The Best Man
by Edith Wharton
DUSK had fallen, and the circle of light shed by the lamp of
Governor Mornway's writing-table just rescued from the surrounding
dimness his own imposing bulk, thrown back in a deep chair in the
lounging attitude habitual to him at that hour.
When the Governor of Midsylvania rested he rested completely. Five
minutes earlier he had been bowed over his office desk, an Atlas with
the State on his shoulders; now, his working hours over, he had the air
of a man who has spent his day in desultory pleasure, and means to end
it in the enjoyment of a good dinner. This freedom from care threw into
relief the hovering fidgetiness of his sister, Mrs. Nimick, who, just
outside the circle of lamplight, haunted the warm gloom of the hearth,
from which the wood fire now and then sent up an exploring flash into
Mrs. Nimick's presence did not usually minister to repose; but the
Governor's serenity was too deep to be easily disturbed, and he felt
the calmness of a man who knows there is a mosquito in the room, but
has drawn the netting close about his head. This calmness reflected
itself in the accent with which he said, throwing himself back to smile
up at his sister: "You know I am not going to make any appointments for
It was the day after the great reform victory which had put John
Mornway for the second time at the head of his State, a triumph
compared with which even the mighty battle of his first election sank
into insignificance, and he leaned back with the sense of unassailable
placidity which follows upon successful effort.
Mrs. Nimick murmured an apology. "I didn't understand — I saw in
this morning's papers that the Attorney-General was reappointed."
"Oh, Fleetwood — his reappointment was involved in the campaign.
He's one of the principles I represent!"
Mrs. Nimick smiled a little tartly. "It seems odd to some people to
think of Mr. Fleetwood in connection with principles."
The Governor's smile had no answering acerbity; the mention of his
Attorney-General's name had set his blood humming with the thrill of
the fight, and he wondered how it was that Fleetwood had not already
been in to clasp hands with him over their triumph.
"No," he said, good-humoredly, "two years ago Fleetwood's name
didn't stand for principles of any sort; but I believed in him, and
look what he's done for me! I thought he was too big a man not to see
in time that statesmanship is a finer thing than practical politics,
and now that I've given him a chance to make the discovery, he's on the
way to becoming just such a statesman as the country needs."
"Oh, it's a great deal easier and pleasanter to believe in people,"
replied Mrs. Nimick, in a tone full of occult allusion, "and, of
course, we all knew that Mr. Fleetwood would have a hearing before any
The Governor took this imperturbably. "Well, at any rate, he isn't
going to fill all the offices in the State; there will probably be one
or two to spare after he has helped himself, and when the time comes
I'll think over your man. I'll consider him."
Mrs. Nimick brightened. "It would make sucha difference to Jack —
it might mean anything to the poor boy to have Mr. Ashford appointed!"
The Governor held up a warning hand.
"Oh, I know, one mustn't say that, or at least you mustn't listen.
You're so dreadfully afraid of nepotism. But I'm not asking for
anything for Jack — I have never asked for a crust for any of us,
thank Heaven! No one can point to me — " Mrs. Nimick checked herself
suddenly and continued in a more impersonal tone: "But there's no harm,
surely, in my saying a word for Mr. Ashford, when I know that he's
actually under consideration, and I don't see why the fact that Jack is
in his office should prevent my speaking."
"On the contrary," said the Governor, "it implies, on your part, a
personal knowledge of Mr. Ashford's qualifications which may be of
great help to me in reaching a decision."
Mrs. Nimick never quite knew how to meet him when he took that
tone, and the flickering fire made her face for a moment the picture of
uncertainty; then at all hazards she launched out: "Well, I have Ella's
promise, at any rate."
The Governor sat upright. "Ella's promise?"
"To back me up. She thoroughly approves of him!"
The Governor smiled. "You talk as if Ella had a political salonand
distributed lettres de cachet!I'm glad she approves of Ashford; but if
you think my wife makes my appointments for me — " He broke off with a
laugh at the superfluity of such a protest.
Mrs. Nimick reddened. "One never knows how you will take the
simplest thing. What harm is there in my saying that Ella approves of
Mr. Ashford? I thought you liked her to take an interest in your work."
"I like it immensely. But I shouldn't care to have it take that
"That of promising to use her influence to get people appointed.
But you always talk of politics in the vocabulary of European courts.
Thank Heaven, Ella has less imagination. She has her sympathies, of
course, but she doesn't think they can affect the distribution of
Mrs. Nimick gathered up her furs with an air at once crestfallen
and resentful. "I'm sorry — I always seem to say the wrong thing. I'm
sure I came with the best intentions — it's natural that your sister
should want to be with you at such a happy moment."
"Of course it is, my dear," exclaimed the Governor genially, as he
rose to grasp the hands with which she was nervously adjusting her
Mrs. Nimick, who lived a little way out of town, and whose visits
to her brother were apparently achieved at the cost of immense effort
and mysterious complications, had come to congratulate him on his
victory, and to sound him regarding the nomination to a coveted post of
the lawyer in whose firm her eldest son was a clerk. In the urgency of
the latter errand she had rather lost sight of the former, but her face
softened as the Governor, keeping both her hands in his, said in the
voice which always seemed to put the most generous interpretation on
her motives: "I was sure you would be one of the first to give me your
"Oh, your success — no one feels it more than I do!" sighed Mrs.
Nimick, always at home in the emotional key. "I keep in the background.
