The Master of the Inn
by Robert Herrick
The author of "The Master of the Inn" having received many
inquiries as to what foundation in fact this tale has wishes to state
explicitly that both incidents and persons are purely imaginary, and
that so far as he is aware there is neither Master nor Inn in
Chicago, Ills., 12 May, 1909.
IT was a plain brick house, three full stories, with four
broad chimneys, and overhanging eaves. The tradition was that it had
been a colonial tavern—a dot among the fir-covered northern hills on
the climbing post-road into Canada. The village scattered along the
road below the inn was called Albany—and soon forgotten when the
railroad sought an opening through a valley less rugged, eight miles
to the west.
Rather more than thirty years ago
the Doctor had arrived, one summer day, and opened all the doors and
windows of the neglected old house, which he had bought from
scattered heirs. He was a quiet man, the Doctor, in middle life then
or nearly so; and he sank almost without remark into the world of
Albany, where they raise hay and potatoes and still cut good white
pine off the hills. Gradually the old brick tavern resumed the
functions of life: many buildings were added to it as well as many
acres of farm and forest to the Doctor's original purchase of
intervale land. The new Master did not open his house to the public,
yet he, too, kept a sort of Inn, where men came and stayed a long
time. Although no sign now hung from the old elm tree in front of the
house, nevertheless an
ever-widening stream of humanity mounted the winding road from White
River and passed through the doors of the Inn, seeking life. . . .
That first summer the Doctor brought with him Sam, the Chinaman,
whom we all came to know and love, and also a young man, who loafed
much while the Doctor worked, and occasionally fished. This was John
Herring—now a famous architect—and it was from his designs,
sketched those first idle summer days, that were built all the
additions to the simple old house—the two low wings in the rear for
the "cells," with the Italian garden between them; the marble seat
curving around the pool that joined the wings on the west; also the substantial wall that hid the Inn, its
terraced gardens and orchards, from Albanian curiosity. Herring found
a store of red brick in some crumbling buildings in the neighborhood,
and he discovered the quarry whence came those thick slabs of purple
slate. The blue-veined marble was had from a fissure in the hills,
and the Doctor's School made the tiles.
I think Herring never did better work than in the making over of
this old tavern: he divined that subtle affinity which exists between
north Italy, with all its art, and our bare New England; and he dared
to graft boldly one to the other, having the rear of the Inn
altogether Italian with its portico, its dainty colonnades, the
garden and the fountain and the pool. From all this one looked down on the waving grass of the Intervale, which
fell away gently to the turbulent White River, then rose again to the
wooded hills that folded one upon another, with ever deepening blue,
always upward and beyond.
Not all this building at once, to be sure, as the millionaire
builds; but a gradual growth over a couple of decades; and all built
lovingly by the "Brothers," stone on stone, brick and beam and
tile—many a hand taking part in it that came weak to the task and
left it sturdy. There was also the terraced arrangement of gardens
and orchards on either side of the Inn, reaching to the farm
buildings on the one side and to the village on the other. For a time
Herring respected the quaint old tavern with its small rooms and pine wainscot; then he made a stately
two-storied hall out of one half where we dined in bad weather, and a
pleasant study for the Doctor from the rest. The doors east and west
always stood open in the summer, giving the rare passer-by a glimpse
of that radiant blue heaven among the hills, with the silver flash of
the river in the middle distance, and a little square of peaceful
garden close at hand.... The tough northern grasses rustled in the
breezes that always played about Albany; and the scent of spruce
drawn by the hot sun—the strong resinous breath of the north—was
borne from the woods.
Thus it started, that household of men in the old Inn at the far
end of Albany village among the northern hills, with the Doctor and
Sam and Herring, who had been
flung aside after his first skirmish with life and was picked up in
pure kindness by the Doctor, as a bit of the broken waste of our
modern world, and carried off with him out of the city. The young
architect returning in due time to the fight—singing—naturally
venerated the Doctor as a father; and when a dear friend stumbled
and fell in the via dura of this life, he whispered to him
word of the Inn and its Master—of the life up there among the hills
where Man is little and God looks down on his earth. . . . "Oh,
you'll understand when you put your eyes on White Face some morning!
The Doctor? He heals both body and soul." And this one having heeded
spoke the word in turn to others in need—"to the right sort, who
would understand." Thus the custom grew like a faith, and a kind of
brotherhood was formed, of those who had found more than health at
the Inn—who had found themselves. The Doctor, ever busy about his
farms and his woods, his building, and above all his School, soon had
on his hands a dozen or more patients or guests, as you might call
them, and he set them to work speedily. There was little medicine to
be found in the Inn: the sick labored as they could and thus grew
And so, as one was added to another, they began to call themselves
in joke "Brothers," and the Doctor, "Father." The older "Brothers"
would return to the Inn from all parts of the land, for a few days
orfew weeks, to grasp the Doctor's hand, to have a dip in the pool,
to try the little brooks among the hills. Young men and middle-aged,
and even the old, they came from the cities where the heat of living
had scorched them, where they had faltered and doubted the goodness
of life. In some way word of the Master had reached them, with this
compelling advice—"Go! And tell him I sent you." So from the clinic
or the lecture-room, from the office or the mill—wherever men labor
with tightening nerves—the needy one started on his long journey.
Toward evening he was set down before the plain red face of the Inn.
And as the Stranger entered the old hall, a voice was sure to greet
him from within somewhere, the deep voice of ahearty man, and
presently the Master appeared to welcome the newcomer, resting one
hand on his guest's shoulder perhaps, with a yearning affection that
ran before knowledge.
"So you've come, my boy," he said. "Herring [or some one] wrote me
to look for you."
And after a few more words of greeting, the Doctor beckoned to
Sam, and gave the guest over to his hands. Thereupon the Chinaman
slippered through tiled passageways to the court, where the Stranger,
caught by the beauty and peace so well hidden, lingered a while. The
little space within the wings was filled with flowers as far as the
yellow water of the pool and the marble bench. In the centre of the
court wasan old gray fountain—sent from Verona by a Brother—from
which the water dropped and ran away among the flower beds to the
pool. A stately elm tree shaded this place, flecking the water below.
