Nigger Jeff by
The city editor was waiting for one of his best reporters,
Elmer Davies by name, a vain and rather self-sufficient
youth who was inclined to be of that turn of mind which
sees in life only a fixed and ordered process of rewards
and punishments. If one did not do exactly right, one did
not get along well. On the contrary, if one did, one did.
Only the so-called evil were really punished, only the good
truly rewarded--or Mr. Davies had heard this so long in his
youth that he had come nearly to believe it. Presently he
appeared. He was dressed in a new spring suit, a new hat
and new shoes. In the lapel of his coat was a small bunch
of violets. It was one o'clock of a sunny spring afternoon,
and he was feeling exceedingly well and good-natured--quite
fit, indeed. The world was going unusually well with him.
It seemed worth singing about.
"Read that, Davies," said the city editor, handing him the
clipping. "I'll tell you afterward what I want you to do."
The reporter stood by the editorial chair and read:
Pleasant Valley, Ko., April 16.
"A most dastardly crime has just been reported here. Jeff
Ingalls, a negro, this morning assaulted Ada Whitaker, the
nineteen-year-old daughter of Morgan Whitaker, a well-to-do
farmer, whose home is four miles south of this place. A
posse, headed by Sheriff Mathews, has started in pursuit.
If he is caught, it is thought he will be lynched."
The reporter raised his eyes as he finished. What a
terrible crime! What evil people there were in the world!
No doubt such a creature ought to be lynched, and that
"You had better go out there, Davies," said the city
editor. "It looks as if something might come of that. A
lynching up here would be a big thing. There's never been
one in this state."
Davies smiled. He was always pleased to be sent out of
town. It was a mark of appreciation. The city editor rarely
sent any of the other men on these big stories. What a nice
ride he would have!
As he went along, however, a few minutes later he began to
meditate on this. Perhaps, as the city editor had
suggested, he might be compelled to witness an actual
lynching. That was by no means so pleasant in itself. In
his fixed code of rewards and punishments he had no
particular place for lynchings, even for crimes of the
nature described, especially if he had to witness the
lynching. It was too horrible a kind of reward or
punishment. Once, in line of duty, he had been compelled to
witness a hanging, and that had made him sick--deathly
so--even though carried out as a part of the due process of
law of his day and place. Now, as he looked at this fine
day and his excellent clothes, he was not so sure that this
was a worthwhile assignment. Why should he always be
selected for such things--just because he could write?
There were others--lots of men on the staff. He began to
hope as he went along that nothing really serious would
come of it, that they would catch the man before he got
there and put him in jail--or, if the worst had to
be--painful thought!--that it would be all over by the time
he got there. Let's see--the telegram had been filed at
nine a.m. It was now one-thirty and would be three by the
time he got out there, all of that. That would give them
time enough, and then, if all were well, or ill, as it
were, he could just gather the details of the crime and
the--aftermath--and return. The mere thought of an
approaching lynching troubled him greatly, and the farther
he went the less he liked it.
He found the village of Pleasant Valley a very small affair
indeed, just a few dozen houses nestling between green
slopes of low hills, with one small business corner and a
rambling array of lanes. One or two merchants of K--, the
city from which he had just arrived, lived out here, but
otherwise it was very rural. He took notes of the whiteness
of the little houses, the shimmering beauty of the small
stream one had to cross in going from the depot. At the one
main corner a few men were gathered about a typical village
barroom. Davies headed for this as being the most likely
source of information.
In mingling with this company at first he said nothing
about his being a newspaper man, being very doubtful as to
its effect upon them, their freedom of speech and manner.
The whole company was apparently tense with interest in the
crime which still remained unpunished, seemingly craving
excitement and desirous of seeing something done about it.
No such opportunity to work up wrath and vent their
stored-up animal propensities had probably occurred here in
years. He took this occasion to inquire into the exact
details of the attack, where it had occurred, where the
Whitakers lived. Then, seeing that mere talk prevailed
here, he went away thinking that he had best find out for
himself how the victim was. As yet she had not been
described, and it was necessary to know a little something
about her. Accordingly, he sought an old man who kept a
stable in the village, and procured a horse. No carriage
was to be had. Davies was not an excellent rider, but he
made a shift of it. The Whitaker home was not so very far
away--about four miles out--and before long he was knocking
at its front door, set back a hundred feet from the rough
"I'm from the Times," he said to the tall, raw-
boned woman who opened the door, with an attempt at being
impressive. His position as reporter in this matter was a
little dubious; he might be welcome, and he might not. Then
he asked if this were Mrs. Whitaker, and how Miss Whitaker
was by now.
"She's doing very well," answered the woman, who seemed
decidedly stern, if repressed and nervous, a Spartan type.
"Won't you come in? She's rather feverish, but the doctor
says she'll probably be all right later on." She said no
Davies acknowledged the invitation by entering. He was very
anxious to see the girl, but she was sleeping under the
influence of an opiate, and he did not care to press the
matter at once.
"When did this happen?" he asked.
"About eight o'clock this morning," said the woman.
"She started to go over to our next door neighbor here, Mr.
Edmonds, and this negro met her. We didn't know anything
about it until she came crying through the gate and dropped
down in here."
"Were you the first one to meet her?" asked Davies.
"Yes, I was the only one," said Mrs. Whitaker. "The men had
all gone to the fields."
Davies listened to more of the details, the type and
history of the man, and then rose to go. Before doing so he
was allowed to have a look at the girl, who was still
sleeping. She was young and rather pretty. In the yard he
met a country man who was just coming to get home news. The
latter imparted more information.
"They're lookin' all around south of here," he said,
speaking of a crowd which was supposed to be searching. "I
expect they'll make short work of him if they get him. He
can't get away very well, for he's on foot, wherever he is.
