in the room of Madame du Boccage. It is
safer for me to have it."
"Ah yes—safer," murmured the governess. He dropped the coat on the
couch; she noticed he had twisted several times round his waist, a thin,
green cord; he saw her look and explained: "that also I found it in her
"You think she contemplates suicide?"
"Who knows? I have been thinking, too, of the baldaquin of her
bed—since you spoke of it—it is dangerous, I must have the
workmen in to make it more secure."
They looked at each other through the gloom, she put her hand out as if
she tried to move a veil between them. "If such a thing should happen," she
sighed. "What a frightful thought! But our only hope is in some such
As if to efface the impression of these words she suddenly cast herself
into his arms in an abandonment of self-pity, of desire, of affection. His
embrace was so powerful that it was difficult for her to draw breath through
her slender body, his kisses and tears on her face left her in no doubt as to
the emotion she had roused in this man. In broken inarticulate cries, he
breathed his passionate desire for her, his furious hatred for their mutual
enemy, his agony at seeing her wilt and fade in the Rue du Harlay, his horror
at the thought of the marriage with which she had tormented him, his disgust,
his fury at spies, the whole world—he and she only—
For a moment her desperately aroused emotion overwhelmed her intellect,
she could think of nothing except that she was in his embrace—but for a
moment only. Even then her pride and her ambition took over, she began to
plan and calculate—to think: "This is the climax, what I cannot get now
I shall never get. It is my last, my only chance. Why should I not have from
him everything a woman may have?"
She was lost for a second only. Then she caught at her senses, her
intellect, and extricated herself even at that moment, from his intense
desire, and her intense wish to accept it in the fullest. As he continued to
murmur with his lips on her bare neck what he would do for her, what he would
give her, she wrenched herself away, disordered, distracted as she was:
"Why not then everything? I am not to be had this way after all... "
Expressing the very height of a frenzy, long-suppressed ambition, she said:
"A separation—a divorce—marriage with me—why not? It has
been done before and if I'm so much to you—"
By his instant withdrawal from her she at once realised that this had been
in his mind too. She was not asking a higher price for herself than he had
already in his mind put on her; yet she wondered if this could be done, if
they could now, possibly, leave each other; it was as hard to fight herself
as it was to fight him... but the prize was surely worth it—
"I cannot think," she whispered, "really, my mind does not work—have
I asked too much?"
"No more than you deserve," he was gripping the back of the chair by the
table; when had she seen him do that before and why did she want to know? Ah,
that first day that she had seen him in the Hotel du Boccage—she must
control these wandering thoughts.
"You think that? Why not do it—for me?"
"You want it? More than anything? More than the night—we might have
The way of ambition was also the way of honour; she with instinctive skill
took advantage of that.
"You would think less of me—you are not the man to love where you
despise. I want your love."
He did not move, she thought the gilt chair would break in his formidable
grip; his face was flushed, his hair was tumbled over his eyes. She was
frightened by the part she played, but she would not give way; her mood was
not the mood of melting romance in which she had set ajar her door in the
Palazzo Frediani. She was defeated now, with nothing to lose but that nominal
innocence that the world valued so highly, that secretly she valued so highly
herself—"to become his harlot is to give his wife the final
triumph—why should I? Yet how resist? I was mad to come."
She found a candle on a porcelain gueridon by the window and lit it, as if
there was protection in the small light.
"The letter," she stammered, with her back to him. "I want that
letter—make her write it—I am as virtuous as she is—she
owes me that letter—I want to publish it before all Paris—" she
heard him come up behind her; she stared into the little flame melting the
hard wax; she forced herself to repeat:
"Is that more to you then staying here with me?"
He put his arms round her and pulled open her thin summer bodice; she felt
his flesh warm through the linen shirt, she leant her head back so that it
rested under his chin; it seemed to her that his grasp was strong enough to
tear her heart out with one movement, but what she whispered, her lips near
"Get that letter from your wife—divorce her—separate from
her—what you will—then come back to me—"
"Lucille—you cannot—make terms, now."
Half naked as she was, she drew away with a pride that overwhelmed his
"I'm not a harlot. I will not be—some day she would know—and
you would be ashamed."
She frantically searched his face for an answer to this—some lovers
could have persuaded her, even then, that pride, ambition and honour were as
nothing compared to love—but not this man. The baffled anger in his
eyes, the quiver of his mouth, his half-recoil told that he would be
ashamed—that he was ashamed now.
She loosened his slackened fingers from her bare breast.
"I will not do it."
She took his hand and held it with her own above the now flaring flame of
the candle so that fire stung their flesh. He winced, then in silence
shuddered back into his self-control. She wondered if she had gone too far,
denied him and herself too violently, if her sacrifice and his was for
She buttoned up her bodice, turned away, pulled her bonnet from the couch,
swinging it mechanically by the pale, lilac strings.
What she had set herself was almost beyond her; she put her bonnet on and
tied the ribbons under her chin in an attempt to steady her nervous, rising
hysteria by movement.
"Tell your wife to give me that letter."
"Come to the Faubourg St. Honoré to-morrow."
"Very well, I will be there. I shall expect the letter—and from
As he put on his coat, as it in a stupor, she stared again at the green
cord twisted round his braces, under the pique waistcoat; she thought of the
bottle of laudanum in his pocket. Why had he not allowed his wife to use it?
The image of the heavy baldaquin came before her mind—she would not
give way, yet she grasped the edge of the table to support herself and was
half regretful that he had not forced her, made an end of this torment of
virtue it cost so much to keep. Her own mood was so distraught that she could
not for once clearly understand his point of view; was he not too silent, had
he not given away too soon? It was the first time since she had known him
intimately that she was not aware of what he was feeling or thinking; only
through the haze of her own emotion she sensed that the man was frantic.
He picked up his hat and gloves, put them down and picked them up
"To-morrow, then," he repeated several times, "to-morrow."
"If you care enough," she whispered, still holding on to the table.
"You shall see how much I care."
He tried to leave the room, forgetting that he had locked the door, then
he fumbled several times with the wrong key; all the while he struggled for
escape she did not speak nor look at him.
Then he was gone, the door slammed after him and she sprang into instant
action which seemed without her own volition.
"It is madness to deny such a moment—such a man—and
myself—I cannot do it—what does anything matter? If only he
stays—Camille, Camille, return!"
She did not know if she spoke or thought these frantic phrases; she dashed
out the candle with her blistered hand, snatched up her cloak and bag
(prudent even then) and ran from the darkening room, down the stairs into the
twilit street. The gas was flaring in the chemist's shop and the bright jets
sent the reflections of the monstrous brilliant bottles of vivid water in
patches of red and purple and green on the dirty pavement. She looked up and
down the street, she could see him, not far away yet, walking unsteadily, his
hat in his hand. The hot gloom of evening made his pale clothes and blond
hair appear ash-like, as if he was a figure without substance.
"What have I done? What will he do?"
Lucille Debelleyme thought: "This is going to be the most
difficult night of my life, I wonder how I shall live through it." She had
returned to the Rue du Hanay decorously early, decorously attired. Madame
Trou had been in the corridor as if waiting for her and gave her a suspicious
"You have the letter for which I asked you, Mademoiselle?" she demanded in
her thick, ugly French.
"I shall have it to-morrow," replied the governess quietly. She marvelled
at the power of her own self-control, she certainly owed something to her
long and bitter training. "To-morrow, in the afternoon, I am calling on
Madame la Duchesse du Boccage in the Faubourg St. Honoré. She is herself
personally giving me this letter."
"I cannot wait longer than to-morrow, Mademoiselle. As I have explained to
you before, if I had had any idea of the state of the case I should not have
taken you in."
Mademoiselle Debelleyme merely smiled at this insolence. She went
carefully up the dingy stairway with the worn drugget, holding her gown off
her elegant feet; she looked back over her shoulder at the scowling,
suspicious Swiss woman as she repeated:
"To-morrow, Madame, to-morrow."
Her tiny room, cramped and dirty as it was, was a refuge. She could not
hope to sleep but she could hope to indulge in the agony of her insomnia
alone, unspied on for a few hours at least.
Taking off only her bonnet and gloves she knelt by the bed and pulled the
pillows, covered in cool coarse linen, under her hot face, turning them in
search of further coolness as they became heated from her flesh.
The long night was very close. She had the sash windows open as wide as
possible, top and bottom; the air that entered was stale, tainted and brought
When the full moon came up behind the black masses of the houses it seemed
to give no light.
"I've gone too far, I should not have denied him. I have injured myself
and him. I cannot go on like this for ever. I asked too much, he will not be
able to give it."
Was it possible that she had refused the greatest delight ever offered her
because of ambition and pride? Her aching loneliness was almost
insupportable. Perhaps the other woman would master him after all, she and
her formidable allies... Perhaps he would leave for Dieppe on the morrow and
she would never see him again.
It was likely enough she would never receive the letter that was to
restore her character and she might be turned with ignominy from the doors of
Madame Trou; worse, when she went to the Faubourg St. Honoré to-morrow it
might be to once again see the gates closed.
Such awful dread and misery possessed her that she had difficulty to keep
from crying aloud.
When as the hot night sank into the first coppery glow of day she heard a
noise outside, she sprang to her door, filled by she knew not what
One of the girls was outside, a dying nightlight in her hand, her plain
face livid, her greasy hair falling in a plait over her flannel
"I feel sick. Mademoiselle, I couldn't sleep it was so hot, the smells
from the streets, and the noises," and her eyes widened with surprise to see
the governess was fully dressed.
"I also," said Mademoiselle Debelleyme in her careful tone, "found it
difficult to sleep, that is why I am dressed so early." She returned to her
room, but through the thin wall she could hear the girl retching. How long
must she stay here, how long could she possibly endure to stay here? It was
not likely he would sleep either; perhaps, already, he was preparing himself
for that interview with his wife in which he would tell her that she must
give the certificate of good character that would keep her enemy in Paris, or
even that he wished for a divorce, a separation, the first step to putting
her rival in her place?—Lucille, Madame la Duchesse du Boccage...
"Am I mad to have thought of such a thing? Have I lost all in asking too
much? A few stolen interviews in the Rue Keller were better than
The dawn strengthened, showing in detail all the squalor of the room. The
noises of the street began, the rattle of a wagon, the cry of a hawker. It
was nearly daylight over Paris, the beggar's instruments squealed out a
polka, the tune floated across the narrow yard on to which her window looked
and brought her to her knees again with her fingers in her ears, not daring
to recall that moment of enchantment by the sea, in Corsica. Her blistered
finger hurt as it pressed against her cheek; she had not before noticed that
All that morning there was no message, no sign, but after
all had she expected or he promised any? She must wait until the afternoon,
when she would call on the Duchess and demand the letter; he would be there
of course; what had been her last words to him?—"I expect of
She drank a great deal of coffee but could eat no food. The fruit and
flowers from Javiaux du Boccage flaunted in the dingy dining-room; Madame
Trou looked askance at the extravagant present, but ate greedily the grapes
and peaches. Mademoiselle Debelleyme gave a music lesson to two of the girls,
while the third, who had been taken ill in the night, lay on the
mohair-covered sofa, groaning now and then with nausea.
Madame Trou had insisted that the two girls should learn the fashionable
La Belle Helene polka. As they played it one after the other, again and
again, stumbling over the notes, the governess, leaning against the tall
pianoforte with the drawn red-silk front, thought: "This is torture, this is
what people mean by acute torture. It is curious how one keeps using words
without knowing what they really mean—but now I know what is meant by
At the unpleasant meal in the gloomy little dining-room, where no one, for
the languor induced by the heat, could eat the food, Madame Trou again
reminded her assistant of the necessity for the letter from Madame du
"I am going this afternoon to fetch it."
She dressed herself with great care for this interview; Madame du Boccage
should not think that she was any less sure of herself. She would risk the
disapproval of Madame Trou, for, surely, she must, somehow, soon escape from
the Rue du Harlay. She selected a pale-grey cashmere dress trimmed with a
soutache of white braid: for bonnet?—that with the taffeta
frills and the lilac ribbons she had worn yesterday—she had nothing
As she tied the strings she remembered that she had left behind the key of
the apartment in the Rue Keller, one of her mistakes; it would have been
pleasant to have had it in her pocket when she confronted Fanny du
His face was so constantly before her mind that she paused to stare at it
as if he really stood there; how different he looked with his hair fallen
over his eyes—peculiar, light coloured hair like a Northerner. How
unattractive she had at first found that excessive fairness; she marked every
detail of that imagined countenance, the slight fullness under the chin, the
slight weariness of the face, the lines under the eyes that showed complete
"I shall expect of you some action."
She slipped out of the Rue du Harlay without anyone noticing her;
circumspect, composed, she proceeded to the Faubourg St. Honoré; she did not
feel very triumphant nor very sure of herself. "He ought to have seen me this
morning, after such a parting as we had it was his duty to see that I was
immediately reassured." Yet how impossible to believe that he would abandon
her; she must believe that he would not fail her...
As she turned into the familiar Faubourg St. Honoré, which was to her a
street of joyous and happy memories, she paused and closed her eyes to steady
herself, then advanced slowly with her light, easy step over the pavement.
She still looked down for she dreaded to see even from a distance that the
lodges were closed, the gates locked, the family away; she could not face the
realisation that he might have forsaken her.
But when she did raise her glance she saw the gates of the Hotel du
Boccage wide open and a crowd filling the courtyard, pressing round the
porter's lodges, while a string of carriages blocked the roadway. People were
passing hurriedly from these carriages in and out of the Hotel du Boccage;
they were all, she noticed, men. Among them she recognised one of the doctors
whom she had often seen in attendance on the Duchess and she thought, with a
gleam of dreadful hope, "she has been taken ill, she has not been able to
sustain the struggle, she is, perhaps, dying—ah! that is why he did not
But why the crowd? Why this commotion? The porter was standing in the
midst of a little group of men who seemed to be eagerly questioning and
writing the answers down in notebooks. She had seen some of these at the
great receptions and been told that they were journalists, that they
represented the new and growing power of the press. The porter's face was
contorted, at first she had scarcely recognised him; he gesticulated
vehemently and kept drawing his hand over his throat.
Lucille Debelleyme pulled her veil over her face and passed into the crowd
in the courtyard; among others there were a few women of the lower classes
with their baskets and marketing handkerchiefs on their arms. She looked up
at the familiar mansion, the white facade showed charmingly through the
little trees. The blinds were down in the pretty windows adorned with their
festoons of marble flowers; the terraces and steps were full of agitated
people coming and going.
"A stroke of apoplexy? Is she then dead?"
The governess turned and spoke to a woman beside her, "Can you tell me
what has happened in the Hotel du Boccage? I am an old friend of the family,
I came on a visit."
Not only the woman to whom she spoke but everyone who could hear her
question answered with eager horror: "Where have you been that you have not
heard? A frightful crime was committed last night—Madame du Boccage has
Mademoiselle Debelleyme pushed her way through the crowd,
but on the edge she paused, there was something she must know. One of the
young men with a notebook was hastening along the pavement, to his newspaper
office no doubt; she detained him, standing in his way. "Tell me, you must
have information—this crime? What is known of it?"
He shrugged, not inclined to speak, impatient to be on his way: "Thieves,
they say. I suppose they thought the house empty, the family returned
unexpectedly. There was another outrage in the Elysee Bourbon two days ago.
No one seems to know anything. The magistrates are there and the police
commissioners of the Quartier du Roule."
"But she—is it certain that she was murdered?"
In obedience to a long-forgotten training the young man crossed himself:
"That is certain—it is horrible, I have seen the room. I really can
tell you nothing, it will all be in the papers. I believe that they are
puzzled." His face crinkled up as she had seen the face of the sick girl
crinkled up last night. "Excuse me, I feel ill—it is one of those
things one does not expect," to defend himself he added, "M. Edouard du
"He saw the room. Do you not understand? She had defended
herself—there had been a struggle. It is really incredible—I
mean, one does not imagine it like that—there was so much
The young woman drew back as if she saw by her feet that thick, warm
trickle from the slaughter-house oozing over the baked stone.
"I should stay away from the Faubourg St. Honoré, Mademoiselle, if I were
you—" the youth hurried away in search of a cognac.
Mademoiselle looked back at the Hotel du Boccage, the crowd had increased
even in the few moments since her arrival. People were hurrying from all
directions, she thought they had a menacing air, and remembered that sinister
sense of rising tumult which she had noticed in the streets last evening; it
seemed now as if all those bitter discontents and muttered furies had found a
focus in the Hotel du Boccage. More carriages, cabs, drove up, more men got
out, doctors, neighbours, magistrates, police—what had
happened—did she dare ask herself that?
"I shall expect of you some action."
She put her fingers to her mouth to prevent herself from crying aloud and
fled back to the Rue du Harlay; she had nowhere else to go.
When Lucille Debelleyme returned, Madame Trou stuck her head
out of the sitting-room and asked: "Eh, you are back early, have you got the
From over her shoulder came the tinkle of the polka. La Belle Helene and
the hiccoughing moans of the sick girl, the greasy garlic odour of the dinner
hung in the hot air.
The governess did not reply; it seemed as if she had not heard. She went
upstairs, hurrying, yet with difficulty, for she had to hold on to the
bannisters to support herself and continually stumbled, catching her feet in
her long skirt. Madame Trou stared after her:
"Ah, you have not got it! It has all been a tale! Well, Mademoiselle, you
must leave to-morrow."
She closed the door of the parlour with an angry slam, still there faintly
penetrated to Lucille Debelleyme's ears the broken rhythm of the polka.
She fled into her room and locked the door; the maid had not yet swept and
tidied it. The bed was disordered, her clothes, her toilet articles were in
disarray; for the first time in her life she lacked neatness in her personal
surroundings. For the first time in her life she did not care what her
surroundings were; "What to do? Where to go? Where to hide? If I could stop
thinking, is there any way to stop thinking?"
She dropped against the tumbled bed, then fell on the dusty floor. Through
the window, still open top and bottom, as she had set it during the night,
the sunshine fell in a hot square over her prone body. By the utmost effort
of her powerful will she did prevent herself from thinking, not a single
reflection passed through her mind, but she could not prevent these words
beating like a hammer throughout her whole body. "I ought to have kept that
laudanum, I ought to have taken the laudanum from him," and "I shall expect
some action from you."