The sun shot long rays beneath its branches into the court, and over
all there was an odor of blossoming flowers and the murmur of bees.
"Bath!" Sam explained, grinning toward the pool.
With the trickle of the fountain in his ears the Stranger looked
out across the ripening fields of the Intervale to the noble sky-line
of the Stowe hills. Those little mountains of the north! Mere hills
to all who know the giants of the earth—not mountains in the
brotherhood of ice and snow and rock! But in form andcolor, in the
lesser things that create the love of men for places, they rise nobly
toward heaven, those little hills! On a summer day like this their
broad breasts flutter with waving tree-tops, and at evening depth on
depth of purple mist gathers over them, dropping into those soft
curves where the little brooks flow, and mounting even to the
sky-line. When the sun has fallen, there rests a band of pure
saffron, and in the calm and perfect peace of evening there is a hint
of coming moonlight. Ah, they are of the fellowship of mountains,
those little hills of Stowe! And when in winter their flanks are
jewelled with ice and snow, then they raise their heads proudly to
the stars, calling across the frozen valleys to their greater
brethren in the midriff ofthe continent—"Behold, we also are hills,
in the sight of the Lord!". . .
Meantime Sam, with Oriental ease, goes slipping along the arcade
until he comes to a certain oak door, where he drops your bag, and
disappears, having saluted. It is an ample and lofty room, and on the
outer side of it hangs a little balcony above the orchard, from which
there is a view of the valley and the woods beyond, and from
somewhere in the fields the note of the thrush rises. The room itself
is cool, of a gray tone, with a broad fireplace, a heavy table, and
many books. Otherwise there are bed and chairs and dressing-table,
the necessities of life austerely provided. And Peace! God, what
Peace to him who has escaped from the furnace men make! It is asif
he had come all the way to the end of the world, and found there a
great still room of peace.
Soon a bell sounds—with a strange vibration as though in distant
lands it had summoned many a body of men together—and the household
assembles under the arcade. If it is fair and not cold, Sam and his
helpers bring out the long narrow table and place it, as Veronese
places his feasters, lengthwise beneath the colonnade, and thus the
evening meal is served. A fresh, coarse napkin is laid on the bare
board before each man, no more than enough for all those present, and
the Doctor sits in the middle, serving all. There are few dishes, and
for the most part such as may be got at home there in the hills.
There is a pitcher of cider atone end and a pitcher of mild white
wine at the other, and the men eat and drink, with jokes and
talk—the laughter of the day. (The novice might feel only the
harmony of it all, but later he will learn how many considered
elements go to the making of Peace.) Afterward, when Sam has brought
pipes and tobacco, the Master leads the way to the sweeping
semicircle of marble seat around the pool with the leafy tree
overhead; and there they sit into the soft night, talking of all
things, with the glow of pipes, until one after another slips away to
sleep. For as the Master said, "Talk among men in common softens the
muscles of the mind and quickens the heart." Yet he loved most to
hear the talk of others.
Thus insensibly for the Novice therebegins the life of the place,
opening in a gentle and persistent routine that takes him in its flow
and carries him on with it. He finds Tradition and Habit all about
him, in the ordered, unconscious life of the Inn, to which he yields
without question. . . . Shortly after dawn the bell sounds, and then
the men meet at the pool, where the Doctor is always first. A plunge
into the yellow water which is flecked with the fallen leaves, and
afterward to each man's room there is brought a large bowl of coffee
and hot milk, with bread and eggs and fruit. What more he craves may
be found in the hall.
Soon there is a tap on the newcomer's door, and a neighborly voice
calls out—"We all go into the fieldsevery morning, you know. You
must earn your dinner, the Doctor says, or borrow it!" So the Novice
goes forth to earn his first dinner with his hands. Beyond the
gardens and the orchards are the barns and sheds, and a vista of
level acres of hay and potatoes and rye, the bearing acres of the
farm, and beyond these the woods on the hills. "Nearly a thousand
acres, fields and woods," the neighbor explains. "Oh, there's plenty
to do all times!" Meantime the Doctor strides ahead through the wet
grass, his eyes roaming here and there, inquiring the state of his
land. And watching him the newcomer believes that there is always
much to be done wherever the Doctor leads.
It may be July and hay time—all the intervale grass land is mowed
byhand—there is a sweat-breaking task! Or it may be potatoes to
hoe. Or later in the season the apples have to be gathered—a
pleasant pungent job, filling the baskets and pouring them into the
fat-bellied barrels. But whatever the work may be the Doctor keeps
the Novice in his mind, and as the sun climbs high over the Stowe
hills, he taps the new one on the shoulder—"Better stop here to-day,
my boy! You'll find a good tree over there by the brook for a nap. .
Under that particular tree in the tall timothy, there is the
coolest spot, and the Novice drowses, thinking of those wonderful
mowers in Anna, as he gazes at the marching files eating their
way through the meadow until his eyelids fall and he sleeps,
theripple of waving timothy in his ears. At noon the bell sounds
again from the Inn, and the men come striding homeward wiping the
sweat from their faces. They gather at the swimming pool, and still
panting from their labor strip off their wet garments, then plunge
one after another, like happy boys. From bath to room, and a few
minutes for fresh clothes, and all troop into the hall, which is dark
and cool. The old brick walls of the tavern never held a gayer lot of
From this time on each one is his own master; there is no common
toil. The farmer and his men take up the care of the farm, and the
Master usually goes down to his School, in company with some of the
Brothers. Each one finds his own wayof spending the hours till
sunset—some fishing or shooting, according to the season; others, in
tennis or games with the boys of the School; and some reading or
loafing until the shadows begin to fall across the pool into the
court, and Sam brings out the long table for dinner.
