Camille (La Dame aux Camilias) by Dumas, fils
CAMILLE (LA DAME AUX CAMILIAS)
by ALEXANDRE DUMAS fils
In my opinion, it is impossible to create characters until one has
spent a long time in studying men, as it is impossible to speak a
language until it has been seriously acquired. Not being old enough to
invent, I content myself with narrating, and I beg the reader to assure
himself of the truth of a story in which all the characters, with the
exception of the heroine, are still alive. Eye-witnesses of the greater
part of the facts which I have collected are to be found in Paris, and
I might call upon them to confirm me if my testimony is not enough.
And, thanks to a particular circumstance, I alone can write these
things, for I alone am able to give the final details, without which it
would have been impossible to make the story at once interesting and
This is how these details came to my knowledge. On the 12th of
March, 1847, I saw in the Rue Lafitte a great yellow placard announcing
a sale of furniture and curiosities. The sale was to take place on
account of the death of the owner. The owner's name was not mentioned,
but the sale was to be held at 9, Rue d'Antin, on the 16th, from 12 to
5. The placard further announced that the rooms and furniture could be
seen on the 13th and 14th.
I have always been very fond of curiosities, and I made up my mind
not to miss the occasion, if not of buying some, at all events of
seeing them. Next day I called at 9, Rue d'Antin.
It was early in the day, and yet there were already a number of
visitors, both men and women, and the women, though they were dressed
in cashmere and velvet, and had their carriages waiting for them at the
door, gazed with astonishment and admiration at the luxury which they
saw before them.
I was not long in discovering the reason of this astonishment and
admiration, for, having begun to examine things a little carefully, I
discovered without difficulty that I was in the house of a kept woman.
Now, if there is one thing which women in society would like to see
(and there were society women there), it is the home of those women
whose carriages splash their own carriages day by day, who, like them,
side by side with them, have their boxes at the Opera and at the
Italiens, and who parade in Paris the opulent insolence of their
beauty, their diamonds, and their scandal.
This one was dead, so the most virtuous of women could enter even
her bedroom. Death had purified the air of this abode of splendid
foulness, and if more excuse were needed, they had the excuse that they
had merely come to a sale, they knew not whose. They had read the
placards, they wished to see what the placards had announced, and to
make their choice beforehand. What could be more natural? Yet, all the
same, in the midst of all these beautiful things, they could not help
looking about for some traces of this courtesan's life, of which they
had heard, no doubt, strange enough stories.
Unfortunately the mystery had vanished with the goddess, and, for
all their endeavours, they discovered only what was on sale since the
owner's decease, and nothing of what had been on sale during her
lifetime. For the rest, there were plenty of things worth buying. The
furniture was superb; there were rosewood and buhl cabinets and tables,
Sevres and Chinese vases, Saxe statuettes, satin, velvet, lace; there
was nothing lacking.
I sauntered through the rooms, following the inquisitive ladies of
distinction. They entered a room with Persian hangings, and I was just
going to enter in turn, when they came out again almost immediately,
smiling, and as if ashamed of their own curiosity. I was all the more
eager to see the room. It was the dressing-room, laid out with all the
articles of toilet, in which the dead woman's extravagance seemed to be
seen at its height.
On a large table against the wall, a table three feet in width and
six in length, glittered all the treasures of Aucoc and Odiot. It was a
magnificent collection, and there was not one of those thousand little
things so necessary to the toilet of a woman of the kind which was not
in gold or silver. Such a collection could only have been got together
little by little, and the same lover had certainly not begun and ended
Not being shocked at the sight of a kept woman's dressing-room, I
amused myself with examining every detail, and I discovered that these
magnificently chiselled objects bore different initials and different
coronets. I looked at one after another, each recalling a separate
shame, and I said that God had been merciful to the poor child, in not
having left her to pay the ordinary penalty, but rather to die in the
midst of her beauty and luxury, before the coming of old age, the
courtesan's first death.
Is there anything sadder in the world than the old age of vice,
especially in woman? She preserves no dignity, she inspires no
interest. The everlasting repentance, not of the evil ways followed,
but of the plans that have miscarried, the money that has been spent in
vain, is as saddening a thing as one can well meet with. I knew an aged
woman who had once been “gay,” whose only link with the past was a
daughter almost as beautiful as she herself had been. This poor
creature to whom her mother had never said, “You are my child,” except
to bid her nourish her old age as she herself had nourished her youth,
was called Louise, and, being obedient to her mother, she abandoned
herself without volition, without passion, without pleasure, as she
would have worked at any other profession that might have been taught
The constant sight of dissipation, precocious dissipation, in
addition to her constant sickly state, had extinguished in her mind all
the knowledge of good and evil that God had perhaps given her, but that
no one had ever thought of developing. I shall always remember her, as
she passed along the boulevards almost every day at the same hour,
accompanied by her mother as assiduously as a real mother might have
accompanied her daughter. I was very young then, and ready to accept
for myself the easy morality of the age. I remember, however, the
contempt and disgust which awoke in me at the sight of this scandalous
chaperoning. Her face, too, was inexpressibly virginal in its
expression of innocence and of melancholy suffering. She was like a
figure of Resignation.
One day the girl's face was transfigured. In the midst of all the
debauches mapped out by her mother, it seemed to her as if God had left
over for her one happiness. And why indeed should God, who had made her
without strength, have left her without consolation, under the
sorrowful burden of her life? One day, then, she realized that she was
to have a child, and all that remained to her of chastity leaped for
joy. The soul has strange refuges. Louise ran to tell the good news to
her mother. It is a shameful thing to speak of, but we are not telling
tales of pleasant sins; we are telling of true facts, which it would be
better, no doubt, to pass over in silence, if we did not believe that
it is needful from time to time to reveal the martyrdom of those who
are condemned without bearing, scorned without judging; shameful it is,
but this mother answered the daughter that they had already scarce
enough for two, and would certainly not have enough for three; that
such children are useless, and a lying-in is so much time lost.
Next day a midwife, of whom all we will say is that she was a friend
of the mother, visited Louise, who remained in bed for a few days, and
then got up paler and feebler than before.
Three months afterward a man took pity on her and tried to heal her,
morally and physically; but the last shock had been too violent, and
Louise died of it. The mother still lives; how? God knows.
This story returned to my mind while I looked at the silver toilet
things, and a certain space of time must have elapsed during these
reflections, for no one was left in the room but myself and an
attendant, who, standing near the door, was carefully watching me to
see that I did not pocket anything.
I went up to the man, to whom I was causing so much anxiety. “Sir,”
I said, “can you tell me the name of the person who formerly lived
“Mademoiselle Marguerite Gautier.”
I knew her by name and by sight.
“What!” I said to the attendant; “Marguerite Gautier is dead?”
“When did she die?”
“Three weeks ago, I believe.”
“And why are the rooms on view?”
“The creditors believe that it will send up the prices. People can
see beforehand the effect of the things; you see that induces them to
“She was in debt, then?”
“To any extent, sir.”
“But the sale will cover it?”
“And more too.”
“Who will get what remains over?”
“She had a family?”
“It seems so.”
The attendant, reassured as to my intentions, touched his hat, and I
“Poor girl!” I said to myself as I returned home; “she must have had
a sad death, for, in her world, one has friends only when one is
perfectly well.” And in spite of myself I began to feel melancholy over
the fate of Marguerite Gautier.
It will seem absurd to many people, but I have an unbounded sympathy
for women of this kind, and I do not think it necessary to apologize
for such sympathy.
One day, as I was going to the Prefecture for a passport, I saw in
one of the neighbouring streets a poor girl who was being marched along
by two policemen. I do not know what was the matter. All I know is that
she was weeping bitterly as she kissed an infant only a few months old,
from whom her arrest was to separate her. Since that day I have never
dared to despise a woman at first sight.
The sale was to take place on the 16th. A day's interval had been
left between the visiting days and the sale, in order to give time for
taking down the hangings, curtains, etc. I had just returned from
abroad. It was natural that I had not heard of Marguerite's death among
the pieces of news which one's friends always tell on returning after
an absence. Marguerite was a pretty woman; but though the life of such
women makes sensation enough, their death makes very little. They are
suns which set as they rose, unobserved. Their death, when they die
young, is heard of by all their lovers at the same moment, for in Paris
almost all the lovers of a well-known woman are friends. A few
recollections are exchanged, and everybody's life goes on as if the
incident had never occurred, without so much as a tear.
Nowadays, at twenty-five, tears have become so rare a thing that
they are not to be squandered indiscriminately. It is the most that can
be expected if the parents who pay for being wept over are wept over in
return for the price they pay.
As for me, though my initials did not occur on any of Marguerite's
belongings, that instinctive indulgence, that natural pity that I have
already confessed, set me thinking over her death, more perhaps than it
was worth thinking over. I remembered having often met Marguerite in
the Bois, where she went regularly every day in a little blue coupe
drawn by two magnificent bays, and I had noticed in her a distinction
quite apart from other women of her kind, a distinction which was
enhanced by a really exceptional beauty.
These unfortunate creatures whenever they go out are always
accompanied by somebody or other. As no man cares to make himself
conspicuous by being seen in their company, and as they are afraid of
solitude, they take with them either those who are not well enough off
to have a carriage, or one or another of those elegant, ancient ladies,
whose elegance is a little inexplicable, and to whom one can always go
for information in regard to the women whom they accompany.
In Marguerite's case it was quite different. She was always alone
when she drove in the Champs-Elysees, lying back in her carriage as
much as possible, dressed in furs in winter, and in summer wearing very
simple dresses; and though she often passed people whom she knew, her
smile, when she chose to smile, was seen only by them, and a duchess
might have smiled in just such a manner. She did not drive to and fro
like the others, from the Rond-Point to the end of the Champs-Elysees.
She drove straight to the Bois. There she left her carriage, walked for
an hour, returned to her carriage, and drove rapidly home.
All these circumstances which I had so often witnessed came back to
my memory, and I regretted her death as one might regret the
destruction of a beautiful work of art.
It was impossible to see more charm in beauty than in that of
Marguerite. Excessively tall and thin, she had in the fullest degree
the art of repairing this oversight of Nature by the mere arrangement
of the things she wore. Her cashmere reached to the ground, and showed
on each side the large flounces of a silk dress, and the heavy muff
which she held pressed against her bosom was surrounded by such
cunningly arranged folds that the eye, however exacting, could find no
fault with the contour of the lines. Her head, a marvel, was the object
of the most coquettish care. It was small, and her mother, as Musset
would say, seemed to have made it so in order to make it with care.
Set, in an oval of indescribable grace, two black eyes, surmounted
by eyebrows of so pure a curve that it seemed as if painted; veil these
eyes with lovely lashes, which, when drooped, cast their shadow on the
rosy hue of the cheeks; trace a delicate, straight nose, the nostrils a
little open, in an ardent aspiration toward the life of the senses;
design a regular mouth, with lips parted graciously over teeth as white
as milk; colour the skin with the down of a peach that no hand has
touched, and you will have the general aspect of that charming
countenance. The hair, black as jet, waving naturally or not, was
parted on the forehead in two large folds and draped back over the
head, leaving in sight just the tip of the ears, in which there
glittered two diamonds, worth four to five thousand francs each. How it
was that her ardent life had left on Marguerite's face the virginal,
almost childlike expression, which characterized it, is a problem which
we can but state, without attempting to solve it.
Marguerite had a marvellous portrait of herself, by Vidal, the only
man whose pencil could do her justice. I had this portrait by me for a
few days after her death, and the likeness was so astonishing that it
has helped to refresh my memory in regard to some points which I might
not otherwise have remembered.
Some among the details of this chapter did not reach me until later,
but I write them here so as not to be obliged to return to them when
the story itself has begun.
Marguerite was always present at every first night, and passed every
evening either at the theatre or the ball. Whenever there was a new
piece she was certain to be seen, and she invariably had three things
with her on the ledge of her ground-floor box: her opera-glass, a bag
of sweets, and a bouquet of camellias.
For twenty-five days of the month the camellias were white, and for
five they were red; no one ever knew the reason of this change of
colour, which I mention though I can not explain it; it was noticed
both by her friends and by the habitue's of the theatres to which she
most often went. She was never seen with any flowers but camellias. At
the florist's, Madame Barjon's, she had come to be called “the Lady of
the Camellias,” and the name stuck to her.
Like all those who move in a certain set in Paris, I knew that
Marguerite had lived with some of the most fashionable young men in
society, that she spoke of it openly, and that they themselves boasted
of it; so that all seemed equally pleased with one another.
Nevertheless, for about three years, after a visit to Bagnees, she was
said to be living with an old duke, a foreigner, enormously rich, who
had tried to remove her as far as possible from her former life, and,
as it seemed, entirely to her own satisfaction.
This is what I was told on the subject. In the spring of 1847
Marguerite was so ill that the doctors ordered her to take the waters,
and she went to Bagneres. Among the invalids was the daughter of this
duke; she was not only suffering from the same complaint, but she was
so like Marguerite in appearance that they might have been taken for
sisters; the young duchess was in the last stage of consumption, and a
few days after Marguerite's arrival she died. One morning, the duke,
who had remained at Bagneres to be near the soil that had buried a part
of his heart, caught sight of Marguerite at a turn of the road. He
seemed to see the shadow of his child, and going up to her, he took her
hands, embraced and wept over her, and without even asking her who she
was, begged her to let him love in her the living image of his dead
child. Marguerite, alone at Bagneres with her maid, and not being in
any fear of compromising herself, granted the duke's request. Some
people who knew her, happening to be at Bagneres, took upon themselves
to explain Mademoiselle Gautier's true position to the duke. It was a
blow to the old man, for the resemblance with his daughter was ended in
one direction, but it was too late. She had become a necessity to his
heart, his only pretext, his only excuse, for living. He made no
reproaches, he had indeed no right to do so, but he asked her if she
felt herself capable of changing her mode of life, offering her in
return for the sacrifice every compensation that she could desire. She
It must be said that Marguerite was just then very ill. The past
seemed to her sensitive nature as if it were one of the main causes of
her illness, and a sort of superstition led her to hope that God would
restore to her both health and beauty in return for her repentance and
conversion. By the end of the summer, the waters, sleep, the natural
fatigue of long walks, had indeed more or less restored her health. The
duke accompanied her to Paris, where he continued to see her as he had
done at Bagneres.
This liaison, whose motive and origin were quite unknown, caused a
great sensation, for the duke, already known for his immense fortune,
now became known for his prodigality. All this was set down to the
debauchery of a rich old man, and everything was believed except the
truth. The father's sentiment for Marguerite had, in truth, so pure a
cause that anything but a communion of hearts would have seemed to him
a kind of incest, and he had never spoken to her a word which his
daughter might not have heard.
Far be it from me to make out our heroine to be anything but what
she was. As long as she remained at Bagneres, the promise she had made
to the duke had not been hard to keep, and she had kept it; but, once
back in Paris, it seemed to her, accustomed to a life of dissipation,
of balls, of orgies, as if the solitude, only interrupted by the duke's
stated visits, would kill her with boredom, and the hot breath of her
old life came back across her head and heart.
We must add that Marguerite had returned more beautiful than she had
ever been; she was but twenty, and her malady, sleeping but not
subdued, continued to give her those feverish desires which are almost
always the result of diseases of the chest.
It was a great grief to the duke when his friends, always on the
lookout for some scandal on the part of the woman with whom, it seemed
to them, he was compromising himself, came to tell him, indeed to prove
to him, that at times when she was sure of not seeing him she received
other visits, and that these visits were often prolonged till the
following day. On being questioned, Marguerite admitted everything to
the duke, and advised him, without arriere-pensee, to concern himself
with her no longer, for she felt incapable of carrying out what she had
undertaken, and she did not wish to go on accepting benefits from a man
whom she was deceiving. The duke did not return for a week; it was all
he could do, and on the eighth day he came to beg Marguerite to let him
still visit her, promising that he would take her as she was, so long
as he might see her, and swearing that he would never utter a reproach
against her, not though he were to die of it.
This, then, was the state of things three months after Marguerite's
return; that is to say, in November or December, 1842.
At one o'clock on the 16th I went to the Rue d'Antin. The voice of
the auctioneer could be heard from the outer door. The rooms were
crowded with people. There were all the celebrities of the most elegant
impropriety, furtively examined by certain great ladies who had again
seized the opportunity of the sale in order to be able to see, close at
hand, women whom they might never have another occasion of meeting, and
whom they envied perhaps in secret for their easy pleasures. The
Duchess of F. elbowed Mlle. A., one of the most melancholy examples of
our modern courtesan; the Marquis de T. hesitated over a piece of
furniture the price of which was being run high by Mme. D., the most
elegant and famous adulteress of our time; the Duke of Y., who in
Madrid is supposed to be ruining himself in Paris, and in Paris to be
ruining himself in Madrid, and who, as a matter of fact, never even
reaches the limit of his income, talked with Mme. M., one of our
wittiest story-tellers, who from time to time writes what she says and
signs what she writes, while at the same time he exchanged confidential
glances with Mme. de N., a fair ornament of the Champs-Elysees, almost
always dressed in pink or blue, and driving two big black horses which
Tony had sold her for 10,000 francs, and for which she had paid, after
her fashion; finally, Mlle. R., who makes by her mere talent twice what
the women of the world make by their dot and three times as much as the
others make by their amours, had come, in spite of the cold, to make
some purchases, and was not the least looked at among the crowd.
We might cite the initials of many more of those who found
themselves, not without some mutual surprise, side by side in one room.
But we fear to weary the reader. We will only add that everyone was in
the highest spirits, and that many of those present had known the dead
woman, and seemed quite oblivious of the fact. There was a sound of
loud laughter; the auctioneers shouted at the top of their voices; the
dealers who had filled the benches in front of the auction table tried
in vain to obtain silence, in order to transact their business in
peace. Never was there a noisier or a more varied gathering.
I slipped quietly into the midst of this tumult, sad to think of
when one remembered that the poor creature whose goods were being sold
to pay her debts had died in the next room. Having come rather to
examine than to buy, I watched the faces of the auctioneers, noticing
how they beamed with delight whenever anything reached a price beyond
their expectations. Honest creatures, who had speculated upon this
woman's prostitution, who had gained their hundred per cent out of her,
who had plagued with their writs the last moments of her life, and who
came now after her death to gather in at once the fruits of their
dishonourable calculations and the interest on their shameful credit,
How wise were the ancients in having only one God for traders and
Dresses, cashmeres, jewels, were sold with incredible rapidity.
There was nothing that I cared for, and I still waited. All at once I
heard: “A volume, beautifully bound, gilt-edged, entitled Manon
Lescaut. There is something written on the first page. Ten francs.”
“Twelve,” said a voice after a longish silence.
“Fifteen,” I said.
Why? I did not know. Doubtless for the something written.
“Fifteen,” repeated the auctioneer.
“Thirty,” said the first bidder in a tone which seemed to defy
It had now become a struggle. “Thirty-five,” I cried in the same
If I had wished to make a sensation I should certainly have
succeeded, for a profound silence had ensued, and people gazed at me as
if to see what sort of a person it was, who seemed to be so determined
to possess the volume.
The accent which I had given to my last word seemed to convince my
adversary; he preferred to abandon a conflict which could only have
resulted in making me pay ten times its price for the volume, and,
bowing, he said very gracefully, though indeed a little late:
“I give way, sir.”
Nothing more being offered, the book was assigned to me.
As I was afraid of some new fit of obstinacy, which my amour propre
might have sustained somewhat better than my purse, I wrote down my
name, had the book put on one side, and went out. I must have given
considerable food for reflection to the witnesses of this scene, who
would nodoubt ask themselves what my purpose could have been in paying
a hundred francs for a book which I could have had anywhere for ten,
or, at the outside, fifteen.
An hour after, I sent for my purchase. On the first page was written
in ink, in an elegant hand, an inscription on the part of the giver. It
consisted of these words:
Manon to Marguerite.
It was signed Armand Duval.
What was the meaning of the word Humility? Was Manon to recognise in
Marguerite, in the opinion of M. Armand Duval, her superior in vice or
in affection? The second interpretation seemed the more probable, for
the first would have been an impertinent piece of plain speaking which
Marguerite, whatever her opinion of herself, would never have accepted.
I went out again, and thought no more of the book until at night,
when I was going to bed.
Manon Lescaut is a touching story. I know every detail of it, and
yet whenever I come across the volume the same sympathy always draws me
to it; I open it, and for the hundredth time I live over again with the
heroine of the Abbe Prevost. Now this heroine is so true to life that I
feel as if I had known her; and thus the sort of comparison between her
and Marguerite gave me an unusual inclination to read it, and my
indulgence passed into pity, almost into a kind of love for the poor
girl to whom I owed the volume. Manon died in the desert, it is true,
but in the arms of the man who loved her with the whole energy of his
soul; who, when she was dead, dug a grave for her, and watered it with
his tears, and buried his heart in it; while Marguerite, a sinner like
Manon, and perhaps converted like her, had died in a sumptuous bed (it
seemed, after what I had seen, the bed of her past), but in that desert
of the heart, a more barren, a vaster, a more pitiless desert than that
in which Manon had found her last resting-place.
Marguerite, in fact, as I had found from some friends who knew of
the last circumstances of her life, had not a single real friend by her
bedside during the two months of her long and painful agony.
Then from Manon and Marguerite my mind wandered to those whom I
knew, and whom I saw singing along the way which led to just such
another death. Poor souls! if it is not right to love them, is it not
well to pity them? You pity the blind man who has never seen the
daylight, the deaf who has never heard the harmonies of nature, the
dumb who has never found a voice for his soul, and, under a false cloak
of shame, you will not pity this blindness of heart, this deafness of
soul, this dumbness of conscience, which sets the poor afflicted
creature beside herself and makes her, in spite of herself, incapable
of seeing what is good, of bearing the Lord, and of speaking the pure
language of love and faith.
Hugo has written Marion Delorme, Musset has written Bernerette,
Alexandre Dumas has written Fernande, the thinkers and poets of all
time have brought to the courtesan the offering of their pity, and at
times a great man has rehabilitated them with his love and even with
his name. If I insist on this point, it is because many among those who
have begun to read me will be ready to throw down a book in which they
will fear to find an apology for vice and prostitution; and the
author's age will do something, no doubt, to increase this fear. Let me
undeceive those who think thus, and let them go on reading, if nothing
but such a fear hinders them.
I am quite simply convinced of a certain principle, which is: For
the woman whose education has not taught her what is right, God almost
always opens two ways which lead thither the ways of sorrow and of
love. They are hard; those who walk in them walk with bleeding feet and
torn hands, but they also leave the trappings of vice upon the thorns
of the wayside, and reach the journey's end in a nakedness which is not
shameful in the sight of the Lord.
Those who meet these bold travellers ought to succour them, and to
tell all that they have met them, for in so doing they point out the
way. It is not a question of setting at the outset of life two
sign-posts, one bearing the inscription “The Right Way,” the other the
inscription “The Wrong Way,” and of saying to those who come there,
“Choose.” One must needs, like Christ, point out the ways which lead
from the second road to the first, to those who have been easily led
astray; and it is needful that the beginning of these ways should not
be too painful nor appear too impenetrable.
Here is Christianity with its marvellous parable of the Prodigal Son
to teach us indulgence and pardon. Jesus was full of love for souls
wounded by the passions of men; he loved to bind up their wounds and to
find in those very wounds the balm which should heal them. Thus he said
to the Magdalen: “Much shall be forgiven thee because thou hast loved
much,” a sublimity of pardon which can only have called forth a sublime
Why do we make ourselves more strict than Christ? Why, holding
obstinately to the opinions of the world, which hardens itself in order
that it may be thought strong, do we reject, as it rejects, souls
bleeding at wounds by which, like a sick man's bad blood, the evil of
their past may be healed, if only a friendly hand is stretched out to
lave them and set them in the convalescence of the heart?
It is to my own generation that I speak, to those for whom the
theories of M. de Voltaire happily exist no longer, to those who, like
myself, realize that humanity, for these last fifteen years, has been
in one of its most audacious moments of expansion. The science of good
and evil is acquired forever; faith is refashioned, respect for sacred
things has returned to us, and if the world has not all at once become
good, it has at least become better. The efforts of every intelligent
man tend in the same direction, and every strong will is harnessed to
the same principle: Be good, be young, be true! Evil is nothing but
vanity, let us have the pride of good, and above all let us never
despair. Do not let us despise the woman who is neither mother, sister,
maid, nor wife. Do not let us limit esteem to the family nor indulgence
to egoism. Since “there is more joy in heaven over one sinner that
repenteth than over ninety and nine just persons that need no
repentance,” let us give joy to heaven. Heaven will render it back to
us with usury. Let us leave on our way the alms of pardon for those
whom earthly desires have driven astray, whom a divine hope shall
perhaps save, and, as old women say when they offer you. some homely
remedy of their own, if it does no good it will do no harm.
Doubtless it must seem a bold thing to attempt to deduce these grand
results out of the meagre subject that I deal with; but I am one of
those who believe that all is in little. The child is small, and he
includes the man; the brain is narrow, and it harbours thought; the eye
is but a point, and it covers leagues.
Two days after, the sale was ended. It had produced 3.50,000 francs.
The creditors divided among them two thirds, and the family, a sister
and a grand-nephew, received the remainder.
The sister opened her eyes very wide when the lawyer wrote to her
that she had inherited 50,000 francs. The girl had not seen her sister
for six or seven years, and did not know what had become of her from
the moment when she had disappeared from home. She came up to Paris in
haste, and great was the astonishment of those who had known Marguerite
when they saw as her only heir a fine, fat country girl, who until then
had never left her village. She had made the fortune at a single
stroke, without even knowing the source of that fortune. She went back,
I heard afterward, to her countryside, greatly saddened by her sister's
death, but with a sadness which was somewhat lightened by the
investment at four and a half per cent which she had been able to make.
All these circumstances, often repeated in Paris, the mother city of
scandal, had begun to be forgotten, and I was even little by little
forgetting the part I had taken in them, when a new incident brought to
my knowledge the whole of Marguerite's life, and acquainted me with
such pathetic details that I was taken with the idea of writing down
the story which I now write.
The rooms, now emptied of all their furniture, had been to let for
three or four days when one morning there was a ring at my door.
My servant, or, rather, my porter, who acted as my servant, went to
the door and brought me a card, saying that the person who had given it
to him wished to see me.
I glanced at the card and there read these two words: Armand Duval.
I tried to think where I had seen the name, and remembered the first
leaf of the copy of Manon Lescaut. What could the person who had given
the book to Marguerite want of me? I gave orders to ask him in at once.
I saw a young man, blond, tall, pale, dressed in a travelling suit
which looked as if he had not changed it for some days, and had not
even taken the trouble to brush it on arriving at Paris, for it was
covered with dust.
M. Duval was deeply agitated; he made no attempt to conceal his
agitation, and it was with tears in his eyes and a trembling voice that
he said to me:
“Sir, I beg you to excuse my visit and my costume; but young people
are not very ceremonious with one another, and I was so anxious to see
you to-day that I have not even gone to the hotel to which I have sent
my luggage, and have rushed straight here, fearing that, after all, I
might miss you, early as it is.”
I begged M. Duval to sit down by the fire; he did so, and, taking
his handkerchief from his pocket, hid his face in it for a moment.
“You must be at a loss to understand,” he went on, sighing sadly,
“for what purpose an unknown visitor, at such an hour, in such a
costume, and in tears, can have come to see you. I have simply come to
ask of you a great service.”
“Speak on, sir, I am entirely at your disposal.”
“You were present at the sale of Marguerite Gautier?”
At this word the emotion, which he had got the better of for an
instant, was too much for him, and he was obliged to cover his eyes
with his hand.
“I must seem to you very absurd,” he added, “but pardon me, and
believe that I shall never forget the patience with which you have
listened to me.”
“Sir,” I answered, “if the service which I can render you is able to
lessen your trouble a little, tell me at once what I can do for you,
and you will find me only too happy to oblige you.”
M. Duval's sorrow was sympathetic, arid in spite of myself I felt
the desire of doing him a kindness. Thereupon he said to me:
“You bought something at Marguerite's sale?”
“Yes, a book.”
“Have you the book still?”
“It is in my bedroom.”
On hearing this, Armand Duval seemed to be relieved of a great
weight, and thanked me as if I had already rendered him a service
merely by keeping the book.
I got up and went into my room to fetch the book, which I handed to
“That is it indeed,” he said, looking at the inscription on the
first page and turning over the leaves; “that is it in deed,” and two
big tears fell on the pages. “Well, sir,” said he, lifting his head,
and no longer trying to hide from me that he had wept and was even then
on the point of weeping, “do you value this book very greatly?”
“Because I have come to ask you to give it up to me.”
“Pardon my curiosity, but was it you, then, who gave it to
“The book is yours, sir; take it back. I am happy to be able to hand
it over to you.”
“But,” said M. Duval with some embarrassment, “the least I can do is
to give you in return the price which you paid for it.”
“Allow me to offer it to you. The price of a single volume in a sale
of that kind is a mere nothing, and I do not remember how much I gave
“You gave one hundred francs.”
“True,” I said, embarrassed in my turn, “how do you know?”
“It is quite simple. I hoped to reach Paris in time for the sale,
and I only managed to get here this morning. I was absolutely resolved
to have something which had belonged to her, and I hastened to the
auctioneer and asked him to allow me to see the list of the things sold
and of the buyers' names. I saw that this volume had been bought by
you, and I decided to ask you to give it up to me, though the price you
had set upon it made me fear that you might yourself have some souvenir
in connection with the possession of the book.”
As he spoke, it was evident that he was afraid I had known
Marguerite as he had known her. I hastened to reassure him.
“I knew Mlle. Gautier only by sight,” I said; “her death made on me
the impression that the death of a pretty woman must always make on a
young man who had liked seeing her. I wished to buy something at her
sale, and I bid higher and higher for this book out of mere obstinacy
and to annoy some one else, who was equally keen to obtain it, and who
seemed to defy me to the contest. I repeat, then, that the book is
yours, and once more I beg you to accept it; do not treat me as if I
were an auctioneer, and let it be the pledge between us of a longer and
more intimate acquaintance.”
“Good,” said Armand, holding out his hand and pressing mine; “I
accept, and I shall be grateful to you all my life.”
I was very anxious to question Armand on the subject of Marguerite,
for the inscription in the book, the young man's hurried journey, his
desire to possess the volume, piqued my curiosity; but I feared if I
questioned my visitor that I might seem to have refused his money only
in order to have the right to pry into his affairs.
It was as if he guessed my desire, for he said to me:
“Have you read the volume?”
“What did you think of the two lines that I wrote in it?”
“I realized at once that the woman to whom you had given the volume
must have been quite outside the ordinary category, for I could not
take those two lines as a mere empty compliment.”
“You were right. That woman was an angel. See, read this letter.”
And he handed to me a paper which seemed to have been many times
I opened it, and this is what it contained:
“MY DEAR ARMAND:—I have received your letter. You are still good,
and I thank God for it. Yes, my friend, I am ill, and with one of those
diseases that never relent; but the interest you still take in me makes
my suffering less. I shall not live long enough, I expect, to have the
happiness of pressing the hand which has written the kind letter I have
just received; the words of it would be enough to cure me, if anything
could cure me. I shall not see you, for I am quite near death, and you
are hundreds of leagues away. My poor friend! your Marguerite of old
times is sadly changed. It is better perhaps for you not to see her
again than to see her as she is. You ask if I forgive you; oh, with all
my heart, friend, for the way you hurt me was only a way of proving the
love you had for me. I have been in bed for a month, and I think so
much of your esteem that I write every day the journal of my life, from
the moment we left each other to the moment when I shall be able to
write no longer. If the interest you take in me is real, Armand, when
you come back go and see Julie Duprat. She will give you my journal.
You will find in it the reason and the excuse for what has passed
between us. Julie is very good to me; we often talk of you together.
She was there when your letter came, and we both cried over it.
“If you had not sent me any word, I had told her to give you those
papers when you returned to France. Do not thank me for it. This daily
looking back on the only happy moments of my life does me an immense
amount of good, and if you will find in reading it some excuse for the
past. I, for my part, find a continual solace in it. I should like to
leave you something which would always remind you of me, but everything
here has been seized, and I have nothing of my own.
“Do you understand, my friend? I am dying, and from my bed I can
hear a man walking to and fro in the drawing-room; my creditors have
put him there to see that nothing is taken away, and that nothing
remains to me in case I do not die. I hope they will wait till the end
before they begin to sell.
“Oh, men have no pity! or rather, I am wrong, it is God who is just
“And now, dear love, you will come to my sale, and you will buy
something, for if I put aside the least thing for you, they might
accuse you of embezzling seized goods.
“It is a sad life that I am leaving!
“It would be good of God to let me see you again before I die.
According to all probability, good-bye, my friend. Pardon me if I do
not write a longer letter, but those who say they are going to cure me
wear me out with bloodletting, and my hand refuses to write any more.
The last two words were scarcely legible. I returned the letter to
Armand, who had, no doubt, read it over again in his mind while I was
reading it on paper, for he said to me as he took it:
“Who would think that a kept woman could have written that?” And,
overcome by recollections, he gazed for some time at the writing of the
letter, which he finally carried to his lips.
“And when I think,” he went on, “that she died before I could see
her, and that I shall never see her again, when I think that she did
for me what no sister would ever have done, I can not forgive myself
for having left her to die like that. Dead! Dead and thinking of me,
writing and repeating my name, poor dear Marguerite!”
And Armand, giving free outlet to his thoughts and his tears, held
out his hand to me, and continued:
“People would think it childish enough if they saw me lament like
this over a dead woman such as she; no one will ever know what I made
that woman suffer, how cruel I have been to her! how good, how resigned
she was! I thought it was I who had to forgive her, and to-day I feel
unworthy of the forgiveness which she grants me. Oh, I would give ten
years of my life to weep at her feet for an hour!”
It is always difficult to console a sorrow that is unknown to one,
and nevertheless I felt so lively a sympathy for the young man, he made
me so frankly the confidant of his distress, that I believed a word
from me would not be indifferent to him, and I said:
“Have you no parents, no friends? Hope. Go and see them; they will
console you. As for me, I can only pity you.”
“It is true,” he said, rising and walking to and fro in the room, “I
am wearying you. Pardon me, I did not reflect how little my sorrow must
mean to you, and that I am intruding upon you something which can not
and ought not to interest you at all.”
“You mistake my meaning. I am entirely at your service; only I
regret my inability to calm your distress. If my society and that of my
friends can give you any distraction, if, in short, you have need of
me, no matter in what way, I hope you will realize how much pleasure it
will give me to do anything for you.”