I make no noise, I claim no credit, but whatever happens, no one shall
ever prevent my rejoicing in my brother's success!"
Mrs. Nimick's felicitations were always couched in the conditional,
with a side-glance at dark contingencies, and the Governor, smiling at
the familiar construction, returned cheerfully: "I don't see why any
one should want to deprive you of that privilege."
"They couldn't — they couldn't — " Mrs. Nimick heroically
"Well, I'm in the saddle for another two years at any rate, so you
had better put in all the rejoicing you can."
"Whatever happens — whatever happens!" cried Mrs. Nimick, melting
on his bosom.
"The only thing likely to happen at present is that you will miss
your train if I let you go on saying nice things to me much longer."
Mrs. Nimick at this dried her eyes, renewed her clutch on her
draperies, and stood glancing sentimentally about the room while her
brother rang for the carriage.
"I take away a lovely picture of you," she murmured. "It's
wonderful what you've made of this hideous house."
"Ah, not I, but Ella — there she doesreign undisputed," he
acknowledged, following her glance about the library, which wore an air
of permanent habitation, of slowly formed intimacy with its inmates, in
marked contrast to the gaudy impersonality of the usual executive
"Oh, she's wonderful, quite wonderful. I see she has got those
imported damask curtains she was looking at the other day at
Fielding's. When I am asked how she does it all, I always say it's
beyond me!" Mrs. Nimick murmured.
"It's an art like another," smiled the Governor. "Ella has been
used to living in tents and she has the knack of giving them a
wonderful look of permanence."
"She certainly makes the most extraordinary bargains — all the
knack in the world won't take the place of such curtains and carpets."
"Are they good? I'm glad to hear it. But all the good curtains and
carpets won't make a house comfortable to live in. There's where the
knack comes in, you see."
He recalled with a shudder the lean Congressional years — the
years before his marriage — when Mrs. Nimick had lived with him in
Washington, and the daily struggle in the House had been combined with
domestic conflicts almost equally recurrent. The offer of a foreign
mission, though disconnecting him from active politics, had the
advantage of freeing him from his sister's tutelage, and in Europe,
where he remained for two years, he had met the lady who was to become
his wife. Mrs. Renfield was the widow of one of the diplomatists who
languish in perpetual first secretary-ship at our various embassies.
Her life had given her ease without triviality, and a sense of the
importance of politics seldom found in ladies of her nationality. She
regarded a public life as the noblest and most engrossing of careers,
and combined with great social versatility an equal gift for reading
blue-books and studying debates. So sincere was the latter taste that
she passed without regret from the amenities of a European life well
stocked with picturesque intimacies to the rawness of the Midsylvanian
capital. She helped Mornway in his fight for the Governorship as a man
likes to be helped by a woman — by her tact, her good looks, her
memory for faces, her knack of saying the right thing to the right
person, and her capacity for obscure hard work in the background of his
public activity. But, above all, she helped him by making his private
life smooth and harmonious. For a man careless of personal ease,
Mornway was singularly alive to the domestic amenities. Attentive
service, well-ordered dinners, brightly burning fires, and a scent of
flowers in the house — these material details, which had come to seem
the extension of his wife's personality, the inevitable result of her
nearness, were as agreeable to him after five years of marriage as in
the first surprise of his introduction to them. Mrs. Nimick had kept
house jerkily and vociferously; Ella performed the same task silently
and imperceptibly, and the results were all in favor of the latter
method. Though neither the Governor nor his wife had large means, the
household, under Mrs. Mornway's guidance, took on an air of sober
luxury as agreeable to her husband as it was exasperating to her
sister-in-law. The domestic machinery ran without a jar. There were no
upheavals, no debts, no squalid cookless hiatuses between intervals of
showy hospitality; the household moved along on lines of quiet elegance
and comfort, behind which only the eye of the housekeeping sex could
have detected a gradually increasing scale of expense.
Such an eye was now projected on the Governor's surroundings, and
its explorations were summed up in the tone in which Mrs. Nimick
repeated from the threshold: "I always say I don't see how she does
The tone did not escape the Governor, but it disturbed him no more
than the buzz of a baffled insect. Poor Grace! It was not his fault if
her husband was given to chimerical investments, if her sons were
"unsatisfactory," and her cooks would not stay with her; but it was
natural that these facts should throw into irritating contrast the ease
and harmony of his own domestic life. It made him all the sorrier for
his sister to know that her envy did not penetrate to the essence of
his happiness, but lingered on those external signs of well-being which
counted for so little in the sum total of his advantages. Poor Mrs.
Nimick's life seemed doubly thin and mean when one remembered that,
beneath its shabby surface, there were no compensating riches of the
IT was the custodian of his own hidden treasure who at this moment
broke in upon his musings. Mrs. Mornway, fresh from her afternoon walk,
entered the room with that air of ease and lightness which seemed to
diffuse a social warmth about her; fine, slender, pliant, so polished
and modeled by an intelligent experience of life that youth seemed
clumsy in her presence. She looked down at her husband and shook her
"You promised to keep the afternoon to yourself, and I hear Grace
has been here."
"Poor Grace — she didn't stay long, and I should have been a brute
not to see her."
He leaned back, filling his gaze to the brim with her charming
image, which obliterated at a stroke the fretful ghost of Mrs. Nimick.
"She came to congratulate you, I suppose?"
