Fault by May
Gibson used to say that he would never marry, because no other woman
could be half as nice as his own mother. Then, of course, he broke his
mother's heart by marrying a woman who was not nice at all.
He was a powerful fellow with a plain, square face, and a manner
that was perfection to the people whom he liked. Unfortunately they
were very few. He did not like any of the ladies whom his mother wanted
him to like, not even when they reproduced for him her gentle, delicate
The younger Mrs. Gibson had none of it. But she had ways with her,
and a power that was said to reside supremely in her hands, her arms,
and her hair. Especially her hair (she was the large white and golden
kind). It was long as a lasso and ample as a cloak. Gibson loved her
hair. The sight and the scent of it filled him with folly. He liked to
braid and unbraid it, to lay his face against it, to plunge his hands
through the coolness into the warmth of it.
It seemed to him to give out the splendor and vitality of her, to
have a secret sympathy with the thought that stirred beneath it.
She had a trick, when she was thinking of caressing it, of winding
and unwinding the little curls that sprang, aureolewise, above her
temples. That was one of her ways, and it brought her hands and arms
into play with stupendous effect.
He would sit opposite her a whole evening, watching it, dumb with
excess of happiness.
It took him six months to find out that the trick he admired so much
was a sign that his wife was bored to extinction.
Is there anything you want? he said.
She laughed hysterically.
You've only to say what you want, and I'll get it for you, if it
can be got.
It could be got all right, said she. But I doubt whether you'd
care very much to get it.
What is it? Tell metell me.
Wellyou're very nice, my dear, I know. But before I married you I
usedthough you mightn't think itto be received in society.
He took her back to it. He said he was a selfish brute to want to
keep her to himself. That speech amused Mrs. Gibson immensely. She had
a curious and capricious sense of humor. It made her very adaptable and
tided them both over a sharp season of infelicity.
Hitherto Mrs. Gibson had been merely bored. Now she was seized with
a malady of unrest. Any other man but Gibson would have been driven mad
with her nerves.
You're doing too much, you know, he said, soothing her. You're
She raised her eyebrows.
Oh, no, she said, not tired.
What you want, said he, is a thorough change.
My dear, said she, I didn't know you were so clever.
Would you like me to take a cottage in the country?
A cottage? In the country?
Well, of course, not too far from town. Some place where I could
run down for the week-ends.
You couldn't, said she, be running down oftener?
No, he said, I'm afraid I couldn't just at present.
Don't you think it might be a trifle lonely?
You can have anyone you like to stay with you.
And you really want to take it? This cottage?
Well, then, said she, take it by all means, and lose no time.
He took it, and went down with her for the first week-end.
It was a tiny place. But some one had built a comfortable
smoking-room at the back. It opened by glass doors into the garden.
One Sunday evening they were sitting together in the smoking-room
when she flung herself down on the floor beside him and laid her head
on his knee. She seized his hand and drew it down to her.
As you are going to leave me to-morrow, she said, you can stroke
my hair to-night.
He went down every week-end. And every week-end he found an
improvement in his wife's health. When he complimented her upon her
appearance, she told him she had been gardening. He took it as an
excellent sign that she should be fond of gardening.
Then one day Gibson (who worked like ten horses to provide all the
things that his wife wanted) got ill and was told to take a month off
in the country.
That was in the middle of the week. He saw his doctor early in the
evening and took the last train down. The cottage was several miles
from the nearest telegraph office, so that he arrived before the wire
that should have announced his coming.
A short cut from the station brought him to the back of the house
through a little wood that screened it. The wood path led into his
garden by a private gate which was always locked.
He climbed the gate and crossed the grass plot to the glass doors of
the smoking-room. The lamps were lit there, and Gibson, as he
approached, could see his wife sitting in the low chair opposite his.
His heart bounded at the sight of her. He was glad to think that she
sat in his room when he was away. He walked quickly over the grass and
stood at the glass doors looking in.
She was lying back in the low chair. In his chair, which a
curtain had concealed from him until now, there sat a man he knew. He
recognized the narrow shoulders and the head with the sleek brown hair,
showing a little sallow patch of baldness at the back. From a certain
tenseness in the man's attitude he knew that his gaze was fastened on
the woman who faced them. Her left arm was raised, its long, loose
sleeve fell back and bared it. Her fingers twisted and untwisted a
little straying curl.
The man could bear it no longer. He jumped up and went to her. He
knelt beside her. With one hand he seized her arm by the full white
wrist and dragged it down and held it to his lips. The other hand
smoothed back her hair into its place and held it there. His fine,
nervous fingers sank through the deep, silky web to the white,
sensitive skin. The woman threw back her head and closed her eyes,
every nerve throbbing felinely under the caress she loved.