The sheriff's after him too, with a deputy or two, I
believe. He'll be tryin' to save him an' take him over to
Clayton, but I don't believe he'll be able to do it, not if
the crowd catches him first."
So, thought Davies, he would probably have to witness a
lynching after all. The prospect was most unhappy.
"Does any one know where this negro lived?" he asked
heavily, a growing sense of his duty weighing upon him.
"Oh, right down here a little way," replied the farmer.
"Jeff Ingalls was his name. We all know him around here. He
worked for one and another of the farmers hereabouts, and
don't appear to have had such a bad record, either, except
for drinkin' a little now and then. Miss Ada recognized
him, all right. You follow this road to the next crossing
and turn to the right. It's a little log house that sets
back off the road--something like that one you see down the
lane there, only it's got lots o' chips scattered about."
Davies decided to go there first, but changed his mind. It
was growing late, and he thought he had better return to
the village. Perhaps by now developments in connection with
the sheriff or the posse were to be learned.
Accordingly, he rode back and put the horse in the hands of
its owner, hoping that all had been concluded and that he
might learn of it here. At the principal corner much the
same company was still present, arguing, fomenting,
gesticulating. They seemed parts of different companies
that earlier in the day had been out searching. He wondered
what they had been doing since, and then decided to
ingratiate himself by telling them he had just come from
the Whitakers and what he had learned there of the present
condition of the girl and the movements of the sheriff.
Just then a young farmer came galloping up. He was
coatless, hatless, breathless.
"They've got him!" he shouted excitedly. "They've got him!"
A chorus of "whos," "wheres" and "whens" greeted this
information as the crowd gathered about the rider.
"Why, Mathews caught him up here at his own house!"
exclaimed the latter, pulling out a handkerchief and wiping
his face. "He must 'a' gone back there for something.
Mathews's takin' him over to Clayton, so they think, but
they don't project he'll ever get there. They're after him
now, but Mathews says he'll shoot the first man that tries
to take him away."
"Which way'd he go?" exclaimed the men in chorus, stirring
as if to make an attack.
"'Cross Sellers' Lane," said the rider. "The boys think
he's goin' by way of Baldwin."
"Whoopee!" yelled one of the listeners. "We'll get him away
from him, all right! Are you goin', Sam?"
"You bet!" said the latter. "Wait'll I get my horse!"
"Lord!" thought Davies. "To think of being (perforce) one
of a lynching party--a hired spectator!"
He delayed no longer, however, but hastened to secure his
horse again. He saw that the crowd would be off in a minute
to catch up with the sheriff. There would be information in
that quarter, drama very likely.
"What's doin'?" inquired the liveryman as he noted Davies'
"They're after him," replied the latter nervously. "The
sheriff's caught him. They're going now to try to take him
away from him, or that's what they say. The sheriff is
taking him over to Clayton, by way of Baldwin. I want to
get over there if I can. Give me the horse again, and I'll
give you a couple of dollars more."
The liveryman led the horse out, but not without many
provisionary cautions as to the care which was to be taken
of him, the damages which would ensue if it were not. He
was not to be ridden beyond midnight. If one were wanted
for longer than that Davies must get him elsewhere or come
and get another, to all of which Davies promptly agreed. He
then mounted and rode away.
When he reached the corner again several of the men who had
gone for their horses were already there, ready to start.
The young man who had brought the news had long since
dashed off to other parts.
Davies waited to see which road this new company would
take. Then through as pleasant a country as one would wish
to see, up hill and down dale, with charming vistas
breaking upon the gaze at every turn, he did the riding of
his life. So disturbed was the reporter by the grim turn
things had taken that he scarcely noted the beauty that was
stretched before him, save to note that it was so. Death!
Death! The proximity of involuntary and enforced death was
what weighed upon him now.
In about an hour the company had come in sight of the
sheriff, who, with two other men, was driving a wagon he
had borrowed along a lone country road. The latter was
sitting at the back, a revolver in each hand, his face
toward the group, which at sight of him trailed after at a
respectful distance. Excited as every one was, there was no
disposition, for the time being at least, to halt the
progress of the law.
"He's in that wagon," Davies heard one man say. "Don't you
see they've got him in there tied and laid down?"
"That's right," said another. "I see him now."
"What we ought to do," said a third, who was riding near
the front, "is to take him away and hang him. That's just
what he deserves, and that's what he'll get before we're
"Yes!" called the sheriff, who seemed to have heard this.
"You're not goin' to do any hangin' this day, so you just
might as well go on back." He did not appear to be much
troubled by the appearance of the crowd.
"Where's old man Whitaker?" asked one of the men who seemed
to feel that they needed a leader. "He'd get him quick
"He's with the other crowd, down below Olney," was the
"Somebody ought to go an' tell him."
"Clark's gone," assured another, who hoped for the worst.
Davies rode among the company a prey to mingled and
singular feelings. He was very much excited and yet
depressed by the character of the crowd which, in so far as
he could see, was largely impelled to its jaunt by
curiosity and yet also able under sufficient motivation on
the part of some one--any one, really--to kill too. There
was not so much daring as a desire to gain daring from
others, an unconscious wish or impulse to organize the
total strength or will of those present into one strength
or one will, sufficient to overcome the sheriff and inflict
death upon his charge. It was strange--almost
intellectually incomprehensible--and yet so it was. The men
were plainly afraid of the determined sheriff. They thought
something ought to be done, but they did not feel like
getting into trouble.
Mathews, a large solemn, sage, brown man in worn clothes
and a faded brown hat, contemplated the recent addition to
his trailers with apparent indifference. Seemingly he was
determined to protect his man and avoid mob justice, come
what may. A mob should not have him if he had to shoot, and
if he shot it would be to kill. Finally, since the company
thus added to did not dash upon him, he seemingly decided
to scare them off. Apparently he thought he could do this,
since they trailed like calves.