"Yes, and to ask me to do something for Ashford."
"Ah — on account of Jack. What does she want for him?"
The Governor laughed. "She said you were in her confidence — that
you were backing her up. She seemed to think your support would ensure
Mrs. Mornway smiled; her smile, always full of delicate
implications, seemed to caress her husband while it gently mocked his
"Poor Grace! I suppose you undeceived her."
"As to your influence? I told her it was paramount where it ought
"And where is that?"
"In the choice of carpets and curtains. It seems ours are almost
"Thanks for the compliment! Too good for what?"
"Our station in life, I suppose. At least they seemed to bother
"Poor Grace! I've always bothered her." She paused, removing her
gloves reflectively and laying her long fine hands on his shoulders as
she stood behind him. "Then you don't believe in Ashford?" Feeling his
slight start, she drew away her hands and raised them to detach her
"What makes you think I don't believe in Ashford?" he asked.
"I asked out of curiosity. I wondered whether you had decided
"No, and I don't mean to for a week. I'm dead beat, and I want to
bring a fresh mind to the question. There is hardly one appointment I'm
sure of except, of course, Fleetwood's."
She turned away from him, smoothing her hair in the mirror above
the mantelpiece. "You're sure of that?" she asked after a moment.
"Of George Fleetwood? And poor Grace thinks you are deep in my
counsels! I am as sure of re-appointing Fleetwood as I am that I have
just been re-elected myself. I've never made any secret of the fact
that if they wanted me back they must have him, too."
"You are tremendously generous!" she murmured.
"Generous? What a strange word to use! Fleetwood is my trump card
— the one man I can count on to carry out my ideas through thick and
She mused on this, smiling a little. "That's why I call you
generous — when I remember how you disliked him two years ago!"
"What of that? I was prejudiced against him, I own; or rather, I
had a just distrust of a man with such a past. But how splendidly he's
wiped it out! What a record he has written on the new leaf he promised
to turn over if I gave him the chance! Do you know," the Governor
interrupted himself with a pleasantly reminiscent laugh, "I was rather
annoyed with Grace when she hinted that you had promised to back up
Ashford — I told her you didn't aspire to distribute patronage. But
she might have reminded me — if she'd known — that it wasyou who
persuaded me to give Fleetwood that chance."
Mrs. Mornway turned with a slight heightening of color. "Grace —
how could she possibly have known?"
"She couldn't, of course, unless she'd read my weakness in my face.
But why do you look so startled at my little joke?"
"It's only that I so dislike Grace's ineradicable idea that I am a
wire-puller. Why should she imagine I would help her about Ashford?"
"Oh, Grace has always been a mild and ineffectual conspirator, and
she thinks every other woman is built on the same plan. But you didget
Fleetwood's job for him, you know," he repeated with laughing
"I had more faith than you in human nature, that's all." She paused
a moment, and then added: "Personally, you know, I have always rather
"Oh, I never doubted your disinterestedness. But you are not going
to turn against your candidate, are you?"
She hesitated. "I am not sure; circumstances alter cases. When you
made Fleetwood Attorney-General two years ago he was the inevitable man
for the place."
"Well — is there a better one now?"
"I don't say there is — it's not my business to look for him, at
any rate. What I mean is that at that time Fleetwood was worth risking
anything for — now I don't know that he is."
"But, even if he were not, what do I risk for him now? I don't see
your point. Since he didn't cost me my re-election, what can he
possibly cost me now I'm in?"
"He's immensely unpopular. He will cost you a great deal of
popularity, and you have never pretended to despise that."
"No, nor ever sacrificed anything essential to it. Are you really
asking me to offer up Fleetwood to it now?"
"I don't ask you to do anything — except to consider if he
isessential. You said you were over-tired and wanted to bring a fresh
mind to bear on the other appointments. Why not delay this one too?"
Mornway turned in his chair and looked at her searchingly. "This
means something, Ella. What have you heard?"
"Just what you have, probably, but with more attentive ears. The
very record you are so proud of has made George Fleetwood innumerable
enemies in the last two years. The Lead Trust people are determined to
ruin him, and if his reappointment is attacked you will not be spared."
"Attacked? In the papers, you mean?"
She paused. "You know the 'Spy' has always threatened a campaign.
And he has a past, as you say."
"Which was public property long before I first appointed him.
Nothing could be gained by raking up his old political history.
Everybody knows he didn't come to me with clean hands, but to hurt him
now the 'Spy' would have to fasten a new scandal on him, and that would
not be easy."
"It would be easy to invent one!"
"Unproved accusations don't count much against a man of such proved
capacity. The best answer is his record of the last two years. That is
what the public looks at."
"The public looks wherever the press points. And besides, you have
your own future to consider. It would be a pity to sacrifice such a
career as yours for the sake of backing up even as useful a man as
George Fleetwood." She paused, as if checked by his gathering frown,
but went on with fresh decision: "Oh, I'm not speaking of personal
ambition; I'm thinking of the good you can do. Will Fleetwood's
reappointment secure the greatest good of the greatest number, if his
unpopularity reacts on you to the extent of hindering your career?"
The Governor's brow cleared and he rose with a smile. "My dear,
your reasoning is admirable, but we must leave my career to take care
of itself. Whatever I may be to-morrow, I am Governor of Midsylvania
to-day, and my business as Governor is to appoint as Attorney-General
the best man I can find for the place — and that man is George
Fleetwood, unless you have a better one to propose." She met this with
perfect good-humor. "No, I have told you already that that is not my
business. But I havea candidate of my own for another office, so Grace
was not quite wrong, after all."