She hoped at first that she would faint or die or in some way pass into
unconsciousness; but her courage and her strength seemed, despite her own
wish, to gather force. Aware of the great heat of the August sun on her arms
and shoulders as she lay on the floor, she shifted and crawled into the hot
shadows at the side of the room; presently she sat up and put back the pale
hair that fell over her face smudged by dust, marked from the pressure of the
rough rug at the foot of the bed. Flies buzzed continuously, hawkers shouted
hoarsely outside; she thought that the word they yelled was 'murder.'
Her indomitable spirit that had been overthrown but not beaten roused her
to faint hope: "Perhaps, after all, even now, there may be a way
out—why should I fear the worst?"
There were heavy steps, loud voices, on the stairs and a sharp rap at her
door; had he perhaps come for her? Had thieves really broken in last night to
the Hotel du Boccage and murdered the woman who had surprised them at their
Lucille Debelleyme got to her feet, searched for a handkerchief, wiped her
face, put back her hair. The imperative knock was repeated, she turned the
key with stiff fingers. Madame Trou was outside and behind her the maid and
two of the pupils, all agape and agog, pale, unfriendly faces thrust forward,
staring at her with inquisitive eyes. Behind them on the first landing of the
stairway were two policemen, others showed beyond them.
At the sight of Lucille Debelleyme standing pale and composed in her
doorway, Madame Trou began to stammer something venomous, horrified, half
"Well, Madame?" asked the governess; she stepped on the landing and closed
the door behind her; ignoring the group of bewildered, alarmed and spiteful
females, she spoke coolly over their heads, glancing down the stairs at the
"Yes, Messieurs, what do you want?"
One of the men came up the stairs, putting aside the other women; his look
and his voice were expressionless.
"It is believed, on the clearest evidence, that M. du Boccage murdered his
wife, and you are arrested as his accomplice."
Lucille Debelleyme was lodged in the Conciergerie in a small
room of the women's prison, a quadrangular building that looked on a small
courtyard. She made no protest, but seemed to hold an amused contempt for all
her surroundings. She had asked for all her possessions and they had been
given her. When she was told that she might, if she wished, communicate with
friends, she had replied: "I have none." When she was asked if she would have
a lawyer, she replied: "I have no means whereby I can pay one," but when told
that she would be brought before the examining magistrates on the following
day, she demanded with impressive gravity: "Of what am I accused? I am in
complete ignorance of all the details of this atrocious crime which you dare
to charge to me. I demand to be enlightened. What occurred in the Faubourg
St. Honoré last night? You say that M. du Boccage is a murderer," and with an
emphasis of contemptuous passion she added: "Impossible! I know him well, the
best, the most generous, the kindest of men, he would not lift his hand
against a woman, against any creature. He must be as innocent as I am
She spoke these words to the men who had been, since dawn, investigating
the apartments and the inmates of the Hotel du Boccage; M. de Tassy, Prefet
de Police and M. Mauzisse, the Public Prosecutor, who had been summoned from
their beds to join the commissaries of the Quartier du Roule and the Quartier
du Champs Élysées in the chamber of the murdered woman.
They had visited the governess in her cell, hoping to surprise from her,
in this moment of terrible emotion, the truth that she would have time to
tamper with before her formal examination on the morrow.
M. de Tassy answered her defiance; he was a man of sixty, robust,
implacable, impassive, hardened by constant contact with crime. His sombre
frock coat, his fringe of grey whiskers, his heavy watch-chain and starched
collar, his well-polished boots and brown leather gloves gave him an air of
hypocritical respectability; he looked like an English Methodist from a
provincial town. It was he who, alone, cool and patient, had, unmoved,
examined the corpse and its surroundings in the Hotel du Boccage and then
named the murderer to his horrified, embarrassed colleagues.
"Unfortunately, Mademoiselle, it is too clear that M. du Boccage is the
assassin. I was able after my investigations this morning to convince M. le
Procureur du Roi, M. le Juge d'instruction, M. le Procureur Général that this
was a matter for the Chamber of Peers. Is that not so, M. Mauzisse?"
The Public Prosecutor assented. He was troubled by an affair that seemed
likely to distract the entire government, and caressed his ginger beard with
nervous fingers as he looked at the woman who had been the cause, he was
convinced, of a crime to the last degree horrible, stupid and
"Impossible," said the governess.
"The Court of Peers is convoked at present, and I, Mademoiselle, shall
bring this charge before them—that of murder against M. du
As she spoke M. Mauzisse stared keenly from behind his spectacles at
Lucille Debelleyme. M. de Tassy had never taken his gaze from her face; he
put in sharply:
"The news of this most horrible crime has caused an explosion of fury in
Paris, it is with difficulty that we prevent the crowd from storming the
Hotel du Boccage and seizing the person of the Duke."
Mademoiselle Debelleyme showed nothing but an outburst of generous emotion
as she exclaimed:
"Where is he—in danger? Has he been arrested?"
"Unfortunately, Mademoiselle, he is a peer of France and it is impossible
to arrest him without a direct order from the King. He is in his own house
but he is being watched."
M. de Tassy, shrewd, cold and practised an observer as he was, could see
no flinching in the bright, vivid glance of the governess as she replied to
"I would I were beside M. du Boccage in his distress. He is my one friend,
my only protector. Perhaps I could give him a little comfort, even if
everyone is against him."
"You will tell your story to-morrow before me, Mademoiselle, and my
colleagues. I am bound to tell you that popular opinion is hot against you
also. It is a most terrible, a most difficult, almost an incredible affair,
even in my experience."
The governess replied:
"Am I, then, to be examined without any preparation, without knowing where
I stand? What have you against me, under what excuse was I arrested?"
M. Mauzisse put in sternly:
"Mademoiselle, the domestic history of the Hotel du Boccage has long been
common property, it has furnished a scandal in which the press of Paris has
concerned itself for the last year—we have besides read the letters of
Madame la Duchess du Boccage to her husband, we have also her diary, we have
the witness of the servants—"
"And, in brief, Mademoiselle, we have quite sufficient evidence—" M.
Mauzisse broke off dramatically, and then, after a pause during which the
governess' gaze never faltered from his, he added: "—to send M. du
Boccage to the guillotine if he were not a peer of France. And you also ...
"—if I were not innocent," finished Lucille Debelleyme boldly. M. de
Tassy was baffled by this audacious defence, he had come to visit her before
her examination because he expected an hysterical feminine breakdown in which
the entire truth would emerge. He had supposed that the young woman,
completely broken, would confess to the whole intrigue, that she had been the
mistress of M. du Boccage, that she had put him up to the crime, that she had
plotted murder to regain her foothold in the Hotel du Boccage. Instead of
that, by this cool effrontery, she had added to the confusion of a baffling
affair. He thought her courage and intelligence remarkable, and began to
understand how she had obtained such an extraordinary hold on a man like M.
du Boccage. He glanced at M. Mauzisse and shrugged his shoulders, then, using
the method of direct accusation, when she again pressed for details of the
crime, cried out:
"No need, Mademoiselle, for this hypocrisy, you very well know the details
of what you planned yourself!"
She looked at him in a way that made him feel that his method was stupid
and melodramatic. She asked quietly:
"Would you do me the favour. Monsieur, to tell me what has become of the
children? I had a great affection for them."
It was M. Mauzisse who answered gruffly:
"The House of Montlosier du Boccage do not lack relations and friends;
though the Maréchal de Frediani is in Corsica, his brother is in Paris, he
has taken some of the children and the others have gone to the Dowager Madame
"Ah, have they told that poor blind woman of this horrible crime?"
"I do not think so, I believe she has been informed that her
daughter-in-law perished in a stroke of apoplexy. Enough, Mademoiselle, I
leave you to your own reflections, we shall see in the morning if we can get
the truth out of you—remember confession is your only hope."
"My life has been lived in the light of day, every action clear and open,"
replied the governess, "it is I who want the truth, it is I who am completely
at a loss as to what has really happened."
She sat down at the bare prison table, looking so frail and young,
resigned and melancholy that the hardened men of the world felt bewildered;
even M. de Tassy was not quite so sure of her guilt as he had been when he
entered her cell.
"Let me see a doctor and have a sleeping draught," she asked, looking down
at her quivering hands folded in front of her, "otherwise I do not think I
shall have the strength for to-morrow."
Thinking that if she either broke down or pretended to break down they
would lose the evidence of the one person who had the key to this appalling
affair, and also that she might betray herself to the doctor, M. de Tassy
agreed to this visit.
As it was one of the doctors who usually attended Madame du
Boccage who visited the governess in her cell, she at once suspected him of
being sent as a spy, and realised that every word she said to him would be
repeated; she was used to being in a trap or a cage, watched and threatened.
She lay still and silent on her prison bed, answering briefly the questions
that he asked her about her health; then she demanded of him in a low voice,
as she had demanded of M. de Tassy, details of the crime in the Faubourg St.
Dr. Lappe, an old man with a fashionable practice, was still shaken by
what he had seen that morning, embarrassed and shocked by the part suddenly
thrust on him. But he did as he had been instructed by the implacable M. de
Tassy, gave her the information she had asked for and, seated by her low,
wooden bed, watched the effect on her. Nor did she try to evade his scrutiny,
her hands hung at her side, there was no attempt to hide her face. A small
jet of gas in an open metal case that hung above the bed cast a coarse light
on that small-featured, fair face, and the tumble of fine hair on the rough
pillow. Beneath the lamp was an unheeded crucifix.
The doctor stammered:
"The servants were roused this morning by the sound of a bell coming from
the apartment of Madame, the family were ready to depart for Dieppe to-day,
some of the servants had gone in advance, several more had been dismissed by
M. du Boccage yesterday. Those who were there ran to the assistance of their
mistress. They found her on the floor by her bed, dead; she had been attacked
and killed with an abominable fury. At first it was believed that thieves had
done this, but there was no trace of anyone entering from the outside. The
handle and the lock had been taken off the little door leading from Madame's
bedchamber to her toilet cabinet and the corridor, it was found that all the
bells had been cut except the one in the far corner of the room which the
poor lady finally found. M. du Boccage was fully dressed, his clothes were
stained—from head to foot—he was supposed to have been the first
to find his wife, to embrace her in his distress, to have in this manner
covered himself with blood."
The governess moved slightly on the prison bed but she did not flinch, and
the doctor, observing her with professional, yet uneasy keenness,
"His room was in the most frightful disorder; one of the magistrates on
entering found him emptying a basin of water out of the window; he had been
washing his clothes and burning fragments of cloth on the hearth, a
suffocating morning like this and a fire burning! Ah, well. Mademoiselle, I
will not give you any more details, I will have pity on you, except to say
when M. du Boccage was examined his denials were embarrassed, miserable, that
on his person was found a green cord and a bottle of laudanum—he could
give no explanation of these. In his room, too, were weapons, a pistol,
Closing her eyes the governess said:
"If he did it, it was because she drove him mad, after one of their
terrible quarrels... "
"So at first it was supposed, but the cut bells. Mademoiselle, the handle
taken off the door?—and, another thing, it was noted soon after the
Duke began to be suspected, that he cast himself with his full weight on his
wife's bed and that he glanced up at the baldaquin, which is very massive, as
if expecting it to fall."
"It was examined afterwards and found that the supports had been loosened
and much of the cement taken away and replaced by wax. The workmanship was
clumsy—that of an amateur, no doubt—but every time that the
Duchess got into bed she risked the baldaquin falling on her. It looks like
premeditation, doesn't it. Mademoiselle? Then they found her letters, her
diary—and yours... "
"They have seen those also?" She opened her eyes; they were fearless. "Ah
well, they will declare nothing but my innocence."
"The police have searched your lodging in the Rue du Harlay,
Mademoiselle—they have the other part of the correspondence—M. du
Boccage's letters to you."
"They will learn nothing from those." She raised herself suddenly on her
elbows, looking like a child with the veil of pale, disordered curls falling
over her slight shoulders. "There is one thing more, doctor—M. du
Boccage? He is still free in his own house?—no one dare touch him?"
"That is the dilemma, he is a peer of France, they have had to apply to
the King. Oh, the scandal! His Majesty will do a great deal not to see the
Chevalier of the Duchesse D'Orleans dragged to the guillotine... "
"To the guillotine?" repeated the governess, "to the guillotine? What will
he do?" she added, clutching the doctor's arms.
"His friends, the peers, have given him his chance, it is not for me to
say what he will do. Mademoiselle, you must think of yourself, you must
The old man rose; despite his professional insensibility and his worldly
self-assurance he was agitated, overwhelmed.
"Yes, I will think of myself—there's no one else to think of me."
The governess took the sleeping draught he had prepared, raising the glass
with a steady hand. "I wish it could give me repose for ever, Monsieur."
Dr. Lappe rose and turned away; he had never been in a prison cell before;
it was not a comfortable situation for a cosy old gentleman who had gentle,
pretty daughters of his own, whose practice had been wholly with the idle,
the elegant, the well-behaved—then, what he had seen this morning in
the greyness of the dawn; those curtains of Brussels lace hanging from gilt
amorini, torn, stained—that nightcap of net with silk strings on the
mantelpiece, soaked and dripping, those prints on the delicate walls, prints
of a thumbless hand fumbling for bell ropes that had been cut away—and
Madame du Boccage herself—thirty wounds—eleven on the head
alone—butchery—then, the scene in the dining-room where the dust
covers had not been taken off the furniture for a family en
passage—eight o'clock in the morning the magistrates gathered round the
long table, among them Camille du Boccage, his redingote closed to the chin,
his hands gloved in brown leather, his sleeves, the knees of his trousers
freshly washed, still damp, his face colourless, impassive, staring past
everyone there—preserving, despite the hour, the occasion, his
disarray, his air of elegance—grotesque, dreadful and in some curious
"Of what are you thinking, M. Lappe?" cried the governess from the bed.
"You have horror in your eyes!"
"Ah, I thought you slept—the draught—" stammered the old
doctor. "Is it not strong enough?"
"Give me another—to-night I do not sleep so easily—"
"No, I dare not."
He left her, having no further courage; a wardress immediately entered and
sat down in silence by the prisoner's bed; Lucille Debelleyme turned her face
to the wall. With expert fingers the wardress crocheted a baby's boot in
white thread and never raised her eyes from this work nor ceased to count the
While the angry crowd clustered round the Hotel du Boccage
openly demanding the punishment of the murderer, who, they feared, owing to
his rank, his friendship with the Royal Family, would escape retribution
(there was already talk that the King had smuggled him to England), while the
whole peerage was aghast, shaken by this frightful disaster, while the civil
authorities were faced by the problem of what to do with a criminal who was
also a peer of France, a member of one of the noblest, most powerful families
of the realm, Lucille Debelleyme, suddenly the most notorious, most hated
woman in France, appeared before M. Mauzisse the procureur géneral,
and M. Hamelin juge d'instruction. These men and their clerks could
not help looking with avid curiosity at this woman whom all the world accused
of long, shameless and secret adultery, of murder plotted in the shadow of a
nursery, between the kisses and caresses of the children of the
victim—this nobody who had brought to ruin a famous House.
She was calm and had dressed herself carefully, her gown of pale nankeen
was adorned with white braid en soutache, she wore a little jacket of
black moire. She carried her frilled straw bonnet with the lilac ribbon, as
if she expected, after her examination, to be permitted to leave the
The setting was one of extreme ugliness, the walls drab. The light from a
high window fell on a bare expanse of brick and the group of elderly men in
their frock coats, striped trousers, formidable in their massed authority,
their sombre gravity, their air of being not only on the side of the law but
that of God. M. Viou had an irritating cough and sucked lozenges that scented
the stale air with a sickly whiff of aromatics; M. Hamelin, who was extremely
stout, felt the heat and alternately wiped his bald head and napped at the
flies with his foulard; two clerks at a side table covered with baize, took
down with great speed question and reply. The Prefet de Police, M. de Tassy,
quite unmoved, conducted the examination.
He began by repeating, in formal fashion, his accusation of last
night—M. du Boccage was a murderer, and she, calling herself Lucille
Debelleyme, was his accomplice. The prisoner broke passionately, without
restraint, but not with hysteria, into denials:
"It is impossible. I do not believe that he has done it. May I go to
him?—may I see him? If he has done it, then indeed I am as much to
blame as he, it was that unhappy letter—I should not have asked for
it—a letter to restore my character. Messieurs, that I demanded of him,
that he was to have obtained from his wife. Some madness—I know I was
wrong—I should never have asked for it—in my letters to the
M. de Tassy interrupted:
"We do not want your sentimental self-accusations, Mademoiselle, we want
the truth. These letters of which you spoke—"
"You can read them, Messieurs."
"We have already read them. They are not only addressed to the children.
These letters that you speak of are also written to M. du Boccage."
"I do not deny it. I have said repeatedly he was so good, so generous to
me, my one friend, my one protector. I did feel for him, I do now, affection,
tenderness, loyalty." Her clear bold glance travelled from one to another of
the keen faces watching her with such hostility. "Is it impossible for you.
Messieurs, to believe in an honest affection? I am not an adultress."
"This sentiment of tender affection," asked the Prefet de Police, "was it
shared by M. du Boccage?"
"No," replied Lucille Debelleyme immediately. "M. le Duc had nothing for
me but the kindness any generous, chivalrous man might feel for a dependant
in his house who served him well. I loved his children, I did what I could
for them, their mother did not know how to treat them... "
"Ah," interrupted M. de Tassy, "if Mr. du Boccage committed this crime,
are we to believe he did it because his wife did not know how to treat their
Mademoiselle Debelleyme did not reply to this but it seemed rather from
contempt for the judges than from lack of anything to say. M. de Tassy,
inexorable, continued with increasing sternness; he did not know if the young
woman spoke with sincerity or was playing a skilful and dangerous game, but
he followed the principle that to discover the crime one must assume that the
accused is guilty.
"The truth is very different, Mademoiselle. Everyone is aware of the
profound disorder which you brought into this household. Everyone knows the
life the Duke and Duchess led, there was even a suggestion, more than one
suggestion, of judicial separation."