The seasons shading imperceptibly into one another vary the course
of the day. Early in September the men begin to sit long about the
hall-fire of an evening, and when the snow packs hard on the hills
there is wood-cutting to be done, and in early spring it is the
carpenter's shop. So the form alters, but the substance remains—work
and play and rest. . . .
To each one a time will come when the Doctor speaks to him alone.
At some hour, before many days havepassed, the Novice will find
himself with those large eyes resting on his face, searchingly. It
may be in the study after the others have scattered, or at the pool
where the Master loved to sit beneath the great tree and hear his
"confessions," as the men called these talks. At such times, when the
man came to remember it afterward, the Doctor asked few questions,
said little, but listened. He had the confessing ear! And as if by
chance his hand would rest on the man's arm or shoulder. For he
said—"Touch speaks: soul flows through flesh into soul."
Thus he sat and confessed his patients one after another, and his
dark eyes seemed familiar with all man's woes, as if he had listened
always. Men said to him what they had neverbefore let pass their
lips to man or woman, what they themselves scarce looked at in the
gloom of their souls. Unawares it slipped from them, the reason
within the reason for their ill, the ultimate cause of sorrow. From
the moment they had revealed to him this hidden thing—had slipped
the leash on their tongues—it seemed no longer to be feared.
"Trouble evaporates, being properly aired," said the Doctor. And
already in the troubled one's mind the sense of the confused snarl of
life began to lessen and veils began to descend between him and it. .
. . "For you must learn to forget," counselled the Doctor, "forget day
by day until the recording soul beneath your mind is clean.
Therefore—work, forget, be new!" . . .
A self-important young man, muchconcerned with himself, once asked
"Doctor, what is the regimen that you would recommend to me?"
And we all heard him say in reply—"The potatoes need hilling, and
then you'll feel like having a dip in the pool."
The young man, it seems, wrote back to the friend in the city who
had sent him "This Doctor cannot understand my case: he tells me to
dig potatoes and bathe in a swimming pool. That is all! All!" But the
friend, who was an old member of the Brotherhood, telegraphed
back—"Dig and swim, you fool!" Sam took the message at the telephone
while we were dining, and repeated it faithfully to the young man
within the hearing of all. A laugh rose thatwas hard in dying, and I
think the Doctor's lips wreathed in smile. . . . In the old days they
say the Master gave medicine like other doctors. That was when be
spent part of the year in the city and had an office there and
believed in drugs. But as he gave up going to the city, the stock of
drugs in the cabinet at the end of the study became exhausted, and
was never renewed. All who needed medicine were sent to an old
Brother, who had settled down the valley at Stowe. "He knows more
about pills than I do," the Doctor said. "At least he can give you
the stuff with confidence." Few of the inmates of the Inn ever went
to Stowe, though Dr. Williams was an excellent physician. And it was
from about this time that we began todrop the title of doctor,
calling him instead the Master; and the younger men sometimes,
Father. He seemed to like these new terms, as denoting affection and
respect for his authority.
By the time that we called him Master, the Inn had come to its
maturity. Altogether it could hold eighteen guests, and if more came,
as in midsummer or autumn, they lived in tents in the orchard or in
the hill camps. The Master was still adding to the forest land—fish
and game preserve the village people called it; for the Master was a
hunter and a fisherman. But up among those curving hills, when he
looked out through the waving trees, measuring by eye a fir or a
pine, he would say, nodding his head—"Boys, behold myheirs—from
generation to generation!"
He was now fifty and had ceased altogether to go to the city. There
were ripe men in the great hospitals that still remembered him as a
young man in the medical school; but he had dropped out, they
said—why? He might have answered that, instead of following the
beaten path, he had spoken his word to the world through men—and
spoken widely. For there was no break in the stream of life that
flowed upward to the old Inn. The "cells" were always full, winter
and summer. Now there were coming children of the older Brothers, and
these, having learned the ways of the place from their fathers, were
already house-broken, as we said, when they came. Theyknew that no
door was locked about the Inn, but that if they returned after ten it
behooved them to come in by the pool and make no noise. They knew
that when the first ice formed on the pool, then they were not
expected to get out of bed for the morning plunge. They knew that
there was an old custom which no one ever forgot, and that was to put
money in the house-box behind the hall door on leaving, at least
something for each day of the time spent, and as much more as one
cared to give. For, as every one knew, all in the box beyond the
daily expense went to maintain the School on the road below the
village. So the books of the Inn were easy to keep—there was never a
word about money in the place—but I know that many alarge sum of
money was found in this box, and the School never wanted means.
That I might tell more of what took place in the Inn, and what the
Master said, and the sort of men one found there, and the talk we all
had summer evenings beside the pool and winter nights in the hall!
Winter, I think, was the best time of all the year, the greatest
beauty and the greatest joy, from the first fall of the snow to the
yellow brook water and the floating ice in White River. Then the
broad velvety shadows lay on the hills between the stiff spruces, then
came rosy mornings out of darkness when you knew that some good thing
was waiting for you in the world. After you had drunk your bowl of
coffee, you got your axe and followedthe procession of choppers, who
were carefully foresting the Doctor's woods. In the spring, when the
little brooks had begun to run down the slopes, there was road making
and mending; for the Master kept in repair most of the roads about
Albany, grinding the rock in his pit, saying that—"a good road is
one sure blessing."
And the dusks I shall never forget—those gold and violet moments
with the light of immortal heavens behind the rampart of hills; and
the nights, so still, so still like everlasting death, each star set
jewel-wise in a black sky above a white earth. How splendid it was to
turn out of the warm hall where we had been reading and talking into
the frosty court, with the thermometer at twentybelow and still
falling, and look down across the broad white valley, marked by the
streak of bushy alders where the dumb river flowed, up to the little
frozen water courses among the hills, up above where the stars
glittered! You took your way to your room in the silence, rejoicing
that it was all so, that somewhere in this tumultuous world of ours
there was hidden all this beauty and the secret of living; and that
you were of the brotherhood of those who had found it. . . .
Thus was the Inn and its Master in the year when he touched sixty,
and his hair and beard were more white than gray.