"Stop a minute!" he called to his driver.
The latter pulled up. So did the crowd behind. Then the
sheriff stood over the prostrate body of the negro, who lay
in the jolting wagon beneath him, and called back:
"Go 'way from here, you people! Go on, now! I won't have
you follerin' after me!"
"Give us the nigger!" yelled one in a half-bantering,
half-derisive tone of voice.
"I'll give ye just two minutes to go on back out o' this
road," returned the sheriff grimly, pulling out his watch
and looking at it. They were about a hundred feet apart.
"If you don't, I'll clear you out!"
"Give us the nigger!"
"I know you, Scott," answered Mathews, recognizing the
voice. "I'll arrest every last one of ye tomorrow. Mark my
The company listened in silence, the horses champing and
"We've got a right to foller," answered one of the men.
"I give ye fair warning," said the sheriff, jumping from
his wagon and leveling his pistols as he approached. "When
I count five I'll begin to shoot!"
He was a serious and stalwart figure as he approached, and
the crowd fell back a little.
"Git out o' this now!" he yelled. "One--Two--"
The company turned completely and retreated, Davies among
"We'll foller him when he gits further on," said one of the
men in explanation.
"He's got to do it," said another. "Let him git a little
The sheriff returned to his wagon and drove on. He seemed,
however, to realize that he would not be obeyed and that
safety lay in haste alone. His wagon was traveling fast. If
only he could lose them or get a good start he might
possibly get to Clayton and the strong county jail by
morning. His followers, however, trailed him swiftly as
might be, determined not to be left behind.
"He's goin' to Baldwin," said one of the company of which
Davies was a member.
"Where's that?" asked Davies.
"Over west o' here, about four miles."
"Why is he going there?"
"That's where he lives. I guess he thinks if he kin git 'im
over there he kin purtect 'im till he kin git more help
from Clayton. I cal'late he'll try an' take 'im over yet
to-night, or early in the mornin' shore."
Davies smiled at the man's English. This countryside lingo
always fascinated him.
Yet the men lagged, hesitating as to what to do. They did
not want to lose sight of Matthews, and yet cowardice
controlled them. They did not want to get into direct
altercation with the law. It wasn't their place to hang the
man, although plainly they felt that he ought to be hanged,
and that it would be a stirring and exciting thing if he
were. Consequently they desired to watch and be on hand--to
get old Whitaker and his son Jake, if they could, who were
out looking elsewhere. They wanted to see what the father
and brother would do.
The quandary was solved by one of the men, who suggested
that they could get to Baldwin by going back to Pleasant
Valley and taking the Sand River pike, and that in the
meantime they might come upon Whitaker and his son en
route, or leave word at his house. It was a shorter cut
than this the sheriff was taking, although he would get
there first now. Possibly they could beat him at least to
Clayton, if he attempted to go on. The Clayton road was
back via Pleasant Valley, or near it, and easily
intercepted. Therefore, while one or two remained to trail
the sheriff and give the alarm in case he did attempt to go
on to Clayton, the rest, followed by Davies, set off at a
gallop to Pleasant Valley. It was nearly dusk now when they
arrived and stopped at the corner store--supper time. The
fires of evening meals were marked by upcurling smoke from
chimneys. Here, somehow, the zest to follow seemed to
depart. Evidently the sheriff had worsted them for the
night. Morg Whitaker, the father, had not been found;
neither had Jake. Perhaps they had better eat. Two or three
had already secretly fallen away.
They were telling the news of what had occurred so far to
one of the two storekeepers who kept the place, when
suddenly Jake Whitaker, the girl's brother, and several
companions came riding up. They had been scouring the
territory to the north of the town, and were hot and tired.
Plainly they were unaware of the developments of which the
crowd had been a part.
"The sheriff's got 'im!" exclaimed one of the company, with
that blatancy which always accompanies the telling of great
news in small rural companies. "He taken him over to
Baldwin in a wagon a coupla hours ago."
"Which way did he go?" asked the son, whose hardy figure,
worn, hand-me-down clothes and rakish hat showed up
picturesquely as he turned here and there on his horse.
"'Cross Seller' Lane. You won't git 'em that-a-way,
though, Jake. He's already over there by now. Better take
the short cut."
A babble of voices now made the scene more interesting. One
told how the negro had been caught, another that the
sheriff was defiant, a third that men were still tracking
him or over there watching, until all the chief points of
the drama had been spoken if not heard.
Instantly suppers were forgotten. The whole customary order
of the evening was overturned once more. The company
started off on another excited jaunt, up hill and down
dale, through the lovely country that lay between Baldwin
and Pleasant Valley.
By now Davies was very weary of this procedure and of his
saddle. He wondered when, if ever, this story was to
culminate, let alone he write it. Tragic as it might prove,
he could not nevertheless spend an indefinite period
trailing a possibility, and yet, so great was the
potentiality of the present situation, he dared not leave.
By contrast with the horror impending, as he now noted, the
night was so beautiful that it was all but poignant. Stars
were already beginning to shine. Distant lamps twinkled
like yellow eyes from the cottages in the valleys and on
the hillsides. The air was fresh and tender. Some peafowls
were crying afar off, and the east promised a golden moon.
Silently the assembled company trotted on--no more than a
score in all. In the dusk, and with Jake ahead, it seemed
too grim a pilgrimage for joking. Young Jake, riding
silently toward the front, looked as if tragedy were all he
craved. His friends seemed considerately to withdraw from
him, seeing that he was the aggrieved.
After an hour's riding Baldwin came into view, lying in a
sheltering cup of low hills. Already its lights were
twinkling softly and there was still an air of honest
firesides and cheery suppers about it which appealed to
Davies in his hungry state. Still, he had no thought now of
anything save this pursuit.