"How was I to know any of that? I was in a position of paid servant in the
household, in the confidence of no one. I felt the warmest esteem and
friendship for M. du Boccage but he did not tell me his secrets, discuss his
wife's domestic affairs with me. I lived enclosed with the children of whom I
had the entire care; how should I, so occupied, in such company, know the
scandals of Paris?"
She argued this unlikely plea with such art that her examiners were more
baffled than they dared allow to appear.
"Were you not. Mademoiselle, aware of a scandal when Monsieur l'Abbé Galle
himself came to speak to you, to beg you to leave the mansion?"
"I was aware of it then, and I left immediately; it was certainly a shock
to me for I believed myself on good terms with Madame du Boccage. We had
exchanged presents not long before and complimentary letters. But the moment
I discovered it was otherwise and I was a source of trouble in the house, I
Triumph edged her smile. She had spoken the truth but, though it carried a
reluctant conviction that it was the truth even in the minds of these men who
had been so sure of her guilt, M. de Tassy pursued the charge.
"Well, Mademoiselle, you had nothing for the Duke but respectful
friendship, and he nothing for you but a kind esteem, and you left the house
immediately you thought you were causing any disorder, any anxiety for Madame
la Duchesse, and yet as soon as you had left there was an exchange of
letters—the Duke returned before his usual custom, indeed most
suddenly, to Paris and his first visit was to you."
"I have confessed, Monsieur, that those letters were my weakness, I could
not endure this sudden separation from the children and from their father
too. I have told you he was my only friend. It is true he came to see me but
he brought the children. I had had to appeal to him for this certificate of
reinstatement. I was aware then, Messieurs, only too poignantly aware, of
these scandals that you have mentioned which are supposed to have run round
Paris for months. It was a question of my honour, my livelihood."
M. de Tassy interrupted:
"This letter—you knew well enough the Duchess would not give it you.
No doubt her husband demanded it of her—what is the
result?—yesterday morning she was murdered."
"There is no one whose horror of that crime could be greater than
M. de Viou scribbled a note on a sheet torn from his pocket-book and
handed it to M. de Tassy. The Prefet de Police read it, then, exclaiming: "A
good point!" turned again to the prisoner:
"You say that you knew nothing of any scandal until M. l'Abbé Galle spoke
to you—yet it is well known to members of the family Montlosier Boccage
that on the return from your visit to Corsica, which shocked everyone, you
went to M. Le Maréchal de Frediani, seemingly outraged by comments in the
"That is true. Friends of mine pointed out some paragraphs—"
"Friends?—what friends have you?"
"Probably none. Monsieur, I had friends when I was more fortunate. I was
so hurt by these illusions that I wished to leave M. du Boccage—I asked
M. de Frediani to bear witness to my behaviour in Corsica. He did so, he
begged me, with all respect, to remain with his daughter—he said such
scribblings were nothing, that the republican papers libelled all the members
of the aristocracy—that I was to ignore such vile rubbish. I did
"Yet, after this conversation, you were surprised when M. l'Abbé Galle
spoke to you of the trouble you were causing in the house of Madame du
The candid eyes of the governess expressed surprise as she answered:
"Certainly, Monsieur. How could I suspect that Madame du Boccage was
disturbed by stupid gossip that her own father had assured me was beneath the
notice of even a poor creature like myself?"
M. Mauzisse pulled at his beard with a movement of irritation, but M. de
Tassy continued, undisturbed by the prisoner's strategy; he changed his
ground and made an attack in an unexpected quarter.
"Matilde Bernard, maid to Madame du Boccage, swears that on the morning of
your departure from the Faubourg St. Honoré she came upon you—in your
own room, in the arms of M. le Duc."
"Servants spy and lie. Monsieur, as a matter of habit. This woman followed
M. le Duc day and night—she could give you an analysis of all his
movements. But it happens to be true that she saw me in his arms. I had been
packing, I was very upset at this sudden dismissal, M. le Duc came to take my
keys. At the moment of giving them I was seized by an attack of
giddiness—I was about to fall, M. de Due caught me—it is possible
that you, Monsieur, might have done the same."
"We are not here to speculate on that, Mademoiselle. The woman Bernard
maintains that you said, on being discovered—'Go and tell your mistress
where and how you found M. le Duc.'"
"That is a lie. And a stupid one. You perceive the creature's despicable
mind!" The prisoner's contempt was icy.
"Well, what did you say?"
"I cannot remember—I have said I was half unconscious—I
thought nothing of the support of M. le Duc."
M. de Tassy, exasperated by the tenacity of this woman who thus defended
herself inch by inch, directly accused her:
"M. du Boccage committed this murder at your instigation. You were his
mistress—you wished at any cost to return to the Faubourg St. Honoré.
It was you who inspired him to replace the plaster of the baldaquin with wax,
and to keep, in case of an opportunity, a cord on his person and poison in
Lucille Debelleyme's bright eyes flickered from one to another of the
grim, hostile faces confronting her but she did not wince.
"If Madame du Boccage had died naturally and M. du Boccage had offered me
his hand I should, out of affection for the children, have refused to consent
to a marriage which would have discredited them, and I happen to be.
Monsieur, the type of woman who has no other thoughts of any connection with
a man than marriage. He was not my lover—he did not plan to make me his
wife. Surely there is something in my accents which will convince you that I
speak the truth?"
"Your accents may be all very well," replied M. de Tassy, "but your matter
is incredible. If there was no tie, no feeling whatever between you and M. du
Boccage, why did he retain you in his household in the face of the frantic
entreaties of his wife, of the threats of his father-in-law, of the murmurs
of public opinion, of the warnings of the Royal Family?"
"I did not know that he had done so." The governess raised her head with a
movement that seemed triumphant. "If that is so, Messieurs, no doubt it was
because I was able to make his children happy and produce some order into his
"Ah, Mademoiselle, you allocate to yourself an impossible virtue. You are,
on your own admission, penniless, friendless, helpless, a nobody. You have
created a good deal of mystery and romance about yourself but you are merely
the illegitimate daughter of one Lucille Clery, and your father is unknown
even to yourself. Your one relative, Desire Gavaudan de Clery, a man of
dubious character, disowns you. You have been earning your own living since
you were about eighteen, you have gone from one place to another, never
remaining very long anywhere."
"But," interrupted Lucille Debelleyme, smiling, "I have always taken away
with me, Messieurs, the most excellent testimonials."
"That may be, Mademoiselle, but your training, your circumstances, your
prospects make it most unlikely that you would have been able to resist a man
like M. du Boccage, cultured, charming, elegant, wealthy, one with whom, as
you confess, you had many tastes in common, but unfortunately, easily led by
a dominating woman—a man whom you admit you regard with tender
The governess smiled again; she did not find these magistrates so
terrifying, she could more than hold her own with them.
"Perhaps I should not have resisted him," she answered quietly. "But have
I not told you, Messieurs, that he never made love to me? Perhaps, as you
say, if he had laid siege to me I should not have been able to preserve my
honour against one who, as you so rightly judge, seemed so attractive to a
miserable nobody like myself. Maybe my gratitude, my loyalty would have made
me sacrifice to M. du Boccage my reputation, my honour, though it never could
have inspired me to insinuate to him a design to touch one hair of his wife's
head; but he never offered me any manner of love."
"I never heard a prisoner so obstinate!" exclaimed M. de Viou,
"Perhaps, Monsieur, you never heard one so innocent."
"Bah!" M. de Tassy rose with calculated violence. "You are lying, go back
to your cell and consider if it is wise to continue lying."
But when the prisoner had been led out, he turned to his colleagues and
threw up his hands in a gesture of despair.
Hatred, desire for vengeance, cruel curiosity beat against
the wall of the prison where the governess was enclosed.
This central figure of this unparalleled scandal regarded all who passed
before her with a fixed gaze, she was well trained to repel spiteful
scrutiny. She remained an enigma to all those who were permitted to visit her
in her cell or to watch her taking her hour's exercise slowly walking to and
fro, wearing the light nankeen dress adorned with white soutache, in
the narrow courtyard between the four prison façades, grim with barred
She had been offered the consolations of a priest, but remembering the
Abbé Galle, who had struck one of the first blows towards her downfall, she
She had equally disdained the religious books offered her by the wardress,
but she took from among her own possessions a small volume of fashionable
poems given her by a former pupil, and this was constantly in her hands
either when she sat in her cell or when she walked in the dreary little
She murmured over again and again to herself the sentimental foolish
lines—they served to keep her from thinking.
Daily one or more of the judges, lawyers or police visited and questioned
her; they believed, in common with the rest of Paris, that this extraordinary
woman held the key to this crime, so terrible as to be almost incredible.
She learnt from their accusing words how the whole country was shaken by
this brutal murder. Not that murders of this kind did not happen almost every
day, but no one paid much attention when some miserable wretch in a slum
raised his hand against a nagging wife or a jealous mistress.
It was the rank, the wealth of the victim, still more the rank, the wealth
of the murderer, which roused this fury of class feeling. The angry mob that
the police could hardly keep in check outside the Hotel du Boccage wanted not
so much justice as to assure themselves that the great nobleman would receive
the same punishment as an insignificant villain, and, behind this increasing
clamour, led and inflamed by furious articles in the press, was the savage
desire to see the head of a peer of France roll on the guillotine step. There
was an explosion of rage against the House of Peers, against the aristocracy,
against the King himself, against the whole insolent, arrogant world of money
and leisure which, in the eyes of the people, had fallen into disrepute with
the murder at the Hotel du Boccage.
Lucille Debelleyme listened to the threats and denunciations of her
examiners without betraying herself; she was neither hysterical nor defiant,
and all her answers had a cold common sense at variance with her romantic
history, her extraordinary circumstances.
Repeatedly she asked: "Has M. du Boccage admitted he is a murderer?" and
they were forced to answer "No."
She then demanded: "If the Duke had been arrested?" Again the answer was
"No—he is still being watched in his own Hotel, as the King could not
bring himself to sign a decree for the arrest of a peer of France the affair
was held in suspension; M. du Boccage was continually being examined but he
had fallen into a low state of health and refused to answer official
questions." The elaborate and detailed denials with which he had at first
defended himself had given place to sullen, brief excuses. "He was too
overcome, he was too fatigued, he had nothing to say."
His brother, his friends had been allowed to visit him, the Maréchal de
Frediani was being called back from Corsica; meanwhile, a most sumptuous
funeral, attended by everyone of consequence in France, had been given in the
Madeleine for the victim—the martyr, the chaste and stainless woman,
the devoted wife, the loving mother, pious, blameless Fanny du Boccage,
already canonised by the grief of a people.
Lucille Debelleyme listened to these accounts, which the police hoped
would strike some emotional admission from her, with downcast eyes.
Exasperated by this enigma M. de Tassy said:
"Well, Mademoiselle, have you nothing to say, no expression of grief or
horror even for this tragedy in which you were so closely concerned? Do you
not at least condemn the horrible crime which the man whom you call your
friend, your protector, has committed?"
"M. du Boccage, according to your own account, M. le Prefect, has not
confessed he is a murderer. Why, therefore, should I assume him guilty when I
do not even know the whole details of the case, when you are my only
informer, when what you say is obviously designed to frighten me, to impress
me with the fact that he is a criminal?"
"He is and you are his accomplice. Remember. Mademoiselle, we have your
"You will learn nothing from them except my devotion to this man and my
love for his children, my pity for his situation, my desire to help the one
person who has been kind to me." Quietly raising her brilliant eyes she
added: "I would now willingly give my life for his, my one regret at my
present situation is that it prevents me going to him."
"Are you as shameless as all that; you have the effrontery to say that you
would go to him, in the face of everything, through the blood of his murdered
"Through anything. Monsieur; he is my friend; it is your misfortune if you
cannot understand the power of friendship. He must be suffering, be in
torment. He and I—" and here a note of wild exultation swept her
careful voice out of control, "should be together now; alone, out of all
Paris, out of all France we perhaps understand each other."
"That is a dangerous admission, Mademoiselle. I believe you have confessed
a little too much; no doubt you and M. du Boccage understood each other only
"It is impossible for friends to understand each other too well."
"Remember we have your letters."
"Search them, Monsieur, through and through—you will find you are
cruelly slandering an innocent woman—maybe. God help you, an innocent
Her looks, her manners, her gestures would have carried a conviction of
innate sincerity, of the dignity and candour of innocence had not it seemed
so unlikely that what she said was true.
M. de Tassy remained amazed at her art, her fortitude, but certain of her
guilt. He was forced to close one enquiry after another without having
obtained anything from Lucille Debelleyme to damage either herself or M. du
Boccage. M. de Tassy grimly admired the courage whereby this young woman,
without a friend, without advice, surrounded by enemies, in an awful
position, under the very shadow of the guillotine, thus defended herself with
skill and a proud dignity behind which seemed to sparkle the vehement passion
of innocence falsely accused.
For a week the ex-governess of the Faubourg St. Honoré endured the
tortures of her position with the stoicism of an Indian brave at the stake.
She was under perpetual surveillance, even at night she would be wakened
suddenly in the hope of startling her into some exclamation that might prove
an admission of guilt.
When she walked in the little garden into which the autumn sunshine
penetrated for only a short time, police, journalists, men of letters, all
the inquisitive people who could contrive to bribe a way into the
Conciergerie regarded her with insatiable curiosity from behind the grilled
windows of the prison. They saw a slight figure in a neat pale dress, with
long, fair curls hanging on her shoulders, a lace scarf tied round her head,
walking to and fro with measured steps, her eyes fastened on a book she held
in her slender hand.
She made no attempt to attract any pity, not by so much as an upward
glance did she appeal to those who pressed their faces against the bars of
the upper window, staring at her as if she had been the inhabitant of some
unknown world suddenly caught and caged.
The more sensitive of those who so cruelly observed her found her
beautiful with that beauty which does not consist only in exactitude of
feature but in the grace, the poise, the air of the entire person. She was
elegant, composed, dignified beyond what seemed possible to expect of a woman
in her circumstances.
Some men said that they could understand the fatal infatuation of M. du
Boccage, but not one of all those who peered and spied and commented and
judged Lucille Debelleyme felt for her the least sympathy.
All pity, all compassion, all respect and admiration had been lavished on
the woman who lay in the gilt and purple velvet coffin, heavy with armorial
bearings, hidden beneath a mountain of costly flowers in the sombre
black-hung aisles of the Madeleine.
M. de Tassy did not fail to detail to Lucille Debelleyme the amazing
scenes of public grief at this funeral, the frantic tokens of veneration, of
love that followed the mutilated remains of her former mistress to the vaults
of the Madeleine—the extravagant wreaths and immense bouquets that even
the very poorest had sent to do honour to one so beloved, so wronged.
The governess coolly remarked: "Poor woman! Had I had the means I, too,
would have liked to have sent a wreath."
Debelleyme was left alone in a solitude which he hoped would wear down her
She was warned, however, that they were searching through her
correspondence, through that of the Duke, through papers and letters of
Madame du Boccage. Her warder and the curious who continued to watch her when
she walked in the garden left her in no doubt as to the violent emotion of
the people, the popular fury, even the prospect of a revolution if she and
her paramour were not brought to justice.
She maintained her calm, behind which seemed to surge a fierce
No one could surprise her into tears; on all occasions she conducted
herself with a brave coolness that provoked a reluctant admiration but
alienated all possible sympathies.
One morning as she walked up and down the narrow courtyard (she never
refused to take this exercise, though well aware to what it exposed her) a
republican journalist pressing against the bars of one of the lower windows
exclaimed, loud enough for her to hear: "A charming but a wicked woman."
The governess raised her brilliant eyes from her little book and, turning
her elegant head, looked full at the young man with a glance he was never to
forget and never to remember without a sense of uneasiness.
"Do you really know what wickedness is?" she demanded. "Even were I judged
and condemned, you would be bold to apply that word to me."
That afternoon she was again summoned before M. de Tassy and his
colleagues. She was observed to tremble a little as she passed into the room
where they subjected her to their interrogations; she asked the wardress who
accompanied her for a glass of water. This was given her and she seemed to
recover her composure, but when she entered the room and glanced at those
hostile figures, those stern, accusing faces, she requested, for the first
time, permission to seat herself. "Was it possible," thought M. de Tassy,
"that she was, at last, weakening?" A chair was given her—she waited
with folded hands and downcast eyes, as so often she had awaited the
inspection of a new employer, the commands of a mistress, the judgment of a
superior. M. de Tassy began:
"Well, Mademoiselle, this terrible affair is now a little different from
when we questioned you last."
"Is that so, Monsieur? As you know, I am totally ignorant of what is
occurring in Paris."
"We will enlighten you. It is now certain M. du Boccage committed this
"Has he confessed?"
"He has confessed in the only fashion which, a man of his birth could use;
by committing another crime he has escaped the punishment of the first."
The Prefet de Police paused, watching with cold interest the young woman,
who moved slightly on her chair, fumbled with her handkerchief, raised it to
her lips and dropped it again.
"Has he confessed?" she asked again, her composure a little blurred.
"He is dead. Mademoiselle, dead in prison. He did the only thing he could
do, he swallowed arsenic."
"Dead in prison," repeated Lucille Debelleyme in an expressionless
"He was arrested at five in the morning, and taken to the prison of the
Luxembourg, Mademoiselle. He was then already a dying man, he had brought
arsenic with him from Javiaux du Boccage. As soon as he saw he was suspected
he drank this frightful poison. He has judged and punished himself—he
has gone before God to answer for this crime—leaving you. Mademoiselle,
the responsibility before human justice."
The judges then had, at last, the satisfaction of seeing their victim lose
her inhuman calm; she sprang from her seat with an involuntary movement of
horror, as if she recoiled from a terrible sight.
"Dead—he is dead!" The waiting, watchful men were silent. "And I
knew nothing about it," she continued. "I was never told—if I had been
there perhaps he would not have done it."
"Mademoiselle, there was nothing else for him to do. By his action,
frightful as it is, he has at least spared the peerage the disgrace of seeing
the head of a Montlosier du Boccage in the basket of the guillotine."
Falling into her chair, Lucille Debelleyme asked in a low voice:
"Did he suffer?"
"The torments of the damned, Mademoiselle. It is not easy to die by
"Laudanum, that's better," she muttered, her hands to her mouth, "why
didn't he use the laudanum?"
"Ah, you know, then, he had laudanum?"
