Her First Appearance by Richard Harding Davis
It was at the end of the first act of the first night of "The Sultana," and every member of the Lester Comic Opera
Company, from Lester himself down to the wardrobe woman's son, who would have had to work if his mother lost
her place, was sick with anxiety.
There is perhaps only one other place as feverish as it is behind the scenes on the first night of a comic opera,
and that is a newspaper office on the last night of a Presidential campaign, when the returns are being flashed on
the canvas outside, and the mob is howling, and the editor-in-chief is expecting to go to the Court of St. James if
the election comes his way, and the office-boy is betting his wages that it won't.
Such nights as these try men's souls; but Van Bibber passed the stage-door man with as calmly polite a nod as
though the piece had been running a hundred nights, and the manager was thinking up souvenirs for the one
hundred and fiftieth, and the prima donna had, as usual, begun to hint for a new set of costumes. The stage-door
keeper hesitated and was lost, and Van Bibber stepped into the unsuppressed excitement of the place with a
pleased sniff at the familiar smell of paint and burning gas, and the dusty odor that came from the scene-lofts
For a moment he hesitated in the cross-lights and confusion about him, failing to recognize in their new costumes
his old acquaintances of the company; but he saw Kripps, the stage-manager, in the centre of the stage, perspiring and in his shirtsleeves as always, wildly waving an arm to some one in the flies, and
beckoning with the other to the gasman in the front entrance. The stage hands were striking the scene for the first
act, and fighting with the set for the second, and dragging out a canvas floor of tessellated marble, and running a
throne and a practical pair of steps over it, and aiming the high quaking walls of a palace and abuse at whoever
came in their way.
"Now then, Van Bibber," shouted Kripps, with a wild glance of recognition, as the white-and-black figure came
towards him, "you know you're the only man in New York who gets behind here to-night. But you can't stay. Lower
it, lower it, can't you?" This to the man in the flies. "Any other night goes, but not this night. I can't have it. I
Where is the backing for the centre entrance? Didn't I tell you men"
Van Bibber dodged two stage hands who were steering a scene at him, stepped over the carpet as it unrolled,
and brushed through a group of anxious, whispering chorus people into the quiet of the star's dressing-room.
The star saw him in the long mirror before which he sat, while his dresser tugged at his boots, and threw up his
"Well," he cried, in mock resignation, "are we in it or are we not? Are they in their seats still or have they fled?"
"How are you, John?" said Van Bibber to the dresser. Then he dropped into a big arm-chair in the corner, and got
up again with a protesting sigh to light his cigar between the wires around the gas-burner. "Oh, it's going very well.
I wouldn't have come around if it wasn't. If the rest of it is as good as the first act, you needn't worry."
Van Bibber's unchallenged freedom behind the scenes had been a source of much comment and perplexity to the
members of the Lester Comic Opera Company. He had made his first appearance there during one hot night of
the long run of the previous summer, and had continued to be an almost nightly visitor for several weeks. At first it
was supposed that he was backing the piece, that he was the "Angel," as those weak and wealthy individuals are
called who allow themselves to be led into supplying the finances for theatrical experiments. But as he never
peered through the curtain-hole to count the house, nor made frequent trips to the front of it to look at the box
sheet, but was, on the contrary, just as undisturbed on a rainy night as on those when the "standing room only"
sign blocked the front entrance, this supposition was discarded as untenable. Nor did he show the least interest in the prima
donna, or in any of the other pretty women of the company; he did not know them, nor did he make any effort to
know them, and it was not until they inquired concerning him outside of the theatre that they learned what a figure
in the social life of the city he really was. He spent most of his time in Lester's dressing-room smoking, listening to
the reminiscences of Lester's dresser when Lester was on the stage; and this seclusion and his clerical attire of
evening dress led the second comedian to call him Lester's father confessor, and to suggest that he came to the
theatre only to take the star to task for his sins. And in this the second comedian was unknowingly not so very far
wrong. Lester, the comedian, and young Van Bibher had known each other at the university, when Lester's voice and gift of mimicry had made him the leader in the college theatricals; and later,
when he had gone upon the stage, and had been cut off by his family even after he had become famous, or on
account of it, Van Bibber had gone to visit him, and had found him as simple and sincere and boyish as he had
been in the days of his Hasty-Pudding successes. And Lester, for his part, had found Van Bibber as likable as did
every one else, and welcomed his quiet voice and youthful knowledge of the world as a grateful relief to the