Once in the village, the company was greeted by calls of
recognition. Everybody seemed to know what they had come
for. The sheriff and his charge were still there, so a
dozen citizens volunteered. The local storekeepers and
loungers followed the cavalcade up the street to the
sheriff's house, for the riders had now fallen into a
"You won't get him though, boys," said one whom Davies
later learned was Seavey, the village postmaster and
telegraph operator, a rather youthful person of between
twenty-five and thirty, as they passed his door. "He's got
two deputies in there with him, or did have, and they say
he's going to take him over to Clayton."
At the first street corner they were joined by the several
men who had followed the sheriff.
"He tried to give us the slip," they volunteered excitedly,
"but he's got the nigger in the house, there, down in the
cellar. The deputies ain't with him. They've gone somewhere
for help--Clayton, maybe."
"How do you know?"
"We saw 'em go out that back way. We think we did, anyhow."
A hundred feet from the sheriff's little white cottage,
which backed up against a sloping field, the men parleyed.
Then Jake announced that he proposed to go boldly up to the
sheriff's door and demand the negro.
"If he don't turn him out I'll break in the door an' take
him!" he said.
"That's right! We'll stand by you, Whitaker," commented
By now the throng of unmounted natives had gathered. The
whole village was up and about, its one street alive and
running with people. Heads appeared at doors and windows.
Riders pranced up and down, hallooing. A few revolver shots
were heard. Presently the mob gathered even closer to the
sheriff's gate, and Jake stepped forward as leader.
Instead, however, of going boldly up to the door as at
first it appeared he would, he stopped at the gate, calling
to the sheriff.
"Eh, eh, eh!" bellowed the crowd.
The call was repeated. Still no answer. Apparently to the
sheriff delay appeared to be his one best weapon.
Their coming, however, was not as unexpected as some might
have thought. The figure of the sheriff was plainly to be
seen close to one of the front windows. He appeared to be
holding a double-barreled shotgun. The negro, as it
developed later, was cowering and chattering in the darkest
corner of the cellar, hearkening no doubt to the voices and
firing of the revolvers outside.
Suddenly, and just as Jake was about to go forward, the
front door of the house flew open, and in the glow of a
single lamp inside appeared first the double-barreled end
of the gun, followed immediately by the form of Mathews,
who held the weapon poised ready for a quick throw to the
shoulder. All except Jake fell back.
"Mr. Mathews," he called deliberately, "we want that
"Well, you can't git 'im!" replied the sheriff. "He's not
"Then what you got that gun fer?" yelled a voice.
Mathews made no answer.
"Better give him up, Mathews," called another, who was safe
in the crowd, "or we'll come in an' take him!"
"No you won't," said the sheriff defiantly. "I said the man
wasn't here. I say it ag'in. You couldn't have him if he
was, an' you can't come in my house! Now if you people
don't want trouble you'd better go on away."
"He's down in the cellar!" yelled another.
"Why don't you let us see?" asked another.
Mathews waved his gun slightly.
"You'd better go away from here now," cautioned the
sheriff. "I'm tellin' ye! I'll have warrants out for the
lot o' ye, if ye don't mind!"
The crowd continued to simmer and stew, while Jake stood as
before. He was very pale and tense, but lacked initiative.
"He won't shoot," called some one at the back of the crowd.
"Why don't you go in, Jake, an' git him?"
"Sure! Rush in. That's it!" observed a second.
"He won't, eh?" replied the sheriff softly. Then he added
in a lower tone, "The first man that comes inside that gate
takes the consequences."
No one ventured inside the gate; many even fell back. It
seemed as if the planned assault had come to nothing.
"Why not go around the back way?" called some one else.
"Try it!" replied the sheriff. "See what you find on that
side! I told you you couldn't come inside. You'd better go
away from here now before ye git into trouble," he
repeated. "You can't come in, an' it'll only mean
There was more chattering and jesting while the sheriff
stood on guard. He, however, said no more. Nor did he allow
the banter, turmoil and lust for tragedy to disturb him.
Only, he kept his eye on Jake, on whose movements the crowd
seemed to hang.
Time passed, and still nothing was done. The truth was that
young Jake, put to the test, was not sufficiently
courageous himself, for all his daring, and felt the
weakness of the crowd behind him. To all intents and
purposes he was alone, for he did not inspire confidence.
He finally fell back a little, observing, "I'll git 'im
before mornin', all right," and now the crowd itself began
to disperse, returning to its stores and homes or standing
about the postoffice and the one village drugstore.
Finally, Davies smiled and came away. He was sure he had
the story of a defeated mob. The sheriff was to be his
great hero. He proposed to interview him later. For the
present, he meant to seek out Seavey, the telegraph
operator, and arrange to file a message, then see if
something to eat was not to be had somewhere.
After a time he found the operator and told him what he
wanted--to write and file a story as he wrote it. The
latter indicated a table in the little postoffice and
telegraph station which he could use. He became very much
interested in the reporter when he learned he was from the
Times, and when Davies asked where he could get
something to eat said he would run across the street and
tell the proprietor of the only boarding house to fix him
something which he could consume as he wrote. He appeared
to be interested in how a newspaper man would go about
telling a story of this kind over a wire.
"You start your story," he said, "and I'll come back and
see if I can get the Times on the wire."
Davies sat down and began his account. He was intent on
describing things to date, the uncertainty and turmoil, the
apparent victory of the sheriff. Plainly the courage of the
latter had won, and it was all so picturesque. "A foiled
lynching," he began, and as he wrote the obliging
postmaster, who had by now returned, picked up the pages
and carefully deciphered them for himself.
"That's all right. I'll see if I can get the Times
now," he commented.