The man rose with an uneasy movement that brought him to the back of
her chair. He stooped and whispered something. She flung up her arms
and drew down his face to hers under the white arch they made.
Gibson did nothing scandalous. He went round quietly to the front
door and let himself in with his latch-key. When he entered the
smoking-room he found his wife there alone. She stood on his hearth,
and met him with hard eyes, desperate and defiant.
What have you to say for yourself? he said.
Everything, said she. Of course you will divorce me.
Will a separation not satisfy you?
No, she said, it will not. If you haven't had proof enough I can
give you more. Or you can ask the servants.
He had always given her what she wanted. He gave it her now.
Gibson went back to his mother.
The incident left him apparently unscathed. He showed no signs of
trouble until four years after, when his mother died. Then the two
shocks rolled into one, and for a year Gibson was a wreck.
At last he was told, as he had been told before, to stop work and go
awayanywherefor a rest. He went to a small seaside town in East
The man's nature was so sound that in a month's time he recovered
sufficiently to take an interest in what was going on around him.
He was lodged in one of a row of small houses facing the esplanade.
Each had its own plot of green garden spread before it, and a flagged
pathway leading from the gate to the door. Path and garden were raised
a good half-foot above the level of the sidewalk, and this half-foot,
Gibson observed, was a serious embarrassment to his next-door
Twice a day a bath-chair with an old gentleman in it would emerge
from the doorway of the house next door. It was drawn by two little
ladies, a dark one and a fair one, whom Gibson judged to be the old
gentleman's daughters. He must have weighed considerably, that old
gentleman, and the ladies (especially the dark one) were far too young
and small and tender for such draft-work. Four times a day at the
garden-gate a struggle took place between little ladies and the
bath-chair. Gibson could see them from his window where he lay, supine
in his nervous apathy. Their going out was only less fearful than their
coming in. Going out, it was very hard to prevent the back wheels from
slipping down with a bump on to the pavement and shaking the old
gentleman horribly. Coming in, they risked overturning him altogether.
You would not have known that there was any struggle going on. The
old gentleman bore himself with so calm and high a heroism; the little
ladies were sustained by so pure a sense of the humors of the
bath-chair. No sharp, irritating cries escaped them. They did nothing
but laugh softly as they pulled and pushed and tugged with their
women's arms, and heaved with delicate shoulders, or hung on, in their
frenzy, from behind while the bath-chair swayed ponderously and
perilously above the footway.
Gibson sometimes wondered whether he oughtn't to rush out and help
them. But he couldn't. He didn't really care.
His landlady told him that the old gentleman was a General
Richardson, that he was paralyzed, that his daughters waited on him
hand and foot, that they were too poor to afford a man-servant to look
after him and push the bath-chair. It wasn't much of a life, the woman
said, for the two young ladies. Gibson agreed that it wasn't much of a
What pleased him was the fine levity with which they took it. He was
always meeting them in their walks on the esplanade. Sometimes they
would come racing down the wind with the bath-chair, their serge skirts
blown forward, their hair curling over the brims of their sailor hats.
(The dark one was particularly attractive in a high wind.) Then they
would come back much impeded, their skirts wrapped tight above their
knees, their little bodies bent to the storm, their faces wearing still
that invincible gaiety of theirs. Sometimes, on a gentle incline, they
would let the bath-chair run on a little by itself, till it threatened
a dangerous independence, when they would fly after it at the top of
their speed and arrest it just in time. Gibson could never make out
whether they did this for their own amusement or the old gentleman's.
But sometimes, when the General came careering past him, he could catch
the glance of a bright and affable eye that seemed to call on him to
observe the extent to which an old fellow might enjoy himself yet.
Gibson's lodging gave him endless opportunity for studying the
habits of his little ladies. He learned that they did everything in
turns. They took it in turns to pull the bath-chair and to push it.
They took it in turns to read aloud to the old gentleman, and to put
him to bed at night and get him up in the morning. They took it in
turns to go to church (did they become suddenly serious, he wondered,
there?), and in turns to air themselves on a certain little plateau on
He was next to find out that they nursed the monstrous ambition of
urging the bath-chair up the hill and landing it on the plateau. Gibson
was sorry for them, for he knew they could never do it. But such was
their determination that each time he encountered them on the hill they
had struggled a little farther up it.
The road had a sort of hump in it just before it forked off on to
the cliff. That baffled them.