boisterous camaraderie of his professional acquaintances. And he allowed Van Bibber to scold him, and to remind
him of what he owed to himself, and to touch, even whether it hurt or not, upon his better side. And in time he
admitted to finding his friend's occasional comments on stage matters of value as coming from the point of view of those who look on at the game; and even Kripps, the veteran, regarded him with respect
after he had told him that he could turn a set of purple costumes black by throwing a red light on them. To the
company, after he came to know them, he was gravely polite, and, to those who knew him if they had overheard,
amusingly commonplace in his conversation. He understood them better than they did themselves, and made no
mistakes. The women smiled on him, but the men were suspicious and shy of him until they saw that he was quite
as shy of the women; and then they made him a confidant, and told him all their woes and troubles, and exhibited
all their little jealousies and ambitions, in the innocent hope that he would repeat what they said to Lester. They
were simple, unconventional, light-hearted folk, and Van Bibber found them vastly more entertaining and preferable to the silence of the deserted club, where the matting was
down, and from whence the regular habitues had departed to the other side or to Newport. He liked the swing of
the light, bright music as it came to him through the open door of the dressing-room, and the glimpse he got of
the chorus people crowding and pushing for a quick charge up the iron stairway, and the feverish smell of oxygen
in the air, and the picturesque disorder of Lester's wardrobe, and the wigs and swords, and the mysterious
articles of make-up, all mixed together on a tray with half-finished cigars and autograph books and newspaper
And he often wished he was clever enough to be an artist with the talent to paint the unconsciously graceful
groups in the sharply divided light and shadow of the wings as he saw them. The brilliantly colored, fantastically clothed girls leaning against the bare brick wall of the theatre, or
whispering together in circles, with their arms close about one another, or reading apart and solitary, or working at
some piece of fancy-work as soberly as though they were in a rocking-chair in their own flat, and not leaning
against a scene brace, with the glare of the stage and the applause of the house just behind them. He liked to
watch them coquetting with the big fireman detailed from the precinct engine-house, and clinging desperately to
the curtain wire, or with one of the chorus men on the stairs, or teasing the phlegmatic scene-shifters as they tried
to catch a minute's sleep on a pile of canvas. He even forgave the prima donna's smiling at him from the stage, as
he stood watching her from the wings, and smiled back at her with polite cynicism, as though he did not know and she did not know that her smiles were not for him, but to disturb some more interested one in
the front row. And so, in time, the company became so well accustomed to him that he moved in and about as
unnoticed as the stage-manager himself, who prowled around hissing "hush" on principle, even though he was
the only person who could fairly be said to be making a noise.
The second act was on, and Lester came off the stage and ran to the dressing-room and beckoned violently.
"Come here," he said; "you ought to see this; the children are doing their turn. You want to hear them. They're
Van Bibber put his cigar into a tumbler and stepped out into the wings. They were crowded on both sides of the
stage with the members of the company; the girls were tiptoeing, with their hands on the shoulders of the men, and making futile little leaps into the air to get a better view, and others were resting on one
knee that those behind might see over their shoulders. There were over a dozen children before the footlights,
with the prima donna in the centre. She was singing the verses of a song, and they were following her
movements, and joining in the chorus with high piping voices. They seemed entirely too much at home and too
self-conscious to please Van Bibber; but there was one exception. The one exception was the smallest of them, a
very, very little girl, with long auburn hair and black eyes; such a very little girl that every one in the house looked
at her first, and then looked at no one else. She was apparently as unconcerned to all about her, excepting the
pretty prima donna, as though she were by a piano at home practising a singing lesson. She seemed to think it
was some new sort of a game. When the prima donna raised her arms, the child raised hers; when the prima donna
courtesied, she stumbled into one, and straightened herself just in time to get the curls out of her eyes, and to see
that the prima donna was laughing at her, and to smile cheerfully back as if to say, " We are doing our best
anyway, aren't we?" She had big, gentle eyes and two wonderful dimples, and in the excitement of the dancing
and the singing her eyes laughed and flashed, and the dimples deepened and disappeared and reappeared
again. She was as happy and innocent looking as though it were nine in the morning and she were playing school
at a kindergarten. From all over the house the women were murmuring their delight, and the men were laughing
and pulling their mustaches and nudging each other to "look at the littlest one."