"Very obliging postmaster," thought Davies as he wrote, but
he had so often encountered pleasant and obliging people on
his rounds that he soon dropped that thought.
The food was brought, and still Davies wrote on, munching
as he did so. In a little while the Times answered
an often-repeated call.
"Davies at Baldwin," ticked the postmaster, "get ready for
quite a story!"
"Let 'er go!" answered the operator at the Times,
who had been expecting this dispatch.
As the events of the day formulated themselves in his mind,
Davies wrote and turned over page after page. Between
whiles he looked out through the small window before him
where afar off he could see a lonely light twinkling
against a hillside. Not infrequently he stopped his work to
see if anything new was happening, whether the situation
was in any danger of changing, but apparently it was not.
He then proposed to remain until all possibility of a
tragedy, this night anyhow, was eliminated. The operator
also wandered about, waiting for an accumulation of pages
upon which he could work but making sure to keep up with
the writer. The two became quite friendly.
Finally, his dispatch nearly finished, he asked the
postmaster to caution the night editor at K-- to the
effect, that if anything more happened before one in the
morning he would file it, but not to expect anything more
as nothing might happen. The reply came that he was to
remain and await developments. Then he and the postmaster
sat down to talk.
About eleven o'clock, when both had about convinced
themselves that all was over for this night anyhow, and the
lights in the village had all but vanished, a stillness of
the purest, summery-est, country-est quality having settled
down, a faint beating of hoofs, which seemed to suggest the
approach of a large cavalcade, could be heard out on the
Sand River pike as Davies by now had come to learn it was,
back or northwest of the postoffice. At the sound the
postmaster got up, as did Davies, both stepping outside and
listening. On it came, and as the volume increased, the
former said, "Might be help for the sheriff, but I doubt
it. I telegraphed Clayton six times to-day. They wouldn't
come that way, though. It's the wrong road." Now, thought
Davies nervously, after all there might be something to add
to his story, and he had so wished that it was all over!
Lynchings, as he now felt, were horrible things. He wished
people wouldn't do such things--take the law, which now
more than ever he respected, into their own hands. It was
too brutal, cruel. That negro cowering there in the dark
probably, and the sheriff all taut and tense, worrying over
his charge and his duty, were not happy things to
contemplate in the face of such a thing as this. It was
true that the crime which had been committed was dreadful,
but still why couldn't people allow the law to take its
course? It was so much better. The law was powerful enough
to deal with cases of this kind.
"They're comin' back, all right," said the postmaster
solemnly, as he and Davies stared in the direction of the
sound which grew louder from moment to moment.
"It's not any help from Clayton, I'm afraid."
"By George, I think you're right!" answered the reporter,
something telling him that more trouble was at hand. "Here
As he spoke there was a clattering of hoofs and crunching
of saddle girths as a large company of men dashed up the
road and turned into the narrow street of the village, the
figure of Jake Whitaker and an older bearded man in a wide
black hat riding side by side in front.
"There's Jake," said the postmaster, "and that's his father
riding beside him there. The old man's a terror when he
gets his dander up. Sompin's sure to happen now."
Davies realized that in his absence writing a new turn had
been given to things. Evidently the son had returned to
Pleasant Valley and organized a new posse or gone out to
meet his father.
Instantly the place was astir again. Lights appeared in
doorways and windows, and both were thrown open. People
were leaning or gazing out to see what new movement was
afoot. Davies noted at once that there was none of the
brash enthusiasm about this company such as had
characterized the previous descent. There was grimness
everywhere, and he now began to feel that this was the
beginning of the end. After the cavalcade had passed down
the street toward the sheriff's house, which was quite dark
now, he ran after it, arriving a few moments after the
former which was already in part dismounted. The
townspeople followed. The sheriff, as it now developed, had
not relaxed any of his vigilance, however; he was not
sleeping, and as the crowd reappeared the light inside
By the light of the moon, which was almost overhead, Davies
was able to make out several of his companions of the
afternoon, and Jake, the son. There were many more, though,
now, whom he did not know, and foremost among them this old
The latter was strong, iron-gray, and wore a full beard. He
looked very much like a blacksmith.
"Keep your eye on the old man," advised the postmaster, who
had by now come up and was standing by.
While they were still looking, the old man went boldly
forward to the little front porch of the house and knocked
at the door. Some one lifted a curtain at the window and
"Hello, in there!" cried the old man, knocking again.
"What do you want?" asked a voice.
"I want that nigger!"
"Well, you can't have him! I've told you people that once."
"Bring him out or I'll break down the door!" said the old
"If you do it's at your own risk. I know you, Whitaker, an'
you know me. I'll give ye two minutes to get off that
"I want that nigger, I tell ye!"
"If ye don't git off that porch I'll fire through the
door," said the voice solemnly. "One--Two--"
The old man backed cautiously away.
"Come out, Mathews!" yelled the crowd. "You've got to give
him up this time. We ain't goin' back without him."
Slowly the door opened, as if the individual within were
very well satisfied as to his power to handle the mob. He
had done it once before this night, why not again? It
revealed his tall form, armed with his shotgun. He looked
around very stolidly, and then addressed the old man as one
would a friend.
"Ye can't have him, Morgan," he said. "It's ag'in' the law.
You know that as well as I do."
"Law or no law," said the old man, "I want that nigger!"
"I tell you I can't let you have him, Morgan. It's ag'in'
the law. You know you oughtn't to be comin' around here at
this time o' night actin' so."
"Well, I'll take him then," said the old man, making a
"Stand back!" shouted the sheriff, leveling his gun on the
instant. "I'll blow ye into kingdom come, sure as hell!"
A noticeable movement on the part of the crowd ceased. The
sheriff lowered his weapon as if he thought the danger were
once more over.