Even in that moment she did not allow them to gain an advantage over
"You yourself told me that," she replied.
She sat crouched and rigid, she seemed to have shrunk under their eyes so
that it was to them as if they looked at the figure of a child.
M. de Tassy rose to his feet. This was surely the moment to strike a final
blow that would extract, in this agony of grief, the truth from Lucille
Debelleyme, who had just learnt that she had no accomplice to shield, no
friend to fight for, no protector on whom she might, however fantastically,
hope to rely in the future.
Leaning forward and pressing his hands on the table, M. de Tassy
"Confess, Mademoiselle, have pity upon yourself, offer the only reparation
in your power—that of the truth."
Still drooping on her chair and shading her eyes with her hands the
"You know all."
"Ah, you admit then that we are right."
"Right in what, Messieurs? You have examined my letters. No doubt by now
you have gone into my life day by day, month by month, year by year,
therefore you must know everything about me. I have no secrets." Then, as if
to herself, as if trying to understand this new and awful fact, she murmured:
"He is dead—he is dead."
M. de Tassy took advantage of this indication of anguish and, hoping to
overwhelm and break her by telling her of the torture of the man whom they
still regarded as her lover and accomplice, he began to relate the details of
the death of M. du Boccage.
To the rage of the people, denied its prey, he had taken arsenic, not, as
was falsely believed, with the connivance of the Chamber of Peers and his
relatives, desperately anxious to avoid a horrible public scandal; he took it
immediately he had believed himself suspected. He had bad ample leisure, for
M. le Duc Pasquier had, by invoking the authority of the Chamber of Peers,
resisted the desire of the police to arrest the suspect.
Despite all the efforts of a number of doctors to keep him alive the Duke
had died after a week of torment. He had a strong constitution and was in
perfect health—he had resisted for several days the inroads of the
deadly poison. During the last few days of his life he had been incessantly
questioned by the representative of the Chamber of Peers, their indomitable
chancellor M. le Duc Pasquier, who endeavoured to force an admission of
At this point Lucille Debelleyme broke into the impassive official
"Ah, the old man, blind with cataract—I remember him," she
whispered—"Despite these—torments M. du Boccage confessed
"There was no need—his terrible action betrayed all."
"He confessed nothing?" persisted the governess and M. de Tassy admitted
that M. du Boccage had died without a direct avowal of the crime passing his
lips—he did not add that the Duke's last word, in answer to the stern
question: "Are you guilty?" had been: "No!"
"Then," said the governess, suddenly lowering her hands and looking at her
examiners directly, "If he has died without confessing he could have said
nothing of an accomplice. Therefore why do your suspicions continue to fall
"Reason, logic, common sense. I know, too, that criminals always lie. It
is very natural."
"This is merely your assumption," she parried, "you have talked much of my
letters, of my correspondence with M. du Boccage—you have had time
enough to read this now, and carefully, too, every line I wrote. Well,
Messieurs, what did you find in them?"
Her judges were silent, admitting nothing, retracting nothing,
intimidating her by their immobility. The truth was that though her letters
might give rise to strong suspicions of guilt, they contained no actual
proofs of either adultery or murder. The ones to M. du Boccage were, indeed,
couched in such terms as she would address to one who was a protector, friend
and affectionate master; in brief, every line she had written, and the few
short, badly expressed letters of the Duke to her, confirmed the almost
incredible relationship that she had avowed existed between them; neither
could the cold eyes of justice see in the impassioned letters of the victim,
nor in her diary, any proof that Madame du Boccage was actually convinced
that the governess was her husband's mistress.
As the formidable silence continued, Lucille Debelleyme's gaze wandered
from the group of watchful men; she appeared to forget she was not alone.
Leaning on the back of the chair she twisted her fingers together and
whispered: "so they are orphans, the little ones whom I loved so much. He,
too, was more a friend than a master during two years! I have received from
him such proofs of goodness and affection—he never said a hard word to
me—never! He did all he could to help me and so often I needed
help—he is dead—dead in a prison—in agony! That terrible
blind old man! They say that I provoked this awful tragedy."
She looked up suddenly as if again aware she was being watched, listened
to. "Never believe that he premeditated this crime, he was the best, the most
excellent of men, he became mad! Oh, if you knew what his home was. Anyone
might have lost their reason in the middle of that hell."
"Ah, Mademoiselle, you admit that the Hotel du Boccage was a hell?"
"Not through me. Look at me! Do I look like the sort of woman to plot
adultery and murder in the shadow of an infant's cradle?"
The melodrama of these words were counteracted by her grave and clear
accent. "It is impossible," she added.
The judges did not give way. M. de Tassy made a last effort:
"The crime was premeditated. You have heard of the wax inserted in the
baldaquin, of the cord that M. du Boccage wore twisted round his braces, you
know of the two phials of poison, laudanum and arsenic, he carried in his
pocket. Come, is it not true that you regarded the death of Madame du
Boccage, who was so justly outraged against you, as the only chance of your
return to this household?"
"I never thought that, therefore it would be impossible for me to inspire
another with it."
"We have read your correspondence, Mademoiselle. In these last letters you
wrote to the Duke you mention several times your hopes for the future, you
dwell on the paradise of Javiaux du Boccage, you appear to look forward to
happy days again amid these splendours—to you so novel, so
entrancing—what is the meaning of that?"
The governess smiled, a convulsive movement of the lips that painfully
distorted her face: "Can one who is about to commit a frightful crime talk of
happy days ahead? Is it not well known that when one is guilty that there is
no more peace or happiness?"
"Well, then, Mademoiselle, to what did you refer? What was this charming,
this peaceful future amid the delights of Javiaux du Boccage to be?"
"Messieurs, I comforted myself with the way of delusion, of dreams, as the
utterly wretched will. Perhaps, understanding so little of the real
grievances of Madame du Boccage against me I hoped that she might relent.
Perhaps I was thinking of the future, when my dear pupils would be all grown
up—mothers themselves. Messieurs, how can I recall what I thought of
when I wrote those letters from the fullness of my heart? All I know was that
no idea of any crime disturbed me."
The examiners rose. "Very well. Mademoiselle, you will have nothing
further to say to us, that is clear. It now only remains to send you before a
commission of the Chamber of Peers who have been appointed to investigate
this dismal affair."
The governess stood up with an almost imperceptible movement of terror:
"Now, without any preparation?—with none to advise?"
"If you are as innocent as you say you need no preparation or advice."
With a final movement of pride she held her head high, with that peculiar
carriage that gave her an air of unconquerable fortitude. "Very well,
Messieurs, I am ready."
The usher conducted her down the corridor into another room; there a
high-set window cast a cold light on a table where another group of men
awaited her. They were representatives of the Chamber of Peers who had been
appointed to conduct the Du Boccage affair. Most of them had been present at
the relentless investigation of the dying man in the cell in the Luxembourg
where another criminal had recently attempted suicide, and some of them had
been present at the Chateau d'Eu when Louis Philippe, his hand unsteady from
anguish, had signed the decree for the arrest of his friend, one of the most
powerful supporters of his House, exclaiming:
"The wretch! he has done worse than he knows!"
The chairman of this small committee of aristocrats was M. le Duc
Pasquier. He leant forward on the table, slightly to the left, for his right
eye was almost completely covered by a cataract; his huge chin was swathed in
folds of batiste which came high on his sagging cheeks, on which the white
whiskers made a sharp line. He was dry, implacable, hard, the only witness of
the torture of M. du Boccage who had been unmoved, though he had afterwards
declared—"it was the most terrible death-bed he had ever, in his long
Lucille Debelleyme had always regarded him with instinctive terror; she
had now some reason for what had been a senseless hatred. She looked away
from the Chancellor to his companions and sensed at once the difference
between them and the lawyers and police she had just left; these were not
official investigators of crime, impartial administrators of justice, but
gentlemen of high birth, who found themselves in an unprecedented position,
faced by an unpleasant task, overwhelmed by the disgrace, perhaps the
distress, brought on their order by this fantastic crime on the part of one
of their members. In the youngest there, the blond Comte du Bondy,
Mademoiselle shivered to recognise a certain likeness to M. du Boccage. An
easy chair was set for her, she was addressed courteously. M. Decaze asked
her if the sun was in her eyes; none of them stared at her offensively, as
had her other judges, and one or two were plainly distressed and embarrassed.
But she knew that in M. Pasquier she had a more terrible opponent than even
in the iron M. de Tassy.
He began with a quiet, ruthless onslaught:
"Mademoiselle, I was present, day and night, during the last hours of M.
du Boccage. I know all. Confess, therefore, your part in this horrible affair
and let justice be finally satisfied."
"I have nothing to confess."
"Think again. I know all." The white-ringed eyes fixed her with contempt.
Suddenly he demanded: "What were your last words to M. du Boccage?"
The prisoner's hands tightened on the back of her chair; the picture of
the room in the Rue Keller was so intense before her eyes that it seemed
absurd that these men could not see it too; had he, tortured by the arsenic,
broken by the pitiless interrogation, half delirious, betrayed her? Her last
words: "I shall expect of you some action."
"Please answer, Mademoiselle."
"It is difficult to recall what seemed, at the time, so unimportant.
Probably—'Good-bye, Monsieur'—the children, Isabelle, Cesarine,
were present, we were all talking together."
"There was not promise of a further meeting?"
"Did you think, then, you might never see him again?"
"Why should I? I believed that I might see him when I went to the Hotel du
Boccage the following day for my interview with Madame—"
"Had you any hope of obtaining this certificate of good character, so
essential to you?"
"Very little, since I knew Madame had sent the Abbé Galle to urge Madame
to ask for it."
"Why, then, did you make this attempt, this appeal?"
"Ah, Monsieur, will not the desperate, the cornered, make the most
foolish, the most pitiful of efforts—of mistakes?"
"To what do you attribute the ardent desire on the part of so many
important, intelligent people, to remove you from Paris?"
"To the unreasonable jealousy of Madame du Boccage, to the relentless
schemes of her toadies."
This bold answer astonished them.
"Do you endeavour to prejudice us against Madame du Boccage, an angel of
charity, of devotion, of piety, this saint, this martyr? That will not do
your cause much good, Mademoiselle."
"I speak the truth as I have seen it before my eyes for two years.
Saint—martyr—what you will—I know what she made that house.
I do not defend myself—why should I? I have nothing to defend. I do not
lie—I have no need to lie. I thought you wished from me some
enlightenment on the cause of this, to you, incomprehensible tragedy—I
endeavour to give it to you. Yet I always speak in the dark, for I do not
know if indeed M. du Boccage murdered his wife."
"I do," replied M. Pasquire. M. Decaze, tall and elegant, with thinning
hair and lively eyes, who had been a personal friend of M. du Boccage, here
asked if he might speak to the prisoner. The Chancellor assented.
The Due Decaze chose gentle methods.
"Mademoiselle, I was present with the prisoner during those last frightful
hours of his life. He was guilty and he punished himself. He was my friend
and I am thankful that he escaped the unspeakable ignominy of a public
"He did not confess?" said the governess, looking steadily at this new
"Not in words."
"He said nothing of any accomplice, then?"
"In any case, he would not have said that. He was, at the last, true to
his breeding. He betrayed no one; he would not even say where he had
purchased the arsenic."
"But the police are almost certain that it was at that shop in the Rue
Keller," put in the Chancellor.
The governess gave a cry which she quickly explained:
"My hand—I clutched the chair—I was not thinking." She showed
a bandaged palm. "I hurt myself."
"How, Mademoiselle?" demanded the Chancellor sternly, suspecting an
attempt at another suicide. "Were you allowed knives?"
"No, nor any weapon, nor any cord—you see, these ugly buttons have
been put on my shoes that used to lace"—she put out her pretty foot and
smiled fixedly. "I blistered my hand before I was arrested. It festers."
M. le Duc Decaze resumed his examination, which he put on a lofty plane of
which M. Pasquier cynically disapproved.
"Mademoiselle, before M. du Boccage died he saw a priest, I knelt at the
head of his bed—M. l'Abbé de Noirlieu brought him the last
sacraments—this calmed him—he admitted that he was
relieved—Voltairean as he was, he declared that he felt more at ease
and begged for a little crucifix to hold on his breast—"
Lucille Debelleyme listened without flinching to this account of the final
repentance of a fellow atheist.
"If that is true, it is very extraordinary," she remarked.
"My word of honour that it is true."
"Well, Monsieur, is it not also true that the dying suffer from
M. Decaze was slightly discomposed: she took advantage of that to add:
"And what is the object of relating this to me?"
The Due Decaze replied:
"To soften your heart, to induce you to also ease yourself by a
repentance, by expiation—to warn you of that final hour which will come
to you also when you too will need a priest, a crucifix—to reveal to
you the wordless confession of your lover, your accomplice—to move you
to give that confession which alone can clear up the mystery of this
M. Pasquier, who disliked the sentimental tone of this, added:
"Come, Mademoiselle, you can no longer avoid giving us the clue to this
Lucille Debelleyme rose in one swift movement; she seemed in a second to
have become the accuser, not the accused.
"The clue? Look for it then in the character of Madame du Boccage; in the
actions of this saint and martyr, not in mine, you must look for the causes
of this crime."
"What, Mademoiselle, do you mean to insinuate that Madame du Boccage
deserved her fate? Do you attempt to excuse the murderer by giving faults to
"Perhaps," said the governess erect and rigid; a movement went among the
men facing her. "Madame du Boccage requires no advocate—all the world
is ready to venerate her, to mourn her, to repeat her eulogies. I speak for
him—I have just heard he is dead. I will not be disloyal to my one
friend. I tell you that this saint of yours drove that man mad; through his
madness she perished, all glorify her. But he—what has happened to him?
The worse agony, the most horrible death."
Even the Chancellor was silent, for she seemed to speak with all her body,
all her soul, her words were only part of her violent expression of some deep
"Seek, I say, in the nature, in the actions of this stupid, jealous,
uncontrolled, violent woman, in her rages, her scenes, her espionages, her
reproaches, her endless letters, her bigotry, her persistent
pursuit—not in me—the causes of this crime. Find in the fury of a
woman who loved and was not loved the cause of this murder!"
M. Pasquier rose.
"Enough. We will hear no more. The prisoner is obdurate. We waste our
time, our appeals before a heart so hard, a conscience so
callous—before a woman capable of no generous impulse, no tender
He began to leave his place; the others rose; the Chancellor's almost
blind eyes turned in the direction where he dimly perceived the prisoner to
"Enough of evasion. M. du Boccage was a brute, a monster, his martyred
wife was a saint, and you, Mademoiselle the governess, I need not name
you—you know what you are. The examination is closed."
For a moment Lucille Debelleyme appeared overwhelmed by this denunciation,
all the lustre of passion and pride, left her; she remained drooping by the
chair as the peers began to file out of the narrow door where the usher
waited. But before the first had left, she had recovered herself.
"Stop, Messieurs. One thing more." They paused, grouped between the table
and door, holding their hats and gloves. "Messieurs, you have evoked the
crucifix. I have seen, in this wretched prison, symbols of the Christian
faith—above my bed there also hangs a crucifix—well, I have this
to say to you. M. Pasquier has spoken of the Due du Boccage as a monster, he
has branded me as a creature of nameless infamy—no doubt you all
M. de Bondy, openly agitated, made a gesture of dissent. "Ah,
then—not all! I know I speak now, not to the agents of the police, to
lawyers who see evil everywhere, but to gentlemen. Well, then, this—if
M. du Boccage was this monster, if I am an infamous woman—is it given
to you to judge?"
"We act for worldly justice, yes," replied the Chancellor.
"But you have spoken of God. From men, neither he, dying in atrocious
torments—nor I, alone, as I have often been reminded, outcast,
nameless, homeless, degraded by universal suspicion, have had one word of
compassion. Not one word of compassion. Monsieur!"
"You have not deserved it. Mademoiselle," said M. Pasquier.
"Would not, for that reason, your Christ give it us? Would not your God be
with us, rather than with her? Already canonised, you say! But I think the
Christ you quote descended into hell." Looking at her bandaged hand, she
added: "If he had himself told me he had done this, planned it, I would have
gone to him, comforted him—even if it meant drawing suspicion on
myself. Has not your Christ as much loyalty, as much love as a wretch like
"Ah!" exclaimed M. Pasquier. "You admit, then, Mademoiselle,
"To love, yes. Not to adultery. Cannot you discern the difference?"
M. Decaze gently touched the Chancellor on the arm. "The time has passed
for attempts at traps, my dear friend. Neither has confessed—it is
finished. Let us indeed leave them to God." Turning to the young woman he
said in a lower tone:
"What is your object in reminding us, Mademoiselle, of Christ's
She put her hands to her throat, as if to ease some constriction there,
and the gesture horribly reminded M. Decaze of M. du Boccage when, no longer
able to swallow, he had clutched at the muscles atrophied by the action of
"To ask for yours. Whatever he did, he has expiated. Do you not think that
I shall also? Imagine the rest of my life. I loved him. I loved his
The Chancellor made a movement of disgust, but M. Decaze and M. de Bondy
restrained him from speech.
"Ah, shrink from me. Monsieur Pasquier! You should be satisfied. The more
I loved, the more I shall be punished. I do not believe in your Christ whom
you use to frighten children and the dying—for you, His followers, do
not follow His impossible example!"
The young Comte de Bondy broke into hurried, nervous speech:
"These are dreadful words, Mademoiselle. A priest attended M. du Boccage
with eager pity—he could attend you—"
"Yes, for the same purpose, to extort a confession! A priest cast the
first stone at me, in the Faubourg St. Honoré. I want no priests. But if your
God were real, I think He would have pitied me."
"What," asked M. Decaze, "do you want of us?"
"I said—your compassion. Your justice, too. Do not leave me with the
brand of an adulteress—of murderess." With a sudden drop of speech, of
look, she added flatly: "I have always been most respectable. I have
The peers glanced at each other, all of them were perturbed; those who had
seen the deathbed of M. du Boccage felt that here was something beyond human
"You want your release?" asked M. Decaze.
"No, M. le Duc, my exoneration."