The girls in the wings were rapturous in their enthusiasm, and were calling her absurdly extravagant titles of
endearment, and making so much noise that Kripps stopped grinning at her from the entrance, and looked back
over his shoulder as he looked when he threatened fines and calls for early rehearsal. And when she had finished
finally, and the prima donna and the children ran off together, there was a roar from the house that went to
Lester's head like wine, and seemed to leap clear across the footlights and drag the children back again.
"That settles it!" cried Lester, in a suppressed roar of triumph. "I knew that child would catch them."
There were four encores, and then the children and Elise Broughten, the pretty prima donna, came off jubilant
and happy, with the Littlest Girl's arms full of flowers, which the management had with kindly forethought prepared for the prima donna, but which that delightful young person
and the delighted leader of the orchestra had passed over to the little girl.
"Well," gasped Miss Broughten, as she came up to Van Bibber laughing, and with one hand on her side and
breathing very quickly, "will you kindly tell me who is the leading woman now? Am I the prima donna, or am I not?
I wasn't in it, was I?"
"You were not," said Van Bibber.
He turned from the pretty prima donna and hunted up the wardrobe woman, and told her he wanted to meet the
Littlest Girl. And the wardrobe woman, who was fluttering wildly about, and as delighted as though they were all
her own children, told him to come into the property-room, where the children were, and which had been changed into a dressing-room that they might be by themselves. The six little girls were in six different states of dishabille,
but they were too little to mind that, and Van Bibber was too polite to observe it.
"This is the little girl, sir," said the wardrobe woman, excitedly, proud at being the means of bringing together two
such prominent people. "Her name is Madeline. Speak to the gentleman, Madeline; he wants to tell you what a
great big hit youse made."
The little girl was seated on one of the cushions of a double throne so high from the ground that the young
woman who was pulling off the child's silk stockings and putting woollen ones on in their place did so without
stooping. The young woman looked at Van Bibber and nodded somewhat doubtfully and ungraciously, and Van
Bibber turned to the little girl in preference. The young woman's face was one of a type that was too familiar to be pleasant.
He took the Littlest Girl's small hand in his and shook it solemnly, and said, "I am very glad to know you. Can I sit
up here beside you, or do you rule alone?"
"Yes, ma'amyes, sir," answered the little girl.
Van Bibber put his hands on the arms of the throne and vaulted up beside the girl, and pulled out the flower in his
button-hole and gave it to her.
"Now," prompted the wardrobe woman, "what do you say to the gentleman?"
"Thank you, sir," stammered the little girl.
"She is not much used to gentlemen's society," explained the woman who was pulling on the stockings.
"I see," said Van Bibber. He did not know exactly what to say next. And yet he wanted to talk to the child very much, so much more than he generally wanted to talk to most young women, who showed no
hesitation in talking to him. With them he had no difficulty whatsoever. There was a doll lying on the top of a chest
near them, and he picked this up and surveyed it critically. "Is this your doll he asked.
"No," said Madeline, pointing to one of the children, who was much taller than herself; "it 's 'at 'ittle durl's. My doll
"Dear me!" said Van Bibber. He made a mental note to get a live one in the morning, and then he said: "That's
very sad. But dead dolls do come to life."
The little girl looked up at him, and surveyed him intently and critically, and then smiled, with the dimples showing,
as much as to say that she understood him and approved of him entirely. Van Bibber answered this sign language by taking Madeline's hand in his and asking her how she liked being a great actress,
and how soon she would begin to storm because that photographer hadn't sent the proofs. The young woman
understood this, and deigned to smile at it, but Madeline yawned a very polite and sleepy yawn, and closed her
eyes. Van Bibber moved up closer, and she leaned over until her bare shoulder touched his arm, and while the
woman buttoned on her absurdly small shoes, she let her curly head fall on his elbow and rest there. Any number
of people had shown confidence in Van Bibbernot in that form exactly, but in the same spiritand though he was
used to being trusted, he felt a sharp thrill of pleasure at the touch of the child's head on his arm, and in the warm
clasp of her fingers around his. And he was conscious of a keen sense of pity and sorrow for her rising in him, which he crushed by thinking that it was entirely wasted, and that the child
was probably perfectly and ignorantly happy.