"You-all ought to be ashamed of yerselves," he went on, his
voice sinking to a gentle neighborly reproof, "tryin' to
upset the law this way."
"The nigger didn't upset no law, did he?" asked one
"Well, the law's goin' to take care of the nigger now,"
Mathews made answer.
"Give us that scoundrel, Mathews; you'd better do it," said
the old man. "It'll save a heap o' trouble."
"I'll not argue with ye, Morgan. I said ye couldn't have
him, an' ye can't. If ye want bloodshed, all right. But
don't blame me. I'll kill the first man that tries to make
a move this way."
He shifted his gun handily and waited. The crowd stood
outside his little fence murmuring.
Presently the old man retired and spoke to several others.
There was more murmuring, and then he came back to the dead
"We don't want to cause trouble, Mathews," he began
explanatively, moving his hand oratorically, "but we think
you ought to see that it won't do any good to stand out. We
Davies and the postmaster were watching young Jake, whose
peculiar attitude attracted their attention. The latter was
standing poised at the edge of the crowd, evidently seeking
to remain unobserved. His eyes were on the sheriff, who was
hearkening to the old man. Suddenly, as the father talked
and when the sheriff seemed for a moment mollified and
unsuspecting, he made a quick run for the porch. There was
an intense movement all along the line as the life and
death of the deed became apparent. Quickly the sheriff drew
his gun to his shoulder. Both triggers were pressed at the
same time, and the gun spoke, but not before Jake was in
and under him. The latter had been in sufficient time to
knock the gun barrel upward and fall upon his man. Both
shots blazed harmlessly over the heads of the crowd in red
puffs, and then followed a general onslaught. Men leaped
the fence by tens and crowded upon the little cottage. They
swarmed about every side of the house and crowded upon the
porch, where four men were scuffling with the sheriff. The
latter soon gave up, vowing vengeance and the law. Torches
were brought, and a rope. A wagon drove up and was backed
into the yard. Then began the calls for the negro.
As Davies contemplated all this he could not help thinking
of the negro who during all this turmoil must have been
crouching in his corner in the cellar, trembling for his
fate. Now indeed he must realize that his end was near. He
could not have dozed or lost consciousness during the
intervening hours, but must have been cowering there,
wondering and praying. All the while he must have been
terrified lest the sheriff might not get him away in time.
Now, at the sound of horses' feet and the new murmurs of
contention, how must his body quake and his teeth chatter!
"I'd hate to be that nigger," commented the postmaster
grimly, "but you can't do anything with 'em. The county
oughta sent help."
"It's horrible, horrible!" was all Davies could say.
He moved closer to the house, with the crowd, eager to
observe every detail of the procedure. Now it was that a
number of the men, as eager in their search as bloodhounds,
appeared at a low cellar entryway at the side of the house
carrying a rope. Others followed with torches. Headed by
father and son they began to descend into the dark hole.
With impressive daring, Davies, who was by no means sure
that he would be allowed but who was also determined if
possible to see, followed.
Suddenly, in the farthest corner, he espied Ingalls. The
latter in his fear and agony had worked himself into a
crouching position, as if he were about to spring. His
nails were apparently forced into the earth. His eyes were
rolling, his mouth foaming.
"Oh, my Lawd, boss," he moaned, gazing almost as one blind,
at the lights, "oh, my Lawd, boss, don't kill me! I won't
do it no mo'. I didn't go to do it. I didn't mean to dis
time. I was just drunk, boss. Oh, my Lawd! My Lawd!" His
teeth chattered the while his mouth seemed to gape open. He
was no longer sane really, but kept repeating monotonously,
"Oh, my Lawd!"
"Here he is, boys! Pull him out," cried the father.
The negro now gave one yell of terror and collapsed,
falling prone. He quite bounded as he did so, coming down
with a dead chug on the earthen floor. Reason had forsaken
him. He was by now a groveling, foaming brute. The last
gleam of intelligence was that which notified him of the
set eyes of his pursuers.
Davies, who by now had retreated to the grass outside
before this sight, was standing but ten feet back when they
began to reappear after seizing and binding him. Although
shaken to the roots of his being, he still had all the cool
observing powers of the trained and relentless reporter.
Even now he noted the color values of the scene, the red,
smoky heads of the torches, the disheveled appearance of
the men, the scuffling and pulling. Then all at once he
clapped his hands over his mouth, almost unconscious of
what he was doing.
"Oh, my God!" he whispered, his voice losing power.
The sickening sight was that of the negro, foaming at the
mouth, bloodshot as to his eyes, his hands working
convulsively, being dragged up the cellar steps feet
foremost. They had tied a rope about his waist and feet,
and so had hauled him out, leaving his head to hang and
drag. The black face was distorted beyond all human
"Oh, my God!" said Davies again, biting his fingers
The crowd gathered about now more closely than ever, more
horror-stricken than gleeful at their own work. None
apparently had either the courage or the charity to gainsay
what was being done. With a kind of mechanical deftness now
the negro was rudely lifted and like a sack of wheat thrown
into the wagon. Father and son now mounted in front to
drive and the crowd took to their horses, content to
clatter, a silent cavalcade, behind. As Davies afterwards
concluded, they were not so much hardened lynchers perhaps
as curious spectators, the majority of them, eager for any
variation--any excuse for one--to the dreary commonplaces
of their existences. The task to most--all indeed--was
entirely new. Wide-eyed and nerve-racked, Davies ran for
his own horse and mounting followed. He was so excited he
scarcely knew what he was doing.
Slowly the silent company now took its way up the Sand
River pike whence it had come. The moon was still high,
pouring down a wash of silvery light. As Davies rode he
wondered how he was to complete his telegram, but decided
that he could not. When this was over there would be no
time. How long would it be before they would really hang
him? And would they? The whole procedure seemed so unreal,
so barbaric that he could scarcely believe it--that he was
a part of it. Still they rode on.