“Pardon, pardon,” said he; “sorrow sharpens the sensations. Let me
stay here for a few minutes longer, long enough to dry my eyes, so that
the idlers in the street may not look upon it as a curiosity to see a
big fellow like me crying. You have made me very happy by giving me
this book. I do not know how I can ever express my gratitude to you.”
“By giving me a little of your friendship,” said I, “and by telling
me the cause of your suffering. One feels better while telling what one
“You are right. But to-day I have too much need of tears; I can not
very well talk. One day I will tell you the whole story, and you will
see if I have reason for regretting the poor girl. And now,” he added,
rubbing his eyes for the last time, and looking at himself in the
glass, “say that you do not think me too absolutely idiotic, and allow
me to come back and see you another time.”
He cast on me a gentle and amiable look. I was near embracing him.
As for him, his eyes again began to fill with tears; he saw that I
perceived it and turned away his head.
“Come,” I said, “courage.”
“Good-bye,” he said.
And, making a desperate effort to restrain his tears, he rushed
rather than went out of the room.
I lifted the curtain of my window, and saw him get into the
cabriolet which awaited him at the door; but scarcely was he seated
before he burst into tears and hid his face in his pocket-handkerchief.
A good while elapsed before I heard anything more of Armand, but, on
the other hand, I was constantly hearing of Marguerite.
I do not know if you have noticed, if once the name of anybody who
might in the natural course of things have always remained unknown, or
at all events indifferent to you, should he mentioned before you,
immediately details begin to group themselves about the name, and you
find all your friends talking to you about something which they have
never mentioned to you before. You discover that this person was almost
touching you and has passed close to you many times in your life
without your noticing it; you find coincidences in the events which are
told you, a real affinity with certain events of your own existence. I
was not absolutely at that point in regard to Marguerite, for I had
seen and met her, I knew her by sight and by reputation; nevertheless,
since the moment of the sale, her name came to my ears so frequently,
and, owing to the circumstance that I have mentioned in the last
chapter, that name was associated with so profound a sorrow, that my
curiosity increased in proportion with my astonishment. The consequence
was that whenever I met friends to whom I had never breathed the name
of Marguerite, I always began by saying:
“Did you ever know a certain Marguerite Gautier?”
“The Lady of the Camellias?”
“Oh, very well!”
The word was sometimes accompanied by a smile which could leave no
doubt as to its meaning.
“Well, what sort of a girl was she?”
“A good sort of girl.”
“Is that all?”
“Oh, yes; more intelligence and perhaps a little more heart than
“Do you know anything particular about her?”
“She ruined Baron de G.”
“No more than that?”
“She was the mistress of the old Duke of . . .”
“Was she really his mistress?”
“So they say; at all events, he gave her a great deal of money.”
The general outlines were always the same. Nevertheless I was
anxious to find out something about the relations between Marguerite
and Armand. Meeting one day a man who was constantly about with known
women, I asked him: “Did you know Marguerite Gautier?”
The answer was the usual: “Very well.”
“What sort of a girl was she?”
“A fine, good girl. I was very sorry to hear of her death.”
“Had she not a lover called Armand Duval?”
“Tall and blond?”
“It is quite true.”
“Who was this Armand?”
“A fellow who squandered on her the little money he had, and then
had to leave her. They say he was quite wild about it.”
“They always say she was very much in love with him, but as girls
like that are in love. It is no good to ask them for what they can not
“What has become of Armand?”
“I don't know. We knew him very little. He was with Marguerite for
five or six months in the country. When she came back, he had gone.”
“And you have never seen him since?”
I, too, had not seen Armand again. I was beginning to ask myself if,
when he had come to see me, the recent news of Marguerite's death had
not exaggerated his former love, and consequently his sorrow, and I
said to myself that perhaps he had already forgotten the dead woman,
and along with her his promise to come and see me again. This
supposition would have seemed probable enough in most instances, but in
Armand's despair there had been an accent of real sincerity, and, going
from one extreme to another, I imagined that distress had brought on an
illness, and that my not seeing him was explained by the fact that he
was ill, perhaps dead.
I was interested in the young man in spite of myself. Perhaps there
was some selfishness in this interest; perhaps I guessed at some
pathetic love story under all this sorrow; perhaps my desire to know
all about it had much to do with the anxiety which Armand's silence
caused me. Since M. Duval did not return to see me, I decided to go and
see him. A pretext was not difficult to find; unluckily I did not know
his address, and no one among those whom I questioned could give it to
I went to the Rue d'Antin; perhaps Marguerite's porter would know
where Armand lived. There was a new porter; he knew as little about it
as I. I then asked in what cemetery Mlle. Gautier had been buried. It
was the Montmartre Cemetery. It was now the month of April; the weather
was fine, the graves were not likely to look as sad and desolate as
they do in winter; in short, it was warm enough for the living to think
a little of the dead, and pay them a visit. I went to the cemetery,
saying to myself: “One glance at Marguerite's grave, and I shall know
if Armand's sorrow still exists, and perhaps I may find out what has
become of him.”
I entered the keeper's lodge, and asked him if on the 22nd of
February a woman named Marguerite Gautier had not been buried in the
Montmartre Cemetery. He turned over the pages of a big book in which
those who enter this last resting-place are inscribed and numbered, and
replied that on the 22nd of February, at 12 o'clock, a woman of that
name had been buried.
I asked him to show me the grave, for there is no finding one's way
without a guide in this city of the dead, which has its streets like a
city of the living. The keeper called over a gardener, to whom he gave
the necessary instructions; the gardener interrupted him, saying: “I
know, I know.—It is not difficult to find that grave,” he added,
turning to me.
“Because it has very different flowers from the others.”
“Is it you who look after it?”
“Yes, sir; and I wish all relations took as much trouble about the
dead as the young man who gave me my orders.”
After several turnings, the gardener stopped and said to me: “Here
I saw before me a square of flowers which one would never have taken
for a grave, if it had not been for a white marble slab bearing a name.
The marble slab stood upright, an iron railing marked the limits of
the ground purchased, and the earth was covered with white camellias.
“What do you say to that?” said the gardener.
“It is beautiful.”
“And whenever a camellia fades, I have orders to replace it.”
“Who gave you the order?”
“A young gentleman, who cried the first time he came here; an old
pal of hers, I suppose, for they say she was a gay one. Very pretty,
too, I believe. Did you know her, sir?” “Yes.”
“Like the other?” said the gardener, with a knowing smile. “No, I
never spoke to her.”
“And you come here, too! It is very good of you, for those that come
to see the poor girl don't exactly cumber the cemetery.”
“Doesn't anybody come?”
“Nobody, except that young gentleman who came once.”
“He never came back again?”
“No, but he will when he gets home.”
“He is away somewhere?”
“Do you know where he is?”
“I believe he has gone to see Mlle. Gautier's sister.”
“What does he want there?”
“He has gone to get her authority to have the corpse dug up again
and put somewhere else.”
“Why won't he let it remain here?”
“You know, sir, people have queer notions about dead folk. We see
something of that every day. The ground here was only bought for five
years, and this young gentleman wants a perpetual lease and a bigger
plot of ground; it will be better in the new part.”
“What do you call the new part?”
“The new plots of ground that are for sale, there to the left. If
the cemetery had always been kept like it is now, there wouldn't be the
like of it in the world; but there is still plenty to do before it will
be quite all it should be. And then people are so queer!”
“What do you mean?”
“I mean that there are people who carry their pride even here. Now,
this Demoiselle Gautier, it appears she lived a bit free, if you'll
excuse my saying so. Poor lady, she's dead now; there's no more of her
left than of them that no one has a word to say against. We water them
every day. Well, when the relatives of the folk that are buried beside
her found out the sort of person she was, what do you think they said?
That they would try to keep her out from here, and that there ought to
be a piece of ground somewhere apart for these sort of women, like
there is for the poor. Did you ever hear of such a thing? I gave it to
them straight, I did: well-to-do folk who come to see their dead four
times a year, and bring their flowers themselves, and what flowers! and
look twice at the keep of them they pretend to cry over, and write on
their tombstones all about the tears they haven't shed, and come and
make difficulties about their neighbours. You may believe me or not,
sir, I never knew the young lady; I don't know what she did. Well, I'm
quite in love with the poor thing; I look after her well, and I let her
have her camellias at an honest price. She is the dead body that I like
the best. You see, sir, we are obliged to love the dead, for we are
kept so busy, we have hardly time to love anything else.”
I looked at the man, and some of my readers will understand, without
my needing to explain it to them, the emotion which I felt on hearing
him. He observed it, no doubt, for he went on:
“They tell me there were people who ruined themselves over that
girl, and lovers that worshipped her; well, when I think there isn't
one of them that so much as buys her a flower now, that's queer, sir,
and sad. And, after all, she isn't so badly off, for she has her grave
to herself, and if there is only one who remembers her, he makes up for
the others. But we have other poor girls here, just like her and just
her age, and they are just thrown into a pauper's grave, and it breaks
my heart when I hear their poor bodies drop into the earth. And not a
soul thinks about them any more, once they are dead! 'Tisn't a merry
trade, ours, especially when we have a little heart left. What do you
expect? I can't help it. I have a fine, strapping girl myself; she's
just twenty, and when a girl of that age comes here I think of her, and
I don't care if it's a great lady or a vagabond, I can't help feeling
it a bit. But I am taking up your time, sir, with my tales, and it
wasn't to hear them you came here. I was told to show you Mlle.
Gautier's grave; here you have it. Is there anything else I can do for
“Do you know M. Armand Duval's address?” I asked.
“Yes; he lives at Rue de —; at least, that's where I always go to
get my money for the flowers you see there.”
“Thanks, my good man.”
I gave one more look at the grave covered with flowers, half longing
to penetrate the depths of the earth and see what the earth had made of
the fair creature that had been cast to it; then I walked sadly away.
“Do you want to see M. Duval, sir?” said the gardener, who was
walking beside me.
“Well, I am pretty sure he is not back yet, or he would have been
“You don't think he has forgotten Marguerite?”
“I am not only sure he hasn't, but I would wager that he wants to
change her grave simply in order to have one more look at her.”
“Why do you think that?”
“The first word he said to me when he came to the cemetery was: 'How
can I see her again?' That can't be done unless there is a change of
grave, and I told him all about the formalities that have to be
attended to in getting it done; for, you see, if you want to move a
body from one grave to another you must have it identified, and only
the family can give leave for it under the direction of a police
inspector. That is why M. Duval has gone to see Mlle. Gautier's sister,
and you may be sure his first visit will be for me.”
We had come to the cemetery gate. I thanked the gardener again,
putting a few coins into his hand, and made my way to the address he
had given me.
Armand had not yet returned. I left word for him, begging him to
come and see me as soon as he arrived, or to send me word where I could
Next day, in the morning, I received a letter from Duval, telling me
of his return, and asking me to call on him, as he was so worn out with
fatigue that it was impossible for him to go out.
I found Armand in bed. On seeing me he held out a burning hand. “You
are feverish,” I said to him. “It is nothing, the fatigue of a rapid
journey; that is all.” “You have been to see Marguerite's sister?”
“Yes; who told you?” “I knew it. Did you get what you wanted?”
“Yes; but who told you of my journey, and of my reason for taking
“The gardener of the cemetery.”
“You have seen the tomb?”
I scarcely dared reply, for the tone in which the words were spoken
proved to me that the speaker was still possessed by the emotion which
I had witnessed before, and that every time his thoughts or speech
travelled back to that mournful subject emotion would still, for a long
time to come, prove stronger than his will. I contented myself with a
nod of the head.
“He has looked after it well?” continued Armand. Two big tears
rolled down the cheeks of the sick man, and he turned away his head to
hide them from me. I pretended not to see them, and tried to change the
conversation. “You have been away three weeks,” I said.
Armand passed his hand across his eyes and replied, “Exactly three
“You had a long journey.”
“Oh, I was not travelling all the time. I was ill for a fortnight or
I should have returned long ago; but I had scarcely got there when I
took this fever, and I was obliged to keep my room.”
“And you started to come back before you were really well?”
“If I had remained in the place for another week, I should have died
“Well, now you are back again, you must take care of yourself; your
friends will come and look after you; myself, first of all, if you will
“I shall get up in a couple of hours.”
“It would be very unwise.”
“What have you to do in such a great hurry?”
“I must go to the inspector of police.”
“Why do you not get one of your friends to see after the matter? It
is likely to make you worse than you are now.”
“It is my only chance of getting better. I must see her. Ever since
I heard of her death, especially since I saw her grave, I have not been
able to sleep. I can not realize that this woman, so young and so
beautiful when I left her, is really dead. I must convince myself of
it. I must see what God has done with a being that I have loved so
much, and perhaps the horror of the sight will cure me of my despair.
Will you accompany me, if it won't be troubling you too much?”
“What did her sister say about it?”
“Nothing. She seemed greatly surprised that a stranger wanted to buy
a plot of ground and give Marguerite a new grave, and she immediately
signed the authorization that I asked her for.”
“Believe me, it would be better to wait until you are quite well.”
“Have no fear; I shall be quite composed. Besides, I should simply
go out of my mind if I were not to carry out a resolution which I have
set myself to carry out. I swear to you that I shall never be myself
again until I have seen Marguerite. It is perhaps the thirst of the
fever, a sleepless night's dream, a moment's delirium; but though I
were to become a Trappist, like M. de Rance', after having seen, I will
“I understand,” I said to Armand, “and I am at your service. Have
you seen Julie Duprat?”
“Yes, I saw her the day I returned, for the first time.”
“Did she give you the papers that Marguerite had left for you?”
Armand drew a roll of papers from under his pillow, and immediately
put them back.
“I know all that is in these papers by heart,” he said. “For three
weeks I have read them ten times over every day. You shall read them,
too, but later on, when I am calmer, and can make you understand all
the love and tenderness hidden away in this confession. For the moment
I want you to do me a service.”
“What is it?”
“Your cab is below?”
“Well, will you take my passport and ask if there are any letters
for me at the poste restante? My father and sister must have written to
me at Paris, and I went away in such haste that I did not go and see
before leaving. When you come back we will go together to the inspector
of police, and arrange for to-morrow's ceremony.”
Armand handed me his passport, and I went to Rue Jean Jacques
Rousseau. There were two letters addressed to Duval. I took them and
returned. When I re-entered the room Armand was dressed and ready to go
“Thanks,” he said, taking the letters. “Yes,” he added, after
glancing at the addresses, “they are from my father and sister. They
must have been quite at a loss to understand my silence.”
He opened the letters, guessed at rather than read them, for each
was of four pages; and a moment after folded them up. “Come,” he said,
“I will answer tomorrow.”
We went to the police station, and Armand handed in the permission
signed by Marguerite's sister. He received in return a letter to the
keeper of the cemetery, and it was settled that the disinterment was to
take place next day, at ten o'clock, that I should call for him an hour
before, and that we should go to the cemetery together.
I confess that I was curious to be present, and I did not sleep all
night. judging from the thoughts which filled my brain, it must have
been a long night for Armand. When I entered his room at nine on the
following morning he was frightfully pale, but seemed calm. He smiled
and held out his hand. His candles were burned out; and before leaving
he took a very heavy letter addressed to his father, and no doubt
containing an account of that night's impressions.
Half an hour later we were at Montmartre. The police inspector was
there already. We walked slowly in the direction of Marguerite's grave.
The inspector went in front; Armand and I followed a few steps behind.
From time to time I felt my companion's arm tremble convulsively, as
if he shivered from head to feet. I looked at him. He understood the
look, and smiled at me; we had not exchanged a word since leaving the
Just before we reached the grave, Armand stopped to wipe his face,
which was covered with great drops of sweat. I took advantage of the
pause to draw in a long breath, for I, too, felt as if I had a weight
on my chest.
What is the origin of that mournful pleasure which we find in sights
of this kind? When we reached the grave the gardener had removed all
the flower-pots, the iron railing had been taken away, and two men were
turning up the soil.
Armand leaned against a tree and watched. All his life seemed to
pass before his eyes. Suddenly one of the two pickaxes struck against a
stone. At the sound Armand recoiled, as at an electric shock, and
seized my hand with such force as to give me pain.
One of the grave-diggers took a shovel and began emptying out the
earth; then, when only the stones covering the coffin were left, he
threw them out one by one.
I scrutinized Armand, for every moment I was afraid lest the
emotions which he was visibly repressing should prove too much for him;
but he still watched, his eyes fixed and wide open, like the eyes of a
madman, and a slight trembling of the cheeks and lips were the only
signs of the violent nervous crisis under which he was suffering.
As for me, all I can say is that I regretted having come.
When the coffin was uncovered the inspector said to the
grave-digger: “Open it.” They obeyed, as if it were the most natural
thing in the world.
The coffin was of oak, and they began to unscrew the lid. The
humidity of the earth had rusted the screws, and it was not without
some difficulty that the coffin was opened. A painful odour arose in
spite of the aromatic plants with which it was covered.
“O my God, my God!” murmured Armand, and turned paler than before.
Even the grave-digger drew back.
A great white shroud covered the corpse, closely outlining some of
its contours. This shroud was almost completely eaten away at one end,
and left one of the feet visible.
I was nearly fainting, and at the moment of writing these lines I
see the whole scene over again in all its imposing reality.
“Quick,” said the inspector. Thereupon one of the men put out his
hand, began to unsew the shroud, and taking hold of it by one end
suddenly laid bare the face of Marguerite.
It was terrible to see, it is horrible to relate. The eyes were
nothing but two holes, the lips had disappeared, vanished, and the
white teeth were tightly set. The black hair, long and dry, was pressed
tightly about the forehead, and half veiled the green hollows of the
cheeks; and yet I recognised in this face the joyous white and rose
face that I had seen so often.
Armand, unable to turn away his eyes, had put the handkerchief to
his mouth and bit it.
For my part, it was as if a circle of iron tightened about my head,
a veil covered my eyes, a rumbling filled my ears, and all I could do
was to unstop a smelling bottle which I happened to have with me, and
to draw in long breaths of it.
Through this bewilderment I heard the inspector say to Duval, “Do
“Yes,” replied the young man in a dull voice.
“Then fasten it up and take it away,” said the inspector.
The grave-diggers put back the shroud over the face of the corpse,
fastened up the coffin, took hold of each end of it, and began to carry
it toward the place where they had been told to take it.
Armand did not move. His eyes were fixed upon the empty grave; he
was as white as the corpse which we had just seen. He looked as if he
had been turned to stone.
I saw what was coming as soon as the pain caused by the spectacle
should have abated and thus ceased to sustain him. I went up to the
inspector. “Is this gentleman's presence still necessary?” I said,
pointing to Armand.
“No,” he replied, “and I should advise you to take him away. He
“Come,” I said to Armand, taking him by the arm.
“What?” he said, looking at me as if he did not recognise me.
“It is all over,” I added. “You must come, my friend; you are quite
white; you are cold. These emotions will be too much for you.”
“You are right. Let us go,” he answered mechanically, but without
moving a step.
I took him by the arm and led him along. He let himself be guided
like a child, only from time to time murmuring, “Did you see her eyes?”
and he turned as if the vision had recalled her.
Nevertheless, his steps became more irregular; he seemed to walk by
a series of jerks; his teeth chattered; his hands were cold; a violent
agitation ran through his body. I spoke to him; he did not answer. He
was just able to let himself be led along. A cab was waiting at the
gate. It was only just in time. Scarcely had he seated himself, when
the shivering became more violent, and he had an actual attack of
nerves, in the midst of which his fear of frightening me made him press
my hand and whisper: “It is nothing, nothing. I want to weep.”
His chest laboured, his eyes were injected with blood, but no tears
came. I made him smell the salts which I had with me, and when we
reached his house only the shivering remained.
With the help of his servant I put him to bed, lit a big fire in his
room, and hurried off to my doctor, to whom I told all that had
happened. He hastened with me.
Armand was flushed and delirious; he stammered out disconnected
words, in which only the name of Marguerite could be distinctly heard.
“Well?” I said to the doctor when he had examined the patient.
“Well, he has neither more nor less than brain fever, and very lucky
it is for him, for I firmly believe (God forgive me!) that he would
have gone out of his mind. Fortunately, the physical malady will kill
the mental one, and in a month's time he will be free from the one and
perhaps from the other.”
Illnesses like Armand's have one fortunate thing about them: they
either kill outright or are very soon overcome. A fortnight after the
events which I have just related Armand was convalescent, and we had
already become great friends. During the whole course of his illness I
had hardly left his side.
Spring was profuse in its flowers, its leaves, its birds, its songs;
and my friend's window opened gaily upon his garden, from which a
reviving breath of health seemed to come to him. The doctor had allowed
him to get up, and we often sat talking at the open window, at the hour
when the sun is at its height, from twelve to two. I was careful not to
refer to Marguerite, fearing lest the name should awaken sad
recollections hidden under the apparent calm of the invalid; but
Armand, on the contrary, seemed to delight in speaking of her, not as
formerly, with tears in his eyes, but with a sweet smile which
reassured me as to the state of his mind.
I had noticed that ever since his last visit to the cemetery, and
the sight which had brought on so violent a crisis, sorrow seemed to
have been overcome by sickness, and Marguerite's death no longer
appeared to him under its former aspect. A kind of consolation had
sprung from the certainty of which he was now fully persuaded, and in
order to banish the sombre picture which often presented itself to him,
he returned upon the happy recollections of his liaison with
Marguerite, and seemed resolved to think of nothing else.
The body was too much weakened by the attack of fever, and even by
the process of its cure, to permit him any violent emotions, and the
universal joy of spring which wrapped him round carried his thoughts
instinctively to images of joy. He had always obstinately refused to
tell his family of the danger which he had been in, and when he was
well again his father did not even know that he had been ill.
One evening we had sat at the window later than usual; the weather
had been superb, and the sun sank to sleep in a twilight dazzling with
gold and azure. Though we were in Paris, the verdure which surrounded
us seemed to shut us off from the world, and our conversation was only
now and again disturbed by the sound of a passing vehicle.
“It was about this time of the year, on the evening of a day like
this, that I first met Marguerite,” said Armand to me, as if he were
listening to his own thoughts rather than to what I was saying. I did
not answer. Then turning toward me, he said:
“I must tell you the whole story; you will make a book out of it; no
one will believe it, but it will perhaps be interesting to do.”
“You will tell me all about it later on, my friend,” I said to him;
“you are not strong enough yet.”
“It is a warm evening, I have eaten my ration of chicken,” he said
to me, smiling; “I have no fever, we have nothing to do, I will tell it
to you now.”
“Since you really wish it, I will listen.”
This is what he told me, and I have scarcely changed a word of the
Yes (Armand went on, letting his head sink back on the chair), yes,
it was just such an evening as this. I had spent the day in the country
with one of my friends, Gaston R—. We returned to Paris in the
evening, and not knowing what to do we went to the Varietes. We went
out during one of the entr'actes, and a tall woman passed us in the
corridor, to whom my friend bowed.
“Whom are you bowing to?” I asked.
“Marguerite Gautier,” he said.
“She seems much changed, for I did not recognise her,” I said, with
an emotion that you will soon understand.
“She has been ill; the poor girl won't last long.”
I remember the words as if they had been spoken to me yesterday.
I must tell you, my friend, that for two years the sight of this
girl had made a strange impression on me whenever I came across her.
Without knowing why, I turned pale and my heart beat violently. I have
a friend who studies the occult sciences, and he would call what I
experienced “the affinity of fluids”; as for me, I only know that I was
fated to fall in love with Marguerite, and that I foresaw it.
It is certainly the fact that she made a very definite impression
upon me, that many of my friends had noticed it and that they had been
much amused when they saw who it was that made this impression upon me.
The first time I ever saw her was in the Place de la Bourse, outside
Susse's; an open carriage was stationed there, and a woman dressed in
white got down from it. A murmur of admiration greeted her as she
entered the shop. As for me, I was rivetted to the spot from the moment
she went in till the moment when she came out again. I could see her
through the shop windows selecting what she had come to buy. I might
have gone in, but I dared not. I did not know who she was, and I was
afraid lest she should guess why I had come in and be offended.
Nevertheless, I did not think I should ever see her again.
She was elegantly dressed; she wore a muslin dress with many
flounces, an Indian shawl embroidered at the corners with gold and silk
flowers, a straw hat, a single bracelet, and a heavy gold chain, such
as was just then beginning to be the fashion.
She returned to her carriage and drove away. One of the shopmen
stood at the door looking after his elegant customer's carriage. I went
up to him and asked him what was the lady's name.
“Mademoiselle Marguerite Gautier,” he replied. I dared not ask him
for her address, and went on my way.
The recollection of this vision, for it was really a vision, would
not leave my mind like so many visions I had seen, and I looked
everywhere for this royally beautiful woman in white.
A few days later there was a great performance at the Opera Comique.
The first person I saw in one of the boxes was Marguerite Gautier.
The young man whom I was with recognised her immediately, for he
said to me, mentioning her name: “Look at that pretty girl.”
At that moment Marguerite turned her opera-glass in our direction
and, seeing my friend, smiled and beckoned to him to come to her.
“I will go and say 'How do you do?' to her,” he said, “and will be
back in a moment.”
“I could not help saying “Happy man!”
“To go and see that woman.”
“Are you in love with her?”
“No,” I said, flushing, for I really did not know what to say; “but
I should very much like to know her.”
“Come with me. I will introduce you.”
“Ask her if you may.”
“Really, there is no need to be particular with her; come.”
What he said troubled me. I feared to discover that Marguerite was
not worthy of the sentiment which I felt for her.
In a book of Alphonse Karr entitles Am Rauchen, there is a man who
one evening follows a very elegant woman, with whom he had fallen in
love with at first sight on account of her beauty. Only to kiss her
hand he felt that he had the strength to undertake anything, the will
to conquer anything, the courage to achieve anything. He scarcely dares
glance at the trim ankle which she shows as she holds her dress out of
the mud. While he is dreaming of all that he would do to possess this
woman, she stops at the corner of the street and asks if he will come
home with her. He turns his head, crosses the street, and goes sadly
back to his own house.
I recalled the story, and, having longed to suffer for this woman, I
was afraid that she would accept me too promptly and give me at once
what I fain would have purchased by long waiting or some great
sacrifice. We men are built like that, and it is very fortunate that
the imagination lends so much poetry to the senses, and that the
desires of the body make thus such concession to the dreams of the
soul. If any one had said to me, You shall have this woman to-night and
be killed tomorrow, I would have accepted. If any one had said to me,
you can be her lover for ten pounds, I would have refused. I would have
cried like a child who sees the castle he has been dreaming about
vanish away as he awakens from sleep.
All the same, I wished to know her; it was my only means of making
up my mind about her. I therefore said to my friend that I insisted on
having her permission to be introduced to her, and I wandered to and
fro in the corridors, saying to myself that in a moment's time she was
going to see me, and that I should not know which way to look. I tried
(sublime childishness of love!) to string together the words I should
say to her.
A moment after my friend returned. “She is expecting us,” he said.
“Is she alone?” I asked.
“With another woman.”
“There are no men?”
My friend went toward the door of the theatre.
“That is not the way,” I said.
“We must go and get some sweets. She asked me for some.”
We went into a confectioner's in the passage de l'Opera. I would
have bought the whole shop, and I was looking about to see what sweets
to choose, when my friend asked for a pound of raisins glaces.
“Do you know if she likes them?”
“She eats no other kind of sweets; everybody knows it.
“Ah,” he went on when we had left the shop, “do you know what kind
of woman it is that I am going to introduce you to? Don't imagine it is
a duchess. It is simply a kept woman, very much kept, my dear fellow;
don't be shy, say anything that comes into your head.”
“Yes, yes,” I stammered, and I followed him, saying to myself that I
should soon cure myself of my passion.
When I entered the box Marguerite was in fits of laughter. I would
rather that she had been sad. My friend introduced me; Marguerite gave
me a little nod, and said, “And my sweets?”
“Here they are.”
She looked at me as she took them. I dropped my eyes and blushed.
She leaned across to her neighbour and said something in her ear, at
which both laughed. Evidently I was the cause of their mirth, and my
embarrassment increased. At that time I had as mistress a very
affectionate and sentimental little person, whose sentiment and whose
melancholy letters amused me greatly. I realized the pain I must have
given her by what I now experienced, and for five minutes I loved her
as no woman was ever loved.
Marguerite ate her raisins glaces without taking any more notice of
me. The friend who had introduced me did not wish to let me remain in
so ridiculous a position.
“Marguerite,” he said, “you must not be surprised if M. Duval says
nothing: you overwhelm him to such a degree that he can not find a word
“I should say, on the contrary, that he has only come with you
because it would have bored you to come here by yourself.”
“If that were true,” I said, “I should not have begged Ernest to ask
your permission to introduce me.”
“Perhaps that was only in order to put off the fatal moment.”
However little one may have known women like Marguerite, one can not
but know the delight they take in pretending to be witty and in teasing
the people whom they meet for the first time. It is no doubt a return
for the humiliations which they often have to submit to on the part of
those whom they see every day.
To answer them properly, one requires a certain knack, and I had not
had the opportunity of acquiring it; besides, the idea that I had
formed of Marguerite accentuated the effects of her mockery. Nothing
that dame from her was indifferent to me. I rose to my feet, saying in
an altered voice, which I could not entirely control:
“If that is what you think of me, madame, I have only to ask your
pardon for my indiscretion, and to take leave of you with the assurance
that it shall not occur again.”
Thereupon I bowed and quitted the box. I had scarcely closed the
door when I heard a third peal of laughter. It would not have been well
for anybody who had elbowed me at that moment.
I returned to my seat. The signal for raising the curtain was given.
Ernest came back to his place beside me.
“What a way you behaved!” he said, as he sat down. “They will think
you are mad.”
“What did Marguerite say after I had gone?”
“She laughed, and said she had never seen any one so funny. But
don't look upon it as a lost chance; only do not do these women the
honour of taking them seriously. They do not know what politeness and
ceremony are. It is as if you were to offer perfumes to dogs—they
would think it smelled bad, and go and roll in the gutter.”
“After all, what does it matter to me?” I said, affecting to speak
in a nonchalant way. “I shall never see this woman again, and if I
liked her before meeting her, it is quite different now that I know
“Bah! I don't despair of seeing you one day at the back of her box,
and of bearing that you are ruining yourself for her. However, you are
right, she hasn't been well brought up; but she would be a charming
mistress to have.”
Happily, the curtain rose and my friend was silent. I could not
possibly tell you what they were acting. All that I remember is that
from time to time I raised my eyes to the box I had quitted so
abruptly, and that the faces of fresh visitors succeeded one another
all the time.
I was far from having given up thinking about Marguerite. Another
feeling had taken possession of me. It seemed to me that I had her
insult and my absurdity to wipe out; I said to myself that if I spent
every penny I had, I would win her and win my right to the place I had
abandoned so quickly.
Before the performance was over Marguerite and her friend left the
box. I rose from my seat.
“Are you going?” said Ernest.
At that moment he saw that the box was empty.
“Go, go,” he said, “and good luck, or rather better luck.”
I went out.
I heard the rustle of dresses, the sound of voices, on the
staircase. I stood aside, and, without being seen, saw the two women
pass me, accompanied by two young men. At the entrance to the theatre
they were met by a footman.
“Tell the coachman to wait at the door of the Cafe' Anglais,” said
Marguerite. “We will walk there.”
A few minutes afterward I saw Marguerite from the street at a window
of one of the large rooms of the restaurant, pulling the camellias of
her bouquet to pieces, one by one. One of the two men was leaning over
her shoulder and whispering in her ear. I took up my position at the
Maison-d'or, in one of the first-floor rooms, and did not lose sight of
the window for an instant. At one in the morning Marguerite got into
her carriage with her three friends. I took a cab and followed them.
The carriage stopped at No. 9, Rue d'Antin. Marguerite got out and went
in alone. It was no doubt a mere chance, but the chance filled me with
From that time forward, I often met Marguerite at the theatre or in
the Champs-Elysees. Always there was the same gaiety in her, the same
emotion in me.
At last a fortnight passed without my meeting her. I met Gaston and
asked after her.
“Poor girl, she is very ill,” he answered.
“What is the matter?”
“She is consumptive, and the sort of life she leads isn't exactly
the thing to cure her. She has taken to her bed; she is dying.”
The heart is a strange thing; I was almost glad at hearing it.
Every day I went to ask after her, without leaving my name or my
card. I heard she was convalescent and had gone to Bagneres.
Time went by, the impression, if not the memory, faded gradually
from my mind. I travelled; love affairs, habits, work, took the place
of other thoughts, and when I recalled this adventure I looked upon it
as one of those passions which one has when one is very young, and
laughs at soon afterward.
For the rest, it was no credit to me to have got the better of this
recollection, for I had completely lost sight of Marguerite, and, as I
told you, when she passed me in the corridor of the Varietes, I did not
recognise her. She was veiled, it is true; but, veiled though she might
have been two years earlier, I should not have needed to see her in
order to recognise her: I should have known her intuitively. All the
same, my heart began to beat when I knew that it was she; and the two
years that had passed since I saw her, and what had seemed to be the
results of that separation, vanished in smoke at the mere touch of her
However (continued Armand after a pause), while I knew myself to be
still in love with her, I felt more sure of myself, and part of my
desire to speak to Marguerite again was a wish to make her see that I
was stronger than she.
How many ways does the heart take, how many reasons does it invent
for itself, in order to arrive at what it wants!
I could not remain in the corridor, and I returned to my place in
the stalls, looking hastily around to see what box she was in. She was
in a ground-floor box, quite alone. She had changed, as I have told
you, and no longer wore an indifferent smile on her lips. She had
suffered; she was still suffering. Though it was April, she was still
wearing a winter costume, all wrapped up in furs.
I gazed at her so fixedly that my eyes attracted hers. She looked at
me for a few seconds, put up her opera-glass to see me better, and
seemed to think she recognised me, without being quite sure who I was,
for when she put down her glasses, a smile, that charming, feminine
salutation, flitted across her lips, as if to answer the bow which she
seemed to expect; but I did not respond, so as to have an advantage
over her, as if I had forgotten, while she remembered. Supposing
herself mistaken,, she looked away.
The curtain went up. I have often seen Marguerite at the theatre. I
never saw her pay the slightest attention to what was being acted. As
for me, the performance interested me equally little, and I paid no
attention to anything but her, though doing my utmost to keep her from
Presently I saw her glancing across at the person who was in the
opposite box; on looking, I saw a woman with whom I was quite familiar.
She had once been a kept woman, and had tried to go on the stage, had
failed, and, relying on her acquaintance with fashionable people in
Paris, had gone into business and taken a milliner's shop. I saw in her
a means of meeting with Marguerite, and profited by a moment in which
she looked my way to wave my hand to her. As I expected, she beckoned
to me to come to her box.
Prudence Duvernoy (that was the milliner's auspicious name) was one
of those fat women of forty with whom one requires very little
diplomacy to make them understand what one wants to know, especially
when what one wants to know is as simple as what I had to ask of her.