THEN there came to the Inn one day in the early part of
the summer a new guest—a man about fifty, with an aging, worldly
face. Bill, the Albany stage man, had brought him from Island
Junction, and on the way had answered all his questions, discreetly,
reckoning in his wisdom that his passenger was "one of those queer
folks that went up to the old Doctor's place." For there was
something smart and fashionable about the stranger's appearance that
made Bill uncomfortable.
"There," he said, as he pulled up outside the red brick house and
pointed over the wall into the garden,"mos' likely you'll find the
old man fussin' 'round somewheres inside there, if he hain't down to
the School," and he drove off with the people's mail.
The stranger looked back through the village street, which was as
silent as a village street should be at four o'clock on a summer day.
Then he muttered to himself, whimsically, "Mos' likely you'll find
the old man fussin' 'round somewheres inside!" Well, what next? And
he glanced at the homely red brick building with the cold eye of one
who has made many goings out and comings in, and to whom novelty
offers little entertainment. As he stood there (thinking possibly of
that early train from the junction on the morrow) the hall door
opened wide, and anoldish man with white eye-brows and black eyes
appeared. He was dressed in a linen suit that deepened the dark tan
of his face and hands. He said:
"You are Dr. Augustus Norton?"
"And you," the Stranger replied with a graceful smile, "are the
Master—and this is the Inn!"
He had forgotten what Percival called the old boy—forgot
everything these days—had tried to remember the name all the way
up—nevertheless, he had turned it off well! So the two looked at
each other—one a little younger as years go, but with lined face and
shaking fingers; the other solid and self-contained, with less of
that ready language which comes from always jostling with nimble
wits. But as they stood there, each saw a Man and an Equal.
"The great surgeon of St. Jerome's," said our Master in further
"Honored by praise from your lips!" Thus the man of the city
lightly turned the compliment, and extended his hand, which the
Master took slowly, gazing meanwhile steadily at his guest.
"Pray come into my house," said the Master of the Inn, with more
stateliness of manner than he usually had with a new Brother. But, it
may be said, Dr. Augustus Norton had the most distinguished name of
that day in his profession. He followed the Master to his study, with
uncertain steps, and sinking into a deep chair before the smouldering
ashes looked at his host with a sad grin—"Perhaps you'll give me
something—the journey, you know? . . . ."
Two years before the head surgeon of St. Jerome's had come to the
hospital of a morning to perform some operation—one of those affairs
for which he was known from coast to coast. As he entered the
officers' room that day, with the arrogant eye of the
commander-in-chief, one of his aides looked at him suspiciously, then
glanced again—and the great surgeon felt those eyes upon him when he
turned his back. And he knew why! Something was wrong with him.
Nevertheless in glum silence he made ready to operate. But when the
moment came, and he was about to take the part of God toward the
piece of flesh lying in the ether sleep before him, he hesitated.
Then, in the terrible recoil of Fear, he turned back.
"Macroe!" he cried to his assistant, "you will have to operate. I
cannot—I am not well!"
There was almost panic, but Macroe was a man, too, and proceeded
to do his work without a word. The great surgeon, his hands now
trembling beyond disguise, went back to the officers' room, took off
his white robes, and returned to his home. There he wrote his
resignation to the directors of St. Jerome's, and his resignation
from other offices of honor and responsibility. Then he sent for a
medical man, an old friend, and held out his shaking hand to him:
"The damn thing won't go," he said, pointing also to his head.
"Too much work," the doctor replied, of course.
But the great surgeon, who was a man of clear views, added
impersonally, "Too much everything, I guess!"
There followed the usual prescription, making the sick man a
wanderer and pariah—first to Europe, "to get rid of me," the surgeon
growled; then to Georgia for golf, to Montana for elk, to Canada for
salmon, and so forth. Each time the sick man returned with a thin
coat of tan that peeled off in a few days, and with those shaking
hands that suggested immediately another journey to another climate.
Until it happened finally that the men of St. Jerome's who had first
talked of the date of their chief's return merely raised their
eyebrows at the mention of his name.
"Done for, poor old boy!" and thegreat surgeon read it with his
lynx eyes, in the faces of the men he met at his clubs. His mouth
drew together sourly and his back sloped. "Fifty-two," he muttered.
"God, that is too early—something ought to pull me together." So he
went on trying this and that, while his friends said he was
"resting," until he had slipped from men's thoughts.
One day Percival of St. Jerome's, one of those boys he had growled
at and cursed in former times, met him crawling down the avenue to
his quietest club, and the old surgeon took him by the arm—he was
gray in face and his neck was wasting away—and told the story of his
troubles—as he would to anyone these days. The young man listened
respectfully. Then he spoke of the oldInn, of the Brotherhood, of
the Master and what he had done for miserable men, who had despaired.
The famous surgeon, shaking his head as one who has heard of these
miracles many times and found them naught, was drinking it all in,
"He takes a man," said the young surgeon, "who doesn't want to live
and makes him fall in love with life."
Dr. Augustus Norton sniffed.
"In love with life! That's good! If your Wonder of the Ages can
make a man of fifty fall in love with anything, I must try him." He
laughed a sneering laugh, the feeble merriment of doubt.
"Ah, Doctor!" cried the young man, "you must go and live with the
Master. And then come back to us at St. Jerome's; for we need you!"
And the great surgeon, touched to the heart by these last words,
"Well, what's the name of your miracle-worker, and where is he to
be found? . . I might as well try all the cures—write a book on 'em
one of these days!"
So he came by the stage to the gate of the old Inn, and the Master,
who had been warned by a telegram from the young doctor only that
morning, stood at his door to welcome his celebrated guest.
He put him in the room of state above the study, a great square
room at the southwest, overlooking the wings and the flower-scented
garden, the pool, and the waving grass fields beyond, dotted with
tall elms—all freshly green.