"Are they really going to hang him?" he asked of one who
rode beside him, a total stranger who seemed however not to
resent his presence.
"That's what they got 'im fer," answered the stranger.
And think, he thought to himself, to-morrow night he would
be resting in his own good bed back in K--!
Davies dropped behind again and into silence and tried to
recover his nerves. He could scarcely realize that he,
ordinarily accustomed to the routine of the city, its
humdrum and at least outward social regularity, was a part
of this. The night was so soft, the air so refreshing. The
shadowy trees were stirring with a cool night wind. Why
should any one have to die this way? Why couldn't the
people of Baldwin or elsewhere have bestirred themselves on
the side of the law before this, just let it take its
course? Both father and son now seemed brutal, the injury
to the daughter and sister not so vital as all this. Still,
also, custom seemed to require death in this way for this.
It was like some axiomatic, mathematic law--hard, but
custom. The silent company, an articulated, mechanical and
therefore terrible thing, moved on. It also was axiomatic,
mathematic. After a time he drew near to the wagon and
looked at the negro again.
The latter, as Davies was glad to note, seemed still out of
his sense. He was breathing heavily and groaning, but
probably not with any conscious pain. His eyes were fixed
and staring, his face and hands bleeding as if they had
been scratched or trampled upon. He was crumpled limply.
But Davies could stand it no longer now. He fell back, sick
at heart, content to see no more. It seemed a ghastly,
murderous thing to do. Still the company moved on and he
followed, past fields lit white by the moon, under dark,
silent groups of trees, through which the moonlight fell in
patches, up low hills and down into valleys, until at last
a little stream came into view, the same little stream, as
it proved, which he had seen earlier to-day and for a
bridge over which they were heading. Here it ran now,
sparkling like electricity in the night. After a time the
road drew closer to the water and then crossed directly
over the bridge, which could be seen a little way ahead.
Up to this the company now rode and then halted. The wagon
was driven up on the bridge, and father and son got out.
All the riders, including Davies, dismounted, and a full
score of them gathered about the wagon from which the negro
was lifted, quite as one might a bag. Fortunately, as
Davies now told himself, he was still unconscious, an
accidental mercy. Nevertheless he decided now that he could
not witness the end, and went down by the waterside
slightly above the bridge. He was not, after all, the
utterly relentless reporter. From where he stood, however,
he could see long beams of iron projecting out over the
water, where the bridge was braced, and some of the men
fastening a rope to a beam, and then he could see that they
were fixing the other end around the negro's neck.
Finally the curious company stood back, and he turned his
"Have you anything to say?" a voice demanded.
There was no answer. The negro was probably lolling and
groaning, quite as unconscious as he was before.
Then came the concerted action of a dozen men, the lifting
of the black mass into the air, and then Davies saw the
limp form plunge down and pull up with a creaking sound of
rope. In the weak moonlight it seemed as if the body were
struggling, but he could not tell. He watched, wide-mouthed
and silent, and then the body ceased moving. Then after a
time he heard the company making ready to depart, and
finally it did so, leaving him quite indifferently to
himself and his thoughts. Only the black mass swaying in
the pale light over the glimmering water seemed human and
alive, his sole companion.
He sat down upon the bank and gazed in silence. Now the
horror was gone. The suffering was ended. He was no longer
afraid. Everything was summery and beautiful. The whole
cavalcade had disappeared; the moon finally sank. His
horse, tethered to a sapling beyond the bridge, waited
patiently. Still he sat. He might now have hurried back to
the small postoffice in Baldwin and attempted to file
additional details of this story, providing he could find
Seavey, but it would have done no good. It was quite too
late, and anyhow what did it matter? No other reporter had
been present, and he could write a fuller, sadder, more
colorful story on the morrow. He wondered idly what had
become of Seavey? Why had he not followed? Life seemed so
sad, so strange, so mysterious, so inexplicable.
As he still sat there the light of morning broke, a tender
lavender and gray in the east. Then came the roseate hues
of dawn, all the wondrous coloring of celestial halls, to
which the waters of the stream responded. The white pebbles
shone pinkily at the bottom, the grass and sedges first
black now gleamed a translucent green. Still the body hung
there black and limp against the sky, and now a light
breeze sprang up and stirred it visibly. At last he arose,
mounted his horse and made his way back to Pleasant Valley,
too full of the late tragedy to be much interested in
anything else. Rousing his liveryman, he adjusted his
difficulties with him by telling him the whole story,
assuring him of his horse's care and handing him a
five-dollar bill. Then he left, to walk and think again.
Since there was no train before noon and his duty plainly
called him to a portion of another day's work here, he
decided to make a day of it, idling about and getting
additional details as to what further might be done. Who
would cut the body down? What about arresting the
lynchers--the father and son, for instance? What about the
sheriff now? Would he act as he threatened? If he
telegraphed the main fact of the lynching his city editor
would not mind, he knew, his coming late, and the day here
was so beautiful. He proceeded to talk with citizens and
officials, rode out to the injured girl's home, rode to
Baldwin to see the sheriff. There was a singular silence
and placidity in that corner. The latter assured him that
he knew nearly all of those who had taken part, and
proposed to swear out warrants for them, but just the same
Davies noted that he took his defeat as he did his danger,
philosophically. There was no real activity in that corner
later. He wished to remain a popular sheriff, no doubt.