"Well, who is your candidate, and for what office? I only hope you
don't want to change cooks!"
"Oh, I do that without your authority, and you never even know it
has been done." She hesitated, and then said with a bright directness:
"I want you to do something for poor Gregg."
"Gregg? Rufus Gregg?" He stared. "What an extraordinary request!
What can I do for a man I've had to kick out for dishonesty?"
"Not much, perhaps; I know it's difficult. But, after all, it was
your kicking him out that ruined him."
"It was his dishonesty that ruined him. He was getting a good
salary as my stenographer, and if he hadn't sold those letters to the
'Spy' he would have been getting it still."
She wavered. "After all, nothing was proved — he always denied
"Good heavens, Ella! Have you ever doubted his guilt?"
"No — no; I don't mean that. But, of course, his wife and children
believe in him, and think you were cruel, and he has been out of work
so long that they are starving."
"Send them some money, then; I wonder you thought it necessary to
"I shouldn't have thought it so, but money is not what I want. Mrs.
Gregg is proud, and it is hard to help her in that way. Couldn't you
give him work of some kind — just a little post in a corner?"
"My dear child, the little posts in the corner are just the ones
where honesty is essential. A footpad doesn't wait under a street-lamp!
Besides, how can I recommend a man whom I have dismissed for theft? I
won't say a word to hinder his getting a place, but on my conscience I
can't give him one."
She paused and turned toward the door silently, though without any
show of resentment; but on the threshold she lingered long enough to
say: "Yet you gave Fleetwood his chance!"
"Fleetwood? You class Fleetwood with Gregg? The best man in the
State with a little beggarly thieving nonentity? It's evident enough
you're new at wire-pulling, or you would show more skill at it!"
She met this with a laugh. "I'm not likely to have much practice if
my first attempt is such a failure. Well, I will see if Mrs. Gregg will
let me help her a little — I suppose there is nothing else to be
"Nothing that we can do. If Gregg wants a place he had better get
one on the staff of the 'Spy.' He served them better than he did me."
THE Governor stared at the card with a frown. Half an hour had
elapsed since his wife had gone upstairs to dress for the big dinner
from which official duties excused him, and he was still lingering over
the fire before preparing for his own solitary meal. He expected no one
that evening but his old friend Hadley Shackwell, with whom it was his
long-established habit to talk over his defeats and victories in the
first lull after the conflict; and Shackwell was not likely to turn up
till nine o'clock. The unwonted stillness of the room, and the
knowledge that he had a quiet evening before him, filled the Governor
with a luxurious sense of repose. The world seemed to him a good place
to be in, and his complacency was shadowed only by the fear that he had
perhaps been a trifle over-harsh in refusing his wife's plea for the
stenographer. There seemed, therefore, a certain fitness in the
appearance of the man's card, and the Governor with a sigh gave orders
that Gregg should be shown in.
Gregg was still the soft-stepping scoundrel who invited the toe of
honesty, and Mornway, as he entered, was conscious of a sharp revulsion
of feeling. But it was impossible to evade the interview, and he sat
silent while the man stated his case.
Mrs. Mornway had represented the stenographer as being in desperate
straits, and ready to accept any job that could be found, but though
his appearance might have seemed to corroborate her account, he
evidently took a less hopeless view of his case, and the Governor found
with surprise that he had fixed his eye on a clerkship in one of the
Government offices, a post which had been half promised him before the
incident of the letters. His plea was that the Governor's charge,
though unproved, had so injured his reputation that he could only hope
to clear himself by getting some sort of small job under the
Administration. After that, it would be easy for him to obtain any
employment he wanted.
He met Mornway's refusal with civility, but remarked after a
moment: "I hadn't expected this, Governor. Mrs. Mornway led me to think
that something might be arranged."
The Governor's tone was brief. "Mrs. Mornway is sorry for your wife
and children, and for their sake would be glad to find work for you,
but she could not have led you to think that there was any chance of
your getting a clerkship."
"Well, that's just it; she said she thought she could manage it."
"You have misinterpreted my wife's interest in your family. Mrs.
Mornway has nothing to do with the distribution of Government offices."
The Governor broke off, annoyed to find himself asseverating for the
second time so obvious a fact.
There was a moment's silence; then Gregg said, still in a perfectly
equable tone: "You've always been hard on me, Governor, but I don't
bear malice. You accused me of selling those letters to the 'Spy' — "
The Governor made an impatient gesture.
"You couldn't prove your case," Gregg went on imperturbably, "but
you were right in one respect. I wason confidential terms with the
'Spy.'" He paused and glanced at Mornway, whose face remained
immovable. "I'm on the same terms with them still, and I'm ready to let
you have the benefit of it if you'll give methe chance to retrieve my
In spite of his irritation the Governor could not repress a smile.
"In other words, you will do a dirty trick for me if I undertake to
convince people that you are the soul of honor."
Gregg smiled also.
"There are always two ways of putting a thing. Why not call it a
plain case of give and take? I want something and can pay for it."
"Not in any coin I have a use for," said Mornway, pushing back his
Gregg hesitated; then he said: "Perhaps you don't mean to reappoint
Fleetwood." The Governor was silent, and he continued: "If you do,
don't kick me out a second time. I'm not threatening you — I'm
speaking as a friend. Mrs. Mornway has been kind to my wife, and I'd
like to help her."