I took advantage of a moment when she was smiling across at
Marguerite to ask her, “Whom are you looking at?”
“You know her?”
“Yes, I am her milliner, and she is a neighbour of mine.”
“Do you live in the Rue d'Antin?”
“No. 7. The window of her dressing-room looks on to the window of
“They say she is a charming girl.”
“Don't you know her?”
“No, but I should like to.”
“Shall I ask her to come over to our box?”
“No, I would rather for you to introduce me to her.”
“At her own house?”
“That is more difficult.”
“Because she is under the protection of a jealous old duke.”
“'Protection' is charming.”
“Yes, protection,” replied Prudence. “Poor old man, he would be
greatly embarrassed to offer her anything else.”
Prudence then told me how Marguerite had made the acquaintance of
the duke at Bagneres.
“That, then,” I continued, “is why she is alone here?”
“But who will see her home?”
“He will come for her?”
“In a moment.”
“And you, who is seeing you home?”
“May I offer myself?”
“But you are with a friend, are you not?”
“May we offer, then?”
“Who is your friend?”
“A charming fellow, very amusing. He will be delighted to make your
“Well, all right; we will go after this piece is over, for I know
the last piece.”
“With pleasure; I will go and tell my friend.”
“Go, then. Ah,” added Prudence, as I was going, “there is the duke
just coming into Marguerite's box.”
I looked at him. A man of about seventy had sat down behind her, and
was giving her a bag of sweets, into which she dipped at once, smiling.
Then she held it out toward Prudence, with a gesture which seemed to
say, “Will you have some?”
“No,” signalled Prudence.
Marguerite drew back the bag, and, turning, began to talk with the
It may sound childish to tell you all these details, but everything
relating to Marguerite is so fresh in my memory that I can not help
recalling them now.
I went back to Gaston and told him of the arrangement I had made for
him and for me. He agreed, and we left our stalls to go round to Mme.
Duvernoy's box. We had scarcely opened the door leading into the stalls
when we had to stand aside to allow Marguerite and the duke to pass. I
would have given ten years of my life to have been in the old man's
When they were on the street he handed her into a phaeton, which he
drove himself, and they were whirled away by two superb horses.
We returned to Prudence's box, and when the play was over we took a
cab and drove to 7, Rue d'Antin. At the door, Prudence asked us to come
up and see her showrooms, which we had never seen, and of which she
seemed very proud. You can imagine how eagerly I accepted. It seemed to
me as if I was coming nearer and nearer to Marguerite. I soon turned
the conversation in her direction.
“The old duke is at your neighbours,” I said to Prudence.
“Oh, no; she is probably alone.”
“But she must be dreadfully bored,” said Gaston.
“We spend most of our evening together, or she calls to me when she
comes in. She never goes to bed before two in the morning. She can't
sleep before that.”
“Because she suffers in the chest, and is almost always feverish.”
“Hasn't she any lovers?” I asked.
“I never see any one remain after I leave; I don't say no one ever
comes when I am gone. Often in the evening I meet there a certain Comte
de N., who thinks he is making some headway by calling on her at eleven
in the evening, and by sending her jewels to any extent; but she can't
stand him. She makes a mistake; he is very rich. It is in vain that I
say to her from time to time, 'My dear child, there's the man for you.'
She, who generally listens to me, turns her back and replies that he is
too stupid. Stupid, indeed, he is; but it would be a position for her,
while this old duke might die any day. Old men are egoists; his family
are always reproaching him for his affection for Marguerite; there are
two reasons why he is likely to leave her nothing. I give her good
advice, and she only says it will be plenty of time to take on the
count when the duke is dead. It isn't all fun,” continued Prudence, “to
live like that. I know very well it wouldn't suit me, and I should soon
send the old man about his business. He is so dull; he calls her his
daughter; looks after her like a child; and is always in the way. I am
sure at this very moment one of his servants is prowling about in the
street to see who comes out, and especially who goes in.”
“Ah, poor Marguerite!” said Gaston, sitting down to the piano and
playing a waltz. “I hadn't a notion of it, but I did notice she hasn't
been looking so gay lately.”
“Hush,” said Prudence, listening. Gaston stopped.
“She is calling me, I think.”
We listened. A voice was calling, “Prudence!”
“Come, now, you must go,” said Mme. Duvernoy.
“Ah, that is your idea of hospitality,” said Gaston, laughing; “we
won't go till we please.”
“Why should we go?”
“I am going over to Marguerite's.”
“We will wait here.”
“Then we will go with you.”
“That still less.”
“I know Marguerite,” said Gaston; I can very well pay her a call.”
“But Armand doesn't know her.”
“I will introduce him.”
We again heard Marguerite's voice calling to Prudence, who rushed to
her dressing-room window. I followed with Gaston as she opened the
window. We hid ourselves so as not to be seen from outside.
“I have been calling you for ten minutes,” said Marguerite from her
window, in almost an imperious tone of voice.
“What do you want?”
“I want you to come over at once.”
“Because the Comte de N. is still here, and he is boring me to
“I can't now.”
“What is hindering you?”
“There are two young fellows here who won't go.”
“Tell them that you must go out.”
“I have told them.”
“Well, then, leave them in the house. They will soon go when they
see you have gone.”
“They will turn everything upside down.”
“But what do they want?”
“They want to see you.”
“What are they called?”
“You know one, M. Gaston R.”
“Ah, yes, I know him. And the other?”
“M. Armand Duval; and you don't know him.”
“No, but bring them along. Anything is better than the count. I
expect you. Come at once.”
Marguerite closed her window and Prudence hers. Marguerite, who had
remembered my face for a moment, did not remember my name. I would
rather have been remembered to my disadvantage than thus forgotten.
“I knew,” said Gaston, “that she would be delighted to see us.”
“Delighted isn't the word,” replied Prudence, as she put on her hat
and shawl. “She will see you in order to get rid of the count. Try to
be more agreeable than he is, or (I know Marguerite) she will put it
all down to me.”
We followed Prudence downstairs. I trembled; it seemed to me that
this visit was to have a great influence on my life. I was still more
agitated than on the evening when I was introduced in the box at the
Opera Comique. As we reached the door that you know, my heart beat so
violently that I was hardly able to think.
We heard the sound of a piano. Prudence rang. The piano was silent.
A woman who looked more like a companion than a servant opened the
door. We went into the drawing-room, and from that to the boudoir,
which was then just as you have seen it since. A young man was leaning
against the mantel-piece. Marguerite, seated at the piano, let her
fingers wander over the notes, beginning scraps of music without
finishing them. The whole scene breathed boredom, the man embarrassed
by the consciousness of his nullity, the woman tired of her dismal
visitor. At the voice of Prudence, Marguerite rose, and coming toward
us with a look of gratitude to Mme. Duvernoy, said:
“Come in, and welcome.”
“Good-evening, my dear Gaston,” said Marguerite to my companion. “I
am very glad to see you. Why didn't you come to see me in my box at the
“I was afraid it would be indiscreet.”
“Friends,” and Marguerite lingered over the word, as if to intimate
to those who were present that in spite of the familiar way in which
she greeted him, Gaston was not and never had been anything more than a
friend, “friends are always welcome.”
“Then, will you permit me to introduce M. Armand Duval?”
“I had already authorized Prudence to do so.”
“As far as that goes, madame,” I said, bowing, and succeeding in
getting more or less intelligible sounds out of my throat, “I have
already had the honour of being introduced to you.”
Marguerite's beautiful eyes seemed to be looking back in memory, but
she could not, or seemed not to, remember.
“Madame,” I continued, “I am grateful to you for having forgotten
the occasion of my first introduction, for I was very absurd and must
have seemed to you very tiresome. It was at the Opera Comique, two
years ago; I was with Ernest de —.”
“Ah, I remember,” said Marguerite, with a smile. “It was not you who
were absurd; it was I who was mischievous, as I still am, but somewhat
less. You have forgiven me?”
And she held out her hand, which I kissed.
“It is true,” she went on; “you know I have the bad habit of trying
to embarrass people the first time I meet them. It is very stupid. My
doctor says it is because I am nervous and always ill; believe my
“But you seem quite well.”
“Oh! I have been very ill.”
“Who told you?”
“Every one knew it; I often came to inquire after you, and I was
happy to hear of your convalescence.”
“They never gave me your card.”
“I did not leave it.”
“Was it you, then, who called every day while I was ill, and would
never leave your name?”
“Yes, it was I.”
“Then you are more than indulgent, you are generous. You, count,
wouldn't have done that,” said she, turning toward M. de N., after
giving me one of those looks in which women sum up their opinion of a
“I have only known you for two months,” replied the count.
“And this gentleman only for five minutes. You always say something
Women are pitiless toward those whom they do not care for. The count
reddened and bit his lips.
I was sorry for him, for he seemed, like myself, to be in love, and
the bitter frankness of Marguerite must have made him very unhappy,
especially in the presence of two strangers.
“You were playing the piano when we came in,” I said, in order to
change the conversation. “Won't you be so good as to treat me as an old
acquaintance and go on?”
“Oh,” said she, flinging herself on the sofa and motioning to us to
sit down, “Gaston knows what my music is like. It is all very well when
I am alone with the count, but I won't inflict such a punishment on
“You show me that preference?” said M. de N., with a smile which he
tried to render delicately ironical.
“Don't reproach me for it. It is the only one.” It was fated that
the poor man was not to say a single word. He cast a really
supplicating glance at Marguerite.
“Well, Prudence,” she went on, “have you done what I asked you to
“All right. You will tell me about it later. We must talk over it;
don't go before I can speak with you.”
“We are doubtless intruders,” I said, “and now that we, or rather I,
have had a second introduction, to blot out the first, it is time for
Gaston and me to be going.”
“Not in the least. I didn't mean that for you. I want you to stay.”
The count took a very elegant watch out of his pocket and looked at
the time. “I must be going to my club,” he said. Marguerite did not
answer. The count thereupon left his position by the fireplace and
going up to her, said: “Adieu, madame.”
Marguerite rose. “Adieu, my dear count. Are you going already?”
“Yes, I fear I am boring you.”
“You are not boring me to-day more than any other day. When shall I
be seeing you?”
“When you permit me.”
It was cruel, you will admit. Fortunately, the count had excellent
manners and was very good-tempered. He merely kissed Marguerite's hand,
which she held out to him carelessly enough, and, bowing to us, went
As he crossed the threshold, he cast a glance at Prudence. She
shrugged her shoulders, as much as to say:
“What do you expect? I have done all I could.”
“Nanine!” cried Marguerite. “Light M. le Comte to the door.”
We heard the door open and shut.
“At last,” cried Marguerite, coming back, “he has gone! That man
gets frightfully on my nerves!”
“My dear child,” said Prudence, “you really treat him too badly, and
he is so good and kind to you. Look at this watch on the mantel-piece,
that he gave you: it must have cost him at least three thousand francs,
I am sure.”
And Mme. Duvernoy began to turn it over, as it lay on the
mantel-piece, looking at it with covetous eyes.
“My dear,” said Marguerite, sitting down to the piano, “when I put
on one side what he gives me and on the other what he says to me, it
seems to me that he buys his visits very cheap.”
“The poor fellow is in love with you.”
“If I had to listen to everybody who was in love with me, I
shouldn't have time for my dinner.”
And she began to run her fingers over the piano, and then, turning
to us, she said:
“What will you take? I think I should like a little punch.”
“And I could eat a little chicken,” said Prudence. “Suppose we have
“That's it, let's go and have supper,” said Gaston.
“No, we will have supper here.”
She rang, and Nanine appeared.
“Send for some supper.”
“What must I get?”
“Whatever you like, but at once, at once.”
Nanine went out.
“That's it,” said Marguerite, jumping like a child, “we'll have
supper. How tiresome that idiot of a count is!”
The more I saw her, the more she enchanted me. She was exquisitely
beautiful. Her slenderness was a charm. I was lost in contemplation.
What was passing in my mind I should have some difficulty in
explaining. I was full of indulgence for her life, full of admiration
for her beauty. The proof of disinterestedness that she gave in not
accepting a rich and fashionable young man, ready to waste all his
money upon her, excused her in my eyes for all her faults in the past.
There was a kind of candour in this woman. You could see she was
still in the virginity of vice. Her firm walk, her supple figure, her
rosy, open nostrils, her large eyes, slightly tinged with blue,
indicated one of those ardent natures which sbed around them a sort of
voluptuous perfume, like Eastern vials, which, close them as tightly as
you will, still let some of their perfume escape. Finally, whether it
was simple nature or a breath of fever, there passed from time to time
in the eyes of this woman a glimmer of desire, giving promise of a very
heaven for one whom she should love. But those who had loved Marguerite
were not to be counted, nor those whom she had loved.
In this girl there was at once the virgin whom a mere nothing had
turned into a courtesan, and the courtesan whom a mere nothing would
have turned into the most loving and the purest of virgins. Marguerite
had still pride and independence, two sentiments which, if they are
wounded, can be the equivalent of a sense of shame. I did not speak a
word; my soul seemed to have passed into my heart and my heart into my
“So,” said she all at once, “it was you who came to inquire after me
when I was ill?”
“Do you know, it was quite splendid of you! How can I thank you for
“By allowing me to come and see you from time to time.”
“As often as you like, from five to six, and from eleven to twelve.
Now, Gaston, play the Invitation A la Valse.”
“To please me, first of all, and then because I never can manage to
play it myself.”
“What part do you find difficult?”
“The third part, the part in sharps.”
Gaston rose and went to the piano, and began to play the wonderful
melody of Weber, the music of which stood open before him.
Marguerite, resting one hand on the piano, followed every note on
the music, accompanying it in a low voice, and when Gaston had come to
the passage which she had mentioned to him, she sang out, running her
fingers along the top of the piano:
“Do, re, mi, do, re, fa, mi, re; that is what I can not do. Over
Gaston began over again, after which Marguerite said:
“Now, let me try.”
She took her place and began to play; but her rebellious fingers
always came to grief over one of the notes.
“Isn't it incredible,” she said, exactly like a child, “that I can
not succeed in playing that passage? Would you believe that I sometimes
spend two hours of the morning over it? And when I think that that
idiot of a count plays it without his music, and beautifully, I really
believe it is that that makes me so furious with him.” And she began
again, always with the same result.
“The devil take Weber, music, and pianos!” she cried, throwing the
music to the other end of the room. “How can I play eight sharps one
after another?” She folded her arms and looked at us, stamping her
foot. The blood flew to her cheeks, and her lips half opened in a
“Come, come,” said Prudence, who had taken off her hat and was
smoothing her hair before the glass, “you will work yourself into a
rage and do yourself harm. Better come and have supper; for my part, I
am dying of hunger.”
Marguerite rang the bell, sat down to the piano again, and began to
hum over a very risky song, which she accompanied without difficulty.
Gaston knew the song, and they gave a sort of duet.
“Don't sing those beastly things,” I said to Marguerite,
“Oh, how proper you are!” she said, smiling and giving me her hand.
“It is not for myself, but for you.”
Marguerite made a gesture as if to say, “Oh, it is long since that I
have done with propriety!” At that moment Nanine appeared.
“Is supper ready?” asked Marguerite. “Yes, madame, in one moment.”
“Apropos,” said Prudence to me, “you have not looked round; come,
and I will show you.” As you know, the drawing-room was a marvel.
Marguerite went with us for a moment; then she called Gaston and
went into the dining-room with him to see if supper was ready.
“Ah,” said Prudence, catching sight of a little Saxe figure on a
side-table, “I never knew you had this little gentleman.”
“A little shepherd holding a bird-cage.”
“Take it, if you like it.”
“I won't deprive you of it.”
“I was going to give it to my maid. I think it hideous; but if you
like it, take it.”
Prudence only saw the present, not the way in which it was given.
She put the little figure on one side, and took me into the
dressing-room, where she showed me two miniatures hanging side by side,
“That is the Comte de G., who was very much in love with Marguerite;
it was he who brought her out. Do you know him?”
“No. And this one?” I inquired, pointing to the other miniature.
“That is the little Vicomte de L. He was obliged to disappear.”
“Because he was all but ruined. That's one, if you like, who loved
“And she loved him, too, no doubt?”
“She is such a queer girl, one never knows. The night he went away
she went to the theatre as usual, and yet she had cried when he said
good-bye to her.”
Just then Nanine appeared, to tell us that supper was served.
When we entered the dining-room, Marguerite was leaning against the
wall, and Gaston, holding her hands, was speaking to her in a low
“You are mad,” replied Marguerite. “You know quite well that I don't
want you. It is no good at the end of two years to make love to a woman
like me. With us, it is at once, or never. Come, gentlemen, supper!”
And, slipping away from Gaston, Marguerite made him sit on her right
at table, me on her left, then called to Nanine:
“Before you sit down, tell them in the kitchen not to open to
anybody if there is a ring.”
This order was given at one o'clock in the morning.
We laughed, drank, and ate freely at this supper. In a short while
mirth had reached its last limit, and the words that seem funny to a
certain class of people, words that degrade the mouth that utters them,
were heard from time to time, amidst the applause of Nanine, of
Prudence, and of Marguerite. Gaston was thoroughly amused; he was a
very good sort of fellow, but somewhat spoiled by the habits of his
youth. For a moment I tried to forget myself, to force my heart and my
thoughts to become indifferent to the sight before me, and to take my
share of that gaiety which seemed like one of the courses of the meal.
But little by little I withdrew from the noise; my glass remained full,
and I felt almost sad as I saw this beautiful creature of twenty
drinking, talking like a porter, and laughing the more loudly the more
scandalous was the joke.
Nevertheless, this hilarity, this way of talking and drinking, which
seemed to me in the others the mere results of bad company or of bad
habits, seemed in Marguerite a necessity of forgetting, a fever, a
nervous irritability. At every glass of champagne her cheeks would
flush with a feverish colour, and a cough, hardly perceptible at the
beginning of supper, became at last so violent that she was obliged to
lean her head on the back of her chair and hold her chest in her hands
every time that she coughed. I suffered at the thought of the injury to
so frail a constitution which must come from daily excesses like this.
At length, something which I had feared and foreseen happened. Toward
the end of supper Marguerite was seized by a more violent fit of
coughing than any she had had while I was there. It seemed as if her
chest were being torn in two. The poor girl turned crimson, closed her
eyes under the pain, and put her napkin to her lips. It was stained
with a drop of blood. She rose and ran into her dressing-room.
“What is the matter with Marguerite?” asked Gaston.
“She has been laughing too much, and she is spitting blood. Oh, it
is nothing; it happens to her every day. She will be back in a minute.
Leave her alone. She prefers it.”
I could not stay still; and, to the consternation of Prudence and
Nanine, who called to me to come back, I followed Marguerite.”
The room to which she had fled was lit only by a single candle. She
lay back on a great sofa, her dress undone, holding one hand on her
heart, and letting the other hang by her side. On the table was a basin
half full of water, and the water was stained with streaks of blood.
Very pale, her mouth half open, Marguerite tried to recover breath.
Now and again her bosom was raised by a long sigh, which seemed to
relieve her a little, and for a few seconds she would seem to be quite
I went up to her; she made no movement, and I sat down and took the
hand which was lying on the sofa.
“Ah! it is you,” she said, with a smile.
I must have looked greatly agitated, for she added:
“Are you unwell, too?”
“No, but you: do you still suffer?”
“Very little;” and she wiped off with her handkerchief the tears
which the coughing had brought to her eyes; “I am used to it now.”
“You are killing yourself, madame,” I said to her in a moved voice.
“I wish I were a friend, a relation of yours, that I might keep you
from doing yourself harm like this.”
“Ah! it is really not worth your while to alarm yourself,” she
replied in a somewhat bitter tone; “see how much notice the others take
of me! They know too well that there is nothing to be done.”
Thereupon she got up, and, taking the candle, put it on the
mantel-piece and looked at herself in the glass.
“How pale I am!” she said, as she fastened her dress and passed her
fingers over her loosened hair. “Come, let us go back to supper. Are
I sat still and did not move.
She saw how deeply I had been affected by the whole scene, and,
coming up to me, held out her hand, saying:
“Come now, let us go.”
I took her hand, raised it to my lips, and in spite of myself two
tears fell upon it.
“Why, what a child you are!” she said, sitting down by my side
again. “You are crying! What is the matter?”
“I must seem very silly to you, but I am frightfully troubled by
what I have just seen.”
“You are very good! What would you have of me? I can not sleep. I
must amuse myself a little. And then, girls like me, what does it
matter, one more or less? The doctors tell me that the blood I spit up
comes from my throat; I pretend to believe them; it is all I can do for
“Listen, Marguerite,” I said, unable to contain myself any longer;
“I do not know what influence you are going to have over my life, but
at this present moment there is no one, not even my sister, in whom I
feel the interest which I feel in you. It has been just the same ever
since I saw you. Well, for Heaven's sake, take care of yourself, and do
not live as you are living now.”
“If I took care of myself I should die. All that supports me is the
feverish life I lead. Then, as for taking care of oneself, that is all
very well for women with families and friends; as for us, from the
moment we can no longer serve the vanity or the pleasure of our lovers,
they leave us, and long nights follow long days. I know it. I was in
bed for two months, and after three weeks no one came to see me.”
“It is true I am nothing to you,” I went on, “but if you will let
me, I will look after you like a brother, I will never leave your side,
and I will cure you. Then, when you are strong again, you can go back
to the life you are leading, if you choose; but I am sure you will come
to prefer a quiet life, which will make you happier and keep your
“You think like that to-night because the wine has made you sad, but
you would never have the patience that you pretend to.”
“Permit me to say, Marguerite, that you were ill for two months, and
that for two months I came to ask after you every day.”
“It is true, but why did you not come up?”
“Because I did not know you then.”
“Need you have been so particular with a girl like me?”
“One must always be particular with a woman; it is what I feel, at
“So you would look after me?”
“You would stay by me all day?”
“And even all night?”
“As long as I did not weary you.”
“And what do you call that?”
“And what does this devotion come from?”
“The irresistible sympathy which I have for you.”
“So you are in love with me? Say it straight out, it is much more
“It is possible; but if I am to say it to you one day, it is not
“You will do better never to say it.”
“Because only one of two things can come of it.”
“Either I shall not accept: then you will have a grudge against me;
or I shall accept: then you will have a sorry mistress; a woman who is
nervous, ill, sad, or gay with a gaiety sadder than grief, a woman who
spits blood and spends a hundred thousand francs a year. That is all
very well for a rich old man like the duke, but it is very bad for a
young man like you, and the proof of it is that all the young lovers I
have had have very soon left me.” I did not answer; I listened. This
frankness, which was almost a kind of confession, the sad life, of
which I caught some glimpse through the golden veil which covered it,
and whose reality the poor girl sought to escape in dissipation, drink,
and wakefulness, impressed me so deeply that I could not utter a single
“Come,” continued Marguerite, “we are talking mere childishness.
Give me your arm and let us go back to the dining-room. They won't know
what we mean by our absence.”
“Go in, if you like, but allow me to stay here.”
“Because your mirth hurts me.”
“Well, I will be sad.”
“Marguerite, let me say to you something which you have no doubt
often heard, so often that the habit of hearing it has made you believe
it no longer, but which is none the less real, and which I will never
“And that is . . . ?” she said, with the smile of a young mother
listening to some foolish notion of her child.
“It is this, that ever since I have seen you, I know not why, you
have taken a place in my life; that, if I drive the thought of you out
of my mind, it always comes back; that when I met you to-day, after not
having seen you for two years, you made a deeper impression on my heart
and mind than ever; that, now that you have let me come to see you, now
that I know you, now that I know all that is strange in you, you have
become a necessity of my life, and you will drive me mad, not only if
you will not love me, but if you will not let me love you.”
“But, foolish creature that you are, I shall say to you, like Mme.
D., 'You must be very rich, then!' Why, you don't know that I spend six
or seven thousand francs a month, and that I could not live without it;
you don't know, my poor friend, that I should ruin you in no time, and
that your family would cast you off if you were to live with a woman
like me. Let us be friends, good friends, but no more. Come and see me,
we will laugh and talk, but don't exaggerate what I am worth, for I am
worth very little. You have a good heart, you want some one to love
you, you are too young and too sensitive to live in a world like mine.
Take a married woman. You see, I speak to you frankly, like a friend.”
“But what the devil are you doing there?” cried Prudence, who had
come in without our bearing her, and who now stood just inside the
door, with her hair half coming down and her dress undone. I recognised
the hand of Gaston.
“We are talking sense,” said Marguerite; “leave us alone; we will be
“Good, good! Talk, my children,” said Prudence, going out and
closing the door behind her, as if to further empbasize the tone in
which she had said these words.
“Well, it is agreed,” continued Marguerite, when we were alone, “you
won't fall in love with me?”
“I will go away.”
“So much as that?”
I had gone too far to draw back; and I was really carried away. This
mingling of gaiety, sadness, candour, prostitution, her very malady,
which no doubt developed in her a sensitiveness to impressions, as well
as an irritability of nerves, all this made it clear to me that if from
the very beginning I did not completely dominate her light and
forgetful nature, she was lost to me.
“Come, now, do you seriously mean what you say?” she said.
“But why didn't you say it to me sooner?”
“When could I have said it?”
“The day after you had been introduced to me at the Opera Comique.”
“I thought you would have received me very badly if I had come to
“Because I had behaved so stupidly.”
“That's true. And yet you were already in love with me.”
“And that didn't hinder you from going to bed and sleeping quite
comfortably. One knows what that sort of love means.”
“There you are mistaken. Do you know what I did that evening, after
the Opera Comique?”
“I waited for you at the door of the Cafe Anglais. I followed the
carriage in which you and your three friends were, and when I saw you
were the only one to get down, and that you went in alone, I was very
Marguerite began to laugh.
“What are you laughing at?”
“Tell me, I beg of you, or I shall think you are still laughing at
“You won't be cross?”
“What right have I to be cross?”
“Well, there was a sufficient reason why I went in alone.”
“Some one was waiting for me here.”
If she had thrust a knife into me she would not have hurt me more. I
rose, and holding out my hand, “Goodbye,” said I.
“I knew you would be cross,” she said; “men are frantic to know what
is certain to give them pain.”
“But I assure you,” I added coldly, as if wishing to prove how
completely I was cured of my passion, “I assure you that I am not
cross. It was quite natural that some one should be waiting for you,
just as it is quite natural that I should go from here at three in the
“Have you, too, some one waiting for you?”
“No, but I must go.”
“You send me away?”
“Not the least in the world.”
“Why are you so unkind to me?”
“How have I been unkind to you?”
“In telling me that some one was waiting for you.”
“I could not help laughing at the idea that you had been so happy to
see me come in alone when there was such a good reason for it.”
“One finds pleasure in childish enough things, and it is too bad to
destroy such a pleasure when, by simply leaving it alone, one can make
somebody so happy.”
“But what do you think I am? I am neither maid nor duchess. I didn't
know you till to-day, and I am not responsible to you for my actions.
Supposing one day I should become your mistress, you are bound to know
that I have had other lovers besides you. If you make scenes of
jealousy like this before, what will it be after, if that after should
ever exist? I never met any one like you.”
“That is because no one has ever loved you as I love you.”
“Frankly, then, you really love me?”
“As much as it is possible to love, I think.”
“And that has lasted since—?”
“Since the day I saw you go into Susse's, three years ago.
“Do you know, that is tremendously fine? Well, what am to do in
“Love me a little,” I said, my heart beating so that I could hardly
speak; for, in spite of the half-mocking smiles with which she had
accompanied the whole conversation, it seemed to me that Marguerite
began to share my agitation, and that the hour so long awaited was
“Well, but the duke?”
“My jealous old duke.”
“He will know nothing.”
“And if he should?”
“He would forgive you.”
“Ah, no, he would leave me, and what would become of me?”
“You risk that for some one else.”
“How do you know?” “By the order you gave not to admit any one
to-night.” “It is true; but that is a serious friend.”
“For whom you care nothing, as you have shut your door against him
at such an hour.”
“It is not for you to reproach me, since it was in order to receive
you, you and your friend.”
Little by little I had drawn nearer to Marguerite. I had put my arms
about her waist, and I felt her supple body weigh lightly on my clasped
“If you knew how much I love you!” I said in a low voice. “Really
“I swear it.”
“Well, if you will promise to do everything I tell you, without a
word, without an opinion, without a question, perhaps I will say yes.”
“I will do everything that you wish!”
“But I forewarn you I must be free to do as I please, without giving
you the slightest details what I do. I have long wished for a young
lover, who should be young and not self-willed, loving without
distrust, loved without claiming the right to it. I have never found
one. Men, instead of being satisfied in obtaining for a long time what
they scarcely hoped to obtain once, exact from their mistresses a full
account of the present, the past, and even the future. As they get
accustomed to her, they want to rule her, and the more one gives them
the more exacting they become. If I decide now on taking a new lover,
he must have three very rare qualities: he must be confiding,
submissive, and discreet.”
“Well, I will be all that you wish.”
“We shall see.”
“When shall we see?”
“Because,” said Marguerite, releasing herself from my arms, and,
taking from a great bunch of red camellias a single camellia, she
placed it in my buttonhole, “because one can not always carry out
agreements the day they are signed.”
“And when shall I see you again?” I said, clasping her in my arms.
“When this camellia changes colour.”
“When will it change colour?”
“To-morrow night between eleven and twelve. Are you satisfied?”
“Need you ask me?”
“Not a word of this either to your friend or to Prudence, or to
“Now, kiss me, and we will go back to the dining-room.”
She held up her lips to me, smoothed her hair again, and we went out
of the room, she singing, and I almost beside myself.
In the next room she stopped for a moment and said to me in a low
“It must seem strange to you that I am ready to take you at a
moment's notice. Shall I tell you why? It is,” she continued, taking my
hand and placing it against her heart so that I could feel how rapidly
and violently it palpitated; “it is because I shall not live as long as
others, and I have promised myself to live more quickly.”
“Don't speak to me like that, I entreat you.”
“Oh, make yourself easy,” she continued, laughing; “however short a
time I have to live, I shall live longer than you will love me!”
And she went singing into the dining-room.
“Where is Nanine?” she said, seeing Gaston and Prudence alone.
“She is asleep in your room, waiting till you are ready to go to
bed,” replied Prudence.
“Poor thing, I am killing her! And now gentlemen, it is time to go.”
Ten minutes after, Gaston and I left the house. Marguerite shook
hands with me and said good-bye. Prudence remained behind.
“Well,” said Gaston, when we were in the street, “what do you think
“She is an angel, and I am madly in love with her.” “So I guessed;
did you tell her so?”
“And did she promise to believe you?”
“She is not like Prudence.”
“Did she promise to?”
“Better still, my dear fellow. You wouldn't think it; but she is
still not half bad, poor old Duvernoy!”
At this point Armand stopped.
“Would you close the window for me?” he said. “I am beginning to
feel cold. Meanwhile, I will get into bed.”
I closed the window. Armand, who was still very weak, took off his
dressing-gown and lay down in bed, resting his head for a few moments
on the pillow, like a man who is tired by much talking or disturbed by
“Perhaps you have been talking too much,” I said to him. “Would you
rather for me to go and leave you to sleep? You can tell me the rest of
the story another day.”
“Are you tired of listening to it?”
“Quite the contrary.”
“Then I will go on. If you left me alone, I should not sleep.”
When I returned home (he continued, without needing to pause and
recollect himself, so fresh were all the details in his mind), I did
not go to bed, but began to reflect over the day's adventure. The
meeting, the introduction, the promise of Marguerite, had followed one
another so rapidly, and so unexpectedly, that there were moments when
it seemed to me I had been dreaming. Nevertheless, it was not the first
time that a girl like Marguerite had promised herself to a man on the
morrow of the day on which he had asked for the promise.
Though, indeed, I made this reflection, the first impression
produced on me by my future mistress was so strong that it still
persisted. I refused obstinately to see in her a woman like other
women, and, with the vanity so common to all men, I was ready to
believe that she could not but share the attraction which drew me to
Yet, I had before me plenty of instances to the contrary, and I had
often heard that the affection of Marguerite was a thing to be had more
or less dear, according to the season.
But, on the other hand, how was I to reconcile this reputation with
her constant refusal of the young count whom we had found at her house?
You may say that he was unattractive to her, and that, as she was
splendidly kept by the duke, she would be more likely to choose a man
who was attractive to her, if she were to take another lover. If so,
why did she not choose Gaston, who was rich, witty, and charming, and
why did she care for me, whom she had thought so ridiculous the first
time she had seen me?
It is true that there are events of a moment which tell more than
the courtship of a year. Of those who were at the supper, I was the
only one who had been concerned at her leaving the table. I had
followed her, I had been so affected as to be unable to hide it from
her, I had wept as I kissed her hand. This circumstance, added to my
daily visits during the two months of her illness, might have shown her
that I was somewhat different from the other men she knew, and perhaps
she had said to herself that for a love which could thus manifest
itself she might well do what she had done so often that it had no more
consequence for her.
All these suppositions, as you may see, were improbable enough; but
whatever might have been the reason of her consent, one thing was
certain, she had consented.
Now, I was in love with Marguerite. I had nothing more to ask of
her. Nevertheless, though she was only a kept woman, I had so
anticipated for myself, perhaps to poetize it a little, a hopeless
love, that the nearer the moment approached when I should have nothing
more to hope, the more I doubted. I did not close my eyes all night.
I scarcely knew myself. I was half demented. Now, I seemed to myself
not handsome or rich or elegant enough to possess such a woman, now I
was filled with vanity at the thought of it; then I began to fear lest
Marguerite had no more than a few days' caprice for me, and I said to
myself that since we should soon have to part, it would be better not
to keep her appointment, but to write and tell her my fears and leave
her. From that I went on to unlimited hope, unbounded confidence. I
dreamed incredible dreams of the future; I said to myself that she
should owe to me her moral and physical recovery, that I should spend
my whole life with her, and that her love should make me happier than
all the maidenly loves in the world.
But I can not repeat to you the thousand thoughts that rose from my
heart to my head, and that only faded away with the sleep that came to
me at daybreak.
When I awoke it was two o'clock. The weather was superb. I don't
think life ever seemed to me so beautiful and so full of possibilities.
The memories of the night before came to me without shadow or
hindrance, escorted gaily by the hopes of the night to come. From time
to time my heart leaped with love and joy in my breast. A sweet fever
thrilled me. I thought no more of the reasons which had filled my mind
before I slept. I saw only the result, I thought only of the hour when
I was to see Marguerite again.
It was impossible to stay indoors. My room seemed too small to
contain my happiness. I needed the whole of nature to unbosom myself.
I went out. Passing by the Rue d'Antin, I saw Marguerite's coupe'
waiting for her at the door. I went toward the Champs-Elysees. I loved
all the people whom I met. Love gives one a kind of goodness.