"Not a bad sort of place,"murmured the weary man, "and there must
be trout in those brooks up yonder. Well, it will do for a week or
two, if there's fishing." . . . Then the bell sounded for dinner which
was served for the first time that season out of doors in the soft
twilight. The Brothers had gathered in the court beside the fountain,
young men and middle-aged—all having bent under some burden, which
they were now learning to carry easily. They stood about the hall
door until the distinguished Stranger appeared, and he walked between
them to the place of honor at the Master's side. Every one at the
long table was named to the great surgeon, and then with the coming
of the soup he was promptly forgotten, while the talk of the day's
work and themorrow's rose vigorously from all sides. It was a
question of the old mill, which had given way. An engineer among the
company described what would have to be done to get at the
foundations. And a young man who happened to sit next to the surgeon
explained that the Master had reopened an old mill above the Inn in
the Intervale, where he ground corn and wheat and rye with the old
water-wheel; for the country people, who had always got their grain
ground there, complained when the mill had been closed. It seemed to
the Stranger that the dark coarse bread which was served was
extraordinarily good, and he wondered if the ancient process had
anything to do with it and he resolved to see the old mill. Then the
young man saidsomething about bass: there was a cool lake up the
valley, which had been stocked. The surgeon's eye gleamed. Did he
know how to fish for bass! Why, before this boy—yes, he would go at
five in the morning, sharp. . . . After the meal, while the blue
wreaths of smoke floated across the flowers and the talk rose and
fell in the court, the Master and his new guest were seated alone
beneath the great elm. The surgeon could trace the Master's face in
the still waters of the pool at their feet, and it seemed to him like
a finely cut cameo, with gentle lines about the mouth and eyes that
relieved the thick nose. Nevertheless he knew by certain instinct
that they were not of the same kind. The Master was very silent this
night, and his guest feltthat some mystery, some vacuum existed
between them, as he gazed on the face in the water. It was as if the
old man were holding him off at arm's length while he looked into
him. But the great surgeon, who was used to the amenities of city
life, resolved to make his host talk:
"Extraordinary sort of place you have here! I don't know that I
have ever seen anything just like it. And what is your System?"
"What is my System?" repeated the Master wonderingly.
"Yes! Your method of building these fellows up—electricity, diet,
massage, baths—what is your line?"
An urbane smile removed the offence of the banter.
"I have no System!" the Master replied thoughtfully. "I live my
lifehere with my work, and those you see come and live with me as my
"Ah, but you have ideas. . . extraordinary success. . . so many
cases," the great man muttered, confused by the Master's steady gaze.
"You will learn more about us after you have been here a little
time. You will see, and the others will help you to understand.
To-morrow we work at the mill, and the next day we shall be in the
gardens—but you may be too tired to join us. And we bathe here,
morning and noon. Harvey will tell you all our customs."
The celebrated surgeon of St. Jerome's wrote that night to an old
friend: "And the learned doctor's prescription seems to be to dig in
the garden and bathe in a great pool! A daffy sort of place—but Iam
going bass fishing to-morrow at five with a young man, who is just
the right age for a son! So to bed, but I suspect that I shall see
you soon—novelties wear out quickly at my years."
Just here there entered that lovely night wind, rising far away
beyond the low lakes to the south—it soughed through the room,
swaying the draperies, sighing, sighing, and it blew out the candle.
The sick man looked down on the court below, white in the moonlight,
and his eyes roved farther to the dark orchard, and the great barns
and the huddled cattle.
"Quite a bit of country here!" the surgeon murmured. As he stood
there looking into the misty light which covered the Intervale, up to
the great hills above which floatedluminous cloud banks, the chorus
of an old song rose from below where the pipes gleamed in the dark
about the pool. He leaned out into the air, filled with all the wild
scent of green fields, and added under a sort of compulsion—"And a
good place, enough!"
He went to bed to a deep sleep, and over his tired, worldly face
the night wind passed gently, stripping leaf by leaf from his weary
mind that heavy coating of care which he had wrapped about him in the
course of many years.
Dr. Augustus Norton did not return at the end of one week, nor of
two. The city saw him, indeed, no more that year. It was said that a
frisky, rosy ghost of the greatsurgeon had slipped into St. Jerome's
near Christmas—had skipped through a club or two and shaken hands
about pretty generally—and disappeared. Sometimes letters came from
him with an out-of-the-way postmark on them, saying in a jesting tone
that he was studying the methods of an extraordinary country doctor,
who seemed to cure men by touch. "He lives up here among the hills in
forty degrees of frost, and if I am not mistaken he is nearer the
Secret than all of you pill slingers"—for he was writing a mere
doctor of medicine!). "Anyhow I shall stay on until I learn the
Secret—or my host turns me out; for life up here seems as good to me
as ice-cream and kisses to a girl of sixteen.... Why should I go back
mucking about with youfellows—just yet? I caught a five-pounder
yesterday, and ate him!"
There are many stories of the great surgeon that have come to me
from those days. He was much liked, especially by the younger men,
after the first gloom had worn off, and he began to feel the blood
run once more. He had a joking way with him that made him a good
table companion, and the Brothers pretending that he would become the
historian of the order taught him all the traditions of the place.
"But the Secret, the Secret! Where is it?" he would demand jestingly.
One night—it was at table and all were there—Harvey asked him:
"Has the Master confessed you?"
"'Confessed me'?" repeated the surgeon. "What's that?"
A sudden silence fell on all, because this was the one thing never
spoken of, at least in public. Then the Master, who had been silent
all that evening, turned the talk to other matters.
The Master, to be sure, gave this distinguished guest all
liberties, and they often talked together as men of the same
profession. And the surgeon witnessed all—the mending of the mill,
the planting and the hoeing and the harvesting, the preparations for
the long winter, the chopping and the road-making—all, and he tested
it with his hands. "Not bad sport," he would say, "with so many
sick-well young men about to help!"
But meanwhile the "secret" escaped the keen mind, though he sought
for it daily.
"You give no drugs, Doctor," hecomplained. "You're a scab on the
"The drugs gave out," the Master explained, "and I neglected to
order more. . . . There's always Bert Williams at Stowe, who can give
you anything you might want—shall I send for him, Doctor?"