The Governor rose, gripping his chair-back sternly. "You will be
kind enough to leave my wife's name out of the discussion. I supposed
you knew me well enough to know that I don't buy newspaper secrets at
any price, least of all at that of the public money!"
Gregg, who had risen also, stood a few feet off, looking at him
"Is that final, Governor?"
"Well, good evening, then."
SHACKWELL and the Governor sat over the evening embers. It was
after ten o'clock, and the servant had carried away the coffee and
liqueurs, leaving the two men to their cigars. Mornway had once more
lapsed into his arm-chair, and sat with out-stretched feet, gazing
comfortably at his friend.
Shackwell was a small dry man of fifty, with a face as sallow and
freckled as a winter pear, a limp mustache, and shrewd, melancholy
"I am glad you have given yourself a day's rest," he said, looking
at the Governor.
"Well, I don't know that I needed it. There's such exhilaration in
victory that I never felt fresher."
"Ah, but the fight's just beginning."
"I know — but I'm ready for it. You mean the campaign against
Fleetwood. I understand there is to be a big row. Well, he and I are
used to rows."
Shackwell paused, surveying his cigar. "You knew the 'Spy' meant to
lead the attack?"
"Yes. I was offered a glimpse of the documents this afternoon."
Shackwell started up. "You didn't refuse?"
Mornway related the incident of Gregg's visit. "I could hardly buy
my information at that price," he said, "and, besides, it is really
Fleetwood's business this time. I suppose he has heard the report, but
it doesn't seem to bother him. I rather thought he would have looked in
to-day to talk things over, but I haven't seen him."
Shackwell continued to twist his cigar through his sallow fingers
without remembering to light it. "You're determined to reappoint
Fleetwood?" he asked at length.
The Governor caught him up. "You're the fourth person who has asked
me that to-day! You haven't lost faith in him, have you, Hadley?"
"Not an atom!" said the other with emphasis.
"Well, then, what are you all thinking of, to suppose I can be
frightened by a little newspaper talk? Besides, if Fleetwood is not
afraid, why should I be?"
"Because you'll be involved in it with him."
The Governor laughed. "What have they got against me now?"
Shackwell, standing up, confronted his friend solemnly. "This —
that Fleetwood bought his appointment two years ago."
"Ah — bought it of me? Why didn't it come out at the time?"
"Because it wasn't known then. It has only been found out lately."
"Known — found out? This is magnificent! What was my price, and
what did I do with the money?"
Shackwell glanced about the room, and his eyes returned to
"Look here, John, Fleetwood is not the only man in the world."
"The only man?"
"The only Attorney-General. "The 'Spy' has the Lead Trust behind it
and means to put up a savage fight. Mud sticks, and — "
"Hadley, is this a conspiracy? You're saying to me just what Ella
said this afternoon."
At the mention of Mrs. Mornway's name a silence fell between the
two men and the Governor moved uneasily in his chair.
"You are not advising me to chuck Fleetwood because the 'Spy' is
going to accuse me of having sold him his first appointment?" he said
Shackwell drew a deep breath. "You say yourself that Mrs. Mornway
gave you the same advice this afternoon."
"Well, what of that? Do you imagine that my wife distrib — " The
Governor broke off with an exasperated laugh.
Shackwell, leaning against the mantelpiece, looked down into the
embers. "I didn't say the 'Spy' meant to accuse youof having sold the
Mornway stood up slowly, his eyes on his friend's averted face. The
ashes dropped from his cigar, scattering a white trail across the
carpet which had excited Mrs. Nimick's envy.
"The office is in my gift. If I didn't sell it, who did?" he
Shackwell laid a hand on his arm. "For heaven's sake, John — "
"Who did, who did?" the Governor violently repeated.
The two men faced each other in the closely curtained silence of
the dim luxurious room. Shackwell's eyes again wandered, as if
summoning the walls to reply. Then he said, "I have positive
information that the 'Spy' will say nothing if you don't appoint
"And what will it say if I do appoint him?"
"That he bought his first appointment from your wife."
The Governor stood silent, immovable, while the blood crept slowly
from his strong neck to his lowering brows. Once he laughed, then he
set his lips and continued to gaze into the fire. After a while he
looked at his cigar and shook the freshly formed cone of ashes
carefully upon the hearth. He had just turned again to Shackwell when
the door opened and the butler announced: "Mr. Fleetwood."
The room swam about Shackwell, and when he recovered himself,
Mornway, with outstretched hand, was advancing quietly to meet his
Fleetwood was a smaller man than the Governor. He was erect and
compact, with a face full of dry energy, which seemed to press forward
with the spring of his prominent features, as though it were the weapon
with which he cleared his way through the world. He was in evening
dress, scrupulously appointed, but pale and nervous. Of the two men, it
was Mornway who was the more composed.
"I thought I should have seen you before this," he said.
Fleetwood returned his grasp and shook hands with Shackwell.
"I knew you needed to be let alone. I didn't mean to come to-
night, but I wanted to say a word to you."
At this, Shackwell, who had fallen into the background, made a
motion of leave-taking, but the Governor arrested it.
"We haven't any secrets from Hadley, have we, Fleetwood?"