"Look at that, now," said the wardrobe woman, catching sight of the child's closed eyelids; "just look at the rest of
the little dears, all that excited they can't stand still to get their hats on, and she just as unconcerned as you
please, and after making the hit of the piece, too."
"She's not used to it, you see," said the young woman, knowingly; "she don't know what it means. It's just that
much play to her."
This last was said with a questioning glance at Van Bibber, in whom she still feared to find the disguised agent of
a Children's Aid Society. Van Bibber only nodded in reply, and did not answer her, because he found he could not
very well, for he was looking a long way ahead at what the future was to bring to the confiding little being at his side, and thinking of the evil knowledge and
temptations that would mar the beauty of her quaintly sweet face, and its strange mark of gentleness and
refinement. Outside he could hear his friend Lester shouting the refrain of his new topical song, and the laughter
and the hand-clapping came in through the wings and open door, broken but tumultuous.
"Does she come of professional people?" Van Bibber asked, dropping into the vernacular. He spoke softly, not so
much that he might not disturb the child, but that she might not understand what he said.
"Yes," the woman answered, shortly, and bent her head to smooth out the child's stage dress across her knees.
Van Bibber touched the little girl's head with his hand and found that she was asleep, and so let his hand rest there, with the curls between his fingers. "Areare you her mother?" he asked, with a slight inclination of his
head. He felt quite confident she was not; at least, he hoped not.
The woman shook her head. "No," she said.
"Who is her mother ?
The woman looked at the sleeping child and then up at him almost defiantly. "Ida Clare was her mother," she said.
Van Bibber's protecting hand left the child as suddenly as though something had burned it, and he drew back so
quickly that her head slipped from his arm, and she awoke and raised her eyes and looked up at him
questioningly. He looked back at her with a glance of the strangest concern and of the deepest pity. Then he
stooped and drew her towards him very tenderly, put her head back in the corner of his arm, and watched her in silence while she smiled drowsily and went to sleep again.
"And who takes care of her now?" he asked.
The woman straightened herself and seemed relieved. She saw that the stranger had recognized the child's
pedigree and knew her story, and that he was not going to comment on it. "I do," she said. "After the divorce Ida
came to me," she said, speaking more freely. "I used to be in her company when she was doing `Aladdin,' and
then when I left the stage and started to keep an actors' boarding-house, she came to me. She lived on with us a
year, until she died, and she made me the guardian of the child. I train children for the stage, you know, me and
my sister, Ada Dyer; you've heard of her, I guess. The courts pay us for her keep, but it isn't much, and I'm
expecting to get what I spent on her from what she makes on the stage. Two of them other children are my pupils; but they can't
touch Madie. She is a better dancer an' singer than any of them. If it hadn't been for the Society keeping her back,
she would have been on the stage two years ago. She's great, she is. She'll be just as good as her mother was.
Van Bibber gave a little start, and winced visibly, but turned it off into a cough. "And her father," he said
hesitatingly, "does he"
" Her father," said the woman, tossing back her head, "he looks after himself, he does. We don't ask no favors of
him. She'll get along without him or his folks, thank you. Call him a gentleman? Nice gentleman he is!" Then she
stopped abruptly. "I guess, though, you know him," she added. Perhaps he's a friend of yourn?"
"I just know him," said Van Bibber, wearily.
He sat with the child asleep beside him while the woman turned to the others and dressed them for the third act.
She explained that Madie would not appear in the last act, only the two larger girls, so she let her sleep, with the
cape of Van Bibber's cloak around her.
Van Bibber sat there for several long minutes thinking, and then looked up quickly, and dropped his eyes again as
quickly, and said, with an effort to speak quietly and unconcernedly: "If the little girl is not on in this act, would you
mind if I took her home? I have a cab at the stage door, and she's so sleepy it seems a pity to keep her up. The
sister you spoke of or some one could put her to bed."
"Yes," the woman said, doubtfully, "Ada's home. Yes, you can take her around, if you want to."
She gave him the address, and he sprang down to the floor, and gathered the child up in his arms and stepped
out on the stage. The prima donna had the centre of it to herself at that moment, and all the rest of the company
were waiting to go on; but when they saw the little girl in Van Bibber's arms they made a rush at her, and the girls
leaned over and kissed her with a great show of rapture and with many gasps of delight.