There was laughter all about, and when it died down the great
surgeon returned to the attack.
"Well, come, tell us now what you do believe in? Magic, the laying
on of hands? Come, there are four doctors here, and we have the right
to know—or we'll report you!"
"I believe," said the Master solemnly, in reply to the banter, "I
believe in Man and in God." And there followed such talk as had
never been in the old hall; for thesurgeon was, after his kind, a
materialist and pushed the Master for definition. The Master believed,
as I recall it, that Disease could not be cured, for the most part.
No chemistry would ever solve the mystery of pain! But Disease could
be ignored, and the best way to forget pain was through labor. Not
labor merely for oneself; but also something for others. Wherefore
the School, around which the Inn and the farm and all had grown. For
he told us then that he had bought the Inn as a home for his boys,
the waste product of the city. Finding the old tavern too small for
his purpose and seeing how he should need helpers, he had encouraged
ailing men to come to live with him and to cure themselves by curing
others. Without that Schoolbelow in the valley, with its work-shops
and cottages, there would have been no Inn!
As for God—that night he would go no further, and the surgeon said
rather flippantly, we all thought, that the Master had left little
room in his world for God, anyhow—he had made man so large. It was a
stormy August evening, I remember, when we had been forced to dine
within on account of the gusty rain that had come after a still, hot
day. The valley seemed filled with murk, which was momentarily torn
by fire, revealing the trembling leaves upon the trees. When we
passed through the arcade to reach our rooms, the surgeon pointed out
into this sea of fire and darkness, and muttered with a touch of
"HE seems to be talking for himself this evening!"
Just then a bolt shot downward, revealing with large exaggeration
the hills, the folded valleys—the descents.
"It's like standing on a thin plank in a turbulent sea!" the
surgeon remarked wryly. "Ah, my boy, Life's like that!" and he
disappeared into his room.
Nevertheless, it was that night he wrote to his friend: "I am
getting nearer this Mystery, which I take to be, the inner heart of
it, a mixture of the Holy Ghost and Sweat—with a good bath
afterward! But the old boy is the mixer of the Pills, mind you, and
he is a Master! Most likely I shall never get hold of the heart
of it; for somehow, yet with all courtesy,he keeps me at a distance.
I have never been 'confessed,' whatever that may be—an experience
that comes to the youngest boy among them! Perhaps the Doctor thinks
that old fellows like you and me have only dead sins to confess,
which would crumble to dust if exposed. But there is a sting in very
old sins, I think—for instance—oh! if you were here to-night, I
should be as foolish as a woman. . . ."
The storm that night struck one of the school buildings and killed
a lad. In the morning the Master and the surgeon set out for the
School Village, which was lower in the valley beyond Albany. It was
warm and clear at the Inn; but thick mist wreaths still lay heavily
over the Intervale. The hills all about glittered as in October,and
there was in the air that laughing peace, that breath of sweet plenty
which comes the morning after a storm. The two men followed the
foot-path, which wound downward from the Inn across the Intervale.
The sun filled the windless air, sucking up the spicy odors of the
tangled path fern and balsam and the mother scent of earth and rain
and sun. The new green rioted over the dead leaves. . . . The Master
closely observing his guest, remarked:
"You seem quite well, Doctor. I suppose you will be leaving us
"Leaving?" the surgeon questioned slowly, as if a secret dread had
risen at the Master's hint of departure. "Yes," he admitted, after a
time, "I suppose I am what you would call well—well enough. But
somethingstill clogs within me. It may be the memory of Fear. I am
afraid of myself!"
"Afraid? You need some test, perhaps. That will come sooner or
later; we need not hurry it!"
"No, we need not hurry!"
Yet he knew well enough that the Inn never sheltered drones, and
that many special indulgences had been granted him: he had borrowed
freely from the younger Brothers—of their time and strength. He
thought complacently of the large cheque which he should drop into
the house-box on his departure. With it the Master would be able to
build a new cottage or a small hospital for the School.
"Some of them," mused the Master, "never go back to the machine
thatonce broke them. They stay about here and help me—buy a farm
and revert! But for the most part they are keen to get back to the
fight, as is right and best. Sometimes when they loiter too long, I
shove them out of the nest!"
"And I am near the shoving point?" his companion retorted quickly.
"So I must leave all your dear boys and Peace and Fishing and you
! Suppose so, suppose so! . . . Doctor, you've saved my life—oh,
hang it, that doesn't tell the story. But even I can feel what
it is to live at the Inn!"
Instinctively he grasped his host by the arm—he was an impulsive
man. But the Master's arm did not respond to the clasp; indeed, a
slight shiver seemed to shake it, so that thesurgeon's hand fell
away while the Master said:
"I am glad to have been of service—to you—yes, especially to
you. . . ."
They came into the school village, a tiny place of old white
houses, very clean and trim, with a number of sweeping elms along the
narrow road. A mountain brook turned an old water-wheel, supplying
power for the workshops where the boys were trained. The great
surgeon had visited the place many times in company with the Master,
and though he admired the order and economy of the institution, and
respected its purpose—that is, to create men out of the refuse of
society—to tell the truth, the place bored him a trifle. This
morning they went directly to the little cottage that served
asinfirmary, where the dead boy had been brought. He was a
black-haired Italian, and his lips curved upward pleasantly. The
Master putting his hand on the dead boy's brow as he might have done
in life stood looking at the face.
"I've got a case in the next room, I'd like to have your opinion
on, Doctor," the young physician said in a low tone to the surgeon,
and the two crossed the passage into the neighboring room. The
surgeon fastened his eyes on the sick lad's body: here was a case he
understood, a problem with a solution. The old Master coming in from
the dead stood behind the two.
"Williams," the surgeon said, "it's so, sure enough—you must
"I was afraid it was that," the younger man replied. "But how can
I operate here?"
The surgeon shrugged his shoulders—"He would never reach the
"Then I must, you think——"
The shrewd surgeon recognized Fear in the young man's voice. Quick
the thrill shot through his nerves, and he cried, "I will operate, now."