"Certainly not. I am glad to have him stay. I have simply come to
say that I have been thinking over my future arrangements, and that I
find it will not be possible for me to continue in office."
There was a long pause, during which Shackwell kept his eyes on
Mornway. The Governor had turned pale, but when he spoke his voice was
full and firm.
"This is sudden," he said.
Fleetwood stood leaning against a high chair-back, fretting its
carved ornaments with restless fingers. "It is sudden — yes. I —
there are a variety of reasons."
"Is one of them the fact that you are afraid of what the 'Spy' is
going to say?"
The Attorney-General flushed deeply and moved away a few steps.
"I'm sick of mud-throwing," he muttered.
"George Fleetwood!" Mornway exclaimed. He had advanced toward his
friend, and the two stood confronting each other, already oblivious of
"It's not only that, of course. I've been frightfully hard- worked.
My health has given way — "
Fleetwood forced a smile. "My dear fellow, what a slave- driver you
are! Hasn't a man the right to take a rest?"
"Not a soldier on the eve of battle. You have never failed me
"I don't want to fail you now. But it isn't the eve of battle —
you're in, and that's the main thing."
"The main thing at present is that you promised to stay in with me,
and that I must have your real reason for breaking your word."
Fleetwood made a deprecatory movement. "My dear Governor, if you
only knew it, I'm doing you a service in backing out."
"A service — why?"
"Because I'm hated — because the Lead Trust wants my blood, and
will have yours too if you appoint me."
"Ah, that's the real reason, then — you're afraid of the 'Spy'?"
"Afraid — ?"
The Governor continued to speak with dry deliberation. "Evidently,
then, you know what they mean to say."
Fleetwood laughed. "One needn't do that to be sure it will be
"Who cares how abominable it is if it isn't true?"
Fleetwood shrugged his shoulders and was silent. Shackwell, from a
distant seat, uttered a faint protesting sound, but no one heeded him.
The Governor stood squarely before Fleetwood, his hands in his pockets.
"It istrue, then?" he demanded.
"What is true?"
"What the 'Spy' means to say — that you bought my wife's influence
to get your first appointment."
In the silence Shackwell started suddenly to his feet. A sound of
carriage-wheels had disturbed the quiet street. They paused and then
rolled up the semicircle to the door of the Executive Mansion.
"John!" Shackwell warned him.
The Governor turned impatiently; there was the sound of a servant's
steps in the hall, followed by the opening and closing of the outer
"Your wife — Mrs. Mornway!" Shackwell cried.
Another step, accompanied by a soft rustle of skirts, was advancing
toward the library.
"My wife? Let her come!" said the Governor.
She stood before them in her bright evening dress, with an arrested
brilliancy of aspect like the sparkle of a fountain suddenly caught in
ice. Her look moved rapidly from one to the other; then she came
forward, while Shackwell slipped behind her to close the door.
"What has happened?" she said.
Shackwell began to speak, but the Governor interposed calmly:
"Fleetwood has come to tell me that he does not wish to remain in
"Ah!" she murmured.
There was another silence. Fleetwood broke it by saying: "It is
getting late. If you want to see me to-morrow — "
The Governor looked from his face to Ella's. "Yes; go now," he
Shackwell moved in Fleetwood's wake to the door. Mrs. Mornway stood
with her head high, smiling slightly. She shook hands with each of the
men in turn; then she moved toward the sofa and laid aside her shining
cloak. All her gestures were calm and noble, but as she raised her hand
to unclasp the cloak her husband uttered a sudden exclamation.
"Where did you get that bracelet? I don't remember it."
"This?" She looked at him with astonishment. "It belonged to my
mother. I don't often wear it."
"Ah — I shall suspect everything now," he groaned.
He turned away and flung himself with bowed head in the chair
behind his writing-table. He wanted to collect himself, to question
her, to get to the bottom of the hideous abyss over which his
imagination hung. But what was the use? What did the facts matter? He
had only to put his memories together — they led him straight to the
truth. Every incident of the day seemed to point a leering finger in
the same direction, from Mrs. Nimick's allusion to the imported damask
curtains to Gregg's confident appeal for rehabilitation.
"If you imagine that my wife distributes patronage — " he heard
himself repeating inanely, and the walls seemed to reverberate with the
laughter which his sister and Gregg had suppressed. He heard Ella rise
from the sofa and lifted his head sharply.
"Sit still!" he commanded. She sank back without speaking, and he
hid his face again. The past months, the past years, were dancing a
witches' dance about him. He remembered a hundred significant things. .
. . Oh, God, he cried to himself, if only she does not lie about
it!Suddenly he recalled having pitied Mrs. Nimick because she could not
penetrate to the essence of his happiness. Those were the very words he
had used! He heard himself laugh aloud. The clock struck — it went on
striking interminably. At length he heard his wife rise again and say
with sudden authority: "John, you must speak."
Authority — she spoke to him with authority! He laughed again, and
through his laugh he heard the senseless rattle of the words, "If you
imagine that my wife distributes patronage . . ."
He looked up haggardly and saw her standing before him. If only she
would not lie about it! He said: "You see what has happened."
"I suppose some one has told you about the 'Spy.'"
"Who told you? Gregg?" he interposed.
"Yes," she said quietly.
"That was why you wanted — ?"
"Why I wanted you to help him? Yes."
"Oh, God! . . . He wouldn't take money?"
"No, he wouldn't take money."