After I had been walking for an hour from the Marly horses to the
Rond-Point, I saw Marguerite's carriage in the distance; I divined
rather than recognised it. As it was turning the corner of the
Champs-Elysees it stopped, and a tall young man left a group of people
with whom he was talking and came up to her. They talked for a few
moments; the young man returned to his friends, the horses set out
again, and as I came near the group I recognised the one who had spoken
to Marguerite as the Comte de G., whose portrait I had seen and whom
Prudence had indicated to me as the man to whom Marguerite owed her
position. It was to him that she had closed her doors the night before;
I imagined that she had stopped her carriage in order to explain to him
why she had done so, and I hoped that at the same time she had found
some new pretext for not receiving him on the following night.
How I spent the rest of the day I do not know; I walked, smoked,
talked, but what I said, whom I met, I had utterly forgotten by ten
o'clock in the evening.
All I remember is that when I returned home, I spent three hours
over my toilet, and I looked at my watch and my clock a hundred times,
which unfortunately both pointed to the same hour.
When it struck half past ten, I said to myself that it was time to
I lived at that time in the Rue de Provence; I followed the Rue du
Mont-Blanc, crossed the Boulevard, went up the Rue Louis-le-Grand, the
Rue de Port-Mahon, and the Rue d'Antin. I looked up at Marguerite's
windows. There was a light. I rang. I asked the porter if Mlle. Gautier
was at home. He replied that she never came in before eleven or a
quarter past eleven. I looked at my watch. I intended to come quite
slowly, and I had come in five minutes from the Rue de Provence to the
I walked to and fro in the street; there are no shops, and at that
hour it is quite deserted. In half an hour's time
Marguerite arrived. She looked around her as she got down from her
coupe', as if she were looking for some one. The carriage drove off;
the stables were not at the house. Just as Marguerite was going to
ring, I went up to her and said, “Good-evening.”
“Ah, it is you,” she said, in a tone that by no means reassured me
as to her pleasure in seeing me.
“Did you not promise me that I might come and see you to-day?”
“Quite right. I had forgotten.”
This word upset all the reflections I had had during the day.
Nevertheless, I was beginning to get used to her ways, and I did not
leave her, as I should certainly have done once. We entered. Nanine had
already opened the door.
“Has Prudence come?” said Marguerite.
“Say that she is to be admitted as soon as she comes. But first put
out the lamp in the drawing-room, and if any one comes, say that I have
not come back and shall not be coming back.”
She was like a woman who is preoccupied with something, and perhaps
annoyed by an unwelcome guest. I did not know what to do or say.
Marguerite went toward her bedroom; I remained where I was.
“Come,” she said.
She took off her hat and her velvet cloak and threw them on the bed,
then let herself drop into a great armchair beside the fire, which she
kept till the very beginning of summer, and said to me as she fingered
“Well, what news have you got for me?”
“None, except that I ought not to have come to-night.”
“Because you seem vexed, and no doubt I am boring you.”
“You are not boring me; only I am not well; I have been suffering
all day. I could not sleep, and I have a frightful headache.”
“Shall I go away and let you go to bed?”
“Oh, you can stay. If I want to go to bed I don't mind your being
At that moment there was a ring.
“Who is coming now?” she said, with an impatient movement.
A few minutes after there was another ring.
“Isn't there any one to go to the door? I shall have to go.” She got
up and said to me, “Wait here.”
She went through the rooms, and I heard her open the outer door. I
The person whom she had admitted did not come farther than the
dining-room. At the first word I recognised the voice of the young
Comte de N.
“How are you this evening?” he said.
“Not well,” replied Marguerite drily.
“Am I disturbing you?”
“How you receive me! What have I done, my dear Marguerite?”
“My dear friend, you have done nothing. I am ill; I must go to bed,
so you will be good enough to go. It is sickening not to be able to
return at night without your making your appearance five minutes
afterward. What is it you want? For me to be your mistress? Well, I
have already told you a hundred times, No; you simply worry me, and you
might as well go somewhere else. I repeat to you to-day, for the last
time, I don't want to have anything to do with you; that's settled.
Good-bye. Here's Nanine coming in; she can light you to the door.
Without adding another word, or listening to what the young man
stammered out, Marguerite returned to the room and slammed the door.
Nanine entered a moment after.
“Now understand,” said Marguerite, “you are always to say to that
idiot that I am not in, or that I will not see him. I am tired out with
seeing people who always want the same thing; who pay me for it, and
then think they are quit of me. If those who are going to go in for our
hateful business only knew what it really was they would sooner be
chambermaids. But no, vanity, the desire of having dresses and
carriages and diamonds carries us away; one believes what one hears,
for here, as elsewhere, there is such a thing as belief, and one uses
up one's heart, one's body, one's beauty, little by little; one is
feared like a beast of prey, scorned like a pariah, surrounded by
people who always take more than they give; and one fine day one dies
like a dog in a ditch, after having ruined others and ruined one's
“Come, come, madame, be calm,” said Nanine; “your nerves are a bit
“This dress worries me,” continued Marguerite, unhooking her bodice;
“give me a dressing-gown. Well, and Prudence?”
“She has not come yet, but I will send her to you, madame, the
moment she comes.”
“There's one, now,” Marguerite went on, as she took off her dress
and put on a white dressing-gown, “there's one who knows very well how
to find me when she is in want of me, and yet she can't do me a service
decently. She knows I am waiting for an answer. She knows how anxious I
am, and I am sure she is going about on her own account, without giving
a thought to me.”
“Perhaps she had to wait.”
“Let us have some punch.”
“It will do you no good, madame,” said Nanine.
“So much the better. Bring some fruit, too, and a pate or a wing of
chicken; something or other, at once. I am hungry.”
Need I tell you the impression which this scene made upon me, or can
you not imagine it?
“You are going to have supper with me,” she said to me; “meanwhile,
take a book. I am going into my dressing-room for a moment.”
She lit the candles of a candelabra, opened a door at the foot of
the bed, and disappeared.
I began to think over this poor girl's life, and my love for her was
mingled with a great pity. I walked to and fro in the room, thinking
over things, when Prudence entered.
“Ah, you here?”' she said, “where is Marguerite?”
“In her dressing-room.”
“I will wait. By the way, do you know she thinks you charming?”
“She hasn't told you?”
“Not at all.”
“How are you here?”
“I have come to pay her a visit.”
“She has received me, as a matter of fact, very badly.”
“She will receive you better by and bye.”
“Do you think so?”
“I have some good news for her.”
“No harm in that. So she has spoken to you about me?”
“Last night, or rather to-night, when you and your friend went. By
the way, what is your friend called? Gaston R., his name is, isn't it?”
“Yes,” said I, not without smiling, as I thought of what Gaston had
confided to me, and saw that Prudence scarcely even knew his name.
“He is quite nice, that fellow; what does he do?”
“He has twenty-five thousand francs a year.”
“Ah, indeed! Well, to return to you. Marguerite asked me all about
you: who you were, what you did, what mistresses you had had; in short,
everything that one could ask about a man of your age. I told her all I
knew, and added that you were a charming young man. That's all.”
“Thanks. Now tell me what it was she wanted to say to you last
“Nothing at all. It was only to get rid of the count; but I have
really something to see her about to-day, and I am bringing her an
At this moment Marguerite reappeared from her dressing-room, wearing
a coquettish little nightcap with bunches of yellow ribbons,
technically known as “cabbages.” She looked ravishing. She had satin
slippers on her bare feet, and was in the act of polishing her nails.
“Well,” she said, seeing Prudence, “have you seen the duke?”
“And what did he say to you?”
“He gave me—”
“Have you got it?”
“Did he seem put out?”
This “Poor man!” was said in a tone impossible to render. Marguerite
took the six notes of a thousand francs.
“It was quite time,” she said. “My dear Prudence, are you in want of
“You know, my child, it is the 15th in a couple of days, so if you
could lend me three or four hundred francs, you would do me a real
“Send over to-morrow; it is too late to get change now.”
“No fear. Will you have supper with us?”
“No, Charles is waiting for me.”
“You are still devoted to him?”
“Crazy, my dear! I will see you to-morrow. Good-bye, Armand.”
Mme. Duvernoy went out.
Marguerite opened the drawer of a side-table and threw the
bank-notes into it.
“Will you permit me to get into bed?” she said with a smile, as she
moved toward the bed.
“Not only permit, but I beg of you.”
She turned back the covering and got into bed.
“Now,” said she, “come and sit down by me, and let's have a talk.”
Prudence was right: the answer that she had brought to Marguerite
had put her into a good humour.
“Will you forgive me for my bad temper tonight?” she said, taking my
“I am ready to forgive you as often as you like.”
“And you love me?”
“In spite of my bad disposition?”
“In spite of all.”
“You swear it?”
“Yes,” I said in a whisper.
Nanine entered, carrying plates, a cold chicken, a bottle of claret,
and some strawberries.
“I haven't had any punch made,” said Nanine; “claret is better for
you. Isn't it, sir?”
“Certainly,” I replied, still under the excitement of Marguerite's
last words, my eyes fixed ardently upon her.
“Good,” said she; “put it all on the little table, and draw it up to
the bed; we will help ourselves. This is the third night you have sat
up, and you must be in want of sleep. Go to bed. I don't want anything
“Shall I lock the door?”
“I should think so! And above all, tell them not to admit anybody
At five o'clock in the morning, as the light began to appear through
the curtains, Marguerite said to me: “Forgive me if I send you away;
but I must. The duke comes every morning; they will tell him, when he
comes, that I am asleep, and perhaps he will wait until I wake.”
I took Marguerite's head in my hands; her loosened hair streamed
about her; I gave her a last kiss, saying: “When shall I see you
“Listen,” she said; “take the little gilt key on the mantelpiece,
open that door; bring me back the key and go. In the course of the day
you shall have a letter, and my orders, for you know you are to obey
“Yes; but if I should already ask for something?”
“Let me have that key.”
“What you ask is a thing I have never done for any one.”
“Well, do it for me, for I swear to you that I don't love you as the
others have loved you.”
“Well, keep it; but it only depends on me to make it useless to you,
“There are bolts on the door.”
“I will have them taken off.”
“You love, then, a little?”
“I don't know how it is, but it seems to me as if I do! Now, go; I
can't keep my eyes open.”
I held her in my arms for a few seconds and then went.
The streets were empty, the great city was still asleep, a sweet
freshness circulated in the streets that a few hours later would be
filled with the noise of men. It seemed to me as if this sleeping city
belonged to me; I searched my memory for the names of those whose
happiness I had once envied; and I could not recall one without finding
myself the happier.
To be loved by a pure young girl, to be the first to reveal to her
the strange mystery of love, is indeed a great happiness, but it is the
simplest thing in the world. To take captive a heart which has had no
experience of attack, is to enter an unfortified and ungarrisoned city.
Education, family feeling, the sense of duty, the family, are strong
sentinels, but there are no sentinels so vigilant as not to be deceived
by a girl of sixteen to whom nature, by the voice of the man she loves,
gives the first counsels of love, all the more ardent because they seem
The more a girl believes in goodness, the more easily will she give
way, if not to her lover, at least to love, for being without mistrust
she is without force, and to win her love is a triumph that can be
gained by any young man of five-and-twenty. See how young girls are
watched and guarded! The walls of convents are not high enough, mothers
have no locks strong enough, religion has no duties constant enough, to
shut these charming birds in their cages, cages not even strewn with
flowers. Then how surely must they desire the world which is hidden
from them, how surely must they find it tempting, how surely must they
listen to the first voice which comes to tell its secrets through their
bars, and bless the hand which is the first to raise a corner of the
But to be really loved by a courtesan: that is a victory of
infinitely greater difficulty. With them the body has worn out the
soul, the senses have burned up the heart, dissipation has blunted the
feelings. They have long known the words that we say to them, the means
we use; they have sold the love that they inspire. They love by
profession, and not by instinct. They are guarded better by their
calculations than a virgin by her mother and her convent; and they have
invented the word caprice for that unbartered love which they allow
themselves from time to time, for a rest, for an excuse, for a
consolation, like usurers, who cheat a thousand, and think they have
bought their own redemption by once lending a sovereign to a poor devil
who is dying of hunger without asking for interest or a receipt.
Then, when God allows love to a courtesan, that love, which at first
seems like a pardon, becomes for her almost without penitence. When a
creature who has all her past to reproach herself with is taken all at
once by a profound, sincere, irresistible love, of which she had never
felt herself capable; when she has confessed her love, how absolutely
the man whom she loves dominates her! How strong he feels with his
cruel right to say: You do no more for love than you have done for
money. They know not what proof to give. A child, says the fable,
having often amused himself by crying “Help! a wolf!” in order to
disturb the labourers in the field, was one day devoured by a Wolf,
because those whom he had so often deceived no longer believed in his
cries for help. It is the same with these unhappy women when they love
seriously. They have lied so often that no one will believe them, and
in the midst of their remorse they are devoured by their love.
Hence those great devotions, those austere retreats from the world,
of which some of them have given an example.
But when the man who inspires this redeeming love is great enough in
soul to receive it without remembering the past, when he gives himself
up to it, when, in short, he loves as he is loved, this man drains at
one draught all earthly emotions, and after such a love his heart will
be closed to every other.
I did not make these reflections on the morning when I returned
home. They could but have been the presentiment of what was to happen
to me, and, despite my love for Marguerite, I did not foresee such
consequences. I make these reflections to-day. Now that all is
irrevocably ended, they a rise naturally out of what has taken place.
But to return to the first day of my liaison. When I reached home I
was in a state of mad gaiety. As I thought of how the barriers which my
imagination had placed between Marguerite and myself had disappeared,
of how she was now mine; of the place I now had in her thoughts, of the
key to her room which I had in my pocket, and of my right to use this
key, I was satisfied with life, proud of myself, and I loved God
because he had let such things be.
One day a young man is passing in the street, he brushes against a
woman, looks at her, turns, goes on his way. He does not know the
woman, and she has pleasures, griefs, loves, in which he has no part.
He does not exist for her, and perhaps, if he spoke to her, she would
only laugh at him, as Marguerite had laughed at me. Weeks, months,
years pass, and all at once, when they have each followed their fate
along a different path, the logic of chance brings them face to face.
The woman becomes the man's mistress and loves him. How? why? Their two
existences are henceforth one; they have scarcely begun to know one
another when it seems as if they had known one another always, and all
that had gone before is wiped out from the memory of the two lovers. It
is curious, one must admit.
As for me, I no longer remembered how I had lived before that night.
My whole being was exalted into joy at the memory of the words we had
exchanged during that first night. Either Marguerite was very clever in
deception, or she had conceived for me one of those sudden passions
which are revealed in the first kiss, and which die, often enough, as
suddenly as they were born.
The more I reflected the more I said to myself that Marguerite had
no reason for feigning a love which she did not feel, and I said to
myself also that women have two ways of loving, one of which may arise
from the other: they love with the heart or with the senses. Often a
woman takes a lover in obedience to the mere will of the senses, and
learns without expecting it the mystery of immaterial love, and lives
henceforth only through her heart; often a girl who has sought in
marriage only the union of two pure affections receives the sudden
revelation of physical love, that energetic conclusion of the purest
impressions of the soul.
In the midst of these thoughts I fell asleep; I was awakened by a
letter from Marguerite containing these words:
“Here are my orders: To-night at the Vaudeville.
“Come during the third entr'acte.”
I put the letter into a drawer, so that I might always have it at
band in case I doubted its reality, as I did from time to time.
She did not tell me to come to see her during the day, and I dared
not go; but I had so great a desire to see her before the evening that
I went to the Champs-Elysees, where I again saw her pass and repass, as
I had on the previous day.
At seven o'clock I was at the Vaudeville. Never had I gone to a
theatre so early. The boxes filled one after another. Only one remained
empty, the stage box. At the beginning of the third act I heard the
door of the box, on which my eyes had been almost constantly fixed,
open, and Marguerite appeared. She came to the front at once, looked
around the stalls, saw me, and thanked me with a look.
That night she was marvellously beautiful. Was I the cause of this
coquetry? Did she love me enough to believe that the more beautiful she
looked the happier I should be? I did not know, but if that had been
her intention she certainly succeeded, for when she appeared all heads
turned, and the actor who was then on the stage looked to see who had
produced such an effect on the audience by her mere presence there.
And I had the key of this woman's room, and in three or four hours
she would again be mine!
People blame those who let themselves be ruined by actresses and
kept women; what astonishes me is that twenty times greater follies are
not committed for them. One must have lived that life, as I have, to
know how much the little vanities which they afford their lovers every
day help to fasten deeper into the heart, since we have no other word
for it, the love which he has for them.
Prudence next took her place in the box, and a man, whom I
recognised as the Comte de G., seated himself at the back. As I saw
him, a cold shiver went through my heart.
Doubtless Marguerite perceived the impression made on me by the
presence of this man, for she smiled to me again, and, turning her back
to the count, appeared to be very attentive to the play. At the third
entr'acte she turned and said two words: the count left the box, and
Marguerite beckoned to me to come to her.
“Good-evening,” she said as I entered, holding out her hand.
“Good-evening,” I replied to both Marguerite and Prudence.
“But I am taking some one's place. Isn't the Comte de G. coming
“Yes; I sent him to fetch some sweets, so that we could talk by
ourselves for a moment. Mme. Duvernoy is in the secret.”
“Yes, my children,” said she; “have no fear. I shall say nothing.”
“What is the matter with you to-night?” said Marguerite, rising and
coming to the back of the box and kissing me on the forehead.
“I am not very well.”
“You should go to bed,” she replied, with that ironical air which
went so well with her delicate and witty face.
“You know that I shouldn't be able to sleep there.”
“Well, then, it won't do for you to come and be pettish here because
you have seen a man in my box.”
“It is not for that reason.”
“Yes, it is. I know; and you are wrong, so let us say no more about
it. You will go back with Prudence after the theatre, and you will stay
there till I call. Do you understand?”
How could I disobey?
“You still love me?”
“Can you ask?”
“You have thought of me?”
“All day long.”
“Do you know that I am really afraid that I shall get very fond of
you? Ask Prudence.”
“Ah,” said she, “it is amazing!”
“Now, you must go back to your seat. The count will be coming back,
and there is nothing to be gained by his finding you here.”
“Because you don't like seeing him.”
“No; only if you had told me that you wanted to come to the
Vaudeville to-night I could have got this box for you as well as he.”
“Unfortunately, he got it for me without my asking him, and he asked
me to go with him; you know well enough that I couldn't refuse. All I
could do was to write and tell you where I was going, so that you could
see me, and because I wanted to see you myself; but since this is the
way you thank me, I shall profit by the lesson.”
“I was wrong; forgive me.”
“Well and good; and now go back nicely to your place, and, above
all, no more jealousy.”
She kissed me again, and I left the box. In the passage I met the
count coming back. I returned to my seat.
After all, the presence of M. de G. in Marguerite's box was the most
natural thing in the world. He had been her lover, he sent her a box,
he accompanied her to the theatre; it was all quite natural, and if I
was to have a mistress like Marguerite I should have to get used to her
Nonetheless, I was very unhappy all the rest of the evening, and
went away very sadly after having seen Prudence, the count, and
Marguerite get into the carriage, which was waiting for them at the
However, a quarter of an hour later I was at Prudence's. She had
only just got in.
“You have come almost as quickly as we,” said Prudence.
“Yes,” I answered mechanically. “Where is Marguerite?”
“With M. de G.”
I walked to and fro in the room.
“Well, what is the matter?”
“Do you think it amuses me to wait here till M. de G. leaves
“How unreasonable you are! Don't you see that Marguerite can't turn
the count out of doors? M. de G. has been with her for a long time; he
has always given her a lot of money; he still does. Marguerite spends
more than a hundred thousand francs a year; she has heaps of debts. The
duke gives her all that she asks for, but she does not always venture
to ask him for all that she is in want of. It would never do for her to
quarrel with the count, who is worth to her at least ten thousand
francs a year. Marguerite is very fond of you, my dear fellow, but your
liaison with her, in her interests and in yours, ought not to be
serious. You with your seven or eight thousand francs a year, what
could you do toward supplying all the luxuries which a girl like that
is in need of? It would not be enough to keep her carriage. Take
Marguerite for what she is, for a good, bright, pretty girl; be her
lover for a month, two months; give her flowers, sweets, boxes at the
theatre; but don't get any other ideas into your head, and don't make
absurd scenes of jealousy. You know whom you have to do with;
Marguerite isn't a saint. She likes you, you are very fond of her; let
the rest alone. You amaze me when I see you so touchy; you have the
most charming mistress in Paris. She receives you in the greatest
style, she is covered with diamonds, she needn't cost you a penny,
unless you like, and you are not satisfied. My dear fellow, you ask too
“You are right, but I can't help it; the idea that that man is her
lover hurts me horribly.”
“In the first place,” replied Prudence; “is he still her lover? He
is a man who is useful to her, nothing more. She has closed her doors
to him for two days; he came this morning—she could not but accept the
box and let him accompany her. He saw her home; he has gone in for a
moment, he is not staying, because you are waiting here. All that, it
seems to me, is quite natural. Besides, you don't mind the duke.”
“Yes; but he is an old man, and I am sure that Marguerite is not his
mistress. Then, it is all very well to accept one liaison, but not two.
Such easiness in the matter is very like calculation, and puts the man
who consents to it, even out of love, very much in the category of
those who, in a lower stage of society, make a trade of their
connivance, and a profit of their trade.”
“Ah, my dear fellow, how old-fashioned you are! How many of the
richest and most fashionable men of the best families I have seen quite
ready to do what I advise you to do, and without an effort, without
shame, without remorse, Why, one sees it every day. How do you suppose
the kept women in Paris could live in the style they do, if they had
not three or four lovers at once? No single fortune, however large,
could suffice for the expenses of a woman like Marguerite. A fortune of
five hundred thousand francs a year is, in France, an enormous fortune;
well, my dear friend, five hundred thousand francs a year would still
be too little, and for this reason: a man with such an income has a
large house, horses, servants, carriages; he shoots, has friends, often
he is married, he has children, he races, gambles, travels, and what
not. All these habits are so much a part of his position that he can
not forego them without appearing to have lost all his money, and
without causing scandal. Taking it all round, with five hundred
thousand francs a year he can not give a woman more than forty or fifty
thousand francs in the year, and that is already a good deal. Well,
other lovers make up for the rest of her expenses. With Marguerite, it
is still more convenient; she has chanced by a miracle on an old man
worth ten millions, whose wife and daughter are dead; who has only some
nephews, themselves rich, and who gives her all she wants without
asking anything in return. But she can not ask him for more than
seventy thousand francs a year; and I am sure that if she did ask for
more, despite his health and the affection he has for her he would not
give it to her.
“All the young men of twenty or thirty thousand francs a year at
Paris, that is to say, men who have only just enough to live on in the
society in which they mix, know perfectly well, when they are the
lovers of a woman like Marguerite, that she could not so much as pay
for the rooms she lives in and the servants who wait upon her with what
they give her. They do not say to her that they know it; they pretend
not to see anything, and when they have had enough of it they go their
way. If they have the vanity to wish to pay for everything they get
ruined, like the fools they are, and go and get killed in Africa, after
leaving a hundred thousand francs of debt in Paris. Do you think a
woman is grateful to them for it? Far from it. She declares that she
has sacrificed her position for them, and that while she was with them
she was losing money. These details seem to you shocking? Well, they
are true. You are a very nice fellow; I like you very much. I have
lived with these women for twenty years; I know what they are worth,
and I don't want to see you take the caprice that a pretty girl has for
you too seriously.
“Then, besides that,” continued Prudence; “admit that Marguerite
loves you enough to give up the count or the duke, in case one of them
were to discover your liaison and to tell her to choose between him and
you, the sacrifice that she would make for you would be enormous, you
can not deny it. What equal sacrifice could you make for her, on your
part, and when you had got tired of her, what could you do to make up
for what you had taken from her? Nothing. You would have cut her off
from the world in which her fortune and her future were to be found;
she would have given you her best years, and she would be forgotten.
Either you would be an ordinary man, and, casting her past in her
teeth, you would leave her, telling her that you were only doing like
her other lovers, and you would abandon her to certain misery; or you
would be an honest man, and, feeling bound to keep her by you, you
would bring inevitable trouble upon yourself, for a liaison which is
excusable in a young man, is no longer excusable in a man of middle
age. It becomes an obstacle to every thing; it allows neither family
nor ambition, man's second and last loves. Believe me, then, my friend,
take things for what they are worth, and do not give a kept woman the
right to call herself your creditor, no matter in what.”
It was well argued, with a logic of which I should have thought
Prudence incapable. I had nothing to reply, except that she was right;
I took her hand and thanked her for her counsels.
“Come, come,” said she, “put these foolish theories to flight, and
laugh over them. Life is pleasant, my dear fellow; it all depends on
the colour of the glass through which one sees it. Ask your friend
Gaston; there's a man who seems to me to understand love as I
understand it. All that you need think of, unless you are quite a fool,
is that close by there is a beautiful girl who is waiting impatiently
for the man who is with her to go, thinking of you, keeping the whole
night for you, and who loves you, I am certain. Now, come to the window
with me, and let us watch for the count to go; he won't be long in
leaving the coast clear.”
Prudence opened the window, and we leaned side by side over the
balcony. She watched the few passers, I reflected. All that she had
said buzzed in my head, and I could not help feeling that she was
right; but the genuine love which I had for Marguerite had some
difficulty in accommodating itself to such a belief. I sighed from time
to time, at which Prudence turned, and shrugged her shoulders like a
physician who has given up his patient.
“How one realizes the shortness of life,” I said to myself, “by the
rapidity of sensations! I have only known Marguerite for two days, she
has only been my mistress since yesterday, and she has already so
completely absorbed my thoughts, my heart, and my life that the visit
of the Comte de G. is a misfortune for me.”
At last the count came out, got into his carriage and disappeared.
Prudence closed the window. At the same instant Marguerite called to
“Come at once,” she said; “they are laying the table, and we'll have
When I entered, Marguerite ran to me, threw her arms around my neck
and kissed me with all her might.
“Are we still sulky?” she said to me.
“No, it is all over,” replied Prudence. “I have given him a talking
to, and he has promised to be reasonable.”
“Well and good.”
In spite of myself I glanced at the bed; it was not unmade. As for
Marguerite, she was already in her white dressing-gown. We sat down to
Charm, sweetness, spontaneity, Marguerite had them all, and I was
forced from time to time to admit that I had no right to ask of her
anything else; that many people would be very happy to be in my place;
and that, like Virgil's shepherd, I had only to enjoy the pleasures
that a god, or rather a goddess, set before me.
I tried to put in practice the theories of Prudence, and to be as
gay as my two companions; but what was natural in them was on my part
an effort, and the nervous laughter, whose source they did not detect,
was nearer to tears than to mirth.
At last the supper was over and I was alone with Marguerite. She sat
down as usual on the hearthrug before the fire and gazed sadly into the
flames. What was she thinking of? I know not. As for me, I looked at
her with a mingling of love and terror, as I thought of all that I was
ready to suffer for her sake.
“Do you know what I am thinking of?”
“Of a plan that has come into my head.”
“And what is this plan?”
“I can't tell you yet, but I can tell you what the result would be.
The result would be that in a month I should be free, I should have no
more debts, and we could go and spend the summer in the country.”
“And you can't tell me by what means?”
“No, only love me as I love you, and all will succeed.”
“And have you made this plan all by yourself?”
“Yes. “And you will carry it out all by yourself?”
“I alone shall have the trouble of it,” said Marguerite, with a
smile which I shall never forget, “but we shall both partake its
I could not help flushing at the word benefits; I thought of Manon
Lescaut squandering with Desgrieux the money of M. de B.
I replied in a hard voice, rising from my seat:
“You must permit me, my dear Marguerite, to share only the benefits
of those enterprises which I have conceived and carried out myself.”
“What does that mean?”
“It means that I have a strong suspicion that M. de G. is to be your
associate in this pretty plan, of which I can accept neither the cost
nor the benefits
“What a child you are! I thought you loved me. I was mistaken; all
She rose, opened the piano and began to play the Invitation a la
Valse, as far as the famous passage in the major which always stopped
her. Was it through force of habit, or was it to remind me of the day
when we first met? All I know is that the melody brought back that
recollection, and, coming up to her, I took her head between my hands
and kissed her. “You forgive me?” I said.
“You see I do,” she answered; “but observe that we are only at our
second day, and already I have had to forgive you something. Is this
how you keep your promise of blind obedience?”
“What can I do, Marguerite? I love you too much and I am jealous of
the least of your thoughts. What you proposed to me just now made me
frantic with delight, but the mystery in its carrying out hurts me
“Come, let us reason it out,” she said, taking both my hands and
looking at me with a charming smile which it was impossible to resist,
“You love me, do you not? and you would gladly spend two or three
months alone with me in the country? I too should be glad of this
solitude a deux, and not only glad of it, but my health requires it. I
can not leave Paris for such a length of time without putting my
affairs in order, and the affairs of a woman like me are always in
great confusion; well, I have found a way to reconcile everything, my
money affairs and my love for you; yes, for you, don't laugh; I am
silly enough to love you! And here you are taking lordly airs and
talking big words. Child, thrice child, only remember that I love you,
and don't let anything disturb you. Now, is it agreed?”
“I agree to all you wish, as you know.”
“Then, in less than a month's time we shall be in some village,
walking by the river side, and drinking milk. Does it seem strange that
Marguerite Gautier should speak to you like that? The fact is, my
friend, that when this Paris life, which seems to make me so happy,
doesn't burn me, it wearies me, and then I have sudden aspirations
toward a calmer existence which might recall my childhood. One has
always had a childhood, whatever one becomes. Don't be alarmed; I am
not going to tell you that I am the daughter of a colonel on half-pay,
and that I was brought up at Saint-Denis. I am a poor country girl, and
six years ago I could not write my own name. You are relieved, aren't
you? Why is it you are the first whom I have ever asked to share the
joy of this desire of mine? I suppose because I feel that you love me
for myself and not for yourself, while all the others have only loved
me for themselves.
“I have often been in the country, but never as I should like to go
there. I count on you for this easy happiness; do not be unkind, let me
have it. Say this to yourself: 'She will never live to be old, and I
should some day be sorry for not having done for her the first thing
she asked of me, such an easy thing to do!'“
What could I reply to such words, especially with the memory of a
first night of love, and in the expectation of a second?
An hour later I held Marguerite in my arms, and, if she had asked me
to commit a crime, I would have obeyed her.
At six in the morning I left her, and before leaving her I said:
“Till to-night!” She kissed me more warmly than ever, but said nothing.
During the day I received a note containing these words:
“DEAR CHILD: I am not very well, and the doctor has ordered quiet. I
shall go to bed early to-night and shall not see you. But, to make up,
I shall expect you to-morrow at twelve. I love you.”
My first thought was: She is deceiving me!
A cold sweat broke out on my forehead, for I already loved this
woman too much not to be overwhelmed by the suspicion. And yet, I was
bound to expect such a thing almost any day with Marguerite, and it had
happened to me often enough with my other mistresses, without my taking
much notice of it. What was the meaning of the hold which this woman
had taken upon my life?
Then it occurred to me, since I had the key, to go and see her as
usual. In this way I should soon know the truth, and if I found a man
there I would strike him in the face.
Meanwhile I went to the Champs-Elysees. I waited there four hours.
She did not appear. At night I went into all the theatres where she was
accustomed to go. She was in none of them.
At eleven o'clock I went to the Rue d'Antin. There was no light in
Marguerite's windows. All the same, I rang. The porter asked me where I
“To Mlle. Gautier's,” I said.
“She has not come in.”
“I will go up and wait for her.”
“There is no one there.”
Evidently I could get in, since I had the key, but, fearing foolish
scandal, I went away. Only I did not return home; I could not leave the
street, and I never took my eyes off Marguerite's house. It seemed to
me that there was still something to be found out, or at least that my
suspicions were about to be confirmed.
About midnight a carriage that I knew well stopped before No. 9. The
Comte de G. got down and entered the house, after sending away the
carriage. For a moment I hoped that the same answer would be given to
him as to me, and that I should see him come out; but at four o'clock
in the morning I was still awaiting him.
I have suffered deeply during these last three weeks, but that is
nothing, I think, in comparison with what I suffered that night.
When I reached home I began to cry like a child. There is no man to
whom a woman has not been unfaithful, once at least, and who will not
know what I suffered.
I said to myself, under the weight of these feverish resolutions
which one always feels as if one had the force to carry out, that I
must break with my amour at once, and I waited impatiently for daylight
in order to set out forthwith to rejoin my father and my sister, of
whose love at least I was certain, and certain that that love would
never be betrayed.
However, I did not wish to go away without letting Marguerite know
why I went. Only a man who really cares no more for his mistress leaves
her without writing to her. I made and remade twenty letters in my
head. I had had to do with a woman like all other women of the kind. I
had been poetizing too much. She had treated me like a school-boy, she
had used in deceiving me a trick which was insultingly simple. My
self-esteem got the upper hand. I must leave this woman without giving
her the satisfaction of knowing that she had made me suffer, and this
is what I wrote to her in my most elegant handwriting and with tears of
rage and sorrow in my eyes:
“MY DEAR MARGUERITE: I hope that your indisposition yesterday was
not serious. I came, at eleven at night, to ask after you, and was told
that you had not come in. M. de G. was more fortunate, for he presented
himself shortly afterward, and at four in the morning he had not left.
“Forgive me for the few tedious hours that I have given you, and be
assured that I shall never forget the happy moments which I owe to you.
“I should have called to-day to ask after you, but I intend going
back to my father's.
“Good-bye, my dear Marguerite. I am not rich enough to love you as I
would nor poor enough to love you as you would. Let us then forget, you
a name which must be indifferent enough to you, I a happiness which has
“I send back your key, which I have never used, and which might be
useful to you, if you are often ill as you were yesterday.”
As you will see, I was unable to end my letter without a touch of
impertinent irony, which proved how much in love I still was.
I read and reread this letter ten times over; then the thought of
the pain it would give to Marguerite calmed me a little. I tried to
persuade myself of the feelings which it professed; and when my servant
came to my room at eight o'clock, I gave it to him and told him to take
it at once.
“Shall I wait for an answer?” asked Joseph (my servant, like all
servants, was called Joseph).
“If they ask whether there is a reply, you will say that you don't
know, and wait.”