It was sundown again before he remembered that he had not
discovered whether the body had been removed. Nor had he
heard why the negro came back, nor exactly how he was
caught. A nine o'clock evening train to the city giving him
a little more time for investigation, he decided to avail
himself of it. The negro's cabin was two miles out along a
pine-shaded road, but so pleasant was the evening that he
decided to walk. En route, the last rays of the sinking sun
stretched long shadows of budding trees across his path. It
was not long before he came upon the cabin, a one-story
affair set well back from the road and surrounded with a
few scattered trees. By now it was quite dark. The ground
between the cabin and the road was open, and strewn with
the chips of a woodpile. The roof was sagged, and the
windows patched in places, but for all that it had the glow
of a home. Through the front door, which stood open, the
blaze of a wood-fire might be seen, its yellow light
filling the interior with a golden glow.
Hesitating before the door, Davies finally knocked.
Receiving no answer he looked in on the battered cane
chairs and aged furniture with considerable interest. It
was a typical negro cabin, poor beyond the need of
description. After a time a door in the rear of the room
opened and a little negro girl entered carrying a battered
tin lamp without any chimney. She had not heard his knock
and started perceptibly at the sight of his figure in the
doorway. Then she raised her smoking lamp above her head in
order to see better, and approached.
There was something ridiculous about her unformed figure
and loose gingham dress, as he noted. Her feet and hands
were so large. Her black head was strongly emphasized by
little pigtails of hair done up in white twine, which stood
out all over her head. Her dark skin was made apparently
more so by contrast with her white teeth and the whites of
Davies looked at her for a moment but little moved now by
the oddity which ordinarily would have amused him, and
asked, "Is this where Ingalls lived?"
The girl nodded her head. She was exceedingly subdued, and
looked as if she might have been crying.
"Has the body been brought here?"
"Yes, suh," she answered, with a soft negro accent.
"When did they bring it?"
"Are you his sister?"
"Well, can you tell me how they caught him? When did he
come back, and what for?" He was feeling slightly ashamed
to intrude thus.
"In de afternoon, about two."
"And what for?" repeated Davies.
"To see us," answered the girl. "To see my motha'."
"Well, did he want anything? He didn't come just to see
her, did he?"
"Yes, suh," said the girl, "he come to say good-by. We doan
know when dey caught him." Her voice wavered.
"Well, didn't he know he might get caught?" asked Davies
sympathetically, seeing that the girl was so moved.
"Yes, suh, I think he did."
She still stood very quietly holding the poor battered lamp
up, and looking down.
"Well, what did he have to say?" asked Davies.
"He didn' have nothin' much to say, suh. He said he wanted
to see motha'. He was a-goin' away."
The girl seemed to regard Davies as an official of some
sort, and he knew it.
"Can I have a look at the body?" he asked.
The girl did not answer, but started as if to lead the way.
"When is the funeral?" he asked.
The girl then led him through several bare sheds of rooms
strung in a row to the furthermost one of the line. This
last seemed a sort of storage shed for odds and ends. It
had several windows, but they were quite bare of glass and
open to the moonlight save for a few wooden boards nailed
across from the outside. Davies had been wondering all the
while where the body was and at the lonely and forsaken air
of the place. No one but this little pig-tailed girl seemed
about. If they had any colored neighbors they were probably
afraid to be seen here.
Now, as he stepped into this cool, dark, exposed outer
room, the desolation seemed quite complete. It was very
bare, a mere shed or wash-room. There was the body in the
middle of the room, stretched upon an ironing board which
rested on a box and a chair, and covered with a white
sheet. All the corners of the room were quite dark. Only
its middle was brightened by splotches of silvery light.
Davies came forward, the while the girl left him, still
carrying her lamp. Evidently she thought the moon lighted
up the room sufficiently, and she did not feel equal to
remaining. He lifted the sheet quite boldly, for he could
see well enough, and looked at the still, black form. The
face was extremely distorted, even in death, and he could
see where the rope had tightened. A bar of cool moonlight
lay just across the face and breast He was still looking,
thinking soon to restore the covering, when a sound, half
sigh, half groan, reached his ears.
At it he started as if a ghost had made it. It was so eerie
and unexpected in this dark place. His muscles tightened.
Instantly his heart went hammering like mad. His first
impression was that it must have come from the dead.
"Oo-o-ohh!" came the sound again, this time whimpering, as
if some one were crying.
Instantly he turned, for now it seemed to come from a
corner of the room, the extreme corner to his right, back
of him. Greatly disturbed, he approached, and then as his
eyes strained he seemed to catch the shadow of something,
the figure of a woman, perhaps, crouching against the
walls, huddled up, dark, almost indistinguishable.
"Oh, oh, oh!" the sound now repeated itself, even more
plaintively than before.
Davies began to understand. He approached slowly, then more
swiftly desired to withdraw, for he was in the presence of
an old black mammy, doubled up and weeping. She was in the
very niche of the two walls, her head sunk on her knees,
her body quite still. "Oh, oh, oh!" she repeated, as he
stood there near her.
Davies drew silently back. Before such grief his intrusion
seemed cold and unwarranted. The guiltlessness of the
mother--her love--how could one balance that against the
other? The sensation of tears came to his eyes. He
instantly covered the dead and withdrew.
Out in the moonlight he struck a brisk pace, but soon
stopped and looked back. The whole dreary cabin, with its
one golden eye, the door, seemed such a pitiful thing. The
weeping mammy, alone in her corner--and he had come back to
say "Good-by!" Davies swelled with feeling. The night, the
tragedy, the grief, he saw it all. But also with the cruel
instinct of the budding artist that he already was, he was
beginning to meditate on the character of story it would
make--the color, the pathos. The knowledge now that it was
not always exact justice that was meted out to all and that
it was not so much the business of the writer to indict as
to interpret was borne in on him with distinctness by the
cruel sorrow of the mother, whose blame, if any, was
"I'll get it all in!" he exclaimed feelingly, if
triumphantly at last. "I'll get it all in!"