In half an hour it was over, and the Master and the surgeon were
leaving the village, climbing up by the steep path under the blazing
noon sun. The Master glanced at the man by his side, who strode along
confidently, a trifle of a swagger in his buoyant steps. The Master
"The test came, and you took it—splendidly."
"Yes," the great surgeon replied,smiling happily, "it's all there,
Doctor, the old power. I believe I am about ready to get into harness
again!" After they had walked more of the way without speaking, the
surgeon added, as to himself—"But there are other things to be
Though the Master looked at him closely he invited no explanation,
and they finished their homeward walk without remark.
It soon got about among the inmates of the Inn what a wonderful
operation the surgeon of St. Jerome's had performed, and it was
rumored that at the beginning of autumn he would go back to his old
position. Meantime the great surgeon enjoyed the homage that men
always pay to power, the consideration of hisfellows. He had been
much liked; but now that the Brothers knew how soon he was to leave
them, they surrounded him with those attentions that men most love,
elevating him almost to the rank of the Master—and they feared him
less. His fame spread, so that from some mill beyond Stowe they
brought to the Inn a desperate case, and the surgeon operated again
successfully, demonstrating that he was once more master of his art,
and master of himself. So he stayed on merely to enjoy his triumph
and escape the dull season in the city.
It was a wonderful summer, that! The fitful temper of the north
played in all its moods. There were days when the sun shone
tropically down into the valleys, without a breath ofair, when the
earthy, woodsy smells were strong—and the nights—perfect stillness
and peace, as if some spirit of the air were listening for love words
on the earth. The great elms along Albany road hung their branches
motionless, and when the moon came over behind the house the great
hills began to swim ghostly, vague—beyond, always beyond! . . .
And then there were the fierce storms that swept up the valley and
hung growling along the hills for days, and afterward, sky-washed and
clear, the westerly breeze would come tearing down the Intervale,
drying the earth before it.... But each day there was a change in the
sound and the smell of the fields and the woods—in the quick race of
the northern summer—a change that the surgeon,fishing up the tiny
streams, felt and noted. Each day, so radiant with its abundant life,
sounded some undernote of fulfilment and change—speaking beforehand
of death to come.
Toward the end of August a snap of cold drove us in-doors for the
night meal. Then around the fire there was great talk between the
Master and the surgeon, a sort of battle of the soul, to which we
others paid silent attention. For wherever those nights the talk
might rise, in the little rills of accidental words, it always flowed
down to the deep underlying thoughts of men. And in those depths, as
I said, these two wrestled with each other. The Master, who had grown
silent of late years, woke once more with fire. The light, keen
thrusts ofthe surgeon, who argued like a fencer, roused his whole
being; and as day by day it went on we who watched saw that in a way
the talk of these two men set forth the great conflict of conflicts,
that deepest fissure of life and belief anent the Soul and the Body.
And the Master, who had lived his faiths by his life before our eyes,
was being worsted in the argument! The great surgeon had the better
mind, and he had seen all of life that one may see with eyes. . . .
They were talking of the day of departure for the distinguished
guest, and arranging for some kind of triumphal procession to escort
him to White River. But he would not set the time, shrinking from
this act, as if all were not yet done. There camea warm, glowing day
early in September, and at night after the pipes were lighted the
surgeon and the Master strolled off in the direction of the pool, arm
in arm. There had been no talk that day, the surgeon apparently
shrinking from coming to the last grapple with one whose faiths were
so important to him as the Master's.
"The flowers are dying: they tell me it's time to move on," said
the surgeon. "And yet, my dear host, I go without the Secret, without
"Perhaps there is no inner Secret," the Master smiled. "It is all
here before you."
"I know that—you have been very good to me, shared everything. If
I have not learned the Secret, it is myfault, my incapacity. But—"
and the gay tone dropped quickly and a flash of bitterness
succeeded—"I at least know that there is a Secret!"
They sat down on the marble bench and looked into the water, each
thinking his thoughts. Suddenly the surgeon began to speak,
hesitantly, as if there had long been something in his mind that he
was compelled to say.
"My friend," he said, "I too have something to tell—the cause
within the cause, the reason of the reason—at least, sometimes I
think it is! The root reason for all—unhappiness, defeat, for the
shaking hand and the jesting voice. And I want you to hear it—if you
The Master raised his face from the pool but said never a word. The
surgeon continued, his voice tremblingat times, though he spoke
slowly, evidently trying to banish all feeling.
"It is a common enough story at the start, at least among men of
our kind. You know that I was trained largely in Europe. My father
had the means to give me the best, and time to take it in. So I was
over there, before I came back to St. Jerome's, three, four years at
Paris, Munich, Vienna, all about. . . . While I was away I lived as
the others, for the most part—you know our profession—and youth.
The rascals are pretty much the same to-day, I judge from what my
friends say of their sons! Well, at least I worked like the devil, and
was decent. . . . Oh, it isn't for that I'm telling the tale! I was
ambitious, then. And the time came to go back, as it does in the end,
and I took afew weeks' run through Italy as a final taste of the
lovely European thing, and came down to Naples to get the boat for
New York. I've never been back to Naples since, and that was
twenty-six years ago this autumn. But I can see the city always as it
was then! The seething human hive—the fellows piling in the freight
to the music of their songs—the fiery mouth of Vesuvius up above.
And the soft, dark night with just a plash of waves on the quay!"
The Master listened, his eyes again buried in the water at their
she was there on board, of course—looking out also
into that warm dark night and sighing for all that was to be lost so
soon. There were few passengers in those days.. . . She was my
countrywoman, and beautiful, and there was something—at least so I
thought then—of especial sweetness in her eyes, something strong in
her heart. She was engaged to a man living somewhere in the States,
and she was going back to marry him. Why she was over there then I
forget, and it is of no importance. I think that the man was a
doctor, too in some small city. . . . I loved her!"
The Master raised his eyes from the pool and leaning on his folded
arms looked into the surgeon's face.