"Don't," said Van Bibber, he could not tell just why. "Don't." "
"Why not?" asked one of the girls, looking up at him sharply.
"She was asleep; you've wakened her," he said, gently.
But he knew that was not the reason. He stepped into the cab at the stage entrance, and put the child carefully
down in one corner. Then he looked back over his shoulder to see that there was no one near enough to hear him, and said to the driver, "To the Berkeley Flats, on Fifth Avenue." He picked the child up gently in his
arms as the carriage started, and sat looking out thoughtfully and anxiously as they flashed past the lighted
shop-windows on Broadway. He was far from certain of this errand, and nervous with doubt, but he reassured
himself that he was acting on impulse, and that his impulses were so often good. The hall-boy at the Berkeley
said, yes, Mr. Caruthers was in, and Van Bibber gave a quick sigh of relief. He took this as an omen that his
impulse was a good one. The young English servant who opened the hall door to Mr. Caruthers's apartment
suppressed his surprise with an effort, and watched Van Bibber with alarm as he laid the child on the divan in the
hall, and pulled a covert coat from the rack to throw over her.
"Just say Mr. Van Bibber would like to see him," he said, "and you need not speak of the little girl having come
She was still sleeping, and Van Bibber turned down the light in the hall, and stood looking down at her gravely
while the servant went to speak to his master.
"Will you come this way, please, sir?" he said.
"You had better stay out here," said Van Bibber, "and come and tell me if she wakes."
Mr. Caruthers was standing by the mantel over the empty fireplace, wrapped in a long, loose dressing-gown
which he was tying around him as Van Bibber entered. He was partly undressed, and had been just on the point
of getting into bed. Mr. Caruthers was a tall, handsome man, with dark reddish hair, turning below the temples
into gray; his mustache was quite white, and his eyes and face showed the signs of either dissipation or of great trouble, or of both. But even in the formless
dressing-gown he had the look and the confident bearing of a gentleman, or, at least, of the man of the world.
The room was very rich-looking, and was filled with the medley of a man's choice of good paintings and fine china,
and papered with irregular rows of original drawings and signed etchings. The windows were open, and the lights
were turned very low, so that Van Bibber could see the many gas lamps and the dark roofs of Broadway and the
Avenue where they crossed a few blocks off, and the bunches of light on the Madison Square Garden, and to the
lights on the boats of the East River. From below in the streets came the rattle of hurrying omnibuses and the
rush of the hansom cabs. If Mr. Caruthers was surprised at this late visit, he hid it, and came forward to receive his caller as if his presence were expected.
"Excuse my costume, will you?" he said. "I turned in rather early to-night, it was so hot." He pointed to a decanter
and some soda bottles on the table and a bowl of ice, and asked, "Will you have some of this?" And while he
opened one of the bottles, he watched Van Bibber's face as though he were curious to have him explain the
object of his visit.
"No, I think not, thank you," said the younger man. He touched his forehead with his handkerchief nervously. "Yes,
it is hot," he said.
Mr. Caruthers filled a glass with ice and brandy and soda, and walked back to his place by the mantel, on which
he rested his arm, while he clinked the ice in the glass and looked down into it.
"I was at the first night of `The Sultana' this evening," said Van Bibber, slowly and uncertainly.
"Oh, yes," assented the elder man, politely, and tasting his drink. "Lester's new piece. Was it any good?"
"I don't know," said Van Bibber.
Yes, I think it was. I didn't see it from the front. There were a lot of children in itlittle ones; they danced and sang,
and made a great hit. One of them had never been on the stage before. It was her first appearance."
He was turning one of the glasses around between his fingers as he spoke. He stopped, and poured out some of
the soda, and drank it down in a gulp, and then continued turning the empty glass between the tips of his fingers.