I buoyed myself up with the hope that she would reply. Poor, feeble
creatures that we are! All the time that my servant was away I was in a
state of extreme agitation. At one moment I would recall how Marguerite
had given herself to me, and ask myself by what right I wrote her an
impertinent letter, when she could reply that it was not M. de G. who
supplanted me, but I who had supplanted M. de G.: a mode of reasoning
which permits many women to have many lovers. At another moment I would
recall her promises, and endeavour to convince myself that my letter
was only too gentle, and that there were not expressions forcible
enough to punish a woman who laughed at a love like mine. Then I said
to myself that I should have done better not to have written to her,
but to have gone to see her, and that then I should have had the
pleasure of seeing the tears that she would shed. Finally, I asked
myself what she would reply to me; already prepared to believe whatever
excuse she made.
“Well?” I said to him.
“Sir,” said he, “madame was not up, and still asleep, but as soon as
she rings the letter will be taken to her, and if there is any reply it
will be sent.”
She was asleep!
Twenty times I was on the point of sending to get the letter back,
but every time I said to myself: “Perhaps she will have got it already,
and it would look as if I have repented of sending it.”
As the hour at which it seemed likely that she would reply came
nearer, I regretted more and more that I had written. The clock struck,
ten, eleven, twelve. At twelve I was on the point of keeping the
appointment as if nothing had happened. In the end I could see no way
out of the circle of fire which closed upon me.
Then I began to believe, with the superstition which people have
when they are waiting, that if I went out for a little while, I should
find an answer when I got back. I went out under the pretext of going
Instead of lunching at the Cafe Foy, at the corner of the Boulevard,
as I usually did, I preferred to go to the Palais Royal and so pass
through the Rue d'Antin. Every time that I saw a woman at a distance, I
fancied it was Nanine bringing me an answer. I passed through the Rue
d'Antin without even coming across a commissionaire. I went to Very's
in the Palais Royal. The waiter gave me something to eat, or rather
served up to me whatever he liked, for I ate nothing. In spite of
myself, my eyes were constantly fixed on the clock. I returned home,
certain that I should find a letter from Marguerite.
The porter had received nothing, but I still hoped in my servant. He
had seen no one since I went out.
If Marguerite had been going to answer me she would have answered
Then I began to regret the terms of my letter; I should have said
absolutely nothing, and that would undoubtedly have aroused her
suspicions, for, finding that I did not keep my appointment, she would
have inquired the reason of my absence, and only then I should have
given it to her. Thus, she would have had to exculpate herself, and
what I wanted was for her to exculpate herself. I already realized that
I should have believed whatever reasons she had given me, and anything
was better than not to see her again.
At last I began to believe that she would come to see me herself;
but hour followed hour, and she did not come.
Decidedly Marguerite was not like other women, for there are few who
would have received such a letter as I had just written without
answering it at all.
At five, I hastened to the Champs-Elysees. “If I meet her,” I
thought, “I will put on an indifferent air, and she will be convinced
that I no longer think about her.”
As I turned the corner of the Rue Royale, I saw her pass in her
carriage. The meeting was so sudden that I turned pale. I do not know
if she saw my emotion; as for me, I was so agitated that I saw nothing
but the carriage.
I did not go any farther in the direction of the Champs-Elysees. I
looked at the advertisements of the theatres, for I had still a chance
of seeing her. There was a first night at the Palais Royal. Marguerite
was sure to be there. I was at the theatre by seven. The boxes filled
one after another, but Marguerite was not there. I left the Palais
Royal and went to all the theatres where she was most often to be seen:
to the Vaudeville, the Varietes, the Opera Comique. She was nowhere.
Either my letter had troubled her too much for her to care to go to
the theatre, or she feared to come across me, and so wished to avoid an
explanation. So my vanity was whispering to me on the boulevards, when
I met Gaston, who asked me where I had been.
“At the Palais Royal.”
“And I at the Opera,” said he; “I expected to see you there.”
“Because Marguerite was there.”
“Ah, she was there?”
“No; with another woman.”
“The Comte de G. came to her box for an instant; but she went off
with the duke. I expected to see you every moment, for there was a
stall at my side which remained empty the whole evening, and I was sure
you had taken it.”
“But why should I go where Marguerite goes?”
“Because you are her lover, surely!”
“Who told you that?”
“Prudence, whom I met yesterday. I give you my congratulations, my
dear fellow; she is a charming mistress, and it isn't everybody who has
the chance. Stick to her; she will do you credit.”
These simple reflections of Gaston showed me how absurd had been my
susceptibilities. If I had only met him the night before and he had
spoken to me like that, I should certainly not have written the foolish
letter which I had written.
I was on the point of calling on Prudence, and of sending her to
tell Marguerite that I wanted to speak to her; but I feared that she
would revenge herself on me by saying that she could not see me, and I
returned home, after passing through the Rue d'Antin. Again I asked my
porter if there was a letter for me. Nothing! She is waiting to see if
I shall take some fresh step, and if I retract my letter of to-day, I
said to myself as I went to bed; but, seeing that I do not write, she
will write to me to-morrow.
That night, more than ever, I reproached myself for what I had done.
I was alone, unable to sleep, devoured by restlessness and jealousy,
when by simply letting things take their natural course I should have
been with Marguerite, hearing the delicious words which I had heard
only twice, and which made my ears burn in my solitude.
The most frightful part of the situation was that my judgment was
against me; as a matter of fact, everything went to prove that
Marguerite loved me. First, her proposal to spend the summer with me in
the country, then the certainty that there was no reason why she should
be my mistress, since my income was insufficient for her needs and even
for her caprices. There could not then have been on her part anything
but the hope of finding in me a sincere affection, able to give her
rest from the mercenary loves in whose midst she lived; and on the very
second day I had destroyed this hope, and paid by impertinent irony for
the love which I had accepted during two nights. What I had done was
therefore not merely ridiculous, it was indelicate. I had not even paid
the woman, that I might have some right to find fault with her;
withdrawing after two days, was I not like a parasite of love, afraid
of having to pay the bill of the banquet? What! I had only known
Marguerite for thirty-six hours; I had been her lover for only
twenty-four; and instead of being too happy that she should grant me
all that she did, I wanted to have her all to myself, and to make her
sever at one stroke all her past relations which were the revenue of
her future. What had I to reproach in her? Nothing. She had written to
say she was unwell, when she might have said to me quite crudely, with
the hideous frankness of certain women, that she had to see a lover;
and, instead of believing her letter, instead of going to any street in
Paris except the Rue d'Antin, instead of spending the evening with my
friends, and presenting myself next day at the appointed hour, I was
acting the Othello, spying upon her, and thinking to punish her by
seeing her no more. But, on the contrary, she ought to be enchanted at
this separation. She ought to find me supremely foolish, and her
silence was not even that of rancour; it was contempt.
I might have made Marguerite a present which would leave no doubt as
to my generosity and permit me to feel properly quits of her, as of a
kept woman, but I should have felt that I was offending by the least
appearance of trafficking, if not the love which she had for me, at all
events the love which I had for her, and since this love was so pure
that it could admit no division, it could not pay by a present, however
generous, the happiness that it had received, however short that
happiness had been.
That is what I said to myself all night long, and what I was every
moment prepared to go and say to Marguerite. When the day dawned I was
still sleepless. I was in a fever. I could think of nothing but
As you can imagine, it was time to take a decided step, and finish
either with the woman or with one's scruples, if, that is, she would
still be willing to see me. But you know well, one is always slow in
taking a decided step; so, unable to remain within doors and not daring
to call on Marguerite, I made one attempt in her direction, an attempt
that I could always look upon as a mere chance if it succeeded.
It was nine o'clock, and I went at once to call upon Prudence, who
asked to what she owed this early visit. I dared not tell her frankly
what brought me. I replied that I had gone out early in order to
reserve a place in the diligence for C., where my father lived.
“You are fortunate,” she said, “in being able to get away from Paris
in this fine weather.”
I looked at Prudence, asking myself whether she was laughing at me,
but her face was quite serious.
“Shall you go and say good-bye to Marguerite?” she continued, as
seriously as before.
“You are quite right.”
“You think so?”
“Naturally. Since you have broken with her, why should you see her
“You know it is broken off?”
“She showed me your letter.”
“What did she say about it?”
“She said: 'My dear Prudence, your protege is not polite; one thinks
such letters, one does not write them.”'
“In what tone did she say that?”
“Laughingly, and she added: “He has had supper with me twice, and
hasn't even called.”'
That, then, was the effect produced by my letter and my jealousy. I
was cruelly humiliated in the vanity of my affection.
“What did she do last night?”
“She went to the opera.”
“I know. And afterward?”
“She had supper at home.”
“With the Comte de G., I believe.”
So my breaking with her had not changed one of her habits. It is for
such reasons as this that certain people say to you: Don't have
anything more to do with the woman; she cares nothing about you.
“Well, I am very glad to find that Marguerite does not put herself
out for me,” I said with a forced smile.
“She has very good reason not to. You have done what you were bound
to do. You have been more reasonable than she, for she was really in
love with you; she did nothing but talk of you. I don't know what she
would not have been capable of doing.”
“Why hasn't she answered me, if she was in love with me?”
“Because she realizes she was mistaken in letting herself love you.
Women sometimes allow you to be unfaithful to their love; they never
allow you to wound their self-esteem; and one always wounds the
self-esteem of a woman when, two days after one has become her lover,
one leaves her, no matter for what reason. I know Marguerite; she would
die sooner than reply.”
“What can I do, then?”
“Nothing. She will forget you, you will forget her, and neither will
have any reproach to make against the other.”
“But if I write and ask her forgiveness?”
“Don't do that, for she would forgive you.”
I could have flung my arms round Prudence's neck.
A quarter of an hour later I was once more in my own quarters, and I
wrote to Marguerite:
“Some one, who repents of a letter that he wrote yesterday and who
will leave Paris to-morrow if you do not forgive him, wishes to know at
what hour he might lay his repentance at your feet.
“When can he find you alone? for, you know, confessions must be made
I folded this kind of madrigal in prose, and sent it by Joseph, who
handed it to Marguerite herself; she replied that she would send the
I only went out to have a hasty dinner, and at eleven in the evening
no reply had come. I made up my mind to endure it no longer, and to set
out next day. In consequence of this resolution, and convinced that I
should not sleep if I went to bed, I began to pack up my things.
It was hardly an hour after Joseph and I had begun preparing for my
departure, when there was a violent ring at the door.
“Shall I go to the door?” said Joseph.
“Go,” I said, asking myself who it could be at such an hour, and not
daring to believe that it was Marguerite.
“Sir,” said Joseph coming back to me, “it is two ladies.”
“It is we, Armand,” cried a voice that I recognised as that of
I came out of my room. Prudence was standing looking around the
place; Marguerite, seated on the sofa, was meditating. I went to her,
knelt down, took her two hands, and, deeply moved, said to her,
She kissed me on the forehead, and said:
“This is the third time that I have forgiven you.”
“I should have gone away to-morrow.”
“How can my visit change your plans? I have not come to hinder you
from leaving Paris. I have come because I had no time to answer you
during the day, and I did not wish to let you think that I was angry
with you. Prudence didn't want me to come; she said that I might be in
“You in the way, Marguerite! But how?”
“Well, you might have had a woman here,” said Prudence, “and it
would hardly have been amusing for her to see two more arrive.”
During this remark Marguerite looked at me attentively.
“My dear Prudence,” I answered, “you do not know what you are
“What a nice place you've got!” Prudence went on. “May we see the
Prudence went into the bedroom, not so much to see it as to make up
for the foolish thing which she had just said, and to leave Marguerite
and me alone.
“Why did you bring Prudence?” I asked her.
“Because she was at the theatre with me, and because when I leave
here I want to have some one to see me home.”
“Could not I do?”
“Yes, but, besides not wishing to put you out, I was sure that if
you came as far as my door you would want to come up, and as I could
not let you, I did not wish to let you go away blaming me for saying
“And why could you not let me come up?”
“Because I am watched, and the least suspicion might do me the
“Is that really the only reason?”
“If there were any other, I would tell you; for we are not to have
any secrets from one another now.”
“Come, Marguerite, I am not going to take a roundabout way of saying
what I really want to say. Honestly, do you care for me a little?”
“A great deal.”
“Then why did you deceive me?”
“My friend, if I were the Duchess So and So, if I had two hundred
thousand francs a year, and if I were your mistress and had another
lover, you would have the right to ask me; but I am Mlle. Marguerite
Gautier, I am forty thousand francs in debt, I have not a penny of my
own, and I spend a hundred thousand francs a year. Your question
becomes unnecessary and my answer useless.”
“You are right,” I said, letting my head sink on her knees; “but I
love you madly.”
“Well, my friend, you must either love me a little less or
understand me a little better. Your letter gave me a great deal of
pain. If I had been free, first of all I would not have seen the count
the day before yesterday, or, if I had, I should have come and asked
your forgiveness as you ask me now, and in future I should have had no
other lover but you. I fancied for a moment that I might give myself
that happiness for six months; you would not have it; you insisted on
knowing the means. Well, good heavens, the means were easy enough to
guess! In employing them I was making a greater sacrifice for you than
you imagine. I might have said to you, 'I want twenty thousand francs';
you were in love with me and you would have found them, at the risk of
reproaching me for it later on. I preferred to owe you nothing; you did
not understand the scruple, for such it was. Those of us who are like
me, when we have any heart at all, we give a meaning and a development
to words and things unknown to other women; I repeat, then, that on the
part of Marguerite Gautier the means which she used to pay her debts
without asking you for the money necessary for it, was a scruple by
which you ought to profit, without saying anything. If you had only met
me to-day, you would be too delighted with what I promised you, and you
would not question me as to what I did the day before yesterday. We are
sometimes obliged to buy the satisfaction of our souls at the expense
of our bodies, and we suffer still more, when, afterward, that
satisfaction is denied us.”
I listened, and I gazed at Marguerite with admiration. When I
thought that this marvellous creature, whose feet I had once longed to
kiss, was willing to let me take my place in her thoughts, my part in
her life, and that I was not yet content with what she gave me, I asked
if man's desire has indeed limits when, satisfied as promptly as mine
had been, it reached after something further.
“Truly,” she continued, “we poor creatures of chance have fantastic
desires and inconceivable loves. We give ourselves now for one thing,
now for another. There are men who ruin themselves without obtaining
the least thing from us; there are others who obtain us for a bouquet
of flowers. Our hearts have their caprices; it is their one distraction
and their one excuse. I gave myself to you sooner than I ever did to
any man, I swear to you; and do you know why? Because when you saw me
spitting blood you took my hand; because you wept; because you are the
only human being who has ever pitied me. I am going to say a mad thing
to you: I once had a little dog who looked at me with a sad look when I
coughed; that is the only creature I ever loved. When he died I cried
more than when my mother died. It is true that for twelve years of her
life she used to beat me. Well, I loved you all at once, as much as my
dog. If men knew what they can have for a tear, they would be better
loved and we should be less ruinous to them.
“Your letter undeceived me; it showed me that you lacked the
intelligence of the heart; it did you more harm with me than anything
you could possibly have done. It was jealousy certainly, but ironical
and impertinent jealousy. I was already feeling sad when I received
your letter. I was looking forward to seeing you at twelve, to having
lunch with you, and wiping out, by seeing you, a thought which was with
me incessantly, and which, before I knew you, I had no difficulty in
“Then,” continued Marguerite, “you were the only person before whom
it seemed to me, from the first, that I could think and speak freely.
All those who come about women like me have an interest in calculating
their slightest words, in thinking of the consequences of their most
insignificant actions. Naturally we have no friends. We have selfish
lovers who spend their fortunes, riot on us, as they say, but on their
own vanity. For these people we have to be merry when they are merry,
well when they want to sup, sceptics like themselves. We are not
allowed to have hearts, under penalty of being hooted down and of
ruining our credit.
“We no longer belong to ourselves. We are no longer beings, but
things. We stand first in their self-esteem, last in their esteem. We
have women who call themselves our friends, but they are friends like
Prudence, women who were once kept and who have still the costly tastes
that their age does not allow them to gratify. Then they become our
friends, or rather our guests at table. Their friendship is carried to
the point of servility, never to that of disinterestedness. Never do
they give you advice which is not lucrative. It means little enough to
them that we should have ten lovers extra, as long as they get dresses
or a bracelet out of them, and that they can drive in our carriage from
time to time or come to our box at the theatre. They have our last
night's bouquets, and they borrow our shawls. They never render us a
service, however slight, without seeing that they are paid twice its
value. You yourself saw when Prudence brought me the six thousand
francs that I had asked her to get from the duke, how she borrowed five
hundred francs, which she will never pay me back, or which she will pay
me in hats, which will never be taken out of their boxes.
“We can not, then, have, or rather I can not have more than one
possible kind of happiness, and this is, sad as I sometimes am,
suffering as I always am, to find a man superior enough not to ask
questions about my life, and to be the lover of my impressions rather
than of my body. Such a man I found in the duke; but the duke is old,
and old age neither protects nor consoles. I thought I could accept the
life which he offered me; but what would you have? I was dying of
ennui, and if one is bound to be consumed, it is as well to throw
oneself into the flames as to be asphyxiated with charcoal.
“Then I met you, young, ardent, happy, and I tried to make you the
man I had longed for in my noisy solitude. What I loved in you was not
the man who was, but the man who was going to be. You do not accept the
position, you reject it as unworthy of you; you are an ordinary lover.
Do like the others; pay me, and say no more about it.”
Marguerite, tired out with this long confession, threw herself back
on the sofa, and to stifle a slight cough put up her handkerchief to
her lips, and from that to her eyes.
“Pardon, pardon,” I murmured. “I understood it all, but I wanted to
have it from your own lips, my beloved Marguerite. Forget the rest and
remember only one thing: that we belong to one another, that we are
young, and that we love. Marguerite, do with me as you will; I am your
slave, your dog, but in the name of heaven tear up the letter which I
wrote to you and do not make me leave you to-morrow; it would kill me.”
Marguerite drew the letter from her bosom, and handing it to me with
a smile of infinite sweetness, said:
“Here it is. I have brought it back.”
I tore the letter into fragments and kissed with tears the hand that
gave it to me.
At this moment Prudence reappeared.
“Look here, Prudence; do you know what he wants?” said Marguerite.
“He wants you to forgive him.”
“And you do?”
“One has to; but he wants more than that.”
“He wants to have supper with us.”
“And do you consent?”
“What do you think?”
“I think that you are two children who haven't an atom of sense
between you; but I also think that I am very hungry, and that the
sooner you consent the sooner we shall have supper.”
“Come,” said Marguerite, “there is room for the three of us in my
“By the way,” she added, turning to me, “Nanine will be gone to bed.
You must open the door; take my key, and try not to lose it again.”
I embraced Marguerite until she was almost stifled.
Thereupon Joseph entered.
“Sir,” he said, with the air of a man who is very well satisfied
with himself, “the luggage is packed.”
“All of it?”
“Well, then, unpack it again; I am not going.”
I might have told you of the beginning of this liaison in a few
lines, but I wanted you to see every step by which we came, I to agree
to whatever Marguerite wished, Marguerite to be unable to live apart
It was the day after the evening when she came to see me that I sent
her Manon Lescaut.
From that time, seeing that I could not change my mistress's life, I
changed my own. I wished above all not to leave myself time to think
over the position I had accepted, for, in spite of myself, it was a
great distress to me. Thus my life, generally so calm, assumed all at
once an appearance of noise and disorder. Never believe, however
disinterested the love of a kept woman may be, that it will cost one
nothing. Nothing is so expensive as their caprices, flowers, boxes at
the theatre, suppers, days in the country, which one can never refuse
to one's mistress.
As I have told you, I had little money. My father was, and still is,
receveur general at C. He has a great reputation there for loyalty,
thanks to which he was able to find the security which he needed in
order to attain this position.
It is worth forty thousand francs a year, and during the ten years
that he has had it, he has paid off the security and put aside a dowry
for my sister. My father is the most honourable man in the world. When
my mother died, she left six thousand francs a year, which he divided
between my sister and myself on the very day when he received his
appointment; then, when I was twenty-one, he added to this little
income an annual allowance of five thousand francs, assuring me that
with eight thousand francs a year I might live very happily at Paris,
if, in addition to this, I would make a position for myself either in
law or medicine. I came to Paris, studied law, was called to the bar,
and, like many other young men, put my diploma in my pocket, and let
myself drift, as one so easily does in Paris.
My expenses were very moderate; only I used up my year's income in
eight months, and spent the four summer months with my father, which
practically gave me twelve thousand francs a year, and, in addition,
the reputation of a good son. For the rest, not a penny of debt.
This, then, was my position when I made the acquaintance of
Marguerite. You can well understand that, in spite of myself, my
expenses soon increased. Marguerite's nature was very capricious, and,
like so many women, she never regarded as a serious expense those
thousand and one distractions which made up her life. So, wishing to
spend as much time with me as possible, she would write to me in the
morning that she would dine with me, not at home, but at some
restaurant in Paris or in the country. I would call for her, and we
would dine and go on to the theatre, often having supper as well; and
by the end of the evening I had spent four or five louis, which came to
two or three thousand francs a month, which reduced my year to three
months and a half, and made it necessary for me either to go into debt
or to leave Marguerite. I would have consented to anything except the
Forgive me if I give you all these details, but you will see that
they were the cause of what was to follow. What I tell you is a true
and simple story, and I leave to it all the naivete of its details and
all the simplicity of its developments.
I realized then that as nothing in the world would make me forget my
mistress, it was needful for me to find some way of meeting the
expenses into which she drew me. Then, too, my love for her had so
disturbing an influence upon me that every moment I spent away from
Marguerite was like a year, and that I felt the need of consuming these
moments in the fire of some sort of passion, and of living them so
swiftly as not to know that I was living them.
I began by borrowing five or six thousand francs on my little
capital, and with this I took to gambling. Since gambling houses were
destroyed gambling goes on everywhere. Formerly, when one went to
Frascati, one had the chance of making a fortune; one played against
money, and if one lost, there was always the consolation of saying that
one might have gained; whereas now, except in the clubs, where there is
still a certain rigour in regard to payments, one is almost certain,
the moment one gains a considerable sum, not to receive it. You will
readily understand why. Gambling is only likely to be carried on by
young people very much in need of money and not possessing the fortune
necessary for supporting the life they lead; they gamble, then, and
with this result; or else they gain, and then those who lose serve to
pay for their horses and mistresses, which is very disagreeable. Debts
are contracted, acquaintances begun about a green table end by quarrels
in which life or honour comes to grief; and though one may be an honest
man, one finds oneself ruined by very honest men, whose only defect is
that they have not two hundred thousand francs a year.
I need not tell you of those who cheat at play, and of how one hears
one fine day of their hasty disappearance and tardy condemnation.
I flung myself into this rapid, noisy, and volcanic life, which had
formerly terrified me when I thought of it, and which. had become for
me the necessary complement of my love for Marguerite. What else could
I have done?
The nights that I did not spend in the Rue d'Antin, if I had spent
them alone in my own room, I could not have slept. Jealousy would have
kept me awake, and inflamed my blood and my thoughts; while gambling
gave a new turn to the fever which would otherwise have preyed upon my
heart, and fixed it upon a passion which laid hold on me in spite of
myself, until the hour struck when I might go to my mistress. Then, and
by this I knew the violence of my love, I left the table without a
moment's hesitation, whether I was winning or losing, pitying those
whom I left behind because they would not, like me, find their real
happiness in leaving it. For the most of them, gambling was a
necessity; for me, it was a remedy. Free of Marguerite, I should have
been free of gambling.
Thus, in the midst of all that, I preserved a considerable amount of
self-possession; I lost only what I was able to pay, and gained only
what I should have been able to lose.
For the rest, chance was on my side. I made no debts, and I spent
three times as much money as when I did not gamble. It was impossible
to resist an existence which gave me an easy means of satisfying the
thousand caprices of Marguerite. As for her, she continued to love me
as much, or even more than ever.
As I told you, I began by being allowed to stay only from midnight
to six o'clock, then I was asked sometimes to a box in the theatre,
then she sometimes came to dine with me. One morning I did not go till
eight, and there came a day when I did not go till twelve.
But, sooner than the moral metamorphosis, a physical metamorphosis
came about in Marguerite. I had taken her cure in hand, and the poor
girl, seeing my aim, obeyed me in order to prove her gratitude. I had
succeeded without effort or trouble in almost isolating her from her
former habits. My doctor, whom I had made her meet, had told me that
only rest and calm could preserve her health, so that in place of
supper and sleepless nights, I succeeded in substituting a hygienic
regime and regular sleep. In spite of herself, Marguerite got
accustomed to this new existence, whose salutary effects she already
realized. She began to spend some of her evenings at home, or, if the
weather was fine, she wrapped herself in a shawl, put on a veil, and we
went on foot, like two children, in the dim alleys of the
Champs-Elysees. She would come in tired, take a light supper, and go to
bed after a little music or reading, which she had never been used to
do. The cough, which every time that I heard it seemed to go through my
chest, had almost completely disappeared.
At the end of six weeks the count was entirely given up, and only
the duke obliged me to conceal my liaison with Marguerite, and even he
was sent away when I was there, under the pretext that she was asleep
and had given orders that she was not to be awakened.
The habit or the need of seeing me which Marguerite had now
contracted had this good result: that it forced me to leave the
gaming-table just at the moment when an adroit gambler would have left
it. Settling one thing against another, I found myself in possession of
some ten thousand francs, which seemed to me an inexhaustible capital.
The time of the year when I was accustomed to join my father and
sister had now arrived, and I did not go; both of them wrote to me
frequently, begging me to come. To these letters I replied as best I
could, always repeating that I was quite well and that I was not in
need of money, two things which, I thought, would console my father for
my delay in paying him my annual visit.
Just then, one fine day in summer, Marguerite was awakened by the
sunlight pouring into her room, and, jumping out of bed, asked me if I
would take her into the country for the whole day.
We sent for Prudence, and all three set off, after Marguerite had
given Nanine orders to tell the duke that she had taken advantage of
the fine day to go into the country with Mme. Duvernoy.
Besides the presence of Mme. Duvernoy being needful on account of
the old duke, Prudence was one of those women who seem made on purpose
for days in the country. With her unchanging good-humour and her
eternal appetite, she never left a dull moment to those whom she was
with, and was perfectly happy in ordering eggs, cherries, milk, stewed
rabbit, and all the rest of the traditional lunch in the country.
We had now only to decide where we should go. It was once more
Prudence who settled the difficulty.
“Do you want to go to the real country?” she asked.
“Well, let us go to Bougival, at the Point du Jour, at Widow
Arnould's. Armand, order an open carriage.”
An hour and a half later we were at Widow Arnould's.
Perhaps you know the inn, which is a hotel on week days and a tea
garden on Sundays. There is a magnificent view from the garden, which
is at the height of an ordinary first floor. On the left the Aqueduct
of Marly closes in the horizon, on the right one looks across bill
after hill; the river, almost without current at that spot, unrolls
itself like a large white watered ribbon between the plain of the
Gabillons and the island of Croissy, lulled eternally by the trembling
of its high poplars and the murmur of its willows. Beyond, distinct in
the sunlight, rise little white houses, with red roofs, and
manufactories, which, at that distance, put an admirable finish to the
landscape. Beyond that, Paris in the mist! As Prudence had told us, it
was the real country, and, I must add, it was a real lunch.
It is not only out of gratitude for the happiness I owe it, but
Bougival, in spite of its horrible name, is one of the prettiest places
that it is possible to imagine. I have travelled a good deal, and seen
much grander things, but none more charming than this little village
gaily seated at the foot of the hill which protects it.
Mme. Arnould asked us if we would take a boat, and Marguerite and
Prudence accepted joyously.
People have always associated the country with love, and they have
done well; nothing affords so fine a frame for the woman whom one loves
as the blue sky, the odours, the flowers, the breeze, the shining
solitude of fields, or woods. However much one loves a woman, whatever
confidence one may have in her, whatever certainty her past may offer
us as to her future, one is always more or less jealous. If you have
been in love, you must have felt the need of isolating from this world
the being in whom you would live wholly. It seems as if, however
indifferent she may be to her surroundings, the woman whom one loves
loses something of her perfume and of her unity at the contact of men
and things. As for me, I experienced that more than most. Mine was not
an ordinary love; I was as much in love as an ordinary creature could
be, but with Marguerite Gautier; that is to say, that at Paris, at
every step, I might elbow the man who had already been her lover or who
was about to, while in the country, surrounded by people whom we had
never seen and who had no concern with us, alone with nature in the
spring-time of the year, that annual pardon, and shut off from the
noise of the city, I could hide my love, and love without shame or
The courtesan disappeared little by little. I had by me a young and
beautiful woman, whom I loved, and who loved me, and who was called
Marguerite; the past had no more reality and the future no more clouds.
The sun shone upon my mistress as it might have shone upon the purest
bride. We walked together in those charming spots which seemed to have
been made on purpose to recall the verses of Lamartine or to sing the
melodies of Scudo. Marguerite was dressed in white, she leaned on my
arm, saying over to me again under the starry sky the words she had
said to me the day before, and far off the world went on its way,
without darkening with its shadow the radiant picture of our youth and
That was the dream that the hot sun brought to me that day through
the leaves of the trees, as, lying on the grass of the island on which
we had landed, I let my thought wander, free from the human links that
had bound it, gathering to itself every hope that came in its way.
Add to this that from the place where I was I could see on the shore
a charming little house of two stories, with a semicircular railing;
through the railing, in front of the house, a green lawn, smooth as
velvet, and behind the house a little wood full of mysterious retreats,
where the moss must efface each morning the pathway that had been made
the day before. Climbing flowers clung about the doorway of this
uninhabited house, mounting as high as the first story.
I looked at the house so long that I began by thinking of it as
mine, so perfectly did it embody the dream that I was dreaming; I saw
Marguerite and myself there, by day in the little wood that covered the
hillside, in the evening seated on the grass, and I asked myself if
earthly creatures had ever been so happy as we should be.
“What a pretty house!” Marguerite said to me, as she followed the
direction of my gaze and perhaps of my thought.
“Where?” asked Prudence.
“Yonder,” and Marguerite pointed to the house in question.
“Ah, delicious!” replied Prudence. “Do you like it?”
“Well, tell the duke to take it for you; he would do so, I am sure.
I'll see about it if you like.”
Marguerite looked at me, as if to ask me what I thought. My dream
vanished at the last words of Prudence, and brought me back to reality
so brutally that I was still stunned with the fall.
“Yes, yes, an excellent idea,” I stammered, not knowing what I was
“Well, I will arrange that,” said Marguerite, freeing my hand, and
interpreting my words according to her own desire. “Let us go and see
if it is to let.”
The house was empty, and to let for two thousand francs.
“Would you be happy here?” she said to me.
“Am I sure of coming here?”
“And for whom else should I bury myself here, if not for you?”
“Well, then, Marguerite, let me take it myself.”
“You are mad; not only is it unnecessary, but it would be dangerous.
You know perfectly well that I have no right to accept it save from one
man. Let me alone, big baby, and say nothing.”
“That means,” said Prudence, “that when I have two days free I will
come and spend them with you.”
We left the house, and started on our return to Paris, talking over
the new plan. I held Marguerite in my arms, and as I got down from the
carriage, I had already begun to look upon her arrangement with less
Next day Marguerite sent me away very early, saying that the duke
was coming at an early hour, and promising to write to me the moment he
went, and to make an appointment for the evening. In the course of the
day I received this note:
“I am going to Bougival with the duke; be at Prudence's to-night at
At the appointed hour Marguerite came to me at Mme. Duvernoy's.
“Well, it is all settled,” she said, as she entered. “The house is
taken?” asked Prudence. “Yes; he agreed at once.”
I did not know the duke, but I felt ashamed of deceiving him.
“But that is not all,” continued Marguerite.
“What else is there?”
“I have been seeing about a place for Armand to stay.”
“In the same house?” asked Prudence, laughing.
“No, at Point du Jour, where we had dinner, the duke and I. While he
was admiring the view, I asked Mme. Arnould (she is called Mme.
Arnould, isn't she?) if there were any suitable rooms, and she showed
me just the very thing: salon, anteroom, and bed-room, at sixty francs
a month; the whole place furnished in a way to divert a hypochondriac.
I took it. Was I right?” I flung my arms around her neck and kissed
“It will be charming,” she continued. “You have the key of the
little door, and I have promised the duke the key of the front door,
which he will not take, because he will come during the day when he
comes. I think, between ourselves, that he is enchanted with a caprice
which will keep me out of Paris for a time, and so silence the
objections of his family. However, he has asked me how I, loving Paris
as I do, could make up my mind to bury myself in the country. I told
him that I was ill, and that I wanted rest. He seemed to have some
difficulty in believing me. The poor old man is always on the watch. We
must take every precaution, my dear Armand, for he will have me watched
while I am there; and it isn't only the question of his taking a house
for me, but he has my debts to pay, and unluckily I have plenty. Does
all that suit you?”
“Yes,” I answered, trying to quiet the scruples which this way of
living awoke in me from time to time.
“We went all over the house, and we shall have everything perfect.
The duke is going to look after every single thing. Ah, my dear,” she
added, kissing me, “you're in luck; it's a millionaire who makes your
bed for you.”
“And when shall you move into the house?” inquired Prudence.
“As soon as possible.”
“Will you take your horses and carriage?”
“I shall take the whole house, and you can look after my place while
I am away.”
A week later Marguerite was settled in her country house, and I was
installed at Point du Jour.
Then began an existence which I shall have some difficulty in
describing to you. At first Marguerite could not break entirely with
her former habits, and, as the house was always en fete, all the women
whom she knew came to see her. For a whole month there was not a day
when Marguerite had not eight or ten people to meals. Prudence, on her
side, brought down all the people she knew, and did the honours of the
house as if the house belonged to her.
The duke's money paid for all that, as you may imagine; but from
time to time Prudence came to me, asking for a note for a thousand
francs, professedly on behalf of Marguerite. You know I had won some
money at gambling; I therefore immediately handed over to Prudence what
she asked for Marguerite, and fearing lest she should require more than
I possessed, I borrowed at Paris a sum equal to that which I had
already borrowed and paid back. I was then once more in possession of
some ten thousand francs, without reckoning my allowance. However,
Marguerite's pleasure in seeing her friends was a little moderated when
she saw the expense which that pleasure entailed, and especially the
necessity she was sometimes in of asking me for money. The duke, who
had taken the house in order that Marguerite might rest there, no
longer visited it, fearing to find himself in the midst of a large and
merry company, by whom he did not wish to be seen. This came about
through his having once arrived to dine tete-a-tete with Marguerite,
and having fallen upon a party of fifteen, who were still at lunch at
an hour when he was prepared to sit down to dinner. He had
unsuspectingly opened the dining-room door, and had been greeted by a
burst of laughter, and had had to retire precipitately before the
impertinent mirth of the women who were assembled there.