He sat silent, looking at her, noting with a morbid minuteness the
exquisite finish of her dress, that finish which seemed so much a part
of herself that it had never before struck him as a merely purchasable
accessory. He knew so little what a woman's dresses cost! For a moment
he lost himself in vague calculations; finally, he said: "What did you
do it for?"
"Take money from Fleetwood."
She paused a moment and then said: "If you will let me explain — "
And then he saw that, all along, he had thought she would be able
to disprove it! A smothering blackness closed in on him, and he had a
physical struggle for breath. Then he forced himself to his feet and
said: "He was your lover?"
"Oh, no, no, no!" she cried with conviction. He hardly knew whether
the shadow lifted or deepened; the fact that he instantly believed her
seemed only to increase his bewilderment. Presently he found that she
was still speaking, and he began to listen to her, catching a phrase
now and then through the deafening clamor of his thoughts.
It amounted to this — that just after her husband's first
election, when Fleetwood's claims for the Attorney-Generalship were
being vainly pressed by a group of his political backers, Mrs. Mornway
had chanced to sit next to him once or twice at dinner. One day, on the
strength of these meetings, he had called and asked her frankly if she
would not help him with her husband. He had made a clean breast of his
past, but had said that, under a man like Mornway, he felt he could
wipe out his political sins and purify himself while he served the
party. She knew the party needed his brains, and she believed in him —
she was sure he would keep his word. She would have spoken in his favor
in any case — she would have used all her influence to overcome her
husband's prejudice — and it was by a mere accident that, in the
course of one of their talks, he happened to give her a "tip" (his past
connections were still useful for such purposes), a "tip" which, in the
first invading pressure of debt after Mornway's election, she had not
had the courage to refuse. Fleetwood had made some money for her —
yes, about thirty thousand dollars. She had repaid what he had lent
her, and there had been no further transactions of the kind between
them. But it appeared that Gregg, before his dismissal, had got hold of
an old check-book which gave a hint of the story, and had pieced the
rest together with the help of a clerk in Fleetwood's office. The "Spy"
was in possession of the facts, but did not mean to use them if
Fleetwood was not reappointed, the Lead Trust having no personal grudge
Her story ended there, and she sat silent while he continued to
look at her. So much had perished in the wreck of his faith that he did
not attach much value to what remained. It scarcely mattered that he
believed her when the truth was so sordid. There had been, after all,
nothing to envy him for but what Mrs. Nimick had seen; the core of his
life was as mean and miserable as his sister's. . . .
His wife rose at length, pale but still calm. She had a kind of
external dignity which she wore like one of her rich dresses. It seemed
as little a part of her now as the finery of which his gaze
contemptuously reckoned the cost.
"John — " she said, laying her hand on his shoulder.
He looked up wearily. "You had better go to bed," he interjected.
"Don't look at me in that way. I am prepared for your being angry
with me — I made a dreadful mistake and must bear my punishment: any
punishment you choose to inflict. But you must think of yourself first
— you must spare yourself. Why should you be so horribly unhappy?
Don't you see that since Mr. Fleetwood has behaved so well we are quite
safe? And I swear to you I have paid back every penny of the money."
THREE days later Shackwell was summoned by telephone to the
Governor's office in the Capitol. There had been, in the interval, no
communication between the two men, and the papers had been silent or
In the lobby Shackwell met Fleetwood leaving the building. For a
moment the Attorney-General seemed about to speak; then he nodded and
passed on, leaving to Shackwell the impression of a face more than ever
thrust forward like a weapon.
The Governor sat behind his desk in the clear autumn sunlight. In
contrast to Fleetwood he seemed relaxed and unwieldy, and the face he
turned to his friend had a gray look of convalescence. Shackwell
wondered, with a start of apprehension, if he and Fleetwood had been
He relieved himself of his overcoat without speaking, and when he
turned again toward Mornway he was surprised to find the latter
watching him with a smile.
"It's good to see you, Hadley," the Governor said.
"I waited to be sent for; I knew you'd let me know when you wanted
me," Shackwell replied.
"I didn't send for you on purpose. If I had, I might have asked
your advice, and I didn't want to ask anybody's advice but my own." The
Governor spoke steadily, but in a voice a trifle too well disciplined
to be natural. "I've had a three days' conference with myself," he
continued, "and now that everything is settled I want you to do me a
"Yes?" Shackwell assented. The private issues of the affair were
still wrapped in mystery to him, but he had never had a moment's doubt
as to its public solution, and he had no difficulty in conjecturing the
nature of the service he was to render. His heart ached for Mornway,
but he was glad the inevitable step was to be taken without further
"Everything is settled," the Governor repeated, "and I want you to
notify the press that I have decided to reappoint Fleetwood."
Shackwell bounded from his seat. "Good heavens!" he ejaculated.
"To reappoint Fleetwood," the Governor repeated, "because at the
present juncture of affairs he is the only man for the place. The work
we began together is not finished, and I can't finish it without him.
Remember the vistas opened by the Lead Trust investigation — he knows
where they lead and no one else does. We must put that inquiry through,
no matter what it costs us, and that is why I have sent for you to take
this letter to the 'Spy.'"
Shackwell's hand drew back from the proffered envelope.
"You say you don't want my advice, but you can't expect me to go on
such an errand with my eyes shut. What on earth are you driving at? Of
course Fleetwood will persist in refusing."