"It seems to me," he said, "that it is a great pity." He looked up interrogatively at the other, but Mr. Caruthers met
his glance without any returning show of interest. "I say," repeated Van Bibber "I say it seems a pity that a child like that should be
allowed to go on in that business. A grown woman can go into it with her eyes open, or a girl who has had decent
training can too. But it's different with a child. She has no choice in the matter; they don't ask her permission; and
she isn't old enough to know what it means; and she gets used to it and fond of it before she grows to know what
the danger is. And then it's too late. It seemed to me that if there was any one who had a right to stop it, it would
be a very good thing to let that person know about herabout this child, I mean; the one who made the hitbefore
it was too late. It seems to me a responsibility I wouldn't care to take myself. I wouldn't care to think that I had the
chance to stop it, and had let the chance go by. You know what the life is, and what the temptation a woman" Van Bibber stopped with a gasp of concern, and added,
hurriedly, "I mean we all knowevery man knows."
Mr. Caruthers was looking at him with his lips pressed closely together, and his eyebrows drawn into the shape of
the letter V. He leaned forward, and looked at Van Bibber intently.
"What is all this about?" he asked. "Did you come here, Mr. Van Bibber, simply to tell me this? What have you to
do with it? What have I to do with it? Why did you come?
"Because of the child."
"Your child," said Van Bibber.
Young Van Bibber was quite prepared for an outbreak of some sort, and mentally braced himself to receive it. He
rapidly assured himself that this man had every reason to be angry, and that he, if he meant to accomplish anything, had every reason to be considerate and patient. So he
faced Mr. Caruthers with shoulders squared, as though it were a physical shock he had had to stand against, and
in consequence he was quite unprepared for what followed. For Mr. Caruthers raised his face without a trace of
feeling in it, and, with his eyes still fixed on the glass in his hand, set it carefully down on the mantel beside him,
and girded himself about with the rope of his robe. When he spoke, it was in a tone of quiet politeness.
"Mr. Van Bibber," he began, you are a very brave young man. You have dared to say to me what those who are
my best friendswhat even my own familywould not care to say. They are afraid it might hurt me, I suppose.
They have some absurd regard for my feelings; they hesitate to touch upon a subject which in no way concerns them and which they know must be very painful to me. But you have the courage of
your convictions; you have no compunctions about tearing open old wounds; and you come here, unasked and
uninvited, to let me know what you think of my conduct, to let me understand that it does not agree with your own
ideas of what I ought to do, and to tell me how I, who am old enough to be your father, should behave. You have
rushed in where angels fear to tread, Mr. Van Bibber, to show me the error of my ways. I suppose I ought to thank
you for it; but I have always said that it is not the wicked people who are to be feared in this world, or who do the
most harm. We know them; we can prepare for them, and checkmate them. It is the well-meaning fool who makes
all the trouble. For no one knows him until he discloses himself, and the mischief is done before he can be stopped. I think, if you will allow me to say so, that you have
demonstrated my theory pretty thoroughly, and have done about as much needless harm for one evening as you
can possibly wish. And so, if you will excuse me," he continued, sternly, and moving from his place, "I will ask to
say good-night, and will request of you that you grow older and wiser and much more considerate before you
come to see me again."
Van Bibber had flushed at Mr. Caruthers's first words, and had then grown somewhat pale, and straightened
himself visibly. He did not move when the elder man had finished, but cleared his throat, and then spoke with
some little difficulty. "It is very easy to call a man a fool," he said, slowly, "but it is much harder to be called a fool
and not to throw the other man out of the window. But that, you see, would not do any good, and I have something to say to you first. I am quite clear
in my own mind as to my position, and I am not going to allow anything you have said or can say to annoy me
much until I am through. There will be time enough to resent it then. I am quite well aware that I did an
unconventional thing in coming herea bold thing or a foolish thing, as you choosebut the situation is pretty bad,
and I did as I would have wished to be done by if I had had a child going to the devil and didn't know it. I should
have been glad to learn of it even from a stranger. However," he said, smiling grimly, and pulling his cape about
him, "there are other kindly disposed people in the world besides fathers. There is an aunt, perhaps, or an uncle
or two; and sometimes, even to-day, there is the chance Samaritan."
Van Bibber picked up his high hat from the table, looked into it critically, and settled it on his head. "Good-night," he said, and walked slowly towards
the door. He had his hand on the knob, when Mr. Caruthers raised his head.
"Wait just one minute, please, Mr. Van Bibber?" asked Mr. Caruthers.
Van Bibber stopped with a prompt obedience which would have led one to conclude that he might have put on his
hat only to precipitate matters.
"Before you go," said Mr. Caruthers, grudgingly, "I want to sayI want you to understand my position."