M. de Bondy put in eagerly:
"What, after all, is there against her? Nothing in her letters, nothing in
her replies, nothing in her conduct! All that we have to go on is public
opinion, gossip of servants, the vulgar interpretation of certain
appearances—all things which must be rejected by men of reason and
M. Pasquier shrugged; he had already heard from M. Mauzisse that the case
against the governess had completely broken down. This examination before the
Committee of Peers had been a last attempt to extract a confession; he spoke
aside to M. Decaze, who said:
"Mademoiselle, this ends your examination. You will hear the result
Caressing her injured hand in silence, the governess made a vague
As the peers hastened down the dirty corridors of the prison M. de Bondy
"That is a remarkable woman! What imperious grace! What dignity! What
With a melancholy smile M. Decaze asked:
"Are you, too, becoming infatuated with Lucille Debelleyme?"
The young man shuddered:
"Mon Dieu! I hope I shall never see her again!"
The next day Lucille Debelleyme was told that she was free.
The released prisoner stepped out of a side door of the
Conciergerie early on a September morning; she wore the pale nankeen dress
with the white soutache and the straw bonnet with the lilac-coloured
ruffles, and ribbons which had become famous throughout Paris. As the door
closed behind her she hesitated; a crowd of journalists, of curious strangers
awaited her. They pressed round with suggestions, requests, half insolent,
half inquisitive, wholly malicious.
What had she to say to the press? To these powerful papers who had led the
hue and cry against her?
"Had she not written some memoirs justifying herself while she was in
prison?"—"Would she give permission to have her correspondence with M.
du Boccage published?"—"Was it true that various scoundrels seeking
notoriety had offered to marry her?"—"Where was she going
now?"—"What was her name—so many stories had spread round
Paris—was it Lucille Clery, Lucille Debelleyme, Mary Showler—was
she English, Italian, Corsican?"—"Could she not, for one of the more
enterprising papers, write a story of her life?"
She leant against the prison door, like the fox when the hounds surround
him at last; no one had the least pity, they thronged closer with their
greedy enquiries, their insatiable curiosity...
She came forward with a sudden movement which caused them to step back,
then raised her brilliant glance that few could encounter with equanimity,
and said, with the very essence of scorn:
"It is permitted, Messieurs, to pass?"
They fell away, muttering, and one youth showed the chivalry that she had
disdained to implore; he thrust his notebook in his pocket and, pulling off
his hat, came forward.
"Where are you going. Mademoiselle? Can I escort you? I fear it will not
be very pleasant for you when you are recognised."
She considered him, he had a fresh, boyish face under his tasselled
"Get a carriage," she said. "There are several waiting outside the
He did so—then hesitated at the door of the cab after she had got
in, feeling that here was a lost professional chance; she looked at him
"I have nothing to tell anyone—nothing. I have, however, a favour to
"A favour, Mademoiselle?"
"Yes—can you tell me where M. du Boccage is buried?"
The young journalist showed troubled reluctance but he could not for long
resist the insistent gaze of the woman, more imperious than imploring fixed
"In The Cemetery of the South—it was very quiet—at
night—the police saw to it for fear of the people—"
"Where? How might one find it?"
"I don't know, Mademoiselle—it was, one understands, a pauper's
"Nothing? No stone? No cross?"
"Nothing, Mademoiselle. What would you? It was a secret burial, no priest,
no prayers. We wished we could have found out about it but we did not till
Lucille Debelleyme's large eyes, totally void of expression, continued to
stare at the young man until he coloured and uneasily pulled at his collar,
and asked her where he should direct the carriage? A denser crowd was already
beginning to gather; early as it was, others besides the journalists had
contrived to hear of the release of Lucille Debelleyme.
"The common ditch," she said without answering his question. "Do you know
"No-one knows that. Mademoiselle; I assure you it was kept very quiet,
there was fear of public trouble. Where shall I direct the man?"
"Tell him to drive on, I will think afterwards where I am going."
The young man obeyed, then elbowed his way through the other newspaper men
and the curious who were beginning to surge round the coach and horse.
So, Lucille Debelleyme drove away from the Conciergerie; she did not know
where to go, her grandfather, Madame Trou—she felt ill at the mere
thought of either St. Cloud or the Rue du Harlay. She had no friend, no money
beyond the few sous in her bag; she had been obliged to leave her possessions
in prison until she could give an address to which they could be sent.
After the cab had driven for a few minutes through the misty September
morning, the man stopped, got down off the box and asked his passenger where
she intended to go? Lucille Debelleyme gave the address of Monsieur Santerre;
she added aloud: "Perhaps they will take me in."
The man stared at her, grumbled something uncivil under his breath,
mounted the box and drove to the narrow street near the railway station where
the Santerres lived.
Mademoiselle Debelleyme herself rang the bell; she smiled into the face of
the woman who opened the door and who instantly retreated with a movement of
horror, putting her hands to her mouth.
"Yes, it is I, Lucille Debelleyme—you know all that has happened. I
have nowhere to go, will you take me in, even for one night?"
No one in Paris had followed the tragedy of the Hotel du Boccage with more
horrified interest than this old servant of the murdered Duchess, no one had
lamented Fanny du Boccage more bitterly nor cried out more frequently and
vehemently bitter imprecations on the head of the governess, but when this
simple, superstitious woman saw Lucille Debelleyme, whom justice had
dismissed, against whom no proof could be found but who was dishonoured,
ruined, penniless, she only hesitated a moment. The strongest motive in her
startled mind was that of her sincere but conventional piety. The sinner must
not be turned away, the penitent must not be suffered to depart, a creature
in despair must not be allowed to do a deed of violence.
"Come upstairs, your old room is empty—you remember, you had it the
night you came to Paris."
She opened her bag and paid the coachman and followed Madame Santerre, who
crossed herself continually, up to the little room with the cheap crucifix
above the bed and the high window looking out over Paris.
Madame Santerre, in a timid voice, asked if she should get her
anything—Refreshments? Coffee? Water?
"I was offered all that in the prison, but could not take it then and
cannot take it now."
"A priest, shall I send a priest?"
The governess shook her head.
"I have only need of a little repose, to be by myself. I shall soon think
of something—I shall not trouble you for long. I must find
Madame Santerre, overawed, hesitated by the door. She could not take her
gaze from her fearful visitor.
"Mademoiselle, you would not disgrace me? I want to be charitable. You
would not here... "
"Kill myself?" finished the governess. "No, I can promise you that.
Besides, I have nothing, neither knife nor poison. Perhaps that may come to
me presently, but not now, not here. Be reassured."
As the humble woman still remained horror-stricken and trembling,
reluctant in the doorway. Mademoiselle Debelleyme, who had thrown off her
"Can you do me one favour? Can you tell me the number of the grave of M.
du Boccage in The Cemetery of the South?"
Madame Santerre burst into convulsive sobs and rubbed her eyes with her
rough apron, exclaiming:
"Oh, how can you ask me that?—how dare you ask me that! Oh,
Mademoiselle, what a frightful thing to ask!"
"Why should I not ask, Madame Santerre? Why should I be ashamed to speak
his name? Come, you must know. All his servants and dependants know, or am I
to go to the Comte Edouard or even to his mother?"
Madame Santerre's cries and sobs redoubled:
"Oh, you must not go to her! I entreat you not to go to her! She knows
nothing. The old Maréchal Frediani went himself to comfort her, he has begged
everyone not to tell her, she thinks it was illness, she is blind, she is
old, she knows nothing!"
"No need to tell me all that," said the governess. "I understand the
situation very well. Come, will you give me this number?"
"I believe, Mademoiselle, that it is one thousand and fifty-four."
The woman turned and fled, crossing herself again as if she hastened away
from some tangible evil.
During the time that she had been in the Conciergerie
Lucille Debelleyme had contrived to reflect on nothing, to analyse nothing,
to permit herself neither regrets nor hopes, to blot out her personality in
her situation. She had lived from moment to moment, concerning herself only
with maintaining her fortitude and baffling the efforts of her enemies to
extort from her dangerous confessions. She had read stupid verses until she
knew them by heart, she had counted up to fantastic numbers, she had made up
poems, exercises in English, French and Italian, she had drawn elaborate
geometric designs, she had arranged patterns for embroidery with the pencil
and paper given her, and so she had contrived with mechanical actions of her
hands and lips and by an exercise of an extraordinary willpower to keep
realisation away from her.
Now the strain was over, she was free, she was not overlooked, not spied
on, she did not need to keep herself taut and alert for fear the door would
suddenly open and some unfriendly face look round hoping to surprise her in
disorder, in despair.
Now she could no longer prevent herself from thinking, she locked the
door, turning the clumsy great key with quivering hands and threw herself on
the straight, hard bed, beneath the crucifix.
"He is dead." She could no longer keep that fact at arm's length. That
time he had rushed from her—from the room above the chemist's shop in
the Rue Keller had been an eternal farewell; he and all he meant was gone
from her life for ever.
For their mutual frustration, their mutual tragedy she blamed herself.
"I went too far, I ought to have known with whom I dealt. I did know he
was obtuse, not very intelligent, in the depths of his nature violent and
savage. I should have seen he was being so driven that he did not know what
he did. I should not have held off. Now there is not even that to
remember—that I was once in his arms—frustrated, thwarted. If I
had not denied him he would not have done it."
She dared, for the first time, to try to reconstruct the crime. "Had he
gone straight from her to the apartment of his sleeping wife, crept in, a
murderer indeed, and struck at the wretched woman in her sleep? So his
accusers said. There had been no quarrel, no recrimination? Had he turned,
like a creature at bay, and destroyed savagely what tormented him?"
"How was it done, how long did she suffer, how soon did he come to his
senses, when did he take the poison? How they must have tortured him! Death
by arsenic, I have heard what that means. Why did he not take the laudanum?
And the cord? Was he lying when he told me he had taken that from her, or did
he intend to use it for her destruction, or for mine, or for his own? And the
baldaquin—I remember when I first saw it—"
All this tumult of horrified speculation passed into an agony of
loneliness. That was her predominant feeling. She had been robbed of the one
person whom she loved, who would have protected her, stood by her, who
She sat up suddenly on the bed, jerked to that posture by the sheer
violence of her emotion, and put her fingers to her throat as if she would
strangle herself with her own hands.
The waste of it, the pity of it, and they had dared to cast him into a
pauper's grave—he who had gloried in the magnificence of Javiaux du
Boccage—he so proud, so gay, so fine.
She began to weep, and these, the first tears she had shed, were drawn
from her by sheer pity for his body, distorted with the convulsions of the
poison, mutilated with the surgeon's knife, rotting in the earth, lost, gone,
"I always knew that to think of it, to pause, to realise, would be to give
way—to give way is damnation—well, that has happened now."
She wondered, in bitter fury, what had kept her up so long, why she had so
tenaciously and so skilfully defended this life, this liberty which were so
barren and so useless? She scorned now her own instinct of self-preservation,
her own indomitable pride which had given her such incredible courage. Yet
even now, almost against her own will, she dragged herself out of engulfing
despair. There was one thing she might do, one person to whom she might turn
for some comfort.
The Dowager Duchesse du Boccage sat by a bright fire, for
the autumn days were damp. Her face was in shadow, for she was sitting in a
deeply-hooded leather chair, but the firelight showed her fine blue-veined
hands grasping a small brass crucifix. She was in a complete bewilderment of
grief; these two sudden deaths, apoplexy, cholera, one after the other
without any farewells! Not all the tender soothing of her son, the caresses
of her daughters, the consolations of the Maréchal Frediani, of her friends,
could wholly erase from the blind woman the terror that something worse than
sudden death had occurred. Camille and Fanny! So suddenly, so soon!
Her maid told her with tender respect (the gentle lady was well loved by
everyone who knew her) that a young woman wished to see her; she had come to
solicit some personal charity and had mentioned the name of l'Abbé Galle.
Such visitors were not infrequent in the apartment in the Faubourg St.
Germain where Madame du Boccage spent a peaceful and benevolent old age.
Yet she hesitated, for this was an intrusion on her grief, her mourning,
her rigid retirement from all social duties. She made some anxious
enquiries—the maid said it was a young woman who was veiled and seemed
in much trouble, she had wept as she had made her plea to be allowed to see
Madame la Duchesse du Boccage.
"Admit her, then, Clarise, one must not be cold to the grief of others
because one has so heavy a sorrow oneself."
As the blind woman waited in her hooded, chair by the fire, her hands
still nervously holding the small crucifix sent her by her dead son, and
which she could not bear out of her touch; she heard her maid return and
another step beside that of Clarise.
She said kindly:
"Mademoiselle, you have been sent to me by l'Abbé Galle? Pray come
forward; I am, unfortunately, blind but I can hear very well."
Lucille Debelleyme came to the fireside and stood erect, looking down on
the old, helpless woman. She was staring, she knew, at the one person in
Paris who had not been told her story, to whom her name had not been
mentioned with abhorrence, to whom all her actions had not been depicted in a
bad light, the one person in Paris, in France, who did not know of the
tragedy in the Faubourg St. Honoré, the one person who could speak of Camille
du Boccage with love and respect.
"Who are you?" asked the blind woman into the silence. "Have you a message
from the Abbé Galle? Where are you? I hear nothing."
"Madame, I have no message, I used his name to gain admittance."
Lucille Debelleyme, peering closely into the shadows of the hooded chair,
saw the old woman move uneasily.
"I know that voice though I have not heard it for some time. Who are
"I am Lucille Debelleyme; I was your daughter-in-law's governess. You used
to be kind to me."
The old lady raised the hands holding the small crucifix and placed them
on her breast.
"Why have you stayed away so long? Why do you come now? What do you
"I have not been able to come before, I was ill, what I want is a little
pity, a little friendship."
"I do not understand, Mademoiselle Debelleyme—are you in trouble,
distress? I heard that you had left, that you were no longer in charge of my
grandchildren? Why is that?"
"This double bereavement overwhelms me, Madame, I thought you were the one
person to whom I might speak of... "
She cut her sentence off short and the blind woman, leaning forward, asked
"Speak of what?"
"Of your son, of M. du Boccage."
"Why do you want to come to me to speak of him?"
"Because there is no one else."
She approached the old woman, bending down and speaking in, a low, rapid
"I am in great trouble, I hardly know what to do. You are the person who
might save me."
"Save you from what, Mademoiselle?" The lady shrank back, inexplicable
terror possessed her, she felt on the brink of some insupportable
"What is that crucifix you hold so tightly, so constantly, Madame? Did he
send it to you?" As she spoke she thought: "If only I could get that
crucifix—the last thing he touched—was he thinking of me? He
never betrayed me, no, my darling, you kept our secret though they tortured
you so—and so did I—"
Madame du Boccage felt small, cold fingers close over hers eagerly,
She called loudly:
Lucille Debelleyme drew back to the other side of the hearth, and the
maid, who never stayed long from her blind mistress, instantly entered,
"Clarise, I do not know who this is here but she must not stay, send her
"Mademoiselle, please leave at once!" cried the alarmed maid; "you have
disturbed Madame la Duchesse!"
"You know who I am," urged Lucille Debelleyme, "do you send me away?"
"I entreat you to go at once, I have nothing for you, I can have nothing.
I was told that you had left the Hotel du Boccage and that I must not speak
"More Christian charity," whispered Lucille Debelleyme, staring at the
crucifix, "more Christian compassion."
"Please go, Mademoiselle," said Clarise, firmly, standing in front of her
mistress, "as Madame has requested."
The visitor ignored the servant.
"Madame du Boccage—might I—once—just touch that
crucifix? In charity?"
"She is mad," whispered the old lady, afraid. "There has been some trouble
of which I have not heard—what has she to do with Camille?"
"If you would let me hold the crucifix I might tell you—"
Suddenly, and with the utmost horror, realising the identity of the
intruder, Clarise cried with vehemence:
"Begone at once! M. de Frediani is expected any instant; he will know how
to deal with you!"
Lucille Debelleyme glided away; catching hold of the warm familiar hand of
her maid the Duchess asked timidly:
"Has she gone?"
"She has gone, Madame. Oh, pray do not disturb yourself. I will see that
she does not come again," and pretending she had not recognised the visitor:
"Who was it?—can you give me her name that I may caution the servants
not to admit her again?"
Ejected by aversion, by fear, Lucille Debelleyme descended the stairs of
the fine house in the Faubourg St. Germain.
Outside she saw a familiar figure descending from a handsome
carriage—the Maréchal Frediani, who had come with that flamboyant
chivalry that all Paris so much admired to console the unsuspecting mother of
his daughter's murderer.
Lucille Debelleyme, with her veil across her bonnet, stood and looked at
him. She recalled how she and her grandfather had once laughed over an
anecdote concerning this old soldier; sent to restore order in Poland, he had
massacred all the revolutionaries and sent back an ironic message: "Peace in
She began to laugh as the old man, whose bearing had not been altered by
age but who now stooped under the shock of an overwhelming grief, turned up
the great steps of the house, and he at this dreadful sound, turned and
glanced over his shoulder.
She took a step towards him:
"Peace in the Faubourg St. Honoré, M. Le Maréchal!" she said and turned
quickly in the direction of The Cemetery of the South.
She found his grave, with weariness that she did not notice and
difficulties that she ignored, after walking through the long avenues of
tombs, heavy, sombre, ironic temples to the dead, avenues of straight poplar
and hard Cyprus, blue-black in the September sunshine, past solitary
crape-clad mourners, grave-diggers and guardians. There, in the large
communal grave, was number one thousand and fifty-four. There was no name, no
date... The ground round about was trampled by the feet of the curious, the
journalists who must write something more for their papers, the morbid whose
appetite for the horrible must be whetted, by perhaps a few who had come
secretly, to say a prayer.
There was no one in sight and dusk was falling; the sun retreated, in
sinking waves of light behind the tombs. Lucille Debelleyme lay down full
length on the damp earth and, closing her eyes, pressed against the heap of
clay broken by the sexton's spade as closely as if she embraced his
form—as if her frantic grasp could penetrate earth, oak boards, linen,
and seize him in her arms. Her most bitter regret was for his body that was
now so close under her own but which she would never see or touch again.
It was nearly dark when she again rang the bell of Madame
Santerre's small house. She had neither eaten, nor drunk, nor rested all day.
She was not aware of any fatigue, only of a lightness in her head. It was M.