Mornway smiled. "He did persist — for three hours. But when he
left here just now he had given me his word to accept."
Shackwell groaned. "Then I am dealing with two madmen instead of
The Governor laughed. "My poor Hadley, you're worse than I
expected. I thought you would understand me."
"Understand you? How can I, in heaven's name, when I don't
understand the situation?
"The situation — the situation?" Mornway repeated slowly. "Whose?
His or mine? I don't either — I haven't had time to think of them."
"What on earth have you been thinking of then?"
The Governor rose, with a gesture toward the window, through which,
below the slope of the Capitol grounds, the roofs and steeples of the
city spread their smoky mass to the mild air.
"Of all that is left," he said. "Of everything except Fleetwood and
"Ah — " Shackwell murmured.
Mornway turned back and sank into his seat. "Don't you see that was
all I had to turn to? The State — the country — it's big enough, in
all conscience, to fill a good deal of a void! My own walls had grown
too cramped for me, so I just stepped outside. You have no idea how it
simplified matters at once. All I had to do was to say to myself: 'Go
ahead, and do the best you can for the country.' The personal issue
simply didn't exist."
"Yes — and then?"
"Then I turned over for three days this question of the
Attorney-Generalship. I couldn't see that it was changed — how should
myfeelings have affected it? Fleetwood hasn't betrayed the State. There
isn't a scar on his public record — he is still the best man for the
place. My business is to appoint the best man I can find, and I can't
find any one as good as Fleetwood."
"But — but — your wife?" Shackwell stammered.
The Governor looked up with surprise. Shackwell could almost have
sworn that he had indeed forgotten the private issue.
"My wife is ready to face the consequences," he said.
Shackwell returned to his former attitude of incredulity.
"But Fleetwood? Fleetwood has no right to sacrifice — "
"To sacrifice my wife to the State? Oh, let us beware of big words.
Fleetwood was inclined to use them at first, but I managed to restore
his sense of proportion. I showed him that our private lives are only a
few feet square anyhow, and that really, to breathe freely, one must
get out of them into the open." He paused and broke out with sudden
violence, "My God, Hadley, didn't you see that Fleetwood had to obey
"Yes — I see that," said Shackwell, with reviving obstinacy. "But
if you've reached such a height and pulled him up to your side it seems
to me that from that standpoint you ought to get an even clearer view
of the madness of your position. You say you have decided to sacrifice
your own feelings and your wife's — though I'm not so sure of your
right to dispose of hervoice in the matter; but what if you sacrifice
the party and the State as well, in this transcendental attempt to
distinguish between private and public honor? You'll have to answer
that before you can get me to carry this letter."
The Governor did not blanch under the attack.
"I think the letter will answer you," he said calmly.
"Yes. It's something more than a notification of Fleetwood's
reappointment." Mornway paused and looked steadily at his friend.
"You're afraid of an investigation — an impeachment? Well, the letter
"How, in heaven's name?"
"By a plain statement of the facts. My wife has told me that she
did borrow of Fleetwood. He speculated for her and made a considerable
sum, out of which she repaid his loan. The 'Spy's' accusation is true.
If it can be proved that my wife induced me to appoint Fleetwood, it
may be argued that she sold him the appointment. But it can't be
proved, and the 'Spy' won't waste its breath in trying to, because my
statement will take the sting out of its innuendoes. I propose to
anticipate its attack by setting forth the facts in its columns, and
asking the public to decide between us. On one side is the private fact
that my wife, without my knowledge, borrowed money from Fleetwood just
before I appointed him to an important post; on the other side is his
public record and mine. I want people to see both sides and judge
between them, not in the red glare of a newspaper denunciation, but in
the plain daylight of common-sense. Charges against the private
morality of a public man are usually made in such a blare of headlines
and cloud of mud-throwing that the voice he lifts up in his defence can
not make itself heard. In this case I want the public to hear what I
have to say before the yelping begins. My letter will take the wind out
of the 'Spy's' sails, and if the verdict goes against me, the case will
have been decided on its own merits, and not at the dictation of the
writers of scare heads. Even if I don't gain my end, it will be a good
thing, for once, for the public to consider dispassionately how far a
private calamity should be allowed to affect a career of public
usefulness, and the next man who goes through what I am undergoing may
have cause to thank me if no one else does."
Shackwell sat silent for a moment, with the ring of the last words
in his ears.
Suddenly he rose and held out his hand. "Give me the letter," he
The Governor caught him up with a kindling eye. "It's all right,
then? You see, and you'll take it?"
Shackwell met his glance with one of melancholy interrogation. "I
think I see a magnificent suicide, but it's the kind of way I shouldn't
mind dying myself."
He pulled himself silently into his coat and put the letter into
one of its pockets, but as he was turning to the door the Governor
called after him cheerfully: "By the way, Hadley, aren't you and Mrs.
Shackwell giving a big dinner to-morrow?"
Shackwell paused with a start. "I believe we are — why?"
"Because, if there is room for two more, my wife and I would like
to be invited."
Shackwell nodded his assent and turned away without answering. As
he came out of the lobby into the clear sunset radiance he saw a
victoria drive up the long sweep to the Capitol and pause before the
central portion. He descended the steps, and Mrs. Mornway leaned from
her furs to greet him.
"I have called for my husband," she said, smiling.
"Can you tell me if any one is with him? He promised to get away in
time for a little turn in the Park before dinner."