Marguerite rose from table, and joined the duke in the next room,
where she tried, as far as possible, to induce him to forget the
incident, but the old man, wounded in his dignity, bore her a grudge
for it, and could not forgive her. He said to her, somewhat cruelly,
that he was tired of paying for the follies of a woman who could not
even have him treated with respect under his own roof, and he went away
in great indignation.
Since that day he had never been heard of.
In vain Marguerite dismissed her guests, changed her way of life;
the duke was not to be heard of. I was the gainer in so, far that my
mistress now belonged to me more completely, and my dream was at length
realized. Marguerite could not be without me. Not caring what the
result might be, she publicly proclaimed our liaison, and I had come to
live entirely at her house. The servants addressed me officially as
Prudence had strictly sermonized Marguerite in regard to her new
manner of life; but she had replied that she loved me, that she could
not live without me, and that, happen what might, she would not
sacrifice the pleasure of having me constantly with her, adding that
those who were not satisfied with this arrangement were free to stay
away. So much I had heard one day when Prudence had said to Marguerite
that she had something very important to tell her, and I had listened
at the door of the room into which they had shut themselves.
Not long after, Prudence returned again. I was at the other end of
the garden when she arrived, and she did not see me. I had no doubt,
from the way in which Marguerite came to meet her, that another similar
conversation was going to take place, and I was anxious to hear what it
was about. The two women shut themselves into a boudoir, and I put
myself within hearing.
“Well?” said Marguerite.
“Well, I have seen the duke.”
“What did he say?”
“That he would gladly forgive you in regard to the scene which took
place, but that he has learned that you are publicly living with M.
Armand Duval, and that he will never forgive that. 'Let Marguerite
leave the young man,' he said to me, 'and, as in the past, I will give
her all that she requires; if not, let her ask nothing more from me.'“
“And you replied?”
“That I would report his decision to you, and I promised him that I
would bring you into a more reasonable frame of mind. Only think, my
dear child, of the position that you are losing, and that Armand can
never give you. He loves you with all his soul, but he has no fortune
capable of supplying your needs, and he will be bound to leave you one
day, when it will be too late and when the duke will refuse to do any
more for you. Would you like me to speak to Armand?”
Marguerite seemed to be thinking, for she answered nothing. My heart
beat violently while I waited for her reply.
“No,” she answered, “I will not leave Armand, and I will not conceal
the fact that I am living with him. It is folly no doubt, but I love
him. What would you have me do? And then, now that he has got
accustomed to be always with me, he would suffer too cruelly if he had
to leave me so much as an hour a day. Besides, I have not such a long
time to live that I need make myself miserable in order to please an
old man whose very sight makes me feel old. Let him keep his money; I
will do without it.”
“But what will you do?”
“I don't in the least know.”
Prudence was no doubt going to make some reply, but I entered
suddenly and flung myself at Marguerite's feet, covering her hands with
tears in my joy at being thus loved.
“My life is yours, Marguerite; you need this man no longer. Am I not
here? Shall I ever leave you, and can I ever repay you for the
happiness that you give me? No more barriers, my Marguerite; we love;
what matters all the rest?”
“Oh yes, I love you, my Armand,” she murmured, putting her two arms
around my neck. “I love you as I never thought I should ever love. We
will be happy; we will live quietly, and I will say good-bye forever to
the life for which I now blush. You won't ever reproach me for the
past? Tell me!”
Tears choked my voice. I could only reply by clasping Marguerite to
“Well,” said she, turning to Prudence, and speaking in a broken
voice, “you can report this scene to the duke, and you can add that we
have no longer need of him.”
From that day forth the duke was never referred to. Marguerite was
no longer the same woman that I had known. She avoided everything that
might recall to me the life which she had been leading when I first met
her. Never did wife or sister surround husband or brother with such
loving care as she had for me. Her nature was morbidly open to all
impressions and accessible to all sentiments. She had broken equally
with her friends and with her ways, with her words and with her
extravagances. Any one who had seen us leaving the house to go on the
river in the charming little boat which I had bought would never have
believed that the woman dressed in white, wearing a straw hat, and
carrying on her arm a little silk pelisse to protect her against the
damp of the river, was that Marguerite Gautier who, only four months
ago, had been the talk of the town for the luxury and scandal of her
Alas, we made haste to be happy, as if we knew that we were not to
be happy long.
For two months we had not even been to Paris. No one came to see us,
except Prudence and Julie Duprat, of whom I have spoken to you, and to
whom Marguerite was afterward to give the touching narrative that I
I passed whole days at the feet of my mistress. We opened the
windows upon the garden, and, as we watched the summer ripening in its
flowers and under the shadow of the trees, we breathed together that
true life which neither Marguerite nor I had ever known before.
Her delight in the smallest things was like that of a child. There
were days when she ran in the garden, like a child of ten, after a
butterfly or a dragon-fly. This courtesan who had cost more money in
bouquets than would have kept a whole family in comfort, would
sometimes sit on the grass for an hour, examining the simple flower
whose name she bore.
It was at this time that she read Manon Lescaut, over and over
again. I found her several times making notes in the book, and she
always declared that when a woman loves, she can not do as Manon did.
The duke wrote to her two or three times. She recognised the writing
and gave me the letters without reading them. Sometimes the terms of
these letters brought tears to my eyes. He had imagined that by closing
his purse to Marguerite, he would bring her back to him; but when he
had perceived the uselessness of these means, he could hold out no
longer; he wrote and asked that he might see her again, as before, no
matter on what conditions.
I read these urgent and repeated letters, and tore them in pieces,
without telling Marguerite what they contained and without advising her
to see the old man again, though I was half inclined to, so much did I
pity him, but I was afraid lest, if I so advised her she should think
that I wished the duke, not merely to come and see her again, but to
take over the expenses of the house; I feared, above all, that she
might think me capable of shirking the responsibilities of every
consequence to which her love for me might lead her.
It thus came about that the duke, receiving no reply, ceased to
write, and that Marguerite and I continued to live together without
giving a thought to the future.
It would be difficult to give you all the details of our new life.
It was made up of a series of little childish events, charming for us
but insignificant to any one else. You know what it is to be in love
with a woman, you know how it cuts short the days, and with what loving
listlessness one drifts into the morrow. You know that forgetfulness of
everything which comes of a violent confident, reciprocated love. Every
being who is not the beloved one seems a useless being in creation. One
regrets having cast scraps of one's heart to other women, and one can
not believe in the possibility of ever pressing another hand than that
which one holds between one's hands. The mind admits neither work nor
remembrance; nothing, in short, which can distract it from the one
thought in which it is ceaselessly absorbed. Every day one discovers in
one's mistress a new charm and unknown delights. Existence itself is
but the unceasing accomplishment of an unchanging desire; the soul is
but the vestal charged to feed the sacred fire of love.
We often went at night-time to sit in the little wood above the
house; there we listened to the cheerful harmonies of evening, both of
us thinking of the coming hours which should leave us to one another
till the dawn of day. At other times we did not get up all day; we did
not even let the sunlight enter our room.
The curtains were hermetically closed, and for a moment the external
world did not exist for us. Nanine alone had the right to open our
door, but only to bring in our meals and even these we took without
getting up, interrupting them with laughter and gaiety. To that
succeeded a brief sleep, for, disappearing into the depths of our love,
we were like two divers who only come to the surface to take breath.
Nevertheless, I surprised moments of sadness, even tears, in
Marguerite; I asked her the cause of her trouble, and she answered:
“Our love is not like other loves, my Armand. You love me as if I
had never belonged to another, and I tremble lest later on, repenting
of your love, and accusing me of my past, you should let me fall back
into that life from which you have taken me. I think that now that I
have tasted of another life, I should die if I went back to the old
one. Tell me that you will never leave me!”
“I swear it!”
At these words she looked at me as if to read in my eyes whether my
oath was sincere; then flung herself into my arms, and, hiding her head
in my bosom, said to me: “You don't know how much I love you!”
One evening, seated on the balcony outside the window, we looked at
the moon which seemed to rise with difficulty out of its bed of clouds,
and we listened to the wind violently rustling the trees; we held each
other's hands, and for a whole quarter of an hour we had not spoken,
when Marguerite said to me:
“Winter is at hand. Would you like for us to go abroad?”
“You are tired of here?”
“I am afraid of the winter; I am particularly afraid of your return
“For many reasons.”
And she went on abruptly, without giving me her reasons for fears:
“Will you go abroad? I will sell all that I have; we will go and
live there, and there will be nothing left of what I was; no one will
know who I am. Will you?”
“By all means, if you like, Marguerite, let us travel,” I said. “But
where is the necessity of selling things which you will be glad of when
we return? I have not a large enough fortune to accept such a
sacrifice; but I have enough for us to be able to travel splendidly for
five or six months, if that will amuse you the least in the world.”
“After all, no,” she said, leaving the window and going to sit down
on the sofa at the other end of the room. “Why should we spend money
abroad? I cost you enough already, here.”
“You reproach me, Marguerite; it isn't generous.”
“Forgive me, my friend,” she said, giving me her hand. “This thunder
weather gets on my nerves; I do not say what I intend to say.”
And after embracing me she fell into a long reverie.
Scenes of this kind often took place, and though I could not
discover their cause, I could not fail to see in Marguerite signs of
disquietude in regard to the future. She could not doubt my love, which
increased day by day, and yet I often found her sad, without being able
to get any explanation of the reason, except some physical cause.
Fearing that so monotonous a life was beginning to weary her, I
proposed returning to Paris; but she always refused, assuring me that
she could not be so happy anywhere as in the country.
Prudence now came but rarely; but she often wrote letters which I
never asked to see, though, every time they came, they seemed to
preoccupy Marguerite deeply. I did not know what to think.
One day Marguerite was in her room. I entered. She was writing. “To
whom are you writing?” I asked. “To Prudence. Do you want to see what I
I had a horror of anything that might look like suspicion, and I
answered that I had no desire to know what she was writing; and yet I
was certain that letter would have explained to me the cause of her
Next day the weather was splendid.' Marguerite proposed to me to
take the boat and go as far as the island of Croissy. She seemed very
cheerful; when we got back it was five o'clock.
“Mme. Duvernoy has been here,” said Nanine, as she saw us enter.
“She has gone again?” asked Marguerite.
“Yes, madame, in the carriage; she said it was arranged.”
“Quite right,” said Marguerite sharply. “Serve the dinner.”
Two days afterward there came a letter from Prudence, and for a
fortnight Marguerite seemed to have got rid of her mysterious gloom,
for which she constantly asked my forgiveness, now that it no longer
existed. Still, the carriage did not return.
“How is it that Prudence does not send you back your carriage?” I
asked one day.
“One of the horses is ill, and there are some repairs to be done. It
is better to have that done while we are here, and don't need a
carriage, than to wait till we get back to Paris.”
Prudence came two days afterward, and confirmed what Marguerite had
said. The two women went for a walk in the garden, and when I joined
them they changed the conversation. That night, as she was going,
Prudence complained of the cold and asked Marguerite to lend her a
So a month passed, and all the time Marguerite was more joyous and
more affectionate than she ever had been. Nevertheless, the carriage
did not return, the shawl had not been sent back, and I began to be
anxious in spite of myself, and as I knew in which drawer Marguerite
put Prudence's letters, I took advantage of a moment when she was at
the other end of the garden, went to the drawer, and tried to open it;
in vain, for it was locked. When I opened the drawer in which the
trinkets and diamonds were usually kept, these opened without
resistance, but the jewel cases had disappeared, along with their
contents no doubt.
A sharp fear penetrated my heart. I might indeed ask Marguerite for
the truth in regard to these disappearances, but it was certain that
she would not confess it.
“My good Marguerite,” I said to her, “I am going to ask your
permission to go to Paris. They do not know my address, and I expect
there are letters from my father waiting for me. I have no doubt he is
concerned; I ought to answer him.”
“Go, my friend,” she said; “but be back early.” I went straight to
“Come,” said I, without beating about the bush, “tell me frankly,
where are Marguerite's horses?”
“And who has sold and pawned them?”
“Why did you not tell me?”
“Because Marguerite made me promise not to.”
“And why did you not ask me for money?”
“Because she wouldn't let me.”
“And where has this money gone?”
“Is she much in debt?”
“Thirty thousand francs, or thereabouts. Ah, my dear fellow, didn't
I tell you? You wouldn't believe me; now you are convinced. The
upholsterer whom the duke had agreed to settle with was shown out of
the house when he presented himself, and the duke wrote next day to say
that he would answer for nothing in regard to Mlle. Gautier. This man
wanted his money; he was given part payment out of the few thousand
francs that I got from you; then some kind souls warned him that his
debtor had been abandoned by the duke and was living with a penniless
young man; the other creditors were told the same; they asked for their
money, and seized some of the goods. Marguerite wanted to sell
everything, but it was too late, and besides I should have opposed it.
But it was necessary to pay, and in order not to ask you for money, she
sold her horses and her shawls, and pawned her jewels. Would you like
to see the receipts and the pawn tickets?”
And Prudence opened the drawer and showed me the papers.
“Ah, you think,” she continued, with the insistence of a woman who
can say, I was right after all, “ah, you think it is enough to be in
love, and to go into the country and lead a dreamy, pastoral life. No,
my friend, no. By the side of that ideal life, there is a material
life, and the purest resolutions are held to earth by threads which
seem slight enough, but which are of iron, not easily to be broken. If
Marguerite has not been unfaithful to you twenty times, it is because
she has an exceptional nature. It is not my fault for not advising her
to, for I couldn't bear to see the poor girl stripping herself of
everything. She wouldn't; she replied that she loved you, and she
wouldn't be unfaithful to you for anything in the world. All that is
very pretty, very poetical, but one can't pay one's creditors in that
coin, and now she can't free herself from debt, unless she can raise
thirty thousand francs.”
“All right, I will provide that amount.”
“You will borrow it?”
“Good heavens! Why, yes!”
“A fine thing that will be to do; you will fall out with your
father, cripple your resources, and one doesn't find thirty thousand
francs from one day to another. Believe me, my dear Armand, I know
women better than you do; do not commit this folly; you will be sorry
for it one day. Be reasonable. I don't advise you to leave Marguerite,
but live with her as you did at the beginning. Let her find the means
to get out of this difficulty. The duke will come back in a little
while. The Comte de N., if she would take him, he told me yesterday
even, would pay all her debts, and give her four or five thousand
francs a month. He has two hundred thousand a year. It would be a
position for her, while you will certainly be obliged to leave her.
Don't wait till you are ruined, especially as the Comte de N. is a
fool, and nothing would prevent your still being Marguerite's lover.
She would cry a little at the beginning, but she would come to accustom
herself to it, and you would thank me one day for what you had done.
Imagine that Marguerite is married, and deceive the husband; that is
all. I have already told you all this once, only at that time it was
merely advice, and now it is almost a necessity.”
What Prudence said was cruelly true.
“This is how it is,” she went on, putting away the papers she had
just shown me; “women like Marguerite always foresee that some one will
love them, never that they will love; otherwise they would put aside
money, and at thirty they could afford the luxury of having a lover for
nothing. If I had only known once what I know now! In short, say
nothing to Marguerite, and bring her back to Paris. You have lived with
her alone for four or five months; that is quite enough. Shut your eyes
now; that is all that any one asks of you. At the end of a fortnight
she will take the Comte de N., and she will save up during the winter,
and next summer you will begin over again. That is how things are done,
my dear fellow!”
And Prudence appeared to be enchanted with her advice, which I
Not only my love and my dignity would not let me act thus, but I was
certain that, feeling as she did now, Marguerite would die rather than
accept another lover.
“Enough joking,” I said to Prudence; “tell me exactly how much
Marguerite is in need of.”
“I have told you: thirty thousand francs.”
“And when does she require this sum?”
“Before the end of two months.”
“She shall have it.”
Prudence shrugged her shoulders.
“I will give it to you,” I continued, “but you must swear to me that
you will not tell Marguerite that I have given it to you.”
“Don't be afraid.”
“And if she sends you anything else to sell or pawn, let me know.”
“There is no danger. She has nothing left.”
I went straight to my own house to see if there were any letters
from my father. There were four.
In his first three letters my father inquired the cause of my
silence; in the last he allowed me to see that he had heard of my
change of life, and informed me that he was about to come and see me.
I have always had a great respect and a sincere affection for my
father. I replied that I had been travelling for a short time, and
begged him to let me know beforehand what day he would arrive, so that
I could be there to meet him.
I gave my servant my address in the country, telling him to bring me
the first letter that came with the postmark of C., then I returned to
Marguerite was waiting for me at the garden gate. She looked at me
anxiously. Throwing her arms round my neck, she said to me: “Have you
“You were a long time in Paris.”
“I found letters from my father to which I had to reply.”
A few minutes afterward Nanine entered, all out of breath.
Marguerite rose and talked with her in whispers. When Nanine had gone
out Marguerite sat down by me again and said, taking my hand:
“Why did you deceive me? You went to see Prudence.”
“Who told you?”
“And how did she know?”
“She followed you.”
“You told her to follow me?”
“Yes. I thought that you must have had a very strong motive for
going to Paris, after not leaving me for four months. I was afraid that
something might happen to you, or that you were perhaps going to see
“Now I am relieved. I know what you have done, but I don't yet know
what you have been told.”
I showed Marguerite my father's letters.
“That is not what I am asking you about. What I want to know is why
you went to see Prudence.”
“To see her.”
“That's a lie, my friend.”
“Well, I went to ask her if the horse was any better, and if she
wanted your shawl and your jewels any longer.”
Marguerite blushed, but did not answer.
“And,” I continued, “I learned what you had done with your horses,
shawls, and jewels.”
“And you are vexed?”
“I am vexed that it never occurred to you to ask me for what you
were in want of.”
“In a liaison like ours, if the woman has any sense of dignity at
all, she ought to make every possible sacrifice rather than ask her
lover for money and so give a venal character to her love. You love me,
I am sure, but you do not know on how slight a thread depends the love
one has for a woman like me. Who knows? Perhaps some day when you were
bored or worried you would fancy you saw a carefully concerted plan in
our liaison. Prudence is a chatterbox. What need had I of the horses?
It was an economy to sell them. I don't use them and I don't spend
anything on their keep; if you love me, I ask nothing more, and you
will love me just as much without horses, or shawls, or diamonds.”
All that was said so naturally that the tears came to my eyes as I
“But, my good Marguerite,” I replied, pressing her hands lovingly,
“you knew that one day I should discover the sacrifice you had made,
and that the moment I discovered it I should allow it no longer.”
“Because, my dear child, I can not allow your affection for me to
deprive you of even a trinket. I too should not like you to be able, in
a moment when you were bored or worried, to think that if you were
living with somebody else those moments would not exist; and to repent,
if only for a minute, of living with me. In a few days your horses,
your diamonds, and your shawls shall be returned to you. They are as
necessary to you as air is to life, and it may be absurd, but I like
you better showy than simple.”
“Then you no longer love me.”
“If you loved me, you would let me love you my own way; on the
contrary, you persist in only seeing in me a woman to whom luxury is
indispensable, and whom you think you are always obliged to pay. You
are ashamed to accept the proof of my love. In spite of yourself, you
think of leaving me some day, and you want to put your
disinterestedness beyond risk of suspicion. You are right, my friend,
but I had better hopes.”
And Marguerite made a motion to rise; I held her, and said to her:
“I want you to be happy and to have nothing to reproach me for, that
“And we are going to be separated!”
“Why, Marguerite, who can separate us?” I cried.
“You, who will not let me take you on your own level, but insist on
taking me on mine; you, who wish me to keep the luxury in the midst of
which I have lived, and so keep the moral distance which separates us;
you, who do not believe that my affection is sufficiently disinterested
to share with me what you have, though we could live happily enough on
it together, and would rather ruin yourself, because you are still
bound by a foolish prejudice. Do you really think that I could compare
a carriage and diamonds with your love? Do you think that my real
happiness lies in the trifles that mean so much when one has nothing to
love, but which become trifling indeed when one has? You will pay my
debts, realize your estate, and then keep me? How long will that last?
Two or three months, and then it will be too late to live the life I
propose, for then you will have to take everything from me, and that is
what a man of honour can not do; while now you have eight or ten
thousand francs a year, on which we should be able to live. I will sell
the rest of what I do not want, and with this alone I will make two
thousand francs a year. We will take a nice little flat in which we can
both live. In the summer we will go into the country, not to a house
like this, but to a house just big enough for two people. You are
independent, I am free, we are young; in heaven's name, Armand, do not
drive me back into the life I had to lead once!”
I could not answer. Tears of gratitude and love filled my eyes, and
I flung myself into Marguerite's arms.
“I wanted,” she continued, “to arrange everything without telling
you, pay all my debts, and take a new flat. In October we should have
been back in Paris, and all would have come out; but since Prudence has
told you all, you will have to agree beforehand, instead of agreeing
afterward. Do you love me enough for that?”
It was impossible to resist such devotion. I kissed her hands
ardently, and said:
“I will do whatever you wish.”
It was agreed that we should do as she had planned. Thereupon, she
went wild with delight; danced, sang, amused herself with calling up
pictures of her new flat in all its simplicity, and began to consult me
as to its position and arrangement. I saw how happy and proud she was
of this resolution, which seemed as if it would bring us into closer
and closer relationship, and I resolved to do my own share. In an
instant I decided the whole course of my life. I put my affairs in
order, and made over to Marguerite the income which had come to me from
my mother, and which seemed little enough in return for the sacrifice
which I was accepting. There remained the five thousand francs a year
from my father; and, whatever happened, I had always enough to live on.
I did not tell Marguerite what I had done, certain as I was that she
would refuse the gift. This income came from a mortgage of sixty
thousand francs on a house that I had never even seen. All that I knew
was that every three months my father's solicitor, an old friend of the
family, handed over to me seven hundred and fifty francs in return for
The day when Marguerite and I came to Paris to look for a flat, I
went to this solicitor and asked him what had to be done in order to
make over this income to another person. The good man imagined I was
ruined, and questioned me as to the cause of my decision. As I knew
that I should be obliged, sooner or later, to say in whose favour I
made this transfer, I thought it best to tell him the truth at once. He
made none of the objections that his position as friend and solicitor
authorized him to make, and assured me that he would arrange the whole
affair in the best way possible. Naturally, I begged him to employ the
greatest discretion in regard to my father, and on leaving him I
rejoined Marguerite, who was waiting for me at Julie Duprat's, where
she had gone in preference to going to listen to the moralizings of
We began to look out for flats. All those that we saw seemed to
Marguerite too dear, and to me too simple. However, we finally found,
in one of the quietest parts of Paris, a little house, isolated from
the main part of the building. Behind this little house was a charming
garden, surrounded by walls high enough to screen us from our
neighbours, and low enough not to shut off our own view. It was better
than our expectations.
While I went to give notice at my own flat, Marguerite went to see a
business agent, who, she told me, had already done for one of her
friends exactly what she wanted him to do for her. She came on to the
Rue de Provence in a state of great delight. The man had promised to
pay all her debts, to give her a receipt for the amount, and to hand
over to her twenty thousand francs, in return for the whole of her
furniture. You have seen by the amount taken at the sale that this
honest man would have gained thirty thousand francs out of his client.
We went back joyously to Bougival, talking over our projects for the
future, which, thanks to our heedlessness, and especially to our love,
we saw in the rosiest light.
A week later, as we were having lunch, Nanine came to tell us that
my servant was asking for me. “Let him come in,” I said.
“Sir,” said he, “your father has arrived in Paris, and begs you to
return at once to your rooms, where he is waiting for you.”
This piece of news was the most natural thing in the world, yet, as
we heard it, Marguerite and I looked at one another. We foresaw
trouble. Before she had spoken a word, I replied to her thought, and,
taking her hand, I said, “Fear nothing.”
“Come back as soon as possible,” whispered Marguerite, embracing me;
“I will wait for you at the window.”
I sent on Joseph to tell my father that I was on my way. Two hours
later I was at the Rue de Provence.
My father was seated in my room in his dressing-gown; he was
writing, and I saw at once, by the way in which he raised his eyes to
me when I came in, that there was going to be a serious discussion. I
went up to him, all the same, as if I had seen nothing in his face,
embraced him, and said:
“When did you come, father?”
“Did you come straight here, as usual?”
“I am very sorry not to have been here to receive you.”
I expected that the sermon which my father's cold face threatened
would begin at once; but he said nothing, sealed the letter which he
had just written, and gave it to Joseph to post.
When we were alone, my father rose, and leaning against the
mantel-piece, said to me:
“My dear Armand, we have serious matters to discuss.”
“I am listening, father.”
“You promise me to be frank?”
“Am I not accustomed to be so?”
“Is it not true that you are living with a woman called Marguerite
“Do you know what this woman was?”
“A kept woman.”
“And it is for her that you have forgotten to come and see your
sister and me this year?”
“Yes, father, I admit it.”
“You are very much in love with this woman?”
“You see it, father, since she has made me fail in duty toward you,
for which I humbly ask your forgiveness to-day.”
My father, no doubt, was not expecting such categorical answers, for
he seemed to reflect a moment, and then said to me:
“You have, of course, realized that you can not always live like
“I fear so, father, but I have not realized it.”
“But you must realize,” continued my father, in a dryer tone, “that
I, at all events, should not permit it.”
“I have said to myself that as long as I did nothing contrary to the
respect which I owe to the traditional probity of the family I could
live as I am living, and this has reassured me somewhat in regard to
the fears I have had.”
Passions are formidable enemies to sentiment. I was prepared for
every struggle, even with my father, in order that I might keep
“Then, the moment is come when you must live otherwise.”
“Because you are doing things which outrage the respect that you
imagine you have for your family.”
“I don't follow your meaning.”
“I will explain it to you. Have a mistress if you will; pay her as a
man of honour is bound to pay the woman whom he keeps, by all means;
but that you should come to forget the most sacred things for her, that
you should let the report of your scandalous life reach my quiet
countryside, and set a blot on the honourable name that I have given
you, it can not, it shall not be.”
“Permit me to tell you, father, that those who have given you
information about me have been ill-informed. I am the lover of Mlle.
Gautier; I live with her; it is the most natural thing in the world. I
do not give Mlle. Gautier the name you have given me; I spend on her
account what my means allow me to spend; I have no debts; and, in
short, I am not in a position which authorizes a father to say to his
son what you have just said to me.”
“A father is always authorized to rescue his son out of evil paths.
You have not done any harm yet, but you will do it.”
“Sir, I know more of life than you do. There are no entirely pure
sentiments except in perfectly chaste women. Every Manon can have her
own Des Grieux, and times are changed. It would be useless for the
world to grow older if it did not correct its ways. You will leave your
“I am very sorry to disobey you, father, but it is impossible.”
“I will compel you to do so.”
“Unfortunately, father, there no longer exists a Sainte Marguerite
to which courtesans can be sent, and, even if there were, I would
follow Mlle. Gautier if you succeeded in having her sent there. What
would you have? Perhaps am in the wrong, but I can only be happy as
long as I am the lover of this woman.”
“Come, Armand, open your eyes. Recognise that it is your father who
speaks to you, your father who has always loved you, and who only
desires your happiness. Is it honourable for you to live like husband
and wife with a woman whom everybody has had?”
“What does it matter, father, if no one will any more? What does it
matter, if this woman loves me, if her whole life is changed through
the love which she has for me and the love which I have for her? What
does it matter, if she has become a different woman?”
“Do you think, then, sir, that the mission of a man of honour is to
go about converting lost women? Do you think that God has given such a
grotesque aim to life, and that the heart should have any room for
enthusiasm of that kind? What will be the end of this marvellous cure,
and what will you think of what you are saying to-day by the time you
are forty? You will laugh at this love of yours, if you can still
laugh, and if it has not left too serious a trace in your past. What
would you be now if your father had had your ideas and had given up his
life to every impulse of this kind, instead of rooting himself firmly
in convictions of honour and steadfastness? Think it over, Armand, and
do not talk any more such absurdities. Come, leave this woman; your
father entreats you.”
I answered nothing.
“Armand,” continued my father, “in the name of your sainted mother,
abandon this life, which you will forget more easily than you think.
You are tied to it by an impossible theory. You are twenty-four; think
of the future. You can not always love this woman, who also can not
always love you. You both exaggerate your love. You put an end to your
whole career. One step further, and you will no longer be able to leave
the path you have chosen, and you will suffer all your life for what
you have done in your youth. Leave Paris. Come and stay for a month or
two with your sister and me. Rest in our quiet family affection will
soon heal you of this fever, for it is nothing else. Meanwhile, your
mistress will console herself; she will take another lover; and when
you see what it is for which you have all but broken with your father,
and all but lost his love, you will tell me that I have done well to
come and seek you out, and you will thank me for it. Come, you will go
with me, Armand, will you not?” I felt that my father would be right if
it had been any other woman, but I was convinced that he was wrong with
regard to Marguerite. Nevertheless, the tone in which he said these
last words was so kind, so appealing, that I dared not answer.
“Well?” said he in a trembling voice.
“Well, father, I can promise nothing,” I said at last; “what you ask
of me is beyond my power. Believe me,” I continued, seeing him make an
impatient movement, “you exaggerate the effects of this liaison.
Marguerite is a different kind of a woman from what you think. This
love, far from leading me astray, is capable, on the contrary, of
setting me in the right direction. Love always makes a man better, no
matter what woman inspires it. If you knew Marguerite, you would
understand that I am in no danger. She is as noble as the noblest of
women. There is as much disinterestedness in her as there is cupidity
“All of which does not prevent her from accepting the whole of your
fortune, for the sixty thousand francs which come to you from your
mother, and which you are giving her, are, understand me well, your
My father had probably kept this peroration and this threat for the
last stroke. I was firmer before these threats than before his
“Who told you that I was handing this sum to her?” I asked.
“My solicitor. Could an honest man carry out such a procedure
without warning me? Well, it is to prevent you from ruining yourself
for a prostitute that I am now in Paris. Your mother, when she died,
left you enough to live on respectably, and not to squander on your
“I swear to you, father, that Marguerite knew nothing of this
“Why, then, do you make it?”
“Because Marguerite, the woman you calumniate, and whom you wish me
to abandon, is sacrificing all that she possesses in order to live with
“And you accept this sacrifice? What sort of a man are you, sir, to
allow Mlle. Gautier to sacrifice anything for you? Come, enough of
this. You will leave this woman. Just now I begged you; now I command
you. I will have no such scandalous doings in my family. Pack up your
things and get ready to come with me.”
“Pardon me, father,” I said, “but I shall not come.”
“Because I am at an age when no one any longer obeys a command.”
My father turned pale at my answer.
“Very well, sir,” he said, “I know what remains to be done.”
He rang and Joseph appeared.
“Have my things taken to the Hotel de Paris,” he said to my servant.
And thereupon he went to his room and finished dressing. When he
returned, I went up to him.
“Promise me, father,” I said, “that you will do nothing to give
My father stopped, looked at me disdainfully, and contented himself
with saying, “I believe you are mad.” After this he went out, shutting
the door violently after him.
I went downstairs, took a cab, and returned to Bougival.
Marguerite was waiting for me at the window.
“At last you have come,” she said, throwing her arms round my neck.
“But how pale you are!”
I told her of the scene with my father.
“My God! I was afraid of it,” she said. “When Joseph came to tell
you of your father's arrival I trembled as if he had brought news of
some misfortune. My poor friend, I am the cause of all your distress.
You will be better off, perhaps, if you leave me and do not quarrel
with your father on my account. He knows that you are sure to have a
mistress, and he ought to be thankful that it is I, since I love you
and do not want more of you than your position allows. Did you tell him
how we had arranged our future?”
“Yes; that is what annoyed him the most, for he saw how much we
really love one another.”
“What are we to do, then?”
“Hold together, my good Marguerite, and let the storm pass over.”
“Will it pass?”
“It will have to.”
“But your father will not stop there.”
“What do you suppose he can do?”
“How do I know? Everything that a father can do to make his son obey
him. He will remind you of my past life, and will perhaps do me the
honour of inventing some new story, so that you may give me up.”
“You know that I love you.”
“Yes, but what I know, too, is that, sooner or later, you will have
to obey your father, and perhaps you will end by believing him.”
“No, Marguerite. It is I who will make him believe me. Some of his
friends have been telling him tales which have made him angry; but he
is good and just, he will change his first impression; and then, after
all, what does it matter to me?”
“Do not say that, Armand. I would rather anything should happen than
that you should quarrel with your family; wait till after to-day, and
to-morrow go back to Paris. Your father, too, will have thought it over
on his side, and perhaps you will both come to a better understanding.
Do not go against his principles, pretend to make some concessions to
what he wants; seem not to care so very much about me, and he will let
things remain as they are. Hope, my friend, and be sure of one thing,
that whatever happens, Marguerite will always be yours.”
“You swear it?”
“Do I need to swear it?”
How sweet it is to let oneself be persuaded by the voice that one
loves! Marguerite and I spent the whole day in talking over our
projects for the future, as if we felt the need of realizing them as
quickly as possible. At every moment we awaited some event, but the day
passed without bringing us any new tidings.
Next day I left at ten o'clock, and reached the hotel about twelve.
My father had gone out.
I went to my own rooms, hoping that he had perhaps gone there. No
one had called. I went to the solicitor's. No one was there. I went
back to the hotel, and waited till six. M. Duval did not return, and I
went back to Bougival.
I found Marguerite not waiting for me, as she had been the day
before, but sitting by the fire, which the weather still made
necessary. She was so absorbed in her thoughts that I came close to her
chair without her hearing me. When I put my lips to her forehead she
started as if the kiss had suddenly awakened her.
“You frightened me,” she said. “And your father?”
“I have not seen him. I do not know what it means. He was not at his
hotel, nor anywhere where there was a chance of my finding him.”
“Well, you must try again to-morrow.”
“I am very much inclined to wait till he sends for me. I think I
have done all that can be expected of me.”
“No, my friend, it is not enough; you must call on your father
again, and you must call to-morrow.”
“Why to-morrow rather than any other day?”
“Because,” said Marguerite, and it seemed to me that she blushed
slightly at this question, “because it will show that you are the more
keen about it, and he will forgive us the sooner.”
For the remainder of the day Marguerite was sad and preoccupied. I
had to repeat twice over everything I said to her to obtain an answer.
She ascribed this preoccupation to her anxiety in regard to the events
which had happened during the last two days. I spent the night in
reassuring her, and she sent me away in the morning with an insistent
disquietude that I could not explain to myself.
Again my father was absent, but he had left this letter for me:
“If you call again to-day, wait for me till four. If I am not in by
four, come and dine with me to-morrow. I must see you.”
I waited till the hour he had named, but he did not appear. I
returned to Bougival.
The night before I had found Marguerite sad; that night I found her
feverish and agitated. On seeing me, she flung her arms around my neck,
but she cried for a long time in my arms. I questioned her as to this
sudden distress, which alarmed me by its violence. She gave me no
positive reason, but put me off with those evasions which a woman
resorts to when she will not tell the truth.