Santerre who opened the door this time, as quickly as if he had been in
readiness, waiting behind the door. He looked at her eyes gleaming behind the
veil, he could see no more of her face than that. Her thin shoes were covered
with mud, the white braid of her dress, to which fragments of dead leaves and
earth were clinging, was dirty, her gloves were torn and her bag was hanging
open and empty on her arm.
"You must not come in," he said quickly, "my wife was too kind. I will not
have it, you must go away at once."
"Where to? Where am I to go?"
"Some priest, some charity; there are places for such as you. You do not
come into my house, you bring a curse with you, you would attract on me the
attention of all Paris. Begone." He closed the door in her face.
Lucille Debelleyme turned away; she began to walk faster and faster
through the twilight. As she reached the more frequented streets she broke
into a run, she had only one thought, one desire—immediate
Too impatient to wait until she reached the river, she intended to throw
herself under a passing vehicle and she hurried eagerly to the streets where
the traffic was most dense. Turning a corner sharply in her headlong flight,
which was causing the passers-by to turn and gaze curiously at her, she found
herself on the steps of a lighted doorway where the bright glow of the
unscreened gas fell on various placards and notices which showed that this
was a church, a Protestant church, and that the preacher was one Frédéric
This light, this doorway, this name seemed to Lucille Debelleyme to surge
up in front of her out of an utter blackness; she was suddenly conscious of
an acute, overwhelming fatigue. She made a movement forward as if to catch at
those placards for support—she was in the doorway, then in the church
and had sunk on a bench—the first to which she had come.
Frédéric Monet was preaching; the interior of the building, the service,
the congregation, all reminded her of her English days when she had had to
lead her charges to a Protestant church. She wondered what had brought her
here, where she was... She fixed her dazed eyes on the tall, gaunt man who,
at once fervid and monotonous, preached of submission to the will of God, of
patience, of resignation.
Pastor Frédéric Monet reluctantly left his church with the
sense of discouragement that comes to an actor who, though successful, has
not been, through convention, applauded. His faith was also his art and his
livelihood, he had put into it all the aspirations of a simple heart, all the
strength of a mediocre intelligence, he was most completely himself when he
was preaching about the terrors of sin, the beauties of repentance and the
joys of forgiveness of God.
When he was in the pulpit he became wrapped in an exultation that
sometimes touched ecstasy; the reaction when he had to leave the empty church
was always in proportion to his enthusiasm. He felt a vague melancholy, a
slight disappointment, to think of all these people who had listened to him
so silently, who should have been so impressed, scattering, passing away into
trivialities of their daily lives, without, it seemed, either acknowledgment
of his powers or need of his administrations. It was true that he knew some
of his flock and that some of them came to him with their troubles but these
were always very ordinary, and Frédéric Monet, a born missionary, a fervent,
earnest believer in the mercies of God and the traps of the devil, had, he
felt regretfully, so far neither met one nor the other, and his pleasant,
amiable, hard-working ordinary life had not brought him into touch with the
dramas of either crime or repentance.
The verger was following the pastor round the church, extinguishing the
gas-lamps, and Frédéric Monet lingered reluctantly, leaving the church with
the regret of one who leaves a scene of what should have been a triumph. As
he reached the door he saw that one member of the congregation was still
seated on the bench directly inside the door. She was neither praying nor, it
seemed by the inattentive droop in her attitude, waiting for him.
He looked at her sideways, his attention attracted by her pale, elegant
nankeen dress trimmed with white soutache, her torn gloves, the
reticule hanging open on her arm, the bits of dead leaves and earth that
clung to her dress, her thin shoes stained and trodden down, her straw bonnet
with the crumpled lilac strings.
"One of the unfortunates of the street," thought the pastor in automatic
disgust, that he instantly and shamefacedly repressed.
As he approached the young woman she did not move; a glance at her pale,
refined face with the dosed eyes and the parted lips changed his opinion. A
lady, after all, and her clothes in good taste and well made. Her state of
exhaustion then and the disorder of her attire must be the result of some
The pastor felt excited. Was she in trouble, and had she, hearing of his
eloquence, his tolerance, his enthusiasm, come to him?
His hesitation left him as he came up to her with the eager firmness of
the shepherd who has unmistakably espied the lost sheep entangled on the
"Mademoiselle... Mademoiselle... I fear you are ill. Can I be of any
service to you?" He half feared she was unconscious but she opened her eyes
and gave him a glance so bright and clear that he felt a faint
"You are the pastor Frédéric Monet?"
Pleased, he nodded.
"I listened to your sermon, it applied exactly to my case."
"Then do not say," replied the clergyman earnestly, flushing with
pleasure, "that you were brought here by chance. God directed you."
The young woman smiled:
She tried to rise but, too faint to hold herself on her feet, sank again
on the bench. The verger, interested and prying, paused behind the pastor and
waited to turn out the last gas-lamp by the door.
"You are in need of succour, Mademoiselle? You are in some distress?"
"I am in deep distress."
"Will you confide in me—will you trust me? That is my duty and my
privilege—to help all."
"Even the outcast and the despised?" and again she gave him that glance
that seemed in its blazing vitality so out of place with the drooping
exhaustion of her appearance.
"Those more than any," replied the pastor, firmly; his earnestness, his
honest goodness were unmistakable.
The young woman, who despite her emotional upheaval could read him at a
"I will tell you first who I am. I have been let out of the Conciergerie
this morning. I am friendless and dishonoured. I have just been turned from
the doors of an acquaintance, I am penniless." She rose, supporting herself
against the drab, painted plaster wall. "I am Lucille Debelleyme."
Then the pastor did wince and the verger, close behind him, was unable to
repress a forward movement of greedy curiosity.
No one had read the flamboyant accounts of the tragedy of the Hotel du
Boccage with more sincere horror than had Frédéric Monet and, though he
strove so hard to be charitable to the worst of sinners, he had not been able
to think of Lucille Debelleyme without a deep aversion.
She noticed his trouble.
"No doubt, Monsieur, you have followed my case in all its details, yet you
can know very little of my story. I was examined in secret—I had no
advisers, no lawyers, no friends. No one put forward my side of the question,
but unable to find the least evidence against me they have released me. It
seems," and her voice sank lower, "that they might as well have sent me to
the guillotine, for I perceive I am become an object from which even the
Frédéric Monet was instantly ashamed of his movement of dismay; he
reminded himself that there was nothing against this woman but the evil
tongues of the multitude. Human justice, rather, human malice had not been
able to discover that she was guilty; it was not for him to judge, nor by as
much as a look to turn her from seeking the Mercy of God.
He grasped her small cold hand in the torn glove in his large fingers, and
said with deepest sincerity:
"Mademoiselle, I am ready to believe there is no evil in you. You are in a
terrible situation, the knowledge of your own innocence must be your major
Lucille Debelleyme smiled at this banality which happened to be the exact
truth, and pulled away her hand from his, for his friendly grasp made her
think of another, when such different fingers, so powerful, had closed round
her own. M. Monet, in his black frock-coat, his grey whiskers, his portly
build, had a look of M. de Tassy.
"Mademoiselle, you are a Protestant?" he urged anxiously.
"Yes, I am a Protestant. In my despair I turned here—my instinct was
to destroy myself but something... "
"It was God," exclaimed the pastor, "who saved you from that desperate
He waited, with a certain bewilderment, a certain delicacy, for her to
explain herself further; she stared round the ugly building, the walls of
slate-coloured paint, the deep-set, dusty windows, black in their recesses,
the gas globes on iron arms, the rows of cheap benches shining with harsh
yellowish varnish; the House of God! There was something in that absurdity
that distracted her acute agony. Nowhere did she see the symbol that had
become to her one of mockery, that reminded her both of the cruelty of man
and a denied love token—the crucifix.
She glanced vaguely from the pastor to the verger, who, in the yellow,
wavering light of the last gas-lamp, was staring at her with such unabashed
curiosity; his keys hung in his hand.
"You think, both of you, that I am guilty? I suppose all Paris thinks so.
I know I am without a friend. No doubt the most terrible stories have been
spread about me, but the truth—no one would guess that!"
"You were a Protestant," exclaimed the pastor, "in the midst of the Roman
Catholics! Madame du Boccage, poor woman was a bigot, is it
Lucille Debelleyme flashed him a clear audacious glance:
"It is true that I was persecuted for my religion by the priest, the
Duchess herself, all of them—the Duke tried to rescue his children and
confide them to me. We were never more than friends. Consider, was it
likely?—he never saw me except when his children were present."
Why was she saying this, trying to make these two ridiculous men, in their
hideous building, believe her? From desire, after all, to live, or from
natural mechanical duplicity? She did not herself know but she continued
quietly to defend herself, like an automaton wound up to go through a routine
of words and gestures.
To the naive honest man who listened she was the very picture of
persecuted innocence; a Protestant at the mercy of Papist cabals! Why had he
not thought of that before? He should have rushed to her defence—
"Mademoiselle, you have no need—before me—to defend yourself
from charges so infamous."
He spoke sincerely; it was really impossible for him to associate this
delicate creature with any crime. He had already come to an astounding
resolution, he would rise to this moment, he would give his utmost, he would
not offer the cold, sneering charity of the Pharisees, he would not suggest
some Home for the destitute and the outcast... No, his own hearth, his own
pious wife, his own pure daughters...
"You are friendless, Mademoiselle—penniless—you have nowhere
"Yes, I thought of the river but it seemed too far, I have not eaten all
"Come with me at once. Mademoiselle Debelleyme, my wife will welcome you,
my daughters will treat you as a sister. You shall find that true charity,
tolerance, kindness does exist—even in Paris."
The absurdity of this last phrase caused a smile that he interpreted as a
flicker of gratitude to distort the pale lips of the governess; he said to
the gaping verger:
"Go and call a cab. Bring it immediately to the door."
As the man, still staring over his shoulder, reluctantly shuffled away.
Mademoiselle Debelleyme lightly laid her hand on the excited pastor's rough
"You are taking me to your wife, to your daughters—you a Christian
clergyman! Well, I am innocent—I can swear it."
She turned towards the distant altar that was only a gathered blot of
shadows in the deep murk of the chapel. She lifted her hand and said
"I take God to witness that I am neither an adulteress nor a murderess. M.
du Boccage was not my lover and I did not inflame him to murder his
She turned her wild stare on the pastor and added:
"Why should people not believe me? Is it that everyone has a mind so foul
that they cannot conceive of virtue? But you, you perhaps can credit what
seems to so many an incredible truth."
She caught him up into her emotion; he became her champion, her defender,
he was subtly flattered, greatly moved.
"I believe you," he declared solemnly, as if he gave an absolution.
She turned her head aside without replying; when her chin drooped she
noticed the earth, the dead leaves still on her dress and remembered where
they came from. With a shriek, such as the pastor had never heard from human
lips before, she fell awkwardly against him. The verger hurried in panting,
aghast at this unparalleled excitement; between them they lifted the light
weight of Lucille Debelleyme and carried her to the hired cab.
The pastor Monet's supper was ready, the fire was burning
cheerfully, the lamp in the large, opal globe lit, the wife was hastening, in
a kindly fashion, the one little maid in the final preparation of the last
At a side table in the pleasant parlour Louise Monet was illuminating a
text; one of the beatitudes, "Blessed are the pure in heart," began to
flourish in gold and scarlet under her pen. Her sister Hortense sat beside
her knitting a curly tippet in white Iceland wool. She had recently recovered
from a slight attack of bronchitis and it was anxiety on her behalf and the
unexpected dampness of the autumn day which had kept the family at home
instead of attending as usual the Thursday service of the husband and father
at the Chapel of the Oratory. The demoiselles Monet were plain young women
with pallid complexions and greasy hair, their teeth were irregular and they
had a tendency to pimples and violent attacks of indigestion. There was only
a year between them and they were exactly alike, similar too in their sweet
and patient dispositions. Pliant, stupid and obedient, they had inherited
their father's unwavering piety and absorbed their mother's conventional
decorum so successfully that they had become in all the utmost that their
parents could have wished. The flame of their unblemished goodness flickered
brightly even after five years' residence in the corruption which they were
well aware blighted the capital; their father, though anxious at first as to
the wisdom of transporting these two innocents from a small country town to
the hectic wickedness of Paris, had long since had his fears allayed. The
virtue of Louise and Hortense Monet was such as could walk unspotted through
the streets of Babylon; they lived as removed from the world about them as
fishes swimming in a bowl are removed from the room that houses them. Louise
was going to be a missionary in China, Hortense was betrothed to a young man
of whom her parents completely approved.
A tall, robust youth leant against the mantelpiece, and stared at the two
girls absorbed in their work. He was an American, in training for holy
orders, one Nathaniel Meadows, a distant relative of Madame Monet, who came
of a well-known Evangelical family from New York.
He had had no experience of anything except the most rigid Puritanism, and
no thought of rebellion against the uncomfortable tenets in which he had been
so vigorously schooled ever crossed a mind obtuse, self-satisfied, narrow.
The least suggestion of any infringement of that code of morals that he
considered had been drawn up by God Himself shocked him profoundly. But his
appearance was that of a strong, kindly animal; there was a look of a drowsy
young bull about his heavy head and shoulders, the dark red curls, the full
features and the brown eyes, expressing a rather dazed kind of nobility. His
ill-cut clothes of expensive materials were outlandishly ugly, and his
movements were awkward.
Suddenly, an impetuous opening of doors, the blowing in of the chill,
foggy autumn air, exclamations, a search for change to pay for this unusual
luxury of a cab, for vinegar, for eau-de-Cologne, broken explanations and an
unconscious stranger was laid on the gleaming horse-hair sofa drawn near the
fire. Madame Monet, experienced, capable, kindly, soon had the situation in
hand. No spirits were ever allowed in the house but a glass of home-made
cordial, highly alcoholic, was forced between the rigid lips of the
unconscious young woman, while the girls gently drew off the straw bonnet
with the crumpled lilac ribbon, drew from the cold fingers the torn gloves
and from the feet, bruised from running, the thin, soiled slippers. The
family Monet experienced all the righteous joy of the good Samaritan, they
glowed with the pleasure of putting into practice long-smouldering
Not without grandeur, his eyes sparkling with a fanatic charity, the
pastor addressed his wife:
"Marthe, this is Mademoiselle Debelleyme," then as the name made them all
pause in alarm, he added quickly: "she has sworn to me on the table of the
Lord that she is innocent. She came to me in her great trouble, she is a
Protestant, she turned to a Protestant for succour."
He spoke quite sincerely, for he had already forgotten that the young
woman had told him that it was by chance she had turned into his church. He
saw her now and would always see her as running straight from the doors of
the Conciergerie to the refuge of the Oratory.
"It is a test," he added excitedly, "a test of our faith. I would not send
her to hospital, to some public organisation—I have brought her here to
my own hearth, to my own wife and daughters. Tell me, Marthe, have I done
"You have shown courage," she said, looking at him with admiration. "No
one else in Paris would have done as much."
"She is friendless—she is penniless—despised and rejected of
men, Marthe," he continued with rising enthusiasm, "she has been greatly
wronged. I believe her oath, she was persecuted because she was a
The three honest women drew a deep breath of horror, of understanding.
Hortense pityingly flicked away some dead leaves and earth which clung to the
bodice of the unconscious victim of the Romish Church; Madame Monet bathed
the poor fallen head, so richly adorned with pale curls, with her
handkerchief wrung out in eau-de-Cologne and water. This practical New
Englander relied on her husband in everything and she wholeheartedly accepted
his verdict in the matter of Lucille Debelleyme. She was eager to step into
the position of protector of the innocent, champion of the maligned,
especially as the persecution of the Protestants was the only portion of the
story of the human race that she knew, and she knew that well indeed; so that
had been the cause of the whole tragedy! She could believe it without
hesitation, without difficulty. The poor young woman, staunchly Protestant,
had been set upon, in a household of Roman Catholics, led by Jesuits
probably—it was generally the Jesuits—
They all began to talk together in low, excited tones. How everything
fitted in! "Yes... yes... that was it, of course—a Protestant against a
crowd of Catholics—what slander, what lies!"
The actual murder they shut out of their consideration, not mentioning it,
not thinking of it. The man had been driven mad of course by the scandalous
attacks of the priests. No need to dwell on that.
Lucille Debelleyme stirred and sat up. Her bodice was open at the neck,
drops of water were on her cheeks and her curls lay damp and dark on her
The pastor and his family gazed at her almost with veneration; compassion
had passed into respect, pity into a fervent championship. All of them had
forgotten Nathaniel Meadows; he stood on the verge of the group, half in the
shadows, straining his attention to understand the situation. He could only
partially grasp the meaning of the rapid French phrases, but he caught again
and again the two famous names of Du Boccage and Lucille Debelleyme...
The young American had read (with a fascinated horror of which he was
secretly ashamed) all the sickening details of the crime which had shaken
France, but he had resisted, not without an effort, an unworthy curiosity
which had urged him to go to the Conciergerie to obtain a glimpse of the
mysterious heroine of this dreadful affair. But he had not resisted what he
feared was a base attraction and had continuously turned his mind to
contemplation of this tragedy of lust, corruption and violence. And here was
this suspect, this woman who had been called names which the young Puritan
would not dare bring across his lips, lying on the familiar horse-hair sofa
by the sacred hearth of the spotless Madame Monet, being, he was sure,
He approached eagerly, he had never really seen a beautiful woman so close
before, nor any woman in such emotional upheaval, in such physical
Before they had noticed him he had stared greedily at her throat, her
hands, her feet, the long pale curls, the fine features, the rich,
close-fitting elegant gown... Lucille Debelleyme from the Conciergerie, a
wronged, persecuted, friendless woman... he immediately saw her through a
blaze of romantic glory as he eagerly watched these blameless, angelic women,
ministering to the young woman who was so incredibly attractive. The first
rapture of his short, repressed life stung the simple heart of Nathaniel
Meadows. The cause of that rapture was that while his senses assured him this
stranger was beautiful, the clamour of his virtuous friends assured him that
she was good; he had not believed such a combination possible, nor even hoped
for such luck as to find a virtuous woman who was also seductive. The
forbidden fruit and the permitted daily bread in one luscious dish... he
stared and stared and, unconsciously, licked his handsome lips.