At last, as he himself was returning from the plateau, he came upon
the sisters right in the middle of the rise, locked in deadly combat
with the bath-chair. Pressed against it, shoulder to shoulder, they
resisted its efforts to hurl itself violently backward down the hill.
The General, as he clung to the arms of the chair, preserved his
attitude of superb indifference to the event.
Gibson leaped to their assistance. With a threefold prodigious
effort they topped the rise, and in silence, in a sort of solemn
triumph, the bath-chair was wheeled on to the plateau.
He liked the simplicity with which they accepted his aid, and he
liked the way they thanked him, both sisters becoming very grave all at
once. It was the fair one who spoke. The dark one only bowed and smiled
as he lifted his cap and turned away.
It's all very well, he heard her saying, but how are we going to
get him down again?
How were they?
He hung about the cliffside till the time came for them to return,
when he presented himself as if by accident.
You must allow me, he said, to see you safe to the bottom of the
They allowed him.
You see (the General addressed his daughters as they paused
halfway), we've accomplished it, and no bones are broken.
Yes, said Gibson, but isn't the expedition just a little
Ah, said the General, I've risked my life too many times to mind
a little danger now.
Gibson's eyebrows said plainly, It wasn't your life, old
boy, I was thinking of.
The sisters looked away.
You must never attempt that again, he said gravely, as he parted
from them at the foot of the hill.
Gibson felt that he had done a good morning's work. He had saved the
lives of the three Richardsons, and he had found out that the fair
one's name was Effie, and the dark one's Phoebe.
After that the acquaintance ripened. They exchanged salutes whenever
they met. Then Gibson, moved beyond endurance by their daily strife
with the bath-chair, was generally to be seen at their gateway in time
to help them.
As the days grew longer the Richardsons began to take their tea out
of doors on their grass-plot. And then it seemed to strike them all at
once that the gentleman next door was lonely, and one afternoon they
invited him to tea.
Then Gibson had his tea served on his grass plot, and invited
the Richardsons, and the Richardsons (they were so absurdly grateful)
invited him to supper and to spend the evening. They thanked him for
coming. It was such a pleasure, Effie said (Effie was the elder),
such a great pleasure to Father.
Gibson hardly thought his society could be a pleasure to anyone, but
he tried to make himself useful. He engaged himself as the General's
bath-chair man. He bowled him along at the round pace he loved, while
the little ladies, Effie and Phoebe, trotted after them, friendly and
And he began to go in and out next door as a matter of course, till
it was open to the little sisters to regard him as their own very
valuable property. But they were not going to be selfish about him. Oh,
no! They took him, as they took everything else, in turns. They tried
hard to divide him fairly. If he attached himself to Effie (the fair
one), Effie would grow uneasy, and she would get up and positively hand
him over to Phoebe (the dark one). If Phoebe permitted herself to talk
to him for any while, her eyes would call to Effie, and when Effie came
she would slip away and take up her sad place by the General's
armchair. In their innocent rivalry it was who could give him more up
to the other. And, as Phoebe was the more determined little person, it
was Phoebe who generally had it her own way. Father, too, came in for
his just share. Gibson felt that he would not be tolerated on any
footing that kept Father out of it. There was also a moment in the
evening when he would be led up to the armchair, and both Effie and
Phoebe would withdraw and leave him to that communion.
There was a third sister he knew now. She was the eldest, and her
name was Mary. She was away somewhere in the north, recovering, he
gathered, from Father (of course, they took it in turns to recover
from him), while Father wandered up and down the south coast,
endeavoring, vainly, to recover from himself. They told Gibson that the
one thing that spoiled it all (the joy, they meant, of their
intercourse with him) was the thought that Mary was missing it. Had
Mary been there she would have had to have her share, her fourth.
Presently he realized that Phoebe (he supposed because of her
superior determination) had effaced herself altogether. She was always
doing dreary things, he noticed, out of her turn. Then he perceived a
change in her. Little Phoebe, in consequence of all the dreary things
she did, was beginning to grow thin and pale. She looked as though she
wanted more of the tonic air of the cliffside. She did still take her
turn at climbing to the plateau and sitting there all alone. But that,
Gibson reflected, was after all, for Phoebe, a very dreary thing to do.
One evening he took courage, and asked Phoebe to come for a walk to
the cliffside with him.
Phoebe did not answer all at once. She shrank, he could see, from
the enormity of having him all to herself.
Go, said Effie, it will do you worlds of good.
Effie laughed and shook her head.
Come too, then. Mr. Gibson, say she's to come too.
You know, said Effie, it's my turn to stay with Father.