"I am afraid I never thought much about that other fellow—never
have to this day! That was part of the brute I am—to see only what
is before my eyes. And I knew by the time we had swung into the
Atlantic thatI wanted that woman as I had never wanted things
before. She stirred me, mind and all. Of course it might have been
some one else—any one you will say—and if she had been an ordinary
young girl, it might have gone differently? It is one of the things
we can't tell in this life. There was something in that woman that
was big all through and roused the spirit in me. I never knew man or
woman who thirsted more for greatness, for accomplishment. Perhaps
the man she was to marry gave her little to hope for—probably it was
some raw boy-and-girl affair such as we have in America. . . . The
days went by, and it was clearer to both of us what must be. But we
didn't speak of it. She found in me, I suppose, the power, the sort
of thing shehad missed in the other. I was to do all those grand
things she was so hot after. I have done some of them too. But that
was when she had gone and I no longer needed her. . . . I needed her
then, and I took her—that is all.
"The detail is old and dim—and what do you care to hear of a young
man's loves! Before we reached port it was understood between us. I
told her I wanted her to leave the other chap—he was never
altogether clear to me—and to marry me as soon as she could. We did
not stumble or slide into it, not in the least: we looked it through
and through—that was her kind and mine. How she loved to look life
in the face! I have found few women who like that. . . . In the end
she asked me not tocome near her the last day. She would write me
the day after we had landed, either yes, or no. So she kissed me, and
we parted still out at sea."
All the Brothers had left the court and the arcades, where they had
been strolling, and old Sam was putting out the Inn lights. But the
two men beside the pool made no movement. The west wind still drew in
down the valley with summer warmth and ruffled the water at their
"My father met me at the dock—you know he was the first surgeon at
St. Jerome's before me. My mother was with him. . . . But as she
kissed me I was thinking of that letter. . . . I knew it would come.
Some things must! Well, it came."
The silent listener bent his head,and the surgeon mused on his
passionate memory. At last the Master whispered in a low voice that
hardly reached into the night:
"Did you make her happy?"
The surgeon did not answer the question at once.
"Did you make her happy?" the old man demanded again, and his
voice trembled this time with such intensity that his companion
looked at him wonderingly. And in those dark eyes of the Master's he
read something that made him shrink away. Then for the third time the
old man demanded sternly:
"Tell me—did you make her happy?"
It was the voice of one who had a right to know, and the surgeon
whispered back slowly:
"Happy? No, my God! Perhaps at first, in the struggle, a little.
But afterward there was too much—too many things. It went, the
inspiration and the love. I broke her heart—she left me! That—that
is my Reason!"
"It is the Reason! For you took all, all—you let her give
all, and you gave her—what?"
"I know—she died."
The Master had risen, and with folded arms faced his guest, a
pitying look in his eyes. The surgeon covered his face with his
hands, and after a long time said:
"So you knew this?"
"Yes, I knew!"
"And knowing you let me come here. You took me into your house,you
healed me, you gave me back my life!"
And the Master replied with a firm voice:
"I knew, and I gave you back your life." In a little while he
explained more softly: "You and I are no longer young men who feel
hotly and settle such a matter with hate. We cannot quarrel now for
the possession of a woman. . . . She chose: remember that! . . . It
was twenty-six years this September. We have lived our lives, you and
I; we have lived out our lives, the good and the evil. Why should we
now for the second time add passion to sorrow?"
"And yet knowing all you took me in!"
"Yes!" the old man cried almost proudly. "And I have made youagain
what you once were. . . . What she loved as you," he added to
himself, "a man full of Power."
Then they were speechless in face of the fact: the one had taken
all and the sweet love turned to acid in his heart, and the other had
lost and the bitter turned to sweet! When a long time had passed the
surgeon spoke timidly:
"It might have been so different for her with you! You loved
There was the light of a compassionate smile on the Master's lips
as he replied:
"Yes, I loved her, too."
"And it changed things—for you!"
"It changed things. There might have been my St. Jerome's—my fame
also. Instead, I came here withmy boys. And here I shall die, please
The old Master then became silent, his face set in a dream of life,
as it was, as it would have been; while the great surgeon of St.
Jerome's thought such thoughts as had never passed before into his
mind. The night wind had died at this late hour, and in its place
there was a coldness of the turning season. The stars shone near the
earth and all was silent with the peace of mysteries. The Master
looked at the man beside him and said calmly:
"It is well as it is—all well!"
At last the surgeon rose and stood before the Master.
"I have learned the Secret," he said, "and now it is time for me to
He went up to the house through the little court and disappeared
within the Inn, while the Master sat by the pool, his face graven
like the face of an old man, who has seen the circle of life and
understands. . . .
The next morning there was much talk about Dr. Norton's
disappearance, until some one explained that the surgeon had been
suddenly called back to the city.
The news spread through the Brotherhood one winter that the old
Inn had been burned to the ground, a bitter December night when all
the water-taps were frozen. And the Master, who had grown deaf of
late, had been caught in his remote chamber, and burned or rather
suffocated. There were few men in the Inn atthe time, it being the
holiday season, and when they had fought their way to the old man's
room, they found him lying on the lounge by the window, the lids
fallen over the dark eyes and his face placid with sleep or
contemplation. . . . They sought in vain for the reason of the
fire—but why search for causes?
All those beautiful hills that we loved to watch as the evening
haze gathered, the Master left in trust for the people of the
State—many acres of waving forests. And the School continued in its
old place, the Brothers looking after its wants and supplying it with
means to continue its work. But the Inn was never rebuilt. The
blackened ruins of buildings were removed and the gardenin the court
extended so that it covered the whole space where the Inn had stood.
This was enclosed with a thick plantation of firs on all sides but
that one which looked westward across the Intervale. The spot can be
seen for miles around on the Albany hill side.
And when it was ready—all fragrant and radiant with flowers—they
placed the Master there beside the pool, where he had loved to sit,
surrounded by men. On the sunken slab his title was engraved—