Lucille Debelleyme accepted without protest or comment her part as
Protestant victim of Roman Catholic intrigue. She was not questioned, of
course, on the affair of the Hotel du Boccage, but by a sigh, a glance, a
chance word, a broken phrase, she gave them to understand that their
interpretation of that tragedy was indeed correct. It had been her most
misguided but well-meaning attempt to rescue the children of M. du Boccage
from the bigotry of their mother, from the fanaticism of the priests, her
honest endeavour to support their unfortunate father in his effort to save
his children's souls which had brought about that hideous catastrophe which
had shocked France.
For several months she lived in retreat with the Monet family, and nothing
in her modest behaviour evoked anything but approval in the ingenuous people
who had so boldly befriended her. Soon after Christmas she began, to go out a
little, often escorted by Mr. Nathaniel Meadows, who had lingered on in Paris
longer than he had intended at first. Leaning on his arm or sitting side by
side with him in some hired carriage, she would show him the more impressive
sights of Paris, those that were advertised in the guide book and that all
foreigners wanted to see. "She had," she remarked quietly, "a good knowledge
of the Capital, having so often taken her young pupils about to show them
what was instructive and amusing."
The young American, who did not lack obvious delicacy, was careful that
these walks and drives should never lead them near the Faubourg St.
Then Lucille Debelleyme ventured to go about alone.
"She wished," she said, "to pray in the chapel in complete solitude," and
with this object begged the key of the Oratory from the willing pastor, who
was deeply impressed by the further proof of her wounded piety,
But Mademoiselle Debelleyme did not use the key; her little excursions led
her to the Rue Keller where she would walk up and down in front of the
chemist's shop, where the first sunshine of the year fell across the large
bottles of coloured water in the windows, purple, red and green.
She paused sometimes by the little side door, while she glanced up and
down the street with a look of unutterable grief. Then sometimes she would
take the omnibus to The Cemetery of the South and pace to and fro before the
heavy central gates without, however, finding the courage to pass through
On some occasions she would go to the Faubourg St. Honoré and pass the
heavy, locked grille between the two porters' lodges and peep through at the
bare trees. The mansion was shuttered, the doors barred.
She knew, for she had procured and avidly read copies of all the August
issues of the more important Parisian papers, that there was one room in that
house that was sealed up by order of the Maréchal Frediani—untouched,
never to be looked at again. Lucille Debelleyme knew the appearance of that
room, she had read the accounts of many curious, horrified spectators; the
overturned furniture, the torn bedclothes, the bloodstains, that would now be
black, everywhere, on the satin chairs, on the alabaster mantelpiece, on the
walls; hand-prints, fingerprints in blood; the cut bell-rope, the door of the
toilet-room without a handle and the heavy baldaquin, gilt and carved, from
which hung the Brussels lace curtains, still in place despite the waxen
She thought of his apartment, the green desk where she had found those
letters of his wife, which had proved such damning evidence against him in
the end... the portrait of Lord Clare—was it still hanging on the wall,
smiling with those thick sensuous lips across the darkness? She had read of
the incredible confusion of his bedroom and dressing-room, the knife, the
pistol, the blood-soaked clothes. She had heard how he had thrown a bowl of
discoloured water out of the window on to the garden, and there came to her
mind his gesture, his action the first time she had met him, when with vivid
impatience he had cast out of the window the dead flowers and the foul water
in the dusty vase.
She wondered if the cupidon, with the sinister, dimpled face was standing
lonely in the grand reception room? There would be a great deal of dust now
on the pelmets, many cobwebs in the shadows of the high window frames.
Her room, her for two years, what had they done with that? Was the little
pianoforte still there and the easels on which she stood her water-colours,
and the mirror in which she had looked at herself, nude, veiled only by her
Javiaux du Boccage, too, that must be standing in solitude in the vast,
The present Duke, the young boy, had been taken abroad by his relatives,
the family had scattered as far as possible from the scene of the
Yes, Javiaux du Boccage would be empty, how forlorn those great rooms must
be, the scaffolding poles, where once his busy workmen had toiled...
And Locroi, the little Italian house in the Normandy fields, by the river,
the weeping willows, and the orangery? All deserted, all silent.
As she stood gazing, on these visits, at the facade behind the light
movements of bare trees, at the little door of the chemist's shop in the Rue
Keller, or at the gloomy gate of The Cemetery of the South, such an
unutterable nostalgia would possess her that her soul seemed wrenched by
sheer agony out of her body to float in an abyss of black misery. But when
she returned to the menage Monet, she would be composed, serene, a little
paler, a little more silent than when she had left the house perhaps, but
they understood this—Exhaustion following the spiritual exultation of
To the sophisticated, the cynical who had watched her in the garden of the
Conciergerie she had been charming but wicked; to these simple people she was
charming but good.
Her grandfather died in January and left her, unexpectedly, a small sum
which relieved her of the necessity of relying on the straitened means of the
pastor. To repay this and to buy little gifts for the three women, she had
already sold what few objects of value she possessed, among them a bracelet
with blue stones that fetched a surprisingly high price.
As she had frankly told her history to the pastor, he had recommended she
should take, in defiance of the world's opinion and in contempt of the
world's scorn, with a gesture that put her above all shade of subterfuge, her
own name. She was henceforth Mademoiselle Lucille Clery; let Lucille
Debelleyme die with the last echoes of the hideous tragedy in which she had
been involved. Her future, as a fervent Protestant, as a martyr to her faith,
was assured; she made many friends, received many offers of employment, of
many advantageous posts, but she refused them all, preferring for the present
at least to remain with the family Monet. Presently she would go to England
or America. Now, it would certainly be impossible for her to remain in Paris,
but for the moment she was not, naturally, strong enough for travel.
Sometimes, diligently reading her English religious books in the evening,
she would glance over the top of the pages at Nathaniel Meadows who was never
far away from her chair. Without ever giving him her confidence, nor indeed
appearing to take any interest in him beyond gentle friendliness, she had had
a profound influence over the young man. He now dressed like a Frenchman and
with some elegance, he had learnt to speak her language correctly. His
Protestantism, his anti-Catholicism were emphasised to the point of bigotry;
he told all his acquaintances that Lucille Clery, not Fanny du Boccage, was
the saint and martyr of the tragedy of the Faubourg St. Honoré.
Lucille Clery read in the papers, now so full of the tumults and
confusions of political unrest, a few lines in small print which stated that
the body of Madame la Duchesse du Boccage, by the wish of her father, the
Maréchal Frediani, had been taken from the vaults of the Madeleine to Javiaux
du Boccage, and that almost at the same time the Comte Edouard had removed
the mortal remains of his brother from The Cemetery of the South and laid him
in an unnamed coffin of oak covered by a plain pall, beside the sumptuous
mausoleum of his wife. Side by side again, dose as in a marriage bed. At last
she had his company in the lonely vaults of deserted Javiaux du Boccage.
This nearly shattered the young woman's control, acquired with such an
agony of effort.
"So, she has cheated me again—at last—triumphed after
M. le Duc Decaze listened to a letter being read to him by
his secretary. It had been inscribed with those entreaties of urgency which
had caused him to select it from among his heavy correspondence. His eyes
stared across the room with an inscrutable expression as the young man read
aloud in a careful unemotional voice:
'Monsieur, weighed down by the terrible tragedy which has almost
extinguished my life and reason, I have refused without hesitation several
advantageous offers of a post, but to-day it is happiness itself which is
offered me. I have not the strength to reject it without making a last effort
to overcome my sad history. The generous man who wishes to give me his name
knows all my story, has full confidence in me. If he were alone I should not
have need of any human witness, but he belongs to a rich and well-considered
family that cannot see him, without uneasiness, unite his destiny with mine.
They are strangers to me, I have never seen them, nor can I hope that they
will easily believe my vows and my tears. Monsieur, but I have no other proof
to give them. The papers that were seized on my arrest have never been
returned to me, the public only know that I was accused. Monsieur, can you in
conscience declare that I was not the infamous wretch who was held up to the
contempt of the world? You were there, you questioned me, you knew this
miserable menage, you were present at his torments, at mine, you must have
been able to understand the part that I played in this drama where I blindly
worked out my fate. You know that neither ambition nor love of power could
have given me the influence that I had over my unhappy pupils—You have
read HIS letters and mine and you know that we did not love each other.
Monsieur, I do not implore your pity but I call on your honour.
'The happiness of all my life depends on your reply. I tell you that
because I know that it cannot influence your decision. I have the vanity to
think that you recognised in me some force of character—you know that I
will endure much in silence—whatever you write I will accept as the
sincere judgment of a man as good, as generous as he is great in the eyes of
the world, and I shall submit to it with the profound sentiment of gratitude
and respect that I shall hold for you to my last breath.
'Signed, Lucille Clery—formerly Debelleyme.'
As the secretary sat with the letter in his hand, waiting, the aristocrat
repeated: "so she has found another protector!—who, I
wonder?—well, it does not matter! She plays her part very well until
the end. Is that letter sincere now, or a piece of drama? It is rather neatly
The tips of his fine fingers tapped on his knees. The letter had brought
back to his mind the appalling death-bed of M. du Boccage, his friend, which
shook even for one of his stern calibre to remember. M. du Boccage. who had
confessed nothing, whose last words had been a denial of his crime.
Lucille Clery had appealed to the judgment of M. Decaze, asked him to
state the truth. Wide as was his experience, long as had been his life,
shrewd and apt as was his mind, the aristocrat found it difficult, even when
sincerely searching his own heart to decide what was the truth in this
As she had skilfully reminded him, he had had some knowledge of the menage
in the Hotel du Boccage, many opportunities of studying at first hand the
characters of M. du Boccage and his wife. He had examined for days together
the murderer and the woman who was supposed to be his accomplice, he had
heard the commentaries of all those who had had the remotest connection with
the tragedy, the opinions of many clever and impartial observers. He had seen
the King, a man of many sorrows, who so loathed the death penalty that he
only traced initials on the warrants except in one instance, blanch and
shudder as he reluctantly signed the decree of arrest for M. du Boccage. He
had heard the Monarch exclaim: "I have had much to endure since I came to the
throne of France, but this is the worst of all"; he had heard the simple and
savage judgment of the people. What conclusion could he come to:
adultery?—the usual thing—a love intrigue? A jealous woman
driving a man mad? One ought to be prepared for everything in this world, but
a crime so appalling and a man of his rank and breeding, one so fastidious,
amiable and even gentle in manners and speech, uncommonly devoted to his
children. Madness then, an outburst of homicidal fury; but M. Decaze had sat
for hours by the bed of the prisoner in the Luxembourg and seen how, during
the most excruciating tortures he had skilfully evaded his pitiless
examiners. Undeniable sanity there... and the premeditation—the Cord,
the poison, the wax in the baldaquin supports? No madness there, yet an
incredible stupidity. The crime was so clumsy that the first investigator had
discovered the author of it; how could M. du Boccage have supposed that he
could escape detection—or, even if he had, how could he have hoped,
after this appalling murder, to introduce Lucille Debelleyme publicly into
his life again, either as governess, mistress or wife?
M. Decaze shrugged his shoulders; the whole affair was one from which his
intelligence shrank, baffled. If he had not known it to be true he would have
dismissed it as a ridiculous fable.
And the woman who had appealed to him? An enigma indeed; he had observed
her very closely, and he believed that though she might be capable of a crime
she was not capable of a crass stupidity. "She is not a fool, she did not
conceive that brutal lunacy."
What was her relationship with the Duke?
M. Decaze was completely mystified. If they were not lovers, what was this
inseparable bond between them, and if they were lovers why should the Duke
have murdered his wife when he had had all he could hope for from his blonde
The certificate of good conduct that she had demanded and he could not
obtain—that seemed to have been the final motive of the murder. The
governess had constantly emphasised her respectability, her excellent
testimonials. Was that the solution, had Camille du Boccage, weak, violent,
sensual, with a streak of cruelty in his nature, harried by a thousand
exasperations, poisoned by hatred of a person with whom he was forced to
live, shattered his reason, his control, the rules of his caste, even his
humanity against the implacable respectability of a sly little bourgeoise,
cunning, prim, skilful—not quite skilful enough—?
M. Decaze thought so. "If they had been lovers he would not have done
it—if she had guessed his intention he would not have done it.
Guiltless then, as far as human justice can go. For the rest it is
incredible, inexplicable—it is even a little ridiculous."
He dictated a dry reply to the appeal of Mademoiselle Clery, in which he
gave her the testimony she required to satisfy the New Englanders. Fresh
distaste touched him; she had said that she loved Camille du Boccage... and
in a few months' time she had found another man.
"Not even loyal!" M. Decaze put the affair out of his mind; he had other
matters to think of. Paris was again on the eve of revolution.
A huge and angry crowd before the Ministry of Foreign
Affairs shouted hot denunciations against M. Guizot; they were, with
difficulty, held in check by a strong detachment of troops and by the
municipal guards who, with drawn sabres, pressed the angry people back to the
edge of the pavement. All the roads leading to the Tuileries and the Palais
Royal were closed by troops, many of the other streets had been closed by the
people; furniture, overturned cabs, omnibuses and torn-up paving-stones
formed barricades against the military. The soldiery appeared to perform
their duties languidly, the municipal guards with brutal threats and insolent
force. Shots had been fired in the Place du Chatelet and the Rue St. Denis,
everywhere through the hurried orders of the military sounded angry cries of:
"Down with the Ministry! Down with the Monarchy! Long live Reform!"
In front of the offices of the newspaper La National passed a procession
of biers carrying the people killed by the troops; fifty-two had already
fallen. Many of them were young students and among them were women and
children; their escort, with cries and tears of fury, yelled for arms, for
vengeance! By the afternoon it was known that the King had given way and
signed the decree for the dismissal of the hated Minister; but the passions
of Paris were not so easily assuaged. This concession was greeted on all
sides with cries of: "No more Kings!"
People attacked the troops defending the Palais Royale. The Fourteenth of
the Line, the National Guards and the Municipal Guards stationed near the Rue
de Valois fired on the advancing mob; this was the signal for the final
explosion of popular wrath. The people, by force of numbers, thrust back the
soldiers and police, and began to burn the Palais Royal; at one of the
windows of this ancient palace of the House of Orleans a young man, the son
of Admiral Baudin, appeared and announced the abdication of Louis
The victorious crowd cried: "It is too late!" and these fatal words were
followed by yells of "To the Tuileries!" The Palais Royal was already
Among the crowds of curious citizens, nervous, ready to fly, who kept on
the fringe of the tumult was a man and a woman—Nathaniel Meadows, with
Lucille Clery hanging on his arm. As the crowd, turning with one accord to
attack the Tuileries, swept out of the Colonnades of the Palais Royal, the
young man quickly drew his companion into a doorway where, unobserved, they
could watch this furious tide of sudden revolution sweep past.
Lucille Clery regarded the yelling, surging crowd of armed revolutionaries
without fear; she had of late been a diligent reader of the newspapers. She
had scanned some of the pamphlets that were so eagerly seized on by the
populace, she had heard, during these sudden days of revolution, many popular
speeches. She knew, therefore, that it was generally considered that as the
affair Teste-Cubieres had been, in the popular estimation, the downfall of
the law and the army, so the affair Du Boccage had been the downfall of the
old aristocracy. This crime had been quickly followed by the dissolution of
the Chamber of Peers, and in the full fury of the overthrow of the Monarchy
the murder of the Faubourg St. Honoré was often hurled as an unanswerable
insult at the Ministry, the Government and the Peerage. A criminal had, with
the connivance of his class, escaped the death penalty; everyone believed
that M. Pasquier, instructed by the Chamber of Peers, had given the poison
that had spared an aristocrat from the guillotine.
Lucille Clery, leaning lightly on her companion's arm, was thinking of
some years ago, when, in an inn at Paddington, she had visualised some such
scene as this and thought of herself as having a hand in it, either as the
Hon. Mrs. Robert Morrison, an influential British aristocrat dabbling in
politics or as Mary Showler, an intelligent, intriguing courtesan. She had
always wanted to pull down this House of Orleans, the younger branch of
Bourbon; she had always hoped to see a return of the Bonapartes to whose
patronage her family had owed whatever they possessed. Now this moment had
really come. Prince Louis Napoleon was supposed to be hastening to Paris,
there might be another Empire ruled over by a Bonaparte—and she had had
some hand in it, not as Mrs. Morrison, not as Mary Showler, not through any
direct interest or interference in politics but merely as a governess in the
household of M. du Boccage.
Her companion, who was shielding her with the greatest anxiety and
continually gave her loving glances of apprehension, suggested, as the street
emptied, that they should turn homewards. Their marriage, for which the
family Monet were making loving preparations, was only a few days ahead.
Within a week they were to sail for New York.
"Let us stay here awhile," said Mademoiselle Clery, "at least we are safe.
Everyone is going to the Tuileries."
"There are three thousand troops there," said the young American with
excitement. "There will be a battle. Perhaps they will burn the
Palace—it is terrible. I wonder if the King will escape?"
A surge of students, carrying a tricolour on which hung the Phrygian cap
of liberty, swept by. They passed close to the doorway where the two were
sheltering and the young man took the opportunity to gather the delicate,
elegant body of Lucille Clery into his powerful arms, nor did he easily let
her go; she remained leaning against him as if overcome by fright, but in
reality she felt no fear. She was thinking of her unblemished body, which in
the interest of ambition had been offered vainly to Robert Morrison and in
the interests of ambition had been vainly withheld from Camille du Boccage
and was now to be given with all the rights of solemn matrimony to this young
Puritan, to whom she was in everything completely alien.
"Is it worth while living in exile with this man who will always be a
stranger—why does one so coolly take the line of least resistance?" She
gave him a clear glance of wonder and he mistook it for a look of love and
pressed her hand warmly; she turned her face aside to hide her
"So, this is my destiny—always to deal with stupid men! But, after
all, he can give me what I want most, in fact the only thing I
want—this great prize, leisure in which to dream what might have been,
to bring before a mental vision another face, another moment."
The streets were deserted, they could hear the sound of firing, a low
smoke began to hang over the city.
"Let us go home," said Lucille Clery.
The young man, eager to do her bidding, released her from his embrace,
adjusting her fine cashmere shawl round her shoulders and putting his arm
round her waist, almost lifting her from the ground, hastened with her
towards the pastor's modest pleasant home; it seemed indeed a place of refuge
amidst this tumult.