She said it severely, as if Phoebe had been trying unfairly to
deprive her of a privilege and a delight. They were delicious, Phoebe
and Effie, but it was Phoebe that he wanted this time.
They set out at a brisk pace that brought the blood to Phoebe's
cheeks and made her prettier than ever. Phoebe, of course, had done her
best to make her prettiness entirely unobtrusive. She wore a muslin
skirt and a tie, and a sailor hat that was not specially becoming to
her small head, and her serge skirt had to be both wide and short
because of pushing the bath-chair about through all kinds of weather.
But the sea wind caught her; it played with her hair; it blew a little
dark curl out of place to hang distractingly over Phoebe's left ear; it
blew the serge skirt tight about her limbs, and showed him, in spite of
Phoebe, how prettily Phoebe was made.
Why didn't you back me up? said Phoebe. She wanted to come all
He turned, as he walked, to look at her.
Why didn't I back you up? Do you really want to know why?
Whenever he took that tone Phoebe looked solemn and a little
frightened. She was frightened now, too frightened to answer him.
Because, said he, I wanted you all to myself.
Oh Phoebe drew a long, terrified breath.
There are many ways of saying Oh, but Gibson had never, never in
his whole life heard any woman say it as Phoebe said it then. It meant
that she was staggered at anybody's having the temerity to want
anything all to himself.
Do you think me very selfish?
Phoebe assured him instantly that that had never been her idea of
Shall I tell you who is selfish?
Phoebe's little mouth hardened. She was so dreadfully afraid that he
was going to say Your father.
You, he said, you.
I'm afraid I am, said she. It's so hard not to be.
He stood still in his astonishment, so that she had to stand still,
Of course it's hard not to give up things, when you like giving
them up. But your sister likes giving them up, too, and it's selfish of
you to prevent her, isn't it?
Oh, but you don't know what it's beenEffie's life and Mary's.
Oh, no, I'm happy enough. I'm the youngest.
You mean you've had a year or two less of it.
Yes. They never told me, for fear of making me unhappy, when
Father's illness came.
How long ago was that?
Five years ago. I was at school.
He made a brief calculation. During the two years of his married
life Phoebe had been a child at school.
And two years, said Phoebe, is a long time to be happy in.
Yes, he said, it's a long time.
And then, she went on presently, I'm so much stronger than Effie
Not strong enough to go dragging that abominable bath-chair about.
Not strong enough? Look
She held out her right arm for him to look at; under her muslin
blouse he saw its tense roundness, and its whiteness through the slit
above her wrist.
His heart stirred in him. Phoebe's arms were beautiful, and they
were strong to help.
I wish, he said, I could make it better for you.
Oh, but you have made it better for us. You can't think what
a difference you've made.
Have I? Have I?
Yes. Effie said so only the other day. She wrote it to Mary. And
Mary says it's a shame she can't be here. It is, you know. It makes us
feel so mean having you all to ourselves like this.
He laughed. He laughed whenever he thought of it. There was nobody
who could say things as Phoebe said them.
I wish, said she, you knew Mary. You'd like her so.
I'm sure I should if she's at all like you.
(Her innocence sheltered him, made him bold.)
Oh, but she isn't.
And he listened while she gave him a long list of Mary's charms.
(Dear little, tender, unconscious Phoebe.)
She sounds, he said, very like you.
She isn't the least bit like me. You don't know me.
Mary's coming back at the end of the month. Then either I or Effie
will go away. Do you think you'll still be here?
He seemed to her to answer absently.
Which of you, did you say, was going away?
Wellit's Effie's turn.
Yes, he said, I think I shall still be here.
One night, a week later, the two sisters sat talking together long
after Father had been put to bed.
Phoebe, said Effie, why did you want me to come with you and Mr.
Because said Phoebe.
My dear, it's you he likes, not me.
But it's true, said Effie.
How can you tell? said Phoebe, and she felt perfidious.
Isn't he always going about with you?
But Phoebe was ingenious in the destruction of her own joy.
Oh, said she, that's his cunning. He likes you dreadfully. He
goes about with me, just to hide it.
Are you sure, Effie, you don't care?
Not a rap.
You never have? Not in the beginning?
Certainly not in the beginning. I only thought he might be nice for
You didn't even want to divide him?
Effie shook her head vehemently.
Wellhe's the only thing I ever wanted all to myself. If Then
Phoebe looked frightened. Effie, she said, he's never said
All the same, you know.
Can you know?
I think so, said Effie.