When she was a little calmed down, I told her the result of my
visit, and I showed her my father's letter, from which, I said, we
might augur well. At the sight of the letter and on hearing my comment,
her tears began to flow so copiously that I feared an attack of nerves,
and, calling Nanine, I put her to bed, where she wept without a word,
but held my hands and kissed them every moment.
I asked Nanine if, during my absence, her mistress had received any
letter or visit which could account for the state in which I found her,
but Nanine replied that no one had called and nothing had been sent.
Something, however, had occurred since the day before, something
which troubled me the more because Marguerite concealed it from me.
In the evening she seemed a little calmer, and, making me sit at the
foot of the bed, she told me many times how much she loved me. She
smiled at me, but with an effort, for in spite of herself her eyes were
veiled with tears.
I used every means to make her confess the real cause of her
distress, but she persisted in giving me nothing but vague reasons, as
I have told you. At last she fell asleep in my arms, but it was the
sleep which tires rather than rests the body. From time to time she
uttered a cry, started up, and, after assuring herself that I was
beside her, made me swear that I would always love her.
I could make nothing of these intermittent paroxysms of distress,
which went on till morning. Then Marguerite fell into a kind of stupor.
She had not slept for two nights.
Her rest was of short duration, for toward eleven she awoke, and,
seeing that I was up, she looked about her, crying:
“Are you going already?”
“No,” said I, holding her hands; “but I wanted to let you sleep on.
It is still early.”
“What time are you going to Paris?”
“So soon? But you will stay with me till then?”
“Of course. Do I not always?”
“I am so glad! Shall we have lunch?” she went on absentmindedly.
“If you like.”
“And then you will be nice to me till the very moment you go?”
“Yes; and I will come back as soon as I can.”
“You will come back?” she said, looking at me with haggard eyes.
“Oh, yes, you will come back to-night. I shall wait for you, as I
always do, and you will love me, and we shall be happy, as we have been
ever since we have known each other.”
All these words were said in such a strained voice, they seemed to
hide so persistent and so sorrowful a thought, that I trembled every
moment lest Marguerite should become delirious.
“Listen,” I said. “You are ill. I can not leave you like this. I
will write and tell my father not to expect me.”
“No, no,” she cried hastily, “don't do that. Your father will accuse
me of hindering you again from going to see him when he wants to see
you; no, no, you must go, you must! Besides, I am not ill. I am quite
well. I had a bad dream and am not yet fully awake.”
From that moment Marguerite tried to seem more cheerful. There were
no more tears.
When the hour came for me to go, I embraced her and asked her if she
would come with me as far as the train; I hoped that the walk would
distract her and that the air would do her good. I wanted especially to
be with her as long as possible.
She agreed, put on her cloak and took Nanine with her, so as not to
return alone. Twenty times I was on the point of not going. But the
hope of a speedy return, and the fear of offending my father still
more, sustained me, and I took my place in the train.
“Till this evening!” I said to Marguerite, as I left her. She did
Once already she had not replied to the same words, and the Comte de
G., you will remember, had spent the night with her; but that time was
so far away that it seemed to have been effaced from my memory, and if
I had any fear, it was certainly not of Marguerite being unfaithful to
me. Reaching Paris, I hastened off to see Prudence, intending to ask
her to go and keep Marguerite company, in the hope that her mirth and
liveliness would distract her. I entered without being announced, and
found Prudence at her toilet.
“Ah!” she said, anxiously; “is Marguerite with you?”
“How is she?”
“She is not well.”
“Is she not coming?”
“Did you expect her?”
Madame Duvernoy reddened, and replied, with a certain constraint:
“I only meant that since you are at Paris, is she not coming to join
I looked at Prudence; she cast down her eyes, and I read in her face
the fear of seeing my visit prolonged.
“I even came to ask you, my dear Prudence, if you have nothing to do
this evening, to go and see Marguerite; you will be company for her,
and you can stay the night. I never saw her as she was to-day, and I am
afraid she is going to be ill.”
“I am dining in town,” replied Prudence, “and I can't go and see
Marguerite this evening. I will see her tomorrow.”
I took leave of Mme. Duvernoy, who seemed almost as preoccupied as
Marguerite, and went on to my father's; his first glance seemed to
study me attentively. He held out his hand.
“Your two visits have given me pleasure, Armand,” he said; “they
make me hope that you have thought over things on your side as I have
“May I ask you, father, what was the result of your reflection?”
“The result, my dear boy, is that I have exaggerated the importance
of the reports that had been made to me, and that I have made up my
mind to be less severe with you.”
“What are you saying, father?” I cried joyously.
“I say, my dear child, that every young man must have his mistress,
and that, from the fresh information I have had, I would rather see you
the lover of Mlle. Gautier than of any one else.”
“My dear father, how happy you make me!”
We talked in this manner for some moments, and then sat down to
table. My father was charming all dinner time.
I was in a hurry to get back to Bougival to tell Marguerite about
this fortunate change, and I looked at the clock every moment.
“You are watching the time,” said my father, “and you are impatient
to leave me. O young people, how you always sacrifice sincere to
“Do not say that, father; Marguerite loves me, I am sure of it.”
My father did not answer; he seemed to say neither yes nor no.
He was very insistent that I should spend the whole evening with him
and not go till the morning; but Marguerite had not been well when I
left her. I told him of it, and begged his permission to go back to her
early, promising to come again on the morrow.
The weather was fine; he walked with me as far as the station. Never
had I been so happy. The future appeared as I had long desired to see
it. I had never loved my father as I loved him at that moment.
Just as I was leaving him, he once more begged me to stay. I
“You are really very much in love with her?” he asked.
“Go, then,” and he passed his hand across his forehead as if to
chase a thought, then opened his mouth as if to say something; but he
only pressed my hand, and left me hurriedly, saying:
“Till to-morrow, then!”
It seemed to me as if the train did not move. I reached Bougival at
Not a window in the house was lighted up, and when I rang no one
answered the bell. It was the first time that such a thing had occurred
to me. At last the gardener came. I entered. Nanine met me with a
light. I went to Marguerite's room.
“Where is madame?”
“Gone to Paris,” replied Nanine.
“An hour after you.”
“She left no word for me?”
Nanine left me.
Perhaps she had some suspicion or other, I thought, and went to
Paris to make sure that my visit to my father was not an excuse for a
day off. Perhaps Prudence wrote to her about something important. I
said to myself when I was alone; but I saw Prudence; she said nothing
to make me suppose that she had written to Marguerite.
All at once I remembered Mme. Duvernoy's question, “Isn't she coming
to-day?” when I had said that Marguerite was ill. I remembered at the
same time how embarrassed Prudence had appeared when I looked at her
after this remark, which seemed to indicate an appointment. I
remembered, too, Marguerite's tears all day long, which my father's
kind reception had rather put out of my mind. From this moment all the
incidents grouped themselves about my first suspicion, and fixed it so
firmly in my mind that everything served to confirm it, even my
Marguerite had almost insisted on my going to Paris; she had
pretended to be calmer when I had proposed staying with her. Had I
fallen into some trap? Was Marguerite deceiving me? Had she counted on
being back in time for me not to perceive her absence, and had she been
detained by chance? Why had she said nothing to Nanine, or why had she
not written? What was the meaning of those tears, this absence, this
That is what I asked myself in affright, as I stood in the vacant
room, gazing at the clock, which pointed to midnight, and seemed to say
to me that it was too late to hope for my mistress's return. Yet, after
all the arrangements we had just made, after the sacrifices that had
been offered and accepted, was it likely that she was deceiving me? No.
I tried to get rid of my first supposition.
Probably she had found a purchaser for her furniture, and she had
gone to Paris to conclude the bargain. She did not wish to tell me
beforehand, for she knew that, though I had consented to it, the sale,
so necessary to our future happiness, was painful to me, and she feared
to wound my self-respect in speaking to me about it. She would rather
not see me till the whole thing was done, and that was evidently why
Prudence was expecting her when she let out the secret. Marguerite
could not finish the whole business to-day, and was staying the night
with Prudence, or perhaps she would come even now, for she must know
bow anxious I should be, and would not wish to leave me in that
condition. But, if so, why those tears? No doubt, despite her love for
me, the poor girl could not make up her mind to give up all the luxury
in which she had lived until now, and for which she had been so envied,
without crying over it. I was quite ready to forgive her for such
regrets. I waited for her impatiently, that I might say to her, as I
covered her with kisses, that I had guessed the reason of her
Nevertheless, the night went on, and Marguerite did not return.
My anxiety tightened its circle little by little, and began to
oppress my head and heart. Perhaps something had happened to her.
Perhaps she was injured, ill, dead. Perhaps a messenger would arrive
with the news of some dreadful accident. Perhaps the daylight would
find me with the same uncertainty and with the same fears.
The idea that Marguerite was perhaps unfaithful to me at the very
moment when I waited for her in terror at her absence did not return to
my mind. There must be some cause, independent of her will, to keep her
away from me, and the more I thought, the more convinced I was that
this cause could only be some mishap or other. O vanity of man, coming
back to us in every form!
One o'clock struck. I said to myself that I would wait another hour,
but that at two o'clock, if Marguerite had not returned, I would set
out for Paris. Meanwhile I looked about for a book, for I dared not
think. Manon Lescaut was open on the table. It seemed to me that here
and there the pages were wet as if with tears. I turned the leaves over
and then closed the book, for the letters seemed to me void of meaning
through the veil of my doubts.
Time went slowly. The sky was covered with clouds. An autumn rain
lashed the windows. The empty bed seemed at moments to assume the
aspect of a tomb. I was afraid.
I opened the door. I listened, and heard nothing but the voice of
the wind in the trees. Not a vehicle was to be seen on the road. The
half hour sounded sadly from the church tower.
I began to fear lest some one should enter. It seemed to me that
only a disaster could come at that hour and under that sombre sky.
Two o'clock struck. I still waited a little. Only the sound of the
bell troubled the silence with its monotonous and rhythmical stroke.
At last I left the room, where every object had assumed that
melancholy aspect which the restless solitude of the heart gives to all
In the next room I found Nanine sleeping over her work. At the sound
of the door, she awoke and asked if her mistress had come in.
“No; but if she comes in, tell her that I was so anxious that I had
to go to Paris.”
“At this hour?”
“But how? You won't find a carriage.”
“I will walk.”
“But it is raining.”
“But madame will be coming back, or if she doesn't come it will be
time enough in the morning to go and see what has kept her. You will be
murdered on the way.”
“There is no danger, my dear Nanine; I will see you to-morrow.”
The good girl went and got me a cloak, put it over my shoulders, and
offered to wake up Mme. Arnould to see if a vehicle could be obtained;
but I would hear of nothing, convinced as I was that I should lose, in
a perhaps fruitless inquiry, more time than I should take to cover half
the road. Besides, I felt the need of air and physical fatigue in order
to cool down the over- excitement which possessed me.
I took the key of the flat in the Rue d'Antin, and after saying
good-bye to Nanine, who came with me as far as the gate, I set out.
At first I began to run, but the earth was muddy with rain, and I
fatigued myself doubly. At the end of half an hour I was obliged to
stop, and I was drenched with sweat. I recovered my breath and went on.
The night was so dark that at every step I feared to dash myself
against one of the trees on the roadside, which rose up sharply before
me like great phantoms rushing upon me.
I overtook one or two wagons, which I soon left behind. A carriage
was going at full gallop toward Bougival. As it passed me the hope came
to me that Marguerite was in it. I stopped and cried out, “Marguerite!
Marguerite!” But no one answered and the carriage continued its course.
I watched it fade away in the distance, and then started on my way
again. I took two hours to reach the Barriere de l'Etoile. The sight of
Paris restored my strength, and I ran the whole length of the alley I
had so often walked.
That night no one was passing; it was like going through the midst
of a dead city. The dawn began to break. When I reached the Rue d'Antin
the great city stirred a little before quite awakening. Five o'clock
struck at the church of Saint Roch at the moment when I entered
Marguerite's house. I called out my name to the porter, who had had
from me enough twenty-franc pieces to know that I had the right to call
on Mlle. Gautier at five in the morning. I passed without difficulty. I
might have asked if Marguerite was at home, but he might have said
“No,” and I preferred to remain in doubt two minutes longer, for, as
long as I doubted, there was still hope.
I listened at the door, trying to discover a sound, a movement.
Nothing. The silence of the country seemed to be continued here. I
opened the door and entered. All the curtains were hermetically closed.
I drew those of the dining-room and went toward the bed-room and pushed
open the door. I sprang at the curtain cord and drew it violently. The
curtain opened, a faint light made its way in. I rushed to the bed. It
I opened the doors one after another. I visited every room. No one.
It was enough to drive one mad.
I went into the dressing-room, opened the window, and called
Prudence several times. Mme. Duvernoy's window remained closed.
I went downstairs to the porter and asked him if Mlle. Gautier had
come home during the day.
“Yes,” answered the man; “with Mme. Duvernoy.”
“She left no word for me?”
“Do you know what they did afterward?”
“They went away in a carriage.”
“What sort of a carriage?”
“A private carriage.”
What could it all mean?
I rang at the next door.
“Where are you going, sir?” asked the porter, when he had opened to
“To Mme. Duvernoy's.”
“She has not come back.”
“You are sure?”
“Yes, sir; here's a letter even, which was brought for her last
night and which I have not yet given her.”
And the porter showed me a letter which I glanced at mechanically. I
recognised Marguerite's writing. I took the letter. It was addressed,
“To Mme. Duvernoy, to forward to M. Duval.”
“This letter is for me,” I said to the porter, as I showed him the
“You are M. Duval?” he replied.
“Ah! I remember. You often came to see Mme. Duvernoy.”
When I was in the street I broke the seal of the letter. If a
thunder-bolt had fallen at my feet I should have been less startled
than I was by what I read.
“By the time you read this letter, Armand, I shall be the mistress
of another man. All is over between us.
“Go back to your father, my friend, and to your sister, and there,
by the side of a pure young girl, ignorant of all our miseries, you
will soon forget what you would have suffered through that lost
creature who is called Marguerite Gautier, whom you have loved for an
instant, and who owes to you the only happy moments of a life which,
she hopes, will not be very long now.”
When I had read the last word, I thought I should have gone mad. For
a moment I was really afraid of falling in the street. A cloud passed
before my eyes and my blood beat in my temples. At last I came to
myself a little. I looked about me, and was astonished to see the life
of others continue without pausing at my distress.
I was not strong enough to endure the blow alone. Then I remembered
that my father was in the same city, that I might be with him in ten
minutes, and that, whatever might be the cause of my sorrow, he would
I ran like a madman, like a thief, to the Hotel de Paris; I found
the key in the door of my father's room; I entered. He was reading. He
showed so little astonishment at seeing me, that it was as if he was
expecting me. I flung myself into his arms without saying a word. I
gave him Marguerite's letter, and, falling on my knees beside his bed,
I wept hot tears.
When the current of life had resumed its course, I could not believe
that the day which I saw dawning would not be like those which had
preceded it. There were moments when I fancied that some circumstance,
which I could not recollect, had obliged me to spend the night away
from Marguerite, but that, if I returned to Bougival, I should find her
again as anxious as I had been, and that she would ask me what had
detained me away from her so long.
When one's existence has contracted a habit, such as that of this
love, it seems impossible that the habit should be broken without at
the same time breaking all the other springs of life. I was forced from
time to time to reread Marguerite's letter, in order to convince myself
that I had not been dreaming.
My body, succumbing to the moral shock, was incapable of movement.
Anxiety, the night walk, and the morning's news had prostrated me. My
father profited by this total prostration of all my faculties to demand
of me a formal promise to accompany him. I promised all that he asked,
for I was incapable of sustaining a discussion, and I needed some
affection to help me to live, after what had happened. I was too
thankful that my father was willing to console me under such a
All that I remember is that on that day, about five o'clock, he took
me with him in a post-chaise. Without a word to me, he had had my
luggage packed and put up behind the chaise with his own, and so he
carried me off. I did not realize what I was doing until the town had
disappeared and the solitude of the road recalled to me the emptiness
of my heart. Then my tears again began to flow.
My father had realized that words, even from him, would do nothing
to console me, and he let me weep without saying a word, only sometimes
pressing my hand, as if to remind me that I had a friend at my side.
At night I slept a little. I dreamed of Marguerite.
I woke with a start, not recalling why I was in the carriage. Then
the truth came back upon me, and I let my head sink on my breast. I
dared not say anything to my father. I was afraid he would say, “You
see I was right when I declared that this woman did not love you.” But
he did not use his advantage, and we reached C. without his having said
anything to me except to speak of matters quite apart from the event
which had occasioned my leaving Paris.
When I embraced my sister, I remembered what Marguerite had said
about her in her letter, and I saw at once how little my sister, good
as she was, would be able to make me forget my mistress.
Shooting had begun, and my father thought that it would be a
distraction for me. He got up shooting parties with friends and
neighbours. I went without either reluctance or enthusiasm, with that
sort of apathy into which I had sunk since my departure.
We were beating about for game and I was given my post. I put down
my unloaded gun at my side, and meditated. I watched the clouds pass. I
let my thought wander over the solitary plains, and from time to time I
heard some one call to me and point to a hare not ten paces off. None
of these details escaped my father, and he was not deceived by my
exterior calm. He was well aware that, broken as I now was, I should
some day experience a terrible reaction, which might be dangerous, and,
without seeming to make any effort to console me, he did his utmost to
distract my thoughts.
My sister, naturally, knew nothing of what had happened, and she
could not understand how it was that I, who had formerly been so
lighthearted, had suddenly become so sad and dreamy.
Sometimes, surprising in the midst of my sadness my father's anxious
scrutiny, I pressed his hand as if to ask him tacitly to forgive me for
the pain which, in spite of myself, I was giving him.
Thus a month passed, but at the end of that time I could endure it
no longer. The memory of Marguerite pursued me unceasingly. I had
loved, I still loved this woman so much that I could not suddenly
become indifferent to her. I had to love or to hate her. Above all,
whatever I felt for her, I had to see her again, and at once. This
desire possessed my mind, and with all the violence of a will which had
begun to reassert itself in a body so long inert.
It was not enough for me to see Marguerite in a month, a week. I had
to see her the very next day after the day when the thought had
occurred to me; and I went to my father and told him that I had been
called to Paris on business, but that I should return promptly. No
doubt he guessed the reason of my departure, for he insisted that I
should stay, but, seeing that if I did not carry out my intention the
consequences, in the state in which I was, might be fatal, he embraced
me, and begged me, almost, with tears, to return without delay.
I did not sleep on the way to Paris. Once there, what was I going to
do? I did not know; I only knew that it must be something connected
with Marguerite. I went to my rooms to change my clothes, and, as the
weather was fine and it was still early, I made my way to the
Champs-Elysees. At the end of half an hour I saw Marguerite's carriage,
at some distance, coming from the Rond-Point to the Place de la
Concorde. She had repurchased her horses, for the carriage was just as
I was accustomed to see it, but she was not in it. Scarcely had I
noticed this fact, when looking around me, I saw Marguerite on foot,
accompanied by a woman whom I had never seen.
As she passed me she turned pale, and a nervous smile tightened
about her lips. For my part, my heart beat violently in my breast; but
I succeeded in giving a cold expression to my face, as I bowed coldly
to my former mistress, who just then reached her carriage, into which
she got with her friend.
I knew Marguerite: this unexpected meeting must certainly have upset
her. No doubt she had heard that I had gone away, and had thus been
reassured as to the consequences of our rupture; but, seeing me again
in Paris, finding herself face to face with me, pale as I was, she must
have realized that I had not returned without purpose, and she must
have asked herself what that purpose was.
If I had seen Marguerite unhappy, if, in revenging myself upon her,
I could have come to her aid, I should perhaps have forgiven her, and
certainly I should have never dreamt of doing her an injury. But I
found her apparently happy, some one else had restored to her the
luxury which I could not give her; her breaking with me seemed to
assume a character of the basest self-interest; I was lowered in my own
esteem as well as in my love. I resolved that she should pay for what I
I could not be indifferent to what she did, consequently what would
hurt her the most would be my indifference; it was, therefore, this
sentiment which I must affect, not only in her eyes, but in the eyes of
I tried to put on a smiling countenance, and I went to call on
Prudence. The maid announced me, and I had to wait a few minutes in the
drawing-room. At last Mme. Duvernoy appeared and asked me into her
boudoir; as I seated myself I heard the drawing-room door open, a light
footstep made the floor creak and the front door was closed violently.
“I am disturbing you,” I said to Prudence.
“Not in the least. Marguerite was there. When she heard you
announced, she made her escape; it was she who has just gone out.”
“Is she afraid of me now?”
“No. but she is afraid that you would not wish to see her.”
“But why?” I said, drawing my breath with difficulty, for I was
choked with emotion. “The poor girl left me for her carriage, her
furniture, and her diamonds; she did quite right, and I don't bear her
any grudge. I met her to-day,” I continued carelessly.
“Where?” asked Prudence, looking at me and seeming to ask herself if
this was the same man whom she had known so madly in love.
“In the Champs-Elysees. She was with another woman, very pretty. Who
“What was she like?”
“Blonde, slender, with side curls; blue eyes; very elegant.”
“Ali! It was Olympe; she is really very pretty.”
“Whom does she live with?”
“With nobody; with anybody.”
“Where does she live?”
“Rue Troncliet, No.—. Do you want to make love to her?”
“One never knows.”
“I should hardly tell you the truth if I said I think no more about
her; but I am one of those with whom everything depends on the way in
which one breaks with them. Now Marguerite ended with me so lightly
that I realize I was a great fool to have been as much in love with her
as I was, for I was really very much in love with that girl.”
You can imagine the way in which I said that; the sweat broke out on
“She was very fond of you, you know, and she still is; the proof is,
that after meeting you to-day, she came straight to tell me about it.
When she got here she was all of a tremble; I thought she was going to
“Well, what did she say?”
“She said, 'He is sure to come here,' and she begged me to ask you
to forgive her.”
“I have forgiven her, you may tell her. She was a good girl; but,
after all, like the others, and I ought to have expected what happened.
I am even grateful to her, for I see now what would have happened if I
had lived with her altogether. It was ridiculous.”
“She will be very glad to find that you take it so well. It was
quite time she left you, my dear fellow. The rascal of an agent to whom
she had offered to sell her furniture went around to her creditors to
find out how much she owed; they took fright, and in two days she would
have been sold up.”
“And now it is all paid?”
“More or less.”
“And who has supplied the money?”
“The Comte de N. Ah, my dear friend, there are men made on purpose
for such occasions. To cut a long story short he gave her twenty
thousand francs, but he has had his way at last. He knows quite well
that Marguerite is not in love with him; but he is very nice with her
all the same. As you have seen, he has repurchased her horses, he has
taken her jewels out of pawn, and he gives her as much money as the
duke used to give her; if she likes to live quietly, he will stay with
her a long time.”
“And what is she doing? Is she living in Paris altogether?”
“She would never go back to Bougival after you went. I had to go
myself and see after all her things, and yours, too. I made a package
of them and you can send here for them. You will find everything,
except a little case with your initials. Marguerite wanted to keep it.
If you really want it, I will ask her for it.”
“Let her keep it,” I stammered, for I felt the tears rise from my
heart to my eyes at the recollection of the village where I had been so
happy, and at the thought that Marguerite cared to keep something which
had belonged to me and would recall me to her. If she had entered at
that moment my thoughts of vengeance would have disappeared, and I
should have fallen at her feet.
“For the rest,” continued Prudence, “I never saw her as she is now;
she hardly takes any sleep, she goes to all the balls, she goes to
suppers, she even drinks. The other day, after a supper, she had to
stay in bed for a week; and when the doctor let her get up, she began
again at the risk of her life. Shall you go and see her?”
“What is the good? I came to see you, because you have always been
charming to me, and I knew you before I ever knew Marguerite. I owe it
to you that I have been her lover, and also, don't I, that I am her
lover no longer?”
“Well, I did all I could to get her away from you, and I believe you
will be thankful to me later on.”
I owe you a double gratitude,” I added, rising, for I was disgusted
with the woman, seeing her take every word I said to her as if it were
“You are going?”
I had learned enough.
“When shall I be seeing you?”
Prudence saw me to the door, and I went back to my own rooms with
tears of rage in my eyes and a desire for vengeance in my heart.
So Marguerite was no different from the others; so the steadfast
love that she had had for me could not resist the desire of returning
to her former life, and the need of having a carriage and plunging into
dissipation. So I said to myself, as I lay awake at night though if I
had reflected as calmly as I professed to I should have seen in this
new and turbulent life of Marguerite the attempt to silence a constant
thought, a ceaseless memory. Unfortunately, evil passion had the upper
hand, and I only sought for some means of avenging myself on the poor
creature. Oh, how petty and vile is man when he is wounded in one of
his narrow passions!
This Olympe whom I had seen was, if not a friend of Marguerite, at
all events the woman with whom she was most often seen since her return
to Paris. She was going to give a ball, and, as I took it for granted
that Marguerite would be there, I tried to get an invitation and
When, full of my sorrowful emotions, I arrived at the ball, it was
already very animated. They were dancing, shouting even, and in one of
the quadrilles I perceived Marguerite dancing with the Comte de N., who
seemed proud of showing her off, as if he said to everybody: “This
woman is mine.”
I leaned against the mantel-piece just opposite Marguerite and
watched her dancing. Her face changed the moment she caught sight of
me. I saluted her casually with a glance of the eyes and a wave of the
When I reflected that after the ball she would go home, not with me
but with that rich fool, when I thought of what would follow their
return, the blood rose to my face, and I felt the need of doing
something to trouble their relations.
After the contredanse I went up to the mistress of the house, who
displayed for the benefit of her guests a dazzling bosom and
magnificent shoulders. She was beautiful, and, from the point of view
of figure, more beautiful than Marguerite. I realized this fact still
more clearly from certain glances which Marguerite bestowed upon her
while I was talking with her. The man who was the lover of such a woman
might well be as proud as M. de N., and she was beautiful enough to
inspire a passion not less great than that which Marguerite had
inspired in me. At that moment she had no lover. It would not be
difficult to become so; it depended only on showing enough money to
attract her attention.
I made up my mind. That woman should be my mistress. I began by
dancing with her. Half an hour afterward, Marguerite, pale as death,
put on her pelisse and left the ball.
It was something already, but it was not enough. I saw the hold
which I had upon this woman, and I took a cowardly advantage of it.
When I think that she is dead now, I ask myself if God will ever
forgive me for the wrong I did her.
After the supper, which was noisy as could be, there was gambling. I
sat by the side of Olympe and put down my money so recklessly that she
could not but notice me. In an instant I had gained one hundred and
fifty or two hundred louis, which I spread out before me on the table,
and on which she fastened her eyes greedily.
I was the only one not completely absorbed by the game, and able to
pay her some attention. All the rest of the night I gained, and it was
I who gave her money to play, for she had lost all she had before her
and probably all she had in the house.
At five in the morning, the guests departed. I had gained three
All the players were already on their way downstairs; I was the only
one who had remained behind, and as I did not know any of them, no one
noticed it. Olympe herself was lighting the way, and I was going to
follow the others, when, turning back, I said to her:
“I must speak to you.”
“To-morrow,” she said.
“What have you to say?”
“You will see.”
And I went back into the room.
“You have lost,” I said.
“All that you had in the house?”
“Well, it is true.”
“I have won three hundred louis. Here they are, if you will let me
stay here to-night.”
And I threw the gold on the table.
“And why this proposition?”
“Because I am in love with you, of course.”
“No, but because you love Marguerite, and you want to have your
revenge upon her by becoming my lover. You don't deceive a woman like
me, my dear friend; unluckily, I am still too young and too
good-looking to accept the part that you offer me.”
“So you refuse?”
“Would you rather take me for nothing? It is I who wouldn't accept
then. Think it over, my dear Olympe; if I had sent some one to offer
you these three hundred louis on my behalf, on the conditions I attach
to them, you would have accepted. I preferred to speak to you myself.
Accept without inquiring into my reasons; say to yourself that you are
beautiful, and that there is nothing surprising in my being in love
Marguerite was a woman in the same position as Olympe, and yet I
should never have dared say to her the first time I met her what I had
said to the other woman. I loved Marguerite. I saw in her instincts
which were lacking in the other, and at the very moment in which I made
my bargain, I felt a disgust toward the woman with whom I was making
She accepted, of course, in the end, and at midday I left her house
as her lover; but I quitted her without a recollection of the caresses
and of the words of love which she had felt bound to shower upon me in
return for the six thousand francs which I left with her. And yet there
were men who had ruined themselves for that woman.
From that day I inflicted on Marguerite a continual persecution.
Olympe and she gave up seeing one another, as you might imagine. I gave
my new mistress a carriage and jewels. I gambled, I committed every
extravagance which could be expected of a man in love with such a woman
as Olympe. The report of my new infatuation was immediately spread
Prudence herself was taken in, and finally thought that I had
completely forgotten Marguerite. Marguerite herself, whether she
guessed my motive or was deceived like everybody else, preserved a
perfect dignity in response to the insults which I heaped upon her
daily. Only, she seemed to suffer, for whenever I met her she was more
and more pale, more and more sad. My love for her, carried to the point
at which it was transformed into hatred, rejoiced at the sight of her
daily sorrow. Often, when my cruelty toward her became infamous,
Marguerite lifted upon me such appealing eyes that I blushed for the
part I was playing, and was ready to implore her forgiveness.
But my repentance was only of a moment's duration, and Olympe, who
had finally put aside all self-respect, and discovered that by annoying
Marguerite she could get from me whatever she wanted, constantly
stirred up my resentment against her, and insulted her whenever she
found an opportunity, with the cowardly persistence of a woman licensed
by the authority of a man.
At last Marguerite gave up going to balls or theatres, for fear of
meeting Olympe and me. Then direct impertinences gave way to anonymous
letters, and there was not a shameful thing which I did not encourage
my mistress to relate and which I did not myself relate in reference to
To reach such a point I must have been literally mad. I was like a
man drunk upon bad wine, who falls into one of those nervous
exaltations in which the hand is capable of committing a crime without
the head knowing anything about it. In the midst of it all I endured a
martyrdom. The not disdainful calm, the not contemptuous dignity with
which Marguerite responded to all my attacks, and which raised her
above me in my own eyes, enraged me still more against her.
One evening Olympe had gone somewhere or other, and had met
Marguerite, who for once had not spared the foolish creature, so that
she had had to retire in confusion. Olympe returned in a fury, and
Marguerite fainted and had to be carried out. Olympe related to me what
had happened, declared that Marguerite, seeing her alone, had revenged
herself upon her because she was my mistress, and that I must write and
tell her to respect the woman whom I loved, whether I was present or
I need not tell you that I consented, and that I put into the letter
which I sent to her address the same day, everything bitter, shameful,
and cruel that I could think of.
This time the blow was more than the unhappy creature could endure
without replying. I felt sure that an answer would come, and I resolved
not to go out all day. About two there was a ring, and Prudence
I tried to assume an indifferent air as I asked her what had brought
her; but that day Mme. Duvernoy was not in a laughing humour, and in a
really moved voice she said to me that since my return, that is to say
for about three weeks, I had left no occasion untried which could give
pain to Marguerite, that she was completely upset by it, and that the
scene of last night and my angry letter of the morning had forced her
to take to her bed. In short, without making any reproach, Marguerite
sent to ask me for a little pity, since she had no longer the moral or
physical strength to endure what I was making her suffer.
“That Mlle. Gautier,” I said to Prudence, “should turn me out of her
own house is quite reasonable, but that she should insult the woman
whom I love, under the pretence that this woman is my mistress, is a
thing I will never permit.”
“My friend,” said Prudence, “you are under the influence of a woman
who has neither heart nor sense; you are in love with her, it is true,
but that is not a reason for torturing a woman who can not defend
“Let Mlle. Gautier send me her Comte de N. and the sides will be
“You know very well that she will not do that. So, my dear Armand,
let her alone. If you saw her you would be ashamed of the way in which
you are treating her. She is white, she coughs—she won't last long
And Prudence held out her hand to me, adding:
“Come and see her; it will make her very happy.”
“I have no desire to meet M. de N.”
“M. de N. is never there. She can not endure him.”
“If Marguerite wishes to see me, she knows where I live; let her
come to see me, but, for my part, I will never put foot in the Rue
“Will you receive her well?”
“Well, I am sure that she will come.”
“Let her come.”
“Shall you be out to-day?”
“I shall be at home all the evening.”
“I will tell her.”
And Prudence left me.
I did not even write to tell Olympe not to expect me. I never
troubled much about her, scarcely going to see her one night a week.
She consoled herself, I believe, with an actor from some theatre or
I went out for dinner and came back almost immediately. I had a fire
lit in my room and I told Joseph he could go out.
I can give you no idea of the different impressions which agitated
me during the hour in which I waited; but when, toward nine o'clock, I
heard a ring, they thronged together into one such emotion, that, as I
opened the door, I was obliged to lean against the wall to keep myself
Fortunately the anteroom was in half darkness, and the change in my
countenance was less visible. Marguerite entered.
She was dressed in black and veiled. I could scarcely recognise her
face through the veil. She went into the drawing-room and raised her
veil. She was pale as marble.
“I am here, Armand,” she said; “you wished to see me and I have
And letting her head fall on her hands, she burst into tears.
I went up to her.
“What is the matter?” I said to her in a low voice.
She pressed my hand without a word, for tears still veiled her
voice. But after a few minutes, recovering herself a little, she said
“You have been very unkind to me, Armand, and I have done nothing to
“Nothing?” I answered, with a bitter smile.
“Nothing but what circumstances forced me to do.”
I do not know if you have ever in your life experienced, or if you
will ever experience, what I felt at the sight of Marguerite.
The last time she had come to see me she had sat in the same place
where she was now sitting; only, since then, she had been the mistress
of another man, other kisses than mine had touched her lips, toward
which, in spite of myself, my own reached out, and yet I felt that I
loved this woman as much, more perhaps, than I had ever loved her.
It was difficult for me to begin the conversation on the subject
which brought her. Marguerite no doubt realized it, for she went on:
“I have come to trouble you, Armand, for I have two things to ask:
pardon for what I said yesterday to Mlle. Olympe, and pity for what you
are perhaps still ready to do to me. Intentionally or not, since your
return you have given me so much pain that I should be incapable now of
enduring a fourth part of what I have endured till now. You will have
pity on me, won't you? And you will understand that a man who is not
heartless has other nobler things to do than to take his revenge upon a
sick and sad woman like me. See, take my hand. I am in a fever. I left
my bed to come to you, and ask, not for your friendship, but for your
I took Marguerite's hand. It was burning, and the poor woman
shivered under her fur cloak.