"Oh, that's all right," said Van Bibber, lightly, opening the door.
"No, it is not all right. One moment, please. I do not intend that you shall go away from here with the idea that you
have tried to do a service, and that I have been unable to appreciate it, and that you are a much-abused and much-misunderstood young man. Since you have done me the honor to make my affairs
your business, I would prefer that you should understand them fully. I do not care to have you discuss my conduct
at clubs and afternoon teas with young women until you"
Van Bibber drew in his breath sharply, with a peculiar whistling sound, and opened and shut his hands. "Oh, I
wouldn't say that if I were you," he said, simply.
"I beg your pardon," the older man said, quickly. "That was a mistake. I was wrong. I beg your pardon. But you
have tried me very sorely. You have intruded upon a private trouble that you ought to know must be very painful
to me. But I believe you meant well. I know you to be a gentleman, and I am willing think you acted on impulse,
and that you will see to-morrow what a mistake you have made. It is not a thing I talk about; I do not speak of it to my friends, and they are far too considerate to
speak of it to me. But you have put me on the defensive. You have made me out more or less of a brute, and I
don't intend to be so far misunderstood. There are two sides to every story, and there is something to be said
about this, even for me."
He walked back to his place beside the mantel, and put his shoulders against it, and faced Van Bibber, with his
fingers twisted in the cord around his waist.
"When I married," said Mr. Caruthers, "I did so against the wishes of my people and the advice of all my friends.
You know all about that. God help us! who doesn't?" he added, bitterly. "It was very rich, rare reading for you and
for everyone else who saw the daily papers, and we gave them all they wanted of it. I took her out of that life and married her because I believed she was as good a woman as any
of those who had never had to work for their living, and I was bound that my friends and your friends should
recognize her and respect her as my wife had a right to be respected; and I took her abroad that I might give all
you sensitive, fine people a chance to get used to the idea of being polite to a woman who had once been a
burlesque actress. It began over there in Paris. What I went through then no one knows; but when I came
backand I would never have come back if she had not made meit was my friends I had to consider, and not
her. It was in the blood; it was in the life she had led, and in the life men like you and me had taught her to live.
And it had to come out."
The muscles of Mr. Caruthers's face were moving, and beyond his control; but Van Bibber did not see this, for he was looking intently out of the
window, over the roofs of the city.
"She had every chance when she married me that a woman ever had," continued the older man. "It only
depended on herself. I didn't try to make a housewife of her or a drudge. She had all the healthy excitement and
all the money she wanted, and she had a home here ready for her when ever she was tired of travelling about
and wished to settle down. And I was and a husband that loved her asshe had everythingeverything that a
man's whole thought and love and money could bring to her. And you know what she did."
He looked at Van Bibber, but Van Bibber's eyes were still turned towards the open window and the night.
And after the divorceand she was free to go where she pleased, and to live as she pleased and with whom she
pleased, without bringing disgrace on a husband who honestly loved herI swore to my God that I would never
see her nor her child again. And I never saw her again, not even when she died. I loved the mother, and she
deceived me and disgraced me and broke my heart, and I only wish she had killed me; and I was beginning to
love her child, and I vowed she should not live to trick me too. I had suffered as no man I know had suffered; in a
way a boy like you cannot understand, and that no one can understand who has not gone to hell and been forced
to live after it. And was I to go through that again? Was I to love and care for and worship this child, and have her
grow up with all her mother's vanity and animal nature, and have her turn on me some day and show me that what is bred in the bone must tell, and that I was a fool againa pitiful fond fool? I
could not trust her. I can never trust any woman or child again, and least of all that woman's child. She is as dead
to me as though she were buried with her mother, and it is nothing to me what she is or what her life is. I know in
time what it will be. She has begun earlier than I had supposed, that is all; but she is nothing to me." The man
stopped and turned his back to Van Bibber, and hid his head in his hands, with his elbows on the mantelpiece. "I
care too much," he said. "I cannot let it mean anything to me; when I do care, it means so much more to me than
to other men. They may pretend to laugh and to forget and to, outgrow it, but it is not so with me. It means too
much." He took a quick stride towards one of the arm-chairs, and threw himself into it.
Why, man," he cried, "I loved that child's mother to the day of her death. I loved that woman then, and, God help
me! I love that woman still."