She was still wondering if she could endure him, if, after all, the river
would not have been better. Towards his person, his character, she was
profoundly indifferent; she knew all there ever would be to know about him,
and none of it held any interest for her. But his clothes, his manners
irritated her, she longed passionately for the costly cloth, the fine linen,
the delicate perfume, the extravagant details of another man's attire; she
despised everything in Nathaniel Meadows that was not—that never could
be—grand seigneur. In their hurry they turned round a corner of a side
street that led quickly home; there had been a struggle there between police
and insurgents and gouts of blood lay across the road. The young American
realised that such a sight must be even more horrible to Mademoiselle Clery
than to most women; he swung her aside towards a florist's shop. It was his
intention to buy her a cluster of the southern violets, but the frightened
shopkeeper was putting up his shutters and as the couple reached his door his
wife was throwing in the street a can of stale water and some withered
violets; flowers had not sold well in Paris for the last few days.
The Villa Violette, the two vessels emptied from the windows of the Hotel
du Boccage, the bunch of faded roses cast into the Seine as the dead boy was
carried to the Morgue, the trickle of blood from under the gates of the
slaughter-house, from the apartment of the husband to that of the wife.
"No flowers!" said the young man in disappointment.
Lucille Clery hid her face with a corner of her Andalusian shawl which she
held to keep off, the evening fog and the fumes of the cannon smoke which
floated down every street. A student in a Grecian cap with a long tassel,
supporting a wounded companion came by and shouted out in excitement that
Louis Philippe, who had been passing in review the garrison of the Tuileries,
had on the approach of the mob at once jumped into a little coupe and had
fled from Paris, and that the Due de Nemours who was in command of the troops
defending the Royal Palace had retired. The people were in the palace, they
had already found the throne, broken it to pieces and thrown it from the
"I should like to pull him down"; the young woman who had uttered these
words in the Paddington inn found some comfort in irony as she hung with her
timid helpless air on the arm of her stalwart young protector. It gave her
some pleasure to reflect how few would guess that in this insignificant
humbly-born young woman was one of the main causes of the revolution which
meant the downfall of a dynasty.
Yet this acrid satisfaction was veiled by such utter misery, such bitter
nostalgia that she almost hated her own fortitude which enabled her to endure
such unhappiness. The troops of soldiers, the ambulances, the screaming
women, the surging crowds who passed, the noise of the cannons, the smoke in
the air, the cries, the shouts, the rumours, all were like a mirage to
Lucille Clery; as she passed lightly, swiftly, close to her lover through the
embattled streets, the uproar of revolution, she saw only a face which gazed
back as if awaiting a signal, the lint-coloured hair disordered on the
forehead: "I shall expect of you some action."
The Pastor Frédéric Monet was putting up a prayer for the two lovers
caught in the turmoil of the rioting, while his daughters, with sentimental
tenderness, sewed sprays of wax orange blossoms on to the satin bonnet of the
Mrs. Lucy Meadows was preparing, in her pleasant, brown stone house, for
one of those agreeable afternoon entertainments, so well known in New York as
a gathering place for the more enlightened Christian workers. Mrs. Meadows
had just returned from Long Island, where she had spent the hot American
summer; she endured excessive heat very badly, and usually passed the month
of August in a state of languid ill-health, but at the coming of the autumn
there was always a return of her energy and, perfect housekeeper and good
organiser as she was, she would at once resume that ceaseless work which made
her the admired centre of a group of prosperous, comfortable, Puritan New
Mrs. Meadows had been married for several years and her union with the
well-known pastor Nathaniel Meadows was considered ideal. Her devotion was of
a nature at once lofty and touching; she was her husband's constant companion
and assisted him in the compilation and editing of his successful paper The
A copy of the proofs of the current issue of this journal lay on the
mahogany desk between the two tall windows but Mrs. Meadows, occupied in
preparing for her guests, gave it no more than a glance; that was a task that
The lion of the party was to be Mrs. Harriet Beecher Stowe, and no doubt
the subject of animated discussion would be the emancipation of the slaves in
the South, which Mrs. Stowe, by her famous novel, had done so much to make a
burning question of the moment.
The handsome room was clean and arranged with faultless taste. Mrs.
Meadows glided here and there, rearranging, with a sure judgment, clusters of
autumn flowers, asters, golden rod, a few last roses that filled the vases of
Colonial silver which made a satisfactory display against the dark-panelled
walls. She was dressed plainly as befitted a pastor's wife but her dress
flattered her slender shape and was finely cut, not too high at the throat
and collared with beautiful lace. Her pale hair was gathered into a knot at
the back of her head and was partly covered by the discreet matron's cap that
was arranged on her small head with an art which approached coquetry. Her
small features as yet showed no line or wrinkle but seemed in their firm
outline to be made of some imperishable material. It was generally recognised
that Mrs. Meadows was a very lovely woman and one wholly without vanity. Her
modest habit of keeping her lovely eyes downcast was much commended; a model
wife, a model marriage. There were no children—a pity perhaps, but
those who were most intimate with the Meadows establishment agreed that no
doubt it was just as well no little ones had come to interfere with the
intense devotion of husband and wife and their mutual absorption in good
Mrs. Meadows paused and critically examined the elaborate tea service for
twelve people which was laid on a side table. She picked up the massive
silver piece by piece, not a speck of tarnish; with delicate fingers she
raised the blue and crimson Worcester china piece by piece, not a fleck of
dust. The homemade cakes were varied and delicious, largely her own work or
made under her immediate supervision, and delicately covered by thin linen
napkins of her own embroidery.
The Rev. Nathaniel Meadows was indeed, blessed in so perfect a
Having finished her inspection she seated herself by the wide hearth on
which the first fire of the year burned clearly. Behind her hung a series of
portraits, drawings and small oils, of her husband's ancestors—sturdy,
hard-working Puritan stock, good business men, able money-makers, people who
had successfully defied the world, the flesh and the devil without feeling
themselves obliged to lead the lives of either saint or hermit. Their
square-cut faces stared unseeingly across the comfortable room where this
exotic woman, so completely alien to all her surroundings, sat at ease,
flourishing discreetly on the substance provided by their toil and
Mrs. Meadows, in an attitude unconsciously elegant, was gazing at a bureau
in the corner on which stood filigree dishes of biscuit-hued china piled with
ruddy fruits and comfits in silver paper. One of the drawers of this bureau
was always locked, she kept the key always about her person. In this moment
of tranquillity she was wondering at the weakness which had made her preserve
what really should have long ago been destroyed. She was alone, there was a
bright fire, was not this, perhaps, the moment? She felt so calm, she could
find the strength to handle what she did not wish to touch again, to look at
what she never wished to see again. Someone must sooner or later burn or
destroy the contents of that drawer; she might die before her husband, and
whenever she died there would be those who, however reverently, would handle
what she left behind—better that she should destroy all trace of what
ought to have long ago been forgotten, what she believed was forgotten by
everyone but herself. She continued to stare at the locked drawer, she did
not need to open it to read the contents of some of the French newspapers.
La Reforme, Le Charivari, L'Union Monarchique, folded away there: the
words seemed to be traced on the air of the pleasant sitting-room.
At dawn on August 16th the few domestics remaining in the Hotel du Boccage
(the Duke bad dismissed almost the entire household the preceding day) were
aroused by the sound of a bell being irregularly rung from the apartments of
Madame la Duchess. Dressing themselves hastily they rushed to her door but
found this unaccustomedly locked from the inside. They then went round the
terrace; as they approached someone from inside opened the window. They
looked in and a frightful spectacle met their eyes, Madame la Duchesse du
Boccage lying extended on the floor near her bed bleeding from many large
wounds, her hands were covered with blood, one of them clutched some
fragments of blond hair. The disorder of the room, the overturning of light
articles of furniture, smashed porcelain and torn curtains showed the unhappy
woman had sustained a terrible struggle with her murderer. As the servants
recoiled they saw a figure detaching itself from the shadows of the cabinet
de toilette. This figure supported itself against the wall, continually took
its head in its hands; as it advanced into the uncertain light of the dawn
they perceived it was M. le Duc du Boccage...
From the first moment that the officers of Justice arrived on the scene a
grave fact was remarked, there was no trace of robbery, of any entry from the
garden, but a track of blood marked the floor from the apartment of the
Duchess to that of the Duke.
Monsieur du Boccage, while the police were examining his other clothes,
put on, with the assistance of Henri, his valet, a robe de chambre of
brown wool lined with blue silk over trousers in wide stripes of blue and
grey, a waistcoat of white batiste and a linen shirt and black silk
Despite the extreme heat of the morning, smoke from an early hour had been
seen to issue from the chimney of the private apartment of M. du Boccage.
It was remarked that he wore gloves throughout the morning. When a medical
examination of his person, was ordered in the afternoon the reason was
apparent; his hands were covered with scratches and there was a severe bite
on one of his thumbs. It was by then established that the blond hairs
clutched in the rigid fingers of the Duchess were of the same colour and
length as those of her husband.
Mrs. Meadows glanced at the clock brought from England in the Colonial
days, it bore the name of a Cambridge maker in tall nourishing letters on the
dial... another twenty minutes before she might expect even the most punctual
of her guests.
Owing to the feeble light and the desire to attract no attention it took
nearly two hours to traverse the back streets from the Faubourg St. Honors to
the prison of the Luxembourg. On arrival there the prisoner was in such a
state of collapse that be had to be carried to his cell. Burning with thirst
and shivering with cold, he was given continual drinks of iced Burgundy to
ease his self-inflicted misery.
The effect of the immense quantity of arsenic he had drunk was such as to
contract his body in his final agonies till he looked like a child. When he
was dead, however, the muscles relaxed and as he lay stripped on the marble
table awaiting the autopsy, the first surgeon to see him exclaimed: "What a
Mrs. Meadows rose and went to the bureau, unlocked the drawer and took out
the bundle of newspapers. There was a copy of The Times there too with a
pencil mark round this paragraph: "We greatly regret to inform our readers of
the sudden death of the Hon. Robert Morrison, who, by a most regrettable
accident, was thrown from his horse while hunting in the Cotswolds
Mrs. Meadows took the papers and tossed them into the bright, clear fire.
They were burnt almost at once, but her keen eyes could discern for a second
or two words where the printer's ink resisted the flame,
All gone now, all vanished, like the Hotel du Boccage itself which had
been demolished several years ago. No one wanted to live in it, nor even to
build on the site. The Rue d'Élysée now crossed the ground where Lucille
Debelleyme had walked for the first time on a warm spring day, where the
blood-stained disordered room that the Maréchal de Frediani had sealed up
once stood, where the new governess had noted the dimpled, smiling face of
the Cupidon looking over her shoulder and M. du Boccage had thrown the
flowers and the stale water out of the window, and two years later another
vessel containing water stained with blood: where the portrait of Lord Clare
had hung on the wall of the little study gazing with his amiable, sensual
smile at the green writing-desk where the correspondence of Fanny du Boccage
had been thrown by an exasperated hand. All gone—all vanished.
Mrs. Meadows took up the poker and stirred the fire, not even ashes
Javiaux du Boccage stood deserted; the family had scattered. The only
inhabitants of that grandiose chateau were the two corpses lying side by side
in the new vaults. She with all the panoply and pomp that love and affection
could suggest—he under his plain black pall with a simple cross put
there by the unwilling hand of outraged charity.
Mrs. Meadows looked again at the clock, in another ten minutes she might
expect the first of her guests.
She had now much that in her youth she would have given half her life to
have possessed—the almost idolatrous affection of her husband; the
admiration of a large circle of friends; the discreet fame of a Protestant
martyr who had been involved in the almost incredible machinations of
Catholics and Jesuits; comfort, ease, leisure, power and influence over those
who felt the force of her wit, her intellect—subtle domination.
Mrs. Lucy Meadows had indeed almost everything that Mary Showler, Lucille
Debelleyme, Lucille Clery had longed for; but she secretly, eagerly marked
the passing of every day that brought her nearer to that annihilation which
was her firm conception of death.
Her husband was the first person to enter the room she had so charmingly
prepared for their guests. He had been parted from her several hours and
greeted her as effusively as if he had returned from a long voyage. This
Evangelistic parson, robust, ardent, simple, was completely happy. He had
found that which none of his readings or the transmitted experiences of his
elders had predisposed him to believe possible to find—a woman who
could be as alluring as an accomplished courtesan, who was a perfect
housekeeper, an intelligent companion; the domestic wife and the accomplished
mistress in one, a paragon that many men have laboured in vain to find. The
Rev. Nathaniel Meadows did not thus analyse the matter to himself; he merely
considered his dear Lucy as a worthy helpmate expressly sent him by God.
He kissed her, even after so many years of marriage, eagerly. She entirely
pleased his senses. The richest part of his life was still those moments when
he was not a Puritan, clergyman, nor she a pious matron, but when he, a man
with a woman, served in secret those lustful passions his Church forbade;
when the company had gone there would be the evening together and after the
evening the night... What he said was, "Have you corrected those proofs, my
dear? The paper ought to go to press to-night."
"I will do it when the company have gone. Don't you think Mrs. Stowe's
article rather coarse—it might offend many good Christians. I know it
is only the way she expresses herself, but one does not wish to trespass in
anything beyond the dictates of the Church—"
He said that she was, as always, right, and gazed at her with looks of
love, asking her if she was quite recovered from the summer languors, if she
did not find New York too hot?
His appearance was fine; she had taken great pains with his manners, his
dress, tastes, trying to mould him to the likeness of a memory; but the
result of all her efforts was only the caricature of another man.
She asked him to replenish the fire and watched him while he placed the
logs in that clear hollow of flame where the French newspapers and the
English cutting had been consumed,
He turned back to her with smiles; how charming, how elegant she was! He
was always so glad when the summer, when August was over, because undoubtedly
she languished in the great heat. Her figure was outlined so prettily against
the wall where hung some of her own drawings of flowers, her
faintly-pencilled landscapes. He sincerely blessed God for this lovely,
clever wife; she had her moods, bleak, melancholy, unaccountable, but they
were always brief and there was something even about her rare flashes of
temper, of acid comment that pleased him, like a sharp flavour not understood
but salty and stimulating. They had had few quarrels. He had once brought
home a parcel of music for an entertainment in the Mission Hall; among the
pieces had been an old polka, "La Belle Helene," and two of his congregation,
Miss Bibby and Miss Prue Hardside had wanted to play it as a duet. Then,
really, darling Lucy had behaved most strangely; she had been quite bitter
and violent at the idea of secular music in the Mission Hall, and when he had
urged her not to be narrow minded, she had begun to say terrible
things—in French, which he could understand only roughly now, but the
look, the tone!—Sometimes he recalled that unpleasant incident with a
veritable shudder. Of course, she had had her way and the concert had been
duly dull; of course, she had soon become herself again; he had been very
careful never again to offend her extreme religious susceptibility.
To satisfy the secret, clumsy, shamefaced lusts of a Puritan, to keep his
house in perfect order, to share his enthusiasm for his childish, unpleasant
creed, was it worth while? Only because of a deep, detested instinct of
self-preservation, the inability to forego those poignant memories that must
cease at an atheist's death... and yet death was longed for too. "What a
relief to think that I shall not go to his Heaven—"
He brought the long sheets of print over to her, admiring her little
contribution, and held it before her asking if she did not like the cut of a
cherub playing with daisies that he had chosen to illustrate her essay?
She looked, she praised dutifully, then her glance fell on the number of
the paper printed by the title: one thousand and fifty-four. Instantly she
bent over her work, she was hemming flannel petticoats for orphan girls; her
silver thimble, wreathed with forget-me-nots, gleamed in the firelight.
"Those sketches, my love, should we not publish them in a little
"I really do not know, dear, whether they are suitable for Christian
Evangelists. Besides, they are really very trivial. You must not flatter me,
I have no talent in that direction."
"You have talents, my darling, in all directions, everything you touch is
He could not read the sincere contempt in her smile as she glanced up at
him, he had never been able to understand her at all and never would be. He
was perfectly satisfied with the artificial self she so contemptuously
offered him; her smile became fixed, one thousand and fifty-four.
"I should like them published in a book. You have almost enough," he
urged, gazing fatuously at the cut, the proof.
"Do you think they would be of any interest to the American public, my
"Why I am sure, such pretty, such charming sketches—your account of
Louis Philippe at the Tuileries and of a holiday at Dieppe—those scenes
in a country chateau and the little anecdotes of servants and children! Why,
Mrs. Stowe was speaking to me of it only yesterday; she said it was all most
charmingly done. But what will you call them?"
She turned a full look from her clear, formidable eyes on his candid
"Sketches of Home Life in France, I thought, but perhaps that is a little
"I think it will do very well." Then, "It is hardly charming, pretty
He took from his wide pocket the manuscript of insipid, amiable and mildly
diverting essays which Mrs. Meadows had written on the manners, surroundings
and customs of those strange and rather forbidding people, the French, who,
she laboured to show, had, after all, a friendly, domestic side.
One thousand and fifty-four.
As he turned over with loving admiration the sheets covered with her neat
handwriting, Mrs. Meadows rose and turned her back to her husband so that he
might not surprise the uncontrollable spasm of agony, of bitter longing which
convulsed the features usually so placid; and as her needle darted
mechanically through the flannel the thought "how do I go on living?" seemed
to dart through her heart. An apartment in the Rue Keller—was the
chemist's shop still standing? A sob rose to her throat and lips—a man
staring at her expectantly from under his thick, fair lashes.
Mr. Meadows continued persistently to ask for a title for the little
volume on which he had set his heart.
She glanced at the neat row of books in a glass case—there in the
corner, next a handsome volume adorned with coloured plates, entitled.
Gentlewoman's Annual Amateur Gardening, was a volume of 'Forget-me-not' for
the year 1840; she touched her lips with her thimble which was wreathed with
the simple blue flower: "I shall not forget them and they will not forget
me—no, none of those who met me will ever forget Lucille
Debelleyme—no, I shall not forget—one thousand and
She turned slowly to her husband as a ring of the bell at the main door
announced the first guest:
"If you really want a pretty title—after all it is a book of
reminiscences, why not call it, dear, Forget-me-not?"