Gibson had been talking a long time to Phoebe. They were sitting
together on the beach, under the shadow of the cliff. He was trying to
form Phoebe's mind. Phoebe's mind was deliciously young, and it had the
hunger and thirst of youth. A little shy and difficult to approach,
Phoebe's mind, but he had found out what it liked best, and it pleased
him to see how confidingly and delicately it, so to speak, ate out of
He puzzled her a good deal. And she had a very pretty way of closing
her eyes when she was puzzled. In another woman it would have meant
that he was boring her; Phoebe did it to shut out the intolerable light
Ah!don't, he cried.
Don't shut my eyes? I always shut my eyes when I'm trying to
think, said Phoebe.
He said nothing. That was not what he had meant when he had said
Am I boring you? he said presently. His tone jarred a little on
Phoebe; he had such a nice voice generally.
No, said she. Why?
Because you keep on doing that.
She put up her hand and untwisted the little tendril of brown hair
that hung deliciously over her left ear.
I always do that when I'm thinking.
He very nearly said, Then, for God's sake, don't think.
But Phoebe was always thinking now. He had given her cause to think.
He began to hate the little brown curl that hung over her left ear,
though it was anguish to him to hate anything that was Phoebe's. He
looked out with nervous anxiety for the movement of her little white
hand. He said to himself, If she does it again, I can't come near her
Yet he kept on coming; and was happy with her until Phoebe (poor,
predestined little Phoebe) did it again. Gibson shuddered with the
horror of the thing. He kept on saying to himself, She's sweet, she's
good, she's adorable. It isn't her fault. But I can'tI can't sit in
the room with it.
And the next minute Phoebe would be so adorable that he would repent
miserably of his brutality.
Then, one hot, still evening, he was alone with her in the little
sitting-room. Outside, on the grass plot, her father sat in his
bath-chair while Effie read aloud to him (out of her turn). Her voice
made a cover for Gibson's voice and Phoebe's.
Phoebe was dressed (for the heat) in a white gown with wide, open
sleeves. Her low collar showed the pure, soft swell of her neck to the
She was sitting upright and demure in a straight-backed chair, with
her hands folded quietly in her lap.
That isn't a very comfortable chair you've got, he said.
He knew that she was tired with pushing the bath-chair about all
It's the one I always sit in, said Phoebe.
Well, you're not going to sit in it now, he said.
He drew the armchair out of its sacred corner and made her sit in
that. He put a cushion at her head and a footstool at her feet.
You make my heart ache, he said.
He could not tell whether the little shaking breath she drew were a
laugh or a sigh.
She lay back, letting her tired body slacken into rest.
The movement loosened the little combs that kept the coil of her
brown hair in place. Phoebe abhorred dishevelment. She put up her hands
to her head. Her wide sleeve fell back, showing the full length of her
He saw another woman stretching her arms to the man who leaned above
her. He saw the movement of her handshands of the same texture and
whiteness as her body, instinct with its impulses. A long procession of
abominations passed through the white arch of her armsthe arch she
raised in triumph and defiance, immortalizing her sin.
He was very tender with Phoebe that night, for his heart was wrung
She's adorable, he said to himself; but I can't live with that.
Gibson left by the early train next day. He went without saying
good-bye and without leaving an explanation or an address.
Phoebe held her head high, and said, day after day, There's sure to
be a letter.
Three weeks passed and no letter came. Phoebe saw that it was all
One day she was found (Effie found her) on her bed, crying. She was
so weak she let Effie take her in her arms.
If I only knew what I had done, she said. Oh, Effie! what could
have made him go away?
I can't tell, my lamb. You mustn't think about him any more.
I can't help thinking. You see, it's not as if he hadn't been so
He couldn't have been nice to treat you that way.
He didn't, said Phoebe fiercely. He didn't treat me any way. I
sometimes think I must have made it all up out of my own head. Did I?
No, no. I'm sure you didn't.
It would have been awful of me. But I'd rather be awful than have
to think that he was. What is my worst fault, Effie?
Your worst fault, in his eyes, is that you have none.
Phoebe sat up on the edge of the bed. She was thinking hard. And as
she thought her hand went up, caressing unconsciously the little brown
If I only knew, said she, what I had done!
Gibson never saw Phoebe Richardson again. But a year later, as he
turned suddenly on to the esplanade of a strange watering-place, he
encountered the bath-chair, drawn by Effie and another lady. He made
way, lifting his cap mechanically to its occupant.
The General looked at him. The courteous old hand checked itself in
the salute. The affable smile died grimly.
Effie turned away her head. The other lady (it must have been
Mary") raised her eyes in somber curiosity.
Phoebe was not with them. Gibson supposed that she was away
somewhere, recovering, in her turn.