He covered his face with his hands, and sat leaning forward and breathing heavily as he rocked himself to and fro.
Van Bibber still stood looking gravely out at the lights that picketed the black surface of the city. He was to all
appearances as unmoved by the outburst of feeling into which the older man had been surprised as though it had
been something in a play. There was an unbroken silence for a moment, and then it was Van Bibber who was the
first to speak.
"I came here, as you say, on impulse," he said; "but I am glad I came, for I have your decisive answer now about
the little girl. I have been thinking," he continued, slowly, "since you have been speaking, and before, when I first saw her dancing in front of the footlights, when I
did not know who she was, that I could give up a horse or two, if necessary, and support this child instead.
Children are worth more than horses, and a man who saves a soul, as it says"he flushed slightly, and looked up
with a hesitating, deprecatory smile"somewhere, wipes out a multitude of sins. And it may be I'd like to try and
get rid of some of mine. I know just where to send her; I know the very place. It's down in Evergreen Bay, on Long
Island. They are tenants of mine there, and very nice farm sort of people, who will be very good to her. They
wouldn't know anything about her, and she'd forget what little she knows of this present life very soon, and grow
up with the other children to be one of them; and then, when she gets older and becomes a young lady, she could go to some schoolbut that's a bit too far ahead to plan for the present; but
that's what I am going to do, though," said the young man, confidently, and as though speaking to himself. "That
theatrical boarding-house person could be bought off easily enough," he went on, quickly, "and Lester won't mind
letting her go if I ask it,andand that's what I'II do. As you say, it's a good deal of an experiment, but I think I'II
run the risk."
He walked quickly to the door and disappeared in the hall, and then came back, kicking the door open as he
returned, and holding the child in his arms.
"This is she," he said, quietly. He did not look at or notice the father, but stood, with the child asleep in the bend of
his left arm, gazing down at her. "This is she," he repeated; "this is your child."
There was something cold and satisfied in Van Bibber's tone and manner, as though he were congratulating
himself upon the engaging of a new groom; something that placed the father entirely outside of it. He might have
been a disinterested looker-on.
"She will need to be fed a bit," Van Bibber ran on, cheerfully. "They did not treat her very well, I fancy. She is thin
and peaked and tired-looking." He drew up the loose sleeve of her jacket, and showed the bare forearm to the
light. He put his thumb and little finger about it, and closed them on it gently. "It is very thin," he said. "And under
her eyes, if it were not for the paint," he went on, mercilessly, "you could see how deep the lines are. This red spot
on her cheek," he said, gravely, "is where Mary Vane kissed her to-night, and this is where Alma Stantley kissed her, and that Lee girl. You have heard of them, perhaps. They will never kiss her again. She is going to grow up a
sweet, fine, beautiful womanare you not?" he said, gently drawing the child higher up on his shoulder, until her
face touched his, and still keeping his eyes from the face of the older man. "She does not look like her mother," he
said; "she has her father's auburn hair and straight nose and finer-cut lips and chin. She looks very much like her
father. It seems a pity," he added, abruptly.
She will grow up," he went on, without knowing him, or who he isor was, if he should die. She will never speak
with him, or see him, or take his hand. She may pass him some day on the street and will not know him, and he
will not know her, but she will grow to be very fond and to be very grateful to the simple, kindhearted old people
who will have cared for her when she was a little girl."
The child in his arms stirred, shivered slightly, and awoke. The two men watched her breathlessly, with silent
intentness. She raised her head and stared around the unfamiliar room doubtfully, then turned to where her father
stood, looking at him a moment, and passed him by; and then, looking up into Van Bibber's face, recognized him,
and gave a gentle, sleepy smile, and, with a sigh of content and confidence, drew her arm up closer around his
neck, and let her head fall back upon his breast.
The father sprang to his feet with a quick, jealous gasp of pain. "Give her to me!" he said, fiercely, under his
breath, snatching her out of Van Bibber's arms. "She is mine; give her to me!"
Van Bibber closed the door gently behind him, and went jumping down the winding stairs of the Berkeley three steps at a time.
And an hour later, when the English servant came to his master's door, he found him still awake and sitting in the
dark by the open window, holding something in his arms and looking out over the sleeping city.
"James, he said, "you can make up a place for me here on the lounge. Miss Caruthers, my daughter, will sleep in
my room to-night.