I rolled the arm-chair in which she was sitting up to the fire.
“Do you think, then, that I did not suffer,” said I, “on that night
when, after waiting for you in the country, I came to look for you in
Paris, and found nothing but the letter which nearly drove me mad? How
could you have deceived me, Marguerite, when I loved you so much?
“Do not speak of that, Armand; I did not come to speak of that. I
wanted to see you only not an enemy, and I wanted to take your hand
once more. You have a mistress; she is young, pretty, you love her they
say. Be happy with her and forget me.”
“And you. You are happy, no doubt?”
“Have I the face of a happy woman, Armand? Do not mock my sorrow,
you, who know better than any one what its cause and its depth are.”
“It only depended on you not to have been unhappy at all, if you are
as you say.”
“No, my friend; circumstances were stronger than my will. I obeyed,
not the instincts of a light woman, as you seem to say, but a serious
necessity, and reasons which you will know one day, and which will make
you forgive me.”
“Why do you not tell me those reasons to-day?”
“Because they would not bring about an impossible reunion between
us, and they would separate you perhaps from those from whom you must
not be separated.”
“Who do you mean?”
“I can not tell you.”
“Then you are lying to me.”
Marguerite rose and went toward the door. I could not behold this
silent and expressive sorrow without being touched, when I compared in
my mind this pale and weeping woman with the madcap who had made fun of
me at the Opera Comique.
“You shall not go,” I said, putting myself in front of the door.
“Because, in spite of what you have done to me, I love you always,
and I want you to stay here.”
“To turn me out to-morrow? No; it is impossible. Our destinies are
separate; do not try to reunite them. You will despise me perhaps,
while now you can only hate me.”
“No, Marguerite,” I cried, feeling all my love and all my desire
reawaken at the contact of this woman. “No, I will forget everything,
and we will be happy as we promised one another that we would be.”
Marguerite shook her head doubtfully, and said:
“Am I not your slave, your dog? Do with me what you will. Take me; I
And throwing off her cloak and hat, she flung them on the sofa, and
began hurriedly to undo the front of her dress, for, by one of those
reactions so frequent in her malady, the blood rushed to her head and
stifled her. A hard, dry cough followed.
“Tell my coachman,” she said, “to go back with the carriage.”
I went down myself and sent him away. When I returned Marguerite was
lying in front of the fire, and her teeth chattered with the cold.
I took her in my arms. I undressed her, without her making a
movement, and carried her, icy cold, to the bed. Then I sat beside her
and tried to warm her with my caresses. She did not speak a word, but
smiled at me.
It was a strange night. All Marguerite's life seemed to have passed
into the kisses with which she covered me, and I loved her so much that
in my transports of feverish love I asked myself whether I should not
kill her, so that she might never belong to another.
A month of love like that, and there would have remained only the
corpse of heart or body.
The dawn found us both awake. Marguerite was livid white. She did
not speak a word. From time to time, big tears rolled from her eyes,
and stayed upon her cheeks, shining like diamonds. Her thin arms
opened, from time to time, to hold me fast, and fell back helplessly
upon the bed.
For a moment it seemed to me as if I could forget all that had
passed since I had left Bougival, and I said to Marguerite:
“Shall we go away and leave Paris?”
“No, no!” she said, almost with affright; “we should be too unhappy.
I can do no more to make you happy, but while there is a breath of life
in me, I will be the slave of your fancies. At whatever hour of the day
or night you will, come, and I will be yours; but do not link your
future any more with mine, you would be too unhappy and you would make
me too unhappy. I shall still be pretty for a while; make the most of
it, but ask nothing more.”
When she had gone, I was frightened at the solitude in which she
left me. Two hours afterward I was still sitting on the side of the
bed, looking at the pillow which kept the imprint of her form, and
asking myself what was to become of me, between my love and my
At five o'clock, without knowing what I was going to do, I went to
the Rue d'Antin.
Nanine opened to me.
“Madame can not receive you,” she said in an embarrassed way.
“Because M. le Comte de N. is there, and he has given orders to let
no one in.”
“Quite so,” I stammered; “I forgot.”
I went home like a drunken man, and do you know what I did during
the moment of jealous delirium which was long enough for the shameful
thing I was going to do? I said to myself that the woman was laughing
at me; I saw her alone with the count, saying over to him the same
words that she had said to me in the night, and taking a
five-hundred-franc note I sent it to her with these words:
“You went away so suddenly that I forgot to pay you. Here is the
price of your night.”
Then when the letter was sent I went out as if to free myself from
the instantaneous remorse of this infamous action.
I went to see Olympe, whom I found trying on dresses, and when we
were alone she sang obscene songs to amuse me. She was the very type of
the shameless, heartless, senseless courtesan, for me at least, for
perhaps some men might have dreamed of her as I dreamed of Marguerite.
She asked me for money. I gave it to her, and, free then to go, I
Marguerite had not answered.
I need not tell you in what state of agitation I spent the next day.
At half past nine a messenger brought me an envelope containing my
letter and the five-hundred-franc note, not a word more.
“Who gave you this?” I asked the man.
“A lady who was starting with her maid in the next mail for
Boulogne, and who told me not to take it until the coach was out of the
I rushed to the Rue d'Antin.
“Madame left for England at six o'clock,” said the porter.
There was nothing to hold me in Paris any longer, neither hate nor
love. I was exhausted by this series of shocks. One of my friends was
setting out on a tour in the East. I told my father I should like to
accompany him; my father gave me drafts and letters of introduction,
and eight or ten days afterward I embarked at Marseilles.
It was at Alexandria that I learned from an attache at the embassy,
whom I had sometimes seen at Marguerite's, that the poor girl was
I then wrote her the letter which she answered in the way you know;
I received it at Toulon.
I started at once, and you know the rest.
Now you have only to read a few sheets which Julie Duprat gave me;
they are the best commentary on what I have just told you.
Armand, tired by this long narrative, often interrupted by his
tears, put his two hands over his forehead and closed his eyes to
think, or to try to sleep, after giving me the pages written by the
hand of Marguerite. A few minutes after, a more rapid breathing told me
that Armand slept, but that light sleep which the least sound banishes.
This is what I read; I copy it without adding or omitting a
To-day is the 15th December. I have been ill three or four days.
This morning I stayed in bed. The weather is dark, I am sad; there is
no one by me. I think of you, Armand. And you, where are you, while I
write these lines? Far from Paris, far, far, they tell me, and perhaps
you have already forgotten Marguerite. Well, be happy; I owe you the
only happy moments in my life.
I can not help wanting to explain all my conduct to you, and I have
written you a letter; but, written by a girl like me, such a letter
might seem to be a lie, unless death had sanctified it by its
authority, and, instead of a letter, it were a confession.
To-day I am ill; I may die of this illness, for I have always had
the presentiment that I shall die young. My mother died of consumption,
and the way I have always lived could but increase the only heritage
she ever left me. But I do not want to die without clearing up for you
everything about me; that is, if, when you come back, you will still
trouble yourself about the poor girl whom you loved before you went
This is what the letter contained; I shall like writing it over
again, so as to give myself another proof of my own justification.
You remember, Armand, how the arrival of your father surprised us at
Bougival; you remember the involuntary fright that his arrival caused
me, and the scene which took place between you and him, which you told
me of in the evening.
Next day, when you were at Paris, waiting for your father, and he
did not return, a man came to the door and handed in a letter from M.
His letter, which I inclose with this, begged me, in the most
serious terms, to keep you away on the following day, on some excuse or
other, and to see your father, who wished to speak to me, and asked me
particularly not to say anything to you about it.
You know how I insisted on your returning to Paris next day.
You had only been gone an hour when your father presented himself. I
won't say what impression his severe face made upon me. Your father had
the old theory that a courtesan is a being without heart or reason, a
sort of machine for coining gold, always ready, like the machine, to
bruise the hand that gives her everything, and to tear in pieces,
without pity or discernment, those who set her in motion.
Your father had written me a very polite letter, in order that I
might consent to see him; he did not present himself quite as he had
written. His manner at first was so stiff, insolent, and even
threatening, that I had to make him understand that I was in my own
house, and that I had no need to render him an account of my life,
except because of the sincere affection which I had for his son.
M. Duval calmed down a little, but still went on to say that he
could not any longer allow his son to ruin himself over me; that I was
beautiful, it was true, but, however beautiful I might be, I ought not
to make use of my beauty to spoil the future of a young man by such
expenditure as I was causing.
At that there was only one thing to do, to show him the proof that
since I was your mistress I had spared no sacrifice to be faithful to
you without asking for more money than you had to give me. I showed him
the pawn tickets, the receipts of the people to whom I had sold what I
could not pawn; I told him of my resolve to part with my furniture in
order to pay my debts, and live with you without being a too heavy
expense. I told him of our happiness, of how you had shown me the
possibility of a quieter and happier life, and he ended by giving in to
the evidence, offering me his hand, and asking pardon for the way in
which he had at first approached me.
Then he said to me:
“So, madame, it is not by remonstrances or by threats, but by
entreaties, that I must endeavour to obtain from you a greater
sacrifice than you have yet made for my son.”
I trembled at this beginning.
Your father came over to me, took both my hands, and continued in an
“My child, do not take what I have to say to you amiss; only
remember that there are sometimes in life cruel necessities for the
heart, but that they must be submitted to. You are good, your soul has
generosity unknown to many women who perhaps despise you, and are less
worthy than you. But remember that there is not only the mistress, but
the family; that besides love there are duties; that to the age of
passion succeeds the age when man, if he is to be respected, must plant
himself solidly in a serious position. My son has no fortune, and yet
he is ready to abandon to you the legacy of his mother. If he accepted
from you the sacrifice which you are on the point of making, his honour
and dignity would require him to give you, in exchange for it, this
income, which would always put you out of danger of adversity. But he
can not accept this sacrifice, because the world, which does not know
you, would give a wrong interpretation to this acceptance, and such an
interpretation must not tarnish the name which we bear. No one would
consider whether Armand loves you, whether you love him, whether this
mutual love means happiness to him and redemption to you; they would
see only one thing, that Armand Duval allowed a kept woman (forgive me,
my child, for what I am forced to say to you) to sell all she had for
him. Then the day of reproaches and regrets would arrive, be sure, for
you or for others, and you would both bear a chain that you could not
sever. What would you do then? Your youth would be lost, my son's
future destroyed; and I, his father, should receive from only one of my
children the recompense that I look for from both.
“You are young, beautiful, life will console you; you are noble, and
the memory of a good deed will redeem you from many past deeds. During
the six months that he has known you Armand has forgotten me. I wrote
to him four times, and he has never once replied. I might have died and
he not known it!
“Whatever may be your resolution of living otherwise than as you
have lived, Armand, who loves you, will never consent to the seclusion
to which his modest fortune would condemn you, and to which your beauty
does not entitle you. Who knows what he would do then! He has gambled,
I know; without telling you of it, I know also, but, in a moment of
madness, he might have lost part of what I have saved, during many
years, for my daughter's portion, for him, and for the repose of my old
age. What might have happened may yet happen.
“Are you sure, besides, that the life which you are giving up for
him will never again come to attract you? Are you sure, you who have
loved him, that you will never love another? Would you not-suffer on
seeing the hindrances set by your love to your lover's life, hindrances
for which you would be powerless to console him, if, with age, thoughts
of ambition should succeed to dreams of love? Think over all that,
madame. You love Armand; prove it to him by the sole means which
remains to you of yet proving it to him, by sacrificing your love to
his future. No misfortune has yet arrived, but one will arrive, and
perhaps a greater one than those which I foresee. Armand might become
jealous of a man who has loved you; he might provoke him, fight, be
killed. Think, then, what you would suffer in the presence of a father
who should call on you to render an account for the life of his son!
“Finally, my dear child, let me tell you all, for I have not yet
told you all, let me tell you what has brought me to Paris. I have a
daughter, as I have told you, young, beautiful, pure as an angel. She
loves, and she, too, has made this love the dream of her life. I wrote
all that to Armand, but, absorbed in you, he made no reply. Well, my
daughter is about to marry. She is to marry the man whom she loves; she
enters an honourable family, which requires that mine has to be no less
honourable. The family of the man who is to become my son-in-law has
learned what manner of life Armand is leading in Paris, and has
declared to me that the marriage must be broken off if Armand continues
this life. The future of a child who has done nothing against you, and
who has the right of looking forward to a happy future, is in your
hands. Have you the right, have you the strength, to shatter it? In the
name of your love and of your repentance, Marguerite, grant me the
happiness of my child.”
I wept silently, my friend, at all these reflections which I had so
often made, and which, in the mouth of your father, took a yet more
serious reality. I said to myself all that your father dared not say to
me, though it had come to his lips twenty times: that I was, after all,
only a kept woman, and that whatever excuse I gave for our liaison, it
would always look like calculation on my part; that my past life left
me no right to dream of such a future, and that I was accepting
responsibilities for which my habits and reputation were far from
giving any guarantee. In short, I loved you, Armand.
The paternal way in which M. Duval had spoken to me; the pure
memories that he awakened in me; the respect of this old man, which I
would gain; yours, which I was sure of gaining later on: all that
called up in my heart thoughts which raised me in my own eyes with a
sort of holy pride, unknown till then. When I thought that one day this
old man, who was now imploring me for the future of his son, would bid
his daughter mingle my name with her prayers, as the name of a
mysterious friend, I seemed to become transformed, and I felt a pride
The exaltation of the moment perhaps exaggerated the truth of these
impressions, but that was what I felt, friend, and these new feelings
silenced the memory of the happy days I had spent with you.
“Tell me, sir,” I said to your father, wiping away my tears, “do you
believe that I love your son?”
“Yes,” said M. Duval.
“With a disinterested love?”
“Do you believe that I had made this love the hope, the dream, the
forgiveness—of my life?”
“Well, sir, embrace me once, as you would embrace your daughter, and
I swear to you that that kiss, the only chaste kiss I have ever had,
will make me strong against my love, and that within a week your son
will be once more at your side, perhaps unhappy for a time, but cured
“You are a noble child,” replied your father, kissing me on the
forehead, “and you are making an attempt for which God will reward you;
but I greatly fear that you will have no influence upon my son.”
“Oh, be at rest, sir; he will hate me.”
I had to set up between us, as much for me as for you, an
I wrote to Prudence to say that I accepted the proposition of the
Comte de N., and that she was to tell him that I would sup with her and
him. I sealed the letter, and, without telling him what it contained,
asked your father to have it forwarded to its address on reaching
He inquired of me what it contained.
“Your son's welfare,” I answered.
Your father embraced me once more. I felt two grateful tears on my
forehead, like the baptism of my past faults, and at the moment when I
consented to give myself up to another man I glowed with pride at the
thought of what I was redeeming by this new fault.
It was quite natural, Armand. You told me that your father was the
most honest man in the world.
M. Duval returned to his carriage, and set out for Paris.
I was only a woman, and when I saw you again I could not help
weeping, but I did not give way.
Did I do right? That is what I ask myself to-day, as I lie ill in my
bed, that I shall never leave, perhaps, until I am dead.
You are witness of what I felt as the hour of our separation
approached; your father was no longer there to support me, and there
was a moment when I was on the point of confessing everything to you,
so terrified was I at the idea that you were going to bate and despise
One thing which you will not believe, perhaps, Armand, is that I
prayed God to give me strength; and what proves that he accepted my
sacrifice is that he gave me the strength for which I prayed.
At supper I still had need of aid, for I could not think of what I
was going to do, so much did I fear that my courage would fail me. Who
would ever have said that I, Marguerite Gautier, would have suffered so
at the mere thought of a new lover? I drank for forgetfulness, and when
I woke next day I was beside the count.
That is the whole truth, friend. judge me and pardon me, as I have
pardoned you for all the wrong that you have done me since that day.
What followed that fatal night you know as well as I; but what you
can not know, what you can not suspect, is what I have suffered since
I heard that your father had taken you away with him, but I felt
sure that you could not live away from me for long, and when I met you
in the Champs-Elysees, I was a little upset, but by no means surprised.
Then began that series of days; each of them brought me a fresh
insult from you. I received them all with a kind of joy, for, besides
proving to me that you still loved me, it seemed to me as if the more
you persecuted me the more I should be raised in your eyes when you
came to know the truth.
Do not wonder at my joy in martyrdom, Armand; your love for me had
opened my heart to noble enthusiasm.
Still, I was not so strong as that quite at once.
Between the time of the sacrifice made for you and the time of your
return a long while elapsed, during which I was obliged to have
recourse to physical means in order not to go mad, and in order to be
blinded and deafened in the whirl of life into which I flung myself.
Prudence has told you (has she not?) how I went to all the fetes and
balls and orgies. I had a sort of hope that I should kill myself by all
these excesses, and I think it will not be long before this hope is
realized. My health naturally got worse and worse, and when I sent Mme.
Duvernoy to ask you for pity I was utterly worn out, body and soul.
I will not remind you, Armand, of the return you made for the last
proof of love that I gave you, and of the outrage by which you drove
away a dying woman, who could not resist your voice when you asked her
for a night of love, and who, like a fool, thought for one instant that
she might again unite the past with the present. You had the right to
do what you did, Armand; people have not always put so high a price on
a night of mine!
I left everything after that. Olympe has taken my place with the
Comte de N., and has told him, I hear, the reasons for my leaving him.
The Comte de G. was at London. He is one of those men who give just
enough importance to making love to women like me for it to be an
agreeable pastime, and who are thus able to remain friends with women,
not hating them because they have never been jealous of them, and he
is, too, one of those grand seigneurs who open only a part of their
hearts to us, but the whole of their purses. It was of him that I
immediately thought. I joined him in London. He received me as kindly
as possible, but he was the lover there of a woman in society, and he
feared to compromise himself if he were seen with me. He introduced me
to his friends, who gave a supper in my honour, after which one of them
took me home with him.
What else was there for me to do, my friend? If I had killed myself
it would have burdened your life, which ought to be happy, with a
needless remorse; and then, what is the good of killing oneself when
one is so near dying already?
I became a body without a soul, a thing without a thought; I lived
for some time in that automatic way; then I returned to Paris, and
asked after you; I heard then that you were gone on a long voyage.
There was nothing left to hold me to life. My existence became what it
had been two years before I knew you. I tried to win back the duke, but
I had offended him too deeply. Old men are not patient, no doubt
because they realize that they are not eternal. I got weaker every day.
I was pale and sad and thinner than ever. Men who buy love examine the
goods before taking them. At Paris there were women in better health,
and not so thin as I was; I was rather forgotten. That is all the past
up to yesterday.
Now I am seriously ill. I have written to the duke to ask him for
money, for I have none, and the creditors have returned, and come to me
with their bills with pitiless perseverance. Will the duke answer? Why
are you not in Paris, Armand? You would come and see me, and your
visits would do me good.
The weather is horrible; it is snowing, and I am alone. I have been
in such a fever for the last three days that I could not write you a
word. No news, my friend; every day I hope vaguely for a letter from
you, but it does not come, and no doubt it will never come. Only men
are strong enough not to forgive. The duke has not answered.
Prudence is pawning my things again.
I have been spitting blood all the time. Oh, you would be sorry for
me if you could see me. You are indeed happy to be under a warm sky,
and not, like me, with a whole winter of ice on your chest. To-day I
got up for a little while, and looked out through the curtains of my
window, and watched the life of Paris passing below, the life with
which I have now nothing more to do. I saw the faces of some people I
knew, passing rapidly, joyous and careless. Not one lifted his eyes to
my window. However, a few young men have come to inquire for me. Once
before I was ill, and you, though you did not know me, though you had
had nothing from me but an impertinence the day I met you first, you
came to inquire after me every day. We spent six months together. I had
all the love for you that a woman's heart can hold and give, and you
are far away, you are cursing me, and there is not a word of
consolation from you. But it is only chance that has made you leave me,
I am sure, for if you were at Paris, you would not leave my bedside.
My doctor tells me I must not write every day. And indeed my
memories only increase my fever, but yesterday I received a letter
which did me good, more because of what it said than by the material
help which it contained. I can write to you, then, to-day. This letter
is from your father, and this is what it says:
“MADAME: I have just learned that you are ill. If I were at Paris I
would come and ask after you myself; if my son were here I would send
him; but I can not leave C., and Armand is six or seven hundred leagues
from here; permit me, then, simply to write to you, madame, to tell you
how pained I am to hear of your illness, and believe in my sincere
wishes for your speedy recovery.
One of my good friends, M. H., will call on you; will you kindly
receive him? I have intrusted him with a commission, the result of
which I await impatiently. “Believe me, madame,
“Yours most faithfully.”
This is the letter he sent me. Your father has a noble heart; love
him well, my friend, for there are few men so worthy of being loved.
This paper signed by his name has done me more good than all the
prescriptions of our great doctor.
This morning M. H. called. He seemed much embarrassed by the
delicate mission which M. Duval had intrusted to him. As a matter of
fact, he came to bring me three thousand francs from your father. I
wanted to refuse at first, but M. H. told me that my refusal would
annoy M. Duval, who had authorized him to give me this sum now, and
later on whatever I might need. I accepted it, for, coming from your
father, it could not be exactly taking alms. If I am dead when you come
back, show your father what I have written for him, and tell him that
in writing these lines the poor woman to whom he was kind enough to
write so consoling a letter wept tears of gratitude and prayed God for
I have passed some terrible days. I never knew the body could suffer
so. Oh, my past life! I pay double for it now.
There has been some one to watch by me every night; I can not
breathe. What remains of my poor existence is shared between being
delirious and coughing.
The dining-room is full of sweets and all sorts of presents that my
friends have brought. Some of them, I dare say, are hoping that I shall
be their mistress later on. If they could see what sickness has made of
me, they would go away in terror.
Prudence is giving her New Year's presents with those I have
There is a thaw, and the doctor says that I may go out in a few days
if the fine weather continues.
I went out yesterday in my carriage. The weather was lovely. The
Champs-Elysees was full of people. It was like the first smile of
spring. Everything about me had a festal air. I never knew before that
a ray of sunshine could contain so much joy, sweetness, and
I met almost all the people I knew, all happy, all absorbed in their
pleasures. How many happy people don't even know that they are happy!
Olympe passed me in an elegant carriage that M. de N. has given her.
She tried to insult me by her look. She little knows how far I am from
such things now. A nice fellow, whom I have known for a long time,
asked me if I would have supper with him and one of his friends, who,
he said, was very anxious to make my acquaintance. I smiled sadly and
gave him my hand, burning with fever. I never saw such an astonished
I came in at four, and had quite an appetite for my dinner. Going
out has done me good. If I were only going to get well! How the sight
of the life and happiness of others gives a desire of life to those
who, only the night before, in the solitude of their soul and in the
shadow of their sick-room, only wanted to die soon!
The hope of getting better was only a dream. I am back in bed again,
covered with plasters which burn me. If I were to offer the body that
people paid so dear for once, how much would they give, I wonder,
We must have done something very wicked before we were born, or else
we must be going to be very happy indeed when we are dead, for God to
let this life have all the tortures of expiation and all the sorrows of
I am always ill.
The Comte de N. sent me some money yesterday. I did not keep it. I
won't take anything from that man. It is through him that you are not
Oh, that good time at Bougival! Where is it now?
If I come out of this room alive I will make a pilgrimage to the
house we lived in together, but I will never leave it until I am dead.
Who knows if I shall write to you to-morrow?
I have not slept for eleven nights. I am suffocated. I imagine every
moment that I am going to die. The doctor has forbidden me to touch a
pen. Julie Duprat, who is looking after me, lets me write these few
lines to you. Will you not come back before I die? Is it all over
between us forever? It seems to me as if I should get well if you came.
What would be the good of getting well?
This morning I was awakened by a great noise. Julie, who slept in my
room, ran into the dining-room. I heard men's voices, and hers
protesting against them in vain. She came back crying.
They had come to seize my things. I told her to let what they call
justice have its way. The bailiff came into my room with his hat on. He
opened the drawers, wrote down what he saw, and did not even seem to be
aware that there was a dying woman in the bed that fortunately the
charity of the law leaves me.
He said, indeed, before going, that I could appeal within nine days,
but he left a man behind to keep watch. My God! what is to become of
me? This scene has made me worse than I was before. Prudence wanted to
go and ask your father's friend for money, but I would not let her.
I received your letter this morning. I was in need of it. Will my
answer reach you in time? Will you ever see me again? This is a happy
day, and it has made me forget all the days I have passed for the last
six weeks. I seem as if I am better, in spite of the feeling of sadness
under the impression of which I replied to you.
After all, no one is unhappy always.
When I think that it may happen to me not to die, for you to come
back, for me to see the spring again, for you still to love me, and for
us to begin over again our last year's life!
Fool that I am! I can scarcely hold the pen with which I write to
you of this wild dream of my heart.
Whatever happens, I loved you well, Armand, and I would have died
long ago if I had not had the memory of your love to help me and a sort
of vague hope of seeing you beside me again.
The Comte de G. has returned. His mistress has been unfaithful to
him. He is very sad; he was very fond of her. He came to tell me all
about it. The poor fellow is in rather a bad way as to money; all the
same, he has paid my bailiff and sent away the man.
I talked to him about you, and he promised to tell you about me. I
forgot that I had been his mistress, and he tried to make me forget it,
too. He is a good friend.
The duke sent yesterday to inquire after me, and this morning he
came to see me. I do not know how the old man still keeps alive. He
remained with me three hours and did not say twenty words. Two big
tears fell from his eyes when he saw how pale I was. The memory of his
daughter's death made him weep, no doubt. He will have seen her die
twice. His back was bowed, his head bent toward the ground, his lips
drooping, his eyes vacant. Age and sorrow weigh with a double weight on
his worn-out body. He did not reproach me. It looked as if he rejoiced
secretly to see the ravages that disease had made in me. He seemed
proud of being still on his feet, while I, who am still young, was
broken down by suffering.
The bad weather has returned. No one comes to see me. Julie watches
by me as much as she can. Prudence, to whom I can no longer give as
much as I used to, begins to make excuses for not coming.
Now that I am so near death, in spite of what the doctors tell me,
for I have several, which proves that I am getting worse, I am almost
sorry that I listened to your father; if I had known that I should only
be taking a year of your future, I could not have resisted the longing
to spend that year with you, and, at least, I should have died with a
friend to hold my hand. It is true that if we had lived together this
year, I should not have died so soon.
God's will be done!
Oh, come, come, Armand! I suffer horribly; I am going to die, O God!
I was so miserable yesterday that I wanted to spend the evening, which
seemed as if it were going to be as long as the last, anywhere but at
home. The duke came in the morning. It seems to me as if the sight of
this old man, whom death has forgotten, makes me die faster.
Despite the burning fever which devoured me, I made them dress me
and take me to the Vaudeville. Julie put on some rouge for me, without
which I should have looked like a corpse. I had the box where I gave
you our first rendezvous. All the time I had my eyes fixed on the stall
where you sat that day, though a sort of country fellow sat there,
laughing loudly at all the foolish things that the actors said. I was
half dead when they brought me home. I coughed and spat blood all the
night. To-day I can not speak, I can scarcely move my arm. My God! My
God! I am going to die! I have been expecting it, but I can not get
used to the thought of suffering more than I suffer now, and if—
After this the few characters traced by Marguerite were
indecipherable, and what followed was written by Julie Duprat.
Since the day that Marguerite insisted on going to the theatre she
has got worse and worse. She has completely lost her voice, and now the
use of her limbs.
What our poor friend suffers is impossible to say. I am not used to
emotions of this kind, and I am in a state of constant fright.
How I wish you were here! She is almost always delirious; but
delirious or lucid, it is always your name that she pronounces, when
she can speak a word.
The doctor tells me that she is not here for long. Since she got so
ill the old duke has not returned. He told the doctor that the sight
was too much for him.
Mme. Duvernoy is not behaving well. This woman, who thought she
could get more money out of Marguerite, at whose expense she was living
almost completely, has contracted liabilities which she can not meet,
and seeing that her neighbour is no longer of use to her, she does not
even come to see her. Everybody is abandoning her. M. de G., prosecuted
for his debts, has had to return to London. On leaving, he sent us more
money; he has done all he could, but they have returned to seize the
things, and the creditors are only waiting for her to die in order to
I wanted to use my last resources to put a stop to it, but the
bailiff told me it was no use, and that there are other seizures to
follow. Since she must die, it is better to let everything go than to
save it for her family, whom she has never cared to see, and who have
never cared for her. You can not conceive in the midst of what gilded
misery the poor thing is dying. Yesterday we had absolutely no money.
Plate, jewels, shawls, everything is in pawn; the rest is sold or
seized. Marguerite is still conscious of what goes on around her, and
she suffers in body, mind, and heart. Big tears trickle down her
cheeks, so thin and pale that you would never recognise the face of her
whom you loved so much, if you could see her. She has made me promise
to write to you when she can no longer write, and I write before her.
She turns her eyes toward me, but she no longer sees me; her eyes are
already veiled by the coming of death; yet she smiles, and all her
thoughts, all her soul are yours, I am sure.
Every time the door opens her eyes brighten, and she thinks you are
going to come in; then, when she sees that it is not you, her face
resumes its sorrowful expression, a cold sweat breaks out over it, and
her cheek-bones flush.
February 19, midnight.
What a sad day we have had to-day, poor M. Armand! This morning
Marguerite was stifling; the doctor bled her, and her voice has
returned to her a while. The doctor begged her to see a priest. She
said “Yes,” and he went himself to fetch an abbe' from Saint Roch.
Meanwhile Marguerite called me up to her bed, asked me to open a
cupboard, and pointed out a cap and a long chemise covered with lace,
and said in a feeble voice:
“I shall die as soon as I have confessed. Then you will dress me in
these things; it is the whim of a dying woman.?
Then she embraced me with tears and added:
“I can speak, but I am stifled when I speak; I am stifling. Air!”
I burst into tears, opened the window, and a few minutes afterward
the priest entered. I went up to him; when he knew where he was, he
seemed afraid of being badly received.
“Come in boldly, father,” I said to him.
He stayed a very short time in the room, and when he came out he
said to me:
“She lived a sinner, and she will die a Christian.”
A few minutes afterward he returned with a choir boy bearing a
crucifix, and a sacristan who went before them ringing the bell to
announce that God was coming to the dying one.
They went all three into the bed-room where so many strange words
have been said, but was now a sort of holy tabernacle.
I fell on my knees. I do not know how long the impression of what I
saw will last, but I do not think that, till my turn comes, any human
thing can make so deep an impression on me.
The priest anointed with holy oil the feet and hands and forehead of
the dying woman, repeated a short prayer, and Marguerite was ready to
set out for the heaven to which I doubt not she will go, if God has
seen the ordeal of her life and the sanctity of her death.
Since then she has not said a word or made a movement. Twenty times
I should have thought her dead if I had not heard her breathing
February 20, 5 P.M.
All is over.
Marguerite fell into her last agony at about two o'clock. Never did
a martyr suffer such torture, to judge by the cries she uttered. Two or
three times she sat upright in the bed, as if she would hold on to her
life, which was escaping toward God.
Two or three times also she said your name; then all was silent, and
she fell back on the bed exhausted. Silent tears flowed from her eyes,
and she was dead.
Then I went up to her; I called her, and as she did not answer I
closed her eyes and kissed her on the forehead.
Poor, dear Marguerite, I wish I were a holy woman that my kiss might
recommend you to God.
Then I dressed her as she had asked me to do. I went to find a
priest at Saint Roch, I burned two candles for her, and I prayed in the
church for an hour.
I gave the money she left to the poor.
I do not know much about religion, but I think that God will know
that my tears were genuine, my prayers fervent, my alms-giving sincere,
and that he will have pity on her who, dying young and beautiful, has
only had me to close her eyes and put her in her shroud.
The burial took place to-day. Many of Marguerite's friends came to
the church. Some of them wept with sincerity. When the funeral started
on the way to Montmartre only two men followed it: the Comte de G., who
came from London on purpose, and the duke, who was supported by two
I write you these details from her house, in the midst of my tears
and under the lamp which burns sadly beside a dinner which I can not
touch, as you can imagine, but which Nanine has got for me, for I have
eaten nothing for twenty-four hours.
My life can not retain these sad impressions for long, for my life
is not my own any more than Marguerite's was hers; that is why I give
you all these details on the very spot where they occurred, in the
fear, if a long time elapsed between them and your return, that I might
not be able to give them to you with all their melancholy exactitude.
“You have read it?” said Armand, when I had finished the manuscript.
“I understand what you must have suffered, my friend, if all that I
read is true.”
“My father confirmed it in a letter.”
We talked for some time over the sad destiny which had been
accomplished, and I went home to rest a little.
Armand, still sad, but a little relieved by the narration of his
story, soon recovered, and we went together to pay a visit to Prudence
and to Julie Duprat.
Prudence had become bankrupt. She told us that Marguerite was the
cause of it; that during her illness she had lent her a lot of money in
the form of promissory notes, which she could not pay, Marguerite
having died without having returned her the money, and without having
given her a receipt with which she could present herself as a creditor.
By the help of this fable, which Mme. Duvernoy repeated everywhere
in order to account for her money difficulties, she extracted a note
for a thousand francs from Armand, who did not believe it, but who
pretended to, out of respect for all those in whose company Marguerite
Then we called on Julie Duprat, who told us the sad incident which
she had witnessed, shedding real tears at the remembrance of her
Lastly, we went to Marguerite's grave, on which the first rays of
the April sun were bringing the first leaves into bud.
One duty remained to Armand—to return to his father. He wished me
to accompany him.
We arrived at C., where I saw M. Duval, such as I had imagined him
from the portrait his son had made of him, tall, dignified, kindly.
He welcomed Armand with tears of joy, and clasped my hand
affectionately. I was not long in seeing that the paternal sentiment
was that which dominated all others in his mind.
His daughter, named Blanche, had that transparence of eyes, that
serenity of the mouth, which indicates a soul that conceives only holy
thoughts and lips that repeat only pious words. She welcomed her
brother's return with smiles, not knowing, in the purity of her youth,
that far away a courtesan had sacrificed her own happiness at the mere
invocation of her name.
I remained for some time in their happy family, full of indulgent
care for one who brought them the convalescence of his heart.
I returned to Paris, where I wrote this story just as it had been
told me. It has only one merit, which will perhaps be denied it; that
is, that it is true.
I do not draw from this story the conclusion that all women like
Marguerite are capable of doing all that she did—far from it; but I
have discovered that one of them experienced a serious love in the
course of her life, that she suffered for it, and that she died of it.
I have told the reader all that I learned. It was my duty.
I am not the apostle of vice, but I would gladly be the echo of
noble sorrow wherever I bear its voice in prayer.
The story of Marguerite is an exception, I repeat; had it not been
an exception, it would not have been worth the trouble of writing it.